Chromatin Modulation of Herpesvirus Lytic Gene Expression: Managing Nucleosome Density and Heterochromatic Histone Modifications

The HSV-1 encoded CCCTC-binding factor, CTRL2, impacts the nature of viral chromatin during HSV-1 lytic infection

HSV-1 genomes are rapidly heterochromatinized following entry by host cells to limit viral gene expression. Efficient HSV-1 genome replication requires mechanisms that de-repress chromatin associated with the viral genome. CCCTC-binding factors, or CTCF insulators play both silencing and activating roles in cellular transcriptional regulation. Importantly, the HSV-1 genome encodes several CTCF insulators that flank IE genes, implying that individual HSV-1 encoded CTCF insulators regulate IE transcription during all stages of the HSV-1 life cycle. We previously reported that the HSV-1 encoded CTCF insulator located downstream of the LAT (CTRL2) controlled IE gene silencing during latency. To further characterize the role of this insulator during the lytic infection we leveraged a ΔCTRL2 recombinant virus to show that there was a genome replication defect that stemmed from decreased IE gene expression in fibroblasts and epithelial cells at early times following initiation of infection. Further experiments indicated that the defect in gene expression resulted from chromatin inaccessibility in the absence of the insulator. To elucidate how chromatin accessibility was altered in the absence of the CTRL2 insulator, we showed that enrichment of Alpha-thalassemia/mental retardation, X-linked chromatin remodeler (ATRX), and the histone variant H3.3, both of which are known for their roles in maintaining repressive histone markers on the HSV-1 viral genome were increased on IE regions of HSV-1. Finally, both H3K27me3 and H3K9me3 repressive histone marks remained enriched by 4 hours post infection in the absence of the CTRL2 insulator, confirming that the CTRL2 insulator is required for de-repression of IE genes of viral genomes. To our knowledge these are the first data that show that a specific CTCF insulator in the HSV-1 genome (CTRL2) regulates chromatin accessibility during the lytic infection.

Five families of diverse DNA viruses comprehensively restructure the nucleus

Many viruses have evolved ways to restructure their host cell's nucleus profoundly and unexpectedly upon infection. In particular, DNA viruses that need to commandeer their host's cellular synthetic functions to produce their progeny can induce the condensation and margination of host chromatin during productive infection, a phenomenon known as virus-induced reorganization of cellular chromatin (ROCC). These ROCC-inducing DNA viruses belong to 5 families (herpesviruses, baculoviruses, adenoviruses, parvoviruses, and geminiviruses) that infect a wide range of hosts and are important for human and ecosystem health, as well as for biotechnology. Although the study of virus-induced ROCC is in its infancy, investigations are already raising important questions, such as why only some DNA viruses that replicate their genomes in the nucleus elicit ROCC. Studying the shared and distinct properties of ROCC-inducing viruses will provide valuable insights into viral reorganization of host chromatin that could have implications for future therapies that target the viral life cycle.

Deletion of the CTRL2 Insulator in HSV-1 Results in the Decreased Expression of Genes Involved in Axonal Transport and Attenuates Reactivation In Vivo

HSV-1 is a human pathogen that establishes a lifelong infection in the host. HSV-1 is transported by retrograde axonal transport to sensory neurons in the peripheral nervous system where latent viral genomes can reactivate. The resulting virus travels via anterograde axonal transport to the periphery and can cause clinical disease. CTCF insulators flank the LAT and IE regions of HSV-1 and during latency and maintain the integrity of transcriptional domains through a myriad of functions, including enhancer-blocking or barrier-insulator functions. Importantly, during reactivation, CTCF protein is evicted from the HSV-1 genome, especially from the CTRL2 insulator. CTRL2 is a functional insulator downstream of the 5′exon region of the LAT, so these results suggest that the disruption of this insulator may be required for efficient HSV-1 reactivation. To further explore this, we used a recombinant virus containing a deletion of the CTRL2 insulator (ΔCTRL2) in a rabbit ocular model of HSV-1 infection and induced reactivation. We show that, in the absence of the CTRL2 insulator, HSV-1 established an equivalent latent infection in rabbits, but those rabbits failed to efficiently reactivate from latency. Furthermore, we found a significant decrease in the expression of the gene Us9-, a gene that codes for a type II membrane protein that has been shown to be required for anterograde transport in neurons. Taken together, these results suggest that the functions of the CTRL2 insulator and Us9 activation in reactivating neurons are intrinsically linked through the regulation of a gene responsible for the axonal transport of HSV-1 to the periphery.

Local Immune Control of Latent Herpes Simplex Virus Type 1 in Ganglia of Mice and Man

Herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) is a prevalent human pathogen. HSV-1 genomes persist in trigeminal ganglia neuronal nuclei as chromatinized episomes, while epithelial cells are typically killed by lytic infection. Fluctuations in anti-viral responses, broadly defined, may underlay periodic reactivations. The ganglionic immune response to HSV-1 infection includes cell-intrinsic responses in neurons, innate sensing by several cell types, and the infiltration and persistence of antigen-specific T-cells. The mechanisms specifying the contrasting fates of HSV-1 in neurons and epithelial cells may include differential genome silencing and chromatinization, dictated by variation in access of immune modulating viral tegument proteins to the cell body, and protection of neurons by autophagy. Innate responses have the capacity of recruiting additional immune cells and paracrine activity on parenchymal cells, for example via chemokines and type I interferons. In both mice and humans, HSV-1-specific CD8 and CD4 T-cells are recruited to ganglia, with mechanistic studies suggesting active roles in immune surveillance and control of reactivation. In this review we focus mainly on HSV-1 and the TG, comparing and contrasting where possible observational, interventional, and in vitro studies between humans and animal hosts.

Cohesin subunit Rad21 binds to the HSV-1 genome near CTCF insulator sites during latency in vivo

Herpes Simplex Virus 1 (HSV-1) is a human pathogen that has the ability to establish a lifelong infection in the host. During latency, HSV-1 genomes are chromatinized and are abundantly associated with histones in sensory neurons, yet the mechanisms that govern the latent-lytic transition remain unclear. We hypothesize that the latent-lytic switch is controlled by CTCF insulators, positioned within the HSV-1 latent genome. CTCF insulators, together with the cohesin complex, have the ability to establish and maintain chromtin loops that allow distance separated gene regions to be spatially oriented for transcriptional control. In this current study, we demonstrated that the cohesin subunit Rad21 was recruited to latent HSV-1 genomes near four of the CTCF insulators during latency. We showed that the CTCF insulator known as CTRS1/2, positioned downstream from the essential transactivating IE region of ICP4 was only enriched in Rad21 prior to but not during latency, suggesting that the CTRS1/2 insulator is not required for the maintenance of latency. Further, deletion of the CTRL2 insulator, positioned downstream from the LAT enhancer, resulted in a loss of Rad21 enrichment at insulators flanking the ICP4 region at early times post-infection in mice ganglia, suggesting that these insulators are interdependent. Finally, deletion of the CTRL2 insulator resulted in a loss of Rad21 enrichment at the CTRL2 insulator in a cell-type specific manner, and this loss of Rad21 enrichment was correlated to decreased LAT expression, suggesting that Rad21 recruitment to viral genomes is important for efficient gene expression.ImportanceCTCF insulators are important for transcriptional control and increasing evidence suggests that that CTCF insulators, together with the cohesin complex, regulate viral transcription in DNA viruses. The CTCF-cohesin interaction is important for the formation of chromatin loops, structures that orient distance separated elements in close spatial proximity for transcriptional control. Herpes Simplex Virus 1 (HSV-1) has seven putative CTCF insulators that flank the LAT and the IE, indicating that CTCF insulators play a role in the transition from latency to reactivation. Contributions from the work presented here include the finding that CTCF insulators in HSV-1 genomes are differentially enriched in the cohesin subunit Rad21, suggesting that CTCF-cohesin interactions could be establishing and anchoring chromatin loop structures to control viral transcription.

The CCCTC Binding Factor, CTRL2, Modulates Heterochromatin Deposition and the Establishment of Herpes Simplex Virus 1 Latency In Vivo

The cellular insulator protein CTCF plays a role in herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) latency through the establishment and regulation of chromatin boundaries. We previously found that the CTRL2 regulatory element downstream from the latency-associated transcript (LAT) enhancer was bound by CTCF during latency and underwent CTCF eviction at early times postreactivation in mice latently infected with 17syn+ virus. We also showed that CTRL2 was a functional enhancer-blocking insulator in both epithelial and neuronal cell lines. We hypothesized that CTRL2 played a direct role in silencing lytic gene expression during the establishment of HSV-1 latency. To test this hypothesis, we used a recombinant virus with a 135-bp deletion spanning only the core CTRL2 insulator domain (ΔCTRL2) in the 17syn+ background. Deletion of CTRL2 resulted in restricted viral replication in epithelial cells but not neuronal cells. Following ocular infection, mouse survival decreased in the ΔCTRL2-infected cohort, and we found a significant decrease in the number of viral genomes in mouse trigeminal ganglia (TG) infected with ΔCTRL2, indicating that the CTRL2 insulator was required for the efficient establishment of latency. Immediate early (IE) gene expression significantly increased in the number of ganglia infected with ΔCTRL2 by 31 days postinfection relative to the level with 17syn+ infection, indicating that deletion of the CTRL2 insulator disrupted the organization of chromatin domains during HSV-1 latency. Finally, chromatin immunoprecipitation with high-throughput sequencing (ChIP-seq) analyses of TG from ΔCTRL2-infected mice confirmed that the distribution of the repressive H3K27me3 (histone H3 trimethylated at K27) mark on the ΔCTRL2 recombinant genomes was altered compared to that of the wild type, indicating that the CTRL2 site modulates the repression of IE genes during latency.IMPORTANCE It is becoming increasingly clear that chromatin insulators play a key role in the transcriptional control of DNA viruses. The gammaherpesviruses Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) and Kaposi's sarcoma-associated herpesvirus (KSHV) utilize chromatin insulators to order protein recruitment and dictate the formation of three-dimensional DNA loops that spatially control transcription and latency. The contribution of chromatin insulators in alphaherpesvirus transcriptional control is less well understood. The work presented here begins to bridge that gap in knowledge by showing how one insulator site in HSV-1 modulates lytic gene transcription and heterochromatin deposition as the HSV-1 genome establishes latency.

CTCF Binding Sites in the Herpes Simplex Virus 1 Genome Display Site-Specific CTCF Occupation, Protein Recruitment, and Insulator Function

There are seven conserved CTCF binding domains in the herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) genome. These binding sites individually flank the latency-associated transcript (LAT) and the immediate early (IE) gene regions, suggesting that CTCF insulators differentially control transcriptional domains in HSV-1 latency. In this work, we show that two CTCF binding motifs in HSV-1 display enhancer blocking in a cell-type-specific manner. We found that CTCF binding to the latent HSV-1 genome was LAT dependent and that the quantity of bound CTCF was site specific. Following reactivation, CTCF eviction was dynamic, suggesting that each CTCF site was independently regulated. We explored whether CTCF sites recruit the polycomb-repressive complex 2 (PRC2) to establish repressive domains through a CTCF-Suz12 interaction and found that Suz12 colocalized to the CTCF insulators flanking the ICP0 and ICP4 regions and, conversely, was removed at early times postreactivation. Collectively, these data support the idea that CTCF sites in HSV-1 are independently regulated and may contribute to lytic-latent HSV-1 control in a site-specific manner.IMPORTANCE The role of chromatin insulators in DNA viruses is an area of interest. It has been shown in several beta- and gammaherpesviruses that insulators likely control the lytic transcriptional profile through protein recruitment and through the formation of three-dimensional (3D) chromatin loops. The ability of insulators to regulate alphaherpesviruses has been understudied to date. The alphaherpesvirus HSV-1 has seven conserved insulator binding motifs that flank regions of the genome known to contribute to the establishment of latency. Our work presented here contributes to the understanding of how insulators control transcription of HSV-1.

Timing Is Everything

N. Drayman et al. in their recent article (mBio 8:e01612-17, 2017, https://doi.org/10.1128/mBio.01612-17) have used dynamic proteomics and machine learning to show that the cell cycle state of any individual cell affects the outcome of a productive herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1) infection. Cells infected from early G₁ through S were most permissive for expression of genes from the HSV-1 genome, whereas cells infected in late G₂ to mitosis were much less so. Most of the infected cells that underwent mitosis became permanently nonpermissive for HSV-1 gene expression afterward. The cell cycle stage accounted for 60% of the success of infection, and cell density and motility accounted for most of the rest. To successfully reactivate, HSV-1 must express its genes in neurons and cells of the spinosum and granulosum epidermis strata. These cells are permanently in the cell cycle stages most permissive for HSV-1 gene expression, and none reenters mitosis, thus maximizing the efficiency of a successful HSV-1 reactivation before the adaptive immunity can control it.

Human Antiviral Protein IFIX Suppresses Viral Gene Expression during Herpes Simplex Virus 1 (HSV-1) Infection and Is Counteracted by Virus-induced Proteasomal Degradation

The interferon-inducible protein X (IFIX), a member of the PYHIN family, was recently recognized as an antiviral factor against infection with herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1). IFIX binds viral DNA upon infection and promotes expression of antiviral cytokines. How IFIX exerts its host defense functions and whether it is inhibited by the virus remain unknown. Here, we integrated live cell microscopy, proteomics, IFIX domain characterization, and molecular virology to investigate IFIX regulation and antiviral functions during HSV-1 infection. We find that IFIX has a dynamic localization during infection that changes from diffuse nuclear and nucleoli distribution in uninfected cells to discrete nuclear puncta early in infection. This is rapidly followed by a reduction in IFIX protein levels. Indeed, using immunoaffinity purification and mass spectrometry, we define IFIX interactions during HSV-1 infection, finding an association with a proteasome subunit and proteins involved in ubiquitin-proteasome processes. Using synchronized HSV-1 infection, microscopy, and proteasome-inhibition experiments, we demonstrate that IFIX co-localizes with nuclear proteasome puncta shortly after 3 h of infection and that its pyrin domain is rapidly degraded in a proteasome-dependent manner. We further demonstrate that, in contrast to several other host defense factors, IFIX degradation is not dependent on the E3 ubiquitin ligase activity of the viral protein ICP0. However, we show IFIX degradation requires immediate-early viral gene expression, suggesting a viral host suppression mechanism. The IFIX interactome also demonstrated its association with transcriptional regulatory proteins, including the 5FMC complex. We validate this interaction using microscopy and reciprocal isolations and determine it is mediated by the IFIX HIN domain. Finally, we show IFIX suppresses immediate-early and early viral gene expression during infection. Altogether, our study demonstrates that IFIX antiviral functions work in part via viral transcriptional suppression and that HSV-1 has acquired mechanisms to block its functions via proteasome-dependent degradation.