Isolation of temperature-sensitive conditional lethal mutants of "fixed" rabies virus

Animal and human RNA viruses: genetic variability and ability to overcome vaccines

RNA viruses, in general, exhibit high mutation rates; this is mainly due to the low fidelity displayed by the RNA-dependent polymerases required for their replication that lack the proofreading machinery to correct misincorporated nucleotides and produce high mutation rates. This lack of replication fidelity, together with the fact that RNA viruses can undergo spontaneous mutations, results in genetic variants displaying different viral morphogenesis, as well as variation on their surface glycoproteins that affect viral antigenicity. This diverse viral population, routinely containing a variety of mutants, is known as a viral ‘quasispecies’. The mutability of their virions allows for fast evolution of RNA viruses that develop antiviral resistance and overcome vaccines much more rapidly than DNA viruses. This also translates into the fact that pathogenic RNA viruses, that cause many diseases and deaths in humans, represent the major viral group involved in zoonotic disease transmission, and are responsible for worldwide pandemics.

Pathogenicity and immunogenicity for mice of temperature-sensitive mutants of vesicular stomatitis virus

Temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of vesicular stomatitis (VS) virus were tested for their pathogenicity and immunogenicity in weanling mice. Compared with the wild-type virus (ts(+)), ts mutants representing genetic complementation groups I, II, and IV were considerably less pathogenic for mice infected by the intracerebral route and caused few deaths after intranasal inoculation. Mice were completely resistant to ts(+) and ts mutants by the intraperitoneal route. Resistance to intracerebral challenge with ts(+) VS virus was only minimal in mice vaccinated intraperitoneally with ts(+) or ts mutants and only moderate in mice vaccinated intranasally with three ts mutants. Intranasal vaccination, particularly with group IV mutants, resulted in solid immunity within 3 days to intranasal challenge with ts(+) virus. VS viral neutralizing antibody was present in the bronchial secretions of mice by 12 h after intranasal inoculation of mutant ts IV44; the bronchial antibody titers declined to undetectable levels between 3 and 7 days after vaccination. Neutralizing antibody was detected in the serum of mice by the third day after intranasal vaccination with ts IV44 and persisted at high level for at least 11 days. Certain classes of ts mutants would appear to be promising candidates for use as attenuated, live virus vaccines.

Temperature-sensitivity of the replication of rabies virus (HEP-flury strain) in BHK-21 cells. I. Alteration of viral RNA synthesis at the elevated temperature

We investigated the nature of temperature sensitivity of the HEP strain of rabies virus. After initial incubation for appropriate period (more than 12 hr) at the permissive temperature (36-37 degrees), incubation temperature of the rabies virus infected cultures was shifted to a nonpermissive temperature (39.5-40.5 degrees). Upon the upshift, virion production was ceased, but the rate of viral RNA synthesis was greatly increased and reached almost 10 times that of 36 degrees-infection within 8-10 hr, and then the activity quickly decreased together with the onset of accelerated CPE. Little or no 42S genome-sized RNA was produced at the elevated temperature, and almost all RNAs produced in large amounts seemed to be viral mRNAs and were shown to be functional in t he cell-free translation system. Consistent with these observations, the viral ribonucleoprotein complex isolated from the temperature-upshifted culture was associated with relatively large amounts of small sized RNAs, which might reflect their increased transcriptive activity. These observations suggest that the viral RNA polymerase itself is not temperature-sensitive and the temperature-induced defect may reside in the regulatory factor which plays a role in turning on the synthesis of viral genome-sized RNA.

Mutants of rabies viruses in skunks: immune response and pathogenicity

In studies to develop an oral rabies vaccine for wildlife, the immune response to and pathogenicity of two types of mutants of rabies viruses were examined. Forty-five small plaque mutants were selected from cultures of ERA rabies virus treated with 8-azaguanine or 5-fluorouracil and tested for pathogenicity in mice. Two of these mutants AZA 1 and AZA 2 (low pathogenicity in mice) were given to skunks by oral (bait), intestinal (endoscope) and intramuscular routes. Additionally, challenge virus standard (CVS) rabies virus and mutants of this and ERA rabies virus (CVS 3766 and 3713, and ERA 3629) that were resistant to neutralization by specific antiglycoprotein monoclonal antibodies (and apathogenic in mice) were tested by various routes in skunks. Skunks given AZA 1 and AZA 2 were challenged at three months postinoculation with street rabies virus. After oral administration, there were very low rates of seroconversion with AZA 1 and AZA 2 and on challenge only 2/7 given AZA 1 and 1/8 given AZA 2 survived. None of the skunks given the other mutants orally seroconverted. AZA 2 produced a high rate of seroconversion (8/8) by the intestinal route and all challenged skunks in this group survived (7/7). All skunks vaccinated intramuscularly with AZA 1 (4/4) or AZA 2 (4/4) developed high levels of rabies neutralizing antibodies and survived challenge. The mutant CVS 3766, while apathogenic when given intracerebrally to adult mice, was consistently pathogenic by this route (and intranasally) in skunks. These results demonstrate that skunks are highly resistant to oral immunization by live rabies virus vaccines and that pathogenicity (by intracerebral route) of the mutant CVS 3766 is markedly different in mice and skunks.

Rabies serogroup viruses in neuroblastoma cells: propagation, "autointerference," and apparently random back-mutation of attenuated viruses to the virulent state

Each of several strains of fixed rabies virus was found to replicate to high titers in C1300 mouse neuroblastoma (clone NA) cells, without adaptation. Rabies serogroup Lagos bat, Mokola, and Duvenhage viruses also replicated efficiently in NA cells. Kotonkan and Obodhiang viruses replicated efficiently after adaptation, to titers not previously obtained in vitro. Infection in NA cells was frequently more cytopathic than in BHK-21 cells, allowing titration of Kotonkan and Obodhiang viruses by plaque assay. Duvenhage virus caused syncytium formation. Serial propagation of rabies viruses at a high multiplicity of infection in NA cells led to a rapid decline in virus yields; similar "autointerference" has not previously been demonstrated with rabies virus in other cell systems. Rabies virus infection in NA cells exhibited extreme sensitivity to interference by experimentally added defective interfering virions. Although several strains of attenuated rabies virus consistently reverted rapidly to virulence after propagation in NA cells, other strains of attenuated rabies and rabies serogroup viruses acquired increased virulence at a more gradual rate or not at all, suggesting that diverse characters may control virulence. When attenuated Flury HEP rabies virus was serially propagated at a low multiplicity of infection in either NA cells or suckling mouse brain, virulence appeared at a very variable rate, indicating that these systems may selectively enhance replication of randomly occurring virulent virus mutants.

Rabies viruses increase in virulence when propagated in neuroblastoma cell culture

Several strains of attenuated rabies virus lacking the capacity to kill adult mice acquired a high lethal potential for mice after one to five serial passages in murine or human neuroblastoma cells. The virulence acquired after passage in neuroblastoma cells is a stable genetic trait retained during subsequent passage of viruses in nonneuroblastoma cell systems.

A spontaneous temperature sensitive mutant of Japanese encephalitis virus: preliminary characterization

A spontaneously arising temperature sensitive (ts) mutant of Japanese encephalitis virus (JEV), ts104, was isolated from chick fibroblast (CF) cell cultures of JEV strain M 1/311. Strain ts104 was plaque purified and characterized to ascertain its potential as a candidate for a live vaccine. Parameters of its growth, temperature lability, immunogenicity and virulence were examined. Ts104 has been shown to be stable ts JEV strain, multiplying as well as the parent strain in CF cultures at 35 degrees C, but not mutiplying at 39 degrees C. It was avirulent for embryonated chicken eggs incubated at 39 degrees C and of reduced virulence for intracerebrally (i.c.) inoculated mice as measured by LD50 in weanling mice and average day of death in weanling and suckling mice. Intraperitoneal injection of adult mice with either parent or ts strain resulted in similar levels of protection against challenge with either strain. The potential of ts104 as a candidate live JEV vaccine strain is discussed.

Thermal inactivation of rabies and other rhabdoviruses: stabilization by the chelating agent ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid at physiological temperatures

Thermal inactivation of rabies and several other rhabdoviruses was studied using virus suspended in several different diluents. Rabies serogroup viruses were more stable than Kern Canyon or vesicular stomatitis viruses. Limited studies of two fish rhabdoviruses requiring low temperatures (less than 33 C) for replication indicated that they were not markedly more thermolabile than rabies virus. Bovine serum protein components in complex cell culture media stabilized virus at 56 C, but at temperatures of less than or equal to 37 C, sodium tris (hydroxymethyl)-aminomethane (NT) buffer containing ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) (NTE) was a much more efficient stabilizer of virus infectivity. Chelating agents EDTA and ethyleneglycol-bis-(beta-aminoethyl ether)tetraacetic acid were equally efficient in protection of rabies virus infectivity; the effect of each was lost when excess Ca2+ was added. Bovine serum in NT or NTE buffers produced a thermostabilizing effect at 37 C not provided by the same serum concentration in complex cell culture media. Bovine serum was more efficient than EDTA in stabilizing virus infectivity during repeated cycles of freezing and thawing.

Temperature-sensitive mutants of rabies virus in mice: a mutant (ts2) revertant mixture selectively pathogenic by the peripheral route of inoculation

Analysis of the pathogenic potential in mice of a variety of rabies and rabies serogroup viruses revealed that an apparently revertant population of virus derived from CVS mutant ts 2 had a unique capacity to selectively induce paralytic disease when given by a peripheral [intraplantar (i.pl.)] route of inoculation. Little paralytic disease was induced by high concentrations of virus administered by the intracerebral (i.c.) route, whereas paralytic disease and death were characteristically induced in mice given only a few infectious doses of virus i.c. Disease induced by i.pl. inoculation was dose dependent. Mice frequently survived paralytic disease induced by i. pl. inoculation, with clinical signs often persisting indefinitely; mice surviving i.c. inoculation of high concentrations of virus frequently exhibited chronic nonspecific signs of minor debility. Analysis of the ts 2 virus population indicated that it was composed of a mixture of ts and revertant virions, each with characteristic pathogenic (or nonpatholgnic) propensities, none of which was identical to the original composite ts 2 virus populations. Despite the heterogeneity of the ts 2 virus population, the typical pathogenic pattern of selective pathogenic capicity after i. pl. inoculation at high doses was retained during 11 ocnsecutive passages in suckling mouse brain. ts 2 virus was demonstrated to interfere with the disease-producing capacity of CVS fixed rabies virus when ts 2-CVS mixtures were inoculated i.c. However, attempts to demonstrate a particular propensity for induction in vitro of "autointerference" by ts 2 in serial passage in BHK-21 cell culture inoculated at high multiplicity were unsuccessful.

Chemically induced temperature-sensitive mutants of dengue virus type 2: comparison of temperature sensitivity in vitro with infectivity suckling mice, hamsters, and rhesus monkeys

A series of temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of dengue virus type 2 (DEN-2, TH-36 isolate) were induced by treatment with 5-azacytidine. These mutants and parental viruses were compared for the ts trait and/or attenuation in four systems: primary hamster kidney cells, suckling mice, golden Syrian hamsters, and rhesus monkeys. Seven clones judged to possess the ts trait in virto demonstrated a variety of patterns in vivo. On initial isolation, five of seven ts mutants exhibited reduced mouse lethality. The remaining two mutants possessed parental levels of mouse lethality. In hamsters, neither ts mutant nor parental viruses replicated very well, and then only when inoculated intracerebrally. Studies in rhesus monkeys indicated that all seven ts clones and parental viruses were capable of inducing abtibody responses; however, ts-1 and ts-2 failed to produce detectable viremia. After challenge with parental virus, all vaccinated monkeys demonstrated rapid secondary-type antibody response. Reversion from ts to ts(+) was confirmed to ts-1 in mice and ts-3 in monkeys, and was strongly suspected in several other instances.

Pathogenesis of temperature-sensitive mutants of sindbis virus in the embryonated egg. I. Characterization and kinetics of viral multiplication

Exploratory experiments were performed with temperature-sensitive (ts) mutants of Sindbis virus for studies on viral pathogenesis in the embryonated egg, a host which is immunologically underdeveloped. Parent and mutants were found to be virulent at the permissive temperature (33 C), but only the mutants were attenuated at the nonpermissive temperature (38.5 C). The degree of attenuation varied with the mutant and the route of inoculation. Chicks which survived infection by ts mutants at a nonpermissive temperature weighed the same as controls and showed no obvious abnormalities on gross examination. Whenever death of the embryo at the nonpermissive temperature occurred after inoculation with a mutant, it was apparently due to the selection of a population of temperature-insensitive virulent revertants. Kinetic studies showed that, after inoculation of the chorioallantoic membrane and incubation at the permissive temperature, a number of cycles of virus multiplication and dissemination apparently occurred rapidly. At the nonpermissive temperature, multiplication was undetectable. Certain pathophysiological signs were seen in the slower, less virulent infections by the mutants at the permissive temperature that were apparently masked or obscured in the more virulent, rapid infection by the parent. From these results and those reported in a subsequent paper, it appears that ts mutants of viruses possess potential as valuable tools for analyzing pathogenesis and immunity in the intact animal host that are complementary to more conventional approaches which employ normal (temperature-insensitive) viruses.