Normal male external genitalia do not rule out CYP11A1 deficiency

Side-chain cleavage enzyme deficiency: Systematic review and case series

OBJECTIVE

P450 side-chain cleavage deficiency (SCCD) patients present with primary adrenal insufficiency (PAI) with or without undervirilized external genitalia. The distinction between classic and nonclassic steroidogenic acute regulatory protein deficiency has been described, whereas in SCCD is unclear. The data on gonadal function and its correlation with SCCD genotype has not been studied. We describe our experience and perform a systematic review of genetically proven SCCD patients to determine the distinct phenotypic and genotypic characteristics of 46,XY SCCD patients with typical male external genitalia (SCCD-TMG) and atypical (SCCD-AG) external genitalia.

DESIGN, PATIENTS AND MEASUREMENTS

Retrospective review of three genetically proven SCCD patients from our centre and per-patient data analysis from a systematic review of 52 probands was performed. SCCD-TMG (n = 19) was defined as external genitalia of Sinnecker score 1 with 46,XY  karyotype; the rest (Sinnecker 2-5) were classified as SCCD-AG (n = 15).

RESULTS

We report two new Indian cases of SCCD with three novel likely pathogenic variants and pubertal follow-up of a previously reported patient. In systematic review, age at diagnosis of PAI and elevated renin were not different between 46,XY  SCCD-TMG (n = 19) and SCCD-AG (n = 15), whereas spontaneous puberty (9/9 vs. 0/3, p = .0045), normal prepubertal (5/5 vs. 6/6, p = .002), pubertal gonadotropins (2/9 vs. 0/3, p = 1) and normal pubertal testosterone (9/11 vs. 0/3, p = .027) were more common in SCCD-TMG. Testicular adrenal rest tumours were exclusive to SCCD-TMG (n = 4). SCCD-TMG was associated with four particular genotypes [monoallelic p.Glu314Lys with another deleterious variant on the second allele (p.Glu314Lys/X-CHS: X-compound heterozygous state), biallelic p.Arg451Trp, p.Phe215Ser/p.Arg232Ter and monoallelic p.Val79Ile]. 46,XX SCCD  patients with p.Glu314Lys/X-CHS also had normal gonadotropins with spontaneous puberty.

CONCLUSION

SCCD-TMG is associated with four specific genotypes and distinct gonadal characteristics from SCCD-AG with overlapping features of PAI.

Can Digenic, Tri-Allelic Inheritance of Variants in STAR and CYP11A1 Give Rise to Primary Adrenal Insufficiency? A Case Report

An eight-year old South Asian boy presenting with progressive hyperpigmentation was found to have primary adrenal insufficiency (PAI) in the form of isolated glucocorticoid deficiency. Follow up of this boy for nine years, until the age of 17 years showed normal pubertal onset and progression. Molecular evaluation, by targeted next generation sequencing of candidate genes linked to PAI revealed changes in two genes that are intricately linked in the early stages of steroid biosynthesis: compound heterozygous variants in STAR, c.465+1G>A and p.(E99K), plus a heterozygous rs6161 change in CYP11A1. No variants in other known causal genes were detected. The proband's mother was heterozygous for the c.465+1G>A STAR and rs6161 CYP11A1 variants, while the father was homozygous for the p.(E99K) alteration in STAR but wild-type for CYP11A1. Both parents had normal adrenal cortical function as revealed by short Synacthen tests. The STAR variant c.465+1G>A will lead to abnormal splicing of exon 4 in mRNA and the addition of the p.(E99K) variant, predicted damaging by SIFT and CADD, may be sufficient to cause PAI but this is by no means certain given that the unaffected father is homozygous for the latter change. The rs6161 CYP11A1 variant [c.940G>A, p.(E314K)] has recently been demonstrated to cause PAI in conjunction with a severe rare disruptive change on the other allele, however sequencing of the coding region of CYP11A1 revealed no further changes in this subject. We wondered whether the phenotype of isolated glucocorticoid deficiency had arisen in this child due to tri-allelic inheritance of a heterozygous CYP11A1 change along with the two STAR variants each of which contribute a partial loss-of-function burden that, when combined, is sufficient to cause PAI or if the loss-of-function c.465+1G>A combined with the presumed partial loss-of-function p.(E99K) in STAR could be causative.