The need for invasive cardiological assessment and operation: viewpoint of a district general hospital

Need for invasive cardiological assessment and intervention: a ten year review

The uptake of invasive cardiological investigation and cardiopulmonary bypass procedures by the North West Surrey Health District was audited over the years 1979-88. Growth was almost continuous throughout the ten year period. The need within the district each year for coronary angiography seemed to be between 111 and 171 and for surgical revascularisation of the myocardium between 63 and 96 procedures; the first figure is the mean of the second quinquennial period (1984-88) and the second figure the total for 1988. After correction for the standardised mortality ratio and catchment area, the national requirement should lie between 690 and 1070 coronary angiograms and 390 and 600 coronary artery bypass graft operations per million population each year. There is a further national requirement for 70 valvar heart operations and 30 miscellaneous procedures per million population each year. Owing to delays in the provision of services, 20 patients died of a cardiovascular cause while they were on the waiting list for investigation or surgery. In the United Kingdom the annual target to be achieved by 1990 was 300 coronary artery bypass procedures per million population.

Delay to invasive investigation and revascularisation for coronary heart disease in south west Thames region: a two tier system?

OBJECTIVES

To assess the accessibility of invasive investigation and revascularisation procedures in the management of coronary heart disease in a defined population in the South West Thames region over 10 years, and to audit the performance of both the NHS and the private sector.

DESIGN

Analysis of all patient referrals to the regional cardiothoracic centres for coronary heart disease during 1979-88.

SETTING

North West Surrey District Health Authority, which had a mean catchment population of 205,000 during the study period. The health district is one of the 13 in the South West Thames region.

PATIENTS

823 patients aged 34-80 years with suspected coronary heart disease, 204 of whom were referred for private investigation and 619 were referred within the NHS. The NHS referrals were mainly to St Thomas's Hospital during 1979-83 and to St George's Hospital during 1984-8.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Difference in time to investigation and intervention between the NHS and the private patients.

RESULTS

After some variation in earlier years the mean (SD, range) waiting times from referral to cardiac catheterisation and then revascularisation increased progressively in NHS patients, to 115.8 (126.5, 22-482) days and 305.9 (164.4, 22-620) days respectively in 1988. There was no significant change over the 10 years in waiting times within the private sector, with a mean of 17.2 (18.2, 1-62) days to angiography and 22.8 (14.5, 2-152) days to surgery. Fifteen people on the NHS waiting list died of probable cardiac causes. No people on the private waiting list died.

CONCLUSIONS

The performance of the NHS system in South West Thames region in response to emergency referral is adequate. The waiting time to routine investigation and revascularisation is prolonged and seems to be worsening despite increased investigative and surgical activity by the regional centre. The delays may subject NHS patients to unnecessary risk, which is not shared by private patients.