The length of the downstream exon and the substitution of specific sequences affect pre-mRNA splicing in vitro

Programmable mutually exclusive alternative splicing for generating RNA and protein diversity

Alternative splicing performs a central role in expanding genomic coding capacity and proteomic diversity. However, programming of splicing patterns in engineered biological systems remains underused. Synthetic approaches thus far have predominantly focused on controlling expression of a single protein through alternative splicing. Here, we describe a modular and extensible platform for regulating four programmable exons that undergo a mutually exclusive alternative splicing event to generate multiple functionally-distinct proteins. We present an intron framework that enforces the mutual exclusivity of two internal exons and demonstrate a graded series of consensus sequence elements of varying strengths that set the ratio of two mutually exclusive isoforms. We apply this framework to program the DNA-binding domains of modular transcription factors to differentially control downstream gene activation. This splicing platform advances an approach for generating diverse isoforms and can ultimately be applied to program modular proteins and increase coding capacity of synthetic biological systems.

A single-nucleotide exon found in Arabidopsis

The presence of introns in gene-coding regions is one of the most mysterious evolutionary inventions in eukaryotic organisms. It has been proposed that, although sequences involved in intron recognition and splicing are mainly located in introns, exonic sequences also contribute to intron splicing. The smallest constitutively spliced exon known so far has 6 nucleotides, and the smallest alternatively spliced exon has 3 nucleotides. Here we report that the Anaphase Promoting Complex subunit 11 (APC11) gene in Arabidopsis thaliana carries a constitutive single-nucleotide exon. In vivo transcription and translation assays performed using APC11-Green Fluorescence Protein (GFP) fusion constructs revealed that intron splicing surrounding the single-nucleotide exon is effective in both Arabidopsis and rice. This discovery warrants attention to genome annotations in the future.

Human genomic sequences that inhibit splicing

Mammalian genes are characterized by relatively small exons surrounded by variable lengths of intronic sequence. Sequences similar to the splice signals that define the 5' and 3' boundaries of these exons are also present in abundance throughout the surrounding introns. What causes the real sites to be distinguished from the multitude of pseudosites in pre-mRNA is unclear. Much progress has been made in defining additional sequence elements that enhance the use of particular sites. Less work has been done on sequences that repress the use of particular splice sites. To find additional examples of sequences that inhibit splicing, we searched human genomic DNA libraries for sequences that would inhibit the inclusion of a constitutively spliced exon. Genetic selection experiments suggested that such sequences were common, and we subsequently tested randomly chosen restriction fragments of about 100 bp. When inserted into the central exon of a three-exon minigene, about one in three inhibited inclusion, revealing a high frequency of inhibitory elements in human DNA. In contrast, only 1 in 27 Escherichia coli DNA fragments was inhibitory. Several previously identified silencing elements derived from alternatively spliced exons functioned weakly in this constitutively spliced exon. In contrast, a high-affinity site for U2AF65 strongly inhibited exon inclusion. Together, our results suggest that splicing occurs in a background of repression and, since many of our inhibitors contain splice like signals, we suggest that repression of some pseudosites may occur through an inhibitory arrangement of these sites.

Multiple distinct splicing enhancers in the protein-coding sequences of a constitutively spliced pre-mRNA

We have identified multiple distinct splicing enhancer elements within protein-coding sequences of the constitutively spliced human beta-globin pre-mRNA. Each of these highly conserved sequences is sufficient to activate the splicing of a heterologous enhancer-dependent pre-mRNA. One of these enhancers is activated by and binds to the SR protein SC35, whereas at least two others are activated by the SR protein SF2/ASF. A single base mutation within another enhancer element inactivates the enhancer but does not change the encoded amino acid. Thus, overlapping protein coding and RNA recognition elements may be coselected during evolution. These studies provide the first direct evidence that SR protein-specific splicing enhancers are located within the coding regions of constitutively spliced pre-mRNAs. We propose that these enhancers function as multisite splicing enhancers to specify 3' splice-site selection.

Function of a bovine papillomavirus type 1 exonic splicing suppressor requires a suboptimal upstream 3' splice site

Alternative splicing is an important mechanism for the regulation of bovine papillomavirus type 1 (BPV-1) gene expression during the virus life cycle. Previous studies in our laboratory have identified two purine-rich exonic splicing enhancers (ESEs), SE1 and SE2, located between two alternative 3' splice sites at nucleotide (nt) 3225 and nt 3605. Further analysis of BPV-1 late-pre-mRNA splicing in vitro revealed a 48-nt pyrimidine-rich region immediately downstream of SE1 that inhibits utilization of the nt 3225 3' splice site. This inhibitory element, which we named an exonic splicing suppressor (ESS), has a U-rich 5' end, a C-rich central part, and an AG-rich 3' end (Z. M. Zheng, P. He, and C. C. Baker, J. Virol. 70:4691-4699, 1996). The present study utilized in vitro splicing of both homologous and heterologous pre-mRNAs to further characterize the ESS. The BPV-1 ESS was inserted downstream of the 3' splice site in the BPV-1 late pre-mRNA, Rous sarcoma virus src pre-mRNA, human immunodeficiency virus tat-rev pre-mRNA, and Drosophila dsx pre-mRNA, all containing a suboptimal 3' splice site, and in the human beta-globin pre-mRNA, which contains a constitutive 3' splice site. These studies demonstrated that suppression of splicing by the BPV-1 ESS requires an upstream suboptimal 3' splice site but not an upstream ESE. Furthermore, the ESS functions when located either upstream or downstream of BPV-1 SE1. Mutational analyses demonstrated that the function of the ESS is sequence dependent and that only the C-rich region of the ESS is essential for suppression of splicing in all the pre-mRNAs tested.

Sequence of the polypyrimidine tract of the 3'-terminal 3' splicing signal can affect intron-dependent pre-mRNA processing in vivo

Most pre-mRNAs require an intron for efficient processing in higher eukaryotes. However, not all introns can provide this function. For example, transcripts synthesized from a variant of the human beta-globin gene lacking its second intervening sequence (IVS2), yet retaining its first intervening sequence (IVS1), exhibit multiple defects in mRNA biogenesis. To investigate why, we transfected into monkey cells plasmids containing the human beta-globin gene and variants of it altered in (i) IVS1, (ii) the 3'-terminal exon, and (iii) the polyadenylation signal. The beta-globin RNAs accumulated in these cells were analyzed by quantitative S1 nuclease mapping for nuclear accumulation, intron excision, polyadenylation and cytoplasmic accumulation. We found that the 3' splicing signal of IVS1, with multiple purines interrupting its polypyrimidine tract, could efficiently function as an internal 3' splicing signal; however, it could not efficiently function as the 3'-terminal 3' splicing signal for any of these steps in intron-dependent mRNA biogenesis unless (i) its polypyrimidine tract was made uninterrupted in pyrimidines, or (ii) specific sequences were deleted from the 3'-terminal exon. We conclude that whether an intron can provide the function necessary for efficient processing of intron-dependent pre-mRNA is dependent upon the ability of its 3' splicing signal to define the 3'-terminal exon. On the practical side, this finding means one needs to consider both the sequence and location of the intron to be included in an intron-dependent gene to obtain efficient expression in vivo.

Selection of novel exon recognition elements from a pool of random sequences

A 20-nucleotide sequence close to the 3' end of the internal exon of a model two-intron, three-exon pre-mRNA (DUP184 [Z. Dominski and R. Kole, J. Biol. Chem. 269:23590-23596, 1994]) was replaced by a random 20-mer, resulting in a pool of pre-mRNAs which, like the initial DUP184 construct, were spliced in vitro by a pathway leading to predominant skipping of the internal exon. The randomized pre-mRNAs were subjected to a selection protocol, resulting in a pool enriched in pre-mRNAs that efficiently included the internal exon. Isolation and sequencing of a number of clones corresponding to the selected pre-mRNAs showed that two classes of sequences were selected from the initial pool. Most abundant among these were sequences with purine tracts similar to those in the recently identified exon-splicing enhancers while a smaller class included sequences lacking discernible purine tracts within the 20-nucleotide region. Splicing of selected pre-mRNAs showed that the purine tracts vary in their ability to promote exon inclusion and, more important, that sequences lacking purine tracts stimulate inclusion of the internal exon as efficiently as their purine-rich counterparts. The latter result indicates the existence of a novel class of exon recognition sequences or splicing enhancers.

A 32-nucleotide exon-splicing enhancer regulates usage of competing 5' splice sites in a differential internal exon

Large alternatively spliced internal exons are uncommon in vertebrate genes, and the mechanisms governing their usage are unknown. In this report, we examined alternative splicing of a 1-kb internal exon from the human caldesmon gene containing two regulated 5' splice sites that are 687 nucleotides apart. In cell lines normally splicing caldesmon RNA via utilization of the exon-internal 5' splice site, inclusion of the differential exon required a long purine-rich sequence located between the two competing 5' splice sites. This element consisted of four identical 32-nucleotide purine-rich repeats that resemble exon-splicing enhancers (ESE) identified in other genes. One 32-nucleotide repeat supported exon inclusion, repressed usage of the terminal 5' splice site, and functioned in a heterologous exon dependent on exon enhancers for inclusion, indicating that the caldesmon purine-rich sequence can be classified as an ESE. The ESE was required for utilization of the internal 5' splice site only in the presence of the competing 5' splice site and had no effect when placed downstream of the terminal 5' splice site. In the absence of the internal 5' splice site, the ESE activated a normally silent cryptic 5' splice site near the natural internal 5' splice site, indicating that the ESE stimulates upstream 5' splice site selection. We propose that the caldesmon ESE functions to regulate competition between two 5' splice sites within a differential internal exon.

Modulation of in vitro splicing of the upstream intron by modifying an intra-exon sequence which is deleted from the dystrophin gene in dystrophin Kobe

Molecular analysis of dystrophin Kobe showed that exon 19 of the dystrophin gene bearing 52-bp deletion was skipped during splicing, although the known consensus sequences at the 5' and 3' splice sites of exon 19 were maintained (Matsuo, M., T. Masumura, H. Nishio, T. Nakajima, Y. Kitoh, T. Takumi, J. Koga, and H. Nakamura. 1991. J. Clin. Invest. 87:2127-2131). These data suggest that the deleted sequence of exon 19 may function as a cis-acting element for exact splicing for the upstream and downstream introns. To investigate this potential role of exon 19, an in vitro splicing system using artificial dystrophin mRNA precursors (pre-mRNAs) was established. Pre-mRNA containing exon 18, truncated intron 18, and exon 19 was spliced precisely in vitro, whereas splicing of intron 18 was almost completely abolished when the wild-type exon 19 was replaced by the dystrophin Kobe exon 19. Splicing of intron 18 was not fully reactivated when dystrophin Kobe exon 19 was restored to nearly normal length by inserting other sequences into the deleted site. These results suggest that the presence of the exon 19 sequence which is lost in dystrophin Kobe is more critical for splicing of intron 18 than the length of the exon 19 sequence. Characteristically, the efficiency of splicing of this intron seemed to correlate with the presence of polypurine tracks within the downstream exon 19. Moreover, an antisense 31-mer 2'-O-methyl ribonucleotide complementary to the 5' half of the deleted sequence in dystrophin Kobe exon 19 inhibited splicing of wild-type pre-mRNA in a dose- and time-dependent manner. This first in vitro evidence that dystrophin pre-mRNA splicing can be modulated by an antisense oligonucleotide raises the possibility of a new therapeutic approach for Duchenne muscular dystrophy.

SR proteins promote the first specific recognition of Pre-mRNA and are present together with the U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particle in a general splicing enhancer complex

We show that addition of SR proteins to in vitro splicing extracts results in a significant increase in assembly of the earliest prespliceosomal complex E and a corresponding decrease in assembly of the heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein (hnRNP) complex H. In addition, SR proteins promote formation of the E5' and E3' complexes that assemble on RNAs containing only 5' and 3' splice sites, respectively. We conclude that SR proteins promote the earliest specific recognition of both the 5' and 3' splice sites and are limiting for this function in HeLa nuclear extracts. Using UV cross-linking, we demonstrate specific, splice site-dependent RNA-protein interactions of SR proteins in the E, E5', and E3' complexes. SR proteins do not UV cross-link in the H complex, and conversely, hnRNP cross-linking is largely excluded from the E-type complexes. We also show that a discrete complex resembling the E5' complex assembles on both purine-rich and non-purine-rich exonic splicing enhancers. This complex, which we have designated the Enhancer complex, contains U1 small nuclear RNP (snRNP) and is associated with different SR protein family members, depending on the sequence of the enhancer. We propose that both downstream 5' splice site enhancers and exonic enhancers function by establishing a network of pre-mRNA-protein and protein-protein interactions involving U1 snRNP, SR proteins, and U2AF that is similar to the interactions that bring the 5' and 3' splice sites together in the E complex.

Identification and characterization by antisense oligonucleotides of exon and intron sequences required for splicing

Certain thalassemic human beta-globin pre-mRNAs carry mutations that generate aberrant splice sites and/or activate cryptic splice sites, providing a convenient and clinically relevant system to study splice site selection. Antisense 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotides were used to block a number of sequences in these pre-mRNAs and were tested for their ability to inhibit splicing in vitro or to affect the ratio between aberrantly and correctly spliced products. By this approach, it was found that (i) up to 19 nucleotides upstream from the branch point adenosine are involved in proper recognition and functioning of the branch point sequence; (ii) whereas at least 25 nucleotides of exon sequences at both 3' and 5' ends are required for splicing, this requirement does not extend past the 5' splice site sequence of the intron; and (iii) improving the 5' splice site of the internal exon to match the consensus sequence strongly decreases the accessibility of the upstream 3' splice site to antisense 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotides. This result most likely reflects changes in the strength of interactions near the 3' splice site in response to improvement of the 5' splice site and further supports the existence of communication between these sites across the exon.

SR proteins promote the first specific recognition of Pre-mRNA and are present together with the U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein particle in a general splicing enhancer complex

We show that addition of SR proteins to in vitro splicing extracts results in a significant increase in assembly of the earliest prespliceosomal complex E and a corresponding decrease in assembly of the heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein (hnRNP) complex H. In addition, SR proteins promote formation of the E5' and E3' complexes that assemble on RNAs containing only 5' and 3' splice sites, respectively. We conclude that SR proteins promote the earliest specific recognition of both the 5' and 3' splice sites and are limiting for this function in HeLa nuclear extracts. Using UV cross-linking, we demonstrate specific, splice site-dependent RNA-protein interactions of SR proteins in the E, E5', and E3' complexes. SR proteins do not UV cross-link in the H complex, and conversely, hnRNP cross-linking is largely excluded from the E-type complexes. We also show that a discrete complex resembling the E5' complex assembles on both purine-rich and non-purine-rich exonic splicing enhancers. This complex, which we have designated the Enhancer complex, contains U1 small nuclear RNP (snRNP) and is associated with different SR protein family members, depending on the sequence of the enhancer. We propose that both downstream 5' splice site enhancers and exonic enhancers function by establishing a network of pre-mRNA-protein and protein-protein interactions involving U1 snRNP, SR proteins, and U2AF that is similar to the interactions that bring the 5' and 3' splice sites together in the E complex.

Identification and characterization by antisense oligonucleotides of exon and intron sequences required for splicing

Certain thalassemic human beta-globin pre-mRNAs carry mutations that generate aberrant splice sites and/or activate cryptic splice sites, providing a convenient and clinically relevant system to study splice site selection. Antisense 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotides were used to block a number of sequences in these pre-mRNAs and were tested for their ability to inhibit splicing in vitro or to affect the ratio between aberrantly and correctly spliced products. By this approach, it was found that (i) up to 19 nucleotides upstream from the branch point adenosine are involved in proper recognition and functioning of the branch point sequence; (ii) whereas at least 25 nucleotides of exon sequences at both 3' and 5' ends are required for splicing, this requirement does not extend past the 5' splice site sequence of the intron; and (iii) improving the 5' splice site of the internal exon to match the consensus sequence strongly decreases the accessibility of the upstream 3' splice site to antisense 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotides. This result most likely reflects changes in the strength of interactions near the 3' splice site in response to improvement of the 5' splice site and further supports the existence of communication between these sites across the exon.

Large exon size does not limit splicing in vivo

Exon sizes in vertebrate genes are, with a few exceptions, limited to less than 300 bases. It has been proposed that this limitation may derive from the exon definition model of splice site recognition. In this model, a downstream donor site enhances splicing at the upstream acceptor site of the same exon. This enhancement may require contact between factors bound to each end of the exon; an exon size limitation would promote such contact. To test the idea that proximity was required for exon definition, we inserted random DNA fragments from Escherichia coli into a central exon in a three-exon dihydrofolate reductase minigene and tested whether the expanded exons were efficiently spliced. DNA from a plasmid library of expanded minigenes was used to transfect a CHO cell deletion mutant lacking the dhfr locus. PCR analysis of DNA isolated from the pooled stable cotransfectant populations displayed a range of DNA insert sizes from 50 to 1,500 nucleotides. A parallel analysis of the RNA from this population by reverse transcription followed by PCR showed a similar size distribution. Central exons as large as 1,400 bases could be spliced into mRNA. We also tested individual plasmid clones containing exon inserts of defined sizes. The largest exon included in mRNA was 1,200 bases in length, well above the 300-base limit implied by the survey of naturally occurring exons. We conclude that a limitation in exon size is not part of the exon definition mechanism.

Large exon size does not limit splicing in vivo

Exon sizes in vertebrate genes are, with a few exceptions, limited to less than 300 bases. It has been proposed that this limitation may derive from the exon definition model of splice site recognition. In this model, a downstream donor site enhances splicing at the upstream acceptor site of the same exon. This enhancement may require contact between factors bound to each end of the exon; an exon size limitation would promote such contact. To test the idea that proximity was required for exon definition, we inserted random DNA fragments from Escherichia coli into a central exon in a three-exon dihydrofolate reductase minigene and tested whether the expanded exons were efficiently spliced. DNA from a plasmid library of expanded minigenes was used to transfect a CHO cell deletion mutant lacking the dhfr locus. PCR analysis of DNA isolated from the pooled stable cotransfectant populations displayed a range of DNA insert sizes from 50 to 1,500 nucleotides. A parallel analysis of the RNA from this population by reverse transcription followed by PCR showed a similar size distribution. Central exons as large as 1,400 bases could be spliced into mRNA. We also tested individual plasmid clones containing exon inserts of defined sizes. The largest exon included in mRNA was 1,200 bases in length, well above the 300-base limit implied by the survey of naturally occurring exons. We conclude that a limitation in exon size is not part of the exon definition mechanism.

Polypurine sequences within a downstream exon function as a splicing enhancer

We have previously shown that a purine-rich sequence located within exon M2 of the mouse immunoglobulin mu gene functions as a splicing enhancer, as judged by its ability to stimulate splicing of a distant upstream intron. This sequence element has been designated ERS (exon recognition sequence). In this study, we investigated the stimulatory effects of various ERS-like sequences, using the in vitro splicing system with HeLa cell nuclear extracts. Here, we show that purine-rich sequences of several natural exons that have previously been shown to be required for splicing function as a splicing enhancer like the ERS of the immunoglobulin mu gene. Moreover, even synthetic polypurine sequences had stimulatory effects on the upstream splicing. Evaluation of the data obtained from the analyses of both natural and synthetic purine-rich sequences shows that (i) alternating purine sequences can stimulate splicing, while poly(A) or poly(G) sequences cannot, and (ii) the presence of U residues within the polypurine sequence greatly reduces the level of stimulation. Competition experiments strongly suggest that the stimulatory effects of various purine-rich sequences are mediated by the same trans-acting factor(s). We conclude from these results that the purine-rich sequences that we examined in this study also represent examples of ERS. Thus, ERS is considered a general splicing element that is present in various exons and plays an important role in splice site selection.

Context effects on N6-adenosine methylation sites in prolactin mRNA

The methylation of internal adenosine residues in mRNA only occurs within GAC or AAC sequences. Although both of these sequence motifs are utilized, a general preference has been noted for the extended sequence RGACU. Not all RGACU sequences in an mRNA are methylated and the mechanisms that govern the selection of methylation sites in mRNA remain unclear. To address this problem we have examined the methylation of transcripts containing sequences of a natural mRNA, namely, bovine prolactin mRNA. In this mRNA, a specific AGACU sequence in the 3' untranslated region is the predominant site of methylation both in vivo and in vitro. The degree to which N6-adenosine methyltransferase recognizes the sequence context of the consensus methylation site was explored by mutational analysis of the nucleotides adjacent to the core sequence as well as the extended regions in which the core element was found. Our results indicate that efficient methylation depends on the extended five nucleotide consensus sequence but is strongly influenced by the context in which the consensus sequence occurs within the overall mRNA molecule. Furthermore, consensus methylation sites present in an RNA duplex are not recognized by the methyltransferase.

Polypurine sequences within a downstream exon function as a splicing enhancer

We have previously shown that a purine-rich sequence located within exon M2 of the mouse immunoglobulin mu gene functions as a splicing enhancer, as judged by its ability to stimulate splicing of a distant upstream intron. This sequence element has been designated ERS (exon recognition sequence). In this study, we investigated the stimulatory effects of various ERS-like sequences, using the in vitro splicing system with HeLa cell nuclear extracts. Here, we show that purine-rich sequences of several natural exons that have previously been shown to be required for splicing function as a splicing enhancer like the ERS of the immunoglobulin mu gene. Moreover, even synthetic polypurine sequences had stimulatory effects on the upstream splicing. Evaluation of the data obtained from the analyses of both natural and synthetic purine-rich sequences shows that (i) alternating purine sequences can stimulate splicing, while poly(A) or poly(G) sequences cannot, and (ii) the presence of U residues within the polypurine sequence greatly reduces the level of stimulation. Competition experiments strongly suggest that the stimulatory effects of various purine-rich sequences are mediated by the same trans-acting factor(s). We conclude from these results that the purine-rich sequences that we examined in this study also represent examples of ERS. Thus, ERS is considered a general splicing element that is present in various exons and plays an important role in splice site selection.

Short artificial hairpins sequester splicing signals and inhibit yeast pre-mRNA splicing

To examine the stability of yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) pre-mRNA structures, we inserted a series of small sequence elements that generated potential RNA hairpins at the 5' splice site and branch point regions. We analyzed spliceosome assembly and splicing in vitro as well as splicing and nuclear pre-mRNA retention in vivo. Surprisingly, the inhibition of in vivo splicing approximately paralleled that of in vitro splicing. Even a 6-nucleotide hairpin could be shown to inhibit splicing, and a 15-nucleotide hairpin gave rise to almost complete inhibition. The in vitro results indicate that hairpins that sequester the 5' splice site have a major effect on the early steps of spliceosome assembly, including U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein binding. The in vivo experiments lead to comparable conclusions as the sequestering hairpins apparently result in the transport of pre-mRNA to the cytoplasm. The observations are compared with previous data from both yeast and mammalian systems and suggest an important effect of pre-mRNA structure on in vivo splicing.

Short artificial hairpins sequester splicing signals and inhibit yeast pre-mRNA splicing

To examine the stability of yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) pre-mRNA structures, we inserted a series of small sequence elements that generated potential RNA hairpins at the 5' splice site and branch point regions. We analyzed spliceosome assembly and splicing in vitro as well as splicing and nuclear pre-mRNA retention in vivo. Surprisingly, the inhibition of in vivo splicing approximately paralleled that of in vitro splicing. Even a 6-nucleotide hairpin could be shown to inhibit splicing, and a 15-nucleotide hairpin gave rise to almost complete inhibition. The in vitro results indicate that hairpins that sequester the 5' splice site have a major effect on the early steps of spliceosome assembly, including U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein binding. The in vivo experiments lead to comparable conclusions as the sequestering hairpins apparently result in the transport of pre-mRNA to the cytoplasm. The observations are compared with previous data from both yeast and mammalian systems and suggest an important effect of pre-mRNA structure on in vivo splicing.

In vivo recognition of a vertebrate mini-exon as an exon-intron-exon unit

Very small vertebrate exons are problematic for RNA splicing because of the proximity of their 3' and 5' splice sites. In this study, we investigated the recognition of a constitutive 7-nucleotide mini-exon from the troponin I gene that resides quite close to the adjacent upstream exon. The mini-exon failed to be included in spliced RNA when placed in a heterologous gene unless accompanied by the upstream exon. The requirement for the upstream exon disappeared when the mini-exon was internally expanded, suggesting that the splice sites bordering the mini-exon are compatible with those of other constitutive vertebrate exons and that the small size of the exon impaired inclusion. Mutation of the 5' splice site of the natural upstream exon did not result in either exon skipping or activation of a cryptic 5' splice site, the normal vertebrate phenotypes for such mutants. Instead, a spliced RNA accumulated that still contained the upstream intron. In vitro, the mini-exon failed to assemble into spliceosome complexes unless either internally expanded or accompanied by the upstream exon. Thus, impaired usage of the mini-exon in vivo was accompanied by impaired recognition in vitro, and recognition of the mini-exon was facilitated by the presence of the upstream exon in vivo and in vitro. Cumulatively, the atypical in vivo and in vitro properties of the troponin exons suggest a mechanism for the recognition of this mini-exon in which initial recognition of an exon-intron-exon unit is followed by subsequent recognition of the intron.

In vivo recognition of a vertebrate mini-exon as an exon-intron-exon unit

Very small vertebrate exons are problematic for RNA splicing because of the proximity of their 3' and 5' splice sites. In this study, we investigated the recognition of a constitutive 7-nucleotide mini-exon from the troponin I gene that resides quite close to the adjacent upstream exon. The mini-exon failed to be included in spliced RNA when placed in a heterologous gene unless accompanied by the upstream exon. The requirement for the upstream exon disappeared when the mini-exon was internally expanded, suggesting that the splice sites bordering the mini-exon are compatible with those of other constitutive vertebrate exons and that the small size of the exon impaired inclusion. Mutation of the 5' splice site of the natural upstream exon did not result in either exon skipping or activation of a cryptic 5' splice site, the normal vertebrate phenotypes for such mutants. Instead, a spliced RNA accumulated that still contained the upstream intron. In vitro, the mini-exon failed to assemble into spliceosome complexes unless either internally expanded or accompanied by the upstream exon. Thus, impaired usage of the mini-exon in vivo was accompanied by impaired recognition in vitro, and recognition of the mini-exon was facilitated by the presence of the upstream exon in vivo and in vitro. Cumulatively, the atypical in vivo and in vitro properties of the troponin exons suggest a mechanism for the recognition of this mini-exon in which initial recognition of an exon-intron-exon unit is followed by subsequent recognition of the intron.

Cooperation of pre-mRNA sequence elements in splice site selection

We have recently demonstrated that short internal exons in pre-mRNA transcripts with three exons and two introns are ignored by splicing machinery in vitro and in vivo, resulting in exon skipping. Exon skipping is reversed when the pyrimidine content of the polypyrimidine tract in the upstream intron is increased (Z. Dominski and R. Kole, Mol. Cell. Biol. 11:6075-6083, 1991). Here we show that skipping of the short internal exon can be partially reversed by mutations which modify the upstream branch point sequence of the 5' splice site at the end of the exon to their respective consensus sequences. When the modified elements are combined with one another in the same pre-mRNA, exon skipping is fully reversed. Full reversion of exon skipping is also observed when these elements are combined individually with the upstream polypyrimidine tract strengthened by three purine-to-pyrimidine mutations. The observed patterns of splice site selection are similar in vitro (in nuclear extracts from HeLa cells) and in vivo (in transfected HeLa cells). We also show that the length of the downstream intron plays a role in splice site selection. Our data indicate that the interplay between the sequence elements in pre-mRNA controls the outcome of each splicing event, providing the means for very subtle regulation of alternative splicing.

Cooperation of pre-mRNA sequence elements in splice site selection

We have recently demonstrated that short internal exons in pre-mRNA transcripts with three exons and two introns are ignored by splicing machinery in vitro and in vivo, resulting in exon skipping. Exon skipping is reversed when the pyrimidine content of the polypyrimidine tract in the upstream intron is increased (Z. Dominski and R. Kole, Mol. Cell. Biol. 11:6075-6083, 1991). Here we show that skipping of the short internal exon can be partially reversed by mutations which modify the upstream branch point sequence of the 5' splice site at the end of the exon to their respective consensus sequences. When the modified elements are combined with one another in the same pre-mRNA, exon skipping is fully reversed. Full reversion of exon skipping is also observed when these elements are combined individually with the upstream polypyrimidine tract strengthened by three purine-to-pyrimidine mutations. The observed patterns of splice site selection are similar in vitro (in nuclear extracts from HeLa cells) and in vivo (in transfected HeLa cells). We also show that the length of the downstream intron plays a role in splice site selection. Our data indicate that the interplay between the sequence elements in pre-mRNA controls the outcome of each splicing event, providing the means for very subtle regulation of alternative splicing.

Selection of splice sites in pre-mRNAs with short internal exons

Model pre-mRNAs containing two introns and three exons, derived from the human beta-globin gene, were used to study the effects of internal exon length on splice site selection. Splicing was assayed in vitro in HeLa nuclear extracts and in vivo during transient expression in transfected HeLa cells. For substrates with internal exons 87, 104, and 171 nucleotides in length, in vitro splicing proceeded via a regular splicing pathway, in which all three exons were included in the spliced product. Primary transcripts with internal exons containing 23, 29, and 33 nucleotides were spliced by an alternative pathway, in which the first exon was joined directly to the third one. The internal exon was missing from the spliced product and together with two flanking introns was included in a large lariat structure. The same patterns of splicing were retained when transcripts containing 171-, 33-, and 29-nucleotide-long internal exons were spliced in vivo. A transcript containing a 51-nucleotide-long exon was spliced in vitro via both pathways but in vivo generated only a correctly spliced product. Skipping of short internal exons was reversed both in vitro and in vivo when purines in the upstream polypyrimidine tract were replaced by pyrimidines. The changes in the polypyrimidine tract achieved by these substitutions led in vitro to complete (transcripts containing 28 pyrimidines in a row) or partial (transcripts containing 15 pyrimidines in a row) restoration of a regular splicing pathway. Splicing in vivo of these transcripts led exclusively to the spliced product containing all three exons. These results suggest that a balance between the length of the uninterrupted polypyrimidine tract and the length of the exon is an important determinant of the relative strength of the splice sites, ensuring correct splicing patterns of multiintron pre-mRNAs.

Selection of splice sites in pre-mRNAs with short internal exons

Model pre-mRNAs containing two introns and three exons, derived from the human beta-globin gene, were used to study the effects of internal exon length on splice site selection. Splicing was assayed in vitro in HeLa nuclear extracts and in vivo during transient expression in transfected HeLa cells. For substrates with internal exons 87, 104, and 171 nucleotides in length, in vitro splicing proceeded via a regular splicing pathway, in which all three exons were included in the spliced product. Primary transcripts with internal exons containing 23, 29, and 33 nucleotides were spliced by an alternative pathway, in which the first exon was joined directly to the third one. The internal exon was missing from the spliced product and together with two flanking introns was included in a large lariat structure. The same patterns of splicing were retained when transcripts containing 171-, 33-, and 29-nucleotide-long internal exons were spliced in vivo. A transcript containing a 51-nucleotide-long exon was spliced in vitro via both pathways but in vivo generated only a correctly spliced product. Skipping of short internal exons was reversed both in vitro and in vivo when purines in the upstream polypyrimidine tract were replaced by pyrimidines. The changes in the polypyrimidine tract achieved by these substitutions led in vitro to complete (transcripts containing 28 pyrimidines in a row) or partial (transcripts containing 15 pyrimidines in a row) restoration of a regular splicing pathway. Splicing in vivo of these transcripts led exclusively to the spliced product containing all three exons. These results suggest that a balance between the length of the uninterrupted polypyrimidine tract and the length of the exon is an important determinant of the relative strength of the splice sites, ensuring correct splicing patterns of multiintron pre-mRNAs.

Effects of Tnt1 tobacco retrotransposon insertion on target gene transcription

The effects of Tnt1 retrotransposon insertion on nitrate reductase (NR) gene transcription have been analyzed in three NR-deficient insertional, mutants of Nicotiana tabacum. In the three mutants, named h9-Nia4, h9-Nia5 and h9-Nia6, Tnt1 was inserted into exon 3, exon 2 and exon 1 of the nia2 NR alloallelle, respectively. The mutants h9-Nia4 and h9-Nia6, which contained Tnt1 insertions that were oriented opposite to the direction of nia2 gene transcription, expressed chimaeric nia2-Tnt1 RNAs, respectively 12 kb and 10 kb long. The size observed in h9-Nia6 was close to the expected size for a full-length hybrid transcript starting and ending under the control of nia2 signals (about 9 kb). The larger transcript found in h9-Nia4 was shown to be due to a failure to splice the nia2 intron 2. The mutant h9-Nia5, which contained a Tnt1 insertion oriented in parallel with the direction of nia2 transcription expressed two truncated nia2-Tnt1 RNAs, 2 kb and 6.7 kb long. These transcripts arose from termination in the long terminal repeats (LTRs) of Tnt1. Since no full-length hybrid RNA was detected, we suggest that Tnt1 carries efficient termination signals, which are more efficiently recognized in the 3' LTR than in the 5' LTR.

Exon skipping during splicing of dystrophin mRNA precursor due to an intraexon deletion in the dystrophin gene of Duchenne muscular dystrophy kobe

Recent molecular studies have shown that in a patient with Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) Kobe, the size of exon 19 of the dystrophin gene was reduced to 36 bp due to the deletion of 52 bp out of 88 bp of the exon. The consensus sequences at the 5' and 3' splice sites of exon 19 were unaltered (Matsuo, M., et al. 1990. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 170:963-967). To further elucidate the molecular nature of the defect, we examined the primary structure of cytoplasmic dystrophin mRNA of the DMD Kobe patient across the junctions of exons 18, 19, and 20 by gel electrophoresis and sequencing of polymerase chain reaction-amplified cDNA. The mRNA coding for dystrophin was reverse transcribed using random primers, and the cDNA was then enzymatically amplified in vitro. The targeted fragment was smaller than expected from the genomic DNA analysis. By sequencing of the amplified product, we found that exon 18 was joined directly to exon 20, so that exon 19 was completely absent, suggesting that this exon was skipped during processing of the dystrophin mRNA precursor. All other bases in the amplified product were unaltered. Therefore, the data strongly suggest that the internal exon deletion generates an abnormally spliced mRNA in which the sequence of exon 18 is joined to the sequence of exon 20. We propose that the deletion is responsible for abnormal processing of the DMD Kobe allele. This finding has important implications regarding the determinants of a functional splice site.

Beta-globin transcripts carrying a single intron with three adjacent nucleotides of 5' exon are efficiently spliced in vitro irrespective of intron position or surrounding exon sequences

To examine the role of exon sequences and intron position in the splicing of an mRNA precursor, we prepared series of sense or anti-sense transcripts of human beta-globin cDNA in which a cassette containing the beta-globin first intron was inserted into one of seven unusual positions. The intron cassette consisted of the intron alone (ml), the intron with three adjacent base pairs of the 5' exon (MI), or the intron with both 5' and 3' exon sequences. All these transcripts were examined in an in vitro splicing system with a HeLa cell nuclear extract. The sense transcripts carrying MI cassette were spliced efficiently and independently of the intron position, except when the 3' exon was too short. The anti-sense transcripts carrying MI cassette produced significantly less spliced products than did those of the sense transcripts. This was mostly because of the instability of the anti-sense transcripts, and the actual splicing efficiency was similar to that seen in the sense transcripts. Sense or anti-sense transcripts carrying ml cassette were spliced to various extents depending on the surrounding sequences. The results indicate that only three nucleotides of the 5' exon are required as specific exon sequences in the splicing of an mRNA precursor carrying a single intron, and that the intron position does not significantly affect the splicing efficiency in vitro.

Base pairing between the 3' exon and an internal guide sequence increases 3' splice site specificity in the Tetrahymena self-splicing rRNA intron

It has been proposed that recognition of the 3' splice site in many group I introns involves base pairing between the start of the 3' exon and a region of the intron known as the internal guide sequence (R. W. Davies, R. B. Waring, J. Ray, T. A. Brown, and C. Scazzocchio, Nature [London] 300:719-724, 1982). We have examined this hypothesis, using the self-splicing rRNA intron from Tetrahymena thermophila. Mutations in the 3' exon that weaken this proposed pairing increased use of a downstream cryptic 3' splice site. Compensatory mutations in the guide sequence that restore this pairing resulted in even stronger selection of the normal 3' splice site. These changes in 3' splice site usage were more pronounced in the background of a mutation (414A) which resulted in an adenine instead of a guanine being the last base of the intron. These results show that the proposed pairing (P10) plays an important role in ensuring that cryptic 3' splice sites are selected against. Surprisingly, the 414A mutation alone did not result in activation of the cryptic 3' splice site.

Base pairing between the 3' exon and an internal guide sequence increases 3' splice site specificity in the Tetrahymena self-splicing rRNA intron

It has been proposed that recognition of the 3' splice site in many group I introns involves base pairing between the start of the 3' exon and a region of the intron known as the internal guide sequence (R. W. Davies, R. B. Waring, J. Ray, T. A. Brown, and C. Scazzocchio, Nature [London] 300:719-724, 1982). We have examined this hypothesis, using the self-splicing rRNA intron from Tetrahymena thermophila. Mutations in the 3' exon that weaken this proposed pairing increased use of a downstream cryptic 3' splice site. Compensatory mutations in the guide sequence that restore this pairing resulted in even stronger selection of the normal 3' splice site. These changes in 3' splice site usage were more pronounced in the background of a mutation (414A) which resulted in an adenine instead of a guanine being the last base of the intron. These results show that the proposed pairing (P10) plays an important role in ensuring that cryptic 3' splice sites are selected against. Surprisingly, the 414A mutation alone did not result in activation of the cryptic 3' splice site.

Exon definition may facilitate splice site selection in RNAs with multiple exons

Interactions at the 3' end of the intron initiate spliceosome assembly and splice site selection in vertebrate pre-mRNAs. Multiple factors, including U1 small nuclear ribonucleoproteins (snRNPs), are involved in initial recognition at the 3' end of the intron. Experiments were designed to test the possibility that U1 snRNP interaction at the 3' end of the intron during early assembly functions to recognize and define the downstream exon and its resident 5' splice site. Splicing precursor RNAs constructed to have elongated second exons lacking 5' splice sites were deficient in spliceosome assembly and splicing activity in vitro. Similar substrates including a 5' splice site at the end of exon 2 assembled and spliced normally as long as the second exon was less than 300 nucleotides long. U2 snRNPs were required for protection of the 5' splice site terminating exon 2, suggesting direct communication during early assembly between factors binding the 3' and 5' splice sites bordering an exon. We suggest that exons are recognized and defined as units during early assembly by binding of factors to the 3' end of the intron, followed by a search for a downstream 5' splice site. In this view, only the presence of both a 3' and a 5' splice site in the correct orientation and within 300 nucleotides of one another will stable exon complexes be formed. Concerted recognition of exons may help explain the 300-nucleotide-length maximum of vertebrate internal exons, the mechanism whereby the splicing machinery ignores cryptic sites within introns, the mechanism whereby exon skipping is normally avoided, and the phenotypes of 5' splice site mutations that inhibit splicing of neighboring introns.

Exon definition may facilitate splice site selection in RNAs with multiple exons

Interactions at the 3' end of the intron initiate spliceosome assembly and splice site selection in vertebrate pre-mRNAs. Multiple factors, including U1 small nuclear ribonucleoproteins (snRNPs), are involved in initial recognition at the 3' end of the intron. Experiments were designed to test the possibility that U1 snRNP interaction at the 3' end of the intron during early assembly functions to recognize and define the downstream exon and its resident 5' splice site. Splicing precursor RNAs constructed to have elongated second exons lacking 5' splice sites were deficient in spliceosome assembly and splicing activity in vitro. Similar substrates including a 5' splice site at the end of exon 2 assembled and spliced normally as long as the second exon was less than 300 nucleotides long. U2 snRNPs were required for protection of the 5' splice site terminating exon 2, suggesting direct communication during early assembly between factors binding the 3' and 5' splice sites bordering an exon. We suggest that exons are recognized and defined as units during early assembly by binding of factors to the 3' end of the intron, followed by a search for a downstream 5' splice site. In this view, only the presence of both a 3' and a 5' splice site in the correct orientation and within 300 nucleotides of one another will stable exon complexes be formed. Concerted recognition of exons may help explain the 300-nucleotide-length maximum of vertebrate internal exons, the mechanism whereby the splicing machinery ignores cryptic sites within introns, the mechanism whereby exon skipping is normally avoided, and the phenotypes of 5' splice site mutations that inhibit splicing of neighboring introns.

Nucleotide substitutions within the cardiac troponin T alternative exon disrupt pre-mRNA alternative splicing

The cardiac troponin T (cTNT) pre-mRNA contains a single alternative exon (exon 5) which is either included or excluded from the processed mRNA. Using transient transfection of cTNT minigenes, we have previously localized pre-mRNA cis elements required for exon 5 alternative splicing to three small regions of the pre-mRNA which include exons 4, 5, and 6. In the present study, nucleotide substitutions were introduced into the region containing exon 5 to begin to define specific nucleotides required for exon 5 alternative splicing. A mutation within the 5' splice site flanking the cTNT alternative exon that increases its homology to the consensus sequence improves splicing efficiency and leads to increased levels of mRNAs that include the alternative exon. Surprisingly, substitution of as few as four nucleotides within the alternative exon disrupts cTNT pre-mRNA alternative splicing and prevents recognition of exon 5 as a bona fide exon. These results establish that the cTNT alternative exon contains information in cis that is required for its recognition by the splicing machinery.

Alternative processing of bovine growth hormone mRNA is influenced by downstream exon sequences

In a previous report, we described the presence, in pituitary tissue, of an alternatively processed species of bovine growth hormone mRNA from which the last intron (intron D) has not been removed by splicing (R. K. Hampson and F. M. Rottman, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 84:2673-2677, 1987). Using transient expression of the bovine growth hormone gene in Cos I cells, we observed that splicing of intron D was affected by sequences within the downstream exon (exon 5). Deletion of a 115-base-pair FspI-PvuII restriction fragment in exon 5 beginning 73 base pairs downstream of the intron 4-exon 5 junction resulted in cytoplasmic bovine growth hormone mRNA, more than 95% of which retained intron D. This contrasted with less than 5% of the growth hormone mRNA retaining intron D observed with expression of the unaltered gene. Insertion of a 10-base-pair inverted repeat sequence, CTTCCGGAAG, which was located in the middle of this deleted segment, partially reversed this pattern, resulting in cytosolic mRNA from which intron D was predominantly removed. More detailed deletion analysis of this region indicated that multiple sequence elements within the exon 5, in addition to the 10-base-pair inverted repeat sequence, are capable of influencing splicing of intron D. The effect of these exon sequences on splicing of bovine growth hormone precursor mRNA appeared to be specific for the growth hormone intron D. Deletions in exon 5 which resulted in marked alterations in splicing of growth hormone intron D had no effect on splicing when exon 5 of bovine growth hormone was placed downstream of the heterologous bovine prolactin intron D. Deletions in exon 5 which resulted in marked alterations in splicing of growth hormone intron D had no effect on splicing when exon 5 of bovine growth hormone was placed downstream of the heterologous bovine prolactin intron D. The results of this study suggest a unique interaction between sequences located near the center of exon 5 and splicing of the adjacent intron D.

Multiple regions in the Rous sarcoma virus src gene intron act in cis to affect the accumulation of unspliced RNA

Retrovirus replication requires the production of both spliced and unspliced viral RNA from a single RNA transcript. In contrast, cellular RNA precursors with introns almost completely spliced. The cis elements and virus-coded trans factors which determine the extent to which Rous sarcoma virus RNA is spliced to src mRNA were investigated by transfecting chicken embryo fibroblasts with cloned wild-type and mutant DNA followed by the analysis of viral RNA. Two cis-acting regions important in the negative control of splicing were detected. Cell cultures transfected with a clone deleted in 80% of the src intron (nucleotide 1149 to nucleotide 6574) demonstrated only a 2-fold reduction in the ratio of unspliced to spliced RNA relative to the wild-type clone, whereas cultures transfected with clones which were further deleted in the gag gene region (between nucleotide 630 and nucleotide 5258) demonstrated an approximate 20-fold reduction. Cell cultures which were transfected with clones deleted only between nucleotides 543 and 1806 demonstrated only a three- to fourfold reduction in the unspliced-to-spliced RNA ratio, suggesting that at least one other region of the src intron can partially compensate for the deletion of the gag region. Both regions appeared to act in cis on the distribution of unspliced and spliced RNA since the ratios were not altered by cotransfection with helper virus DNA.

Alternative processing of bovine growth hormone mRNA is influenced by downstream exon sequences

In a previous report, we described the presence, in pituitary tissue, of an alternatively processed species of bovine growth hormone mRNA from which the last intron (intron D) has not been removed by splicing (R. K. Hampson and F. M. Rottman, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 84:2673-2677, 1987). Using transient expression of the bovine growth hormone gene in Cos I cells, we observed that splicing of intron D was affected by sequences within the downstream exon (exon 5). Deletion of a 115-base-pair FspI-PvuII restriction fragment in exon 5 beginning 73 base pairs downstream of the intron 4-exon 5 junction resulted in cytoplasmic bovine growth hormone mRNA, more than 95% of which retained intron D. This contrasted with less than 5% of the growth hormone mRNA retaining intron D observed with expression of the unaltered gene. Insertion of a 10-base-pair inverted repeat sequence, CTTCCGGAAG, which was located in the middle of this deleted segment, partially reversed this pattern, resulting in cytosolic mRNA from which intron D was predominantly removed. More detailed deletion analysis of this region indicated that multiple sequence elements within the exon 5, in addition to the 10-base-pair inverted repeat sequence, are capable of influencing splicing of intron D. The effect of these exon sequences on splicing of bovine growth hormone precursor mRNA appeared to be specific for the growth hormone intron D. Deletions in exon 5 which resulted in marked alterations in splicing of growth hormone intron D had no effect on splicing when exon 5 of bovine growth hormone was placed downstream of the heterologous bovine prolactin intron D. Deletions in exon 5 which resulted in marked alterations in splicing of growth hormone intron D had no effect on splicing when exon 5 of bovine growth hormone was placed downstream of the heterologous bovine prolactin intron D. The results of this study suggest a unique interaction between sequences located near the center of exon 5 and splicing of the adjacent intron D.