Conditional poliovirus mutants made by random deletion mutagenesis of infectious cDNA

RanDeL-Seq: a High-Throughput Method to Map Viral cis- and trans-Acting Elements

Recent studies have renewed interest in developing novel antiviral therapeutics and vaccines based on defective interfering particles (DIPs)—a subset of viral deletion mutants that conditionally replicate. Identifying and engineering DIPs require that viral cis- and trans-acting elements be accurately mapped.

It has long been known that noncoding genomic regions can be obligate cis elements acted upon in trans by gene products. In viruses, cis elements regulate gene expression, encapsidation, and other maturation processes, but mapping these elements relies on targeted iterative deletion or laborious prospecting for rare spontaneously occurring mutants. Here, we introduce a method to comprehensively map viral cis and trans elements at single-nucleotide resolution by high-throughput random deletion. Variable-size deletions are randomly generated by transposon integration, excision, and exonuclease chewback and then barcoded for tracking via sequencing (i.e., random deletion library sequencing [RanDeL-seq]). Using RanDeL-seq, we generated and screened >23,000 HIV-1 variants to generate a single-base resolution map of HIV-1’s cis and trans elements. The resulting landscape recapitulated HIV-1’s known cis-acting elements (i.e., long terminal repeat [LTR], Ψ, and Rev response element [RRE]) and, surprisingly, indicated that HIV-1’s central DNA flap (i.e., central polypurine tract [cPPT] to central termination sequence [CTS]) is as critical as the LTR, Ψ, and RRE for long-term passage. Strikingly, RanDeL-seq identified a previously unreported ∼300-bp region downstream of RRE extending to splice acceptor 7 that is equally critical for sustained viral passage. RanDeL-seq was also used to construct and screen a library of >90,000 variants of Zika virus (ZIKV). Unexpectedly, RanDeL-seq indicated that ZIKV’s cis-acting regions are larger than the untranscribed (UTR) termini, encompassing a large fraction of the nonstructural genes. Collectively, RanDeL-seq provides a versatile framework for generating viral deletion mutants, enabling discovery of replication mechanisms and development of novel antiviral therapeutics, particularly for emerging viral infections.

Functional coupling between replication and packaging of poliovirus replicon RNA

Poliovirus RNA genomes that contained deletions in the capsid-coding regions were synthesized in monkey kidney cells that constitutively expressed T7 RNA polymerase. These replication-competent subgenomic RNAs, or replicons (G. Kaplan and V. R. Racaniello, J. Virol. 62:1687-1696, 1988), were encapsidated in trans by superinfecting polioviruses. When superinfecting poliovirus resistant to the antiviral compound guanidine was used, the RNA replication of the replicon RNAs could be inhibited independently of the RNA replication of the guanidine-resistant helper virus. Inhibiting the replication of the replicon RNA also profoundly inhibited its trans-encapsidation, even though the capsid proteins present in the cells could efficiently encapsidate the helper virus. The observed coupling between RNA replication and RNA packaging could account for the specificity of poliovirus RNA packaging in infected cells and the observed effects of mutations in the coding regions of nonstructural proteins on virion morphogenesis. It is suggested that this coupling results from direct interactions between the RNA replication machinery and the capsid proteins. The coupling of RNA packaging to RNA replication and of RNA replication to translation (J. E. Novak and K. Kirkegaard, Genes Dev. 8:1726-1737, 1994) could serve as mechanisms for late proofreading of poliovirus RNA, allowing only those RNA genomes capable of translating a full complement of functional RNA replication proteins to be propagated.

Human protein Sam68 relocalization and interaction with poliovirus RNA polymerase in infected cells

A HeLa cDNA expression library was screened for human polypeptides that interacted with the poliovirus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, 3D, using the two-hybrid system in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Sam68 (Src-associated in mitosis, 68 kDa) emerged as the human cDNA that, when fused to a transcriptional activation domain, gave the strongest 3D interaction signal with a LexA-3D hybrid protein. 3D polymerase and Sam68 coimmunoprecipitated from infected human cell lysates with antibodies that recognized either protein. Upon poliovirus infection, Sam68 relocalized from the nucleus to the cytoplasm, where poliovirus replication occurs. Sam68 was isolated from infected cell lysates with an antibody that recognizes poliovirus protein 2C, suggesting that it is found on poliovirus-induced membranes upon which viral RNA synthesis occurs. These data, in combination with the known RNA- and protein-binding properties of Sam68, make Sam68 a strong candidate for a host protein with a functional role in poliovirus replication.

RNA binding properties of poliovirus subviral particles

The mechanism of encapsidation of the RNA genome of poliovirus and other picornaviruses is unknown. To test whether any of the putative assembly intermediates of poliovirus could interact directly with the poliovirus RNA genome, poliovirus RNA was attached to magnetic streptavidin beads and incubated with partially purified extracts containing 35S-labeled 14S pentamer and 75S empty-capsid subviral particles from infected cells. The amount of labeled protein bound to the beads was monitored, thus testing the RNA-binding activities of only the labeled viral proteins in the preparations. In this assay, nonspecific RNA-binding activity was displayed by the 14S pentameric particles and mature virons. 75S empty capsids displayed no propensity to associate with RNA. 14S pentamers were demonstrated to form rapidly sedimenting complexes and to undergo a conformational alteration upon RNA binding. These findings are consistent with a direct role for the 14S pentameric particles in RNA packaging during poliovirus morphogenesis.

Coupling between genome translation and replication in an RNA virus

The replication of poliovirus RNA genomes containing amber mutations was studied to test whether viral proteins provided in trans could rescue the replication of an RNA genome that could not be completely translated itself. Mutants containing amber codons at different positions in the genome displayed vastly different abilities to be rescued by wild-type proteins provided by a helper genome. Amber-suppressing cell lines were used to ensure that the defects in the amber mutants arose from their failure to be translated, not from defects in RNA sequence or structure. An internal region of the poliovirus genome was identified whose translation is required in cis; failure to translate this region was shown to inhibit RNA replication. This coupling between translation and RNA replication could provide a late proofreading mechanism that enables poliovirus, and possibly many other RNA viruses, to prevent the replication of defective genomes.

Clustered charged-to-alanine mutagenesis of poliovirus RNA-dependent RNA polymerase yields multiple temperature-sensitive mutants defective in RNA synthesis

To generate a collection of conditionally defective poliovirus mutants, clustered charged-to-alanine mutagenesis of the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase 3D was performed. Clusters of charged residues in the polymerase coding region were replaced with alanines by deoxyoligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis of a full-length poliovirus cDNA clone. Following transfection of 27 mutagenized cDNA clones, 10 (37%) gave rise to viruses with temperature-sensitive (ts) phenotypes. Three of the ts mutants displayed severe ts plaque reduction phenotypes, producing at least 10(3)-fold fewer plaques at 39.5 degrees C than at 32.5 degrees C; the other seven mutants displayed ts small-plaque phenotypes. Constant-temperature, single-cycle infections showed defects in virus yield or RNA accumulation at the nonpermissive temperature for eight stable ts mutants. In temperature shift experiments, seven of the ts mutants showed reduced accumulation of viral RNA at the nonpermissive temperature and showed no other ts defects. The mutations responsible for the phenotypes of most of these ts mutants lie in the N-terminal third of the 3D coding region, where no well-characterized mutations responsible for viable mutants had been previously identified. Clustered charged-to-alanine mutagenesis (S. H. Bass, M. G. Mulkerrin, and J. A. Wells, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 88:4498-4502, 1991; W. F. Bennett, N. F. Paoni, B. A. Keyt, D. Botstein, J. J. S. Jones, L. Presta, F. M. Wurm, and M. J. Zoller, J. Biol. Chem. 266:5191-5201, 1991; and K. F. Wertman, D. G. Drubin, and D. Botstein, Genetics 132:337-350, 1992) is designed to target residues on the surfaces of folded proteins; thus, extragenic suppression analysis of such mutant viruses may be very useful in identifying components of the viral replication complex.

Poliovirus capsid proteins derived from P1 precursors with glutamine-valine cleavage sites have defects in assembly and RNA encapsidation

Assembly of poliovirus virions requires proteolytic cleavage of the P1 capsid precursor polyprotein between two separate glutamine-glycine (QG) amino acid pairs by the viral protease 3CD. In this study, we have investigated the effects on P1 polyprotein processing and subsequent assembly of processed capsid proteins caused by substitution of the glycine residue at the individual QG cleavage sites with valine (QG-->QV). P1 cDNAs encoding the valine substitutions were created by site-directed mutagenesis and were recombined into wild-type vaccinia virus to generate recombinant vaccinia viruses which expressed the mutant P1 precursors. The recombinant vaccinia virus-expressed mutant P1 polyproteins were analyzed for proteolytic processing defects in cells coinfected with a recombinant vaccinia virus (VVP3) that expresses the poliovirus 3CD protease and for processing and assembly defects by using a trans complementation system in which P1-expressing recombinant vaccinia viruses provide capsid precursor to a defective poliovirus genome that does not express functional capsid proteins (D. C. Ansardi, D. C. Porter, and C. D. Morrow, J. Virol. 67:3684-3690, 1993). The QV-substituted precursors were proteolytically processed at the altered sites both in cells coinfected with VVP3 and in cells coinfected with defective poliovirus, although the kinetics of cleavage at the altered sites were slower than those of cleavage at the wild-type QG site in the precursor. Completely processed capsid proteins VP0, VP3, and VP1 derived from the mutant precursor containing a valine at the amino terminus of VP3 (VP3-G001V) were unstable and failed to assemble stable subviral structures in cells coinfected with defective poliovirus. In contrast, capsid proteins derived from the P1 precursor with a valine substitution at the amino terminus of VP1 (VP1-G001V) assembled empty capsid particles but were deficient in assembling RNA-containing virions. The assembly characteristics of the VP1-G001V mutant were compared with those of a previously described VP3-VP1 cleavage site mutant (K. Kirkegaard and B. Nelsen, J. Virol. 64:185-194, 1990) which contained a deletion of the first four amino-terminal residues of VP1 (VP1-delta 1-4) and which was reconstructed for our studies into the recombinant vaccinia virus system. Complete proteolytic processing of the VP1-delta 1-4 precursor also occurred more slowly than complete cleavage of the wild-type precursor, and formation of virions was delayed; however, capsid proteins derived from the VP1-G001V mutant assembled RNA-containing virions less efficiently than those derived from the VP1-delta 1-4 precursor.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Role for the P4 amino acid residue in substrate utilization by the poliovirus 3CD proteinase

Amino acid insertions or substitutions were introduced into the poliovirus P1 capsid precursor at locations proximal to the two known Q-G cleavage sites to examine the role of the P4 residue in substrate processing by proteinase 3CD. Analysis of the processing profile of P1 precursors containing four-amino-acid insertions into the carboxy terminus of VP3 or a single-amino-acid substitution at the P4 position of the VP3-VP1 cleavage site demonstrates that substitution of the alanine residue in the P4 position of the VP3-VP1 cleavage site significantly affects cleavage at that site by proteinase 3CD. A single-amino-acid substitution at the P4 position of the VP0-VP3 cleavage site, on the other hand, has only a slight effect on 3CD-mediated processing at this cleavage site. Finally, analysis of six amino acid insertion mutations containing Q-G amino acid pairs demonstrates that the in vitro and in vivo selection of a cleavage site from two adjacent Q-G amino acid pairs depends on the presence of an alanine in the P4 position of the cleaved site. Our data provide genetic and biochemical evidence that the alanine residue in the P4 position of the VP3-VP1 cleavage site is a required substrate determinant for the recognition and cleavage of that site by proteinase 3CD and suggest that the P4 alanine residue may be specifically recognized by proteinase 3CD.

Regulation of a double-stranded RNA modification activity in human cells

A double-stranded RNA (dsRNA)-specific modification activity from Xenopus oocytes and human cells dsRNA modifier) converts adenosine residues present in dsRNA to inosines. The function of the dsRNA modifier is unknown, although it has been suggested that it may be part of the cellular antiviral response. We investigated the relationship between the activity of the dsRNA modifier, viral infection, and the antiviral response in human cells induced by poly(rI)-poly(rC) [poly(I.C)] treatment. We found, unexpectedly, that treatment of HeLa cells with poly(I.C) or other dsRNA molecules resulted in the dramatic inhibition of the dsRNA modifier. Mixing experiments, reconstruction experiments, and pretreatment of extracts with RNases indicated that inhibition of the dsRNA modifier did not result from the continued presence of a soluble inhibitor such as dsRNA) in the in vitro modification reactions. Treatment of cells with cyclohexamide or dactinomycin simultaneously with the poly(I.C) demonstrated that in vivo inhibition of the dsRNA modifier did not require new transcription or translation. The dsRNA modification activity was also substantially inhibited in cells infected with poliovirus and was slightly inhibited in cells infected with adenovirus. The inhibition of the dsRNA modifier during the antiviral state is thus not consistent with an antiviral function, and instead suggests another cellular function for dsRNA modification.

Regulation of a double-stranded RNA modification activity in human cells

A double-stranded RNA (dsRNA)-specific modification activity from Xenopus oocytes and human cells dsRNA modifier) converts adenosine residues present in dsRNA to inosines. The function of the dsRNA modifier is unknown, although it has been suggested that it may be part of the cellular antiviral response. We investigated the relationship between the activity of the dsRNA modifier, viral infection, and the antiviral response in human cells induced by poly(rI)-poly(rC) [poly(I.C)] treatment. We found, unexpectedly, that treatment of HeLa cells with poly(I.C) or other dsRNA molecules resulted in the dramatic inhibition of the dsRNA modifier. Mixing experiments, reconstruction experiments, and pretreatment of extracts with RNases indicated that inhibition of the dsRNA modifier did not result from the continued presence of a soluble inhibitor such as dsRNA) in the in vitro modification reactions. Treatment of cells with cyclohexamide or dactinomycin simultaneously with the poly(I.C) demonstrated that in vivo inhibition of the dsRNA modifier did not require new transcription or translation. The dsRNA modification activity was also substantially inhibited in cells infected with poliovirus and was slightly inhibited in cells infected with adenovirus. The inhibition of the dsRNA modifier during the antiviral state is thus not consistent with an antiviral function, and instead suggests another cellular function for dsRNA modification.

Analysis of putative active site residues of the poliovirus 3C protease

It was recently suggested that the picornavirus 3C proteases are homologous to the chymotrypsin-like serine proteases. The two structural models proposed differ in one of the postulated active site residues, Glu/Asp71 or Asp85. We changed Glu71 of the poliovirus type 1 protease to Asp or Gln and Asp85 to Glu by oligonucleotide-directed site-specific mutagenesis of an infectious cDNA, and attempted to recover virus after transfection. Both Glu71 changes were lethal for the virus and proteolytic activity was abolished in vitro with the exception of the primary cleavage event at the P2/P3 junction. In contrast, the Asp85----Glu virus was viable. This mutant was temperature-sensitive for growth at 39 degrees and exhibited a minute plaque phenotype at permissive temperature. This defect correlated with low levels of viral-specific RNA and protein syntheses and slow virus growth. Proteolytic processing at the COOH-terminus of 3C was impaired, reducing the production of mature 3C and the viral replicase 3D. In addition, 3C-mediated cleavage events within the P2 region of the polyprotein seemed to occur rather inefficiently. 3C-specific processing within P1 and elsewhere within P3 was unaffected. We suggest that Asp85 does not form part of the active site of 3C, but could be important for the specific recognition of cleavage sites within P2.

Temperature-sensitive poliovirus mutant fails to cleave VP0 and accumulates provirions

A temperature-sensitive mutant of poliovirus, VP2-103, was isolated and characterized. A single nucleotide change, resulting in the substitution of glutamine for arginine at amino acid 76 of the capsid protein VP2, prevented the maturation of virions at the nonpermissive temperature. Particles indistinguishable from the previously elusive provirions were observed; these particles have been proposed to be penultimate in virion morphogenesis. Cleavage of VP0 into VP2 and VP4, the products found in mature virions, was not observed in VP2-103-infected cells at the nonpermissive temperature. The cleavage of VP0 in wild-type poliovirus-infected cells is dependent on RNA packaging; this reaction has been postulated to be autocatalytic. The existence of RNA-containing provirionlike particles in VP2-103-infected cells shows that RNA packaging can be uncoupled from VP0 cleavage.

Mutations in VP1 of poliovirus specifically affect both encapsidation and release of viral RNA

The phenotypic defects of two type 1 Mahoney poliovirus mutants, termed VP1-101 and VP1-102, were caused by two different small deletions in the region of the RNA genome encoding the amino terminus of the capsid protein VP1. This portion of VP1 was unresolved in the three-dimensional structure of the poliovirion, buried within the virion, and likely to interact with the viral RNA. Both VP1-101 and VP1-102 showed a diminished ability to enter CV1 but not HeLa cells; both mutants formed plaques on CV1 and HeLa cells that were smaller than wild type. Neither the rate of binding to cells nor the rate of subsequent receptor-dependent conformational change of the mutant poliovirions was affected. However, both mutants displayed delayed kinetics of RNA release compared with wild-type virus. One of the mutants, VP1-102, also displayed a defect in viral morphogenesis: 75S empty capsids formed normally, but 150S particles that contained RNA accumulated much more slowly. We suggest that the VP1-102 mutation affects RNA encapsidation as well as RNA release, whereas the VP1-101 mutation affects only RNA release. Therefore, RNA packaging and RNA release are genetically linked but can be mutated separately in different VP1 alleles, and both processes involve the amino terminus of VP1.