Determinants of mRNA stability in Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae: differences in poly(A) tail length, ribosome loading, and mRNA size cannot account for the heterogeneity of mRNA decay rates

Genetic and molecular analysis of the temperature-sensitive mutant un-17 carrying a mutation in the gene encoding poly(A)-polymerase in Neurospora crassa

The un-17 mutant was originally isolated as an irreparable temperature-sensitive (ts) mutant in Neurospora crassa. Early experiments showed that cells of this mutant immediately stopped growing and died when the temperature of the culture was shifted from a permissive temperature (25 degrees C) to non-permissive temperature (35 degrees C). This ts phenotype is suppressed by addition of cycloheximide or in some conditions of growth repression. Even at the permissive temperature, it shows a female sterile phenotype and is deficient in production of exocellular superoxide dismutase SOD4 (EC 1.15.1.1). By searching for a DNA fragment that complements the ts phenotype of the un-17 mutant from a N. crassa genome library, we found the un-17 gene. The cloned un-17 gene encodes a homolog of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae poly(A) polymerase (PAP). The un-17 mutant had a one-base substitution mutation in the gene. The cloned un-17 genes from the wild-type strain and the un-17 mutant were introduced into both the un-17 mutant and wild-type strain. The un-17 mutant introduced by un-17 DNA from the wild-type strain showed recovery of both the ts and female sterile phenotypes. Moreover, the purified product derived from the wild-type strain showed PAP activity in vitro. These findings indicate that the un-17 mutant carries a ts mutation in the gene encoding PAP.

Bioinformatic analysis of post-transcriptional regulation by uORF in human and mouse

RNA decay is thought to exert an important influence on gene expression by maintaining a steady-state level of transcripts and/or by eliminating aberrant transcripts. However, the sequence elements which control such processes have not been determined. Upstream open reading frames (uORFs) in the transcripts of several genes are reported to control translational initiation by stalling ribosomes and thereby promote RNA decay. We therefore performed bioinformatic analysis of the tissue-wide expression profiles and mRNA half-life of transcripts containing uORFs in humans and mice to assess the relationship between RNA decay and the presence of uORFs in transcripts. The expression levels of transcripts containing uORF were markedly lower than those not containing uORF. Moreover, the half-life of the uORF-containing transcripts was also shorter. These results suggest that uORFs are sequence elements that down-regulate RNA transcripts via RNA decay mechanisms.

Relationship between mRNA stability and length: an old question with a new twist

The half-life of individual mRNA plays a central role in controlling the level of gene expression. However, the determinants of mRNA stability have not yet been well defined. Most previous studies suggest that mRNA length does not affect its stability. Here, we show significant negative correlations between mRNA length and stability in human and Escherichia coli, but not in Saccharomyces cerevisiae or Bacillus subtilis. This finding suggests the possibility that endonucleolytic attacks by RNA endonuclease and/or mechanical damage may strongly influence mRNA stability in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

Inactivation of SSM4, a new Saccharomyces cerevisiae gene, suppresses mRNA instability due to rna14 mutations

Decay rates of mRNAs depend on many elements and among these, the role of the poly(A) tail is now well established. In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, thermosensitive mutations in two genes, RNA14 and RNA15, result in mRNAs having shorter poly(A) tails and reduced half-life. To identify other components interacting in the same process, we have used a genetic approach to isolate mutations that suppress the thermosensitivity of an rna14 mutant strain. Mutations in a single locus, named SSM4, not only suppress the cell growth phenotype but also the mRNA instability and extend the short mRNA poly(A) tails. The frequency of appearance and the recessive nature of these mutations suggested that the suppressor effect was probably due to a loss of function. We failed to clone the SSM4 gene directly by complementation, owing to its absence from gene banks; it later emerged that the gene is toxic to Escherichia coli, but we have nevertheless been able to clone the SSM4 sequence by Ty element transposition tagging. Disruption of the SSM4 gene does not affect cell viability and suppresses the rna14 mutant phenotypes. The protein encoded by the SSM4 gene has a calculated molecular mass of 151 kDa and does not contain any known motif or show homology with known proteins. The toxicity of the SSM4 gene in E. coli suggests that a direct biochemical activity is associated with the corresponding protein.

Why, when and how does the poly(A) tail shorten during mRNA translation?

1. The length of the poly(A) tail at the 3'-end of mRNA may control protein synthesis by bringing the 3'-end in close proximity to the 5'-end of the noncoding region as well as increasing the duration of mRNA translation by its binding to the poly(A) binding protein. 2. The rate-limiting step in the decay of the body of the message is the shortening of a long poly(A) tail during mRNA translation. The shortening of the poly(A) tail occurs during pre-elongation in the protein synthesis cycle. 3. The shortening of the poly(A) tail during mRNA translation may not involve RNase activity, however poly(A) binding protein seems to play a role, at least in part, in shortening of the poly(A) tail.

Brain non-adenylated mRNAs

Most eukaryotic messenger RNA (mRNA) species contain a 3'-poly(A) tract. The histone mRNAs are a notable exception although a subclass of histone-encoding mRNAs is polyadenylated. A class of mRNAs lacking a poly(A) tail would be expected to be less stable than poly(A)+ mRNAs and might, like the histones, have a half-life that varied in response to changes in the intracellular milieu. Brain mRNA exhibits an unusually high degree of sequence complexity; studies published ten years ago suggested that a large component of this complexity might be present in a poly(A)- mRNA population that was expressed postnatally. The question of the existence of a complex class of poly(A)- brain mRNAs is particularly tantalizing in light of the heterogeneity of brain cells and the possibility that the stability of these poly(A)- mRNAs might vary with changes in synaptic function, changing hormonal stimulation or with other modulations of neuronal function. The mRNA complexity analyses, although intriguing, did not prove the existence of the complex class of poly(A)- brain mRNAs. The observed mRNA complexity could have resulted from a variety of artifacts, discussed in more detail below. Several attempts have been made to clone members of this class of mRNA. This search for specific poly(A)- brain mRNAs has met with only limited success. Changes in mRNA polyadenylation state do occur in brain in response to specific physiologic stimuli; however, both the role of polyadenylation and de-adenylation in specific neuronal activities and the existence and significance of poly(A)- mRNAs in brain remain unclear.

Effects of protein synthesis inhibition on the transcription and transcript stability of Dictyostelium prespore genes

The in vivo accumulation of several prespore transcripts of Dictyostelium discoideum has previously been shown to depend upon concomitant protein synthesis (Ratner, D.I., Pentz, W.H. and Pelletier, D.A. (1989) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 1008, 71-78). Measurements of in vivo mRNA decay and nuclear run-on transcription assays have now been used to learn whether protein synthesis is required primarily for mRNA synthesis or transcript stability. The translational inhibitors cycloheximide and pactamycin stabilized existing prespore transcripts, despite their effect upon mRNA accumulation. Transcriptional assays, performed at intervals throughout the developmental cycle, demonstrated that temporal changes in the abundance of several cell-specific transcripts correlated closely with changes in their rates of synthesis. Finally, blocking protein synthesis strongly inhibited the transcription of the prespore genes examined. These results imply that one or more developmentally regulated, labile proteins are needed for the activation of prespore gene transcription.

Turnover rate of yeast PGK mRNA can be changed by specific alterations in its trailer structure

The effect of insertions in the 5'- and 3'-untranslated regions (UTR) of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae mRNA encoding phosphoglycerate kinase (PGK) on the stability of the transcript in vivo was determined. None of the structural alterations in the 5'-UTR affected mRNA turnover significantly, despite the strong negative effect on translational efficiency of some of these alterations previously observed. We conclude that the structure of the 5'-UTR is not important for the relatively high affinity of PGK mRNA in yeast cells. Moreover, translation cannot be a major factor in determining the rate of turnover of this mRNA. Insertion of either a polyG or polyU, but not a polyA or polyC, tract into the 3'-UTR of PGK mRNA increased its half-life by a factor of about two. Introduction of a hairpin structure containing 18 G.C base pairs had only a slight stabilizing effect. We argue that the stabilization by the structural changes in the 3'-UTR is due to altered folding of the mutant mRNA which retards a rate-limiting endonucleolytic cleavage step in the normal turnover pathway of PGK mRNA. The stabilizing effect of local structural alterations in the 3'-UTR opens the possibility for further increasing the product yield of a (heterologous) gene cloned in yeast cells.

Tales of poly(A): a review

Until recently, evidence to support a translational role for the 3'-poly(A) tract of eukaryotic mRNAs has been mostly indirect, including: a correlation between the adenylation status of individual mRNAs and their translatability in vivo or in vitro, the demonstration that exogenously added poly(A) is a potent competitive inhibitor of the translation of poly(A)+mRNA, but not poly(A)-mRNAs in vitro, and a correlation between the abundance and stability of poly(A)-binding proteins (PABPs) and the rate of translational initiation in vivo. However, more recent studies demonstrate directly that poly(A)+mRNAs can initiate translation more efficiently than poly(A)-mRNAs, and indicate that this effect is: (i) targeted to the formation of 80S initiation complexes, and (ii) likely to be mediated by the cytoplasmic PABP. We suggest that the 3'-poly(A) tail should be considered a translational enhancer which may stimulate translational initiation in much the same way that transcriptional enhancers are thought to stimulate transcriptional initiation.

Dictyostelium erasure mutant HI4 abnormally retains development-specific mRNAs during dedifferentiation

The Dictyostelium mutant HI4 progresses through morphogenesis normally, but is defective in the reverse program of dedifferentiation. In contrast to dedifferentiating wild-type cells, HI4 cells retain the capacity to rapidly reaggregate well after the "erasure event" employing a nonchemotactic aggregation mechanism involving random collisions and cohesion. They also do not lose contact sites A (gp80) at the prescribed time in the dedifferentiation program. HI4 cells accumulate transcripts of the cysteine protease gene CP2 (formerly referred to as 16G1) and the cohesion glycoprotein gene gp80 at the correct times in the morphogenetic program, but abnormally retain these transcripts at high levels well after the prescribed times at which they are lost in wild-type cells during the reverse program of dedifferentiation. The retention of these mRNAs in HI4 cells after the erasure event is not due to abnormal maintenance of a high level of intracellular cAMP during dedifferentiation. The rapid reduction in the level of gp80 transcript which can be effected by the addition of cAMP prior to the erasure event in wild-type cells is also retained by HI4 cells well after the erasure event. The results suggest that cells possess at least two mechanisms for the reduction of gp80 transcript. One involves the immediate response to cAMP and may function during the forward program of development. The second functions specifically during the reverse program of dedifferentiation. It is this latter, erasure-specific mechanism which is selectively defective in the HI4 variant.

Cloning and sequencing of a complementary deoxyribonucleic acid coding for a bovine alpha s1-casein A from mammary tissue of a homozygous B variant cow

A cDNA clone for bovine alpha s1-casein variant A was isolated from a mammary gland cDNA library using a synthetic degenerate oligonucleotide probe. The largest Pst I insert containing an EcoR I site was sequenced. It contained 1090 base pairs, 47 in the 5' noncoding region, 603 in the coding region and 440 in the 3' noncoding region. The nucleotide sequence was compared with three published cDNA sequences for alpha s1-casein variant B. The most obvious difference was the absence of the 39 bases encoding the 13 amino acids that are present in the B variant but absent from the A variant. In addition, five other single base positions differed within individual codons among the four sequences at the third base for each codon, but this did not change the amino acids encoded. There were, however, a number of differences found in the 3' noncoding region. The isolated cDNA was subjected to site-directed mutagenesis to replace a Val-Ile dipeptide with Phe-Phe to increase the chymosin sensitivity of the protein. When the milk proteins from mammary gland tissue extracts were typed, the alpha s1-casein A gene product was not detected.

The poly(A) binding protein is required for poly(A) shortening and 60S ribosomal subunit-dependent translation initiation

Depletion of the essential poly(A) binding protein (PAB) in S. cerevisiae by promoter inactivation or by the utilization of a temperature-sensitive mutation (pab1-F364L) results in the inhibition of translation initiation and poly(A) tail shortening. Reversion analysis of pab1-F364L yielded seven independent, extragenic cold-sensitive mutations (spb1-spb7) that also suppress a PAB1 deletion. These mutations allow translation initiation without significantly changing poly(A) tail lengths in the absence of PAB, and they affect the amount of 60S ribosomal subunit. Consistent with this, SPB2 encodes the ribosomal protein L46. These data suggest that the 60S subunit mediates the PAB requirement of translation initiation, thereby ensuring that only intact poly(A)+ mRNA will be translated efficiently in vivo.

Poly(A), poly(A) binding protein and the regulation of mRNA stability

This review has focused on the possibility that interactions between mRNA sequences and the poly(A)-nucleoprotein complex play important roles in mRNA turnover. It is important to stress that additional genetic and biochemical tests are necessary to characterize how PABP interacts with mRNA in cells and to determine whether the poly(A) protection hypothesis is accurate. Moreover, there may be a significant number of mRNAs whose half-lives are independent of polyadenylation. For example, the stabilities of poly(A)-containing and deadenylated alpha 2u-globulin and interferon mRNAs are similar in microinjected oocytes. Thus, an important challenge in this field will be to analyse the complex and interactive factors that determine the half-lives of specific mRNAs.

Accelerated poly(A) loss on alpha-tubulin mRNAs during protein synthesis inhibition in Chlamydomonas

Detachment of flagella in Chlamydomonas reinhardii stimulates a rapid accumulation of tubulin mRNAs. The induced tubulin mRNAs are normally rapidly degraded following flagellar regeneration, but inhibition of protein synthesis with cycloheximide prevents their degradation. alpha-Tubulin poly(A) tail lengths were measured during normal accumulation and degradation, and in cycloheximide-treated cells. To measure alpha-tubulin mRNA poly(A) chain lengths with high resolution, specific 3' fragments of alpha 1- and alpha 2-tubulin mRNAs, generated by RNase H digestion of mRNA-oligonucleotide hybrids, were sized by Northern analysis. Both alpha-tubulin mRNAs have a newly synthesized poly(A) chain of about 110 adenylate residues. The poly(A) tails shorten with time, and show an average length of 40 to 60 adenylate residues by 90 minutes after deflagellation, at which time induced alpha-tubulin mRNA is being rapidly degraded. Poly(A) loss is significantly accelerated in cycloheximide-treated cells, and this loss is not attributible simply to the longer time the stabilized molecules spend in the cytoplasm. A large fraction of alpha-tubulin mRNA accumulates as mRNA with very short poly(A) tails (less than 10 residues) in the presence of cycloheximide, indicating that deadenylated alpha-tubulin mRNAs can be stable in vivo, at least in the absence of protein synthesis. The rate and extent of poly(A) loss in cycloheximide are greater for alpha 2-tubulin mRNA than for alpha 1-tubulin mRNA. This difference cannot be attributed to differential ribosome loading. This finding is interesting in that the two mRNAs are very similar in sequence with the exception of their 3' untranslated regions.

Visualizing mRNA expression in plant protoplasts: factors influencing efficient mRNA uptake and translation

In this paper we demonstrate that RNA sequences present upstream and downstream of a reporter gene coding region play an important role in determining the amount of protein produced from an mRNA. A translational enhancer, omega, derived from tobacco mosaic virus, when present at the 5'-end of beta-glucuronidase mRNA increased the efficiency of translation 16-fold to 18-fold in electroporated tobacco or carrot protoplasts, and threefold to 11-fold in maize or rice protoplasts. The presence of omega did not alter the half-life of the mRNA in vivo. We also demonstrate for the first time that a minimum polyadenylated tail length of 25 adenylate residues is sufficient to substantially increase the expression and half-life of the reporter mRNA in plants. When in vitro-produced mRNAs were synthesized such that extra sequence was added to the 3'-end of the poly(A) tail, however, the final level of expression was decreased up to 80%. Omega, the translational enhancer, and a poly(A) tail function independently of each other; their combined effect on translation, when both are present in an mRNA, is the multiplication of their individual effects. Histochemical analysis for the presence of beta-glucuronidase in tobacco established that virtually all viable cells receive mRNA during electroporation. Video image analysis of tobacco protoplasts electroporated with luciferase mRNA demonstrated that there is a wide range in the level of expression of this marker. Carrier RNA, when present during electroporation, had only a modest effect on increasing mRNA uptake. Reporter mRNA expression in electroporated protoplasts was directly proportional to the input mRNA up to at least 30 micrograms/ml.

Characterization of genes which are transiently expressed during the preaggregative phase of development of Dictyostelium discoideum

We have identified and characterized three genes, the I genes (I for induced), which are induced during the preaggregative phase of the developmental program of Dictyostelium discoideum. None of these genes are expressed in cells growing vegetatively on bacteria or in axenic broth, and their induction during early development is due to transcriptional activation. Developmental expression of I6, I8, and I11 occurs even in the absence of protein synthesis. Their induction is very rapid and occurs essentially at the onset of development. The expression is transient, peaking between 2 and 4 hr followed by a rapid loss of expression. These characteristics suggest that the induction of I6, I8, and I11 is a primary result of the initiation of development, and thus they represent the first such genes isolated. Although their expression behavior shares these characteristics, examination of their expression under various conditions of development and in a variety of aggregation-deficient mutant strains reveals that the details of the regulation and developmental control of these three genes are distinct.

Deactivation of gene expression upon the onset of development in dictyostelium discoideum

Several genes that are deactivated upon the initiation of development of Dictyostelium discoideum have been identified by differential screening of various cDNA libraries. These genes have in common a decrease in the steady-state levels of their corresponding mRNAs as development proceeds. When development was carried out in the absence of protein synthesis by inhibition with cycloheximide, the decrease in mRNA levels for most genes (V genes) was normal or slightly accelerated. However, for about 5% of the genes (H genes), cycloheximide caused an apparent induction of expression, as revealed by a slight or dramatic increase in mRNA levels instead of the normal decrease. This effect was due to inhibition of protein synthesis and not to cycloheximide per se. The induction was found to be due to an enhancement of the transcription rate; normal rates of transcription for the H genes were dependent upon continued protein synthesis during vegetative growth and during development. Thus, two general regulatory classes exist for deactivation of gene expression upon initiation of development, one dependent and one independent of protein synthesis. Models concerning the control of expression of these two classes of genes are discussed here. Analysis of expression of these genes in mutant strains that are aggregation-deficient has also been performed, and the results lead to subdivisions of the classes.

Regulation of mRNA stability and the poly(A) problem in Dictyostelium discoideum

This paper reviews our studies of three aspects of post-transcriptional regulation in Dictyostelium discoideum: 1) the determinants of mRNA stability in vegetative amoebae; 2) the effects of disaggregation and cyclic AMP on the decay rates of cell-type-specific mRNAs in late developing cells; and 3) the cytoplasmic function of the 3' poly(A) tracts present on most mRNAs. We find that: 1) mRNA stability in vegetative amoebae is not dependent on mRNA size, ribosome loading, or poly(A) tract length, but may be determined by specific 3'-untranslated sequences within a given mRNA; 2) mRNA decay rates in late developing cells are heterogeneous, and cyclic AMP does not act directly to stabilize cell-type-specific mRNAs; and 3) poly(A) is most likely involved in the initiation of protein synthesis via an interaction with cytoplasmic poly(A)-binding proteins.

Post-transcriptional regulation of ribosomal protein gene expression during development in Dictyostelium discoideum

We have isolated recombinant plasmids that contain cDNA inserts complementary to mRNAs encoding six different r-proteins of Dictyostelium discoideum. Southern and quantitative dot blot analyses have shown that each of the r-protein genes represented in these plasmids is encoded by a single copy gene and that these genes are not tightly linked to each other. We have determined the relative amount of the six r-protein mRNAs present in cells at intervals throughout development and find that for the first 9 hours of development, each of the mRNAs remains present at virtually the same level as in vegetatively growing cells. Between 9 and 11 hours of development, there is a rapid loss of these mRNAs to 15% or less of vegetative levels, and that low level remains, or slightly declines, through the late stages of development. We have shown that two post-transcriptional events contribute to the developmental regulation of the expression of the r-protein genes. The first involves a specific block to translational initiation that is not the result of inactivation of these mRNAs by decapping or deadenylation. The second is a change in the stability of these mRNAs during early development. In order to begin to analyze the role of specific sequences that may act as targets or signals in these events, we have cloned and sequenced a 1.9-kb genomic DNA fragment that encodes one of the r-proteins. We find that transcription of this gene begins in a pyrimidine-rich region that is not preceded by a TATA box, the gene contains a single intron of 350 bp, and there are two alternative 3' processing sites. In addition, the 5'-untranslated region of the transcript contains an unusually high percentage of G and C residues relative to other Dictyostelium mRNAs.