Death despite malaria prophylaxis

Malaria in Aberdeen: an audit of 110 patients admitted between 1980-1991

All 110 patients seen in North East Scotland after contracting malaria from foreign travel were treated in the Regional Infection Unit in Aberdeen. Those patients managed there from January 1980 to March 1991 are described. There were 54 episodes of Plasmodium falciparum malaria (49%) and 26 episodes (23%) of Plasmodium vivax malaria. The remainder had either mixed infection or were diagnosed as malaria on high clinical probability. The majority of the patients were male (80%) and under 40 years of age (84%). Most patients were either caucasians born in the UK (69%) or native Africans (23%) who were students recently arrived for further education or who had returned from visiting their country of origin for summer holidays. The British residents acquired infection either while on oil related business in West or Central Africa (46%) or after travelling on holiday (30%). The peak incidence of presentation was August and September. 93.5% of patients with falciparum malaria had returned or originated from Africa. 42% with vivax malaria had visited Africa and 27% Papua New Guinea. 70% had been prescribed antimalarial prophylaxis but less than half of these took their medication correctly. The majority of patients with falciparum malaria presented within two weeks of arrival in Britain while patients with vivax malaria presented at varying (but generally longer) intervals, 42% being diagnosed more than three months after exposure. Falciparum infection was more severe although there have been no deaths in the unit from malaria. Our experience seemed of interest and worth reporting because of the number of patients whose infection reflected travel related to the off shore oil industry, which is centred in Aberdeen.

Validation of malaria surveillance case reports: implications for studies of malaria risk

STUDY OBJECTIVE

The aim of the study was to investigate the quality of national malaria surveillance reports in the United Kingdom.

DESIGN

Persons with malaria reported to the Malaria Reference Laboratory (MRL) in 1987 were contacted by post to verify existing records with respect to key variables. The MRL data set was then analysed for inaccuracies.

SETTING

The study was confined to UK residents.

PARTICIPANTS

602 persons with malaria in 1987 responded (53%).

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Review of case reports showed few missing data except for duration of residence in the UK, detailed chemoprophylactic regimens, and compliance. There were more missing surveillance data in reports of ethnic minority groups, principally in dates of travel (p = 0.008) and chemoprophylaxis use (p less than 0.0001). Patient recall in the survey was at variance with the surveillance reports in dates of travel and onset of infection, chemoprophylaxis use, and in compliance. Surveillance reports overestimated the number of days between leaving a malarious area and onset of symptoms (by 9 d for P falciparum and by 24 d for P vivax), and underestimated the delay between onset and diagnosis of P falciparum by 3 d. Over 50% of patients who had recalled the use of chloroquine, proguanil, pyrimethamine/dapsone, and pyrimethamine had not been recorded as having taken these drugs on the surveillance reports. Reported compliance also differed between the two data sets.

CONCLUSIONS

It is recommended that research units test the quality of their surveillance data before embarking on analytical studies used to generate health policy guidelines.

Malaria in Leicester 1983-1988: a review of 114 cases

We have reviewed 114 episodes of malaria in 110 patients who were admitted to the Infectious Diseases Unit in Leicester during the 5 year period from February 1983-January 1988. There were 71 episodes of vivax malaria (62%), 33 episodes of falciparum malaria (29%), four patients with mixed infection and six patients with negative blood films who were diagnosed on clinical suspicion alone. Most patients presented in the summer months, 68% were aged under 40 years, 39% were born in the Indian subcontinent, 23% in East Africa and 23% in Britain. Eighty-two per cent of patients with falciparum malaria had recently returned from Africa whereas 82% with vivax malaria had visited Asia. Thirty six per cent had been given antimalarial chemoprophylaxis but only half of these took medication correctly. Seventy five per cent of episodes of falciparum malaria presented within 2 weeks of arrival in Britain, however vivax malaria could present at any time and 49% of cases occurred over 3 months after exposure. Presenting symptoms and signs were often non-specific. Twenty nine per cent of patients had been treated with antibiotics and 11% received antimalarials prior to admission. Vivax malaria was generally a mild infection but falciparum malaria was often severe with 39% of patients experiencing complications including one death. Although Plasmodium vivax and P. falciparum are morphologically similar the diseases caused by the two species of parasite are quite distinct. Physicians must ensure that malaria is excluded in anyone who has travelled to an endemic area.

Malaria--an overview

The epidemiology, clinical features, diagnosis, prognosis, management, chemotherapy and chemoprophylaxis of malaria are reviewed.