Model to identify potentially preventable cerebral palsy of intrapartum origin

The role of perinatal and intrapartum risk factors in the etiologyof cerebral palsy in term deliveries in a Turkish population

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the relationship between cerebral palsy (CP) and perinatal and intrapartum risk factors and markers of birth asphyxia.

METHODS

This was a retrospective case-control study of 101 children with CP and 308 controls who were born at the Zeynep Kamil Hospital between 1990 and 2000. The roles of possible perinatal and intrapartum risk factors were investigated in CP development. Chi-square tests, Fisher's exact tests, Student t-tests, and regression analysis were used for statistical analysis (p < 0.05).

RESULTS

The only significant perinatal risk factor was neonatal weight of <2500 grams. The CP rate in the presence of solely intrapartum risk factors was estimated as 24.7% (n = 25). In 39.6% of cases, no risk factor could be identified. When regression analysis was performed, the following factors were significant: decreased beat-to-beat variability on electronic fetal monitoring (EFM) (p = 0.02), an Apgar score of <7 at 1 and 5 minutes (p = 0.02), and the necessity for neonatal intensive care unit admission (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSION

Intrapartum risk factors were significantly more frequent in the CP group (p < 0.01). An increased cesarean section rate could not prevent CP, suggesting that the hypoxic insult that causes CP might be of chronic onset. The development of diagnostic tests to detect non-reassuring fetal status in its intrauterine life and interventions at appropriate times may decrease the CP rate.

Outcome after intrapartum asphyxia in term infants

Investigatory techniques, particularly magnetic resonance (MR) imaging and spectroscopy, performed in the early neonatal period on infants suspected of intrapartum asphyxia i.e. abnormal fetal heart recording, poor cord gases, low Apgar scores and the need for resuscitation, or with neonatal encephalopathy or seizures, have allowed a much better understanding of the patterns of brain injury and the biochemical processes that follow these events. It is usually possible to distinguish these patterns from those seen in other, often confounding, diagnoses. This has allowed far more precision about the timing of insults and in the prediction of particularly motor, feeding and visual outcome and to some extent intellectual outcome. Long-term neurological and psychometric follow-up of infants in whom detailed perinatal clinical histories and examination, haematological and biochemical investigation and MR brain scans are obtained will allow even more accurate prediction of outcome in the future. Such studies also help to validate standardized neonatal and infant clinical neurological examinations, making them useful tools to predict outcome.

Neonatal seizures associated with cerebral lesions shown by magnetic resonance imaging

AIM

To determine the diagnostic potential of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in neonatal seizures; to elucidate the aetiology, timing, and prognosis of the cerebral lesions detected.

METHODS

Thirty one term neonates with clinical seizures underwent ultrasonography between days 1-7 (mean 2.5 days) and a high field spin-echo MRI scan on days 1-30 (mean 8.1 days), both of which were repeated at 3 months of age. Routine investigation excluded, as far as possible, infection, haematological, and metabolic-toxic causes as causes of the neonatal seizures.

RESULTS

Brain abnormality was demonstrated by MRI in 68% of infants and ultrasonographically in 10%. Diffuse brain lesions (present in 29%) were associated with high mortality (58%) and morbidity (42%), whatever the aetiology. In contrast to a better short term prognosis for neonates with focal lesions where no infants died, 33% had a handicap, and the rest were normal at a mean follow up age of 2 1/2 years. Cerebral lesions were presumed to have antepartum origin in 43% of cases. Seizure aetiology was considered to be hypoxic-ischaemic in 35%, haemorrhagic in 26%, metabolic disturbances and cerebral dysgenesis in 16% and unknown in 23%.

CONCLUSIONS

MRI detected a remarkably high incidence of brain lesions in neonatal seizures. Almost half of these were of prenatal origin and pathogenesis may essentially be attributed to hypoxic and/or haemodynamic causes.

Characteristics of successful claims for payment by the Florida Neurologic Injury Compensation Association Fund

OBJECTIVES

Our purpose was to examine the obstetric characteristics of claims paid by the State of Florida after the birth of a neurologically impaired child.

STUDY DESIGN

The Florida Birth Related Neurological Injury Compensation plan is a no-fault alternative to litigation for compensation after a catastrophic neurologic birth injury. The plan has specific criteria for inclusion. We retrospectively analyzed claims for compensation that were accepted and paid (n = 64) after a birth-related neurologic injury. Simple description statistics were compiled for the relative frequencies of various obstetric correlates found in successful claims for payment.

RESULTS

Seventy percent of infants (45) were delivered by cesarean section and 15 of 19 vaginal deliveries (79%) were operative (forceps or vacuum), yielding a 94% operative delivery rate. A persistent nonreassuring fetal heart rate tracing was seen before delivery in all cases. The 5-minute Apgar score was < or = 6 in 91% of deliveries and the 10-minute Apgar score was < 6 in 86% of deliveries. When first examined in the labor and delivery suite, 17 women had a nonreassuring fetal heart rate, and a nonreassuring tracing developed in labor in 47. Nine attempts at vaginal birth after a cesarean section led to a uterine rupture. Seven of these deliveries were either inductions or augmentations against an unfavorable cervix. Forty-five percent (27) of deliveries were associated with meconium-stained amniotic fluid, including 17 infants with meconium aspiration syndrome. There were three shoulder dystocias and four infants with group B streptococcal sepsis. In eight cases (12.5%), there appeared to be a breach of the published standard of care, which contributed to the poor outcome.

CONCLUSION

Most of these cases should not have been eligible for compensation in a traditional tort-based system because the applicable standard of care was not breached. Meeting the published standard for perinatal care failed to prevent these devastating neurologic injuries. Obviously, not all intrapartum injuries can be prevented; however, if we are to prevent similar injuries in the future, we will need to examine the clinical management in these or similar case for clues to develop novel strategies to respond to intrapartum emergencies. An unexpected finding was the frequency of catastrophic birth injuries after an attempted vaginal birth after cesarean section with the predominance of these deliveries associated with oxytocin stimulation against an unripe cervix. It is apparent that the push to lower cesarean section rates is not without some risk.