Distinct Chemotaxis Protein Paralogs Assemble into Chemoreceptor Signaling Arrays To Coordinate Signaling Output

Chemosensory systems interact to shape relevant traits for bacterial plant pathogenesis

Chemosensory systems allow bacteria to respond and adapt to environmental conditions. Many bacteria contain more than one chemosensory system, but knowledge of their specific roles in regulating different functions remains scarce. Here, we address this issue by analyzing the function of the F6, F8, and alternative (non-motility) cellular functions (ACF) chemosensory systems of the model plant pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato. In this work, we assign PsPto chemoreceptors to each chemosensory system, and we visualize for the first time the F6 and F8 chemosensory systems of PsPto using cryo-electron tomography. We confirm that chemotaxis and swimming motility are controlled by the F6 system, and we demonstrate how different components from the F8 and ACF systems also modulate swimming motility. We also determine how the kinase and response regulators from the F6 and F8 chemosensory systems do not work together in the regulation of biofilm, whereas both components from the ACF system contribute together to regulate these traits. Furthermore, we show how the F6, F8, and ACF kinases interact with the ACF response regulator WspR, supporting crosstalk among chemosensory systems. Finally, we reveal how all chemosensory systems play a role in regulating virulence.

IMPORTANCE

Chemoperception through chemosensory systems is an essential feature for bacterial survival, as it allows bacterial interaction with its surrounding environment. In the case of plant pathogens, it is especially relevant to enter the host and achieve full virulence. Multiple chemosensory systems allow bacteria to display a wider plasticity in their response to external signals. Here, we perform a deep characterization of the F6, F8, and alternative (non-motility) cellular functions chemosensory systems in the model plant pathogen Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato DC3000. These chemosensory systems regulate key virulence-related traits, like motility and biofilm formation. Furthermore, we unveil an unexpected crosstalk among these chemosensory systems at the level of the interaction between kinases and response regulators. This work shows novel results that contribute to the knowledge of chemosensory systems and their role in functions alternative to chemotaxis.

An Azospirillum brasilense chemoreceptor that mediates nitrate chemotaxis has conditional roles in the colonization of plant roots

Motile plant-associated bacteria use chemotaxis and dedicated chemoreceptors to navigate gradients in their surroundings and to colonize host plant surfaces. Here, we characterize a chemoreceptor that we named Tlp2 in the soil alphaproteobacterium Azospirillum brasilense. We show that the Tlp2 ligand-binding domain is related to the 4-helix bundle family and is conserved in chemoreceptors found in the genomes of many soil- and sediment-dwelling alphaproteobacteria. The promoter of tlp2 is regulated in an NtrC- and RpoN-dependent manner and is most upregulated under conditions of nitrogen fixation or in the presence of nitrate. Using fluorescently tagged Tlp2 (Tlp2-YFP), we show that this chemoreceptor is present in low abundance in chemotaxis-signaling clusters and is prone to degradation. We also obtained evidence that the presence of ammonium rapidly disrupts Tlp2-YFP localization. Behavioral experiments using a strain lacking Tlp2 and variants of Tlp2 lacking conserved arginine residues suggest that Tlp2 mediates chemotaxis in gradients of nitrate and nitrite, with the R159 residue being essential for Tlp2 function. We also provide evidence that Tlp2 is essential for root surface colonization of some plants (teff, red clover, and cowpea) but not others (wheat, sorghum, alfalfa, and pea). These results highlight the selective role of nitrate sensing and chemotaxis in plant root surface colonization and illustrate the relative contribution of chemoreceptors to chemotaxis and root surface colonization.IMPORTANCEBacterial chemotaxis mediates host-microbe associations, including the association of beneficial bacteria with the roots of host plants. Dedicated chemoreceptors specify sensory preferences during chemotaxis. Here, we show that a chemoreceptor mediating chemotaxis to nitrate is important in the beneficial soil bacterium colonization of some but not all plant hosts tested. Nitrate is the preferred nitrogen source for plant nutrition, and plants sense and tightly control nitrate transport, resulting in varying nitrate uptake rates depending on the plant and its physiological state. Nitrate is thus a limiting nutrient in the rhizosphere. Chemotaxis and dedicated chemoreceptors for nitrate likely provide motile bacteria with a competitive advantage to access this nutrient in the rhizosphere.

Azospirillum brasilense AerC and Tlp4b Cytoplasmic Chemoreceptors Are Promiscuous and Interact with the Two Membrane-Bound Chemotaxis Signaling Clusters Mediating Chemotaxis Responses

Chemotaxis in Bacteria and Archaea depends on the presence of hexagonal polar arrays composed of membrane-bound chemoreceptors that interact with rings of baseplate signaling proteins. In the alphaproteobacterium Azospirillum brasilense, chemotaxis is controlled by two chemotaxis signaling systems (Che1 and Che4) that mix at the baseplates of two spatially distinct membrane-bound chemoreceptor arrays. The subcellular localization and organization of transmembrane chemoreceptors in chemotaxis signaling clusters have been well characterized but those of soluble chemoreceptors remain relatively underexplored. By combining mutagenesis, microscopy, and biochemical assays, we show that the cytoplasmic chemoreceptors AerC and Tlp4b function in chemotaxis and localize to and interact with membrane-bound chemoreceptors and chemotaxis signaling proteins from both polar arrays, indicating that soluble chemoreceptors are promiscuous. The interactions of AerC and Tlp4b with polar chemotaxis signaling clusters are not equivalent and suggest distinct functions. Tlp4b, but not AerC, modulates the abundance of chemoreceptors within the signaling clusters through an unknown mechanism. The AerC chemoreceptor, but not Tlp4b, is able to traffic in and out of chemotaxis signaling clusters depending on its level of expression. We also identify a role of the chemoreceptor composition of chemotaxis signaling clusters in regulating their polar subcellular organization. The organization of chemotaxis signaling proteins as large membrane-bound arrays underlies chemotaxis sensitivity. Our findings suggest that the composition of chemoreceptors may fine-tune chemotaxis signaling not only through their chemosensory specificity but also through their role in the organization of polar chemotaxis signaling clusters. IMPORTANCE Cytoplasmic chemoreceptors represent about 14% of all chemoreceptors encoded in bacterial and archaeal genomes, but little is known about how they interact with and function in large polar assemblies of membrane-bound chemotaxis signaling clusters. Here, we show that two soluble chemoreceptors with a role in chemotaxis are promiscuous and interact with two distinct membrane-bound chemotaxis signaling clusters that control all chemotaxis responses in Azospirillum brasilense. We also found that any change in the chemoreceptor composition of chemotaxis signaling clusters alters their polar organization, suggesting a dynamic interplay between the sensory specificity of chemotaxis signaling clusters and their polar membrane organization.

Studying bacterial chemosensory array with CryoEM

Bacteria direct their movement in respond to gradients of nutrients and other stimuli in the environment through the chemosensory system. The behavior is mediated by chemosensory arrays that are made up of thousands of proteins to form an organized array near the cell pole. In this review, we briefly introduce the architecture and function of the chemosensory array and its core signaling unit. We describe the in vivo and in vitro systems that have been used for structural studies of chemosensory array by cryoEM, including reconstituted lipid nanodiscs, 2D lipid monolayer arrays, lysed bacterial ghosts, bacterial minicells and native bacteria cells. Lastly, we review recent advances in structural analysis of chemosensory arrays using state-of-the-art cryoEM and cryoET methodologies, focusing on the latest developments and insights with a perspective on current challenges and future directions.

Multiple CheY Proteins Control Surface-Associated Lifestyles of Azospirillum brasilense

Bacterial chemotaxis is the directed movement of motile bacteria in gradients of chemoeffectors. This behavior is mediated by dedicated signal transduction pathways that couple environment sensing with changes in the direction of rotation of flagellar motors to ultimately affect the motility pattern. Azospirillum brasilense uses two distinct chemotaxis pathways, named Che1 and Che4, and four different response regulators (CheY1, CheY4, CheY6, and CheY7) to control the swimming pattern during chemotaxis. Each of the CheY homologs was shown to differentially affect the rotational bias of the polar flagellum and chemotaxis. The role, if any, of these CheY homologs in swarming, which depends on a distinct lateral flagella system or in attachment is not known. Here, we characterize CheY homologs’ roles in swimming, swarming, and attachment to abiotic and biotic (wheat roots) surfaces and biofilm formation. We show that while strains lacking CheY1 and CheY6 are still able to navigate air gradients, strains lacking CheY4 and CheY7 are chemotaxis null. Expansion of swarming colonies in the presence of gradients requires chemotaxis. The induction of swarming depends on CheY4 and CheY7, but the cells’ organization as dense clusters in productive swarms appear to depend on functional CheYs but not chemotaxis per se. Similarly, functional CheY homologs but not chemotaxis, contribute to attachment to both abiotic and root surfaces as well as to biofilm formation, although these effects are likely dependent on additional cell surface properties such as adhesiveness. Collectively, our data highlight distinct roles for multiple CheY homologs and for chemotaxis on swarming and attachment to surfaces.

Diversity of bacterial chemosensory systems

Chemosensory system is the most complex, specialized mode of signal transduction in bacteria and archaea. It is composed of several core and auxiliary protein components that are highly organized in order to deliver a fast response to changing environmental conditions. Chemosensory pathways were studied in-depth in a handful of model organisms and experimentally characterized at least to some degree in approximately thirty other species. However, genome-wide analyses have revealed their presence in thousands of sequenced microbial genomes. Both experimental and computational studies uncovered substantial diversity in system design, functional regulation, cellular localization and phyletic distribution of chemosensory pathways. Here, we summarize advances and expose gaps in our current understanding of the diversity of chemosensory systems.

The Azospirillum brasilense Core Chemotaxis Proteins CheA1 and CheA4 Link Chemotaxis Signaling with Nitrogen Metabolism

Bacterial chemotaxis affords motile bacteria the ability to navigate the environment to locate niches for growth and survival. At the molecular level, chemotaxis depends on chemoreceptor signaling arrays that interact with cytoplasmic proteins to control the direction of movement. In Azospirillum brasilense, chemotaxis is mediated by two distinct chemotaxis pathways: Che1 and Che4. Both Che1 and Che4 are critical in the A. brasilense free-living and plant-associated lifestyles. Here, we use whole-cell proteomics and metabolomics to characterize the role of chemotaxis in A. brasilense physiology. We found that mutants lacking CheA1 or CheA4 or both are affected in nonchemotaxis functions, including major changes in transcription, signaling transport, and cell metabolism. We identify specific effects of CheA1 and CheA4 on nitrogen metabolism, including nitrate assimilation and nitrogen fixation, that may depend, at least, on the transcriptional control of rpoN, which encodes RpoN, a global regulator of metabolism, including nitrogen. Consistent with proteomics, the abundance of several nitrogenous compounds (purines, pyrimidines, and amino acids) changed in the metabolomes of the chemotaxis mutants relative to the parental strain. Further, we uncover novel, and yet uncharacterized, layers of transcriptional and posttranscriptional control of nitrogen metabolism regulators. Together, our data reveal roles for CheA1 and CheA4 in linking chemotaxis and nitrogen metabolism, likely through control of global regulatory networks.

IMPORTANCE Bacterial chemotaxis is widespread in bacteria, increasing competitiveness in diverse environments and mediating associations with eukaryotic hosts ranging from commensal to beneficial and pathogenic. In most bacteria, chemotaxis signaling is tightly linked to energy metabolism, with this coupling occurring through the sensory input of several energy-sensing chemoreceptors. Here, we show that in A. brasilense the chemotaxis proteins have key roles in modulating nitrogen metabolism, including nitrate assimilation and nitrogen fixation, through novel and yet unknown regulations. These results are significant given that A. brasilense is a model bacterium for plant growth promotion and free-living nitrogen fixation and is used as a bio-inoculant for cereal crops. Chemotaxis signaling in A. brasilense thus links locomotor behaviors to nitrogen metabolism, allowing cells to continuously and reciprocally adjust metabolism and chemotaxis signaling as they navigate gradients.

Spatiotemporal Organization of Chemotaxis Pathways in Magnetospirillum gryphiswaldense

Magnetospirillum gryphiswaldense employs iron-rich nanoparticles for magnetic navigation within environmental redox gradients. This behavior termed magneto-aerotaxis was previously shown to rely on the sensory pathway CheOp1, but the precise localization of CheOp1-related chemoreceptor arrays during the cell cycle and its possible interconnection with three other chemotaxis pathways have remained unstudied. Here, we analyzed the localization of chemoreceptor-associated adaptor protein CheW₁ and histidine kinase CheA₁ by superresolution microscopy in a spatiotemporal manner. CheW₁ localized in dynamic clusters that undergo occasional segregation and fusion events at lateral sites of both cell poles. Newly formed smaller clusters originating at midcell before completion of cytokinesis were found to grow in size during the cell cycle. Bipolar CheA₁ localization and formation of aerotactic swim halos were affected depending on the fluorescent protein tag, indicating that CheA₁ localization is important for aerotaxis. Furthermore, polar CheW₁ localization was independent of cheOp2 to cheOp4 but lost in the absence of cheOp1 or cheA₁ Results were corroborated by the detection of a direct protein interaction between CheA₁ and CheW₁ and by the observation that cheOp2- and cheOp3-encoded CheW paralogs localized in spatially distinct smaller clusters at the cell boundary. Although the findings of a minor aerotaxis-related CheOp4 phenotype and weak protein interactions between CheOp1 and CheOp4 by two-hybrid analysis implied that CheW₁ and CheW₄ might be part of the same chemoreceptor array, CheW₄ was localized in spatially distinct polar-lateral arrays independent of CheOp1, suggesting that CheOp1 and CheOp4 are also not connected at the molecular level.IMPORTANCE Magnetotactic bacteria (MTB) use the geomagnetic field for navigation in aquatic redox gradients. However, the highly complex signal transduction networks in these environmental microbes are poorly understood. Here, we analyzed the localization of selected chemotaxis proteins to spatially and temporally resolve chemotaxis array localization in Magnetospirillum gryphiswaldense Our findings suggest that bipolar localization of chemotaxis arrays related to the key signaling pathway CheOp1 is important for aerotaxis and that CheOp1 signaling units assemble independent of the three other chemotaxis pathways present in M. gryphiswaldense Overall, our results provide deeper insights into the complex organization of signaling pathways in MTB and add to the general understanding of environmental bacteria possessing multiple chemotaxis pathways.

Electrolocation? The evidence for redox-mediated taxis in Shewanella oneidensis

Shewanella oneidensis is a dissimilatory metal reducing bacterium and model for extracellular electron transfer (EET), a respiratory mechanism in which electrons are transferred out of the cell. In the last 10 years, migration to insoluble electron acceptors for EET has been shown to be nonrandom and tactic, seemingly in the absence of molecular or energy gradients that typically allow for taxis. As the ability to sense, locate, and respire electrodes has applications in bioelectrochemical technology, a better understanding of taxis in S. oneidensis is needed. While the EET conduits of S. oneidensis have been studied extensively, its taxis pathways and their interplay with EET are not yet understood, making investigation into taxis phenomena nontrivial. Since S. oneidensis is a member of an EET-encoding clade, the genetic circuitry of taxis to insoluble acceptors may be conserved. We performed a bioinformatic analysis of Shewanella genomes to identify S. oneidensis chemotaxis orthologs conserved in the genus. In addition to the previously reported core chemotaxis gene cluster, we identify several other conserved proteins in the taxis signaling pathway. We present the current evidence for the two proposed models of EET taxis, "electrokinesis" and flavin-mediated taxis, and highlight key areas in need of further investigation.

Specific Root Exudate Compounds Sensed by Dedicated Chemoreceptors Shape Azospirillum brasilense Chemotaxis in the Rhizosphere

Plant roots shape the rhizosphere community by secreting compounds that recruit diverse bacteria. Colonization of various plant roots by the motile alphaproteobacterium Azospirillum brasilens e causes increased plant growth, root volume, and crop yield. Bacterial chemotaxis in this and other motile soil bacteria is critical for competitive colonization of the root surfaces. The role of chemotaxis in root surface colonization has previously been established by endpoint analyses of bacterial colonization levels detected a few hours to days after inoculation. More recently, microfluidic devices have been used to study plant-microbe interactions, but these devices are size limited. Here, we use a novel slide-in chamber that allows real-time monitoring of plant-microbe interactions using agriculturally relevant seedlings to characterize how bacterial chemotaxis mediates plant root surface colonization during the association of A. brasilens e with Triticum aestivum (wheat) and Medicago sativa (alfalfa) seedlings. We track A. brasilense accumulation in the rhizosphere and on the root surfaces of wheat and alfalfa. A. brasilense motile cells display distinct chemotaxis behaviors in different regions of the roots, including attractant and repellent responses that ultimately drive surface colonization patterns. We also combine these observations with real-time analyses of behaviors of wild-type and mutant strains to link chemotaxis responses to distinct chemicals identified in root exudates to specific chemoreceptors that together explain the chemotactic response of motile cells in different regions of the roots. Furthermore, the bacterial second messenger c-di-GMP modulates these chemotaxis responses. Together, these findings illustrate dynamic bacterial chemotaxis responses to rhizosphere gradients that guide root surface colonization.IMPORTANCE Plant root exudates play critical roles in shaping rhizosphere microbial communities, and the ability of motile bacteria to respond to these gradients mediates competitive colonization of root surfaces. Root exudates are complex chemical mixtures that are spatially and temporally dynamic. Identifying the exact chemical(s) that mediates the recruitment of soil bacteria to specific regions of the roots is thus challenging. Here, we connect patterns of bacterial chemotaxis responses and sensing by chemoreceptors to chemicals found in root exudate gradients and identify key chemical signals that shape root surface colonization in different plants and regions of the roots.