Homologous plasmid recombination is elevated in immortally transformed cells

A Small-Molecule Inhibitor of RAD51 Reduces Homologous Recombination and Sensitizes Multiple Myeloma Cells to Doxorubicin

We previously reported high expression of RAD51 and increased homologous recombination (HR) rates in multiple myeloma (MM) cells, and showed that genomic instability and disease progression are commensurate with HR levels. Moreover, high RAD51 expression in vivo is associated with chemoresistance and poor patient survival. Doxorubicin (DOX) is one of the most widely used drug treatments in MM chemotherapy. DOX is cytotoxic because it induces DNA double-strand breaks, which can be repaired by RAD51-mediated HR; activation of this pathway thus contributes to resistance. To investigate the role of RAD51 in MM drug resistance, we assessed the ability of B02, a small-molecule inhibitor of RAD51, to enhance DOX sensitivity of MM cells. Combining low-toxicity doses of DOX and B02 resulted in significant synthetic lethality, observed as increased apoptosis and reduced viability compared to either agent alone, or to the product of their individual effects. In contrast, the combination did not produce significant synergy against normal human CD19⁺ B cells from peripheral blood. DOX induced RAD51 at both mRNA and protein levels, while arresting cells in S and G2. DOX treatment also increased the number of RAD51 foci, a marker of HR repair, so that the fraction of cells with ≥5 foci rose fourfold, whereas γH2AX foci rose far less, implying that most new breaks are repaired. When B02 treatment preceded DOX exposure, the induction of RAD51 foci was severely blunted, whereas, γH2AX foci rose significantly relative to basal levels or either agent alone. In MM cells carrying a chromosomally integrated reporter of HR repair, DOX increased HR events while B02 inhibition of RAD51 blocked the HR response. These studies demonstrate the crucial role of RAD51 in protecting MM cells from genotoxic agents such as DOX, and suggest that specific inhibition of RAD51 may be an effective means to block DNA repair in MM cells and thus to enhance the efficacy of chemotherapy.

Dysfunctional homologous recombination mediates genomic instability and progression in myeloma

A prominent feature of most if not all cancers is a striking genetic instability, leading to ongoing accrual of mutational changes, some of which underlie tumor progression, including acquisition of invasiveness, drug resistance, and metastasis. Thus, the molecular basis for the generation of this genetic diversity in cancer cells has important implications in understanding cancer progression. Here we report that homologous recombination (HR) activity is elevated in multiple myeloma (MM) cells and leads to an increased rate of mutation and progressive accumulation of genetic variation over time. We demonstrate that the inhibition of HR activity in MM cells by small inhibitory RNA (siRNAs) targeting recombinase leads to significant reduction in the acquisition of new genetic changes in the genome and, conversely, the induction of HR activity leads to significant elevation in the number of new mutations over time and development of drug resistance in MM cells. These data identify dysregulated HR activity as a key mediator of DNA instability and progression of MM, with potential as a therapeutic target.

Elevated recombination in immortal human cells is mediated by HsRAD51 recombinase

Normal diploid cells have a limited replicative potential in culture, with progressively increasing interdivision time. Rarely, cell lines arise which can divide indefinitely; like tumor cells, such "immortal" lines display frequent chromosomal aberrations which may reflect high rates of recombination. Recombination frequencies within a plasmid substrate were 3.5-fold higher in nine immortal human cell lines than in six untransformed cell strains. Expression of HsRAD51, a human homolog of the yeast RAD51 and Escherichia coli recA recombinase genes, was 4.5-fold higher in immortal cell lines than in mortal cells. Stable transformation of human fibroblasts with simian virus 40 large T antigen prior to cell immortalization increased both chromosomal recombination and the level of HsRAD51 transcripts by two- to fivefold. T-antigen induction of recombination was efficiently blocked by introduction of HsRAD51 antisense (but not control) oligonucleotides spanning the initiation codon, implying that HsRAD51 expression mediates augmented recombination. Since p53 binds and inactivates HsRAD51, T-antigen-p53 association may block such inactivation and liberate HsRAD51. Upregulation of HsRAD51 transcripts in T-antigen-transformed and other immortal cells suggests that recombinase activation can also occur at the RNA level and may facilitate cell transformation to immortality.

Characterization of homologous DNA recombination activity in normal and immortal mammalian cells

Homologous DNA recombination levels were measured in normal and spontaneously immortalized murine and human fibroblasts, and in a number of primate and murine established fibroblast cell lines. Immortal cell lines and tumor-derived clones homologously recombined extrachromosomal plasmid substrates at frequencies approximately 100-fold higher than did normal cells. To further explore the mechanism responsible for this phenotype, homologous recombination frequency was measured using nuclear extracts derived from normal and immortalized murine and human fibroblasts. Extracts prepared from immortal cells catalyzed high levels of homologous recombination, whereas very little recombination activity was detected in extracts prepared from normal fibroblasts. Similarly, only extracts derived from immortal cells contained strand-transferase activity as measured by the recently described pairing-on-membrane assay. Mixing experiments indicated that a recombination enhancing factor or factors present in immortal cells, rather than a recombination inhibitor in normal cells, was responsible for the enhanced homologous recombination activity observed using extracts derived from the former.

Single-stranded DNA as a recombination substrate in plants as assessed by stable and transient recombination assays

Two separate assays, one that requires stable integration of recombination products and one that does not, were employed to elucidate the role of single-stranded DNA in extrachromosomal homologous recombination in Nicotiana tabacum. Both assays revealed that single-stranded DNA in linear and in circular forms was an efficient substrate for recombination, provided that the cotransformed recombination substrates were of complementary sequence, so that direct annealing was possible. Recombination was inefficient when both single-stranded recombination partners contained homologous regions of identical sequence and generation of a double-stranded DNA was required prior to heteroduplex formation. These results indicate that direct annealing of single strands is an important initial step for intermolecular recombination in tobacco cells. Annealed cotransformed single-stranded molecules yielded intermediates that could be further processed by either continuous or discontinuous second-strand synthesis. The type of intermediate had no influence on the recombination efficiency. Double-stranded circles were unable to recombine efficiently either with each other or with single-stranded DNA. Our results suggest that a helicase activity is involved in the initial steps of double-stranded DNA recombination which unwinds duplex molecules at the site of double-strand breaks.

Single-stranded DNA as a recombination substrate in plants as assessed by stable and transient recombination assays

Two separate assays, one that requires stable integration of recombination products and one that does not, were employed to elucidate the role of single-stranded DNA in extrachromosomal homologous recombination in Nicotiana tabacum. Both assays revealed that single-stranded DNA in linear and in circular forms was an efficient substrate for recombination, provided that the cotransformed recombination substrates were of complementary sequence, so that direct annealing was possible. Recombination was inefficient when both single-stranded recombination partners contained homologous regions of identical sequence and generation of a double-stranded DNA was required prior to heteroduplex formation. These results indicate that direct annealing of single strands is an important initial step for intermolecular recombination in tobacco cells. Annealed cotransformed single-stranded molecules yielded intermediates that could be further processed by either continuous or discontinuous second-strand synthesis. The type of intermediate had no influence on the recombination efficiency. Double-stranded circles were unable to recombine efficiently either with each other or with single-stranded DNA. Our results suggest that a helicase activity is involved in the initial steps of double-stranded DNA recombination which unwinds duplex molecules at the site of double-strand breaks.

DNA nicking favors PCR recombination

We attempted to use the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to monitor in vitro recombination in a plasmid containing directly repeated sequences. Some of the plasmid preparations which had not been exposed to recombination conditions were however found to behave in the PCR test as if they had undergone homologous recombination. We show here that such false positives are attributable to a small degree of nicking and/or breaking of the DNA template. Presumably, such damage allows the formation of hybrid parental duplexes containing at least one truncated strand, the 3' end of which maps within the homology; extension of this 3' end by the polymerase then results in a linkage of sequences identical to that arising from homologous recombination.

Intrachromosomal recombination mediated by papovavirus large T antigens

To investigate the mechanism by which the large T antigen (T-Ag) of polyomavirus and simian virus 40 can promote recombination in mammalian cells, we analyzed homologous recombination events occurring between two defective copies of the polyomavirus middle T (pmt) oncogene lying in close proximity on the same chromosome in a rat cell line. Reconstitution of a functional pmt gene by spontaneous recombination occurred at a rate of about 2 x 10(-7) per cell generation. Introduction of the polyomavirus large T (plt) oncogene into the cell line by DNA transfection promoted recombination very efficiently, with rates in the range of 10(-1) to 10(-2) per cell generation. Recombination was independent of any amplification of viral sequences and could even be promoted by the large T-Ag from simian virus 40, which cannot activate polyomavirus DNA replication. To explain the role of large T-Ag, we propose a novel mechanism of nonconservative recombination involving slipped-strand mispairing between the two viral repeats followed by gap repair synthesis.

Normal diploid human and rodent cells lack a detectable frequency of gene amplification

Gene amplification is frequently observed in tumors and transformed cell lines. This phenomenon is known to contribute to the generation of drug-resistant tumor cells and quantitation of the event is believed to have prognostic value in several types of neoplasias. To date, most studies of gene amplification have used immortalized cell lines and biopsied tumor samples. In this study I examine the amplification potentials of primary diploid cells, both human and rodent, and quantitatively compare them to the amplification potentials of their transformed counterparts. I have used a strictly defined protocol (i.e., selection at a stringency of 9 X LD50) to measure amplification potential at two loci, the gene for the multifunctional protein containing activities for carbamoyl phosphate synthase, aspartate transcarbamylase, and dihydroorotase (CAD) and the gene for dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR). I find that the frequency of amplification in transformed cells is at least four orders of magnitude greater than that in normal cells. Out of 29 cell populations studied, the 7 diploid normal cell populations exhibited no detectable amplification frequency (limit of detection at 10(-8) whereas the 22 transformed cell lines demonstrated amplification frequencies between 10(-3) and 10(-7). These results demonstrate that a dramatic difference exists between primary diploid cell populations and immortalized cell populations in their ability to amplify genomic sequences and suggests a significant difference in genetic stability between these two cell types.