Nucleotide sequence of the long terminal repeat and flanking cellular sequences of avian endogenous retrovirus ev-2: variation in Rous-associated virus-0 expression cannot be explained by differences in primary sequence

Locus-specific diagnostic tests for endogenous avian leukosis-type viral loci in chickens

The genome of the chicken, Gallus gallus, contains endogenous proviral elements (ALVE elements or ev genes) that display a high degree of similarity to the Avian Leukosis class of retroviruses. The ALVE proviruses are known to modulate physiological processes of the host birds. Different ALVE elements retain variable portions of the complete, prototype viral genome, and each provirus resides in its own specific location within the host genome. Thus, each ALVE element has its own particular potential to modulate host physiology depending on the nature of its integration site, the completeness of the proviral genome, and the level of expression of the locus. It is important, therefore, to be able to establish the ALVE element profiles of chickens quickly and accurately, both in the laboratory and in a commercial setting. The current method of choice for simple, quick, and accurate typing is the polymerase chain reaction (PCR). This paper reviews the present status of PCR typing of ALVE proviruses and lists the assay protocols for 19 different elements. In addition, it compares the insertion sites of these elements in an effort to identify common motifs at ALVE integration sites.

Consistent chromosomal aberration in cell lines transformed with Marek's disease herpesvirus: evidence of genomic DNA amplification

A specific chromosomal aberration was observed in 14 of 15 avian lymphoblastoid cell lines transformed with Marek's disease herpesvirus. This aberration, designated dup(1p)(p22-p23), appeared as an extra G-positive band and interband on the short arm of one chromosome I homolog. Using fluorescent in situ hybridization, we identified amplified genomic DNA sequences in this region. This amplification involves sequences linked to an endogenous retrovirus locus and genes in the histone multigene family. This aberration was not observed in cells transformed by reticuloendotheliosis virus or by avian leukosis virus, nor has it been observed in untransformed chicken cells. The induction of the 1p+ chromosomal aberration may be an essential event in the transformation of lymphocytes by Marek's disease virus.

Functional and defective components of avian endogenous virus long terminal repeat enhancer sequences

Oncogenic avian retroviruses, such as Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) and the avian leukosis viruses, contain a strong enhancer in the U3 portion of the proviral long terminal repeat (LTR). The LTRs of a second class of avian retroviruses, the endogenous viruses (ev) lack detectable enhancer activity. By creating ev-RSV hybrid LTRs, we previously demonstrated that, despite the lack of independent enhancer activity in the ev U3 region, ev LTRs contain sequences that are able to functionally replace essential enhancer domains from the RSV enhancer. A hypothesis proposed to explain these data was that ev LTRs contain a partial enhancer that includes sequences necessary but not sufficient for enhancer activity and that these sequences were complemented by RSV enhancer domains present in the original hybrid constructs to generate a functional enhancer. Studies described in this report were designed to define sequences from both the ev and RSV LTRs required to generate this composite enhancer. This was approached by generating additional ev-RSV hybrid LTRs that exchanged defined regions between ev and RSV and by directly testing the requirement for specific motifs by site-directed mutagenesis. Results obtained demonstrate that ev enhancer sequences are present in the same relative location as upstream enhancer sequences from RSV, with which they share limited sequence similarity. In addition, a 67-bp region from the internal portion of the RSV LTR that is required to complement ev enhancer sequences was identified. Finally, data showing that CArG motifs are essential for high-level activity, a finding that has not been previously demonstrated for retroviral LTRs, are presented.

CArG, CCAAT, and CCAAT-like protein binding sites in avian retrovirus long terminal repeat enhancers

A strong enhancer element is located within the long terminal repeats (LTRs) of exogenous, oncogenic avian retroviruses, such as Rous sarcoma virus (RSV) and the avian leukosis viruses. The LTRs of a second class of avian retroviruses, the endogenous viruses (evs), lack detectable enhancer function, a property that correlates with major sequence differences between the LTRs of these two virus groups. Despite this lack of independent enhancer activity, we previously identified sequences in ev LTRs that were able to functionally replace essential enhancer domains from the RSV enhancer with which they share limited sequence similarity. To identify candidate enhancer domains in ev LTRs that are functionally equivalent to those in RSV LTRs, we analyzed and compared ev and RSV LTR-specific DNA-protein interactions. Using this approach, we identified two candidate enhancer domains and one deficiency in ev LTRs. One of the proposed ev enhancer domains was identified as a CArG box, a motif also found upstream of several muscle-specific genes, and as the core sequence of the c-fos serum response element. The RSV LTR contains two CArG motifs, one at a previously identified site and one identified in this report at the same relative location as the ev CArG motif. A second factor binding site that interacts with a heat-stable protein was also identified in ev LTRs and, contrary to previous suggestions, appears to be different from previously described exogenous virus enhancer binding proteins. Finally, a deficiency in factor binding was found within the one inverted CCAAT box in ev LTRs, affirming the importance of sequences that flank CCAAT motifs in factor binding and providing a candidate defect in the ev enhancer.

The Endogenous Retroviral ev 21 Locus in Commercial Chicken Lines and its Relationship with the Slow-Feathering Phenotype (K)

Provirus ev21 was found in both K- and k(+)-feathering Rhode Island Red commercial layers. Probe EV21-int revealed the presence of two distinct but similar regions, US (unoccupied site) and OS (occupied site). Restriction analysis showed that these regions had at least 19 kb structural homology but were distinguishable by ev21 proviral sequences, OS, and possibly three polymorphics US. The loci OS and US were both located on Chromosome Z. The k(+)-feathering birds were found to have only one site (either OS or US) per individual Z chromosome, whereas K-feathering birds had at least one Z chromosome with both regions in cis configuration. It has been possible to show that the reversion to the k(+)-feathering phenotype is accompanied by the loss of either a US or OS region that disrupts the cis configuration in K-feathering birds.

Association of a chicken repetitive element with the endogenous virus-21 slow-feathering locus

The DNA sequences of an endogenous virus ev21-cell junction fragment (JFIL-1), and the pristine ev21 unoccupied region were analyzed. Comparisons of 3' proviral sequences of JFIL-1 with comparable regions of ev2, the prototype Rous-associated provirus (RAV-0), revealed minor single-base substitutions in the transmembrane domain of proviral envelope glycoprotein and the long terminal repeat of ev21. In the cell component of the JFIL-1, insertion of a 9-bp direct repeat and deletion of a guanine deoxynucleotide abolished HaeIII and BalI recognition sites that were present in the pristine region. Upstream from the insertion site, a large region was 71 and 75% homologous with dispersed chicken repetitive (CR1) elements associated with vitellogenin and very low density apolipoprotein II genes, respectively. Southern blot hybridizations and comparisons of CR1 motifs such as polypurine tracts, a tandem imperfect octamer, and 6-bp duplications indicated that this sex-linked, CR1 element (CR1ev21) may be the longest member of this family reported thus far.

Activation of an endogenous retrovirus enhancer by insertion into a heterologous context

An enhancer element is located in the U3 portion of exogenous avian retrovirus long terminal repeats (LTRs). A similar element has not been detected in the LTRs of ev-1 and ev-2, two avian endogenous viruses (evs) that normally are not expressed in vivo. Experiments were initiated to determine whether minor nucleotide differences in the U3 region of a previously untested ev that is ubiquitously expressed in vivo (ev-3) might confer enhancer function on the LTR of this provirus. This question was addressed by inserting U3 regions from ev-3 and from ev-1 and/or ev-2 both upstream of the herpesvirus thymidine kinase gene promoter and in place of the major enhancer domains of the Rous sarcoma virus LTR and determining their relative effects on transcription. U3 regions from all evs tested were unable to enhance transcription from the thymidine kinase gene promoter, indicating that nucleotide differences in the ev U3 regions do not affect their relative enhancer function and therefore are unlikely to play a role in their differential expression in vivo. Unexpectedly, however, all ev U3 regions were able to augment transcription in an orientation-independent manner in the ev-Rous sarcoma virus hybrid LTRs. Further experiments conducted to determine why this enhancer activity is not detectable in intact ev LTRs demonstrated that it was not due to removal of repressor sequences in the ev fragments used that might normally be present in intact ev LTRs. The lack of detectable enhancer activity in intact ev LTRs also was not explained by a defect in ev promoters that makes them unresponsive to enhancers in cis. These experiments therefore identify sequences that, although unable to function detectably as enhancers in their natural context, can function efficiently in a heterologous context. Data are discussed in terms of the modularity of enhancer elements and possible interactions between enhancers and promoter-specific sequences.

Varied interactions between proviruses and adjacent host chromatin

Retroviruses integrated at unique locations in the host genome can be expressed at different levels. We have analyzed the preintegration sites of three transcriptionally competent avian endogenous proviruses (evs) to determine whether the various levels of provirus expression correlate with their location in active or inactive regions of chromatin. Our results show that in three of four cell types, the chromatin conformation (as defined by relative nuclease sensitivity) of virus preintegration sites correlates with the level of expression of the resident provirus in ev+ cells: two inactive proviruses (ev-1 and ev-2) reside in nuclease-resistant chromatin domains and one active provirus (ev-3) resides in a nuclease-sensitive domain. Nuclear runoff transcription assays reveal that the preintegration sites of the active and inactive viruses are not transcribed. However, in erythrocytes of 15-day-old chicken embryos (15d RBCs), the structure and activity of the ev-3 provirus is independent of the conformation of its preintegration site. In this cell type, the ev-3 preintegration site is organized in a nuclease-resistant conformation, while the ev-3 provirus is in a nuclease-sensitive conformation and is transcribed. In addition, the nuclease sensitivity of host sequences adjacent to ev-3 is altered in ev-3+ 15d RBCs relative to that found in 15d RBCs that lack ev-3. These data suggest that the relationship between preintegration site structure and retrovirus expression is more complex than previously described.

Role of the avian retrovirus mRNA leader in expression: evidence for novel translational control

Avian retroviral mRNAs contain a long 5' untranslated leader of approximately 380 nucleotides. The leader includes sequences required for viral replication and three AUG codons which precede the AUG codon used for translational initiation of the gag and env genes. We have used sensitive, quantitative assays of viral gene transcription and translation to analyze the role of this mRNA leader in viral gene expression. By substituting segments from related viruses, we had previously shown that the endogenous avian provirus ev-1 contained a defective leader segment (B. R. Cullen, A. M. Skalka, and G. Ju, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 80:2946-2950, 1983). The sequence analysis presented here, followed by comparison with the nondefective ev-2 endogenous provirus segment, identified the critical changes at nucleotides 4 and 7 upstream of the initiator AUG. These differences do not alter the most conserved nucleotides within the consensus sequence which precedes eucaryotic initiation codons, but lie within a nine-nucleotide region that is otherwise highly conserved among avian retrovirus strains. Analysis of a series of deletion mutants indicated that other sequences within the leader are also required for efficient expression. Characterization of the altered transcripts demonstrated that the presence of the defective ev-1 segment or the deletion of a ca. 200-nucleotide leader segment did not affect the steady-state level or splicing efficiency of these mRNAs. Thus, we conclude that the reduced expression of these mRNAs is due to a translational deficiency. These results indicate that specific leader sequences, other than the previously identified consensus nucleotides which precede eucaryotic AUG initiator codons, can influence eucaryotic gene translation.

Varied interactions between proviruses and adjacent host chromatin

Retroviruses integrated at unique locations in the host genome can be expressed at different levels. We have analyzed the preintegration sites of three transcriptionally competent avian endogenous proviruses (evs) to determine whether the various levels of provirus expression correlate with their location in active or inactive regions of chromatin. Our results show that in three of four cell types, the chromatin conformation (as defined by relative nuclease sensitivity) of virus preintegration sites correlates with the level of expression of the resident provirus in ev+ cells: two inactive proviruses (ev-1 and ev-2) reside in nuclease-resistant chromatin domains and one active provirus (ev-3) resides in a nuclease-sensitive domain. Nuclear runoff transcription assays reveal that the preintegration sites of the active and inactive viruses are not transcribed. However, in erythrocytes of 15-day-old chicken embryos (15d RBCs), the structure and activity of the ev-3 provirus is independent of the conformation of its preintegration site. In this cell type, the ev-3 preintegration site is organized in a nuclease-resistant conformation, while the ev-3 provirus is in a nuclease-sensitive conformation and is transcribed. In addition, the nuclease sensitivity of host sequences adjacent to ev-3 is altered in ev-3+ 15d RBCs relative to that found in 15d RBCs that lack ev-3. These data suggest that the relationship between preintegration site structure and retrovirus expression is more complex than previously described.

A conserved cis-acting sequence in the 5' leader of avian sarcoma virus RNA is required for packaging

The deletion of a conserved sequence of ca. 30 nucleotides in the 5' noncoding leader region of an avian sarcoma virus DNA clone resulted in a loss of infectivity after transfection of chicken embryo fibroblasts. Genetic and biochemical analysis of a representative mutant demonstrated that the env gene was expressed normally. Thus, viral RNA transcription, splicing, and translation were not impaired. The amount of mutant viral RNA encapsidated into virions, however, was severely reduced despite the presence of helper-virus. We conclude that the deleted sequence is an essential cis-acting packaging signal.

Role of the avian retrovirus mRNA leader in expression: evidence for novel translational control

Avian retroviral mRNAs contain a long 5' untranslated leader of approximately 380 nucleotides. The leader includes sequences required for viral replication and three AUG codons which precede the AUG codon used for translational initiation of the gag and env genes. We have used sensitive, quantitative assays of viral gene transcription and translation to analyze the role of this mRNA leader in viral gene expression. By substituting segments from related viruses, we had previously shown that the endogenous avian provirus ev-1 contained a defective leader segment (B. R. Cullen, A. M. Skalka, and G. Ju, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 80:2946-2950, 1983). The sequence analysis presented here, followed by comparison with the nondefective ev-2 endogenous provirus segment, identified the critical changes at nucleotides 4 and 7 upstream of the initiator AUG. These differences do not alter the most conserved nucleotides within the consensus sequence which precedes eucaryotic initiation codons, but lie within a nine-nucleotide region that is otherwise highly conserved among avian retrovirus strains. Analysis of a series of deletion mutants indicated that other sequences within the leader are also required for efficient expression. Characterization of the altered transcripts demonstrated that the presence of the defective ev-1 segment or the deletion of a ca. 200-nucleotide leader segment did not affect the steady-state level or splicing efficiency of these mRNAs. Thus, we conclude that the reduced expression of these mRNAs is due to a translational deficiency. These results indicate that specific leader sequences, other than the previously identified consensus nucleotides which precede eucaryotic AUG initiator codons, can influence eucaryotic gene translation.

Functional analysis of the transcription control region located within the avian retroviral long terminal repeat

We used several quantitative assays of in vivo transient gene expression to dissect the elements within the Rous sarcoma virus long terminal repeat (LTR) which constitute the retroviral transcription control region. Site-directed deletion mutagenesis was used to locate and define the enhancer and promoter elements within the LTR. In addition, we inserted exogenous DNA fragments into the LTR to examine the effects of position and sequence on the activity of these LTR transcriptional elements. The Rous sarcoma virus enhancer element, which we propose is located entirely within the LTR, was shown to activate both the beta-globin and retroviral LTR promoters when located in cis. We observed a striking correlation between the degree of activation and the distance between the retroviral promoter and enhancer elements. The LTR promoter element mediated the activation effect of the enhancer element, as LTR deletion mutants containing only the enhancer and TATA box region expressed little activity. The promoter region encoded a low but significant level of transcriptional activity even in the absence of an enhancer. Overall LTR transcriptional activity declined sharply with increasing distance between the LTR promoter and initiator elements. These results shed light on both the importance of the spatial arrangement of the sequence elements within this eucaryotic transcription control region and on the functional interrelationship between these elements.

Enhancer activity correlates with the oncogenic potential of avian retroviruses

Avian retroviruses lacking an oncogene, such as Rous-associated virus 1 (RAV-1), RAV-2, and td mutants of Rous sarcoma virus (RSV), can nevertheless cause leukemias and other neoplastic diseases. During this process, viral DNA integrates near a cellular proto-oncogene, such as c-myc, and thus de-regulates its expression. The virus RAV-0, on the other hand, is known to be non-oncogenic even in long-term in vivo infections of domestic chickens. The major difference between oncogenic and non-oncogenic viruses is found within the U3 region of the long terminal repeat (LTR) which is known to harbor the promoter and enhancer elements. We therefore wanted to see whether viral oncogenicity was correlated with enhancer activity. Using a variety of techniques (including the SV40 'enhancer trap' from which we obtained RSV-SV40 recombinant viruses), we demonstrate that a strong enhancer exists within the LTRs of both RSV and RAV-1. In contrast, no enhancer is present in RAV-0, although RAV-0 has functional promoter elements. Our data therefore strongly support a concept of oncogenesis by enhancer insertion.

Functional analysis of the transcription control region located within the avian retroviral long terminal repeat

We used several quantitative assays of in vivo transient gene expression to dissect the elements within the Rous sarcoma virus long terminal repeat (LTR) which constitute the retroviral transcription control region. Site-directed deletion mutagenesis was used to locate and define the enhancer and promoter elements within the LTR. In addition, we inserted exogenous DNA fragments into the LTR to examine the effects of position and sequence on the activity of these LTR transcriptional elements. The Rous sarcoma virus enhancer element, which we propose is located entirely within the LTR, was shown to activate both the beta-globin and retroviral LTR promoters when located in cis. We observed a striking correlation between the degree of activation and the distance between the retroviral promoter and enhancer elements. The LTR promoter element mediated the activation effect of the enhancer element, as LTR deletion mutants containing only the enhancer and TATA box region expressed little activity. The promoter region encoded a low but significant level of transcriptional activity even in the absence of an enhancer. Overall LTR transcriptional activity declined sharply with increasing distance between the LTR promoter and initiator elements. These results shed light on both the importance of the spatial arrangement of the sequence elements within this eucaryotic transcription control region and on the functional interrelationship between these elements.

The consensus sequence YGTGTTYY located downstream from the AATAAA signal is required for efficient formation of mRNA 3' termini

Our previous DNA sequence comparisons of 3' terminal portions from equivalent herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) and HSV-2 genes identified a conserved sequence (consensus YGTGTTYY; Y = pyrimidine) located approximately 30bp downstream from the AATAAA signal. We report here that this signal is located downstream from 67% of the mammalian mRNA 3' termini examined. Using constructions with the bacterial chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) gene linked to an HSV 'terminator' fragment, we show that deletions in the 'terminator' reduce CAT activities and the levels of CAT mRNA 3' termini. Specifically: (1) deletions of downstream sequences which extend up to the consensus YGTGTTYY signal reduce CAT levels to values 35% of those obtained with undeleted plasmids, (2) a deletion of a further 14bp, which removes the YGTGTTYY consensus but not the poly A site, reduces CAT activities to 1%-4%. The levels of CAT mRNA 3' termini reflect the reductions in CAT activities however, levels of mRNA 5' termini are unaffected by these deletions. The RNA produced in the absence of the YGTGTTYY signal is present in the cytoplasm although no CAT activity is detectable.

Transcriptional activity of avian retroviral long terminal repeats directly correlates with enhancer activity

Retroviral long terminal repeats (LTRs) contain elements responsible for the control of proviral transcription and gene expression. Molecular clones of the LTR region of a number of avian retroviruses have been isolated, and DNA sequence analysis of these clones reveals the existence of a related, but heterogeneous, family of LTRs. To examine the functional significance of the observed sequence differences, we have directly tested the abilities of several different avian retrovirus LTRs to act as promoters and enhancers of mRNA transcription. Our results indicate that large differences in LTR transcriptional activity exist and that these differences in gene expression directly correlate with LTR enhancer activity. In particular, we show that the LTR of Fujinami sarcoma virus is intermediate in both transcriptional and enhancer activity when compared with the very active LTRs of the exogenous viruses RAV-2 and Schmidt-Ruppin B and the much less active LTRs of the endogenous virus RAV-0 and its provirus ev-2. These results suggest that LTR enhancer activity may be the primary determinant of avian retroviral LTR transcriptional activity and, hence, oncogenic potential.

Characterization of endogenous viral loci in five lines of white Leghorn chickens

Five lines of chickens have been examined for the presence of DNA sequences related to the endogenous avian retrovirus. Five new loci have been identified, based upon analysis with the restriction endonucleases SacI and BamHI. One locus has been associated with the production of infectious endogenous virus. Restriction endonuclease mapping suggested a limited similarity between the flanking cellular sequences of two of these loci, ev-17 and ev-18, and several endogenous loci, including ev-1, already characterized. The data suggested that these two loci might have been generated by chromosomal duplication. Hybridization analysis with a probe containing the cellular sequences that flank ev-1, however, revealed that these flanking sequences shared no detectable homology with the cellular sequences that surround ev-17, ev-18, or nine other endogenous loci that were examined. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that several of the endogenous viral loci resulted either from independent infections of the germ line or from virus transpositions.

Characterization of a solitary long terminal repeat of avian endogenous virus origin

A recombinant lambda phage library constructed with a partial EcoR1 digest of DNA from a normal RPRL line 15B chicken was screened using 32P-labeled plasmid containing Rous-associated virus (pRAV-2). Nucleotide sequence analyses of a fragment of one subclone revealed the presence of a solitary long terminal repeat (LTR) that is similar to the LTRs of avian endogenous retroviruses ev1 and ev2. This LTR is flanked by unique 6 bp direct repeats characteristic of the target site for duplication of avian leukosis viruses.

Endogenous avian retroviruses contain deficient promoter and leader sequences

A sensitive and quantitative biological assay has been utilized to measure the ability of the exogenous and endogenous avian retroviral long terminal repeats (LTR) to promote gene expression in avian cells. This assay has revealed that the exogenous virus RAV-2 LTR is approximately equal to 10-fold more active than the LTRs of endogenous viruses RAV-0, ev-1, and ev-2. The endogenous viral LTRs show approximately equal activity. Upstream flanking cellular or viral sequences have no significant modulating effect on gene expression in our assay. Unexpectedly, we have detected and localized an additional defect outside of the LTR in the 5' noncoding leader sequence of ev-1 that further decreases gene expression relative to RAV-0 by approximately equal to 10-fold.