Guidelines to identify abnormalities after childhood urinary tract infections: a prospective audit

Outcomes of guidelines from health technology assessment organizations in community-based primary care: a systematic mixed studies review

BACKGROUND

Health technology assessment (HTA) organizations generate guidelines to inform healthcare practices toward improved health outcomes. This review sought to identify and classify outcomes of guidelines from HTA organizations within published research.

METHODOLOGY

We performed a systematic mixed studies review of empirical studies that (a) referred to a published guideline from an HTA organization and (b) reported an outcome resulting from a guideline. We searched the published literature in English or French within seven databases. Outcome types were classified within five dimensions of an existing framework for online health information (e.g., relevance, cognitive/affective impact, and use). Subdimensions were inductively developed. A two-phase sequential data synthesis was performed. Phase 1: a hybrid deductive-inductive thematic analysis identified the types of outcomes and displayed their relationships on a concept map. Phase 2: descriptive statistics were tabulated by the type of outcome.

RESULTS

A total of 6,719 records were retrieved through searches on 6 February 2023. After screening, we included 120 observational studies (twenty-one qualitative, ninety-four quantitative, and five mixed methods). Phase 1 identified twenty-nine types of outcomes. The most frequently reported outcomes were within the organizational dimension (reported in ninety-four studies). The most common subdimensions were "Referrals" (thirty-eight occurrences), the "Quality of Prescriptions" (fifteen occurrences), and the "Quality of Diagnosis" (eight occurrences). For Phase 2, we could only generate descriptive statistics on seventeen outcomes. These were almost equally distributed among positive, neutral, and negative effects. Our results contribute to knowledge about the outcomes of HTA guidelines and options for documenting and measuring them in future evaluations.

A retrospective study of uropathogen and its antibiotic resistance among children with urinary tract infection from a single center in China

Urinary tract infection (UTI) is a well-known bacterial infection posing serious health problem in children. A retrospective study was conducted to explore the uropathogen and its antibiotic resistance in children with UTI. Data of urine culture and antimicrobial susceptibility test was collected. Consequently, 840 children were included. The overall culture-positive UTI was 458 (54.52 %) with Escherichia coli 166 (36.24 %), followed by Enterococcus faecalis 59 (12.88 %), Enterococcus faecium 70 (15.28 %) and others. They were highly resistant to the most commonly used antibiotics. In 694 children with complicated UTI, there were 8 children with fungal infection. Multiple drug resistance (MDR) was recorded in 315 (80.98 %). The overall proportion of Extended Spectrum β-Lactamase (ESβL) production was 25 (6.43 %). In 146 children with simple UTI, MDR were also detected in 47 (77.05 %). There were 6 (9.84 %) positive for ESβL production. Our study found that complicated UTI was relatively common. Escherichia coli was the most prevalent isolate, followed by Enterococcus faecium and Enterococcus faecalis. These organisms were highly resistant to the most commonly used antibiotics. Relatively high prevalence of MDR and low ESβL-producing organisms were observed.

Conflicting views of physicians and surgeons concerning pediatric urinary tract infection: a comparative review

BACKGROUND

A first febrile urinary tract infection (UTI) is a common condition in children, and pathways of management have evolved over time.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the extent to which pediatricians and surgeons differ in their investigation and management of a first febrile UTI, and to evaluate the justifications for any divergence of approach.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A literature search was conducted for papers addressing investigation and/or management following a first febrile UTI in children published between 2011 and 2021. Searches were conducted on Medline, Embase, and the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register. To be eligible for inclusion, a paper was required to provide recommendations on one or more of the following: ultrasound (US) and voiding cystourethrogram (VCUG), the need for continuous antibiotic prophylaxis and surgery when vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) was detected. The authorship required at least one pediatrician or surgeon. Authorship was categorized as medical, surgical, or combined.

RESULTS

Pediatricians advocated less imaging and intervention and were more inclined to adopt a "watchful-waiting" approach, confident that any significant abnormality, grades IV-V VUR in particular, should be detected following a second febrile UTI. In contrast, surgeons were more likely to recommend imaging to detect VUR (p<0.00001), and antibiotic prophylaxis (p<0.001) and/or surgical correction (p=0.004) if it was detected, concerned that any delay in diagnosis and treatment could place the child at risk of kidney damage. Papers with combined authorship displayed intermediate results.

CONCLUSION

There are two distinct directions in the literature regarding the investigation of an uncomplicated first febrile UTI in a child. In general, when presented with a first febrile UTI in a child, physicians recommend fewer investigations and less treatment, in contrast to surgeons who advocate extensive investigation and aggressive intervention in the event that imaging detects an abnormality. This has the potential to confuse the carers of affected children.

Low yield from imaging after non-E. coli urine tract infections in children treated in primary care and emergency department

BACKGROUND

Imaging is recommended for selected children following urinary tract infections (UTIs) to look for actionable structural abnormalities. Non-E. coli is considered high risk in many national guidelines, but evidence is mainly drawn from small cohorts from tertiary centres.

OBJECTIVE

To ascertain imaging yield from infants and children <12 years diagnosed with their first confirmed UTI (pure single growth >100 000 cfu per ml) in primary care or an emergency department without admission stratified by bacteria type.

DESIGN, SETTING, PATIENTS

Data were collected from an administrative database of a UK citywide direct access UTI service between 2000 and 2021. Imaging policy mandated renal tract ultrasound and Technetium-99m dimercaptosuccinic acid scans in all children, plus micturating cystourethrogram in infants <12 months.

RESULTS

7730 children (79% girls, 16% aged <1 year, 55% 1-4 years) underwent imaging after first UTI diagnosed by primary care (81%) or emergency department without admission (13%). E. coli UTI yielded abnormal kidney imaging in 8.9% (566/6384). Enterococcus and KPP (Klebsiella, Proteus, Pseudomonas) yielded 5.6% (42/749) and 5.0% (24/483) with relative risks 0.63 (95% CI 0.47 to 0.86) and 0.56 (0.38 to 0.83)), respectively. No difference was found when stratified by age banding or imaging modality.

CONCLUSION

In this largest published group of infants and children diagnosed in primary and emergency care not requiring admission, non-E. coli UTI was not associated with a higher yield from renal tract imaging.

Kidney Echogenicity and Vesicoureteral Reflux in Children with Febrile Urinary Tract Infection

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate increased kidney echogenicity as a predictor of vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) in young children with first febrile urinary tract infection (UTI).

STUDY DESIGN

We performed a single center retrospective study of hospitalized children with first febrile UTI diagnosed in accordance with the American Academy of Pediatrics guidelines. All patients had kidney bladder ultrasound (KBUS) and voiding cystourethrography. Variables analyzed using χ² test or Mann-Whitney U test as appropriate. Multivariable logistic regression analysis was performed for the abnormal KBUS findings and OR and 95% CI were calculated.

RESULTS

Our cohort included 415 children (830 kidney units) with median age of 5 months (1 month to 5 years) and 80% were female. One hundred thirty-two (31.8%) patients had abnormal KBUS, including increased echogenicity in 45 patients. Overall, 42.2% of patients with increased echogenicity had VUR vs 23.3% with normal ultrasound (P = .013) and 31.1% of patients with increased echogenicity had high-grade III-V VUR vs 8.1% with normal ultrasound (P = .001). In total, 24.3% of kidneys with increased echogenicity had VUR vs 20% with normal ultrasound (P = .246) and 20% of kidneys with increased echogenicity had high-grade III-V VUR vs 9.9%with normal ultrasound (P = .005).

CONCLUSIONS

These data support adding increased kidney echogenicity to the list of other KBUS findings that are helpful in decision making about a need for voiding cystourethrography in young children with first febrile UTI.

Diagnosing and treating occult vesicoureteric reflux using PIC cystography: Is it influenced by abnormalities on DMSA?

BACKGROUND

Positioning the Instillation of Contrast cystography (PICc) is used to identify occult vesicoureteric reflux (VUR) in patients with recurrent urinary tract infections (UTI) despite optimized bladder and bowel function and without VUR demonstrated on conventional imaging.

AIM

To determine the incidence of finding occult VUR in such patients usingPICc and the benefit, if any, of treating it. We also assessed if this was influenced by abnormalities on the pre-operative DMSA.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This was a retrospective review of PICc in our hospital between 2016 and 2018 and involved three paediatric urologists. The primary indication for PICc was two or more culture proven UTIs despite optimized bladder and bowel function and no reflux on voiding cystourethrography (VCUG) or indirect radionuclide cystography (I-RNC). All children had a preoperative DMSA scan to document any abnormalities. PICc was performed in a standardized way to each ureteric orifice. If occult reflux was found, it was treated concomitantly by cystoscopic injection of Deflux®. To assess the influence of the pre-operative DMSA status, the cohort was subdivided into two groups based on the DMSA scan: Group 1-abnormal DMSA, Group 2-normal DMSA. The median follow-up was 26 months (range 3-39 months).

RESULTS

PICc was performed in 25 patients [23 females and 2 males; median age: 7 years (range 2-16 years; IQR = 4)]; 17 from Group 1 and 8 from Group 2. Occult VUR was identified in 22 patients (88%); 15/17 (88.2%) in Group 1 and 7/8 (87.5%) in Group 2 (p = 0.9). After cystoscopic treatment, 21/25 (84%) became infection free and this was not influenced by the preoperative DMSA status (p = 0.6). Fig 1.

DISCUSSION

In this challenging group of patients, looking for and treating occult reflux appears to be clinically useful and beneficial. The ability to test and treat at the same sitting is an added advantage of PICc. The DMSA results did not influence the diagnostic or therapeutic aspect of the process. Our results concur with other published literature.

CONCLUSION

There is a high incidence of finding occult reflux using PICc in this cohort of patients. Concomitant cystoscopic treatment led to 84% of children becoming infection free on follow up. Abnormalities on DMSA did not influence either the likelihood of finding occult reflux or the likelihood of successful treatment.

Urinary tract infection in pediatrics: an overview

OBJECTIVE

This review aimed to provide a critical overview on the pathogenesis, clinical findings, diagnosis, imaging investigation, treatment, chemoprophylaxis, and complications of urinary tract infection in pediatric patients.

SOURCE OF DATA

Data were obtained independently by two authors, who carried out a comprehensive and non-systematic search in public databases.

SUMMARY OF FINDINGS

Urinary tract infection is the most common bacterial infection in children. Urinary tract infection in pediatric patients can be the early clinical manifestation of congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract (CAKUT) or be related to bladder dysfunctions. E. coli is responsible for 80-90% of community-acquired acute pyelonephritis episodes, especially in children. Bacterial virulence factors and the innate host immune systems may contribute to the occurrence and severity of urinary tract infection. The clinical presentation of urinary tract infections in children is highly heterogeneous, with symptoms that can be quite obscure. Urine culture is still the gold standard for diagnosing urinary tract infection and methods of urine collection in individual centers should be determined based on the accuracy of voided specimens. The debate on the ideal imaging protocol is still ongoing and there is tendency of less use of prophylaxis. Alternative measures and management of risk factors for recurrent urinary tract infection should be emphasized. However, in selected patients, prophylaxis can protect from recurrent urinary tract infection and long-term consequences. According to population-based studies, hypertension and chronic kidney disease are rarely associated with urinary tract infection.

CONCLUSION

Many aspects regarding urinary tract infection in children are still matters of debate, especially imaging investigation and indication of antibiotic prophylaxis. Further longitudinal studies are needed to establish tailored approach of urinary tract infection in childhood.

Renal tract abnormalities missed in a historical cohort of young children with UTI if the NICE and AAP imaging guidelines were applied

OBJECTIVE

In a historical cohort of children with a urinary tract infection (UTI) who had already undergone all the imaging procedures, the aim was to determine renal tract abnormalities which would have been missed had we implemented the new guidelines from the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence in the United Kingdom (NICE) or the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

After a UTI episode, forty-three children (28 females, 65%) aged between 2 months and 2 years presenting at two general hospitals with a febrile UTI before 2008 underwent all the recommended imaging studies predating the new guidelines. Hydronephrosis was defined and graded according to the Society for Fetal Urology (SFU) classification. Hydronephrosis grade II (mild pelvicalyceal dilatation), grade III (moderate dilatation), and grade IV (gross dilatation with thinning of the renal cortex), duplication, vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) grade II and above, renal scarring and reduced renal uptake (<45%) on technetium-99m-labeled dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA) scintigraphy were considered significant abnormalities. We calculated the proportion of abnormalities which would have been missed had the new guidelines been used instead.

RESULTS

The median of age was 7.6 months (mean 8.7, range 2-24 months), with the majority (n = 37, 86%) being under 1 year of age. Ultrasound (US) showed hydronephrosis in 14 (32%), all grade II. A voiding cystourethrogram (VCUG) was performed in all and showed VUR ≥ grade II in 16 (37%), including eight children (19%) where it was bilateral. DMSA scan showed scarring in 25 children (58%) of whom 11 (26%) had bilateral scars. Reduced differential renal uptake was present in 10 children (23%). Of the 29 children with normal US, 18 (62%) had renal scarring and nine (31%) had VUR ≥ grade II. The NICE guidelines would have missed 63% of the children with VUR ≥ grade II, including a high proportion of grades IV and V VUR, 44% of the children with renal scarring, and 20% of the children with decreased renal uptake, including some children with bilateral renal scarring and with decreased renal uptake. The AAP guidelines would have missed 56% of the children with VUR ≥ grade II, including a high proportion of grades IV and V VUR, and all children with renal scarring as well as those with decreased renal uptake.

CONCLUSION

The prevalence of renal tract abnormalities missed by the new guidelines is high. They should be used with full awareness of their limitations.