Effective fertility counselling for transgender adolescents: a qualitative study of clinician attitudes and practices

Fertility Intentions and Histories Among Transgender Adults Who Started Gender-Affirming Testosterone Before Adulthood

BACKGROUND

As more transgender adolescents and young adults seek gender-affirming care, questions persist about how their desire for potentially fertility-affecting treatment intersects with their fertility intentions.

METHODS

We surveyed 125 individuals born with a uterus and ovaries, living in the United States, initially prescribed gender-affirming testosterone at or before age 18, about their interest in genetically related children and history of fertility preservation and fertility-affecting procedures.

RESULTS

Twenty-two percent of respondents did not want children, and 47% wanted children but did not think a genetic relationship was important. Another 8% indicated having genetically related children was important and 17% indicated they did not know. Only 47% recalled counseling about fertility preservation. Those who might want genetically related children were less satisfied when they did not recall counseling (p = .001). Significantly more people in the group who might want genetically related children still had one or both ovaries (100% vs. 86%; p = .03), desired to carry a pregnancy in the future or were unsure (30% vs. 8%; p = .01), and either desired to use their eggs for genetically related children or were unsure (93% vs. 26%; p < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

More than one-half of individuals prescribed gender-affirming testosterone as adolescents had no interest in genetically related children. Those who were interested in genetically related children were more likely to have other fertility-preserving interests and behaviors, including potentially desiring a pregnancy and still having one or both ovaries. This finding suggests that fertility-related behaviors of individuals prescribed gender-affirming testosterone are in line with their stated goals.

An Intervention to Increase Fertility Preservation Counseling Prior to Starting Gender-Affirming Hormone Therapy

PURPOSE

To determine if an educational handout regarding fertility preservation options affected rates of fertility preservation counseling, REI referrals, and gamete cryopreservation in transgender and nonbinary adolescents.

METHODS

This was a retrospective observational pre/post intervention study of patients seen at a single academic gender-affirming care clinic and were prescribed gender-affirming hormone therapy from January 2022 to January 2023 and April 2023 to April 2024.

EXPOSURE

Educational handout.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary outcome was the rate of fertility preservation counseling.

RESULTS

There were 208 eligible patients, with 143 in the pre-intervention group and 65 in the post-intervention group. There was a significant increase in fertility preservation counseling rates after implementing the educational handout (31.5% counseling rate pre-intervention vs 58.46% post-intervention, percentage change 26.9%, SE 7.3%, P < .001). Of the patients counseled on fertility preservation, there was no significant difference in REI referral rates (percentage change -3.2%, SE 6.5%, P = .6208) or in gamete cryopreservation.

DISCUSSION

Increased access to educational materials increases the rate of fertility preservation counseling in transgender and nonbinary adolescents. More research is needed to determine how to improve resources and empower adolescents and their families to make informed decisions regarding reproductive health.

IMPLICATIONS AND CONTRIBUTION

Clinicians who provide gender-affirming medical care should be equipped with educational resources they can offer their patients. Increased education and counseling may assist patients in making an informed decision regarding their fertility, regardless of whether or not they choose to preserve their fertility.

Patient education and counselling of fertility preservation for transgender and gender diverse people: A scoping review

Objectives

To examine patient education, counselling practices, decision aids, and education resources related to fertility preservation for transgender and gender diverse (TGD) youth and young adults.

Methods

A scoping review was conducted using a comprehensive literature search (Ovid MEDLINE, PubMed Medline, OVID Embase, Ovid PsychoINFO, and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials) conducted from 1806 to October 21, 2022. Inclusion criteria involved abstracts and articles on patient education, counselling, decision aids or education resources regarding fertility preservation for TGD youth and adults.

Results

Of 1,228 identified articles and abstracts, only six articles met inclusion criteria. Three key themes were identified: (1) patient education and counselling practices (n = 4), with majority of patients receiving fertility preservation counselling at their respective centres; (2) decision aids and strategies for clinicians on fertility preservation for TGD individuals (n = 2) and; (3) patient education resources (n = 1). There was a paucity of literature on decision aids and patient education resources.

Conclusions

This study highlights the need to further develop and evaluate decision aids for healthcare providers and patient education resources, including eLearning modules, around fertility preservation for TGD individuals.

Barriers to fertility preservation access in transgender and gender diverse adolescents: a narrative review

Fertility preservation (FP) involves the cryopreservation of gametes, embryos, and/or gonadal tissue oocytes, for future use in family building. FP as part of a comprehensive approach to care of transgender and gender diverse (TGD) individuals is an understudied topic. Current evidence indicates that gender affirming therapies may increase the risk for infertility. As a result, TGD individuals, including adolescents, should receive counseling regarding FP prior to beginning gender affirming treatment. Many barriers exist to TGD adolescents receiving FP counseling and undergoing FP if desired. The objective of this narrative review is to summarize the literature regarding the desire for FP in TGD adolescents, the barriers to TGD adolescents in accessing of FP, and to discuss potential interventions for alleviation of such barriers. A literature search using the following Medical Subject Headings search terms: 'transgender persons' and 'fertility preservation' and 'adolescents' was conducted via searching PubMed. Additional articles were located via reference review. Included articles consist of qualitative and quantitative research and society guidelines. Articles from inception to 1st July 2023 were included. The results of the literature search have been summarized into the format of a narrative review. Key barriers to FP for TGD adolescents include inconsistencies in form and timing of counseling, potential worsening of gender dysphoria with FP treatment, high cost of treatment, limited research on FP outcomes, and legal barriers. Intersectionality between gender identity and other forms of minority status can compound these barriers to FP and healthcare in general. Barriers to TGD adolescents accessing FP are significant. Increased research is needed upon methods to mitigate these barriers. Solutions include increasing uniformity and timing of FP counseling by varying health care providers, advocacy efforts to mitigate legal and financial barriers, increased research efforts in FP outcomes, and increased cultural competency in clinics offering FP care to TGD adolescents.

Update on bioethical, medical and fertility issues in gender incongruence during transition age

PURPOSE

Many issues still remain unresolved in the management of pubertal patients with gender incongruence (GI). The aim of this review is to discuss the main aspects of the treatment of these patients to provide a practical approach for clinicians.

METHODS

A comprehensive literature search within PubMed was performed to provide updates of available evidence regarding the impact on bioethical, medical and fertility issues in gender incongruence during transition age.

RESULTS

Gender Affirming Hormone Treatment (GAHT) and Gender Affirming Surgery (GAS) can induce unsatisfaction with change, future regrets, and the risk of infertility. This raises ethical issues especially in the management of pubertal patients that remain unresolved. Therapy with GnRH analogues (GnRHa) is intended to delay puberty, so as to give the adolescent a longer period of time to decide whether to continue with the treatments. At the level of physical changes, this therapy may have an effect on bone mineralization and body composition; however, long-term longitudinal data are not yet available. An important feature related to the use of GnRHa is the risk of fertility. Gamete cryopreservation is the most established method of fertility preservation (FP) and should be counselled to transgender adolescents. However, these patients are not always interested in having biological children.

CONCLUSION

Based on the current evidence, there is a need to conduct further research to clarify certain issues and to standardize clinical practice and improve counselling in transgender adolescent decision making and avoid regrets in the future.

"Lights and Shades" of Fertility Preservation in Transgender Men Patients: A Clinical and Pathological Review

Fertility preservation (FP) is becoming a critical issue in transgender men who desire biological offspring in the future. The prevalence of transgender individuals in the United States is increasing, and as a result, the demand for gender-affirming surgeries (GAS) and associated FP techniques is rising. Despite the growing demand, there is currently no personalized approach to FP for transgender men, and the available techniques have limitations that require further investigation. In the present review we carefully examine the existing literature on this topic to highlight the shortcomings of current methods and areas where additional research is needed to advance the field. Hormonal therapy (HT), which is an integral part of gender transition in transgender men, can have a significant impact on fertility and may increase the risk of various diseases. Moreover, GAS usually leads to permanent sterility in these patients. Therefore, it is essential to provide patients with accurate information about the benefits and potential risks of different FP techniques, taking into account the patient's reproductive goals. This review underscores the complex and multifaceted nature of FP in transgender men and emphasizes the need for further research to develop more effective and personalized approaches to FP for this population.

Fertility preservation in transgender men and the need for uniform, comprehensive counseling

Objective

To review the literature to assess best practices for counseling transgender men who desire gender-affirming surgery on fertility preservation options.

Design

A scoping review of articles published through July 2021.

Setting

None.

Patient(s)

Articles published in Cochrane, Web of Science, PubMed, Science Direct, SCOPUS, and Psychinfo.

Intervention(s)

None.

Main Outcome Measure(s)

Papers discussing transgender men, fertility preservation (FP), and FP counseling.

Result(s)

The primary search yielded 1,067 publications. After assessing eligibility and evaluating with a quality assessment tool, 25 articles remained, including 8 reviews, 5 surveys, 4 consensus studies, 3 retrospective studies, 3 committee opinions, and 2 guidelines. Publications highlighted the importance of including the following topics during counseling: (1) FP and family building options; (2) FP outcomes; (3) effects of testosterone therapy on fertility; (4) contraception counseling; (5) attitudes toward family building; (6) consequences of transgender parenting; and (7) barriers to success.

Conclusion(s)

Currently, there is a lack of standardization for comprehensive counseling about FP for transgender men. Standardized approaches can facilitate conversation between physicians and transgender men and ensure patients are making informed decisions regarding pelvic surgery and future family building plans.