Characterization of mutant mitochondrial plasmids of Neurospora spp. that have incorporated tRNAs by reverse transcription

Horizontal transfer of tRNA genes to mitochondrial plasmids facilitates gene loss from fungal mitochondrial DNA

Fungal and plant mitochondria are known to exchange DNA with retroviral plasmids. Transfer of plasmid DNA to the organellar genome is best known and occurs through wholesale insertion of the plasmid. Less well known is the transfer of organellar DNA to plasmids, in particular tRNA genes. Presently, it is unknown whether fungal plasmids can adopt mitochondrial functions such as tRNA production through horizontal gene transfer. In this paper, we studied the exchange of DNA between fungal linear plasmids and fungal mtDNA, mainly focusing on the basidiomycete family Lyophyllaceae. We report at least six independent transfers of complete tRNA genes to fungal plasmids. Furthermore, we discovered two independent cases of loss of a tRNA gene from a fungal mitochondrial genome following transfer of such a gene to a linear mitochondrial plasmid. We propose that loss of a tRNA gene from mtDNA following its transfer to a plasmid creates a mutualistic dependency of the host mtDNA on the plasmid. We also find that tRNA genes transferred to plasmids encode codons that occur at the lowest frequency in the host mitochondrial genomes, possibly due to a higher number of unused transcripts. We discuss the potential consequences of mtDNA transfer to plasmids for both the host mtDNA and the plasmid.

Coevolution Theory of the Genetic Code at Age Forty: Pathway to Translation and Synthetic Life

The origins of the components of genetic coding are examined in the present study. Genetic information arose from replicator induction by metabolite in accordance with the metabolic expansion law. Messenger RNA and transfer RNA stemmed from a template for binding the aminoacyl-RNA synthetase ribozymes employed to synthesize peptide prosthetic groups on RNAs in the Peptidated RNA World. Coevolution of the genetic code with amino acid biosynthesis generated tRNA paralogs that identify a last universal common ancestor (LUCA) of extant life close to Methanopyrus, which in turn points to archaeal tRNA introns as the most primitive introns and the anticodon usage of Methanopyrus as an ancient mode of wobble. The prediction of the coevolution theory of the genetic code that the code should be a mutable code has led to the isolation of optional and mandatory synthetic life forms with altered protein alphabets.

Origins and Early Evolution of the tRNA Molecule

Modern transfer RNAs (tRNAs) are composed of ~76 nucleotides and play an important role as "adaptor" molecules that mediate the translation of information from messenger RNAs (mRNAs). Many studies suggest that the contemporary full-length tRNA was formed by the ligation of half-sized hairpin-like RNAs. A minihelix (a coaxial stack of the acceptor stem on the T-stem of tRNA) can function both in aminoacylation by aminoacyl tRNA synthetases and in peptide bond formation on the ribosome, indicating that it may be a vestige of the ancestral tRNA. The universal CCA-3' terminus of tRNA is also a typical characteristic of the molecule. "Why CCA?" is the fundamental unanswered question, but several findings give a comprehensive picture of its origin. Here, the origins and early evolution of tRNA are discussed in terms of various perspectives, including nucleotide ligation, chiral selectivity of amino acids, genetic code evolution, and the organization of the ribosomal peptidyl transferase center (PTC). The proto-tRNA molecules may have evolved not only as adaptors but also as contributors to the composition of the ribosome.

Senescence in fungi: the view from Neurospora

Some naturally occurring strains of fungi cease growing through successive subculturing, i.e., they senesce. In Neurospora, senescing strains usually contain intramitochondrial linear or circular plasmids. An entire plasmid or its part(s) integrates into the mtDNA, causing insertional mutagenesis. The functionally defective mitochondria replicate faster than the wild-type mitochondria and spread through interconnected hyphal cells. Senescence could also be due to spontaneous lethal nuclear gene mutations arising in the multinucleated mycelium. However, their phenotypic effects remain masked until the nuclei segregate into a homokaryotic spore, and the spore germinates to form a mycelium that is incapable of extended culturing. Ultimately the growth of a fungal colony ceases due to dysfunctional oxidative phosphorylation. Results with senescing nuclear mutants or growth-impaired cytoplasmic mutants suggest that mtDNA is inherently unstable, requiring protection by as yet unidentified nuclear-gene-encoded factors for normal functioning. Interestingly, these results are in accord with the endosymbiotic theory of origin of eukaryotic cells.

Characterization and prevalence of a circular mitochondrial plasmid in senescence-prone isolates of Neurospora intermedia

Genetic and molecular analyses of the phenomenon of senescence-i.e., irreversible loss of growth and reproductive potential upon subculturing-in Neurospora intermedia strain M1991-60A, collected from Maddur in southern India, showed the presence of plasmid pMaddur1, which is homologous to the senescence-inducing circular mitochondrial plasmid, pVarkud. Maternal inheritance of senescence in M1991-60A correlated to the formation of variant pMaddur1, its subsequent insertion into mitochondrial (mt)DNA and the accumulation of defective mtDNA with the pMaddur1insert. PCR-based analyses for similar plasmids in 147 natural isolates of Neurospora from Maddur showed that nearly 40% of the strains had pMaddur1 or pMaddur2 that shared 97-98% sequence homology with pVarkud and pMauriceville. Nearly 50% of the strains that harbored either pMaddur1 or pMaddur2, also contained a circular Varkud satellite plasmid (pVS). Size polymorphism maps to the cluster of PstI sites in the non-coding region. Whereas senescence of nearly 40% of N. intermedia strains may be due to pMaddur, the presence in seven strains of pVS but not pMaddur and the absence of either of these two plasmids in other senescence-prone isolates suggests yet undiscovered mechanisms of senescence in the Maddur strains.

Complete DNA sequence and analysis of a mitochondrial plasmid in the mycoparasitic Trichoderma harzianum strain T95

A circular plasmid called pThr1, with a monomer size of 2.6 kb, was identified in the mitochondria of a Trichoderma harzianum isolate. Hybridization studies using cloned plasmids revealed no DNA sequence similarity between the plasmid and the mitochondrial genome of the isolate. The complete sequence of the plasmid was determined, and the sequence analysis revealed that it contained a single long open reading frame of 1818 bp. Sequence comparisons indicated that the derived amino acid sequence of the ORF exhibited similarity to the reverse transcriptases of the circular Mauriceville and Varkud retroplasmids of Neurospora spp. and the linear pFOXC2 and pFOXC3 retroplasmids of Fusarium oxysporum strains. In the regions of homology all of the seven conserved amino acid blocks characteristic of RTs could be found.

Role of Mitochondrial DNA in the Senescence and Hypovirulence of Fungi and Potential for Plant Disease Control

The unique coenocytic anatomy of the mycelia of the filamentous fungi and the formation of anastomoses between hyphae from different mycelia enable the intracellular accumulation and infectious transmission of plasmids and mutant mitochondrial DNAs (mtDNAs) that cause senescence. For reasons that are not fully apparent, mitochondria that are rendered dysfunctional by so-called "suppressive" mtDNA mutations proliferate rapidly in growing cells and gradually displace organelles that contain wild-type mtDNA molecules and are functional. The consequence of this process is senescence and death if the suppressive mtDNA contains a lethal mutation. Suppressive mtDNA mutations and mitochondrial plasmids can elicit cytoplasmically transmissible "mitochondrial hypovirulence" syndromes in at least some of the phytopathogenic fungi. In the chestnut-blight fungus Cryphonectria parasitica, the pattern of asexual transmission of mutant mtDNAs and mitochondrial plasmids resembles the pattern of "infectious" transmission displayed by the attenuating virus that is most commonly used for the biological control of this fungus. At least some of the attenuating mitochondrial hypovirulence factors are inherited maternally in crosses, whereas the viruses are not transmitted sexually. The natural control of blight in an isolated stand of chestnut trees has resulted from the invasion of the local population of C. parasitica by a senescence-inducing mutant mtDNA. Moreover, a mitochondrial plasmid, pCRY1, attenuates at least some virulent strains of C. parasitica, suggesting that such factors could be applied to control plant diseases caused by fungi.

Characterization of an unusual tRNA-like sequence found inserted in a Neurospora retroplasmid

We characterized an unusual tRNA-like sequence that had been found inserted in suppressive variants of the mitochondrial retroplasmid of Neurospora intermedia strain Varkud. We previously identified two forms of the tRNA-like sequence, one of 64 nt (TRL-64)and the other of 78 nt (TRL-78) containing a 14-nt internal insertion in the anticodon stem at a position expected for a nuclear tRNA intron. Here, we show that TRL-78 is encoded in Varkud mitochondrial (mt)DNA within a 7 kb sequence that is not present in Neurospora crassa wild-type 74A mtDNA. This 7-kb insertion also contains a perfectly duplicated tRNA(Trp)gene, segments of several mitochondrial plasmids and numerous GC-rich pallindromic sequences that are repeated elsewhere in the mtDNA. The mtDNA-encoded copy of TRL-78 is transcribed and apparently undergoes 5'- and 3'-end processing and 3' nucleotide addition by tRNA nucleotidyl transferase to yield a discrete tRNA-sized molecule. However, the 14 nt intron-like sequence in TRL-78, which is missing in the TRL-64 form, is not spliced detectably in vivo or in vitro. Our results show that TRL-78 is an unusual tRNA-like species that could be incorporated into suppressive retroplasmids by the same reverse transcription mechanism used to incorporate mt tRNAs. The tRNA-like sequence may have been derived from an intron-containing nuclear tRNA gene or it may serve some function, like tmRNA. Our results suggest that mtRNAs or tRNA-like species may be integrated into mtDNA via reverse transcription, analogous to SINE elements in animal cells.

Identification of a novel human tRNA(Ser(CGA)) functional in murine leukemia virus replication

We have identified a human tRNA(Ser) isoacceptor matching the UCG codon. The tRNA was discovered via its ability to act in reverse transcription of a murine leukemia virus vector containing a complementary tRNA primer binding site (Lund et al., Nucleic Acids Res., 28 (2000) 791-799). The tRNA(Ser(CGA)) was detected in cell lines of human, monkey and mouse origin. The UCG codon is the most rarely used codon in human genes. The cloned human tRNA(Ser(CGA)) gene encodes an 85 nucleotide, intron-less tRNA, contains a consensus split intragenic promoter and is located at region p21.3-22.2 on chromosome 6. The integrity and functionality of the cloned tRNA(Ser(CGA)) gene was verified by in vitro transcription analysis in HeLa nuclear extracts.

Characterization of an unusual tRNA-like sequence found inserted in a Neurospora retroplasmid

We characterized an unusual tRNA-like sequence that had been found inserted in suppressive variants of the mitochondrial retroplasmid of Neurospora intermedia strain Varkud. We previously identified two forms of the tRNA-like sequence, one of 64 nt (TRL-64) and the other of 78 nt (TRL-78) containing a 14-nt internal insertion in the anticodon stem at a position expected for a nuclear tRNA intron. Here, we show that TRL-78 is encoded in Varkud mitochondrial (mt)DNA within a 7 kb sequence that is not present in Neurospora crassa wild-type 74 A mtDNA. This 7-kb insertion also contains a perfectly duplicated tRNA(Trp)gene, segments of several mitochondrial plasmids and numerous GC-rich palindromic sequences that are repeated elsewhere in the mtDNA. The mtDNA-encoded copy of TRL-78 is transcribed and apparently undergoes 5'- and 3'-end processing and 3' nucleotide addition by tRNA nucleotidyl transferase to yield a discrete tRNA-sized molecule. However, the 14 nt intron-like sequence in TRL-78, which is missing in the TRL-64 form, is not spliced detectably in vivo or in vitro. Our results show that TRL-78 is an unusual tRNA-like species that could be incorporated into suppressive retroplasmids by the same reverse transcription mechanism used to incorporate mt tRNAs. The tRNA-like sequence may have been derived from an intron-containing nuclear tRNA gene or it may serve some function, like mtRNA. Our results suggest that mt tRNAs or tRNA-like species may be integrated into mtDNA via reverse transcription, analogous to SINE elements in animal cells.

De novo and DNA primer-mediated initiation of cDNA synthesis by the mauriceville retroplasmid reverse transcriptase involve recognition of a 3' CCA sequence

The Mauriceville mitochondrial retroplasmid of Neurospora encodes a novel reverse transcriptase that initiates cDNA synthesis at a 3' tRNA-like structure of the plasmid transcript, either de novo (i.e. without a primer) or by using the 3' OH group of a DNA primer. Both the de novo and primer-mediated initiations involve recognition of structural features at the 3' end of the retroplasmid transcript, which ends with a 3' CCACCA. Here, detailed biochemical characterization of the retroplasmid reverse transcriptase shows that the 3' CCA of the plasmid transcript is the major structural feature recognized by the reverse transcriptase for both the de novo and primer-mediated initiations. Complementarity between the DNA primer and RNA template is not required for the primer-mediated initiation, although short (1 to 3 nt) base-pairing interactions can influence both the efficiency and site of initiation near the 3' end of the transcript. Single nucleotide changes in the 3' CCA lead to less efficient initiation in the upstream CCA with an increased propensity to add extra "non-coded" nucleotides to the 5' end of the cDNA during de novo initiation or to the 3' end of the primer during primer-mediated initiation. Secondary structure features upstream of the 3' CCA also influence the efficiency of initiation, but are not stringently required in vitro. Finally, we find that the retroplasmid reverse transcriptase does not efficiently use DNA primers that are base-paired to internal positions in the RNA template, nor does it use analogs of natural substrates used by non-long terminal repeat retrotransposon or retroviral reverse transcriptases. Our results indicate that the retroplasmid reverse transcriptase is uniquely adapted to initiate cDNA synthesis by recognizing a 3' CCA sequence. The ability to recognize a specific template sequence is common for RNA polymerases, but unprecedented for a reverse transcriptase.

The Mauriceville and Varkud plasmids: primitive retroelements found inNeurosporamitochondria

The Mauriceville and closely related Varkud plasmids are small circular DNAs (3.6 and 3.7 kb, respectively) found in the mitochondria of certain Neurospora spp. strains isolated from nature. The plasmids replicate via reverse transcription and appear to be primitive retroelements that may be related to the early ancestors of retroviruses. Recent studies have shown that the plasmid reverse transcriptase closely resembles certain viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerases in initiating (−) strand cDNA synthesis de novo (i.e., without a primer) at a tRNA-like structure at the 3′ end of the plasmid transcript. The plasmid reverse transcriptase can also use DNA or RNA primers and can carry out template-switching reactions that lead to the generation of suppressive mutant plasmids or the integration of the plasmids into mitochondrial DNA. The characteristics of the plasmids and their reverse transcription mechanism suggest an evolutionary connection between RNA and DNA replication and raise the possibility that the plasmids are related to the earliest DNA-based life forms that emerged at the time of transition from an RNA to a DNA world. Key words: DNA synthesis, evolution, retrovirus, reverse transcriptase, RNA virus.

Recombinant mitochondrial plasmids in Neurospora composed of Varkud and a new multimeric mitochondrial plasmid

A mitochondrial plasmid, V5124, in Neurospora intermedia isolate 5124 has a deletion in its sequence relative to the highly similar Mauriceville and Varkud plasmids. These insertions in the latter plasmids are 28 bp in length and are positioned at sites that correspond to their major transcript 5' termini. The 28-bp sequence is nearly identical to a putative processing site upstream of the ND4L gene on the mitochondrial genome. The absence of this 28-bp sequence in V5124 apparently results in transcripts whose 5' termini correspond to an upstream consensus promoter sequence. Two variant forms of V5124 coexist with V5124 and have either of two similar 0.3-kb inserts positioned exactly as is the 28-bp insert in Varkud. These long inserts are chimeric, partly deriving from a newly discovered multimeric plasmid, MP. MP has significant similarity to a short region of the mitochondrial satellite plasmid VS. Another part of the 0.3-kb inserts in V5124 variants derives from the mitochondrial genome, within restriction fragment EcoRI-8. Neurospora mitochondria in many isolates can have several types of mitochondrial plasmids belonging to different homology groups. We propose that a common ancestral plasmid acquired insertions from either the mitochondrial genome or from other plasmids. The V5124 variants are the first instance of a chimeric mitochondrial plasmid in which distinct plasmids have recombined. This recombination proves that different plasmids coexist currently, or else did so at some point in their evolution, within a single mitochondrion.

The Mauriceville plasmid reverse transcriptase can initiate cDNA synthesis de novo and may be related to reverse transcriptase and DNA polymerase progenitor

We show that the reverse transcriptase (RT) encoded by the Mauriceville mitochondrial plasmid of Neurospora closely resembles viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerases in initiating cDNA synthesis opposite the penultimate C residue of a 3' tRNA-like structure and has the unprecedented ability for a DNA polymerase to initiate DNA synthesis at a specific site in a natural template without a primer. The Mauriceville plasmid enzyme can also use DNA or RNA primers in a manner suggesting how a primitive RT could have evolved from an RNA-dependent RNA polymerase into retroviral and other types of RTs. The characteristics of the Mauriceville plasmid RT suggest that it may be related to the progenitor of present-day RTs and DNA polymerases.

Plasmid diversity in senescent and nonsenescent strains of Neurospora

A sample of 171 natural isolates of Neurospora crassa and Neurospora intermedia was tested for senescence. Of these, 28 strains senesced within the duration of the experiment. These senescent strains, together with a selection of nonsenescent strains, were examined for the presence of mitochondrial plasmids. This was done by digesting mitochondrial DNA preparations with proteinase K, and running these samples on agarose gels. Most of the strains examined, both senescent and nonsenescent, contained plasmids, many of them new. Some new plasmids were linear, as inferred from their resistance to 5' exonuclease and sensitivity to 3' exonuclease. New circular plasmids were also found. Some strains carry several plasmids, and mixtures of circular and linear elements were common. A cross-homology study was performed on a sample of plasmid-bearing strains, and several cases of apparent relatedness were found, some between strains from distant geographical locations. Linear plasmids homologous to the maranhar linear senescence plasmid were quite common. A new member of the LaBelle circular plasmid homology group was found. In the sample tested for homology, no strains contained elements related to the kalilo linear senescence plasmid. The relationship of the new plasmids to senescence is not known. In addition to plasmid monomers, several different types of derivatives were found. The kalilo linear plasmid was found to occur in linear and circular forms of low mobility, presumed to be giant concatamers, and, in some strains, variant sibling structures and ladders of short derivatives were found. Circular plasmids also gave rise to extensive ladders on electrophoresis, probably representing different relaxation states and head-to-tail concatameric series. Some such forms migrated more slowly than mitochondrial DNA. One unique type of plasmid modification observed was a pair of linear elements that had apparently arisen de novo which showed homology to a circular plasmid.

Characterization of circular mitochondrial plasmids in three Pythium species

Four circular plasmids, with a monomer size ranging from 3.2 to 4.94 kb, have been identified in isolates of P. aphanidermatum (two different plasmids), P. torulosum, and an unidentified echinulate isolate. The mitochondrial location has been confirmed for three of the plasmids. Each fungal isolate contained a single plasmid, present in both monomeric and oligomeric forms; plasmid monomers were present as open circles and as supercoiled forms. Restriction maps of the plasmids were dissimilar. Hybridization studies using cloned plasmids revealed no DNA sequence similarity among the different plasmids or between the plasmids and the nuclear or mitochondrial genome of the isolates from which they were recovered. Hybridization of labeled plasmid DNA to Northern transfers of mitochondrial RNA for two isolates indicate that what appears to be the predominant RNA transcript is unit length in size. For three isolates, the plasmid was retained following subculturing and was present in all asexual and sexual single-spore progeny evaluated. For one isolate of P. aphanidermatum the plasmid was unstable and was lost during subculturing.

Analysis of large deletions in the Mauriceville and Varkud mitochondrial plasmids of Neurospora

The Mauriceville and Varkud mitochondrial plasmids are closely related, closed-circular DNAs (3.6 and 3.7 kb, respectively) that have characteristics of mtDNA introns and retroid elements. Both plasmids contain a 710 amino acid open reading frame (ORF) that encodes an 81 kDa protein having reverse transcriptase activity. Here, we analyzed two mutant plasmids, V5-36 and M3-24, that have undergone relatively large deletions (approximately 0.35 and 0.5 kb, respectively). Both deletions occur downstream of the long ORF in a non-coding region of the plasmids that contains a direct repeat of 160 bp and a cluster of five PstI-palindromes, a repetitive sequence element in Neurospora mtDNA. In V5-36, the deletion end points are at the bases of two hairpin structures that are centered around PstI-palindromes and flank the deleted region. In M3-24, the deletion junction contains an extra T-residue that is not encoded in the plasmid. In both plasmids, the deletion end points do not correspond to homologous or directly repeated sequences of more than one nucleotide, whose pairing could account for the deletion junction. The characteristics of the deletion end points can be accounted for either by illegitimate recombination, possibly following double strand breaks at cruciform structures, or by interruption of reverse transcription followed by reinitiation downstream. The finding that the deletions encompass the 160 bp direct repeat and all five PstI-palindromes indicates that neither are required for propagation of the plasmids and supports the hypothesis that PstI-palindromes are selfish DNA elements that inserted into a nonessential region of the plasmid.