Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 TAR element revertant viruses define RNA structures required for efficient viral gene expression and replication

Early treatment regimens achieve sustained virologic remission in infant macaques infected with SIV at birth

Early antiretroviral therapy (ART) in HIV-infected infants generally fails to achieve a sustained state of ART-free virologic remission, even after years of treatment. Our studies show that viral reservoir seeding is different in neonatal macaques intravenously exposed to SIV at birth, in contrast to adults. Furthermore, one month of ART including an integrase inhibitor, initiated at day 3, but not day 4 or 5 post infection, efficiently and rapidly suppresses viremia to undetectable levels. Intervention initiated at day 3 post infection and continued for 9 months achieves a sustained virologic remission in 4 of 5 infants. Collectively, an early intervention strategy within a key timeframe and regimen may result in viral remission or successful post-exposure prophylaxis for neonatal SIV infection, which may be clinically relevant for optimizing treatment strategies for HIV-infected or exposed infants.

Strategies in the design and development of (TAR) DNA-binding protein 43 (TDP-43) binding ligands

The human transactive responsive (TAR) DNA-binding protein 43 (TDP-43) is involved in a number of physiological processes in the body. Its primary function involves RNA regulation. The TDP-43 protein is also involved in many diseases such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), frontotemporal dementia (FTD), Alzheimer's disease (AD), Parkinson's disease (PD) and even cancers. These TDP-43 mediated diseases are collectively called as TDP-43 proteinopathies. Intense research in the last decade has increased our understanding on TDP-43 structure and function in biology. The three-dimensional structures of TDP-43 domains such as N-terminal domain (NTD), RNA-recognition motif-1 (RRM1), RNA-recognition motif-2 (RRM2) and the C-terminal domain (CTD) or low-complexity domain (LCD) have been solved. These structures have yielded insights into novel binding sites and pockets at various TDP-43 domains, which can be targeted by designing a diverse library of ligands including small molecules, peptides and oligonucleotides as molecular tools to (i) study TDP-43 function, (ii) develop novel diagnostic agents and (iii) discover disease-modifying therapies to treat TDP-43 proteinopathies. This review provides a summary on recent progress in the development of TDP-43 binding ligands and uses the solved structures of various TDP-43 domains to investigate putative ligand binding regions that can be exploited to discover novel molecular probes to modulate TDP-43 structure and function.

Target-Directed Azide-Alkyne Cycloaddition for Assembling HIV-1 TAR RNA Binding Ligands

The highly conserved HIV-1 transactivation response element (TAR) binds to the trans-activator protein Tat and facilitates viral replication in its latent state. The inhibition of Tat-TAR interactions by selectively targeting TAR RNA has been used as a strategy to develop potent antiviral agents. Therefore, HIV-1 TAR RNA represents a paradigmatic system for therapeutic intervention. Herein, we have employed biotin-tagged TAR RNA to assemble its own ligands from a pool of reactive azide and alkyne building blocks. To identify the binding sites and selectivity of the ligands, the in situ cycloaddition has been further performed using control nucleotide (TAR DNA and TAR RNA without bulge) templates. The hit triazole-linked thiazole peptidomimetic products have been isolated from the biotin-tagged target templates using streptavidin beads. The major triazole lead generated by the TAR RNA presumably binds in the bulge region, shows specificity for TAR RNA over TAR DNA, and inhibits Tat-TAR interactions.

Single-molecule FRET studies of HIV TAR-DNA hairpin unfolding dynamics

We directly measure the dynamics of the HIV trans-activation response (TAR)-DNA hairpin with multiple loops using single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer (smFRET) methods. Multiple FRET states are identified that correspond to intermediate melting states of the hairpin. The stability of each intermediate state is calculated from the smFRET data. The results indicate that hairpin unfolding obeys a "fraying and peeling" mechanism, and evidence for the collapse of the ends of the hairpin during folding is observed. These results suggest a possible biological function for hairpin loops serving as additional fraying centers to increase unfolding rates in otherwise stable systems. The experimental and analytical approaches developed in this article provide useful tools for studying the mechanism of multistate DNA hairpin dynamics and of other general systems with multiple parallel pathways of chemical reactions.

Opening of the TAR hairpin in the HIV-1 genome causes aberrant RNA dimerization and packaging

Background

The TAR hairpin is present at both the 5′ and 3′ end of the HIV-1 RNA genome. The 5′ element binds the viral Tat protein and is essential for Tat-mediated activation of transcription. We recently observed that complete TAR deletion is allowed in the context of an HIV-1 variant that does not depend on this Tat-TAR axis for transcription. Mutations that open the 5′ stem-loop structure did however affect the leader RNA conformation and resulted in a severe replication defect. In this study, we set out to analyze which step of the HIV-1 replication cycle is affected by this conformational change of the leader RNA.

Results

We demonstrate that opening the 5′ TAR structure through a deletion in either side of the stem region caused aberrant dimerization and reduced packaging of the unspliced viral RNA genome. In contrast, truncation of the TAR hairpin through deletions in both sides of the stem did not affect RNA dimer formation and packaging.

Conclusions

These results demonstrate that, although the TAR hairpin is not essential for RNA dimerization and packaging, mutations in TAR can significantly affect these processes through misfolding of the relevant RNA signals.

Effects of unpaired nucleotides within HIV-1 genomic secondary structures on pausing and strand transfer

Reverse transcriptase-mediated RNA displacement synthesis is required for DNA polymerization through the base-paired stem portions of secondary structures present in retroviral genomes. These regions of RNA duplex often possess single unpaired nucleotides, or "bulges," that disrupt contiguous base pairing. By using well defined secondary structures from the human immunodeficiency virus, type 1 (HIV-1), genome, we demonstrate that removal of these bulges either by deletion or by introducing a complementary base on the opposing strand results in increased pausing at specific positions within the RNA duplex. We also show that the HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein can increase synthesis through the pause sites but not as efficiently as when a bulge residue is present. Finally, we demonstrate that removing a bulge increases the proportion of strand transfer events to an acceptor template that occur prior to complete replication of a donor template secondary structure. Together our data suggest a role for bulge nucleotides in enhancing synthesis through stable secondary structures and reducing strand transfer.

Aromatic polyamidines inhibiting the Tat-induced HIV-1 transcription recognize structured TAR-RNA

We have investigated the effects of aromatic polyamidines on HIV-1 transcription. We found a block to Tat-induced HIV-1 transcription assessed by inhibition of CAT activity in HL3T1 cells at a concentration lower than the IC50 value, suggesting that molecules with three (TAPB) and four (TAPP) benzamidine rings could be useful against HIV-1. In contrast, aromatic polyamidines with only two benzamidine rings (DAPP) did not block Tat-induced transcription. We reasoned that this effect could be due to binding of TAPB and TAPP to HIV-1 TAR RNA. By EMSA and filter binding assays, we studied possible interactions of aromatic polyamidines with HIV-1 TAR RNA. Wild-type TAR RNA or TAR RNA with mutations in the stem or bulge sequences, but retaining the stem-loop structure, was used to define the RNA-binding activities of these compounds. Our data suggest that aromatic polyamidines with two (DAPP) and four (TAPP) benzamidine rings, respectively, do not bind to TAR RNA or bind without sequence selectivity. Interestingly, an aromatic polyamidine with three benzamidine rings (TAPB) recognizes the wild-type TAR RNA in a specific manner. Furthermore, we found that introduction of one halogen atom into the benzamidine rings strongly increases the RNA-binding activity of these compounds.

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 TAR RNA upper stem-loop plays distinct roles in reverse transcription and RNA packaging

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) RNA genome is flanked by a repeated sequence (R) that is required for HIV-1 replication. The first 57 nucleotides of R form a stable stem-loop structure called the transactivation response element (TAR) that can interact with the virally encoded transcription activator protein, Tat, to promote high levels of gene expression. Recently, we demonstrated that TAR is also important for efficient HIV-1 reverse transcription, since HIV-1 mutated in the upper stem-loop of TAR showed a reduced ability both to initiate and to complete reverse transcription. We have analyzed a series of HIV-1 mutant viruses to better defined the structural or sequence elements required for natural endogenous reverse transcription and packaging of virion RNA. Our results indicate that the requirement for TAR in reverse transcription is conformation dependent, since mutants with mutations that alter the upper stem-loop orientation are defective for reverse transcription initiation and have minor defects in RNA packaging. In contrast, TAR mutations that allowed the formation of alternative upper stem-loop structure greatly reduced RNA packaging but did not affect reverse transcription efficiency. These results are consistent with direct involvement of the upper stem-loop structure in packaging of genomic RNA and suggest that the TAR RNA stem-loop from nucleotide +18 to +42 interacts with other components of the reverse transcription initiation complex to promote efficient reverse transcription.

A structured RNA motif is involved in correct placement of the tRNA(3)(Lys) primer onto the human immunodeficiency virus genome

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) reverse transcription is primed by the cellular tRNA(3)(Lys) molecule that binds with its 3'-terminal 18 nucleotides to the fully complementary primer-binding site (PBS) on the viral RNA genome. Besides this complementarity, annealing of the primer may be stimulated by additional base-pairing interactions between other parts of the tRNA molecule and viral sequences flanking the PBS. According to the RNA secondary structure model of the HIV-1 leader region, part of the PBS sequence is involved in base pairing to form a small stem-loop structure, termed the U5-PBS hairpin. This hairpin may be involved in the process of reverse transcription. To study the role of the U5-PBS hairpin in the viral replication cycle, we introduced mutations in the U5 region that affect the stability of this structured RNA motif. Stabilization and destabilization of the hairpin significantly inhibited virus replication. Upon prolonged culturing of the virus mutant with the stabilized hairpin, revertant viruses were obtained with additional mutations that restore the thermodynamic stability of the U5-PBS hairpin. The thermodynamic stability of the U5-PBS hairpin apparently has to stay within narrow limits for efficient HIV-1 replication. Transient transfection experiments demonstrated that transcription of the proviral genomes, translation of the viral mRNAs, and assembly of the virions with a normal RNA content is not affected by the mutations within the U5-PBS hairpin. We show that stabilization of the hairpin reduced the amount of tRNA primer that is annealed to the PBS. Destabilization of the hairpin did not affect tRNA annealing, but the viral RNA-tRNA complex was less stable. These results suggest that the U5-PBS hairpin is involved in correct placement of the tRNA primer on the viral genome. The analysis of virus mutants and revertants and the RNA structure probing experiments presented in this study are consistent with the existence of the U5-PBS hairpin as predicted in the RNA secondary structure model.

Jembrana disease virus Tat can regulate human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) long terminal repeat-directed gene expression and can substitute for HIV Tat in viral replication

Jembrana disease virus (JDV) is a bovine lentivirus genetically similar to bovine immunodeficiency virus; it causes an acute and sometimes fatal disease in infected animals. This virus carries a very potent Tat that can strongly activate not only its own long terminal repeat (LTR) but also the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) LTR. In contrast, HIV Tat cannot reciprocally activate the JDV LTR (H. Chen, G. E. Wilcox, G. Kertayadnya, and C. Wood, J. Virol. 73:658-666, 1999). This indicates that in transactivation JDV Tat may utilize a mechanism similar to but not the same as that of the HIV Tat. To further study the similarity of JDV and HIV tat in transactivation, we first tested the responses of a series of HIV LTR mutants to the JDV Tat. Cross-transactivation of HIV LTR by JDV Tat was impaired by mutations that disrupted the HIV type 1 transactivation response element (TAR) RNA stem-loop structure. Our results demonstrated that JDV Tat, like HIV Tat, transactivated the HIV LTR at least partially in a TAR-dependent manner. However, the sequence in the loop region of TAR was not as critical for the function of JDV Tat as it was for HIV Tat. The competitive inhibition of Tat-induced transactivation by the truncated JDV or HIV Tat, which consisted only of the activation domain, suggested that similar cellular factors were involved in both JDV and HIV Tat-induced transactivation. Based on the one-round transfection assay with HIV tat mutant proviruses, the cotransfected JDV tat plasmid can functionally complement the HIV tat defect. To further characterize the effect of JDV Tat on HIV, a stable chimeric HIV carrying the JDV tat gene was generated. This chimeric HIV replicated in a T-cell line, C8166, and in peripheral blood mononuclear cells, which suggested that JDV Tat can functionally substitute for HIV Tat. Further characterization of this chimeric virus will help to elucidate how JDV Tat functions and to explain the differences between HIV and JDV Tat transactivation.

Cell cycle-regulated transcription by the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Tat transactivator

Cyclin-dependent kinases are required for the Tat-dependent transition from abortive to productive elongation. Further, the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Vpr protein prevents proliferation of infected cells by arresting them in the G(2) phase of the cell cycle. These findings suggest that the life cycle of the virus may be integrally related to the cell cycle. We now demonstrate by in vitro transcription analysis that Tat-dependent transcription takes place in a cell cycle-dependent manner. Remarkably, Tat activates gene expression in two distinct stages of the cell cycle. Tat-dependent long terminal repeat activation is observed in G(1). This activation is TAR dependent and requires a functional Sp1 binding site. A second phase of transactivation by Tat is observed in G(2) and is TAR independent. This later phase of transcription is enhanced by a natural cell cycle blocker of HIV-1, vpr, which arrests infected cells at the G(2)/M boundary. These studies link the HIV-1 Tat protein to cell cycle-specific biological functions.

An intact TAR element and cytoplasmic localization are necessary for efficient packaging of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 genomic RNA

Although most reports defining the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) genomic RNA packaging signal have focused on the region downstream of the major 5' splice site, others have suggested that sequences upstream of the splice site may also play an important role. In this study we have directly examined the role played by the HIV-1 TAR region in RNA packaging. For these experiments we used a proviral expression system that is largely independent of Tat for transcriptional activation. This allowed us to create constructs that efficiently expressed RNAs carrying mutations in TAR and to determine the ability of these RNAs to be packaged. Our results indicate that loss of sequences in TAR significantly reduce the ability of a viral RNA to be packaged. The requirement for TAR sequences in RNA packaging was further examined by using a series of missense mutations positioned throughout the entire TAR structure. TAR mutations previously shown to influence Tat transactivation, such as G31U in the upper loop region or UCU to AAG in the bulge (nucleotides [nt] 22 to 24), failed to have any effect on RNA packaging. Mutations which disrupted the portion of the TAR stem immediately below the bulge also had little effect. In contrast, dramatic effects on RNA packaging were observed with constructs containing mutations in the lower portion of the TAR stem. Point mutations which altered nt 5 to 9, 10 to 15, 44 to 49, or 50 to 54 all reduced RNA packaging 11- to 25-fold. However, compensatory double mutations which restored the stem structure were able to restore packaging. These results indicate that an intact lower stem structure, rather than a specific sequence, is required for RNA packaging. Our results also showed that RNA molecules retained within the nucleus cannot be packaged, unless they are transported to the cytoplasm by either Rev/Rev response element or the Mason-Pfizer monkey virus constitutive transport element.

Genetic instability of live, attenuated human immunodeficiency virus type 1 vaccine strains

Live, attenuated viruses have been the most successful vaccines in monkey models of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) infection. However, there are several safety concerns about using such an anti-HIV vaccine in humans, including reversion of the vaccine strain to virulence and recombination with endogenous retroviral sequences to produce new infectious and potentially pathogenic viruses. Because testing in humans would inevitably carry a substantial risk, we set out to test the genetic stability of multiply deleted HIV constructs in perpetuated tissue culture infections. The Delta3 candidate vaccine strain of HIV-1 contains deletions in the viral long terminal repeat (LTR) promoter and the vpr and nef genes. This virus replicates with delayed kinetics, but a profound enhancement of virus replication was observed after approximately 2 months of culturing. Analysis of the revertant viral genome indicated that the three introduced deletions were maintained but a 39-nucleotide sequence was inserted in the LTR promoter region. This insert was formed by duplication of the region encoding three binding sites for the Sp1 transcription factor. The duplicated Sp1 region was demonstrated to increase the LTR promoter activity, and a concomitant increase in the virus replication rate was measured. In fact, duplication of the Sp1 sites increased the fitness of the Delta3 virus (Vpr/Nef/U3) to levels higher than that of the singly deleted DeltaVpr virus. These results indicate that deleted HIV-1 vaccine strains can evolve into fast-replicating variants by multiplication of remaining sequence motifs, and their safety is therefore not guaranteed. This insight may guide future efforts to develop more stable anti-HIV vaccines.

The 5' and 3' TAR elements of human immunodeficiency virus exert effects at several points in the virus life cycle

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 RNA genome contains a terminal repeat (R) sequence that encodes the TAR hairpin motif, which has been implicated in Tat-mediated activation of transcription. More recently, a variety of other functions have been proposed for this structured RNA element. To determine the replicative roles of the 5' and 3' TAR hairpins, we analyzed multiple steps in the life cycle of wild-type and mutant viruses. A structure-destabilizing mutation was introduced in either the 5', the 3', or both TAR motifs of the proviral genome. As expected, opening of the 5' TAR hairpin caused a transcription defect. Because the level of protein expression was not similarly reduced, the translation of this mRNA was improved. No effect of the 3' hairpin on transcription and translation was measured. Mutations of the 5' and 3' hairpin structures reduced the efficiency of RNA packaging to similar extents, and RNA packaging was further reduced in the 5' and 3' TAR double mutant. Upon infection of cells with these virions, a reduced amount of reverse transcription products was synthesized by the TAR mutant. However, no net reverse transcription defect was observed after correction for the reduced level of virion RNA. This result was confirmed in in vitro reverse transcription assays. These data indicate that the 5' and 3' TAR motifs play important roles in several steps of the replication cycle, but these structures have no significant effect on the mechanism of reverse transcription.

Inhibitors of protein-RNA complexation that target the RNA: specific recognition of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 TAR RNA by small organic molecules

TAR RNA represents an attractive target for the intervention of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) replication by small molecules. We now describe three small molecule inhibitors of the HIV-1 Tat-TAR interaction that target the RNA, not the protein. The chemical structures and RNA binding characteristics of these inhibitors are unique for each molecule. Results from various biochemical and spectroscopic methods reveal that each of the three Tat-TAR inhibitors recognizes a different structural feature at the bulge, lower stem, or loop region of TAR. Furthermore, one of these Tat-TAR inhibitors has been demonstrated, in cellular environments, to inhibit (a) a TAR-dependent, Tat-activated transcription and (b) the replication of HIV-1 in a latently infectious model.

In vitro selection of HIV-1 TAR variants by the Tat protein

Starting from a pool of 10(13) RNA sequences, we isolated a number of TAR RNA variants after nine rounds of selection by binding to recombinant Tat in vitro (SELEX procedure). Sequence analysis of part of the selected molecular species indicated that two TAR variants (clones A and B) were, respectively, represented five and four times. These two groups of sequences constituted approximately 25% of the total number of analyzed clones (9/34). As far as the primary and presumptive secondary structures of the wild-type TAR are concerned, the selected A and B variants showed an almost complete sequence conservation of the Tat-binding domain, but the configuration of this nucleotide region differed within the secondary structure. Despite this difference, as verified by gel retardation and filter binding assays, both the A and B variants bound Tat in vitro with an affinity that was very close to that of the wild-type TAR. Conversely, neither variant sustained Tat-mediated trans-activation in vivo when they replaced the wild-type TAR inside the long terminal repeat of HIV_1. Taken together, our results suggest that these TAR variants have lost the ability to bind cell factor(s) in vivo and may therefore represent useful decoys for the inhibition of HIV-1 replication.

Genotypic and phenotypic characterization of long terminal repeat sequences from long-term survivors of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 infection

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1)-infected individuals who remain asymptomatic despite prolonged infection present a unique opportunity to understand virologic and immunologic factors involved in the pathogenesis of AIDS. We have previously identified a group of long-term survivors (LTS) who are clinically healthy and immunologically normal despite 13 to 15 years of HIV-1 infection. In this study, we examined the 5' long terminal repeat (5' LTR) sequences in eight of these LTS. A total of 29 nucleotide sequences were obtained from their peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC). Analysis of these sequences revealed no gross deletions within the 5' LTR. Seven of the eight subjects shared nearly identical consensus sequences in the binding sites for NF-kappaB, Sp1, and the viral trans-activator Tat. In multiple samples from one individual (Pt 5), however, G-to-A hypermutations were found throughout the entire region, suggesting a genetically defective 5' LTR. The effects of the observed genetic variations on LTR transcription were studied by transient transfection of an LTR-driven luciferase reporter gene and by infection with a full-length recombinant HIV-1 containing a luciferase reporter (HIVHXBLTRluc). A wide range of basal and Tat-induced transcriptional activities was found among the 5' LTR from seven of the eight LTS in both transfected 293 cells and donor PBMC, suggesting a functionally intact 5' LTR in these individuals. It is therefore unlikely that defects in the 5' LTR are the underlying explanation for the benign clinical course associated with these seven individuals. However, functional abnormalities were found in the LTR from Pt 5 in directing both heterologous and viral gene expression, providing a possible genetic explanation for the low viral load and prolonged asymptomatic state of this individual. Last, a similar overall degree of genetic diversity was found among viruses from the LTS compared to those from patients with AIDS, reinforcing the notion that a strong correlation between the degree of genetic diversity and the rate of disease progression is unlikely.

Efficient encapsidation of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 vectors and further characterization of cis elements required for encapsidation

To determine whether there is a cis-acting effect of translational expression of gag on RNA encapsidation, we compared the encapsidation of wild-type RNA with that of a mutant in which the translation of gag was ablated. This comparison indicated that there is not such a cis effect. To determine what is necessary and sufficient for encapsidation, we measured the relative encapsidation efficiencies of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 vector RNAs containing mutations in domains proximal to the canonical encapsidation signal or containing large deletions in the remainder of the genome. These data indicate that TAR and two additional regions are required for encapsidation and that the 5' end of the genome is sufficient for encapsidation. The Rev-responsive element is required mainly for efficient RNA transport from the nucleus to the cytoplasm. A foreign sequence was found to have a negative effect on encapsidation upon placement within the parental vector. Interestingly, this negative effect was compounded by multiple copies of the sequence.

Tat is required for efficient HIV-1 reverse transcription

The ability of human immunodeficiency virus-1 (HIV-1) to undergo efficient reverse transcription is dependent on a number of parameters. These include the binding of the tRNA(3)(Lys) to the HIV-1 primer binding site and the subsequent interaction with the heterodimeric reverse transcriptase. Recently, we demonstrated that TAR RNA was also necessary for efficient HIV-1 reverse transcription. Given the fact that the Tat protein is involved in the activation of HIV-1 gene expression in conjunction with TAR, we wished to determine whether Tat might also be involved in the control of HIV-1 reverse transcription. HIV-1 virions deleted in the tat gene were unable to initiate reverse transcription efficiently upon infection of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs). This defect was not due to decreased amounts of genomic RNA, reverse transcriptase or other HIV-1 proteins which were incorporated into the virion. Following transfection of wild-type but not mutant tat genes into cell lines producing HIV-1 lacking tat, the virions produced could be complemented for defects in reverse transcription upon subsequent infection of PBMCs. In contrast, the defect in reverse transcription seen with HIV-1 lacking the tat gene could not be complemented when the target cells rather than the producer cells contained tat. Viruses lacking tat were also defective in endogenous assays of reverse transcription, although these viruses contained similar levels of reverse transcriptase. These results indicate that the Tat protein, in addition to regulating the level of gene expression, is also important for efficient HIV-1 reverse transcription.

Forced evolution of a regulatory RNA helix in the HIV-1 genome

The 5'and 3'end of the HIV-1 RNA genome forms a repeat (R) element that encodes a double stem-loop structure (the TAR and polyA hairpins). Phylogenetic analysis of the polyA hairpin in different human and simian immunodeficiency viruses suggests that the thermodynamic stability of the helix is fine-tuned. We demonstrated previously that mutant HIV-1 genomes with a stabilized or destabilized hairpin are severely replication-impaired. In this study, we found that the mutant with a destabilized polyA hairpin structure is conditionally defective. Whereas reduced replication is measured in infections at the regular temperature (37 degrees C), this mutant is more fit than the wild-type virus at reduced temperature (33 degrees C). This observation of a temperature-dependent replication defect underscores that the stability of this RNA structure is critical for function. An extensive analysis of revertant viruses was performed to further improve the understanding of the critical sequence and structural features of the element under scrutiny. The virus mutants with a stabilized or destabilized hairpin were used as a starting point in multiple, independent selections for revertant viruses with compensatory mutations. Both mutants reverted to hairpins with wild-type stability along various pathways by acquisition of compensatory mutations. We identified 19 different revertant HIV-1 forms with improved replication characteristics, providing a first look at some of the peaks in the total sequence landscape that are compatible with virus replication. These experiments also highlight some general principles of RNA structure building.

A conserved hairpin motif in the R-U5 region of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 RNA genome is essential for replication

The untranslated leader region of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) RNA genome contains multiple hairpin motifs. The repeat region of the leader, which is reiterated at the 3' end of the RNA molecule, encodes the well-known TAR hairpin and a second hairpin structure with the polyadenylation signal AAUAAA in the single-stranded loop [the poly(A) hairpin]. The fact that this poly(A) stem-loop structure and its thermodynamic stability are well conserved among HIV and simian immunodeficiency virus isolates, despite considerable divergence in sequence, suggests a biological function for this RNA motif in viral replication. Consistent with this idea, we demonstrate that mutations that alter the stability of the stem region or delete the upper part of the hairpin do severely inhibit replication of HIV type 1. Whereas destabilizing mutations in either the left- or right-hand side of the base-paired stem interfere with virus replication, the double mutant, which allows the formation of new base pairs, replicates more rapidly than the two individual virus mutants. Upon prolonged culturing of viruses with an altered hairpin stability, revertant viruses were obtained with additional mutations that restore the thermodynamic stability of the poly(A) hairpin. Transient transfection experiments demonstrated that transcription of the proviral genomes, translation of the viral mRNAs, and reverse transcription of the genomic RNAs are not affected by mutation of the 5' poly(A) hairpin. We show that the genomic RNA content of the virions is reduced by destabilization of this poly(A) hairpin but not by stabilization or truncation of this structure. These results suggest that the formation of the poly(A) hairpin structure at the 5' end of the genomic RNA molecule is necessary for packaging of viral genomes into virions and/or stability of the virion RNA.

Optimal Tat-mediated activation of the HIV-1 LTR promoter requires a full-length TAR RNA hairpin

HIV-1 transcription from the LTR promoter is activated by the viral Tat protein through interaction with the nascent TAR RNA hairpin structure. The mechanism of Tat-mediated transcriptional activation has been extensively investigated with LTR-CAT reporter genes in transient transfections and, more recently, in infection experiments with mutant HIV-1 variants. Several discrepancies between these two assay systems have been reported. For instance, whereas opening of the lower part of the TAR RNA stem does not affect the promoter activity of an LTR-CAT plasmid in transient assays, the corresponding virus mutant is fully replication-impaired. With the aim to resolve this controversy, we have examined the activity of a set of TAR RNA mutants in transient transfection experiments with a variety of cell types. We now demonstrate that truncated TAR motifs exhibit a severe, but cell-type dependent transcription defect. Whereas full LTR activity is measured in COS cells that have been used regularly in previous transfection assays, a severe defect is apparent in a variety of human cell lines, including T cell lines that are typically used in HIV-1 replication studies. These results suggest the presence of a human protein that participates in Tat-mediated transcriptional activation through binding to the lower part of the TAR stem. Several candidate co-factors have been reported in literature. This study resolves the discrepancy between transfection and infection studies on the requirements of the lower TAR stem structure. The evidence also implies that LTR transcription studies should be performed preferentially in human cell types.

RNAs Selected in vitro by the HIV-2 Tat Protein

The Tat proteins of human immunodeficiency virus types 1 (HIV-1) and 2 (HIV-2), termed Tat-1 and Tat-2, respectively, are essential for efficient viral replication. Tat proteins activate viral transcription by binding to the TAR RNA stem-loop structure at the 5' end of viral transcripts. We used an in vitro selection procedure to identify RNAs present in a large sequence pool that are able to bind to purified Tat-2 protein. The sequences of the selected RNAs demonstrated a consensus feature: 20 of 27 RNAs contained computer-predicted loop structures that were >50% U or C nucleotides. A selected RNA was characterized for its in vitro binding properties to various Tat-2 proteins. This synthetic RNA was bound by wild-type Tat-2 proteins with an affinity that was only slightly lower than that of the natural HIV-2 TAR RNA. Tat-2 required a wild-type RNA binding domain to bind to this synthetic RNA. This study indicates that in vitro selection techniques can be used to investigate Tat protein-TAR RNA interactions. Copyright 1997 S. Karger AG, Basel

Structure of HIV-1 TAR RNA in the absence of ligands reveals a novel conformation of the trinucleotide bulge

Efficient transcription from the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) promoter depends on binding of the viral regulatory protein Tat to a cis-acting RNA regulatory element, TAR. Tat binds at a trinucleotide bulge located near the apex of the TAR stem-loop structure. An essential feature of Tat-TAR interaction is that the protein induces a conformational change in TAR that repositions the functional groups on the bases and the phosphate backbone that are critical for specific intermolecular recognition of TAR RNA. We have previously determined a high resolution structure for the bound form of TAR RNA using heteronuclear NMR. Here, we describe a high resolution structure of the free TAR RNA based on 871 experimentally determined restraints. In the free TAR RNA, bulged residues U23 and C24 are stacked within the helix, while U25 is looped out. This creates a major distortion of the phosphate backbone between C24 and G26. In contrast, in the bound TAR RNA, each of the three residues from the bulge are looped out of the helix and U23 is drawn into proximity with G26 through contacts with an arginine residue that is inserted between the two bases. Thus, TAR RNA undergoes a transition from a structure with an open and accessible major groove to a much more tightly packed structure that is folded around basic side chains emanating from the Tat protein.

Recombinant human immunodeficiency virus type 1 genomes with tat unconstrained by overlapping reading frames reveal residues in Tat important for replication in tissue culture

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Tat is essential for virus replication and is a potent trans activator of viral gene expression. Evidence suggests that Tat also influences virus infectivity and cytopathicity. Extensive structure-function studies of Tat in subgenomic settings with point mutagenesis and transient transfection readouts have been performed. These reporter assays have defined certain amino acid residues as being important for trans activation of reporter plasmids. However, they have not directly addressed functions related to virus replication. Here, we have studied Tat structure-function in the setting of replicating viruses. We characterized mutations that emerged in Tat during HIV-1 infections of T lymphocytes. To ensure that the selection pressure for change was directed toward protein function, we constructed HIV-Is in which the Tat reading frame was freed from constraints exerted by overlapping with the reading frames of vpr, rev, and env. When these recombinant viruses were passaged in T cells, 26 novel nucleotide changes in tat were observed from sequencing of 220 independently isolated clones. Recloning of these changes into a pNL4-3 molecular background allowed for the characterization of residues in Tat important for virus replication. Interestingly, many of the changes that affected replication when they were assayed in transient trans activation of plasmid reporters were found to be relatively neutral. We conclude that the structure-function of Tat in virus replication is incompletely reflected by activity measurements based only on subgenomic transient transfections.

A critical role for the TAR element in promoting efficient human immunodeficiency virus type 1 reverse transcription

The regulation of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) gene expression is dependent on the transactivator protein Tat and an RNA element extending from the transcription initiation site to +57 known as TAR. TAR forms a stable RNA secondary structure which is critical for high levels of HIV-1 gene expression and efficient viral replication. Using a genetic approach, we isolated HIV-1 mutants in TAR that were competent for high levels of gene expression but yet were markedly defective for viral replication. Single-cycle infections with these viruses demonstrated that they were defective in the initiation of reverse transcription. Additional mutational analysis revealed a variety of other HIV-1 TAR mutants with the same defective phenotype. Thus, in addition to the well-characterized role of the primer binding site, other RNA elements within the HIV-1 genome are also critical in the regulation of reverse transcription. These studies demonstrate that HIV-1 TAR RNA is a key regulator of the reverse transcription and illustrate how a unique RNA structure can modulate diverse regulatory processes in the HIV-1 life cycle crucial for efficient viral replication.

Fusion with an RNA binding domain to confer target RNA specificity to an RNase: design and engineering of Tat-RNase H that specifically recognizes and cleaves HIV-1 RNA in vitro

A target RNA/DNA-specific nuclease could be constructed if a specific RNA/DNA binding domain allowing target RNA/DNA recognition was fused to a (deoxy)ribonucleolytic domain allowing target RNA/ DNA cleavage. The design and construction of such a chimeric enzyme could be of value for both basic research involving structure-function relationships and applied research requiring inactivation of harmful RNA/DNA molecules of cellular or pathogenic origin. The feasibility of this designer nuclease approach for inactivating specific RNA/DNA molecules was assessed using human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) RNA as a model. Trans-activator of transcription (Tat) protein is one of the key regulatory proteins encoded by HIV-1. It binds to the trans-activation-responsive (TAR) RNA element located within the 5' non-coding region of HIV-1 RNAs. The TAR RNA binding domain of this protein was fused to the ribonuclease (RNase) H domain of HIV-1 reverse transcriptase (RT). RNase H by itself lacks an RNA binding domain. The chimeric Tat-RNase H protein was shown to specifically recognize and cleave HIV-1 TAR RNA in vitro. Cleavage was abolished by mutations in the Tat binding region within the TAR RNA, indicating that it is specific to HIV-1 TAR RNA.

Structural and Functional Properties of HIV-1(GER) TAR Sequences

Sequencing of HIV-1(GER) long terminal repeat (LTR) has demonstrated, for the first time in an HIV-1 primary isolate, a TAR duplication referred to as TAR1 (nucleotides +1 through +68) and TAR2 (nucleotides +69 through +136). This TAR duplication is stable during replication of HIV-1(GER) isolate in CEM cells. Analysis of LTR-CAT reporter constructs demonstrated that under Tat transactivation the HIV-1(GER)/LTR (containing TAR1 and TAR2) was expressed at a higher level than a similar construct (HIV-1(GER)DeltaTAR) containing a single TAR sequence. Among the two transcription initiation sites found in the HIV-1(GER)/LTR, only the most 5' start site was shown to be functionally active. The predicted secondary structure of the 5'-end mRNAs of HIV-1(GER) suggests it may fold into a double TAR hairpin which resembles that of HIV-2. Finally, HIV-1(GER) Tat protein shows primary sequence similarity with Tat proteins from other isolates of HIV-1 and is apparently unrelated to HIV-2 Tat proteins. This work provides the first evidence of a TAR sequence duplication in HIV-1 which increases the efficiency of transactivation by Tat. Copyright 1996 S. Karger AG, Basel