Survival and place of treatment after premature delivery

The impact of level of neonatal care provision on outcomes for preterm babies born between 27 and 31 weeks of gestation, or with a birth weight between 1000 and 1500 g: a review of the literature

OBJECTIVE

There is evidence that birth and care in a maternity service associated with a neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) is associated with improved survival in preterm babies born at <27 weeks of gestation. We conducted a systematic review to address whether similar gains manifested in babies born between 27+0 and 31+6 weeks (hereafter 27 and 31 weeks) of gestation, or in those with a birth weight between 1000 and 1500 g.

METHODS

We searched Embase, Medline and CINAHL databases for studies comparing outcomes for babies born between 27 and 31 weeks or between 1000 and 1500 g birth weight, based on designation of the neonatal unit where the baby was born or subsequently cared for (NICU vs non-NICU setting). A modified QUIPS (QUality In Prognostic Studies) tool was used to assess quality.

RESULTS

Nine studies compared outcomes for babies born between 27 and 31 weeks of gestation and 11 studies compared outcomes for babies born between 1000 and 1500 g birth weight. Heterogeneity in comparator groups, birth locations, gestational age ranges, timescale for mortality reporting, and description of morbidities facilitated a narrative review as opposed to a meta-analysis.

CONCLUSION

Due to paucity of evidence, significant heterogeneity and potential for bias, we were not able to answer our question-does place of birth or care affect outcomes for babies born between 27 and 31 weeks? This supports the need for large-scale research to investigate place of birth and care for babies born in this gestational age range.

Differences in access to Emergency Paediatric Intensive Care and care during Transport (DEPICT): study protocol for a mixed methods study

INTRODUCTION

Following centralisation of UK paediatric intensive care, specialist retrieval teams were established who travel to general hospitals to stabilise and transport sick children to regional paediatric intensive care units (PICUs). There is national variation among these PICU retrieval teams (PICRTs) in terms of how quickly they reach the patient's bedside and in the care provided during transport. The impact of these variations on clinical outcomes and the experience of stakeholders (patients, families and healthcare staff) is however unknown. The primary objective of this study is to address this evidence gap.

METHODS AND ANALYSIS

This mixed-methods project involves the following: (1) retrospective analysis of linked data from routine clinical audits (2014-2016) to assess the impact of service variations on 30-day mortality and other secondary clinical outcomes; (2) a prospective questionnaire study conducted at 24 PICUs and 9 associated PICRTs in England and Wales over a 12-month period in 2018 to collect experience data from parents of transported children as well as qualitative analysis of in-depth interviews with a purposive sample of patients, parents and staff to assess the impact of service variations on patient/family experience; (3) health economic evaluation analysing transport service costs (and other associated costs) against lives saved and longer term measurements of quality of life at 12 months in transported children and (4) mathematical modelling evaluating the costs and potential impact of different service configurations. A final work stream involves a series of stakeholder workshops to synthesise study findings and generate recommendations.

ETHICS AND DISSEMINATION

The study has been reviewed and approved by the Health Research Authority, ref: 2 18 569. Study results will be actively disseminated through peer-reviewed journals, conference presentations, social media, print and broadcast media, the internet and stakeholder workshops.

Saving Newborn Babies - The Benefits of Interventions in Neonatal Care in Norway over More Than 40 Years

The aim of this study was to examine the effect that the introduction of new medical interventions at birth has had on mortality among newborn babies in Norway during the period 1967-2011. During this period, there has been a significant decline in mortality, in particular for low birth weight infants. We identified four interventions that together explained about 50% of the decline in early neonatal and infant mortality: ventilators, antenatal steroids, surfactant and insure. The analyses were performed on a large set of data, encompassing more than 1.6 million deliveries (Medical Birth Registry of Norway). The richness of the data allowed us to perform several robustness tests. Our study indicates that the introduction of new medical interventions has been a very important channel through which the decline in mortality among newborn babies occurred during the second half of the last century. Copyright © 2016 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Effect of specialist retrieval teams on outcomes in children admitted to paediatric intensive care units in England and Wales: a retrospective cohort study

BACKGROUND

Intensive care services for children have undergone substantial centralisation in the UK. Along with the establishment of regional paediatric intensive care units (PICUs), specialist retrieval teams were set up to transport critically ill children from other hospitals. We studied the outcome of children transferred from local hospitals to PICUs.

METHODS

We analysed data that were gathered for a cohort of children (<or=16 years) admitted consecutively to 29 PICUs in England and Wales during 4 years (Jan 1, 2005, to Dec 31, 2008). We compared unplanned admissions from wards within the same hospital as the PICU and from other hospitals; interhospital transfers by non-specialist and specialist retrieval teams; and patients transferred to their nearest PICU and those who were not. Primary outcome measures were mortality rate in PICU and length of stay in PICU. We analysed data by use of logistic regression analysis.

FINDINGS

There were 57 997 admissions to PICUs during the study. Nearly half of unplanned admissions (17 649 [53%] of 33 492) were from other hospitals. Although children admitted from other hospitals were younger (median 10 months [IQR 1-55] vs 18 months [3-85]), sicker at admission (median predicted risk of mortality 6% [4-10] vs 4% [2-7]), stayed longer in PICUs (75 h [33-153] vs 43 h [18-116]), and had higher crude mortality rates (1384 [8%] of 17 649 vs 996 [6%] of 15 843; odds ratio 1.27, 95% CI 1.16-1.38), the risk-adjusted mortality rate in PICUs was lower than among children admitted from within the same hospital (0.65, 0.53-0.80). In a multivariable analysis, use of a specialist retrieval team for transfer was associated with improved survival (0.58, 0.39-0.87).

INTERPRETATION

These findings support the policy of combining centralisation of intensive care services for children with transfer by specialist retrieval teams.

FUNDING

National Clinical Audit and Patient Outcomes Programme through Healthcare Quality Improvement Partnership, Health Commission Wales Specialised Services, National Health Service (NHS) Lothian and National Service Division NHS Scotland, the Royal Belfast Hospital for Sick Children, and the Pan Thames PICU Commissioning Consortium.

Characteristics of neonatal units that care for very preterm infants in Europe: results from the MOSAIC study

OBJECTIVES

We sought to compare guidelines for level III units in 10 European regions and analyze the characteristics of neonatal units that care for very preterm infants.

METHODS

The MOSAIC (Models of Organising Access to Intensive Care for Very Preterm Births) project combined a prospective cohort study on all births between 22 and 31 completed weeks of gestation in 10 European regions and a survey of neonatal unit characteristics. Units that admitted > or = 5 infants at < 32 weeks of gestation were included in the analysis (N = 111). Place of hospitalization of infants who were admitted to neonatal care was analyzed by using the cohort data (N = 4947). National or regional guidelines for level III units were reviewed.

RESULTS

Six of 9 guidelines for level III units included minimum size criteria, based on number of intensive care beds (6 guidelines), neonatal admissions (2), ventilated patients (1), obstetric intensive care beds (1), and deliveries (2). The characteristics of level III units varied, and many were small or unspecialized by recommended criteria: 36% had fewer than 50 very preterm annual admissions, 22% ventilated fewer than 50 infants annually, and 28% had fewer than 6 intensive care beds. Level II units were less specialized, but some provided mechanical ventilation (57%) or high-frequency ventilation (20%) or had neonatal surgery facilities (17%). Sixty-nine percent of level III and 36% of level I or II units had continuous medical coverage by a qualified pediatrician. Twenty-two percent of infants who were < 28 weeks of gestation were treated in units that admitted fewer than 50 very preterm infants annually (range: 2%-54% across the study regions).

CONCLUSIONS

No consensus exists in Europe about size or other criteria for NICUs. A better understanding of the characteristics associated with high-quality neonatal care is needed, given the high proportion of very preterm infants who are cared for in units that are considered small or less specialized by many recommendations.

Neonatal intensive care unit characteristics affect the incidence of severe intraventricular hemorrhage

OBJECTIVES

The incidence of intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH), adjusted for known risk factors, varies across neonatal intensive care units (NICU)s. The effect of NICU characteristics on this variation is unknown. The objective was to assess IVH attributable risks at both patient and NICU levels.

STUDY DESIGN

Subjects were <33 weeks' gestation, <4 days old on admission in the Canadian Neonatal Network database (all infants admitted in 1996-97 to 17 NICUs). The variation in severe IVH rates was analyzed using Bayesian hierarchical modeling for patient level and NICU level factors.

RESULTS

Of 3772 eligible subjects, the overall crude incidence rates of grade 3-4 IVH was 8.3% (NICU range 2.0-20.5%). Male gender, extreme preterm birth, low Apgar score, vaginal birth, outborn birth, and high admission severity of illness accounted for 30% of the severe IVH rate variation; admission day therapy-related variables (treatment of acidosis and hypotension) accounted for an additional 14%. NICU characteristics, independent of patient level risk factors, accounted for 31% of the variation. NICUs with high patient volume and high neonatologist/staff ratio had lower rates of severe IVH.

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of severe IVH is affected by NICU characteristics, suggesting important new strategies to reduce this important adverse outcome.

Quality of care by neonatal nurse practitioners: a review of the Ashington experiment

The Ashington experiment, an innovative neonatal service run entirely by advanced neonatal nurse practitioners (ANNPs), has been evaluated. This is a report of that evaluation and a review of the benefits, hazards, and implications of nurse practitioner led services.

Managing safe staffing

Low staffing numbers in intensive care are associated with a number of adverse sequelae, including increased mortality. This article explores the evidence behind recommendations for safe staffing of neonatal units within the UK. Increasing pressure to reduce the hours all medical staff work and the increasing duration of neonatal nurse training requires all units to reflect on how they develop and maintain staff skills and prioritise training. To ensure safe staffing, numerous examples of innovative practice exist within the UK. Examples include network-wide workforces, clinical support workers and neonatal housekeepers.

Preterm delivery, level of care, and infant death in sweden: a population-based study

OBJECTIVE

To elucidate the role of level of care in combination with other perinatal risk factors for infant death in very preterm deliveries.

DESIGN

Population-based cohort study.

SETTING

Sweden, 1992-1998.

SUBJECTS

Singleton infants (2285) born at 24 to 31 completed weeks of gestation to primiparous women.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

Infant mortality.

RESULTS

The rate of infant mortality increased from 5% among infants born at 31 weeks' gestation to 56% among infants born at 24 weeks' gestation. Compared with infants born at university hospitals, the unadjusted odds ratio (OR) of infant death was 0.70 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.54-0.90) among infants delivered at general hospitals. However, after adjustment, the OR of infant death shifted to 1.33 (95% CI: 0.88-2.02) for preterm births at general hospitals. This shift was primarily due to different gestational age distributions in regional and general hospitals. Among infants born at 24 to 27 weeks' gestation, infant mortality rates were 23% (87 deaths) in university hospitals and 32% (73 deaths) in general hospitals, giving an adjusted OR of 2.00 for general versus university hospitals (95% CI: 1.15-3.49). The risk of death at 24 to 27 weeks' gestation in general hospitals was increased specifically in pregnancies with placental complications.

CONCLUSION

Taking obstetric complications into account, there is an excess mortality risk among extremely preterm infants born at general hospitals.

Variations in initial assessment and management of inflammatory bowel disease across Great Britain and Ireland

BACKGROUND

There are no published data from Great Britain and Ireland detailing the initial management of children with inflammatory bowel disease (IBD).

AIMS

To prospectively record the initial investigation and treatment of children aged less than 16 years with newly diagnosed IBD.

METHODS

For 13 months, between June 1998 and June 1999, 3247 paediatricians, adult gastroenterologists, and surgeons across the UK and Ireland were prospectively surveyed each month and asked to report every newly diagnosed case of childhood IBD. Reporters subsequently completed a postal questionnaire about each case.

RESULTS

A total of 739 new IBD cases were reported from 172 institutions. Significant variations were observed in the investigation and treatment of these cases, when examined by number of cases reported per institution, or by the specialists providing care. There were wide regional variations in the proportion of children having access to paediatric gastroenterology services. Overall, one third of children received care from an adult service, and a tenth care exclusively from an adult gastroenterologist. Children with Crohn's disease who had some or all of their care from adult services were more likely to receive systemic steroids and less likely to receive dietary therapy; those with ulcerative colitis were more likely to receive rectal steroids and to have surgery. Height and weight were also less likely to be recorded in those whose care involved adult services.

CONCLUSION

Current specialist provision, and initial investigation and treatment of IBD, is heterogeneous. Optimisation of care is likely to be achieved by greater access to specialist paediatric gastroenterology services for all those with suspected IBD.

The clinical risk index of babies (CRIB) score in India

OBJECTIVE

To assess the usefulness of clinical risk index of babies (CRIB score) in predicting neonatal mortality in extremely preterm neonates, compared to birth weight and gestation.

METHODS

97 preterm neonates with gestational age less than 31 weeks or birth weight less than or equal to 1500 g were enrolled for the prospective longitudinal study. Relevant neonatal data was recorded. Blood gas analysis results and the maximum and the minimum FiO2 required by babies in first 12 hours of life were noted. Mortality was taken as death while the baby was in nursery. The prediction of mortality by birth weight, gestational age and CRIB score was done using the Logistic model, and expressed as area under the ROC curve.

RESULTS

The area under the ROC curve for birth weight, gestational age and CRIB score was almost the same, the areas being 0.829, 0.819 and 0.823 respectively. Hence CRIB score did not fare better than birth weight and gestational age in predicting neonatal mortality.

CONCLUSION

The CRIB score did not improve on the ability of birth weight and gestational age to predict neonatal mortality in the study.

Patient volume, staffing, and workload in relation to risk-adjusted outcomes in a random stratified sample of UK neonatal intensive care units: a prospective evaluation

BACKGROUND

UK recommendations suggest that large neonatal intensive-care units (NICUs) have better outcomes than small units, although this suggestion remains unproven. We assessed whether patient volume, staffing levels, and workload are associated with risk-adjusted outcomes, and with costs or staff wellbeing.

METHODS

186 UK NICUs were stratified according to volume of patients, nursing provision, and neonatal consultant provision. Primary outcomes were hospital mortality, mortality or cerebral damage, and nosocomial bacteraemia. We studied 13515 infants of all birthweights consecutively admitted to 54 randomly selected NICUs. Multiple logistic regression analyses were done with every primary outcome as the dependent variable. Staff wellbeing and stress were assessed by anonymous mental health index (MHI)-5 questionnaires.

FINDINGS

Data were available for 13334 (99%) infants. High-volume NICUs treated the sickest infants and had highest crude mortality. Risk-adjusted mortality and mortality or cerebral damage were unrelated to patient volume or staffing provision; however, nosocomial bacteraemia was less frequent in NICUs with low neonatal consultant provision (odds ratio 0.65, 95% CI 0.43-0.98). Mortality was raised with increasing workload in all types of NICUs. Infants admitted at full capacity versus half capacity were about 50% more likely to die, but there was wide uncertainty around this estimate. Most staff had MHI-5 scores that suggested good mental health.

INTERPRETATION

The implications of this report for staffing policy, medicolegal risk management, and ethical practice remain to be tested. Centralisation of only the sickest infants could improve efficiency, provided that this does not create excessive workload for staff. Assessment of increased staffing levels that are closer to those in adult intensive care might be appropriate.

Factors determining admission to neonatal units in Jamaica

In order to identify the factors associated with admission to neonatal care units in a developing country, 1,823 newborns admitted to Jamaica's eight neonatal care units over a 6-month period were compared with 9,563 newborns identified during an island-wide population morbidity study. Maternal sociodemographic characteristics, past obstetric history, infant's growth parameters at birth and mode and place of delivery were investigated. Babies of mothers resident in the two regions of the island where specialist paediatric services were available had increased odds of admission (OR= 1.45, 1.22) compared with those living elsewhere (OR=0.70, 0.80). Maternal history of a previous miscarriage, termination or early neonatal death were associated with subsequent admission, but a previous stillbirth or late neonatal death were not. Very low birthweight infants of gestational age 28-31 weeks were more likely to be admitted than those < 28 weeks with ORs of 1.45 and 0.34 respectively. Factors determining neonatal admission in the developing world may be quite different from those of developed countries. The development of guidelines and support services to ensure wider access to these services for those most in need could contribute to more equitable utilisation of services.

A critical review of cost reduction in neonatal intensive care. I. The structure of costs

Neonatal intensive care is expensive. In the current era of intense cost containment in hospital care, neonatologists and hospital administrators are under intense pressure to find strategies for cost reduction for neonatal services. Few neonatal clinicians are trained in economics, management, or accounting, and few hospital administrators are familiar with neonatal intensive care. In this review, we describe the structure and sources of hospital costs and the accounting systems needed to isolate and measure such costs. We discuss where efficiencies might be found and consider specific issues in capitated settings such as health maintenance organizations in the United States, the Canadian health care system and the National Health System in the United Kingdom.

Variation in the use of alternative levels of hospital care for newborns in a managed care organization

OBJECTIVE(S)

To assess the extent to which variation in the use of neonatal intensive care resources in a managed care organization is a consequence of variation in neonatal health risks and/or variation in the organization and delivery of medical care to newborns.

STUDY DESIGN

Data were collected on a cohort of all births from four sites in Kaiser Permanente by retrospective medical chart abstraction of the birth admission. Likelihood of admission into a neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) is estimated by logistic regression. Durations of NICU stays and of hospital stay following birth are estimated by Cox proportional hazards regression.

RESULTS

The likelihood of admission into NICU and the duration of both NICU care and hospital stay are proportional to the degree of illness and complexity of diagnosis. Adjusting for variation in health risks across sites, however, does not fully account for observed variation in NICU admission rates or for length of hospital stay. One site has a distinct pattern of high rates of NICU admissions; another site has a distinct pattern of low rates of NICU admission but long durations of hospital stay for full-term newborns following NICU admission as well as for all newborns managed in normal care nurseries.

CONCLUSIONS

Substantial variations exist among sites in the risk-adjusted likelihood of NICU admission and in durations of NICU stay and hospital stay. Hospital and NICU affiliation (Kaiser Permanente versus contract) or affiliation of the neonatologists (Kaiser Permanente versus contract) could not explain the variation in use of alternative levels of hospital care. The best explanation for these variations in neonatal resource use appears to be the extent to which neonatology and pediatric practices differ in their policies with respect to the management of newborns of minimal to moderate illness.

The frequency and outcome of biliary atresia in the UK and Ireland

BACKGROUND

Biliary atresia is an obliterative cholangiopathy of infancy that is fatal if untreated. Surgical treatment, the Kasai portoenterostomy, may restore bile flow and clear jaundice, and, if successful, achieve a 10-year survival of 90% with a native liver. The outcome of a 2-year cohort of children with biliary atresia in the UK and Ireland was assessed to find the current frequency, the factors influencing outcome, and the medium-term need for liver transplantation.

METHODS

Cases diagnosed between March, 1993, and February, 1995, were notified by paediatricians to the British Paediatric Surveillance Unit via a monthly reporting system. Confirmed cases were followed up by postal questionnaires to notifying paediatricians.

FINDINGS

93 cases were confirmed, a frequency of 1/16700 livebirths. Primary surgery was done in 91 children in 15 surgical centres with an early success rate for clearing jaundice of 55% overall. Centres were grouped according to caseload; group A had more than 5 cases/year and group B fewer than 5 cases/year. Early success was higher in group-A centres, odds ratio 2.02 (95% CI 0.86-4.73), but this did not reach statistical significance. Of 41 children in whom surgery was unsuccessful in clearing jaundice 9 (22%) died and 30 (73%) underwent liver transplantation. Survival without liver transplantation and overall survival were both significantly greater in group-A centres, rate ratios 0.48 (95% CI 0.27-0.86) and 0.32 (0.11-0.94). Actuarial 5-year survival without transplantation was 61.3% in group-A centres and 13.7% in groupB centres. Actuarial 5-year overall survival was 91.2% in group A and 75% in group B. Once centre size was taken into account, no other factor, including age at surgery, was predictive of survival without transplantation or overall survival.

INTERPRETATION

The outcome of children with biliary atresia is related to the caseload of the surgical centre where they have their primary surgery. Children with biliary atresia should be managed in surgical centres with a caseload of more than five cases annually.

Survival and place of delivery following preterm birth: 1994-96

AIM

To compare the survival of premature infants, adjusted for disease severity, in different types of neonatal intensive care setting.

METHODS

A prospective observational study in the Trent Health Region was carried out of all infants born to resident mothers at or before 32 weeks of gestation between 1 January 1994 to 31 December 1996 inclusive. The 16 neonatal units in Trent were subdivided into five relatively large units which regularly took outside referrals and 11 smaller units which provided intensive care for a variable proportion (sometimes nearly 100%) of their local population. Data regarding obstetric management, neonatal care, and outcome were collected by independent neonatal nurses who visited the units on a regular basis. Survival rates were compared with an expected rate calculated using the Clinical Risk Index for Babies (CRIB). For either setting to be abnormally good or bad actual deaths had to exceed the 95% confidence interval of the CRIB estimate.

RESULTS

Actual survival rates for infants < or = 32 weeks gestation and for the group of babies < or = 28 weeks gestation fell within the 95% confidence interval of the rate predicted by CRIB for both the larger referral units and the smaller district units. Similarly, compared with the CRIB prediction, infants transferred in utero or postnatally were not adversely affected in terms of the number who died.

CONCLUSION

Previous results from this geographical population, showing that survival of babies < or = 28 weeks gestation was better when their care was provided by referral units, are no longer sustained. Significant changes to the neonatal services over time make the current results plausible. However, the new structure poses potential threats to the teaching, training, and research base of the neonatal service as a whole.

Where should paediatric surgery be performed?

We have tried to review the evidence for the organisation of paediatric surgical care. Difficulties arise because of the lack of published data from district general hospitals concerning paediatric surgical conditions. Hence much of the debate about the surgical management of children is based on anecdotal evidence. However, at a time when the provision of health care is being radically reorganised to an internal market based on a system of purchasers and providers it is more important than ever to understand the issues at stake. Two separate issues have been discussed: the role of the specialist paediatric centre and the provision of non-specialist paediatric surgery in district general hospitals. There are arguments for and against large regional specialist paediatric centres. The benefits of centralisation include concentration of expertise, more appropriate consultant on call commitment, development of support services, and junior doctor training. The disadvantages include children and their families having to travel long distances for care, and the loss of expertise at a local level. If specialist paediatric emergency transport is available the benefits of centralisation far outweigh the adverse effects of having to take children to a regional paediatric intensive care centre. Specialist paediatric centres are aware of the importance of treating children and their parents as a family unit as highlighted by the Platt committee; this is an important challenge and enormous improvements have occurred to provide proper accommodation for families while their children are treated in hospital. To keep these arguments of large distances and separation from the home in context, one paediatric intensive care unit in Victoria, Australia, providing a centralised service to a region larger in are than England and with a similar admission rate, has a lower mortality rate than the decentralised paediatric intensive care provided in the Trent region of the UK. There is clear evidence that all neonatal surgery and anaesthesia should be conducted only by specialists. The debate now centres around the number of complex surgical cases a unit should treat to maintain its specialist status. The NHS executive, in its guidelines on contracting for specialist services, emphasises that "Sensible contracting needs to take into account the optimum population size not only for the stability of contracted referrals but also to give sufficient 'critical mass' for clinical effectiveness." Achieving this balance has consequences, not just for the maintenance of surgical expertise, but for the essential ancilliary services. There is clear evidence in anaesthesia that anaesthetists doing small numbers of neonatal procedures had significantly worse results. The same seems to be true in the fields of oncology, radiology, pathology, and intensive care. The reasons why the results of management of certain paediatric conditions are better at specialist centres are open to speculation. Presumably greater exposure to rare complex cases, concentration of expertise, more peer review, and a trickle down effect of the multidisciplinary approach all help to keep health care workers up to date with current world practice. In addition, it allows for appropriate specialist on call rotas and dedicated junior staff. If insufficient numbers of specialist surgical cases are being treated at a centre then the whole multidisciplinary team suffers. The 1989 NCEPOD report states "that paediatricians and general surgeons must recognise that small babies differ from other patients not only in size, and that they pose quite separate problems of pathology and management." The need for large centres of paediatric surgical expertise is now accepted by the Royal College of Surgeons of England, the British Association of Paediatric Surgeons, the Senate of Surgery of Great Britain and Ireland, the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, the Royal College of Anaesthetists, the Audit

A study of the referral patterns of obstetric clinics and the performance of receiving neonatal intensive care units in Taiwan

To study the referral patterns of obstetric clinics, and the performance of receiving intensive care units measured by the survival of transported neonates, transport records were collected prospectively between July, 1991 and June, 1992. Two hundred and fifty-four transported neonates born in 51 obstetric clinics (level I units) in Tainan City and County, in southern Taiwan, were enrolled in this study. Nineteen percent of the transported neonates were very low birthweight infants (< 1500 g). Nearly equal numbers of them were transported to eight district hospitals (level II units) and to a tertiary center (level III unit), but these infants were 1.5 times more likely to die in a level II unit than a level III unit. In addition, equal numbers of infants assisted by mechanical ventilators were transported to level II and III units, but these infants were three times more likely to die in a level II unit than a level III unit (P = 0.006). Seventy-seven percent of the normal birthweight infants (> or = 2500 g) were transported to level II units, and the mortality in this group was 12.3% compared with 0% in those transported to the level III unit. Approximately 56% of these normal birthweight infants in level II units died of severe birth asphyxia. The referral patterns of level 1 units had an unfavorable effect on the survival of neonates requiring mechanical ventilation. Enhancing the skills of the staff in level I units to recognize and stabilize such infants, elevating the capability of level II units in treating some of these cases, and increasing the hospital beds for level III care are necessary to increase their chance of survival.

The Swedish national prospective study on extremely low birthweight (ELBW) infants. Incidence, mortality, morbidity and survival in relation to level of care

In a 2-year (1990-92) prospective national investigation, comprising all stillborn and live-born ELBW infants with a birthweight of < or = 1000 g born at 23 completed weeks of gestation or more, we examined the incidence, neonatal mortality, major morbidity and infant survival in relation to level of care and place of residence. A total of 633 ELBW infants were live-born, i.e. 0.26% of all live-born infants, and 298 were stillborn. The average neonatal mortality was 37% and 91% at 23 weeks, 70% at 24 weeks, and 40% at 25 weeks of gestation. Of neonatal survivors, 8% had intraventricular haemorrhage grade 3, 10% retinopathy of prematurity of stage > or = 3, 2% necrotizing enterocolitis, and 28% were oxygen-dependent at a time corresponding to 36 weeks of gestation. In all, 77% were treated with mechanical ventilation, whereas 19% survived without, almost all of them being CPAP treated. Infant mortality among infants born at level III (tertiary centres) was 30%, at level IIa (with full perinatal service) 46% and at level IIb (with basic neonatal service) 55%. Only 1% was born at hospital level I. Regarding the relation to place of residence, the mortality rates among infants residing in the areas served by levels III, IIa and IIb hospitals were 36%, 45% and 41%, respectively. The referral system thus functioned well, but can be improved, and increased perinatal referral, at borderline perinatal viability, might provide a better quality of care and a better chance of survival.

The regionalization of perinatal care in Wales and Washington State

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to compare perinatal regionalization and neonatal mortality in Wales and Washington State.

METHODS

The 28 hospitals in Wales and the 80 hospitals in Washington State that offered maternity services and the 218,326 births that occurred in these hospitals in 1989 and 1990 were studied. Surveys were used to identify the neonatal technology and the referral policies of each hospital, and linked data from birth and death certificates were used to examine birthweight-specific neonatal mortality rates for all babies born in these hospitals.

RESULTS

Welsh district general hospitals (broadly equivalent to Level II perinatal centers in the United States) have more sophisticated neonatal technology than their Washington State counterparts and appear less likely to refer small or preterm babies to regional or subregional centers. Neonatal mortality rates were quite similar in the two settings.

CONCLUSIONS

Perinatal care in Wales appears to be less regionalized than in a similar region in the United States. The relative lack of perinatal regionalization in Wales may contribute to duplication and underutilization of expensive neonatal technologies. National health care systems do not, in and of themselves, lead to optimal regionalization of services.

Use of the CRIB (clinical risk index for babies) score in prediction of neonatal mortality and morbidity

A prospective study of the outcome of care of a regional cohort of very low birthweight (< 1500 g) and very preterm (< 32 weeks) infants was carried out. Its aims were to assess the ability of the CRIB (clinical risk index for babies) score, rather than gestational age or birthweight, to predict mortality before hospital discharge, neurological morbidity, and length of stay, and to access CRIB score as an indicator of neonatal intensive care performance. 676 live births fulfilled the criteria and complete data were available for 643 (95%). Compared with gestation and birthweight, CRIB was better for the prediction of mortality, was as good for the prediction of morbidity, and was not as good for the prediction of length of stay. CRIB adjusted mortality did not demonstrate better performance in units providing the highest level of care. Either the CRIB score was not sensitive to performance or the level 3 hospitals in this study were performing badly. On the basis of this analysis purchasers and providers of neonatal intensive care cannot yet rely on the CRIB score as a performance indicator.

Secular changes in the outcomes to eighteen to twenty-four months of age of extremely low birth weight infants, with adjustment for changes in risk factors and severity of illness

OBJECTIVES

To analyze secular changes in the rates of death and of major impaired outcome in surviving outborn infants who weighted < or = 800 gm at birth and were admitted in 1980 to 1989, with adjustment for changes in risk factors and severity of illness around the time of birth; and to identify changes in these factors that might explain changes in outcomes.

DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study with follow-up to a minimum of 18 months of postterm age. After preliminary screening, multivariate models of association between risk/severity of illness factors and outcomes were constructed, validated, and used to adjust outcomes (death and major impairment to 18 to 24 months of age).

SETTING

Regional neonatal intensive care unit for referral of "outborn" infants.

PATIENTS

Two hundred eighty-seven consecutively admitted infants who weighted < or = 800 gm at birth (97% follow-up).

RESULTS

The death rate during the 1980s did not fall significantly (p adjusted for risk factors = 0.115). The major impairment rate fell (odds ratio, 0.24 (95% confidence interval, 0.10, 0.60); p = 0.002, adjusted for delivery route and respiratory failure measures), mainly because of a reduced rate of blindness, not attributable to cryotherapy. The risk factors that improved and were possibly related to the reduced impairment rate were blood pH and glucose concentration, and serum sodium concentration in the first 48 hours of life.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite an increasing selection for referral of less mature and more severely ill outborn babies near the "limit of viability," and despite more aggressive care, the rate of major impairment fell significantly during the 1980s. This trend was enhanced by adjustment for severity of illness. The fall was attributable to a reduced rate of blindness, and was associated with evidence of improved control of physiologic balance after birth.

Health care technology in the United Kingdom

The UK National Health Service (NHS) is based on the principle that everyone is entitled to any kind of medical treatment for any condition, free of charge. The NHS is funded primarily from general tax revenues. The health service is presently in the middle of a profound change in philosophy and practice. Health authorities have been given specific responsibility for identifying their population's health needs and for using public money to buy services under a specific contract so as to meet those needs. Health care technology assessment (TA) has also developed very rapidly in the UK recently. While the limited budgets of the NHS have controlled expenditures for health care, there has not been a coherent policy for technology development until very recently. During the past decade, awareness of the concepts of appropriateness, effectiveness, and cost-benefit analysis have moved to center stage on the agenda of policy makers. A new R&D strategy in the NHS is emphasizing technology assessment as an aid to choice and management of technology. The increased necessity for making choices, and the increasing availability of results from health care TA, seem to indicate that such research will have an increasing impact on health care and its management.

Outcome of neonates transported between Level III centres depends upon centre of care

This study aimed to clarify whether the adverse outcomes seen in babies transported between New Zealand Level III intensive care nurseries were due to the transport itself or to possible differences in care in different centres. The outcomes of 34 infants inborn at National Women's Hospital, Auckland but transported to other centres were compared with those of 68 matched controls inborn at the receiving centres and with 68 controls inborn and cared for at National Women's Hospital. Transport was associated with a transient (non-significant) deterioration in respiratory status but no increase in chronic lung disease. However, infants cared for elsewhere, whether transported or control, had more periventricular hemorrhage than Auckland babies (23% and 29% vs 15%, P = 0.03) and worse neurodevelopmental outcome (70% and 66% vs 88% of those whose outcomes were known were normal at follow up, P = 0.002). We conclude that differences in care between centres may be more important than the transport itself in determining the long-term outcome of transported neonates.

Changing survival and impairment rates at 18-24 months in outborn very low-birth-weight infants: 1984-1987 versus 1980-1983

Outcomes at 18-24 months corrected age of very low-birth-weight infants admitted to our Neonatal Intensive Care Unit in 1984-1987 (period 2) were compared with the outcomes of infants admitted in 1980-1983 (period 1) (total 1357 infants). In the 500-750-g birth-weight subgroup, the survival rate increased from 32 to 54% (p = 0.002). Rates of moderate and severe impairment at 18-24 months (neurosensory deficit, or Bayley corrected mental developmental index < or = 68) in this subgroup decreased from 41 to 15% (p = 0.005), and in those without severe impairment, mean mental Bayley scores in periods 1 and 2 were 84 +/- 18 and 90 +/- 16, respectively (p = 0.20). Analysis after exclusion of small-for-gestational-age infants gave similar results. In the small-for-gestational-age infants of birth weight 500-750 g, the survival rate increased but the impairment rate was unchanged between periods. It is concluded that outcomes improved in 1984-1987 compared with 1980-1983 only for infants with birth weight of 500-750 g.

Adverse effects of neonatal transport between level III centres

The effect of neonatal transport between level III intensive care nurseries was studied by comparing the outcome of 40 infants inborn at a regional level III centre but transported to other level III nurseries for intensive care, with 80 matched inborn controls. Transport appeared to affect respiratory status adversely but transiently. However, transported infants grew less well than control infants (32% were below 3rd centile for weight at 36 weeks vs 15% of controls), were more likely to suffer periventricular haemorrhage (40 vs 21% of controls) and had a worse neurodevelopmental outcome (70% normal at follow up vs 83% of controls). It can be concluded that for infants inborn at the National Women's Hospital, Auckland, transport to another level III centre for intensive care is associated with an increased risk of adverse outcome.

Neonatal intensive care. When and where is it justified?

There is a wide panorama of disorders in the newborn infant where neonatal intensive care has been proven effective in reducing mortality. Although modern neonatal intensive care can be very costly, short and simple interventions for support and resuscitation still can be highly beneficial. In reviewing the field of neonatal intensive care during the 1980s, it becomes evident that a major challenge for the future will be to apply physiological principles of great and proven value for the newborn baby to more simple devices. Only thereby can the technology of neonatal care defined as a complex of actions-not only equipment and techniques-become justified for future generations.