Evolutionary changes of sequences and factors that direct transcription termination of human and mouse ribsomal genes

Regulation of DNA Replication through Natural Impediments in the Eukaryotic Genome

All living organisms need to duplicate their genetic information while protecting it from unwanted mutations, which can lead to genetic disorders and cancer development. Inaccuracies during DNA replication are the major cause of genomic instability, as replication forks are prone to stalling and collapse, resulting in DNA damage. The presence of exogenous DNA damaging agents as well as endogenous difficult-to-replicate DNA regions containing DNA–protein complexes, repetitive DNA, secondary DNA structures, or transcribing RNA polymerases, increases the risk of genomic instability and thus threatens cell survival. Therefore, understanding the cellular mechanisms required to preserve the genetic information during S phase is of paramount importance. In this review, we will discuss our current understanding of how cells cope with these natural impediments in order to prevent DNA damage and genomic instability during DNA replication.

Nucleolar DNA: the host and the guests

Nucleoli are formed on the basis of ribosomal genes coding for RNAs of ribosomal particles, but also include a great variety of other DNA regions. In this article, we discuss the characteristics of ribosomal DNA: the structure of the rDNA locus, complex organization and functions of the intergenic spacer, multiplicity of gene copies in one cell, selective silencing of genes and whole gene clusters, relation to components of nucleolar ultrastructure, specific problems associated with replication. We also review current data on the role of non-ribosomal DNA in the organization and function of nucleoli. Finally, we discuss probable causes preventing efficient visualization of DNA in nucleoli.

The Human RNA Polymerase I Transcription Terminator Complex Acts as a Replication Fork Barrier That Coordinates the Progress of Replication with rRNA Transcription Activity

In S phase, the replication and transcription of genomic DNA need to accommodate each other, otherwise their machineries collide, with chromosomal instability as a possible consequence. Here, we characterized the human replication fork barrier (RFB) that is present downstream from the 47S pre-rRNA gene (ribosomal DNA [rDNA]). We found that the most proximal transcription terminator, Sal box T1, acts as a polar RFB, while the other, Sal box T4/T5, arrests replication forks bidirectionally. The fork-arresting activity at these sites depends on polymerase I (Pol I) transcription termination factor 1 (TTF-1) and a replisome component, TIMELESS (TIM). We also found that the RFB activity was linked to rDNA copies with hypomethylated CpG and coincided with the time that actively transcribed rRNA genes are replicated. Failed fork arrest at RFB sites led to a slowdown of fork progression moving in the opposite direction to rRNA transcription. Chemical inhibition of transcription counteracted this deceleration of forks, indicating that rRNA transcription impedes replication in the absence of RFB activity. Thus, our results reveal a role of RFB for coordinating the progression of replication and transcription activity in highly transcribed rRNA genes.

Chromatin-specific regulation of mammalian rDNA transcription by clustered TTF-I binding sites

Enhancers and promoters often contain multiple binding sites for the same transcription factor, suggesting that homotypic clustering of binding sites may serve a role in transcription regulation. Here we show that clustering of binding sites for the transcription termination factor TTF-I downstream of the pre-rRNA coding region specifies transcription termination, increases the efficiency of transcription initiation and affects the three-dimensional structure of rRNA genes. On chromatin templates, but not on free rDNA, clustered binding sites promote cooperative binding of TTF-I, loading TTF-I to the downstream terminators before it binds to the rDNA promoter. Interaction of TTF-I with target sites upstream and downstream of the rDNA transcription unit connects these distal DNA elements by forming a chromatin loop between the rDNA promoter and the terminators. The results imply that clustered binding sites increase the binding affinity of transcription factors in chromatin, thus influencing the timing and strength of DNA-dependent processes.

The sequence-specific binding of proteins to regulatory regions controls gene expression. Binding sites for transcription factors are rather short and present several million times in large genomes. However, only a small number of these binding sites are functionally important. How proteins can discriminate and select their functional regions is not clear, to date. Regulatory loci like gene promoters and enhancers commonly comprise multiple binding sites for either one factor or a combination of several DNA binding proteins, allowing efficient factor recruitment. We studied the cluster of TTF-I binding sites downstream of the rRNA gene and identified that cooperative binding to the multimeric termination sites in combination with low-affinity binding of TTF-I to individual sites upstream of the gene serves multiple regulatory functions. Packaging of the clustered sites into chromatin is a prerequisite for high-affinity binding, coordinated activation of transcription and the formation of a chromatin loop between the promoter and the terminator.

Transcription termination by nuclear RNA polymerases

Gene transcription in the cell nucleus is a complex and highly regulated process. Transcription in eukaryotes requires three distinct RNA polymerases, each of which employs its own mechanisms for initiation, elongation, and termination. Termination mechanisms vary considerably, ranging from relatively simple to exceptionally complex. In this review, we describe the present state of knowledge on how each of the three RNA polymerases terminates and how mechanisms are conserved, or vary, from yeast to human.

The transcript release factor PTRF augments ribosomal gene transcription by facilitating reinitiation of RNA polymerase I

Termination of murine rDNA transcription by RNA polymerase I (Pol I) requires pausing of Pol I by terminator-bound TTF-I (transcription termination factor for Pol I), followed by dissociation of the ternary complex by PTRF (Pol I and transcript release factor). To examine the functional correlation between transcription termination and initiation, we have compared transcription on terminator-containing and terminator-less rDNA templates. We demonstrate that terminated RNA molecules are more efficiently synthesized than run-off transcripts, indicating that termination facilitates reinitiation. Transcriptional enhancement is observed in multiple- but not single-round transcription assays measuring either promoter-dependent or promoter-independent Pol I transcription. Increased synthesis of terminated transcripts is observed in crude extracts but not in a PTRF-free reconstituted transcription system, indicating that PTRF-mediated release of pre-rRNA is responsible for transcriptional enhancement. Consistent with PTRF serving an important role in modulating the efficiency of rRNA synthesis, PTRF exhibits pronounced charge heterogeneity, is phosphorylated at multiple sites and fractionates into transcriptionally active and inactive forms. The results suggest that regulation of PTRF activity may be an as yet unrecognized means to control the efficiency of ribosomal RNA synthesis.

Cloning and functional characterization of PTRF, a novel protein which induces dissociation of paused ternary transcription complexes

Termination of transcription by RNA polymerase I (Pol I) is a two-step process which involves pausing of elongating transcription complexes and release of both pre-rRNA and Pol I from the template. In mouse, pausing of elongation complexes is mediated by the transcription termination factor TTF-I bound to the 'Sal box' terminator downstream of the rDNA transcription unit. Dissociation of paused ternary complexes requires a cellular factor, termed PTRF for Pol I and transcript release factor. Here we describe the molecular cloning of a cDNA corresponding to murine PTRF. Recombinant PTRF is capable of dissociating ternary Pol I transcription complexes in vitro as revealed by release of both Pol I and nascent transcripts from the template. Consistent with its function in transcription termination, PTRF interacts with both TTF-I and Pol I. Moreover, we demonstrate specific binding of PTRF to transcripts containing the 3' end of pre-rRNA. Substitution of 3'-terminal uridylates by guanine residues abolishes PTRF binding and impairs release activity. The results reveal a network of protein-protein and protein-nucleic acid interactions that governs termination of Pol I transcription.

The release element of the yeast polymerase I transcription terminator can function independently of Reb1p

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae polymerase I (polI) transcription terminator utilizes a DNA-binding protein (Reb1p) as part of a signal that causes the polymerase to pause prior to release from the template. To study the release element of the terminator, independent of the Reb1p pause signal, we have replaced the Reb1p binding site with the binding site for the lac repressor, which acts as a self-contained heterologous pause signal for polI. Release efficiency is maximal when the lac repressor causes polI to pause in exactly the same position that Reb1p would have caused it to pause, suggesting that polI must be precisely positioned for transcript release to occur. Mutational analysis shows that the release element is a region rich in T residues which codes for the extreme 3' end of the transcript and which has no apparent ability to form hairpins when transcribed into RNA. We discuss possible mechanisms whereby this polI release element might function.

Trans-acting factors involved in species-specificity and control of mouse ribosomal gene transcription

Faithful and efficient transcription initiation at the mouse ribosomal gene promoter requires besides RNA polymerase I (pol I) four polypeptide trans-acting factors, termed TIF-IA, TIF-IB, TIF-IC, and mUBF. We have partially purified these proteins from cultured Ehrlich ascites cells and show that in the presence of TIF-IA and TIF-IB, pol I directs very low amounts of specific transcripts. Neither TIF-IC nor mUBF on their own significantly stimulate the efficiency of template utilization. However, both factors together strongly activate transcription. Interestingly, factor TIF-IB - the murine homologue of human SL1 - fails to program a human extract to transcribe the murine template, but requires its homologous RNA polymerase I. This finding implicates that not only some rDNA transcription factors but also pol I exhibits species-specific differences. The growth-related factor TIF-IA, on the other hand, stimulates both mouse and human rDNA transcription. This regulatory factor whose amount or activity fluctuates according to the proliferation rate of the cells, is functionally inactivated by antibodies against cdc2 protein kinase. This result together with the observation that transcription is stimulated by ATP-gamma S, an ATP analogue which is a substrate for protein kinases but not for protein phosphatases, strongly suggests that post-translational protein modification is involved in rDNA transcription regulation.

The mouse ribosomal DNA promoter has more stringent requirements in vivo than in vitro

Using mouse ribosomal DNA templates bearing polymerase I terminators to prevent transcriptional interference (S. L. Henderson, K. Ryan, and B. Sollner-Webb, Genes Dev. 3:212-223, 1989) and facilitate promoter analysis in intact cells, we demonstrate that a -140 promoter domain (as well as the core region) is essential for appreciable levels of initiation in vivo. This in vivo polymerase I promoter can also be detected in vitro but only under very stringent conditions.

Functional difference between the sites of ribosomal 40S precursor 3' end formation in Xenopus laevis and Xenopus borealis

In the ribosomal genes of X. laevis, the sequence GACTTGCNC is found about 60bp upstream of the gene promoter (T3) and is necessary and sufficient to cause termination of RNA polymerase I transcription. At the 3' end of the 40S precursor coding region (T2) a sequence differing by one nucleotide, GACTTGCNG, directs RNA 3' end formation but allows polymerase to transcribe on into the intergenic spacer (Labhart and Reeder, 1989, Genes and Dev. 4: 269-276). Sites corresponding to T2 and T3 are also found in a related species, X. borealis. Inspection of the T2 sequence in X. borealis reveals that it contains two copies of the terminator sequence, GACTTGCNC, located 15 and 96 bp downstream of the 3' end of the 40S precursor coding region. Here we present functional tests of those two T2 elements that show that, as predicted from the sequence, they both show termination activity and are functionally indistinguishable from the T3 site in X. laevis. These results suggest that X. laevis T2 is an example of a naturally occurring point mutation, and the inability to terminate transcription at T2 is an exception to the general pattern of ribosomal gene transcription in higher eukaryotes.

The mouse ribosomal DNA promoter has more stringent requirements in vivo than in vitro

Using mouse ribosomal DNA templates bearing polymerase I terminators to prevent transcriptional interference (S. L. Henderson, K. Ryan, and B. Sollner-Webb, Genes Dev. 3:212-223, 1989) and facilitate promoter analysis in intact cells, we demonstrate that a -140 promoter domain (as well as the core region) is essential for appreciable levels of initiation in vivo. This in vivo polymerase I promoter can also be detected in vitro but only under very stringent conditions.

An undecamer DNA sequence directs termination of human ribosomal gene transcription

Previously we have shown that a repetitive 18 bp sequence motif, the Sal box (AGGTCGACCAGA/TT/ANTCCG), present in the 3' terminal spacer of mouse rDNA constitutes a termination signal for RNA polymerase I (pol I). Similar sequence elements which are functionally analogous to the murine terminator are present in the spacer of human rDNA. However, the human termination signal is shorter encompassing only 11 bp (GGGTCGACCAG) which correspond to the proximal part of the mouse sequence. Two out of the five human Sal box elements are functionally inactive due to natural point mutations which damage factor binding. A similar sequence motif with a 10 of 11 base identity with the downstream terminators is located upstream of the human transcription initiation site. The upstream element interacts with the same factor(s) as the downstream terminators and is also capable to stop elongating human RNA polymerase I. Despite the human and mouse factors exert different electrophoretic mobilities in gel retardation assays, UV-crosslinking and proteolytic clipping experiments indicate that both the sizes and the tertiary structure of the Sal box binding proteins of both species are very similar. When bound to DNA, both the human and the mouse factor terminate transcription of pol I from the heterologous species. The results implicate that changes in signal sequences necessary for termination have been accompanied by compensatory changes in the DNA binding domain of the protein(s) interacting with the termination signal. In contrast, the protein-protein interactions between the termination factor and the transcribing RNA polymerase I appear to have been conserved during evolution.

Termination region in rRNA genes from a eucaryotic thermophile, Thermomyces lanuginosus

S1 mapping of the termination region in the ribosomal DNA from a thermophilic fungus, Thermomyces lanuginosus, revealed three distinct termini corresponding to the mature 25S rRNA, a precursor that is 19 nucleotides longer and corresponds to the 37S precursor in yeast cells, and a putative termination site at +96 that bears a limited sequence homology with the SalI box of mammalian cells. An estimate of the secondary structure suggested that the three termini are in close proximity, a feature that may be essential to precursor termination and maturation. The results raise questions regarding recently reported relationships between ribosomal DNA termination and spacer enhancer elements in fungi.

Termination region in rRNA genes from a eucaryotic thermophile, Thermomyces lanuginosus

S1 mapping of the termination region in the ribosomal DNA from a thermophilic fungus, Thermomyces lanuginosus, revealed three distinct termini corresponding to the mature 25S rRNA, a precursor that is 19 nucleotides longer and corresponds to the 37S precursor in yeast cells, and a putative termination site at +96 that bears a limited sequence homology with the SalI box of mammalian cells. An estimate of the secondary structure suggested that the three termini are in close proximity, a feature that may be essential to precursor termination and maturation. The results raise questions regarding recently reported relationships between ribosomal DNA termination and spacer enhancer elements in fungi.

Termination of transcription by yeast RNA polymerase I

Analysis of the termination of transcription by yeast RNA polymerase I (Pol I) using in vitro run-on experiments in both isolated nuclei and permeabilized cells demonstrated that Pol I does not traverse the whole intergenic spacer separating consecutive 37S operons, but terminates transcription before reaching the 5S rRNA gene, that is within NTS 1. In order to discriminate between processing and termination at the 3'-end generating sites previously identified in vivo in NTS 1 (T1, T2 and T3), fragments containing these sites were inserted into the middle of the reporter DNA of an artificial rRNA minigene. RNA isolated from yeast cells transformed with these minigenes was analyzed for the presence of transcripts derived from sequences both up- and downstream of the insert by Northern blot hybridization, reverse transcription analysis and S1 nuclease mapping. In accordance with previously obtained results T1 (+15 to +50) was found to behave as a processing site. T2 (+210) however was concluded to be an efficient, genuine Pol I terminator. In addition to T2, two other terminators were identified in NTS 1: T3A (at +690) and T3B (at +950). Surprisingly, when the 3' terminal part of NTS 2 was tested for its capacity to generate 3'-ends, another terminator (Tp) was found to be present at a position 300 bp upstream of the transcription initiation site of the 37S-rRNA operon.

Analysis of pre-rRNAs in heat-shocked HeLa cells allows identification of the upstream termination site of human polymerase I transcription

Human rRNA precursor from normal or stressed HeLa cells were studied by S1 nuclease mapping of unlabeled RNA and by antisense RNase mapping of RNA from cells that had been labeled in vivo with [32P]PO4. Heating cells to 43 degrees C decreased the amount of newly synthesized rRNA to less than 5% of the control level and led to greater than 95% inhibition of transcription termination at a region 355 to 362 nucleotides downstream of the 3' end of 28S rRNA, with readthrough continuing into the next transcription unit. Heating of cells to 42 degrees C led to 60% inhibition of termination at this site; 50% of transcripts that extended into the nontranscribed spacer ended in a region 200 to 210 nucleotides upstream of the polymerase I (Pol I) initiation site. This is presumed to be the human upstream transcription termination site because of the absence of RNAs with a 5' end corresponding to this region, the location relative to the Pol I initiation site (which is similar to the location of upstream terminators in other species), and the fact that it is 15 to 25 nucleotides upstream of the sequence GGGTTGACC, which has an 8-of-9 base identity with the sequence 3' of the downstream termination site. Surprisingly, treatment of cells with sodium arsenite, which also leads to the induction of a stress response, did not inhibit termination. Pol I initiation was decreased to the same extent as termination, which lends support to the hypothesis that termination and initiation are coupled. Although termination was almost completely inhibited at 43 degrees C, the majority of the recently synthesized rRNAs were processed to have the correct 3' end of 28S. This finding suggests that 3'-end formation can involve an endonucleolytic cut and is not solely dependent on exonucleolytic trimming of correctly terminated rRNAs.

Analysis of pre-rRNAs in heat-shocked HeLa cells allows identification of the upstream termination site of human polymerase I transcription

Human rRNA precursor from normal or stressed HeLa cells were studied by S1 nuclease mapping of unlabeled RNA and by antisense RNase mapping of RNA from cells that had been labeled in vivo with [32P]PO4. Heating cells to 43 degrees C decreased the amount of newly synthesized rRNA to less than 5% of the control level and led to greater than 95% inhibition of transcription termination at a region 355 to 362 nucleotides downstream of the 3' end of 28S rRNA, with readthrough continuing into the next transcription unit. Heating of cells to 42 degrees C led to 60% inhibition of termination at this site; 50% of transcripts that extended into the nontranscribed spacer ended in a region 200 to 210 nucleotides upstream of the polymerase I (Pol I) initiation site. This is presumed to be the human upstream transcription termination site because of the absence of RNAs with a 5' end corresponding to this region, the location relative to the Pol I initiation site (which is similar to the location of upstream terminators in other species), and the fact that it is 15 to 25 nucleotides upstream of the sequence GGGTTGACC, which has an 8-of-9 base identity with the sequence 3' of the downstream termination site. Surprisingly, treatment of cells with sodium arsenite, which also leads to the induction of a stress response, did not inhibit termination. Pol I initiation was decreased to the same extent as termination, which lends support to the hypothesis that termination and initiation are coupled. Although termination was almost completely inhibited at 43 degrees C, the majority of the recently synthesized rRNAs were processed to have the correct 3' end of 28S. This finding suggests that 3'-end formation can involve an endonucleolytic cut and is not solely dependent on exonucleolytic trimming of correctly terminated rRNAs.

High initiation rates at the ribosomal gene promoter do not depend upon spacer transcription

We report experiments that test the model that in Xenopus laevis, RNA polymerase I is "handed over" in a conservative fashion from the T3 terminator to the adjacent gene promoter. We have introduced transcription-terminating lesions into the ribosomal DNA repeat by irradiating cultured cells with ultraviolet light. We used isolated nuclei to measure the effect of such lesions on transcription. UV damage sufficient to prevent all elongating RNA polymerase from reaching T3 from upstream had no adverse effect on the density of RNA polymerase at the very 5' end of the gene. We conclude that high rates of transcription initiation at the gene promoter do not depend upon polymerase passing from one repeat to the next or on polymerase initiating at the spacer promoters.

Purification and characterization of TTFI, a factor that mediates termination of mouse ribosomal DNA transcription

Termination of rRNA gene transcription is dependent on an 18-base-pair sequence motif, AGGTCGAC CAG AT TA NTCCG (the Sal box), which is present several times in the spacer region downstream of the 3' end of the pre-rRNA coding region. We report here the purification to molecular homogeneity of a nuclear factor which specifically interacts with the Sal box element. Addition of the isolated protein to S-100 extracts which contain low levels of the Sal box-binding protein and are therefore termination incompetent restores terminating activity, indicating that this protein is a polymerase I-specific transcription termination factor. The purified protein (termed TTFI) has a molecular weight of approximately 105,000 on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels. Mild proteolysis generates a relatively protease-resistant core which still specifically recognizes its target sequence. However, the termination activity has been lost, suggesting that the interaction with the DNA and the interaction with the transcription apparatus reside in different protein domains.

Purification and characterization of TTFI, a factor that mediates termination of mouse ribosomal DNA transcription

Termination of rRNA gene transcription is dependent on an 18-base-pair sequence motif, AGGTCGAC CAG AT TA NTCCG (the Sal box), which is present several times in the spacer region downstream of the 3' end of the pre-rRNA coding region. We report here the purification to molecular homogeneity of a nuclear factor which specifically interacts with the Sal box element. Addition of the isolated protein to S-100 extracts which contain low levels of the Sal box-binding protein and are therefore termination incompetent restores terminating activity, indicating that this protein is a polymerase I-specific transcription termination factor. The purified protein (termed TTFI) has a molecular weight of approximately 105,000 on sodium dodecyl sulfate-polyacrylamide gels. Mild proteolysis generates a relatively protease-resistant core which still specifically recognizes its target sequence. However, the termination activity has been lost, suggesting that the interaction with the DNA and the interaction with the transcription apparatus reside in different protein domains.