Mutations in the carboxy-terminal domain of TBP affect the synthesis of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 full-length and short transcripts similarly

Help or Hinder: Protein Host Factors That Impact HIV-1 Replication

Interactions between human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) and the host factors or restriction factors of its target cells determine the cell's susceptibility to, and outcome of, infection. Factors intrinsic to the cell are involved at every step of the HIV-1 replication cycle, contributing to productive infection and replication, or severely attenuating the chances of success. Furthermore, factors unique to certain cell types contribute to the differences in infection between these cell types. Understanding the involvement of these factors in HIV-1 infection is a key requirement for the development of anti-HIV-1 therapies. As the list of factors grows, and the dynamic interactions between these factors and the virus are elucidated, comprehensive and up-to-date summaries that recount the knowledge gathered after decades of research are beneficial to the field, displaying what is known so that researchers can build off the groundwork of others to investigate what is unknown. Herein, we aim to provide a review focusing on protein host factors, both well-known and relatively new, that impact HIV-1 replication in a positive or negative manner at each stage of the replication cycle, highlighting factors unique to the various HIV-1 target cell types where appropriate.

The HIV-1 Transcriptional Program: From Initiation to Elongation Control

A large body of work in the last four decades has revealed the key pillars of HIV-1 transcription control at the initiation and elongation steps. Here, I provide a recount of this collective knowledge starting with the genomic elements (DNA and nascent TAR RNA stem-loop) and transcription factors (cellular and the viral transactivator Tat), and later transitioning to the assembly and regulation of transcription initiation and elongation complexes, and the role of chromatin structure. Compelling evidence support a core HIV-1 transcriptional program regulated by the sequential and concerted action of cellular transcription factors and Tat to promote initiation and sustain elongation, highlighting the efficiency of a small virus to take over its host to produce the high levels of transcription required for viral replication. I summarize new advances including the use of CRISPR-Cas9, genetic tools for acute factor depletion, and imaging to study transcriptional dynamics, bursting and the progression through the multiple phases of the transcriptional cycle. Finally, I describe current challenges to future major advances and discuss areas that deserve more attention to both bolster our basic knowledge of the core HIV-1 transcriptional program and open up new therapeutic opportunities.

HIV Expression in Infected T Cell Clones

The principal barrier to an HIV-1 cure is the persistence of infected cells harboring replication-competent proviruses despite antiretroviral therapy (ART). HIV-1 transcriptional suppression, referred to as viral latency, is foremost among persistence determinants, as it allows infected cells to evade the cytopathic effects of virion production and killing by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) and other immune factors. HIV-1 persistence is also governed by cellular proliferation, an innate and essential capacity of CD4+ T cells that both sustains cell populations over time and enables a robust directed response to immunological threats. However, when HIV-1 infects CD4+ T cells, this capacity for proliferation can enable surreptitious HIV-1 propagation without the deleterious effects of viral gene expression in latently infected cells. Over time on ART, the HIV-1 reservoir is shaped by both persistence determinants, with selective forces most often favoring clonally expanded infected cell populations harboring transcriptionally quiescent proviruses. Moreover, if HIV latency is incomplete or sporadically reversed in clonal infected cell populations that are replenished faster than they are depleted, such populations could both persist indefinitely and contribute to low-level persistent viremia during ART and viremic rebound if treatment is withdrawn. In this review, select genetic, epigenetic, cellular, and immunological determinants of viral transcriptional suppression and clonal expansion of HIV-1 reservoir T cells, interdependencies among these determinants, and implications for HIV-1 persistence will be presented and discussed.

Regulation of HIV-1 transcription

Human immunodeficiency virus type-1 (HIV-1) is a highly pathogenic lentivirus that requires transcription of its provirus genome for completion of the viral life cycle and the production of progeny virions. Since the first genetic analysis of HIV-1 in 1985, much has been learned about the transcriptional regulation of the HIV-1 genome in infected cells. It has been demonstrated that HIV-1 transcription depends on a varied and complex interaction of host cell transcription factors with the viral long terminal repeat (LTR) promoter. The regulatory elements within the LTR interact with constitutive and inducible transcription factors to direct the assembly of a stable transcription complex that stimulates multiple rounds of transcription by RNA polymerase II (RNAPII). However, the majority of these transcripts terminate prematurely in the absence of the virally encoded trans-activator protein Tat, which stimulates HIV-1 transcription elongation by interacting with a stem-loop RNA element (TAR) formed at the extreme 5' end of all viral transcripts. The Tat-TAR interaction recruits a cellular kinase into the initiation-elongation complex that alters the elongation properties of RNAPII during its transit through TAR. This review summarizes our current knowledge and understanding of the regulation of HIV-1 transcription in infected cells and highlights the important contributions human lentivirus gene regulation has made to our general understanding of the transcription process.

Tat gets the "green" light on transcription initiation

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Tat transactivation is an essential step in the viral life cycle. Over the past several years, it has become widely accepted that Tat exerts its transcriptional effect by binding the transactivation-responsive region (TAR) and enhancing transcriptional elongation. Consistent with this hypothesis, it has been shown that Tat promotes the binding of P-TEFb, a transcription elongation factor composed of cyclin T1 and cdk9, and the interaction of Tat with P-TEFb and TAR leads to hyperphosphorylation of the C-terminal domain (CTD) of RNA Pol II and increased processivity of RNA Pol II. A recent report, however, has generated renewed interest that Tat may also play a critical role in transcription complex (TC) assembly at the preinitiation step. Using in vivo chromatin immunoprecipitation assays, the authors reported that the HIV TC contains TBP but not TBP-associated factors. The stimulatory effect involved the direct interaction of Tat and P-TEFb and was evident at the earliest step of TC assembly, the TBP-TATA box interaction. In this article, we will review this data in context of earlier data which also support Tat's involvement in transcriptional complex assembly. Specifically, we will discuss experiments which demonstrated that Tat interacted with TBP and increased transcription initiation complex stability in cell free assays. We will also discuss studies which demonstrated that over expression of TBP alone was sufficient to obtain Tat activated transcription in vitro and in vivo. Finally, studies using self-cleaving ribozymes which suggested that Tat transactivation was not compatible with pausing of the RNA Pol II at the TAR site will be discussed.

Analysis of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 transcriptional elongation in resting CD4+ T cells in vivo

A stable latent reservoir for human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) in resting memory CD4+ T cells presents a barrier to eradication of the infection even in patients on highly active antiretroviral therapy. Potential mechanisms for latency include inaccessibility of the integrated viral genome, absence of key host transcription factors, premature termination of HIV-1 RNAs, and abnormal splicing patterns. To differentiate among these mechanisms, we isolated extremely pure populations of resting CD4+ T cells from patients on highly active antiretroviral therapy. These cells did not produce virus but retained the capacity to do so if appropriately stimulated. Products of HIV-1 transcription were examined in purified resting CD4+ T cells. Although short, prematurely terminated HIV-1 transcripts have been suggested as a marker for latently infected cells, the production of short transcripts had not been previously demonstrated in purified populations of resting CD4+ T cells. By separating RNA into polyadenylated and nonpolyadenylated fractions, we showed that resting CD4+ T cells from patients on highly active antiretroviral therapy produce abortive transcripts that lack a poly(A) tail and that terminate prior to nucleotide 181. Short transcripts dominated the pool of total HIV-1 transcripts in resting CD4+ T cells. Processive, polyadenylated HIV-1 mRNAs were also present at a low level. Both unspliced and multiply spliced forms were found. Taken together, these results show that the nonproductive nature of the infection in resting CD4+ T cells from patients on highly active antiretroviral therapy is not due to absolute blocks at the level of either transcriptional initiation or elongation but rather relative inefficiencies at multiple steps.

FBI-1 can stimulate HIV-1 Tat activity and is targeted to a novel subnuclear domain that includes the Tat-P-TEFb-containing nuclear speckles

FBI-1 is a cellular POZ-domain-containing protein that binds to the HIV-1 LTR and associates with the HIV-1 transactivator protein Tat. Here we show that elevated levels of FBI-1 specifically stimulate Tat activity and that this effect is dependent on the same domain of FBI-1 that mediates Tat-FBI-1 association in vivo. FBI-1 also partially colocalizes with Tat and Tat's cellular cofactor, P-TEFb (Cdk9 and cyclin T1), at the splicing-factor-rich nuclear speckle domain. Further, a less-soluble population of FBI-1 distributes in a novel peripheral-speckle pattern of localization as well as in other nuclear regions. This distribution pattern is dependent on the FBI-1 DNA binding domain, on the presence of cellular DNA, and on active transcription. Taken together, these results suggest that FBI-1 is a cellular factor that preferentially associates with active chromatin and that can specifically stimulate Tat-activated HIV-1 transcription.

Phosphorylation of the RAP74 subunit of TFIIF correlates with Tat-activated transcription of the HIV-1 long terminal repeat

Transcription from the HIV-1 long terminal repeat (LTR) is regulated by the viral transactivator Tat, which increases RNA polymerase II (RNAP II) processivity. Previous reports have demonstrated that phosphorylation of the RNAP II carboxy-terminal domain by TFIIH and P-TEFb is important for Tat transactivation. Our present results demonstrate that phosphorylation of the RAP74 subunit of TFIIF is also an important step in Tat transactivation. Interestingly, while the general transcription factor TFIIF is required for both basal and Tat-activated transcription, phosphorylation of the RAP74 subunit occurs in the presence of Tat and correlates with a high level of transcription activity. Using a biotinylated DNA template transcription assay, we provide evidence that RAP74 is phosphorylated by TAF(II)250 during Tat-activated transcription. Depletion of RAP74 from the HeLa nuclear extract inhibited HIV-1 LTR-driven basal transcription and Tat transactivation. The addition of TFIIF, reconstituted from recombinant RAP30 and RAP74, to the depleted HeLa nuclear extract resulted in restoration of Tat transactivation. Of importance, the exogenous RAP74 was rapidly phosphorylated in the presence of Tat. These results suggest that RAP74 phosphorylation is one important step, of several, in the Tat transactivation cascade.

Recruitment of the TATA-binding protein to the HIV-1 promoter is a limiting step for Tat transactivation

OBJECTIVES

To examine the functional interaction between HIV-1 Tat protein and the TATA-binding protein (TBP).

DESIGN

HIV long terminal repeat reporter plasmids were cotransfected into mammalian and Drosophila insect cells with expression vectors encoding Tat and vectors encoding TBP either alone or linked to an heterologous DNA-binding domain.

METHODS

The activity of the different reporters was compared in the presence or absence of Tat or TBP, or both, upon cotransfections into human and Drosophila insect cell lines.

RESULTS

Tat protein is unable to transactivate enhancerless HIV-1 minimal promoter bearing only the TATA box and TAR. Artificial recruitment of human TBP (hTBP) to the enhancerless HIV minimal promoter was found to trigger gene expression and coexpression of Tat resulted in a marked synergy. Tat protein cooperated with DNA-bound hTBP by inducing high levels of processive viral transcripts. Synergy between Tat and hTBP was also observed when both factors were targeted to a promoter DNA template. The functional cooperation between TBP and Tat was further demonstrated using the Drosophila Schneider SL2 cells. In these cells Tat protein alone was ineffective; however, coexpression of Drosophila TBP and Tat resulted in a trans-activating response region-dependent synergistic transactivation of basal transcription.

CONCLUSION

The strong synergy between TBP and Tat in the absence of any DNA-bound activator suggests that Tat stimulates transcription in an activator-independent manner most likely by a functional interaction with general transcription factors that occurs after TBP recruitment. Thus, efficient recruitment of TBP represents a limiting step for Tat transactivation.

The HIV-1 inducer of short transcripts activates the synthesis of 5,6-dichloro-1-beta-D-benzimidazole-resistant short transcripts in vitro

The HIV-1 inducer of short transcripts (IST) is an unusual promoter element that activates the synthesis of short transcripts from the HIV-1 promoter as well as from heterologous promoters. While the DNA sequences constituting IST have been characterized in some detail, little is known about the biochemical mechanisms underlying IST activity. Here, we describe a cell-free transcription assay that faithfully reproduces the synthesis of IST-dependent HIV-1 short transcripts. As in vivo, formation of these short transcripts requires a functional IST element and is repressed in the presence of the viral trans-activator Tat. Short transcript and full-length transcript synthesis respond differently to variations in several reaction parameters, suggesting that the short and full-length transcripts are synthesized by transcription complexes with distinct biochemical properties. In particular, short transcript synthesis is resistant to the action of 5,6-dichloro-1-beta-D-benzimidazole, an inhibitor of transcript elongation. Formation of transcription complexes directed by the IST element may, therefore, not require the activity of a factor inhibited by 5, 6-dichloro-1-beta-D-benzimidazole, such as the TFIIH-associated or pTEFb kinases.

CA150, a nuclear protein associated with the RNA polymerase II holoenzyme, is involved in Tat-activated human immunodeficiency virus type 1 transcription

Maximal human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) gene expression requires specific cellular factors in addition to the virus-encoded trans-activator protein Tat and the RNA element TAR. We developed a functional assay, based on transcriptional activation in vitro, to identify these cellular factors. Here, we describe the purification and molecular cloning of CA150, a nuclear protein that is associated with the human RNA polymerase II holoenzyme and is involved in Tat-dependent HIV-1 transcriptional activation. The sequence of CA150 contains an extensive glutamine- and alanine-rich repeat that is found in transcriptional modulators such as GAL11 and SSN6 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Zeste in Drosophila melanogaster. Immunodepletion of CA150 abolished Tat trans activation in vitro. Moreover, overexpression of a mutant CA150 protein specifically and dramatically decreased Tat-mediated activation of the HIV-1 promoter in vivo, strongly suggesting a role for CA150 in HIV-1 gene regulation. Immunoprecipitation experiments demonstrated that both CA150 and Tat associate with the RNA polymerase II holoenzyme. Furthermore, we found that functional Tat associates with the holoenzyme whereas activation-deficient Tat mutants do not. Thus, we propose that Tat action is transduced via an RNA polymerase II holoenzyme that contains CA150.

Purification and characterization of FBI-1, a cellular factor that binds to the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 inducer of short transcripts

The human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) promoter directs the synthesis of two classes of RNA molecules, short transcripts and full-length transcripts. The synthesis of short transcripts depends on a bipartite DNA element, the inducer of short transcripts (IST), located in large part downstream of the HIV-1 start site of transcription. IST does not require any viral product for function and is thought to direct the assembly of transcription complexes that are incapable of efficient elongation. Nothing is known, however, about the biochemical mechanisms that mediate IST function. Here, we report the identification and purification of a factor that binds specifically to the IST. This factor, FBI-1, recognizes a large bipartite binding site that coincides with the bipartite IST element. It is constituted at least in part by an 86-kDa polypeptide that can be specifically cross-linked to IST. FBI-1 also binds to promoter and attenuation regions of a number of cellular and viral transcription units that are regulated by a transcription elongation block. This observation, together with the observation that the binding of FBI-1 to IST mutants correlates with the ability of these mutants to direct IST function, suggests that FBI-1 may be involved in the establishment of abortive transcription complexes.

Role for the amino-terminal region of human TBP in U6 snRNA transcription

Basal transcription from the human RNA polymerase III U6 promoter depends on a TATA box that recruits the TATA box-binding protein (TBP) and a proximal sequence element that recruits the small nuclear RNA (snRNA)-activating protein complex (SNAPc). TBP consists of a conserved carboxyl-terminal domain that performs all known functions of the protein and a nonconserved amino-terminal region of unknown function. Here, the amino-terminal region is shown to down-regulate binding of TBP to the U6 TATA box, mediate cooperative binding with SNAPc to the U6 promoter, and enhance U6 transcription.

RNA-targeted activators, but not DNA-targeted activators, repress the synthesis of short transcripts at the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 long terminal repeat

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) promoter directs the synthesis of two types of RNA molecules: full-length transcripts, whose synthesis is activated by the viral activator Tat, and short transcripts, whose synthesis is dependent on the inducer of short transcripts (IST), a bipartite DNA element located in large part downstream of the HIV-1 transcriptional start site. In the absence of Tat, short transcripts constitute the large majority of the RNA molecules synthesized from the HIV-1 promoter. In the presence of Tat, synthesis of the short transcripts is repressed and synthesis of the full-length transcripts is activated. Tat is unique among transcriptional activators in acting through an RNA target, the TAR element. However, Tat has been shown to activate transcription from a DNA target when fused to the appropriate DNA binding domain, raising the question of why Tat has been directed to the RNA. Here we have compared the abilities of Tat and other RNA- and DNA-bound activators to stimulate transcription from the HIV-1 promoter. We show that DNA-targeted activators, including DNA-targeted Tat, activate the synthesis of both short and long transcripts, while RNA-targeted Tat and another RNA-targeted activator activate the synthesis of full-length transcripts but specifically repress that of short transcripts. The unique ability of RNA-targeted activators to down-regulate short transcript synthesis suggests that Tat is directed to the RNA specifically for the purpose of repressing short transcripts.