Single amino acid insertions at the junction of the sindbis virus E2 transmembrane domain and endodomain disrupt virus envelopment and alter infectivity

Chikungunya virus host range E2 transmembrane deletion mutants induce protective immunity against challenge in C57BL/6J mice

A vaccine against Chikungunya virus (ChikV), a reemerging pathogenic arbovirus, has been made by attenuating wild-type (WT) virus via truncation of the transmembrane domain (TMD) of E2 and selecting for host range (HR) mutants. Mice are a standard model system for ChikV disease and display the same symptoms of the disease seen in humans. Groups of mice were inoculated with one of three ChikV HR mutants to determine the ability of each mutant strain to elicit neutralizing antibody and protective immunity upon virus challenge. One mutant, ChikV TM17-2, fulfilled the criteria for a good vaccine candidate. It displayed no reactogenicity at the site of injection, no tissue disease in the foot/ankle and quadriceps, and no evidence of viral persistence in foot/ankle tissues 21 days after infection. Upon challenge with a highly pathogenic strain of ChikV, the mutant blocked viral replication in all tissues tested. This study identified a ChikV HR mutant that grows to high levels in insect cells but was restricted in the ability to assemble virus in mammalian cells in vitro. The study demonstrates that these HR strains are attenuated in the mammalian host and warrant further development as live-attenuated vaccine strains.

Eilat virus, a unique alphavirus with host range restricted to insects by RNA replication

Most alphaviruses and many other arboviruses are mosquito-borne and exhibit a broad host range, infecting many different vertebrates including birds, rodents, equids, humans, and nonhuman primates. Consequently, they can be propagated in most vertebrate and insect cell cultures. This ability of arboviruses to infect arthropods and vertebrates is usually essential for their maintenance in nature. However, several flaviviruses have recently been described that infect mosquitoes but not vertebrates, although the mechanism of their host restriction has not been determined. Here we describe a unique alphavirus, Eilat virus (EILV), isolated from a pool of Anopheles coustani mosquitoes from the Negev desert of Israel. Phylogenetic analyses placed EILV as a sister to the Western equine encephalitis antigenic complex within the main clade of mosquito-borne alphaviruses. Electron microscopy revealed that, like other alphaviruses, EILV virions were spherical, 70 nm in diameter, and budded from the plasma membrane of mosquito cells in culture. EILV readily infected a variety of insect cells with little overt cytopathic effect. However, in contrast to typical mosquito-borne alphaviruses, EILV could not infect mammalian or avian cell lines, and viral as well as RNA replication could not be detected at 37 °C or 28 °C. Evolutionarily, these findings suggest that EILV lost its ability to infect vertebrate cells. Thus, EILV seems to be mosquito-specific and represents a previously undescribed complex within the genus Alphavirus. Reverse genetic studies of EILV may facilitate the discovery of determinants of alphavirus host range that mediate disease emergence.

Conformational changes in Sindbis virus induced by decreased pH are revealed by small-angle neutron scattering

Alphaviruses, such as Sindbis virus, undergo dramatic changes in three-dimensional structure upon exposure to low pH, and such exposure can establish conditions allowing fusion of the virus membrane with a cell plasma membrane upon return to neutral pH. While exposure to low pH is not required for entry of Sindbis virus into vertebrate or invertebrate cells, the conformational changes occurring at low pH may mimic those occurring upon virus-receptor interaction. Here, we employed small-angle neutron scattering with contrast variation to probe how the structure of a mammalian-grown Sindbis virus responds to moderately acidic pH. Several changes took place throughout the virion structure when the pH decreased from 7.2 to 6.4. Specifically, the RNA in the virion core underwent a conformational change. Additionally, the protein was redistributed. A significant amount of protein moved from the layer containing the lipid bilayer to the exterior of the virion. The results improve our understanding of the pH-driven alteration of Sindbis virus structure.

Interactions of the cytoplasmic domain of Sindbis virus E2 with nucleocapsid cores promote alphavirus budding

Alphavirus budding from the plasma membrane occurs through the specific interaction of the nucleocapsid core with the cytoplasmic domain of the E2 glycoprotein (cdE2). Structural studies of the Sindbis virus capsid protein (CP) have suggested that these critical interactions are mediated by the binding of cdE2 into a hydrophobic pocket in the CP. Several molecular genetic studies have implicated amino acids Y400 and L402 in cdE2 as important for the budding of alphaviruses. In this study, we characterized the role of cdE2 residues in structural polyprotein processing, glycoprotein transport, and capsid interactions. Along with hydrophobic residues, charged residues in the N terminus of cdE2 were critical for the effective interaction of cores with cdE2, a process required for virus budding. Mutations in the C-terminal signal sequence region of cdE2 affected E2 protein transport to the plasma membrane, while nonbudding mutants that were defective in cdE2-CP interaction accumulated E2 on the plasma membrane. The interaction of cdE2 with cytoplasmic cores purified from infected cells and in vitro-assembled core-like particles suggests that cdE2 interacts with assembled cores to mediate budding. We hypothesize that these cdE2 interactions induce a change in the organization of the nucleocapsid core upon binding leading to particle budding and priming of the nucleocapsid cores for disassembly that is required for virus infection.

Molecular links between the E2 envelope glycoprotein and nucleocapsid core in Sindbis virus

A three-dimensional reconstruction of Sindbis virus at 7.0 Å resolution presented here provides a detailed view of the virion structure and includes structural evidence for key interactions that occur between the capsid protein (CP) and transmembrane (TM) glycoproteins E1 and E2. Based on crystal structures of component proteins and homology modeling, we constructed a nearly complete, pseudo-atomic model of the virus. Notably, this includes identification of the 33-residue cytoplasmic domain of E2 (cdE2), which follows a path from the E2 TM helix to the CP where it enters and exits the CP hydrophobic pocket and then folds back to contact the viral membrane. Modeling analysis identified three major contact regions between cdE2 and CP, and the roles of specific residues were probed by molecular genetics. This identified R393 and E395 of cdE2 and Y162 and K252 of CP as critical for virus assembly. The N-termini of the CPs form a contiguous network that interconnects 12 pentameric and 30 hexameric CP capsomers. A single glycoprotein spike cross-links three neighboring CP capsomers as might occur during initiation of virus budding.

An alternative pathway for alphavirus entry

The study of alphavirus entry has been complicated by an inability to clearly identify a receptor and by experiments which only tangentially and indirectly examine the process, producing results that are difficult to interpret. The mechanism of entry has been widely accepted to be by endocytosis followed by acidification of the endosome resulting in virus membrane-endosome membrane fusion. This mechanism has come under scrutiny as better purification protocols and improved methods of analysis have been brought to the study. Results have been obtained that suggest alphaviruses infect cells directly at the plasma membrane without the involvement of endocytosis, exposure to acid pH, or membrane fusion. In this review we compare the data which support the two models and make the case for an alternative pathway of entry by alphaviruses.

Differential incorporation of cholesterol by Sindbis virus grown in mammalian or insect cells

Cholesterol has been shown to be essential for the fusion of alphaviruses with artificial membranes (liposomes). Cholesterol has also been implicated as playing an essential and critical role in the processes of entry and egress of alphaviruses in living cells. Paradoxically, insects, the alternate host for alphaviruses, are cholesterol auxotrophs and contain very low levels of this sterol. To further evaluate the role of cholesterol in the life cycle of alphaviruses, the cholesterol levels of the alphavirus Sindbis produced from three different mosquito (Aedes albopictus) cell lines; one other insect cell line, Sf21 from Spodoptera frugiperda; and BHK (mammalian) cells were measured. Sindbis virus was grown in insect cells under normal culture conditions and in cells depleted of cholesterol by growth in serum delipidated by using Cab-O-sil, medium treated with methyl-beta-cyclodextrin, or serum-free medium. The levels of cholesterol incorporated into the membranes of the cells and into the virus produced from these cells were determined. Virus produced from these treated and untreated cells was compared to virus grown in BHK cells under standard conditions. The ability of insect cells to produce Sindbis virus after delipidation was found to be highly cell specific and not dependent on the level of cholesterol in the cell membrane. A very low level of cholesterol was required for the generation of wild-type levels of infectious Sindbis virus from delipidated cells. The data show that one role of the virus membrane is structural, providing the stability required for infectivity that may not be provided by the delipidated membranes in some cells. These data show that the amount of cholesterol in the host cell membrane in and of itself has no effect on the process of virus assembly or on the ability of virus to infect cells. Rather, these data suggest that the cholesterol dependence reported for infectivity and assembly of Sindbis virus is a reflection of differences in the insect cell lines used and the methods of delipidation.

Sindbis virus conformational changes induced by a neutralizing anti-E1 monoclonal antibody

A rare Sindbis virus anti-E1 neutralizing monoclonal antibody, Sin-33, was investigated to determine the mechanism of in vitro neutralization. A cryoelectron microscopic reconstruction of Sindbis virus (SVHR) neutralized with FAb from Sin-33 (FAb-33) revealed conformational changes on the surface of the virion at a resolution of 24 A. FAb-33 was found to bind E1 in less than 1:1 molar ratios, as shown by the absence of FAb density in the reconstruction and stoichiometric measurements using radiolabeled FAb-33, which determined that about 60 molecules of FAb-33 bound to the 240 possible sites in a single virus particle. FAb-33-neutralized virus particles became sensitive to digestion by endoproteinase Glu-C, providing further evidence of antibody-induced structural changes within the virus particle. The treatment of FAb-33-neutralized or Sin-33-neutralized SVHR with low pH did not induce the conformational rearrangements required for virus membrane-cell membrane fusion. Exposure to low pH, however, increased the amount of Sin-33 or FAb-33 that bound to the virus particles, indicating the exposure of additional epitopes. The neutralization of SVHR infection by FAb-33 or Sin-33 did not prevent the association of virus with host cells. These data are in agreement with the results of previous studies that demonstrated that specific antibodies can inactivate the infectious state of a metastable virus in vitro by the induction of conformational changes to produce an inactive structure. A model is proposed which postulates that the induction of conformational changes in the infectious state of a metastable enveloped virus may be a general mechanism of antibody inactivation of virus infectivity.

Functional characterization of the Sindbis virus E2 glycoprotein by transposon linker-insertion mutagenesis

The glycoprotein envelope of alphaviruses consists of two proteins, E1 and E2. E1 is responsible for fusion and E2 is responsible for receptor binding. An atomic structure is available for E1, but one for E2 has not been reported. In this study, transposon linker-insertion mutagenesis was used to probe the function of different domains of E2. A library of mutants, containing 19 amino acid insertions in the E2 glycoprotein sequence of the prototype alphavirus, Sindbis virus (SINV), was generated. Fifty-seven independent E2 insertions were characterized, of which more than half (67%) gave rise to viable virus. The wild-type-like mutants identify regions that accommodate insertions without perturbing virus production and can be used to insert targeting moieties to direct SINV to specific receptors. The defective and lethal mutants give insight into regions of E2 important for protein stability, transport to the cell membrane, E1-E2 contacts, and receptor binding.

Mutations in the endodomain of Sindbis virus glycoprotein E2 define sequences critical for virus assembly

Envelopment of Sindbis virus at the plasma membrane is a multistep process in which an initial step is the association of the E2 protein via a cytoplasmic endodomain with the preassembled nucleocapsid. Sindbis virus is vectored in nature by blood-sucking insects and grows efficiently in a number of avian and mammalian vertebrate hosts. The assembly of Sindbis virus, therefore, must occur in two very different host cell environments. Mammalian cells contain cholesterol which insect membranes lack. This difference in membrane composition may be critical in determining what requirements are placed on the E2 tail for virus assembly. To examine the interaction between the E2 tail and the nucleocapsid in Sindbis virus, we have produced substitutions and deletions in a region of the E2 tail (E2 amino acids 408 to 415) that is initially integrated into the endoplasmic reticulum. This sequence was identified as being critical for nucleocapsid binding in an in vitro peptide protection assay. The effects of these mutations on virus assembly and function were determined in both vertebrate and invertebrate cells. Amino acid substitutions (at positions E2: 408, 410, 411, and 413) reduced infectious virus production in a position-dependent fashion but were not efficient in disrupting assembly in mammalian cells. Deletions in the E2 endodomain (delta406-407, delta409-411, and delta414-417) resulted in the failure to assemble virions in mammalian cells. Electron microscopy of BHK cells transfected with these mutants revealed assembly of nucleocapsids that failed to attach to membranes. However, introduction of these deletion mutants into insect cells resulted in the assembly of virus-like particles but no assayable infectivity. These data help define protein interactions critical for virus assembly and suggest a fundamental difference between Sindbis virus assembly in mammalian and insect cells.

Mapping the structure and function of the E1 and E2 glycoproteins in alphaviruses

The 9 A resolution cryo-electron microscopy map of Sindbis virus presented here provides structural information on the polypeptide topology of the E2 protein, on the interactions between the E1 and E2 glycoproteins in the formation of a heterodimer, on the difference in conformation of the two types of trimeric spikes, on the interaction between the transmembrane helices of the E1 and E2 proteins, and on the conformational changes that occur when fusing with a host cell. The positions of various markers on the E2 protein established the approximate topology of the E2 structure. The largest conformational differences between the icosahedral surface spikes at icosahedral 3-fold and quasi-3-fold positions are associated with the monomers closest to the 5-fold axes. The long E2 monomers, containing the cell receptor recognition motif at their extremities, are shown to rotate by about 180 degrees and to move away from the center of the spikes during fusion.

Role of a conserved tripeptide in the endodomain of Sindbis virus glycoprotein E2 in virus assembly and function

Envelopment of Sindbis virus (SV) at the plasma membrane begins with the interaction of the E2 glycoprotein endodomain with a hydrophobic cleft in the surface of the pre-assembled nucleocapsid. The driving force for this budding event is thought to reside in this virus type-specific association at the surface of the cell. The specific amino acids involved in this interaction have not been identified; however, it has been proposed that a conserved motif (TPY) at aa 398-400 in the E2 tail plays a critical role in this interaction. This interaction has been examined with virus containing mutations at two positions in this conserved domain, T398A and Y400N. The viruses produced have very low infectivity (as determined by particle : p.f.u. ratios); however, there appears to be no defect in assembly, as the virus has wild-type density and electron microscopy shows assembled particles with no obvious aberrant structural changes. The loss of infectivity in the double mutant is accompanied by the loss of the ability to fuse cells after brief exposure to acid pH. These data support the idea that these residues are vital for production of infectious/functional virus; however, they are dispensable for assembly. These results, combined with other published observations, expand our understanding of the interaction of the E2 endodomain with the capsid protein.

Single and multiple deletions in the transmembrane domain of the Sindbis virus E2 glycoprotein identify a region critical for normal virus growth

Sindbis virus is composed of two nested T = 4 icosahedral protein shells containing 240 copies each of three structural proteins: E1, E2, and Capsid in a 1:1:1 stoichiometric ratio. E2 is a 423 amino acid glycoprotein with a membrane spanning domain 26 amino acids in length and a 33 amino acid cytoplasmic endodomain. The interaction of the endodomain with the nucleocapsid is an essential step in virus maturation and directs the formation of the outer protein shell as envelopment occurs. A previous study had determined that deletions in the transmembrane domain could affect virus assembly and infectivity (Hernandez et al., 2003. J. Virol. 77 (23), 12710-12719). Unexpectedly, a single deletion mutant (from 26 to 25 amino acids) resulted in a 1000-fold decrease in infectious virus production while another deletion of eight amino acids had no affect on infectious virus production. To further investigate the importance of these mutants, other single deletion mutants and another eight amino acid deletion mutant were constructed. We found that deletions located closer to the cytoplasmic (inner leaflet) of the membrane bilayer had a more detrimental effect on virus assembly and infectivity than those located closer to the luminal (outer leaflet) of the membrane bilayer. We also found that selective pressure can restore single amino acid deletions in the transmembrane domain but not necessarily to the wild type sequence. The partial restoration of an eight amino acid deletion (from 18 to 22 amino acids) also partially restored infectious virus production. The amount of infectious virus produced by this revertant was equivalent to that produced for the four amino acid deletion produced by site directed mutagenesis. These results suggest that the position of the deletion and the length of the C terminal region of the E2 transmembrane domain is vital for normal virus production. Deletion mutants resulting in decreased infectivity produce particles that appear to be processed and transported correctly suggesting a role involved in virus entry.