Conditional human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease mutants show no role for the viral protease early in virus replication

Cellular Targets of HIV-1 Protease: Just the Tip of the Iceberg?

Human immunodeficiency virus 1 (HIV-1) viral protease (PR) is one of the most studied viral enzymes and a crucial antiviral target. Despite its well-characterized role in virion maturation, an increasing body of research is starting to focus on its ability to cleave host cell proteins. Such findings are apparently in contrast with the dogma of HIV-1 PR activity being restricted to the interior of nascent virions and suggest catalytic activity within the host cell environment. Given the limited amount of PR present in the virion at the time of infection, such events mainly occur during late viral gene expression, mediated by newly synthesized Gag-Pol polyprotein precursors, rather than before proviral integration. HIV-1 PR mainly targets proteins involved in three different processes: those involved in translation, those controlling cell survival, and restriction factors responsible for innate/intrinsic antiviral responses. Indeed, by cleaving host cell translation initiation factors, HIV-1 PR can impair cap-dependent translation, thus promoting IRES-mediated translation of late viral transcripts and viral production. By targeting several apoptotic factors, it modulates cell survival, thus promoting immune evasion and viral dissemination. Additionally, HIV-1 PR counteracts restriction factors incorporated in the virion that would otherwise interfere with nascent virus vitality. Thus, HIV-1 PR appears to modulate host cell function at different times and locations during its life cycle, thereby ensuring efficient viral persistency and propagation. However, we are far from having a complete picture of PR-mediated host cell modulation, which is emerging as a field that needs further investigation.

Specificity of the HIV-1 Protease on Substrates Representing the Cleavage Site in the Proximal Zinc-Finger of HIV-1 Nucleocapsid Protein

To explore the sequence context-dependent nature of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease’s specificity and to provide a rationale for viral mutagenesis to study the potential role of the nucleocapsid (NC) processing in HIV-1 replication, synthetic oligopeptide substrates representing the wild-type and modified versions of the proximal cleavage site of HIV-1 NC were assayed as substrates of the HIV-1 protease (PR). The S1′ substrate binding site of HIV-1 PR was studied by an in vitro assay using KIVKCF↓NCGK decapeptides having amino acid substitutions of N17 residue of the cleavage site of the first zinc-finger domain, and in silico calculations were also performed to investigate amino acid preferences of S1′ site. Second site substitutions have also been designed to produce “revertant” substrates and convert a non-hydrolysable sequence (having glycine in place of N17) to a substrate. The specificity constants obtained for peptides containing non-charged P1′ substitutions correlated well with the residue volume, while the correlation with the calculated interaction energies showed the importance of hydrophobicity: interaction energies with polar residues were related to substantially lower specificity constants. Cleavable “revertants” showed one residue shift of cleavage position due to an alternative productive binding mode, and surprisingly, a double cleavage of a substrate was also observed. The results revealed the importance of alternative binding possibilities of substrates into the HIV-1 PR. The introduction of the “revertant” mutations into infectious virus clones may provide further insights into the potential role of NC processing in the early phase of the viral life-cycle.

Effect of internal cleavage site mutations in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 capsid protein on its structure and function

The capsid protein of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 has been found to be a substrate of the retroviral protease in vitro, and its processing was predicted to be strongly dependent on a pH‐induced conformational change. Several protease cleavage sites have been identified within the capsid protein, but the importance of its cleavage by the viral protease at the early phase of infection is controversial. To confirm the relevance of this process, we aimed to design, produce, and characterize mutant capsid proteins, in which the protein susceptibility toward HIV‐1 protease is altered without affecting other steps of the viral life cycle. Our results indicate that while the introduced mutations changed the cleavage rate at the mutated sites of the capsid protein by HIV‐1 protease, some of them caused only negligible or moderate structural changes (A78V, L189F, and L189I). However, the effects of other mutations (W23A, A77P, and L189P) were dramatic, as assessed by secondary structure determination or cyclophilin A‐binding assay. Based on our observations, the L189F mutant capsid remains structurally and functionally unchanged and may therefore be the best candidate for use in studies aimed at better understanding the role of the protease in the early postentry events of viral infection or retrovirus‐mediated gene transduction.

Temperature-sensitive mutants and revertants in the coronavirus nonstructural protein 5 protease (3CLpro) define residues involved in long-distance communication and regulation of protease activity

Positive-strand RNA virus genomes are translated into polyproteins that are processed by viral proteases to yield functional intermediate and mature proteins. Coronaviruses (CoVs) carry genes that encode an nsp5 protease (also known as 3CLpro or Mpro) responsible for 11 maturation cleavages. The nsp5 structure contains two chymotrypsin-like domains (D1 and D2) and a unique domain (D3), and forms functional dimers. However, little is known of interactions or communication across the structure of the protease during nsp5 activity. Using reverse genetic mutagenesis of the CoV murine hepatitis virus (MHV) nsp5, we identified a new temperature-sensitive (ts) mutation in D2 of nsp5 (Ser133Ala) and confirmed a ts residue in D3 (Phe219Leu). Both D2-tsS133A and D3-tsF219L were impaired for viral replication and nsp5-mediated polyprotein processing at the nonpermissive temperature. Passage of tsS133A and tsF219L at the nonpermissive temperature resulted in emergence of multiple second-site suppressor mutations, singly and in combinations. Among the second-site mutations, a D2 His134Tyr change suppressed the ts phenotype of D2-tsS133A and D3-tsF219L, as well as the previously reported D2-tsV148A. Analysis of multiple CoV nsp5 structures, and alignment of nonredundant nsp5 primary sequences, demonstrated that ts and suppressor residues are not conserved across CoVs and are physically distant (>10 Å) from each other, from catalytic and substrate-binding residues, and from the nsp5 dimer interface. These findings demonstrate that long-distance communication pathways between multiple residues and domains of nsp5 play a significant role in nsp5 activity and viral replication, suggesting possible novel targets for non-active site inhibitors of nsp5.

Characterization of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) containing mutations in the nucleocapsid protein at a putative HIV-1 protease cleavage site

The HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein (NC) has been hypothesized to be cleaved by the viral protease (PR) during early infection. Characterization of viruses, with amino-acid substitutions that modulate PR cleavage of NC in vitro, was performed in cell culture. Two of the NC mutants, NCN17F and NCN17G, had decreased infectivity and exhibited severe H9 replication defects. Examination of viral DNA after infections revealed defects in reverse transcription and integration, although integration defects were cell-type dependent. However, while the defects in reverse transcription and integration correlate with lowered infectivity in a single-round of infection, they did not approach the magnitude of the replication defect measured in H9 cells over multiple rounds. Importantly, we fail to see evidence that H9 cells are re-infected with the NCN17G and NCN17F viruses 24 h after the initial infection, which suggests that the principal defect caused by these NC mutations occurs during late events of viral replication.

Replication-dependent fitness recovery of Human immunodeficiency virus 1 harbouring mutations of Asn17 of the nucleocapsid protein

The genetic stability of attenuated Human immunodeficiency virus 1 (HIV-1) variants harbouring mutations (Gly or Lys) of Asn17, the protease-cleavage site of the proximal zinc finger of the nucleocapsid protein, was studied. All possible codons for the Gly mutants were tested as starting sequences. Long-term replication assays revealed that the mutants were unstable; mutations of Gly17 to Arg, Ala, Ser and Cys, as well as a Lys17Asn reversion, were observed. Replication kinetic assays in H9 cells revealed that the replication of Ala, Ser and Arg mutants was improved substantially compared with the Gly variant; the infectivity of Ala17 and Ser17 viruses was equal to, and that of Arg17 was almost equal to, the infectivity of the wild-type virus. Kinetic analysis of the cleavage of oligopeptides representing the corresponding nucleocapsid-cleavage sites revealed that all mutations improved cleavability, in good agreement with the previously proposed role of nucleocapsid cleavage in HIV-1 replication.

In vitro processing of HIV-1 nucleocapsid protein by the viral proteinase: effects of amino acid substitutions at the scissile bond in the proximal zinc finger sequence

The human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) nucleocapsid protein flanked by Gag sequences (r-preNC) was expressed in Escherichia coli and purified. HIV-1 proteinase cleaved r-preNC to the "mature" NCp7 form, which is comprised of 55 residues. Further incubation resulted in cleavages of NCp7 itself between Phe16 and Asn17 of the proximal zinc finger domain and between Cys49 and Thr50 in the C-terminal part. Kinetic parameters determined for the cleavage of oligopeptides corresponding to the cleavage sites in r-preNC correlated well with the sequential processing of r-preNC. Mutations of Asn17 were introduced to alter the susceptibility of NC protein to HIV-1 proteinase. While mutating Asn17 to Ala resulted in a protein which was processed in a manner similar to that of the wild type, mutating it to Phe or Leu resulted in proteins which were processed at a substantially higher rate at this site than the wild type. Mutation of Asn17 to Lys or Gly resulted in proteins which were very poorly cleaved at this site. Oligopeptides containing the same amino acid substitutions at the cleavage site of the proximal zinc finger domain were also tested as substrates of the proteinase, and the kinetic parameters agreed well with the semiquantitative results obtained with the protein substrates.

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 capsid protein is a substrate of the retroviral proteinase while integrase is resistant toward proteolysis

The capsid protein of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 was observed to undergo proteolytic cleavage in vitro when viral lysate was incubated in the presence of dithiothreitol at acidic pH. Purified HIV-1 capsid protein was also found to be a substrate of the viral proteinase in a pH-dependent manner; acidic pH (<7) was necessary for cleavage, and decreasing the pH toward 4 increased the degree of processing. Based on N-terminal sequencing of the cleavage products, the capsid protein was found to be cleaved at two sites, between residues 77 and 78 as well as between residues 189 and 190. Oligopeptides representing these cleavage sites were also cleaved at the expected peptide bonds. The presence of cyclophilin A decreased the degree of capsid protein processing. Unlike the capsid protein, integrase was found to be resistant toward proteolysis in good agreement with its presence in the preintegration complex.

Naturally occurring amino acid polymorphisms in human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) Gag p7(NC) and the C-cleavage site impact Gag-Pol processing by HIV-1 protease

Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease activity is targeted at nine cleavage sites comprising different amino acid sequences in the viral Gag-Pol polyprotein. Amino acid polymorphisms in protease and in regions of Gag, particularly p7(NC) and the C-cleavage site between p2 and p7(NC), occur in natural variants of HIV-1 within infected patients. Studies were designed to examine the role of natural polymorphisms in protease and to identify determinants in Gag that modulate protease processing activity. Closely related Gag-Pol regions from an HIV-1-infected mother and two children were evaluated for processing in an inducible expression system, for protease activity on cleavage-site analogues, and for impact on replication by recombinant viruses. Gag-Pol regions displayed one of three processing phenotypes based on the appearance of Gag intermediates and accumulation of mature p24(CA). Gag-Pol regions that were processed rapidly to produce p24(CA) resulted in high-level replication by recombinant viruses, while slow-processing Gag-Pol variants resulted in recombinant viruses that replicated with reduced kinetics in both T cell lines and peripheral blood mononuclear cells. Direct impact by Gag sequences on processing by protease was assessed by construction of chimeric Gag-Pol regions and by site-directed mutagenesis. Optimal protease activity occurred when Gag and Pol regions were derived from the same gag-pol allele. Heterologous Gag regions generally diminished rates and extent of protease processing. Natural polymorphisms in novel positions in p7(NC) and the C-cleavage site have a dominant effect on protease processing activity. Accumulation of Gag products after processing at the C site appears to delay subsequent cleavage and production of mature p24(CA).

Differential effects of HIV-1 protease inhibitors on dendritic cell immunophenotype and function

Recent findings show that human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-1 protease inhibitors designed to specifically inhibit the aspartic protease of HIV-1 nonetheless exert various effects on immune cell function in vitro and in vivo. Dendritic cells (DC), central players of the immune system, express several aspartic proteases that are important for DC function. In the present study, we demonstrate that all of the HIV-1 protease inhibitors tested affect DC maturation. In addition, saquinavir had a strong inhibitory effect on the T-cell stimulatory capacity of mature DC. In contrast, indinavir had only a slight effect on DC induced T-cell proliferation and allowed efficient transduction of DC with a replication-incompetent HIV-1 vector designed for DC-based immunotherapy. HIV-1 protease inhibitors that have little or no effect on DC function may be preferable for combination with immunotherapy for HIV/AIDS.

Kinetics of antiviral activity and intracellular pharmacokinetics of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 protease inhibitors in tissue culture

We have examined the kinetics of the inhibition of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) particle infectivity by protease inhibitors (PIs) in cell culture, using either transfected HeLa cells or infected peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) as producers of infectious virions. Both the kinetics of the initiation of antiviral activity after addition of the PIs to these cultures and the kinetics of restoration of virion infectivity after removal of the PIs from the treated cultures were examined. We found that the kinetics of initiation of particle infectivity inhibition produced by a high extracellular concentration (5 microM) of the inhibitors were similar for all five inhibitors tested: loss of particle infectivity was perceptible as early as 1 h after the initiation of PI treatment and increased gradually thereafter. By contrast, the durability of this antiviral effect following removal of the drug from the culture varied dramatically according to the drug studied. In transfected HeLa cells, saquinavir and nelfinavir exerted the most prolonged inhibition, with the half-lives of their antiviral activities being greater than 24 h, while ritonavir exerted an intermediate length of inhibition (18 h) and indinavir and amprenavir exerted a reproducibly shorter length of inhibition (5 h). For all five tested PIs, these kinetics were significantly faster in PBMCs than in HeLa cells. The striking differences in antiviral kinetics observed among the different PIs appear mostly due to differences in their intracellular concentrations and/or rates of cellular clearance. Our observations, although limited to tissue culture conditions, may help delineate the cellular parameters of the antiviral activities of HIV-1 PIs and further optimize the efficiencies of these antiretrovirals in vivo.

Functional characterization of adenoviral/retroviral chimeric vectors and their use for efficient screening of retroviral producer cell lines

We have generated three different E1-deleted replication-defective adenoviral vectors expressing either Moloney murine leukemia virus (Mo-MuLV) Gag-Pol core particle proteins, gibbon ape leukemia virus (GALV) envelope glycoproteins, or an MuLV-derived retroviral vector genome encoding mCD2 antigen, a murine cell surface marker easily detectable by flow cytometry. Each of the three vectors was first characterized individually by infection of cells providing the complementary retroviral function(s) and able to induce the production of retroviral vectors with an efficiency similar to or higher than that of FLY stable retroviral packaging cells [Cosset, F.-L., Takeuchi, Y., Battini, J.-L., Weiss, R.A., and Collins, M.K.L., (1995). J. Virol. 69, 7430-7436]. In small-scale pilot experiments, TE671 cells simultaneously coinfected with the three adenoviral vectors efficiently released helper-free retroviral vectors in their supernatant, with titers greater than 10(6) infectious particles per milliliter by end-point titrations. Our results also indicated that in contrast to retroviral vector-packageable RNAs, the adenovirus-mediated overexpression of both Gag-Pol and Env packaging functions had limited impact on retroviral titers. The primary mechanism suspected is the premature intracellular cleavage of the Pr65gag precursor that we found in gag-pol-expressing cells, which in turn may impair the normal incorporation of high loads of functional Env. Last, the characterization of the adenoviral/retroviral chimeric vectors allowed the screening of various primate cells for retroviral production and we found that three hepatocyte-derived cell lines were highly efficient in the assembly and release of infectious retroviral particles.

HIV-1 protease does not play a critical role in the early stages of HIV-1 infection

We asked whether human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) protease plays a major role in the early stages of infection (i.e. from viral entry to reverse transcription) by using various protease inhibitors (saquinavir, ritonavir, and KNI-272). When assessed in the two-day multinuclear activation of a galactosidase indicator (MAGI) assay, involving a single cycle of HIV-1 replication, all protease inhibitors failed to block infection of HeLa-CD4-LTR-beta-gal cells by HIV-1, while reverse transcriptase (RT) inhibitors (AZT and ddI) completely blocked the infection. Moreover, when HIV-1 proviral DNA synthesis was examined by polymerase chain reaction in HeLa-CD4-LTR-beta-gal cells exposed to HIV-1 and cultured in the presence of protease inhibitors, a significant amount of proviral DNA was detected, while no proviral DNA synthesis was detected when the cells were cultured in the presence of RT inhibitors. Protease inhibitors also failed to block chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) expression in HLCD4-CAT cells exposed to HIV-1, while RT inhibitors completely suppressed CAT expression. These results strongly suggest, contrary to a previous report by Nagy et al. (1994), that HIV-1 protease does not play a major role in the early stages of infection.