Evidence that continuous normothermic blood cardioplegia offers better myocardial protection than intermittent hypothermic cardioplegia

Myocardial Protection With Different Cardioplegia in Adult Cardiac Surgery: A Network Meta-Analysis

AIM

Cardioplegia is one of the most studied fields of myocardial protection during cardiac surgery. However, the most effective cardioplegia for protection in adult cardiac surgery remains unknown.

METHOD

PubMed and other databases were searched and a network meta-analysis with a Bayesian framework was performed. The primary outcomes were the serum concentrations of creatine kinase-myocardial band (CK-MB), cardiac troponin I, and cardiac troponin T (cTnT) at four time points. Several clinical outcomes were evaluated, including low output syndrome, myocardial infarction, and risk of early mortality. All studies that involved crystalloid cardioplegia without reference to St Thomas cardioplegia or histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution, and if the cardioplegia was used at a temperature between 4°C and 16°C were classified as cold crystalloid (cCCP) or cold blood cBCP cardioplegia. Warm blood cardioplegia (wBCP) was defined as the blood cardioplegia used at a temperature between 32°C and 37°C.

RESULTS

Forty-seven (47) studies with a total of 4,175 patients were included. Seven (7) cardioplegia solutions were used, including cold CCP or BCP, del Nido solution, histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutaratesolution, St Thomas cardioplegia, wBCP and warm terminal blood cardioplegia (wtBCP). The serum concentrations of CK-MB at 2 hours (mean difference [MD], 213.56; 95% confidence interval [CI], -25.79 to -1.59) and cTnT at 24 hours of wBCP (MD, -1.50; 95% CI, -2.69 to -0.31) were significantly lower than that of cCCP. There were no significant differences in other outcomes of these six cardioplegia solutions, when compared to cCCP.

CONCLUSIONS

The seven cardioplegia solutions analysed had similar myocardial protective effects after adult cardiac surgery, although wBCP had a lower CK-MB at 2 hours and lower cTnT at 24 hours.

Early postoperative function of the heart after coronary artery bypass grafting is not predicted by myocardial necrosis and glutathione-associated oxidative stress

BACKGROUND

To investigate whether cardioplegia-related myocardial necrosis, lactate and glutathione release are predictive for early postoperative cardiac function after coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG).

METHODS

Twelve patients with stabile angina scheduled for elective CABG were included. Myocardial release of troponin I (Tn I), creatine kinase MB isoenzyme mass (CK-MB), oxidized glutathione (GSSG) and lactate in blood were measured before cardioplegia, and up to 20 min thereafter. Cardiac function was assessed for 12 postoperative hours.

RESULTS

Release of Tn I and CK-MB peaked at 20 min (-14.5+/-24.1 ng/ml and -23.9+/-30.6 ng/ml, respectively) and lactate at 1 min of reperfusion (-1.5+/-0.6 mmol/l). Significant GSSG release occurred at 5 min, with concomitant increase of glutathione redox ratio. The changes were not correlated to ischemic time. Cardiac index was increased after CPB and remained higher than preoperative value until the first postoperative morning. No correlations between postcardioplegic heart function and markers of tissue injury were found.

CONCLUSIONS

The extent of myocardial reversible and irreversible injury does not predict early postoperative contractile function of the heart.

Comparison between warm blood and crystalloid cardioplegia during open heart surgery

OBJECTIVE

This study was designed to compare the degree of myocardial protection afforded by warm blood and cold crystalloid cardioplegia in a group of patients undergoing elective coronary artery bypass surgery.

METHODS

Seventeen patients, were randomly assigned to Group A (n=9), who received crystalloid cardioplegic solution, and Group B who received warm blood cardioplegic solution (n=8). Before the aorta was clamped, and 10 min after reperfusion, blood samples from the coronary sinus were obtained to assay alpha-tocopherol, beta-carotene, ubiquinol, and thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARS). At the same intervals, biopsies from the left ventricle were obtained to determine ultrastructural alterations.

RESULTS

No significant changes were observed between preischemia and reperfusion values for both blood and crystalloid groups concerning alpha-tocopherol, beta-carotene, and ubiquinol, and no differences between groups were detected. Values for TBARS in group A were 3.49+/-0.3 and 5.27+/-0.45 microM for presichemia and reperfusion samples, respectively (P<0.01). In group B values were 2.6+/-0.3 and 3.54+/-0.3 microM, respectively (P=NS). For electron microscopy studies, semiquantitative analysis showed a significant mitochondrial damage in reperfusion biopsies from group A (grades 0, 3 and 4). In group B, no significant changes were observed in mitochondrial damage between preischemia and repefusion biopsies (except for grade 0).

CONCLUSION

These results indicate that blood cardioplegia affords better protection to the myocyte than crystalloid cardioplegia.

Oxidative stress and mitochondrial damage in coronary artery bypass graft surgery: effects of antioxidant treatments

We examined antioxidant actions in 73 patients undergoing coronary artery surgery by assessing mitochondrial damage and oxidative stress in ventricular biopsies obtained at preischemia and postreperfusion. Those patients who received antioxidant therapy benefited by less oxidative stress and mitochondrial damage.

Hypothermia to reduce neurological damage following coronary artery bypass surgery

BACKGROUND

Coronary artery bypass surgery (CABG) may be life saving, but known side effects include neurological damage and cognitive impairment. The temperature used during cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) may be important with regard to these adverse outcomes, where hypothermia is used as a means of neuroprotection.

OBJECTIVES

To assess the effectiveness of hypothermia during CABG in reducing neurological damage and subsequent cognitive deficits.

SEARCH STRATEGY

The Cochrane Controlled Trials Register was searched for randomised controlled trials (RCT) and this was updated by searching MEDLINE and EMBASE to December 1999 using database specific RCT filters. Reference lists of retrieved articles were searched and experts in the field were contacted.

SELECTION CRITERIA

Only RCTs were considered. All patients undergoing CABG, either first time or revisions, elective or emergency procedures, were included. Any hypothermia protocol was considered. Only trials reporting neurological outcomes were included.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Studies were selected independently and data were extracted from the source papers independently by two reviewers. Authors were contacted for further information. Studies were combined with meta-analysis where appropriate, and meta-regression was used to explore heterogeneity.

MAIN RESULTS

There was a trend towards a reduction in the incidence of non fatal strokes in the hypothermic group (OR 0.68 (0.43, 1.05)). Conversely, there was a trend for the number of non stroke related perioperative deaths to be higher in the hypothermic group (OR 1.46 (0.9, 2.37)). Hypothermia had no effect on the incidence of non fatal myocardial infarction (OR 1.05 (0.81, 1.37)), but the incidence of another marker of myocardial damage, low output syndrome, was higher in the hypothermic group (OR 1.21 (0.99, 1.48). When pooling all "bad" outcomes (stroke, perioperative death, myocardial infarction, low output syndrome, intra aortic balloon pump use) there was no significant advantage of either hypothermia or normothermia (OR 1.07 (0.92, 1.24)). Only 4 of 17 trials reported neuropsychological function as an outcome.

REVIEWER'S CONCLUSIONS

This review could find no definite advantage of hypothermia over normothermia in the incidence of clinical events. Hypothermia was associated with a reduced stroke rate, but this is off set by a trend towards an increase in non stroke related perioperative mortality and myocardial damage. There is insufficient data to date to draw any conclusions about the use of mild hypothermia. Similarly, there is insufficient data to date to comment on the effect of temperature during CPB on subtle neurological deficits, and further trials are needed in these areas.

Leucocyte-depleted cardioplegia does not reduce reperfusion injury in hypothermic coronary artery bypass surgery

This study investigated the effects of leucocyte-depleted cardioplegia on postreperfusion oxidative stress and myocardial injury in elective hypothermic coronary artery bypass surgery. Forty patients were randomized to receive either cardioplegia with leucocytes depleted by an in-line Pall BC1B filter, or blood cardioplegia without leucocyte depletion. Transmyocardial oxidative stress was assessed by oxidized glutathione measurements in samples taken simultaneously from the coronary sinus and aortic root, and myocardial injury by postoperative CKMB and troponin-T measurements. The BC1B filters reduced numbers of cardioplegia leucocytes by a mean of 90.7%. Both patient groups demonstrated significant increases (p < 0.001) in transcardiac oxidized glutathione gradients after crossclamp release. No significant differences were found between the groups for postreperfusion oxidized glutathione gradients, postoperative levels of CKMB or troponin-T, or in the frequency of perioperative and postoperative complications. These results suggest that leucocyte-depleted cardioplegia does not significantly improve myocardial protection in patients undergoing elective coronary artery bypass surgery.

Intraoperative release of troponin T in coronary venous and arterial blood and its relation to recovery of left ventricular function and oxidative metabolism following coronary artery surgery

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the intraoperative release of troponin T during uncomplicated coronary artery surgery and to determine its relation to ischaemic time and to recovery of left ventricular function and oxidative metabolism.

DESIGN

A prospective observational study.

SETTING

Cardiac surgical unit in a tertiary referral centre.

METHODS

Troponin T, creatine kinase, and lactate were analysed from arterial and coronary sinus samples taken before operation, and 1, 4, 6, 10, 20, 35, and 45 minutes after cross clamp release. Net myocardial troponin T release and lactate extraction were derived from their respective arteriovenous differences. Haemodynamic measurements were made using a thermodilution pulmonary artery catheter.

PATIENTS

45 patients, mean (SD) age 62 (9) years, with two or three vessel coronary artery disease and chronic stable angina undergoing routine coronary artery surgery.

RESULTS

Before operation, troponin T concentrations were not raised, but within one minute of cross clamp release they increased progressively in both coronary sinus and arterial blood for the entire 45 minutes of reperfusion studied. Coronary sinus troponin T concentrations were consistently higher than arterial concentrations at all time points (p < 0.001), indicating net troponin T release by the myocardium. Peak net troponin T release and area under the curve of net troponin T release correlated closely with ischaemic time (r = 0.58 and r = 0.61, p < 0.0001 for both). Area under the curve of arterial troponin T concentration was also significantly correlated with ischaemic time (r = 0.44, p < 0.01). Patients with cross clamp times longer than 72 minutes (upper quartile for ischaemic time) had greater troponin T release, delayed reversion to lactate extraction, and lower left ventricular stroke work index three hours after surgery, compared with patients who had short (< 50 minutes, lower quartile) and intermediate (51-71 minutes, interquartile) cross clamp times. Peak net troponin T release and area under the curve of arterial troponin T concentration were inversely correlated with left ventricular stroke work index three hours after surgery (r = -0.57, r = -0.38, p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Troponin T concentrations increased in every patient after cross clamp release, and were consistently higher in coronary sinus blood than in arterial blood, indicating net myocardial release of troponin T during the period of reperfusion. Intraoperative net troponin T release has functional significance, as it is closely related to ischaemic time and reflects delayed recovery of left ventricular function and oxidative metabolism; therefore, its measurement may contribute to the perioperative assessment of myocardial injury sustained during coronary artery surgery.

Role of leucocytes in free radical production during myocardial revascularisation

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the role of leucocytes in free radical production in patients with depressed or normal ejection fraction undergoing coronary bypass.

DESIGN

Two randomised control trials.

SETTING

Tertiary care centre.

PATIENTS AND INTERVENTIONS

In the first study, 22 patients with ejection fractions of < or = 40% received blood cardioplegic reperfusion with (n = 11) or without (n = 11) leucocyte depletion. In the second study, 22 patients with ejection fractions > or = 45% received either leucocyte depleted (n = 11) or blood cardioplegia (n = 11).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Glutathione, hypoxanthine, and lipid peroxidation products were measured in coronary sinus blood and plasma before aortic cross clamping and at 0, 15, and 30 minutes after unclamping. Haemodynamic variables and creatine kinase MB isoenzymes were monitored on the first postoperative day. Comparison between treatments was performed on difference (delta) between measurements at time 0 and at baseline, and on slopes obtained by fitting measurements after unclamping with a linear regression model.

RESULTS

At unclamping no difference in delta for plasma glutathione redox ratio (oxidised/total glutathione, %) was observed between treated and control groups with low ejection fraction (delta = 16 (SD 8.39) and 24 (7.0) redox ratio %, respectively). Baseline value recovery rate (redox ratio %/min) was significantly faster in treated v control patients (slope -0.912 (0.380) v -0.158 (0.200), P < 0.005, respectively). Cardiac index showed a trend to greater improvement in the treated group (slope 0.04 (0.03) v 0.003 (0.002) 1/min/m2/h, P < 0.02, treated v controls, respectively). In patients with normal ejection fraction, leucocyte depletion did not result in significant improvement v controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Leucocyte depletion seems to provide benefit only in patients with left ventricular dysfunction.