Vesicular stomatitis virus mutant with altered polyadenylic acid polymerase activity in vitro

Understanding and altering cell tropism of vesicular stomatitis virus

Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) is a prototypic nonsegmented negative-strand RNA virus. VSV's broad cell tropism makes it a popular model virus for many basic research applications. In addition, a lack of preexisting human immunity against VSV, inherent oncotropism and other features make VSV a widely used platform for vaccine and oncolytic vectors. However, VSV's neurotropism that can result in viral encephalitis in experimental animals needs to be addressed for the use of the virus as a safe vector. Therefore, it is very important to understand the determinants of VSV tropism and develop strategies to alter it. VSV glycoprotein (G) and matrix (M) protein play major roles in its cell tropism. VSV G protein is responsible for VSV broad cell tropism and is often used for pseudotyping other viruses. VSV M affects cell tropism via evasion of antiviral responses, and M mutants can be used to limit cell tropism to cell types defective in interferon signaling. In addition, other VSV proteins and host proteins may function as determinants of VSV cell tropism. Various approaches have been successfully used to alter VSV tropism to benefit basic research and clinically relevant applications.

Opposing effects of inhibiting cap addition and cap methylation on polyadenylation during vesicular stomatitis virus mRNA synthesis

The multifunctional large (L) polymerase protein of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) contains enzymatic activities essential for RNA synthesis, including mRNA cap addition and polyadenylation. We previously mapped amino acid residues G1154, T1157, H1227, and R1228, present within conserved region V (CRV) of L, as essential for mRNA cap addition. Here we show that alanine substitutions to these residues also affect 3'-end formation. Specifically, the cap-defective polymerases produced truncated transcripts that contained A-rich sequences at their 3' termini and predominantly terminated within the first 500 nucleotides (nt) of the N gene. To examine how the cap-defective polymerases respond to an authentic VSV termination and reinitiation signal present at each gene junction, we reconstituted RNA synthesis using templates that contained genes inserted (I) at the leader-N gene junction. The I genes ranged in size from 382 to 1,098 nt and were typically transcribed into full-length uncapped transcripts. In addition to lacking a cap structure, the full-length I transcripts synthesized by the cap-defective polymerases lacked an authentic polyadenylate tail and instead contained 0 to 24 A residues. Moreover, the cap-defective polymerases were also unable to copy efficiently the downstream gene. Thus, single amino acid substitutions in CRV of L protein that inhibit cap addition also inhibit polyadenylation and sequential transcription of the genome. In contrast, an amino acid substitution, K1651A, in CRVI of L protein that completely inhibits cap methylation results in the hyperpolyadenylation of mRNA. This work reveals that inhibiting cap addition and cap methylation have opposing effects on polyadenylation during VSV mRNA synthesis and provides evidence in support of a link between correct 5' cap formation and 3' polyadenylation.

Analysis of a structural homology model of the 2'-O-ribose methyltransferase domain within the vesicular stomatitis virus L protein

The large (L) proteins of non-segmented negative stranded (NNS) RNA viruses contain the core RNA dependent RNA polymerase activity for RNA replication and transcription as well as the activities for polyadenylating and capping the mRNA transcripts and for methylating the cap structures. There is currently no structural information available for these large multi-functional proteins. Phylogenetic analyses have led to the division of the L protein primary structure into six functional domains of high conservation that are linked by variable regions. The studies in this report investigate the role of specific amino acids within domain VI of the VSV L protein, which contains a 2'-O-ribose methyltransferase (MTase) domain. We generated a structural homology model of residues 1644-1842 within domain VI based on the crystal structure determined for the known 2'-O-ribose MTase of E. coli, RrmJ. The information generated by this homology model directed us to residues structurally important for MTase activity and SAM binding. Selected residues were analyzed by site-specific mutagenesis and the mutant L proteins were assayed for their effects on RNA synthesis and cap methylation. The goal of this study was to functionally test the model in order to gain insight into the structural constraints of this region of the L protein. The data presented here revealed specific mutations that affect transcription, replication, and 5' cap methylation, many of which resulted in polymerases temperature sensitive for RNA synthesis.

S-adenosyl homocysteine-induced hyperpolyadenylation of vesicular stomatitis virus mRNA requires the methyltransferase activity of L protein

There are many unique aspects of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) transcription. In addition to its unusual mRNA capping and methyltransferase mechanisms, the addition of S-adenosyl homocysteine (SAH), which is the by-product and competitive inhibitor of S-adenosyl methionine (SAM)-mediated methyltransferase reactions, leads to synthesis of poly(A) tails on the 3' end of VSV mRNAs that are 10- or 20-fold longer than normal. The mechanism by which this occurs is not understood, since it has been shown that productive transcription is not dependent on 5' cap methylation and full-length VSV mRNAs can be synthesized in the absence of SAM. To investigate this unusual phenotype, we assayed the effects of SAH on transcription using a panel of recombinant viruses that contained mutations in domain VI of the VSV L protein. The L proteins we investigated displayed a range of 5' cap methyltransferase activities. In the present study, we show that the ability of the VSV L protein to catalyze methyl transfer correlates with its sensitivity to SAH with respect to polyadenylation, thereby indicating an intriguing connection between 5' and 3' end mRNA modifications. We also identified an L protein mutant that hyperpolyadenylates mRNA irrespective of the presence or absence of exogenous SAH. Further, the data presented here show that the wild-type L protein hyperpolyadenylates a percentage of VSV mRNAs in infected cells as well as in vitro.

New mRNAs are preferentially translated during vesicular stomatitis virus infection

During vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) infection, host protein synthesis is inhibited, while synthesis of viral proteins increases. VSV infection causes inhibition of host transcription and RNA transport. Therefore, most host mRNAs in the cytoplasm of infected cells were synthesized before infection. However, viral mRNAs are synthesized throughout infection and are newer than preexisting host mRNAs. To determine if the timing of appearance of mRNAs in the cytoplasm affected their translation during VSV infection, we transfected reporter mRNAs into cells at various times relative to the time of infection and measured their rate of translation in mock- and VSV-infected cells. We found that translation of mRNAs transfected during infection was not inhibited but that translation of mRNAs transfected prior to infection was inhibited during VSV infection. Based on these data, we conclude that the timing of viral mRNA appearance in the cytoplasm is responsible, at least in part, for the preferential translation of VSV mRNAs. A time course measuring translation efficiencies of viral and host mRNAs showed that the translation efficiencies of viral mRNAs increased between 4 and 8 h postinfection, while translation efficiencies of host mRNAs decreased. The increased translation efficiency of viral mRNAs occurred in cells infected with an M protein mutant virus that is defective in host shutoff, demonstrating that the enhanced translation of viral mRNA is genetically separable from inhibition of translation of host mRNA.

Vesicular stomatitis viruses resistant to the methylase inhibitor sinefungin upregulate RNA synthesis and reveal mutations that affect mRNA cap methylation

Sinefungin (SIN), a natural S-adenosyl-L-methionine analog produced by Streptomyces griseolus, is a potent inhibitor of methyltransferases. We evaluated the effect of SIN on replication of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), a prototype of the nonsegmented negative-strand RNA viruses. The 241-kDa large polymerase (L) protein of VSV methylates viral mRNA cap structures at the guanine-N-7 (G-N-7) and ribose-2'-O (2'-O) positions. By performing transcription reactions in vitro, we show that both methylations are inhibited by SIN and that methylation was more sensitive at the G-N-7 than at 2'-O position. We further show that SIN inhibited growth of VSV in cell culture, reducing viral yield by 50-fold and diminishing plaque size. We isolated eight mutants that were resistant to SIN as judged by their growth characteristics. The SIN-resistant (SINR) viruses contained mutations in the L gene, the promoter for L gene expression provided by the conserved sequence elements of the G-L gene junction and the M gene. Five mutations resulted in amino acid substitutions to conserved regions II/III and VI of the L protein. For each mutant, we examined viral gene expression in cells and cap methylation in vitro. SINR mutants upregulated RNA synthesis in the presence of SIN, which may be responsible for their resistance. We also found that some SINR viruses with L gene mutations were defective in cap methylation in vitro, yet their methylases were less sensitive to SIN inhibition than those of the wild-type parent. These studies show that the VSV methylases are inhibited by SIN, and they define new regions of L protein that affect cap methylation. These studies also provide experimental evidence that inhibition of cap methylases is a potential strategy for development of antiviral therapeutics against nonsegmented negative-strand RNA viruses.

Preferential translation of vesicular stomatitis virus mRNAs is conferred by transcription from the viral genome

Host protein synthesis is inhibited in cells infected with vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV). It has been proposed that viral mRNAs are subjected to the same inhibition but are predominantly translated because of their abundance. To compare translation efficiencies of viral and host mRNAs during infection, we used an enhanced green fluorescent protein (EGFP) reporter expressed from a recombinant virus or from the host nucleus in stably transfected cells. Translation efficiency of host-derived EGFP mRNA was reduced more than threefold at eight hours postinfection, while viral-derived mRNA was translated around sevenfold more efficiently than host-derived EGFP mRNA in VSV-infected cells. To test whether mRNAs transcribed in the cytoplasm are resistant to shutoff of translation during VSV infection, HeLa cells were infected with a recombinant simian virus 5 (rSV5) that expressed GFP. Cells were then superinfected with VSV or mock superinfected. GFP mRNA transcribed by rSV5 was not resistant to translation inhibition during superinfection with VSV, indicating that transcription in the cytoplasm is not sufficient for preventing translation inhibition. To determine if cis-acting sequences in untranslated regions (UTRs) were involved in preferential translation of VSV mRNAs, we constructed EGFP reporters with VSV or control UTRs and measured the translation efficiency in mock-infected and VSV-infected cells. The presence of VSV UTRs did not affect mRNA translation efficiency in mock- or VSV-infected cells, indicating that VSV mRNAs do not contain cis-acting sequences that influence translation. However, we found that when EGFP mRNAs transcribed by VSV or by the host were translated in vitro, VSV-derived EGFP mRNA was translated 22 times more efficiently than host-derived EGFP mRNA. This indicated that VSV mRNAs do contain cis-acting structural elements (that are not sequence based), which enhance translation efficiency of viral mRNAs.

Comparison of identical temperature-sensitive mutations in the L polymerase proteins of sendai and parainfluenza3 viruses

The L subunit of the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of negative strand RNA viruses is believed to possess all the enzymatic activities necessary for viral transcription and replication. Mutations in the L proteins of human parainfluenza virus type 3 (PIV3) and vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) have been shown to confer temperature sensitivity to the viruses; however, their specific defects have not been determined. Mutant PIV3 L proteins expressed from plasmids were tested for temperature sensitivity in transcription and replication in a minigenome reporter system in cells and for in vitro transcription from purified PIV3 template. The single L mutants, Y942H and L992F, were temperature sensitive (ts) in both assays, although viral RNA synthesis was not completely abolished at the nonpermissive temperature. Surprisingly, the T1558I L mutant was not ts, although its cognate virus was ts. Thus the ts defect in this virus may be due to the abrogation of an essential interaction of the mutant polymerase with a host cell component, which is not measured by the RNA synthesis assays. Most of the combinations of the PIV3 L mutations were not additive and did not show temperature sensitivity in in vitro transcription. Since they were ts in the minigenome assay in vivo, replication appears to be specifically defective. The ts mutations in PIV3 and VSV L proteins were also substituted into the Sendai L protein to compare the defects in related systems. Only Sendai Y942H L was ts in both transcription and replication. One Sendai L mutant, L992F, gave much better replication than transcription. Several other mutants could transcribe but not replicate in vitro, while replication in vivo was normal.

Increased synthesis of polycistronic mRNA associated with increased polyadenylation by vesicular stomatitis virus

Electron microscopy suggested that the mRNA produced in vitro by tsG16(I), a temperature-sensitive mutant of vesicular stomatitis virus, contained an increased proportion of polycistronic mRNAs. Using hybrid selection, we found that the poly(A)+ mRNA synthesized in vitro by tsG16(I) contained approximately two to three times more polycistronic mRNA than did poly(A)+ mRNA synthesized in vitro by the parental wild-type (wt) virus. The increase in polycistronic mRNA occurred at all intergenic junctions examined. In vitro, tsG16(I) has an increased polyadenylation phenotype and a temperature-sensitive transcriptase activity that appear to be due to different mutations. Partial revertants of tsG16(I), which have lost the aberrant polyadenylation phenotype but retain the in vitro thermosensitive transcriptase, produced wt amounts of polycistronic mRNA. This suggested that the increased production of polycistronic mRNA by tsG16(I) may be associated with the increased polyadenylation phenotype of this mutant. These data further support the hypothesis that an increase in size of poly(A) tracts is associated with increased production of polycistronic mRNA.

Gene expression of nonsegmented negative strand RNA viruses

Nonsegmented negative strand RNA viruses comprise major human and animal pathogens in nature. This class of viruses is ubiquitous and infects vertebrates, invertebrates, and plants. Our laboratory has been working on the gene expression of two prototype nonsegmented negative strand RNA viruses, vesicular stomatitis virus (a rhabdovirus) and human parainfluenza virus 3 (a paramyxovirus). An RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (L and P protein) is packaged within the virion which faithfully copies the genome RNA in vitro and in vivo; this enzyme complex, in association with the nucleocapsid protein (N), is also involved in the replication process. In this review, we have presented up-to-date information of the structure and function of the RNA polymerases of these two viruses, the mechanisms of transcription and replication, and the role of host proteins in the life-cycle of the viruses. These detailed studies have led us to a better understanding of the roles of viral and cellular proteins in the viral gene expression.

Revertants of a mutant of vesicular stomatitis virus which has an aberrant polyadenylation activity and a temperature-sensitive transcriptase

tsG16(l), a temperature-sensitive mutant of vesicular stomatitis virus, in vitro has at least three phenotypic differences from its parental wild-type (wt) virus due to mutation of the L gene. It was not known whether (i) the temperature-sensitivity of the transcriptase, (ii) the aberrant polyadenylation phenotype, and (iii) the extent of increased polyadenylation in response to S-adenosylhomocysteine (SAH) were associated with a single mutation. Spontaneous partial revertants were selected from tsG16(I) on the basis of the ability to form plaques at 34.7 degrees (35G16 revertants) or from 35G16 revertants on the basis of the ability to form plaques at 37 degrees (37G16 revertants). All six 35G16 revertants had fully (five) or partially (one) recovered the wt polyadenylation phenotype and the former five had also fully recovered the wt polyadenylation response to SAH. This suggested that a single mutation in tsG16(I) was probably associated with both of these phenotypes and also probably conferred the inability to grow at 34.7 degrees. None of the 35G16 revertants regained the wt phenotype for thermosensitivity of the transcriptase, although both of the 37G16 revertants did. This suggested that in vitro temperature-sensitivity of transcription by tsG16(I) might be due to a mutation different than the one affecting polyadenylation in the absence or presence of SAH.

The vesicular stomatitis virus L protein possesses the mRNA methyltransferase activities

We have previously shown that the vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) host range mutant, hr 1, is completely defective for the mRNA methyltransferase activities, but can synthesize full-length, unmethylated mRNAs in vitro [S. M. Horikami and S. A. Moyer (1982). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79, 7694-7698] and in vivo [S. M. Horikami, F. De Ferra, and S. A. Moyer (1984). Virology 138, 1-15]. Here we have used the hr 1 mutant to identify the viral protein which possesses the methyltransferase activities. The wild-type VSV L and NS proteins, subunits of the viral RNA polymerase, were separately purified and added to high salt dissociated mutant hr 1 nucleocapsids for in vitro transcription reactions. The results show that the purified wild-type L protein, but not the NS protein, restores methylation and thus possesses the viral mRNA methyltransferase activities.

Aberrant polyadenylation by a vesicular stomatitis virus mutant is due to an altered L protein

TsG16(I) is a temperature-sensitive mutant of vesicular stomatitis virus, Indiana serotype. Our stocks of this mutant overproduce polyadenylic acid in an in vitro transcription system. The overproduction of polyadenylic acid occurs at all temperatures tested (27, 31, 35, and 39 degrees C) and is apparently not due to an alternation in the N protein-RNA template. To characterize the altered moiety in tsG16(I) responsible for this phenotype, virions were fractionated and the polyadenylation phenotype in homologous and heterologous reconstitution assays was determined. The aberrant polyadenylation phenotype correlated with the presence of ts L protein but not ts NS or ts M protein fractions. Results of experiments in which solubilized tsG16(I) and wild-type virion components were mixed indicated that the altered moiety behaved as if present in stoichiometric amounts relative to active L protein. The effects of raising the temperature from 31 to 39 degrees C in such mixes were as would be predicted upon the assumption that the polyadenylation phenotype was associated with a thermosensitive transcriptase component [the L protein of tsG16(I) is known to be thermosensitive]. We conclude that the data strongly support the hypothesis that L is the altered protein responsible for the aberrant polyadenylation phenotype of tsG16(I).

Detection of in vivo synthesis of polycistronic mRNAs of vesicular stomatitis virus

The in vivo synthesis of polycistronic transcripts of vesicular stomatitis virus in human amnion U cells and mouse L cells was detected by RNA blot hybridization. Within the molecular weight range resolved by this gel electrophoresis system, all possible combinations of sequentially linked messages were observed, as identified by their patterns of hybridization and their apparent molecular weights. Actinomycin D pretreatment of mouse L cells did not affect the frequency or size of polycistronic messages, nor did these differ between L cells and U cells. Vesicular stomatitis virus polycistronic transcripts were synthesized in vivo in a roughly uniform distribution, except for the NS-M dicistronic mRNA, which was much more frequent. Most of the polycistronic RNA species were found to be poly(A)+, but at least one, the tetracistronic molecule N-NS-M-G, was clearly poly(A)-. Analysis of RNA following treatment with RNase H in the presence of oligo(dT) indicated that the in vivo-synthesized poly(A)+ polycistronic species NS-M, M-G, and N-NS-M had poly(A) tracts at their 3' molecular termini but not internally at their intercistronic junctions.