Characterization of the interaction between the nuclease and reverse transcriptase activity of the yeast telomerase complex

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae Hrq1 and Pif1 DNA helicases synergistically modulate telomerase activity in vitro

Telomere length homeostasis is vital for maintaining genomic stability and is regulated by multiple factors, including telomerase activity and DNA helicases. The Saccharomyces cerevisiae Pif1 helicase was the first discovered catalytic inhibitor of telomerase, but recent experimental evidence suggests that Hrq1, the yeast homolog of the disease-linked human RecQ-like helicase 4 (RECQL4), plays a similar role via an undefined mechanism. Using yeast extracts enriched for telomerase activity and an in vitro primer extension assay, here we determined the effects of recombinant WT and inactive Hrq1 and Pif1 on total telomerase activity and telomerase processivity. We found that titrations of these helicases alone have equal-but-opposite biphasic effects on telomerase, with Hrq1 stimulating activity at high concentrations. When the helicases were combined in reactions, however, they synergistically inhibited or stimulated telomerase activity depending on which helicase was catalytically active. These results suggest that Hrq1 and Pif1 interact and that their concerted activities ensure proper telomere length homeostasis in vivo We propose a model in which Hrq1 and Pif1 cooperatively contribute to telomere length homeostasis in yeast.

Telomere lengthening and other functions of telomerase

Telomerase is an enzyme that maintains the length of the telomere. The telomere length specifies the number of divisions a cell can undergo before it finally dies (i.e. the proliferative potential of cells). For example, telomerase is activated in embryonic cell lines and the telomere length is maintained at a constant level; therefore, these cells have an unlimited fission potential. Stem cells are characterized by a lower telomerase activity, which enables only partial compensation for the shortening of telomeres. Somatic cells are usually characterized by the absence of telomerase activity. Telomere shortening leads to the attainment of the Hayflick limit, the transition of cells to a state of senescence. The cells subsequently enter a state of crisis, accompanied by massive cell death. The surviving cells become cancer cells, which are capable both of dividing indefinitely and maintaining telomere length (usually with the aid of telomerase). Telomerase is a reverse transcriptase. It consists of two major components: telomerase RNA (TER) and reverse transcriptase (TERT). TER is a non-coding RNA, and it contains the region which serves as a template for telomere synthesis. An increasing number of articles focussing on the alternative functions of telomerase components have recently started appearing. The present review summarizes data on the structure, biogenesis, and functions of telomerase.

Similarities between long interspersed element-1 (LINE-1) reverse transcriptase and telomerase

Long interspersed element-1 (LINE-1 or L1) retrotransposons encode two proteins (ORF1p and ORF2p) that contain activities required for conventional retrotransposition by a mechanism termed target-site primed reverse transcription. Previous experiments in XRCC4 or DNA protein kinase catalytic subunit-deficient CHO cell lines, which are defective for the nonhomologous end-joining DNA repair pathway, revealed an alternative endonuclease-independent (ENi) pathway for L1 retrotransposition. Interestingly, some ENi retrotransposition events in DNA protein kinase catalytic subunit-deficient cells are targeted to dysfunctional telomeres. Here we used an in vitro assay to detect L1 reverse transcriptase activity to demonstrate that wild-type or endonuclease-defective L1 ribonucleoprotein particles can use oligonucleotide adapters that mimic telomeric ends as primers to initiate the reverse transcription of L1 mRNA. Importantly, these ribonucleoprotein particles also contain a nuclease activity that can process the oligonucleotide adapters before the initiation of reverse transcription. Finally, we demonstrate that ORF1p is not strictly required for ENi retrotransposition at dysfunctional telomeres. Thus, these data further highlight similarities between the mechanism of ENi L1 retrotransposition and telomerase.

Telomerase: structure, functions, and activity regulation

Telomerase is the enzyme responsible for maintenance of the length of telomeres by addition of guanine-rich repetitive sequences. Telomerase activity is exhibited in gametes and stem and tumor cells. In human somatic cells proliferation potential is strictly limited and senescence follows approximately 50-70 cell divisions. In most tumor cells, on the contrary, replication potential is unlimited. The key role in this process of the system of the telomere length maintenance with involvement of telomerase is still poorly studied. No doubt, DNA polymerase is not capable to completely copy DNA at the very ends of chromosomes; therefore, approximately 50 nucleotides are lost during each cell cycle, which results in gradual telomere length shortening. Critically short telomeres cause senescence, following crisis, and cell death. However, in tumor cells the system of telomere length maintenance is activated. Besides catalytic telomere elongation, independent telomerase functions can be also involved in cell cycle regulation. Inhibition of the telomerase catalytic function and resulting cessation of telomere length maintenance will help in restriction of tumor cell replication potential. On the other hand, formation of temporarily active enzyme via its intracellular activation or due to stimulation of expression of telomerase components will result in telomerase activation and telomere elongation that can be used for correction of degenerative changes. Data on telomerase structure and function are summarized in this review, and they are compared for evolutionarily remote organisms. Problems of telomerase activity measurement and modulation by enzyme inhibitors or activators are considered as well.

The conserved Est1 protein stimulates telomerase DNA extension activity

The first telomerase cofactor identified was the budding yeast protein Est1, which is conserved through humans. While it is evident that Est1 is required for telomere DNA maintenance, understanding its mechanistic contributions to telomerase regulation has been limited. In vitro, the primary effect of Est1 is to activate telomerase-mediated DNA extension. Although Est1 displayed specific DNA and RNA binding, neither activity contributed significantly to telomerase stimulation. Rather Est1 mediated telomerase upregulation through direct contacts with the reverse transcriptase subunit. In addition to intrinsic Est1 functions, we found that Est1 cooperatively activated telomerase in conjunction with Cdc13 and that the combinatorial effect was dependent upon a known salt-bridge interaction between Est1 (K444) and Cdc13 (E252). Our studies provide insights into the molecular events used to control the enzymatic activity of the telomerase holoenzyme.

The MRT-1 nuclease is required for DNA crosslink repair and telomerase activity in vivo in Caenorhabditis elegans

The telomerase reverse transcriptase adds de novo DNA repeats to chromosome termini. Here we define Caenorhabditis elegans MRT-1 as a novel factor required for telomerase-mediated telomere replication and the DNA-damage response. MRT-1 is composed of an N-terminal domain homologous to the second OB-fold of POT1 telomere-binding proteins and a C-terminal SNM1 family nuclease domain, which confer single-strand DNA-binding and processive 3'-to-5' exonuclease activity, respectively. Furthermore, telomerase activity in vivo depends on a functional MRT-1 OB-fold. We show that MRT-1 acts in the same telomere replication pathway as telomerase and the 9-1-1 DNA-damage response complex. MRT-1 is dispensable for DNA double-strand break repair, but functions with the 9-1-1 complex to promote DNA interstrand cross-link (ICL) repair. Our data reveal MRT-1 as a dual-domain protein required for telomerase function and ICL repair, which raises the possibility that telomeres and ICL lesions may share a common feature that plays a critical role in de novo telomere repeat addition.

Structures of telomerase subunits provide functional insights

BACKGROUND

Telomerase continues to generate substantial attention both because of its pivotal roles in cellular proliferation and aging and because of its unusual structure and mechanism. By replenishing telomeric DNA lost during the cell cycle, telomerase overcomes one of the many hurdles facing cellular immortalization. Functionally, telomerase is a reverse transcriptase, and it shares structural and mechanistic features with this class of nucleotide polymerases. Telomerase is a very unusual reverse transcriptase because it remains stably associated with its template and because it reverse transcribes multiple copies of its template onto a single primer in one reaction cycle.

SCOPE OF REVIEW

Here, we review recent findings that illuminate our understanding of telomerase. Even though the specific emphasis is on structure and mechanism, we also highlight new insights into the roles of telomerase in human biology.

GENERAL SIGNIFICANCE

Recent advances in the structural biology of telomerase, including high resolution structures of the catalytic subunit of a beetle telomerase and two domains of a ciliate telomerase catalytic subunit, provide new perspectives into telomerase biochemistry and reveal new puzzles.

The Hsp82 molecular chaperone promotes a switch between unextendable and extendable telomere states

Distinct protein assemblies are nucleated at telomeric DNA to both guard the ends from damage and lengthen the DNA following replication. In yeast, Cdc13 recruits either Stn1/Ten1 to form a protective cap or the telomerase holoenzyme to extend the DNA. We have established an in vitro yeast telomere system in which Stn1/Ten1-unextendable or telomerase-extendable states can be observed. Both assemblies are Cdc13-dependent, as the Cdc13 C-terminal region supports Stn1/Ten1 interactions and the N-terminal region contains a telomerase activation function. Notably, the yeast Hsp90 chaperone Hsp82 mediates the switch between the telomere capping and extending structures by modulating the DNA binding activity of Cdc13. Taken together, our data demonstrate that the Hsp82 chaperone facilitates telomere DNA maintenance by promoting transitions between different operative complexes and by reducing the potential for binding events that would otherwise block the assembly of downstream structures.

The structure and function of telomerase reverse transcriptase

The structure and integrity of telomeres are essential for genome stability. Telomere dysregulation can lead to cell death, cell senescence, or abnormal cell proliferation. The maintenance of telomere repeats in most eukaryotic organisms requires telomerase, which consists of a reverse transcriptase (RT) and an RNA template that dictates the synthesis of the G-rich strand of telomere terminal repeats. Structurally, telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) contains unique and variable N- and C-terminal extensions that flank a central RT-like domain. The enzymology of telomerase includes features that are both similar to and distinct from those characteristic of other RTs. Two distinguishing features of TERT are its stable association with the telomerase RNA and its ability to repetitively reverse transcribe the template segment of RNA. Here we discuss TERT structure and function; its regulation by RNA-DNA, TERT-DNA, TERT-RNA, TERT-TERT interactions, and TERT-associated proteins; and the relationship between telomerase enzymology and telomere maintenance.

Saccharomyces cerevisiaetelomerase subunit Est3p binds DNA and RNA and stimulates unwinding of RNA/DNA heteroduplexes

Telomerase is a key participant of telomere length maintenance system in majority of eukaryotes. It synthesizes telomere repeats at 3'-end of telomere DNA according to its own RNA template. In addition to the reverse transcriptase subunit Est2p and telomerase RNA TLC1, yeast telomerase contain Est1p, necessary for telomerase attachment to telomere and telomerase activation, and Est3p, a subunit with unknown function. We have isolated Est3p and examined its biochemical properties. Est3p binds both DNA and RNA oligonucleotides containing telomere repeat sequences and stimulates dissociation of RNA/DNA heteroduplexes. The importance of these properties of Est3p for telomerase function is discussed.

Chromosome healing byde novotelomere addition inSaccharomyces cerevisiae

The repair of spontaneous or induced DNA damage by homologous recombination (HR) in Saccharomyces cerevisiae will suppress chromosome rearrangements. Alternative chromosome healing pathways can result in chromosomal instability. One of these pathways is de novo telomere addition where the end of a broken chromosome is stabilized by telomerase-dependent addition of telomeres at non-telomeric sites. De novo telomere addition requires the recruitment of telomerase to chromosomal targets. Subsequently, annealing of the telomerase reverse transcriptase RNA-template (guide RNA) at short regions of homology is followed by extension of the nascent 3'-end of the broken chromosome to copy a short region of the telomerase guide RNA; multiple cycles of this process yield the new telomere. Proteins including Pif1 helicase, the single-stranded DNA-binding protein Cdc13 and the Ku heterocomplex are known to participate in native telomere functions and also regulate the de novo telomere addition reaction. Studies of the sequences added at de novo telomeres have lead to a detailed description of the annealing-extension-dissociation cycles that copy the telomerase guide RNA, which can explain the heterogeneity of telomeric repeats at de novo and native telomeres in S. cerevisiae.

Characterization of recombinant Saccharomyces cerevisiae telomerase core enzyme purified from yeast

Telomerase is a cellular reverse transcriptase that elongates the single-stranded chromosome ends and oligonucleotides in vivo and in vitro. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Est2p (telomerase catalytic subunit) and Tlc1 (telomerase RNA template subunit) constitute the telomerase core complex. We co-overexpressed GST (glutathione S-transferase)-Est2p and Tlc1 in S. cerevisiae, and reconstituted the telomerase activity. The GST-Est2p-Tlc1 complex was partially purified by ammonium sulphate fractionation and affinity chromatography on glutathione beads, and the partially purified telomerase did not contain the other two subunits of the telomerase holoenzyme, Est1p and Est3p. The purified recombinant GST-Est2p-Tlc1 telomerase core complex could specifically add nucleotides on to the single-stranded TG(1-3) primer in a processive manner, but could not translocate to synthesize more than one telomeric repeat. The purified telomerase core complex exhibited different activities when primers were paired with the Tlc1 template at different positions. The procedure of reconstitution and purification of telomerase core enzyme that we have developed now allows for further mechanistic studies of the functions of other subunits of the telomerase holoenzyme as well as other telomerase regulation proteins.

A human telomerase-associated nuclease

Ciliate and yeast telomerase possess a nucleolytic activity capable of removing DNA from the 3' end of a single-stranded oligonucleotide substrate. The nuclease activity is thought to assist in enzyme proofreading and/or processivity. Herein, we report a previously uncharacterized human telomerase-associated nuclease activity that shares several properties with ciliate and yeast telomerases. Partially purified human telomerase, either from cell extracts or recombinantly produced, demonstrated an ability to remove 3' nontelomeric nucleotides from a substrate containing 5' telomeric DNA, followed by extension of the newly exposed telomeric sequence. This cleavage/extension activity was apparent at more than one position within the telomeric DNA and was influenced by sequences 5' to the telomeric/nontelomeric boundary and by substitution with a methylphosphonate moiety at the telomeric/nontelomeric DNA boundary. Our data suggest that human telomerase is associated with an evolutionarily conserved nucleolytic activity and support a model in which telomerase-substrate interactions can occur distal from the 3' primer end.

Human telomerase catalyzes nucleolytic primer cleavage

Telomerase is a reverse transcriptase that uses an integral RNA molecule to add de novo G-rich repeats onto telomeric DNA, or onto nontelomeric DNA generated during chromosome fragmentation and breakage events. A telomerase-mediated DNA substrate cleavage activity has been reported in ciliates and yeasts. Nucleolytic cleavage may serve a proofreading function, enhance processivity or ensure that nontemplate telomerase RNA sequences are not copied into DNA. We identified and characterized a human telomerase-mediated nucleolytic cleavage activity using enzyme reconstituted in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate in vitro transcription/translation system and native enzyme extracted from cells. We found that telomerase catalyzed the removal of nucleotides from DNA substrates including those that can form a mismatch with the RNA template or that contain nontelomeric sequences located 3' to a telomeric sequence. Unlike Tetrahymena telomerase, human telomerase catalyzed the removal of more than one nucleotide (up to 13) from telomeric primers. DNA substrates predicted to align at the 3'-end of the RNA template were not cleaved, consistent with cleavage being dictated by the template 5'-end. We also found some differences in the nuclease activity between RRL-reconstituted human telomerase and native enzyme.

Template requirements for telomerase translocation in Kluyveromyces lactis

Telomeres are synthesized by telomerase, a specialized reverse transcriptase, which contains a template in its intrinsic RNA component. In Kluyveromyces lactis, the repeats synthesized by the wild-type telomerase are 25 nucleotides (nt) in length and uniform in sequence. To determine the role of the 5-nt repeats defining the ends of the K. lactis telomerase RNA template in telomerase translocation, we have made mutations in and around them and observed their effects on telomere length and the sequence of newly made telomeric repeats. These template mutations typically result in telomeres that are shorter than those of wild-type cells. The mismatches between the telomerase template and the telomeric tip that occur after telomerase-mediated incorporation of the mutations are normally not removed. Instead, the mutations lead to the synthesis of aberrant repeats that range in size from 31 to 13 bp. Therefore, the specificity with which the telomeric tip aligns with the telomere is critical for the production of the uniform repeats seen in K. lactis. In addition, the region immediately 3' of the template may play an important role in translocation of the enzyme.

A template-proximal RNA paired element contributes to Saccharomyces cerevisiae telomerase activity

The ribonucleoprotein complex telomerase is critical for replenishing chromosome-end sequence during eukaryotic DNA replication. The template for the addition of telomeric repeats is provided by the RNA component of telomerase. However, in budding yeast, little is known about the structure and function of most of the remainder of the telomerase RNA. Here, we report the identification of a paired element located immediately 5' of the template region in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae telomerase RNA. Mutations disrupting or replacing the helical element showed that this structure, but not its exact nucleotide sequence, is important for telomerase function in vivo and in vitro. Biochemical characterization of a paired element mutant showed that the mutant generated longer products and incorporated noncognate nucleotides. Sequencing of in vivo synthesized telomeres from this mutant showed that DNA synthesis proceeded beyond the normal template. Thus, the S. cerevisiae element resembles a similar element found in Kluyveromyces budding yeasts with respect to a function in template boundary specification. In addition, the in vitro activity of the paired element mutant indicates that the RNA element has additional functions in enzyme processivity and in directing template usage by telomerase.

The C terminus of the human telomerase reverse transcriptase is a determinant of enzyme processivity

The catalytic subunit of telomerase (TERT) contains conserved reverse transcriptase-like motifs but N- and C-terminal regions unique to telomerases. Despite weak sequence conservation, the C terminus of TERTs from various organisms has been implicated in telomerase-specific functions, including telomerase activity, functional multimerization with other TERT molecules, enzyme processivity and telomere length maintenance. We studied hTERT proteins containing small C-terminal deletions or substitutions to identify and characterize hTERT domains mediating telomerase activity, hTERT multimerization and processivity. Using sequence alignment of five vertebrate TERTs and Arabidopsis thaliana TERT, we identified blocks of highly conserved amino acids that were required for human telomerase activity and functional hTERT complementation. We adapted the non-PCR-based telomerase elongation assay to characterize telomerase expressed and reconstituted in the in vitro transcription/translation rabbit reticulocyte lysate system. Using this assay, we found that the hTERT C terminus, like the C terminus of Saccharomyces cerevisiae TERT, contributes to successive nucleotide addition within a single 6-base telomeric repeat (type I processivity). Certain mutations in the hTERT C terminus also reduced the repetitive addition of multiple telomeric repeats (type II processivity). Our results suggest a functionally conserved role for the TERT C terminus in telomerase enzyme processivity.

Biochemical aspects of telomerase function

Arthur Kornberg "never met a dull enzyme" (For the Love of Enzymes: The Odyssey of a Biochemist, Harvard University Press, 1989) and telomerase is no exception. Telomerase is a remarkable polymerase that uses an internal RNA template to reverse-transcribe telomere DNA, one nucleotide at a time, onto telomeric, G-rich single-stranded DNA. In the 17 years since its discovery, the characterization of telomerase enzyme components has uncovered a highly conserved family of telomerase reverse transcriptases that, together with the telomerase RNA, appear to comprise the enzymatic core of telomerase. While not as comprehensively understood as yet, some telomerase-associated proteins also serve crucial roles in telomerase function in vivo, such as telomerase ribonudeoprotein (RNP) assembly, recruitment to the telomere, and the coordination of DNA replication at the telomere. A selected overview of the biochemical properties of this unique enzyme, in vitro and in vivo, will be presented.

Generation of Telomeric G Strand Overhangs Involves Both G and C Strand Cleavage

Processing of telomeric DNA is required to generate the 3' G strand overhangs necessary for capping chromosome ends. We have investigated the steps involved in telomere processing by examining G overhang structure in Tetrahymena cells that lack telomerase or have altered telomeric sequences. We show that overhangs are generated by two precise cleavage steps involving nucleases that are robust but lack sequence specificity. Our data suggest that a G overhang binding protein delineates the boundaries for G and C strand cleavage. We also show that telomerase is not the nuclease responsible for G strand cleavage, although telomerase depletion alters the precision of processing. This change in processing indicates that telomerase affects multiple transactions at the telomere and provides a physical footprint for the continued association of telomerase with the telomere after repeat addition is complete.

Telomere formation on macronuclear chromosomes of Oxytricha trifallax and O. fallax: alternatively processed regions have multiple telomere addition sites

BACKGROUND

Ciliates employ massive chromatid breakage and de novo telomere formation during generation of the somatic macronucleus. Positions flanking the 81-MAC locus are reproducibly cut. But those flanking the Common Region are proposed to often escape cutting, generating three nested macronuclear chromosomes, two retaining "arms" still appended to the Common Region. Arm-distal positions must differ (in cis) from the Common Region flanks.

RESULTS

The Common-Region-flanking positions also differ from the arm-distal positions in that they are "multi-TAS" regions: anchored PCR shows heterogeneous patterns of telomere addition sites, but arm-distal sites do not. The multi-TAS patterns are reproducible, but are sensitive to the sequence of the allele being processed. Thus, random degradation following chromatid cutting does not create this heterogeneity; these telomere addition sites also must be dictated by cis-acting sequences.

CONCLUSIONS

Most ciliates show such micro-heterogeneity in the precise positions of telomere addition sites. Telomerase is believed to be tightly associated with, and act in concert with, the chromatid-cutting nuclease: heterogeneity must be the result of intervening erosion activity. Our "weak-sites" hypothesis explains the correlation between alternative chromatid cutting at the Common Region boundaries and their multi-TAS character: when the chromatid-breakage machine encounters either a weak binding site or a weak cut site at these regions, then telomerase dissociates prematurely, leaving the new end subject to erosion by an exonuclease, which pauses at cis-acting sequences; telomerase eventually heals these resected termini. Finally, we observe TAS positioning influenced by trans-allelic interactions, reminiscent of transvection.

Functional multimerization of the human telomerase reverse transcriptase

The telomerase enzyme exists as a large complex (approximately 1,000 kDa) in mammals and at minimum is composed of the telomerase RNA and the catalytic subunit telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT). In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, telomerase appears to function as an interdependent dimer or multimer in vivo (J. Prescott and E. H. Blackburn, Genes Dev. 11:2790-2800, 1997). However, the requirements for multimerization are not known, and it remained unclear whether telomerase exists as a multimer in other organisms. We show here that human TERT (hTERT) forms a functional multimer in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate reconstitution assay and in human cell extracts. Two separate, catalytically inactive TERT proteins can complement each other in trans to reconstitute catalytic activity. This complementation requires the amino terminus of one hTERT and the reverse transcriptase and C-terminal domains of the second hTERT. The telomerase RNA must associate with only the latter hTERT for reconstitution of telomerase activity to occur. Multimerization of telomerase also facilitates the recognition and elongation of substrates in vitro and in vivo. These data suggest that the catalytic core of human telomerase may exist as a functionally cooperative dimer or multimer in vivo.

Yeast telomerase appears to frequently copy the entire template in vivo

Telomeres derived from the same formation event in wild type strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae possess the same, precise TG(1-3) sequence for the most internal approximately 100 bp of the 250-350 bp TG(1-3) repeats. The conservation of this internal domain is thought to reflect the fact that telomere lengthening and shortening, and thus alteration of the precise TG(1-3) sequence, is confined to the terminal region of the telomere. The internal domains of telomeres from yku70 and tel1 mutants, whose entire telomeres are only approximately 100 bp, were examined by analyzing 5.1 kb of cloned TG(1-3) sequences from telomeres formed during transformation of wild type, yku70 and tel1 cells. The internal domains were 97-137 bp in wild type cells, 27-36 bp in yku70 cells and 7-9 bp in tel1 cells. These data suggest that the majority of the tel1 cell TG(1-3) repeats may be resynthesized during shortening and lengthening reactions while a portion of the yku70 cell telomeres are protected. TG(1-3) sequences are synthesized by telomerase repeatedly copying an internal RNA template, which introduces a sequence bias into TG(1-3) repeats. Analysis of in vivo-derived telomeres revealed that of the many possible high affinity binding sites for the telomere protein Rap1p in TG(1-3) repeats, only those consistent with telomere hybridization to the ACACAC in the 3'-region of the telomerase RNA template followed by copying of most of the template were present. Copies of the telomerase RNA template made up 40-60% of the TG(1-3) sequences from each strain and could be found in long, tandem repeats. The data suggest that in vivo yeast telomerase frequently allows telomeres to hybridize to the 3'-region of RNA template and copy most of it prior to dissociation, or that in vivo telomere processing events result in the production of TG(1-3) sequences that mimic this process.