Chromatin structural transitions and the phenomenon of vitellogenin gene memory in chickens

A dynamic model of transcriptional imprinting derived from the vitellogenesis memory effect

Transcriptional memory of transient signals can be imprinted on living systems and influence their reactivity to repeated stimulations. Although they are classically ascribed to structural chromatin rearrangements in eukaryotes, such behaviors can also rely on dynamic memory circuits with sustained self-amplification loops. However, these phenomena are either of finite duration, or conversely associated to sustained phenotypic changes. A mechanism is proposed, in which only the responsiveness of the target gene is durably reset at a higher level after primary stimulation, using the celebrated but still puzzling vitellogenesis memory effect. The basic ingredients of this system are: 1), a positive autoregulation of the estrogen receptor α gene; 2), a strongly cooperative action of the estradiol receptor on vitellogenin expression; and 3), a variant isoform of the estradiol receptor with two autonomous transcription-activating modules, one of which is signal-independent and the other, signal-dependent. Realistic quantification supports the possibility of a multistationary situation in which ligand-independent activity is unable by itself to prime the amplification loop, but can click the system over a memory threshold after a primary stimulation. This ratchet transcriptional mechanism can have developmental and ecotoxicological importance and explain lifelong imprinting of past exposures without apparent phenotypic changes before restimulation and without need for persistent chromatin modifications.

Estrogen-induced transcription of the progesterone receptor gene does not parallel estrogen receptor occupancy

The activation of the silent endogenous progesterone receptor (PR) gene by 17-beta-estradiol (E2) in cells stably transfected with estrogen receptor (ER) was used as a model system to study the mechanism of E2-induced transcription. The time course of E2-induced PR transcription rate was determined by nuclear run-on assays. No marked effect on specific PR gene transcription rates was detected at 0 and 1 h of E2 treatment. After 3 h of E2 treatment, the PR mRNA synthesis rate increased 2.0- +/- 0.2-fold and continued to increase to 3.5- +/- 0.4-fold by 24 h as compared with 0 h. The transcription rate increase was followed by PR mRNA accumulation. No PR mRNA was detectable at 0, 1, and 3 h of E2 treatment. PR mRNA accumulation was detected at 6 h of E2 treatment and continued to accumulate until 18 h, the longest time point examined. Interestingly, this slow and gradual transcription rate increase of the endogenous PR gene did not parallel binding of E2 to ER, which was maximized within 30 min. Furthermore, the E2-ER level was down-regulated to 15% at 3 h as compared with 30 min of E2 treatment and remained low at 24 h of E2 exposure. These paradoxical observations indicate that E2-induced transcription activation is more complicated than just an association of the occupied ER with the transcription machinery.

Formation of nuclear bodies in hepatocytes of estrogen-treated roosters

As a model for cellular growth and stimulation without accompanying proliferation, we have examined the induction and formation of nuclear bodies (NBs) in hepatocytes of estrogen-treated roosters. Four-week-old roosters were injected with a single intramuscular dose of estradiol and then killed at time points of 8 h, 48 h, and 4 wk post-injection. For immunofluorescence analyses, livers were excised and isolated hepatocyte nuclei were fixed and then labeled with antibody to the coiled body-specific protein, p80-coilin. In control animals (no estradiol) or in animals 8 h post-injection, each hepatocyte nucleus contained an average of 1.0 coiled body (CB), which appeared randomly distributed in the nucleoplasm. At 48 h post-injection, there were an average of 2.7 CBs/nucleus and many of these appeared to be in contact with the nucleolus. Pairs of CBs were also observed. By 4 wk post-injection an average of 1.5 CBs/nucleus were detected, with no apparent relationship to the nucleolus observed. By serial-section electron microscopy of intact livers, two different types of round NBs were observed, sometimes in close proximity to each other and to the expanded interchromatin granule region in maximally stimulated cells. One type of NB was a classical CB that averaged 0.35 microns in diameter and the other NB type was ring shaped, averaged 0.25 microns in diameter, was composed of a fibrous shell surrounding a hollow interior, and appeared as a simple NB when sectioned tangentially through its outer shell. Immunoelectron microscopy revealed that CBs were the only class of NBs that contained p80-coilin. From these data, we conclude that CBs proliferate in response to estrogen stimulation, possibly arising from the nucleolar surface and then increasing in number by replicative division.

Mutational studies reveal a complex set of positive and negative control elements within the chicken vitellogenin II promoter

The endogenous chicken vitellogenin II (VTGII) gene is transcribed exclusively in hepatocytes in response to estrogen. We previously identified two estrogen response elements (EREs) upstream of this gene. We now present an analysis of the VTGII promoter activated by these EREs in response to estrogen. Chimeric VTGII-CAT genes were cotransfected into LMH chicken hepatoma cells along with an estrogen receptor expression vector, and transient CAT expression was assayed after culturing the cells in the absence or presence of estrogen. An analysis of constructs bearing deletions downstream of the more proximal ERE indicated that promoter elements relevant to transcription in LMH cells extend to between -113 and -96. The relative importance of sequences within the VTGII promoter was examined by using 10 contiguous linker scanner mutations spanning the region from -117 to -24. Although most of these mutations compromised VTGII promoter function, one dramatically increased expression in LMH cells and also rendered the VTGII promoter capable of being activated by cis-linked EREs in fibroblasts cotransfected with an estrogen receptor expression vector. Gel retardation and DNase I footprinting assays revealed four factor-binding sites within this promoter. We demonstrate that three of these sites bind C/EBP, SP1, and USF (or related factors), respectively; the fourth site binds a factor that we denote TF-V beta. The biological relevance of these findings is suggested by the fact that three of these binding sites map to sites previously shown to be occupied in vivo in response to estrogen.

Mutational studies reveal a complex set of positive and negative control elements within the chicken vitellogenin II promoter

The endogenous chicken vitellogenin II (VTGII) gene is transcribed exclusively in hepatocytes in response to estrogen. We previously identified two estrogen response elements (EREs) upstream of this gene. We now present an analysis of the VTGII promoter activated by these EREs in response to estrogen. Chimeric VTGII-CAT genes were cotransfected into LMH chicken hepatoma cells along with an estrogen receptor expression vector, and transient CAT expression was assayed after culturing the cells in the absence or presence of estrogen. An analysis of constructs bearing deletions downstream of the more proximal ERE indicated that promoter elements relevant to transcription in LMH cells extend to between -113 and -96. The relative importance of sequences within the VTGII promoter was examined by using 10 contiguous linker scanner mutations spanning the region from -117 to -24. Although most of these mutations compromised VTGII promoter function, one dramatically increased expression in LMH cells and also rendered the VTGII promoter capable of being activated by cis-linked EREs in fibroblasts cotransfected with an estrogen receptor expression vector. Gel retardation and DNase I footprinting assays revealed four factor-binding sites within this promoter. We demonstrate that three of these sites bind C/EBP, SP1, and USF (or related factors), respectively; the fourth site binds a factor that we denote TF-V beta. The biological relevance of these findings is suggested by the fact that three of these binding sites map to sites previously shown to be occupied in vivo in response to estrogen.

Serum stimulation of the c-fos enhancer induces reversible changes in c-fos chromatin structure

Transcription of the proto-oncogene c-fos is known to be activated by growth factors in serum and subsequently repressed by the Fos protein. We show that generalized DNase I sensitivity of c-fos chromatin correlates closely with enhancer activity during induction, repression, and superinduction of the c-fos gene. Within 90 s of serum stimulation, proximal DNA sequences on both sides of the enhancer exhibit increased DNase I sensitivity. Within 5 min, elevated DNase I sensitivity spreads to chromatin at the distal 3' end of the c-fos gene. These results suggest that an open state of chromatin is propagated in both directions from the enhancer. The induced alterations in chromatin structure precede the increased transcriptional activity of the c-fos gene, suggesting that these changes in chromatin structure potentiate transcription.

Serum stimulation of the c-fos enhancer induces reversible changes in c-fos chromatin structure

Transcription of the proto-oncogene c-fos is known to be activated by growth factors in serum and subsequently repressed by the Fos protein. We show that generalized DNase I sensitivity of c-fos chromatin correlates closely with enhancer activity during induction, repression, and superinduction of the c-fos gene. Within 90 s of serum stimulation, proximal DNA sequences on both sides of the enhancer exhibit increased DNase I sensitivity. Within 5 min, elevated DNase I sensitivity spreads to chromatin at the distal 3' end of the c-fos gene. These results suggest that an open state of chromatin is propagated in both directions from the enhancer. The induced alterations in chromatin structure precede the increased transcriptional activity of the c-fos gene, suggesting that these changes in chromatin structure potentiate transcription.

The ubiquitous nuclear protein, NHP1, binds with high affinity to different sequences of the chicken vitellogenin II gene

In gel shift assays, affinity chromatography-purified NHP1 forms a stable complex with different sequences of the chicken vitellogenin II gene. The apparent KD of NHP1 with the estrogen response element (ERE) containing 5-methylcytosine is 1 X 10(-11) M. NHP1 does not form a complex with the Xenopus vitellogenin ERE where the GCG bases are replaced by CAG. NHP1 is closely related if not identical to the other ubiquitous proteins NHP2, NHP3 and NHP4 that bind specifically to different sequences. All four proteins behave identically on chromatography and give identical patterns in proteolytic bandshift assays. NHP1, NHP2 and NHP3 have a native molecular weight of 170,000 and are composed of two polypeptides of 85 and 75 kDa. The possible function of NHP1 is discussed.

Two functional estrogen response elements are located upstream of the major chicken vitellogenin gene

We used a transient-expression assay to identify two estrogen response elements (EREs) associated with the major chicken vitellogenin gene (VTGII). Each element was characterized by its ability to confer estrogen responsiveness when cloned in either orientation next to a chimeric reporter gene consisting of the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase promoter and the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase-coding region. Deletion analyses indicated that sequences necessary for the distal ERE resided within the region from -626 to -613 (nucleotide positions relative to the VTGII start site) whereas those necessary for the proximal ERE were within the region from -358 to -335. These distal and proximal elements contain, respectively, a perfect copy and an imperfect copy of the 13-base-pair sequence that is an essential feature of the EREs associated with two frog vitellogenin genes. These chicken VTGII EREs mapped near regions that were restructured at the chromatin level when the endogenous VTGII gene was expressed in the liver in response to estradiol. These data suggest a model for the tissue-specific expression of this estrogen-responsive gene.

Two functional estrogen response elements are located upstream of the major chicken vitellogenin gene

We used a transient-expression assay to identify two estrogen response elements (EREs) associated with the major chicken vitellogenin gene (VTGII). Each element was characterized by its ability to confer estrogen responsiveness when cloned in either orientation next to a chimeric reporter gene consisting of the herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase promoter and the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase-coding region. Deletion analyses indicated that sequences necessary for the distal ERE resided within the region from -626 to -613 (nucleotide positions relative to the VTGII start site) whereas those necessary for the proximal ERE were within the region from -358 to -335. These distal and proximal elements contain, respectively, a perfect copy and an imperfect copy of the 13-base-pair sequence that is an essential feature of the EREs associated with two frog vitellogenin genes. These chicken VTGII EREs mapped near regions that were restructured at the chromatin level when the endogenous VTGII gene was expressed in the liver in response to estradiol. These data suggest a model for the tissue-specific expression of this estrogen-responsive gene.

Long-term effects of estrogen on avian liver: estrogen-inducible switch in expression of nuclear, hormone-binding proteins

The stimulation of chicks or embryos with estrogen results in transient, hepatic expression of the vitellogenin gene, as well as long-term, propagatable alterations in the rapidity with which the gene can be reactivated. We examined the possibility that nuclear, type II estrogen-binding sites are involved in this long-term change in response characteristics. We demonstrate that the primary induction kinetics of type II sites in embryos and chicks correlated with the expression of the vitellogenin gene and that once their induction was triggered by estrogen, they accumulated, were propagated, and persisted for months after withdrawal of the hormone. We also show that their accumulation in the embryo was accompanied by prolonged expression of both the vitellogenin and very low-density apolipoprotein II genes, in the absence of elevated levels of type I receptor, and that the type II sites, like the classical receptor, appear to be preferentially associated with active or potentially active chromatin. Finally, we describe a regulatory mechanism, tested by computer modelling, that simulated the behavioral characteristics of these nuclear estrogen-binding sites and which may explain their role in mediating the long-term effects of estrogen.

Developmental regulation of the estrogen receptor and the estrogen responsiveness of five yolk protein genes in the avian liver

The magnitude of the expression of five yolk protein genes in the avian liver in response to exogenous estradiol is shown to be developmentally regulated. Though each of these yolk protein genes gains the capacity to respond to estradiol during embryonic development, we demonstrate that maximal responses for the different genes are achieved at distinct ages between 1 and 6 weeks after hatching. This observation prompted us to look for possible correlations between yolk protein gene expression and changes in the expression of estrogen receptors that might also occur after hatching. We discovered that indeed the maximal level of nuclear estrogen receptors (assayed following the administration of estradiol) increases progressively over this same period of development from approximately 1000 receptors per cell at 1 week after hatching to approximately 3500 receptors per cell at 6 weeks after hatching. The latter number represents the fully mature state, as comparable levels of receptors are present in the livers of egg-laying hens. Thus, though increases in the expression of estrogen receptors during embryonic liver development have previously been reported, our results indicate that the changes that occur after hatching are quantitatively far more significant to the developmental program for this transcription factor.

Long-term effects of estrogen on avian liver: estrogen-inducible switch in expression of nuclear, hormone-binding proteins

The stimulation of chicks or embryos with estrogen results in transient, hepatic expression of the vitellogenin gene, as well as long-term, propagatable alterations in the rapidity with which the gene can be reactivated. We examined the possibility that nuclear, type II estrogen-binding sites are involved in this long-term change in response characteristics. We demonstrate that the primary induction kinetics of type II sites in embryos and chicks correlated with the expression of the vitellogenin gene and that once their induction was triggered by estrogen, they accumulated, were propagated, and persisted for months after withdrawal of the hormone. We also show that their accumulation in the embryo was accompanied by prolonged expression of both the vitellogenin and very low-density apolipoprotein II genes, in the absence of elevated levels of type I receptor, and that the type II sites, like the classical receptor, appear to be preferentially associated with active or potentially active chromatin. Finally, we describe a regulatory mechanism, tested by computer modelling, that simulated the behavioral characteristics of these nuclear estrogen-binding sites and which may explain their role in mediating the long-term effects of estrogen.