Identification of an upstream sequence element required for vesicular stomatitis virus mRNA transcription

How does the polymerase of non-segmented negative strand RNA viruses commit to transcription or genome replication?

The Mononegavirales, or non-segmented negative-sense RNA viruses (nsNSVs), includes significant human pathogens, such as respiratory syncytial virus, parainfluenza virus, measles virus, Ebola virus, and rabies virus. Although these viruses differ widely in their pathogenic properties, they are united by each having a genome consisting of a single strand of negative-sense RNA. Consistent with their shared genome structure, the nsNSVs have evolved similar ways to transcribe their genome into mRNAs and replicate it to produce new genomes. Importantly, both mRNA transcription and genome replication are performed by a single virus-encoded polymerase. A fundamental and intriguing question is: how does the nsNSV polymerase commit to being either an mRNA transcriptase or a replicase? The polymerase must become committed to one process or the other either before it interacts with the genome template or in its initial interactions with the promoter sequence at the 3´ end of the genomic RNA. This review examines the biochemical, molecular biology, and structural biology data regarding the first steps of transcription and RNA replication that have been gathered over several decades for different families of nsNSVs. These findings are discussed in relation to possible models that could explain how an nsNSV polymerase initiates and commits to either transcription or genome replication.

Sendai Virus and a Unified Model of Mononegavirus RNA Synthesis

Vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), the founding member of the mononegavirus order (Mononegavirales), was found to be a negative strand RNA virus in the 1960s, and since then the number of such viruses has continually increased with no end in sight. Sendai virus (SeV) was noted soon afterwards due to an outbreak of newborn pneumonitis in Japan whose putative agent was passed in mice, and nowadays this mouse virus is mainly the bane of animal houses and immunologists. However, SeV was important in the study of this class of viruses because, like flu, it grows to high titers in embryonated chicken eggs, facilitating the biochemical characterization of its infection and that of its nucleocapsid, which is very close to that of measles virus (MeV). This review and opinion piece follow SeV as more is known about how various mononegaviruses express their genetic information and carry out their RNA synthesis, and proposes a unified model based on what all MNV have in common.

Identification and characterization of short leader and trailer RNAs synthesized by the Ebola virus RNA polymerase

Transcription of non-segmented negative sense (NNS) RNA viruses follows a stop-start mechanism and is thought to be initiated at the genome’s very 3’-end. The synthesis of short abortive leader transcripts (leaderRNAs) has been linked to transcription initiation for some NNS viruses. Here, we identified the synthesis of abortive leaderRNAs (as well as trailer RNAs) that are specifically initiated opposite to (anti)genome nt 2; leaderRNAs are predominantly terminated in the region of nt ~ 60–80. LeaderRNA synthesis requires hexamer phasing in the 3’-leader promoter. We determined a steady-state NP mRNA:leaderRNA ratio of ~10 to 30-fold at 48 h after Ebola virus (EBOV) infection, and this ratio was higher (70 to 190-fold) for minigenome-transfected cells. LeaderRNA initiation at nt 2 and the range of termination sites were not affected by structure and length variation between promoter elements 1 and 2, nor the presence or absence of VP30. Synthesis of leaderRNA is suppressed in the presence of VP30 and termination of leaderRNA is not mediated by cryptic gene end (GE) signals in the 3’-leader promoter. We further found different genomic 3’-end nucleotide requirements for transcription versus replication, suggesting that promoter recognition is different in the replication and transcription mode of the EBOV polymerase. We further provide evidence arguing against a potential role of EBOV leaderRNAs as effector molecules in innate immunity. Taken together, our findings are consistent with a model according to which leaderRNAs are abortive replicative RNAs whose synthesis is not linked to transcription initiation. Rather, replication and transcription complexes are proposed to independently initiate RNA synthesis at separate sites in the 3’-leader promoter, i.e., at the second nucleotide of the genome 3’-end and at the more internally positioned transcription start site preceding the first gene, respectively, as reported for Vesicular stomatitis virus.

The RNA polymerase (RdRp) of Ebola virus (EBOV) initiates RNA synthesis at the 3’-leader promoter of its encapsidated, non-segmented negative sense (NNS) RNA genome, either at the penultimate 3’-end position of the genome in the replicative mode or more internally (position 56) at the transcription start site (TSS) in its transcription mode. Here we identified the synthesis of abortive replicative RNAs that are specifically initiated opposite to genome nt 2 (termed leaderRNAs) and predominantly terminated in the region of nt ~ 60–80 near the TSS. The functional role of abortive leaderRNA synthesis is still enigmatic; a role in interferon induction could be excluded. Our findings indirectly link leaderRNA termination to nucleoprotein (NP) availability for encapsidation of nascent replicative RNA or to NP removal from the template RNA. Our findings further argue against the model that leaderRNA synthesis is a prerequisite for each transcription initiation event at the TSS. Rather, our findings are in line with the existence of distinct replicase and transcriptase complexes of RdRp that interact differently with the 3’-leader promoter and intiate RNA synthesis independently at different sites (position 2 or 56 of the genome), mechanistically similar to another NNS virus, Vesicular stomatitis virus.

Two second-site mutations compensate the engineered mutation of R7A in vesicular stomatitis virus nucleocapsid protein

The functional template for the transcription and replication of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) is genomic RNA encapsidated by nucleocapsid (N) protein. Previous studies showed that the amino acid R7 in the N-terminal arm of N is involved in N-N interaction in the N-RNA complex. In our study, the recombinant virus with mutation of R7A (rVSV(R7A)) in N was recovered, and the replication level of passage 1 (P1) of rVSV(R7A) was 1000 times lower than that of wild-type rVSV at 37°C. After eight passages, the replication level of P8 of rVSV(R7A) with two second-site mutations in the genome (T242 P in N protein and U7-U8 in G-L gene junction) was significantly higher than that of P1. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the mutation of either T242P or U7-U8 can compensate the effect caused by the mutation of R7A on the replication of rVSV(R7A). Therefore, we conclude that two second-site mutations both can compensated the engineered mutation of R7A in VSV N protein.

Transcriptional Regulation in Ebola Virus: Effects of Gene Border Structure and Regulatory Elements on Gene Expression and Polymerase Scanning Behavior

The highly pathogenic Ebola virus (EBOV) has a nonsegmented negative-strand (NNS) RNA genome containing seven genes. The viral genes either are separated by intergenic regions (IRs) of variable length or overlap. The structure of the EBOV gene overlaps is conserved throughout all filovirus genomes and is distinct from that of the overlaps found in other NNS RNA viruses. Here, we analyzed how diverse gene borders and noncoding regions surrounding the gene borders influence transcript levels and govern polymerase behavior during viral transcription. Transcription of overlapping genes in EBOV bicistronic minigenomes followed the stop-start mechanism, similar to that followed by IR-containing gene borders. When the gene overlaps were extended, the EBOV polymerase was able to scan the template in an upstream direction. This polymerase feature seems to be generally conserved among NNS RNA virus polymerases. Analysis of IR-containing gene borders showed that the IR sequence plays only a minor role in transcription regulation. Changes in IR length were generally well tolerated, but specific IR lengths led to a strong decrease in downstream gene expression. Correlation analysis revealed that these effects were largely independent of the surrounding gene borders. Each EBOV gene contains exceptionally long untranslated regions (UTRs) flanking the open reading frame. Our data suggest that the UTRs adjacent to the gene borders are the main regulators of transcript levels. A highly complex interplay between the different cis-acting elements to modulate transcription was revealed for specific combinations of IRs and UTRs, emphasizing the importance of the noncoding regions in EBOV gene expression control.

IMPORTANCE

Our data extend those from previous analyses investigating the implication of noncoding regions at the EBOV gene borders for gene expression control. We show that EBOV transcription is regulated in a highly complex yet not easily predictable manner by a set of interacting cis-active elements. These findings are important not only for the design of recombinant filoviruses but also for the design of other replicon systems widely used as surrogate systems to study the filovirus replication cycle under low biosafety levels. Insights into the complex regulation of EBOV transcription conveyed by noncoding sequences will also help to interpret the importance of mutations that have been detected within these regions, including in isolates of the current outbreak.

Capping of vesicular stomatitis virus pre-mRNA is required for accurate selection of transcription stop-start sites and virus propagation

The multifunctional RNA-dependent RNA polymerase L protein of vesicular stomatitis virus catalyzes unconventional pre-mRNA capping via the covalent enzyme-pRNA intermediate formation, which requires the histidine–arginine (HR) motif in the polyribonucleotidyltransferase domain. Here, the effects of cap-defective mutations in the HR motif on transcription were analyzed using an in vitro reconstituted transcription system. The wild-type L protein synthesized the leader RNA from the 3′-end of the genome followed by 5′-capped and 3′-polyadenylated mRNAs from internal genes by a stop–start transcription mechanism. Cap-defective mutants efficiently produced the leader RNA, but displayed aberrant stop–start transcription using cryptic termination and initiation signals within the first gene, resulting in sequential generation of ∼40-nucleotide transcripts with 5′-ATP from a correct mRNA-start site followed by a 28-nucleotide transcript and long 3′-polyadenylated transcript initiated with non-canonical GTP from atypical start sites. Frequent transcription termination and re-initiation within the first gene significantly attenuated the production of downstream mRNAs. Consistent with the inability of these mutants in in vitro mRNA synthesis and capping, these mutations were lethal to virus replication in cultured cells. These findings indicate that viral mRNA capping is required for accurate stop–start transcription as well as mRNA stability and translation and, therefore, for virus replication in host cells.

Analysis of the highly diverse gene borders in Ebola virus reveals a distinct mechanism of transcriptional regulation

Ebola virus (EBOV) belongs to the group of nonsegmented negative-sense RNA viruses. The seven EBOV genes are separated by variable gene borders, including short (4- or 5-nucleotide) intergenic regions (IRs), a single long (144-nucleotide) IR, and gene overlaps, where the neighboring gene end and start signals share five conserved nucleotides. The unique structure of the gene overlaps and the presence of a single long IR are conserved among all filoviruses. Here, we sought to determine the impact of the EBOV gene borders during viral transcription. We show that readthrough mRNA synthesis occurs in EBOV-infected cells irrespective of the structure of the gene border, indicating that the gene overlaps do not promote recognition of the gene end signal. However, two consecutive gene end signals at the VP24 gene might improve termination at the VP24-L gene border, ensuring efficient L gene expression. We further demonstrate that the long IR is not essential for but regulates transcription reinitiation in a length-dependent but sequence-independent manner. Mutational analysis of bicistronic minigenomes and recombinant EBOVs showed no direct correlation between IR length and reinitiation rates but demonstrated that specific IR lengths not found naturally in filoviruses profoundly inhibit downstream gene expression. Intriguingly, although truncation of the 144-nucleotide-long IR to 5 nucleotides did not substantially affect EBOV transcription, it led to a significant reduction of viral growth.

IMPORTANCE

Our current understanding of EBOV transcription regulation is limited due to the requirement for high-containment conditions to study this highly pathogenic virus. EBOV is thought to share many mechanistic features with well-analyzed prototype nonsegmented negative-sense RNA viruses. A single polymerase entry site at the 3' end of the genome determines that transcription of the genes is mainly controlled by gene order and cis-acting signals found at the gene borders. Here, we examined the regulatory role of the structurally unique EBOV gene borders during viral transcription. Our data suggest that transcriptional regulation in EBOV is highly complex and differs from that in prototype viruses and further the understanding of this most fundamental process in the filovirus replication cycle. Moreover, our results with recombinant EBOVs suggest a novel role of the long IR found in all filovirus genomes during the viral replication cycle.

Sequence variability in viral genome non-coding regions likely contribute to observed differences in viral replication amongst MARV strains

The Marburg viruses Musoke (MARV-Mus) and Angola (MARV-Ang) have highly similar genomic sequences. Analysis of viral replication using various assays consistently identified MARV-Ang as the faster replicating virus. Non-coding genomic regions of negative sense RNA viruses are known to play a role in viral gene expression. A comparison of the six non-coding regions using bicistronic minigenomes revealed that the first two non-coding regions (NP/VP35 and VP35/VP40) differed significantly in their transcriptional regulation. Deletion mutation analysis of the MARV-Mus NP/VP35 region further revealed that the MARV polymerase (L) is able to initiate production of the downstream gene without the presence of highly conserved regulatory signals. Bicistronic minigenome assays also identified the VP30 mRNA 5' untranslated region as an rZAP-targeted RNA motif. Overall, our studies indicate that the high variation of MARV non-coding regions may play a significant role in observed differences in transcription and/or replication.

Second-site mutations selected in transcriptional regulatory sequences compensate for engineered mutations in the vesicular stomatitis virus nucleocapsid protein

The active template for RNA synthesis for vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) and other negative-strand viruses is the RNA genome in association with the nucleocapsid (N) protein. The N protein molecules sequester the genomic RNA and are linked together by a network of noncovalent interactions. We previously demonstrated that mutations predicted to weaken interactions between adjacent N protein molecules altered the levels of RNA synthesis directed from subgenomic ribonucleoprotein (RNP) templates. To determine if these mutations affect virus replication, recombinant viruses containing single-amino-acid substitutions in the N protein were recovered. Four mutations altered transcription and genome replication levels, perturbed viral protein synthesis, and inhibited virus replication. Selective pressure for improved virus replication was applied by eight sequential passages. After five passages, virus replication improved and RNA synthesis recovered concomitantly with the restoration of the protein molar ratios to near-wild-type levels. Genome sequences were compared before and after passage to determine whether compensatory mutations were selected and to potentially identify interactions between N protein molecules or between the RNP template and the viral polymerase. Improved virus replication correlated with the selection of additional mutations located in cis-acting transcriptional regulatory sequences at the gene junctions of the genome rather than in coding sequences, with one exception. The engineered N gene mutations perturbed mRNA and protein expression levels, but the selection of modified transcriptional regulatory sequences with passage facilitated the restoration of wild-type protein expression by modulating transcription levels, reflecting the adaptability and versatility of gene regulation by transcriptional control.

A temperature sensitive VSV identifies L protein residues that affect transcription but not replication

To investigate the polymerase components selectively involved in transcription versus replication of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), we sequenced the polymerase gene of a conditionally RNA defective, temperature sensitive VSV: ts(G)114, which has a phenotype upon shift from permissive to non-permissive temperature of shut-down of mRNA transcription and unaffected genome replication. Sequence analysis of the ts(G)114 L gene identified three altered amino acid residues in the L protein. These three changes were specifically engineered individually and in combinations into a functional cDNA clone encoding the VSV genome and tested for association with the temperature sensitive and RNA defective phenotypes in the background of recovered engineered viruses. The data presented in this study show a specific amino acid substitution in domain II of the VSV L protein that significantly affects total RNA synthesis, but when in combination with two additional amino acid substitutions identified in the ts(G)114 L protein, leads to a specific reduction in mRNA transcription, but not replication.

Selection for gene junction sequences important for VSV transcription

The heptauridine tract at each gene end and intergenic region (IGR) at the gene junctions of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) have effects on synthesis of the downstream mRNA, independent of their respective roles in termination of the upstream mRNA. To investigate the role of the U tract and the IGR in downstream gene transcription, we altered the N/P gene junction of infectious VSV such that transcription levels would be affected and result in altered molar ratios of the N and P proteins, which are critical for optimal viral RNA replication. The changes included extended IGRs between the N and P genes and shortening the length of the heptauridine tract upstream of the P gene start. Viruses having various combinations of these changes were recovered from cDNA and selective pressure for efficient viral replication was applied by sequential passage in cell culture. The replicative ability and sequence at the altered intergenic junctions were monitored throughout the passages to compare the effects of the changes at the IGR and U tract. VSV variants with wild-type U tracts upstream of the P gene replicated to levels similar to wt VSV. Variants with shortened U tracts were reduced in their ability to replicate. With passage, populations emerged that replicated to higher levels. Sequence analysis revealed that mutations had been selected for in these populations that increased the length of the U tract. This correlated with an increase in abundance of P mRNA and protein to provide improved N:P protein molar ratios. Extended IGRs resulted in decreased downstream transcription but the effect was not as extensive as that caused by shortened U tracts. Extended IGRs were not selected against in 5 passages. Our results indicate that the size of the upstream gene end U tract is an important determinant of efficient downstream gene transcription in infectious virus.

Genomic characterisation of Wongabel virus reveals novel genes within the Rhabdoviridae

Viruses belonging to the family Rhabdoviridae infect a variety of different hosts, including insects, vertebrates and plants. Currently, there are approximately 200 ICTV-recognised rhabdoviruses isolated around the world. However, the majority remain poorly characterised and only a fraction have been definitively assigned to genera. The genomic and transcriptional complexity displayed by several of the characterised rhabdoviruses indicates large diversity and complexity within this family. To enable an improved taxonomic understanding of this family, it is necessary to gain further information about the poorly characterised members of this family. Here we present the complete genome sequence and predicted transcription strategy of Wongabel virus (WONV), a previously uncharacterised rhabdovirus isolated from biting midges (Culicoides austropalpalis) collected in northern Queensland, Australia. The 13,196 nucleotide genome of WONV encodes five typical rhabdovirus genes N, P, M, G and L. In addition, the WONV genome contains three genes located between the P and M genes (U1, U2, U3) and two open reading frames overlapping with the N and G genes (U4, U5). These five additional genes and their putative protein products appear to be novel, and their functions are unknown. Predictive analysis of the U5 gene product revealed characteristics typical of viroporins, and indicated structural similarities with the alpha-1 protein (putative viroporin) of viruses in the genus Ephemerovirus. Phylogenetic analyses of the N and G proteins of WONV indicated closest similarity with the avian-associated Flanders virus; however, the genomes of these two viruses are significantly diverged. WONV displays a novel and unique genome structure that has not previously been described for any animal rhabdovirus.

The VSV polymerase can initiate at mRNA start sites located either up or downstream of a transcription termination signal but size of the intervening intergenic region affects efficiency of initiation

Transcription by the vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV) polymerase has been characterized as obligatorily sequential with transcription of each downstream gene dependent on termination of the gene immediately upstream. In studies described here we investigated the ability of the VSV RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) to access mRNA initiation sites located at increasing distances either downstream or upstream of a transcription termination signal. Bi-cistronic subgenomic replicons were constructed containing progressively extended intergenic regions preceding the initiation site of a downstream gene. The ability of the RdRp to access the downstream sites was progressively reduced as the length of the intergenic region increased. Alternatively, bi-cistronic replicons were constructed containing an mRNA start signal located at increasing distances upstream of a termination site. Analysis of transcription of these "overlapped" genes showed that for an upstream mRNA start site to be recognized it had to contain not only the canonical 3'-UUGUCnnUAG-5' gene start signal, but that signal needed also to be preceded by a U7 tract. Access of these upstream mRNA initiation sites by the VSV RdRp was proportionately reduced with increasing distance between the termination site and the overlapped initiation signal. Possible mechanisms for how the RdRp accesses these upstream start sites are discussed.

Role of intergenic sequences in newcastle disease virus RNA transcription and pathogenesis

Newcastle disease virus (NDV), a member of the family Paramyxoviridae, has a nonsegmented negative-sense RNA genome consisting of six genes (3'-NP-P-M-F-HN-L-5'). The first three 3'-end intergenic sequences (IGSs) are single nucleotides (nt), whereas the F-HN and HN-L IGSs are 31 and 47 nt, respectively. To investigate the role of IGS length in NDV transcription and pathogenesis, we recovered viable viruses containing deletions or additions in the IGSs between the F and HN and the HN and L genes. The IGS of F-HN was modified to contain an additional 96 nt or more or a deletion of 30 nt. Similarly, the IGS of HN-L was modified to contain an additional 96 nt or more or a deletion of 42 nt. The level of transcription of each mRNA species (NP, F, HN, and L) was examined by Northern blot analysis. Our results showed that NDV can tolerate an IGS length of at least 365 nt. The extended lengths of IGSs down-regulated the transcription of the downstream gene and suggested that 31 nt in the F-HN IGS and 47 nt in the HN-L IGS are required for efficient transcription of the downstream gene. The effect of IGS length on pathogenicity of mutant viruses was evaluated in embryonated chicken eggs, 1-day-old chicks, and 6-week-old chickens. Our results showed that all IGS mutants were attenuated in chickens. The level of attenuation increased as the length of the IGS increased. Interestingly, decreased IGS length also attenuated the viruses. These findings can have significant applications in NDV vaccine development.

Sendai virus RNA polymerase scanning for mRNA start sites at gene junctions

Mini-genomes expressing two reporter genes and a variable gene junction were used to study Sendai virus RNA polymerase (RdRp) scanning for the mRNA start signal of the downstream gene (gs2). We found that RdRp could scan the template efficiently as long as the initiating uridylate of gs2 (3' UCCCnnUUUC) was preceded by the conserved intergenic region (3' GAA) and the last 3 uridylates of the upstream gene end signal (ge1; 3' AUUCUUUUU). The end of the leader sequence (3' CUAAAA, which precedes gs1) could also be used for gene2 expression, but this sequence was considerably less efficient. Increasing the distance between ge1 and gs2 (up to 200 nt) led to the progressive loss of gene2 expression, in which half of gene2 expression was lost for each 70 nucleotides of intervening sequence. Beyond 200 nt, gene2 expression was lost more slowly. Our results suggest that there may be two populations of RdRp that scan at gene junctions, which can be distinguished by the efficiency with which they can scan the genome template for gs.

Conserved aspartic acid 233 and alanine 231 are not required for poliovirus polymerase function in replicons

Nucleic acid polymerases have similar structures and motifs. The function of an aspartic acid (conserved in all classes of nucleic acid polymerases) in motif A remains poorly understood in RNA-dependent RNA polymerases. We mutated this residue to alanine in a poliovirus replicon. The resulting mutant could still replicate, although at a reduced level. In addition, mutation A231C (also in motif A) yielded high levels of replication. Taken together these results show that poliovirus polymerase conserved residues D233 and A231 are not essential to poliovirus replicon function.

Vesicular stomatitis viruses resistant to the methylase inhibitor sinefungin upregulate RNA synthesis and reveal mutations that affect mRNA cap methylation

Sinefungin (SIN), a natural S-adenosyl-L-methionine analog produced by Streptomyces griseolus, is a potent inhibitor of methyltransferases. We evaluated the effect of SIN on replication of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), a prototype of the nonsegmented negative-strand RNA viruses. The 241-kDa large polymerase (L) protein of VSV methylates viral mRNA cap structures at the guanine-N-7 (G-N-7) and ribose-2'-O (2'-O) positions. By performing transcription reactions in vitro, we show that both methylations are inhibited by SIN and that methylation was more sensitive at the G-N-7 than at 2'-O position. We further show that SIN inhibited growth of VSV in cell culture, reducing viral yield by 50-fold and diminishing plaque size. We isolated eight mutants that were resistant to SIN as judged by their growth characteristics. The SIN-resistant (SINR) viruses contained mutations in the L gene, the promoter for L gene expression provided by the conserved sequence elements of the G-L gene junction and the M gene. Five mutations resulted in amino acid substitutions to conserved regions II/III and VI of the L protein. For each mutant, we examined viral gene expression in cells and cap methylation in vitro. SINR mutants upregulated RNA synthesis in the presence of SIN, which may be responsible for their resistance. We also found that some SINR viruses with L gene mutations were defective in cap methylation in vitro, yet their methylases were less sensitive to SIN inhibition than those of the wild-type parent. These studies show that the VSV methylases are inhibited by SIN, and they define new regions of L protein that affect cap methylation. These studies also provide experimental evidence that inhibition of cap methylases is a potential strategy for development of antiviral therapeutics against nonsegmented negative-strand RNA viruses.

Unravelling the complexities of respiratory syncytial virus RNA synthesis

Human respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) is the leading cause of paediatric respiratory disease and is the focus of antiviral- and vaccine-development programmes. These goals have been aided by an understanding of the virus genome architecture and the mechanisms by which it is expressed and replicated. RSV is a member of the order Mononegavirales and, as such, has a genome consisting of a single strand of negative-sense RNA. At first glance, transcription and genome replication appear straightforward, requiring self-contained promoter regions at the 3' ends of the genome and antigenome RNAs, short cis-acting elements flanking each of the genes and one polymerase. However, from these minimal elements, the virus is able to generate an array of capped, methylated and polyadenylated mRNAs and encapsidated antigenome and genome RNAs, all in the appropriate ratios to facilitate virus replication. The apparent simplicity of genome expression and replication is a consequence of considerable complexity in the polymerase structure and its cognate cis-acting sequences; here, our understanding of mechanisms by which the RSV polymerase proteins interact with signals in the RNA template to produce different RNA products is reviewed.

Recombinant rhabdoviruses: vectors for vaccine development and gene therapy

The establishment of methods to recover rhabdoviruses from cDNA, so-called reverse genetics systems, has made it possible to genetically engineer rhabdoviruses and to study all aspects of the virus life cycle by introducing defined mutations into the viral genomes. It has also opened the way to make use of the viruses in biomedical applications such as vaccination, gene therapy, or oncolytic virotherapy. The typical gene expression mode of rhabdoviruses, a high genetic stability, and the propensity to tolerate changes in the virus envelope have made rhabdoviruses attractive, targetable gene expression vectors. This chapter provides an overview on the possibilities to manipulate biological properties of the rhabdoviruses that may be important for further development of vaccine vectors and examples of recombinant rhabdoviruses expressing foreign genes and antigens.

Genetic comparison of the rhabdoviruses from animals and plants

There are more than 160 viral species in the Rhabdovidae family, most of which can be grouped into one of the six genera including Vesiculovirus, Lyssavirus, Ephemerovirus, Novirhabdovirus, Cytorhabdovirus, and Nucleorhabdovirus. These viruses are not only morphologically similar but also genetically related. Analysis of viral genes shows that rhabdoviruses are more closely related to each other than to viruses in other families. With the development of reverse genetics, the functions of many cis- and trans-elements important in the process of viral transcription and replication have been clearly defined such as the leader, trailer, and the intergenic sequences. Furthermore, it has been shown that there are two entry sites for the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase: 3' entry for leader synthesis and RNA replication, and direct entry at the N gene start sequence for transcription of the monocistronic mRNAs.

Variations in intergenic region sequences of Human respiratory syncytial virus clinical isolates: analysis of effects on transcriptional regulation

Sequences at the beginnings and ends of Human respiratory syncytial virus (HRSV) genes are necessary for efficient initiation and termination of transcription. The gene start sequences are well conserved and contain signals required for initiation, while the semi-conserved sequences at the gene ends direct transcriptional termination with varying efficiencies. The intergenic regions, which lie between the gene ends and the downstream gene start sequences, are not conserved in length or sequence, and certain positions have been reported to play a role in transcriptional regulation. We have previously shown that the gene end sequences in HRSV subgroup A clinical isolates are variable and that variations found at certain gene ends decreased transcriptional termination and downstream mRNA expression. Here, we have extended this work to examine variation in the intergenic regions between the genes of clinical isolates. We determined the sequences of the eight intergenic regions and the M2/L overlap from clinical isolates from the US and UK and found that all of these regions contained variations from the prototype A2 strain. The amount of variation observed was disparate among the different intergenic regions and did not correlate with length. The effects of selected variant sequences on transcription were examined in the context of subgenomic replicons. While some changes in the intergenic regions had minor effects, certain sequence variations significantly altered transcription termination or initiation. A single nucleotide deletion in the M/SH intergenic region decreased initiation at the SH gene start seven-fold, while changes in the F/M2 intergenic region were found that in some cases increased and in others decreased termination at the F gene end. The P/M intergenic region was the most variable, but none of the changes examined affected either termination at the P gene end or initiation of the downstream M gene start. These results show that in HRSV clinical isolates the intergenic region sequences are variable and that changes in these regions have the potential to affect transcriptional control at the gene junctions.

Nucleotide sequence of RNA2 of Lettuce big-vein virus and evidence for a possible transcription termination/initiation strategy similar to that of rhabdoviruses

Lettuce big-vein virus (LBVV) is the type species of the genus Varicosavirus and is a two-segmented negative-sense single-stranded RNA virus. The larger LBVV genome segment (RNA1) consists of 6797 nt and encodes an L polymerase that resembles that of rhabdoviruses. Here, the nucleotide sequence of the second LBVV genome segment (RNA2) is reported. LBVV RNA2 consisted of 6081 nt and contained antisense information for five major ORFs: ORF1 (nt 210-1403 on the viral RNA), ORF2 (nt 1493-2494), ORF3 (nt 2617-3489), ORF4 (nt 3843-4337) and ORF5 (nt 4530-5636), which had coding capacities of 44, 36, 32, 19 and 41 kDa, respectively. The gene at the 3' end of the viral RNA encoded a coat protein, while the other four genes encoded proteins of unknown functions. The 3'-terminal 11 nt of LBVV RNA2 were identical to those of LBVV RNA1, and the 5'-terminal regions of LBVV RNA1 and RNA2 contained a long common nucleotide stretch of about 100 nt. Northern blot analysis using probes specific to the individual ORFs revealed that LBVV transcribes monocistronic RNAs. Analysis of the terminal sequences, and primer extension and RNase H digestion analysis of LBVV mRNAs, suggested that LBVV utilizes a transcription termination/initiation strategy comparable with that of rhabdoviruses.

Transcription and replication of nonsegmented negative-strand RNA viruses

The nonsegmented negative-strand (NNS) RNA viruses of the order Mononegavirales include a wide variety of human, animal, and plant pathogens. The NNS RNA genomes of these viruses are templates for two distinct RNA synthetic processes: transcription to generate mRNAs and replication of the genome via production of a positive-sense antigenome that acts as template to generate progeny negative-strand genomes. The four virus families within the Mononegavirales all express the information encoded in their genomes by transcription of discrete subgenomic mRNAs. The key feature of transcriptional control in the NNS RNA viruses is entry of the virus-encoded RNA-dependent RNA polymerase at a single 3' proximal site followed by obligatory sequential transcription of the linear array of genes. Levels of gene expression are primarily regulated by position of each gene relative to the single promoter and also by cis-acting sequences located at the beginning and end of each gene and at the intergenic junctions. Obligatory sequential transcription dictates that termination of each upstream gene is required for initiation of downstream genes. Therefore, termination is a means to regulate expression of individual genes within the framework of a single transcriptional promoter. By engineering either whole virus genomes or subgenomic replicon derivatives, elements important for signaling transcript initiation, 5' end modification, 3' end polyadenylation, and transcription termination have been identified. Although the diverse families of NNS RNA virus use different sequences to control these processes, transcriptional termination is a common theme in controlling gene expression and overall transcriptional regulation is key in controlling the outcome of viral infection. The latest models for control of replication and transcription are discussed.

Transcriptional control of the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of vesicular stomatitis virus

The nonsegmented negative strand (NNS) RNA viruses include some of the mosr problematic human, animal and plant pathogens extant: for example, rabies virus, Ebola virus, respiratory syncytial virus, the parainfluenza viruses, measles and infectious hemapoietic necrosis virus. The key feature of transcriptional control in the NNS RNA viruses is polymerase entry at a single 3' proximal site followed by obligatory sequential transcription of the linear array of genes. The levels of gene expression are primarily regulated by their position on the genome. The promoter proximal gene is transcribed in greatest abundance and each successive downstream gene is synthesized in progressively lower amounts due to attenuation of transcription at each successive gene junction. In addition, NNS RNA virus gene expression is regulated by cis-acting sequences that reside at the beginning and end of each gene and the intergenic junctions. Using vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV), the prototypic NNS, many of these control elements have been identified.The signals for transcription initiation and 5' end modification and for 3' end polyadenylation and termination have been elucidated. The sequences that determine the ability of the polymerase to slip on the template to generate polyadenylate have been identified and polyadenylation has been shown to be template dependent and integral to the termination process. Transcriptional termination is a key element in control of gene expression of the negative strand RNA viruses and a means by which expression of individual genes may be silenced or regulated within the framework of a single transcriptional promoter. In addition, the fundamental question of the site of entry of the polymerase during transcription has been reexamined and our understanding of the process altered and updated. The ability to engineer changes into infectious viruses has confirmed the action of these elements and as a consequence, it has been shown that transcriptional control is key to controlling the outcome of a viral infection. Finally, the principles of transcriptional regulation have been utilized to develop a new paradigm for systematic attenuation of virulence to develop live attenuated viral vaccines.

Adding genes to the RNA genome of vesicular stomatitis virus: positional effects on stability of expression

Gene expression of the nonsegmented negative strand (NNS) RNA viruses is controlled primarily at the level of transcription by the position of the genes relative to the single transcriptional promoter. We tested this principle by generating engineered variants of vesicular stomatitis virus in which an additional, identical, transcriptional unit was added to the genome at each of the viral gene junctions. Analysis of transcripts confirmed that the level of transcription was determined by the position of the gene relative to the promoter. However, the position at which a gene was inserted affected the replication potential of the viruses. Adding a gene between the first two genes, N and P, reduced replication by over an order of magnitude, whereas addition of a gene at the other gene junctions had no effect on replication levels. All genes downstream of the inserted gene had decreased levels of expression, since transcription of the extra gene introduced an additional transcriptional attenuation event. The added gene was stably maintained in the genome upon repeated passage in all cases. However, expression of the added gene was stable at only three of the four positions. In the case of insertion between the N and P genes, a virus population arose within two passages that had restored replication to wild-type levels. In this population, expression of the additional gene as a monocistronic mRNA was suppressed by mutations at the end of the upstream (N) gene that abolished transcriptional termination. Because transcription is obligatorily sequential, this prevented transcription of the inserted downstream gene as a monocistronic mRNA and resulted instead in polymerase reading through the gene junction to produce a bicistronic mRNA. This eliminated the additional attenuation step and restored expression of all downstream genes and viral replication to wild-type levels. These data show that transcriptional termination is a key element in control of gene expression of the negative strand RNA viruses and a means by which expression of individual genes may be regulated within the framework of a single transcriptional promoter. Further, these results are directly relevant to the use of NNS viruses as vectors and vaccine delivery agents, as they show that the level of expression of an added gene can be controlled by its insertion position but that not all positions of insertion yield stable expression of the added gene.