Underenumeration in 1991 census. Forms not retrieved

Informing the market: the strengths and weaknesses of information in the British National Health Service

Many countries are experimenting with planned (or quasi-) markets to discover if they can efficiently deliver health care in keeping with societal objectives. This paper examines the information requirements of this approach. Information is necessary in order to compare the performance of providers, to support billing, and to monitor access to care. It should be accurate, unambiguous, and resistant to manipulation. We draw on a project to find out how information on hospitalisation could be used in contracting in the British National Health Service. We conclude that the existing British system fails to provide robust measures of how many patients are treated, for what conditions, and with what treatments. We identify some promising remedies, others that are more difficult, and some which may be impossible to implement in any planned market, given the uncertainty of clinical practice.

Challenges of monitoring use of secondary care at local level: a study based in London, UK

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To provide those working at district level with practical guidance on using hospital data linked to small geographic areas to explore patterns of care.

DESIGN

Examination of the association between age standardised hospital episode rates for the commonest diagnostic categories and deprivation levels (Carstairs index) of the electoral ward of residence.

SETTING

An inner London district, Kensington, Chelsea and Westminster, with a population of approximately 325,000.

POPULATION

All finished consultant episodes recorded in NHS hospitals for the district population in the year to April 1994.

MAIN RESULTS

Many, but not all, disease categories were associated strongly with deprivation, with high episode rates in the most deprived electoral wards. This is partly due to more of those in deprived areas being admitted to hospital and to them being admitted more often.

CONCLUSIONS

A wide range of factors needs to be taken into account in interpreting these data. They include the contribution of the private sector and artifacts of both the numerator and denominator. This paper provides a framework for those working at district level to begin to analyse the association between hospitalisation and deprivation locally. It also identifies some of the issues that must be taken into account when seeking to interpret these data.

Is the risk of cancer increased in Asians living in the UK?

The pattern of cancer in white and Asian (Indian, Pakistani, and Bangladeshi) children living in the West Midlands Health Authority Region was investigated using age standardised incidence rates. Two sets of rates were calculated, a 10 year rate (1982-91) using survey based estimates of the ethnic population and a four year rate (1989-92) using the ethnic population counts from the 1991 census. The 10 year rates showed a significantly higher annual incidence of cancer in Asian (159.1/million/year) than in white (130.8) children. The pattern of cancers in Asian children was different, with an excess of lymphomas and germ cell tumours, and a deficit of rhabdomyosarcomas. These findings were confirmed by the four year rates. Although underestimation of the Asian population probably contributes to the apparent excess, there remains cause for concern that UK Asian children may be at higher risk of cancer. Accurate ethnic population figures and confirmatory studies are urgently required.