Pneumococcal arthritis

Septic arthritis in the adult caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae: A report of 4 cases and review of the literature

OBJECTIVES

To identify coexistent diseases, clinical features, approaches to management, and predictors of outcome in patients with pneumococcal septic arthritis.

METHODS

Case series of 4 adults with Streptococcus pneumoniae septic arthritis seen at a university hospital, plus a review of 115 adults with pneumococcal septic arthritis reported in the medical literature from 1973 through 2003.

RESULTS

Among our 4 patients, 3 had polyarticular infections, joint prostheses were involved in 1, 3 had underlying joint diseases, and 1 had concurrent meningitis. Infection was caused by penicillin-intermediate/cephalosporine-susceptible S pneumoniae in 1 patient and penicillin-resistant/cephalosporine-intermediate S. pneumoniae in 1 patient. After a mean treatment duration of 6 weeks, all patients were clinically cured of infection. Review of the literature identified 115 cases of S pneumoniae septic arthritis in adults. Clinical data were available for 107 patients. Twenty-nine cases were polyarticular (26%), joint prostheses were involved in 15 patients (13%), and 61 patients had underlying joint disease (57%). Meningitis was a concurrent infection in 15 cases. The presumed primary focus of infection was the respiratory tree in 44 patients. Ninety-six percent of cases were caused by penicillin-susceptible organisms. Cure of infection with survival was achieved in 83% (79 of 95) of patients with native joint septic arthritis and in 67% (8 of 12) of patients with prosthetic joint infection. A good functional outcome (full range of motion or return to baseline range of motion) after infection was achieved by 44 of 71 patients (62%) with native joint infection and by 4 of 7 patients (57%) with infections of prosthetic joints. The likelihood of cure of infection or good functional outcome was not influenced by method of joint drainage.

CONCLUSIONS

S pneumoniae is an uncommon, but not rare, cause of septic arthritis in the adult. Many patients have underlying joint disease (especially rheumatoid arthritis) and coexistent alcoholism. Although most infections involve native joints, prosthetic joint infections comprise 13% of cases. Polyarticular disease occurs in approximately one quarter of patients. Most patients have a preceding or concurrent extra-articular focus of pneumococcal infection. To date, the majority of reported infections are caused by penicillin-susceptible organisms, so penicillin G or a third-generation cephalosporine such as ceftriaxone remains the appropriate treatment option. However, infection with drug-resistant organisms is likely to be an increasing problem in the future. With directed antimicrobial therapy and appropriate joint drainage, the outcome is generally good for patients with native joint infections. In contrast, only two thirds of patients with infections of prosthetic joints survive their infections. Approximately 40% of surviving patients experience functional impairment or chronic pain as a sequelae of their infection.

Streptococcal septic arthritis in adults. A study of 55 cases with a literature review

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the rate of occurrence and characteristics of streptococcal septic arthritis.

METHODS

Retrospective single-center study of patients with bacteriologically documented septic arthritis admitted to a rheumatology department over a 20-year period.

RESULTS

Of 303 cases of septic arthritis, 55 (18%) were due to streptococci and 166 (55%) to Staphylococcus aureus (55%). As compared to patients with S. aureus arthritis, patients with streptococcal arthritis was more likely to be in female (56% vs. 36%, P < 0.006) and older than 60 years of age (71% vs. 58%), less likely to have comorbidities (36% vs. 56%), rheumatoid arthritis (5% vs. 19%, P < 0.01), or diabetes (2% vs. 15%, P < 0.01), and more likely to have cancer (13% vs. 7%). Involved joints and proportions of patients with arthritis in multiple joints were similar in two groups. Mortality was lower in the group with streptococcal infection (3.6% vs. 7.8%). The streptococci were distributed as follows: group A (n = 7), group B (n = 12), group C (n = 4), group D (n = 7), group F (n = 1), group G (n = 2), nongroupable (n = 14), nontypable (n = 1), and Streptococcus pneumoniae (n = 7). Groups A and B and nongroupable strains mainly affected women; group A selectively involved younger patients and group B very elderly patients. Comorbidity, most notably cancer, was common in patients with S. pneumoniae or group D streptococci. The portal of entry was often a skin lesion for groups A and B and a medical procedure for group D. Multiple joint involvement was common with groups A and B and prosthetic joint infection with groups B and C. Group A and S. pneumoniae were associated with severe systemic symptoms and extra articular foci of infection, whereas a smoldering course was more common with groups D and G and with nongroupable strains. Residual joint abnormalities were noted in half the patients, with no differences across groups.

CONCLUSIONS

The features of streptococcal septic arthritis vary according to the group of the causative organism and differ from those of S. aureus arthritis.

Pneumococcal septic arthritis: review of 190 cases

This article reports 13 cases of pneumococcal septic arthritis and reviews another 177 cases reported since 1965. Of 2407 cases of septic arthritis from large series, 156 (6%) were caused by Streptococcus pneumoniae. Mortality was 19% among adults and 0% among children. Pneumococcal bacteremia was the strongest predictor of mortality. At least 1 knee was involved in 56% of adults. Polyarticular disease (36%) and bacteremia (72%) were more common among adults with septic arthritis caused by S. pneumoniae than among adults with other causative organisms. Only 50% of adults with pneumococcal septic arthritis had another focus of pneumococcal infection, such as pneumonia. Functional outcomes were good in 95% of patients. Uncomplicated pneumococcal septic arthritis can be managed with arthrocentesis and 4 weeks of antibiotic therapy; most cases of pneumococcal prosthetic joint infection can be managed without prosthesis removal. A fatal case of septic arthritis caused by a beta-lactam-resistant strain of S. pneumoniae is also presented.

Septic arthritis due to Streptococcus pneumoniae in Nottingham, United Kingdom, 1985-1998

Pneumonia and meningitis are the 2 most frequent manifestations of Streptococcus neumoniae infection. Pneumococcal septic arthritis is considered to be relatively uncommon. Between 1985 and 1998, 32 (8. 2%) of 389 cases of septic arthritis seen in the 2 hospitals in Nottingham, United Kingdom, were due to S. pneumoniae. Six of 7 children with pneumococcal septic arthritis were aged <2 years. Of the 25 adults, 20 (80%) were aged >60 years, 11 (44%) had concomitant pneumococcal infection elsewhere, and 23 (92%) had articular or nonarticular diseases and/or other risk factors. In the elderly, a lack of febrile response was striking. S. pneumoniae was isolated from blood and joint cultures in >70% of cases, and gram-positive diplococci were seen in the joint fluids of 90% of patients. The mean duration of antimicrobial therapy for adults was twice as long as that for children. Eight (32%) of the adults died.

Unusual manifestations of invasive pneumococcal infection

Unusual pneumococcal infections occurred frequently in the preantibiotic age but rapidly declined with the advent of the antibiotic era. Unfortunately, the morbidity and mortality associated with invasive pneumococcal disease remain high despite antibiotic therapy and monumental advances in medical technology. The incidence of invasive pneumococcal disease has increased recently because of the onset of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) epidemic and the emergence of antibiotic-resistant pneumococcus. Robert Austrian described the clinical triad of pneumococcal pneumonia, meningitis, and endocarditis, a syndrome that now bears his name. Although seen infrequently today, unusual manifestations of pneumococcal infection such as those Austrian reported still occur. A review of these cases is warranted because, as drug-resistant organisms continue to emerge worldwide, more unusual pneumococcal infections will be seen. Streptococcus pneumoniae is responsible for a remarkable array of disease processes; our literature review uncovered 95 different types of unusual pneumococcal infections representing 2,064 cases. Examples of these infections included pancreatic and liver abscesses, aortitis, gingival lesions, phlegmonous gastritis, inguinal adenitis, testicular and tubo-ovarian abscesses, and necrotizing fasciitis. We also reviewed predisposing underlying illnesses and conditions. Alcoholism, HIV infection, splenectomy, connective tissue disease, steroid use, diabetes mellitus, and intravenous drug use remain common risk factors for invasive pneumococcal infections. Currently, multidrug-resistant S. pneumoniae remains susceptible to vancomycin and several new third-generation fluoroquinolones. As what some fear will be a possible postantibiotic era approaches, clinicians must be able to recognize and manage unusual pneumococcal infections.

Destructive pneumococcal septic arthritis in end-stage renal disease

Pneumococcal arthritis generally presents as non-destructive monoarthritis, although some underlying metabolic disorders such as liver failure and diabetes have been suggested to represent a risk factor for severe joint disease. Here we report a case of destructive pneumococcal arthritis of the left hip joint in a patient suffering from chronic renal failure treated with hemodialysis for ten years. Inspite of effective anti-pneumococcal antibiotic treatment, the patient with preexisting renal osteopathy and a mild osteoarthritis continued to suffer from severe and disabling pain of the left hip. This case demonstrates that pneumococcal joint infection in patients with underlying uremic bone disease can lead to quick deterioration of the affected joint.

Septic arthritis in adults: clinical features, outcome, and intensive care requirements

A review of adults with septic arthritis was undertaken to evaluate outcome of treatment and intensive care requirements in a community-based teaching hospital. During an 80-month period (1986-1992), 38 cases of septic arthritis were identified. Underlying joint disease was present in 84% of patients. Mean age was 68 years, with a range of 26 to 100 years and a median of 70 years. Patients did not always initially display signs of infection; fever was present in only 42%, and leukocytosis was present in 67%. Total in-hospital mortality was 26%, but the mortality attributed to septic arthritis was 13%. Polyarticular septic arthritis occurred in 26% of patients and carried a 40% mortality. Twenty-four percent of patients required transfer to the intensive care unit (ICU); they had a 67% mortality. Three of four patients with polyarticular septic arthritis requiring intensive care died. Average length of hospital stay for survivors receiving a full course of antibiotics was 35 days; it diminished to 14 days for 5 uncomplicated cases who received home IV antibiotics. Eighty-nine percent of survivors had return of function of the affected joints. Thirty-two percent required surgical intervention, and 5% were complicated by osteomyelitis. Septic arthritis remains a costly disease affecting primarily the elderly with underlying joint disease. Polyarticular septic arthritis and the need for ICU care portend a high mortality. The functional outcome of those who recovered was generally good.