Autoimmunity in chronic liver disease caused by hepatitis delta virus

Autoimmune Hepatitis Induced by Hepatitis Delta Virus: A Conundrum

Introduction

The association of hepatitis delta virus (HDV) infection with positive autoantibodies and autoimmune features has been known for decades. However, to date, very few cases of clinical autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) have been reported in association with HDV infection, most of them being in the context of treatment with peginterferon.

Case Report

This case refers to a 46-year-old woman born in Guinea-Bissau who moved to Portugal in 2018 to investigate complaints of diffuse abdominal discomfort and nausea. Her initial work-up, including laboratory and liver histology, was consistent with type 1 AIH. She had HBe antigen-negative chronic hepatitis B virus infection with negative DNA and also a positive total anti-HDV antibody, with negative IgM and undetectable RNA. Therefore, after initiating prophylactic tenofovir difumarate, she was started on prednisolone followed by azathioprine, which was later stopped due to presumed hepatotoxicity. Repeated histology showed signs of viral superinfection, and she was treated with acyclovir due to a positive herpes simplex IgM, with HDV RNA remaining negative. A third flare in transaminases prompted the introduction of mycophenolate mofetil (MMF) after a thorough exclusion of additional causes of liver disease. About 6 months later, during another bout of hepatitis, HDV RNA was finally positive and classified as genotype 5. MMF was stopped, and, considering a contraindication to interferon, the patient was offered therapy with bulevirtide, which she refused for personal reasons as she is currently living in her home country.

Discussion

This is a challenging case of autoimmune or "autoimmune-like" hepatitis, probably induced by chronic HDV infection. High suspicion of HDV was essential because, had the case been interpreted as refractory AIH, with escalation of immunosuppression, a more severe course of the viral infection might have ensued. Recently, HDV suppression with bulevirtide was shown to reverse autoimmune liver disease. We hypothesize that the same could have happened to our patient, had she accepted this treatment.

Management of autoimmune hepatitis induced by hepatitis delta virus

Approximately 12-72 million people worldwide are co-infected with hepatitis B virus (HBV) and hepatitis delta virus (HDV). This concurrent infection can lead to several severe outcomes with hepatic disease, such as cirrhosis, fulminant hepatitis, and hepatocellular carcinoma, being the most common. Over the past few decades, a correlation between viral hepatitis and autoimmune diseases has been reported. Furthermore, autoantibodies have been detected in the serum of patients co-infected with HBV/HDV, and autoimmune features have been reported. However, to date, very few cases of clinically significant autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) have been reported in patients with HDV infection, mainly in those who have received treatment with pegylated interferon. Interestingly, there are some patients with HBV infection and AIH in whom HDV infection is unearthed after receiving treatment with immunosuppressants. Consequently, several questions remain unanswered with the challenge to distinguish whether it is autoimmune or "autoimmune-like" hepatitis being the most crucial. Second, it remains uncertain whether autoimmunity is induced by HBV or delta virus. Finally, we investigated whether the cause of AIH lies in the previous treatment of HDV with pegylated interferon. These pressing issues should be elucidated to clarify whether new antiviral treatments for HDV, such as Bulevirtide or immu-nosuppressive drugs, are more appropriate for the management of patients with HDV and AIH.

Non-organ-specific autoantibodies with unspecific patterns are a frequent para-infectious feature of chronic hepatitis D

Infections with hepatotropic viruses are associated with various immune phenomena. Hepatitis D virus (HDV) causes the most severe form of viral hepatitis. However, few recent data are available on non-disease-specific and non-organ-specific antibody (NOSA) titers and immunoglobulin G (IgG) levels in chronic hepatitis D (CHD) patients. Here, we examined the NOSA titers and IgG levels of 40 patients with CHD and different disease courses and compared them to 70 patients with chronic hepatitis B (CHB) infection. 43% of CHD patients had previously undergone treatment with pegylated interferon-α (IFN-α). The antibody display of 46 untreated patients diagnosed with autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) was used as a reference. The frequency of elevated NOSA titers (CHD 69% vs. CHB 43%, p < 0.01), and the median IgG levels (CHD 16.9 g/L vs. CHB 12.7 g/L, p < 0.01) were significantly higher in CHD patients than in patients with CHB, and highest in patients with AIH (96%, 19.5 g/L). Also, the antinuclear antibody pattern was homogeneous in many patients with AIH and unspecific in patients with viral hepatitis. Additionally, f-actin autoantibodies were only detectable in patients with AIH (39% of SMA). In CHD patients, IgG levels correlated with higher HDV viral loads, transaminases, and liver stiffness values. IgG levels and NOSA were similar in CHD patients irrespective of a previous IFN-α treatment. In summary, autoantibodies with an unspecific pattern are frequently detected in CHD patients with unclear clinical relevance.

Hepatitis Delta Virus Detected in Salivary Glands of Sjögren's Syndrome Patients and Recapitulates a Sjögren's Syndrome-Like Phenotype in Vivo

Background:

Low-level, chronic viral infections have been suspect in the development of select autoimmune diseases, including primary Sjögren's syndrome (pSS). Multiple studies have shown stimulation of antiviral response pathways in pSS tissues suggestive of a viral infection. Yet, with this data in hand, a causal link between a viral infection and development of pSS had not been identified. Therefore, a study was designed to further define the viral landscape within pSS-affected salivary gland tissue to identify potential viral-mediated triggers in the pathogenesis of this autoimmune disease.

Methods:

A viral microarray was utilized to measure viral transcripts present in salivary gland tissue from patients diagnosed with pSS compared to healthy controls. Murine models of salivary gland localized HDV antigen expression were developed to evaluate the capacity of a chronic HDV signature to trigger the development of a pSS-like phenotype.

Results:

Through this analysis, two distinct viral profiles were identified, including the increased presence of hepatitis delta virus (HDV) in 50% of pSS patients evaluated. Presence of HDV antigen and sequence were confirmed in minor salivary gland tissue. Patients with elevated HDV levels in salivary gland tissue were negative for detectible hepatitis B virus (HBV) surface antigen and antibodies to HBV or HDV. Expression of HDV antigens in vivo resulted in reduced stimulated saliva flow, increase in focal lymphocytic infiltrates, and development of autoantibodies.

Conclusion:

Identification of HDV in pSS patients and induction of a complete pSS-like phenotype in vivo provides further support of a viral-mediated etiopathology in the development of pSS.

Autoimmunity and hepatitis C

Hepatitis C is a widespread chronic liver disease leading to cirrhosis and to the complications of portal hypertension. Based on biochemical and clinical features, it is almost indistinguishable from autoimmune hepatitis, which is characterized by the absence of viral infection, and other causes of chronic liver diseases, and represents a classical autoimmune disease with loss of immunological tolerance of liver tissue. Although the differentiation between both diseases is not difficult due the availability of diagnostic viral markers, it is well recognized that not only are autoantibodies present in autoimmune hepatitis frequently detected in hepatitis C, but also that an array of immune-mediated symptoms and diseases occur in patients with chronic hepatitis C. This has prompted research aimed at identifying a link between hepatitis C and autoimmunity, and autoimmune hepatitis in particular. This review focuses on the general immunological mechanisms linking viral infections with autoimmunity and includes the specific features of hepatitis C- and D-associated autoimmunity. Virus infection remains at the center of molecular and cellular research aimed at identifying the forces driving human autoimmunity and autoimmune diseases.

Autoimmunity and viruses

Although viruses are commonly cited as triggers for autoimmune disease, the actual mechanisms by which they initiate autoimmunity are unknown. Molecular mimicry is the most popular hypothesis, and it proposes that viral antigens that share homologies with host antigens generate an immune response that damages host tissue. The viral antigen may not be needed for perpetuation of the disease, and cross-reacting immune responses can involve humoral, cellular, or both types of reactivity. Linear and conformational epitopes may be involved, and foreign antigens do not need to share exact amino acid sequences with self-proteins to activate autoreactive T cells. Bystander effects can enhance the autoimmune process if previously sequestered or cryptic antigens are exposed to the immune system, and superantigens that are produced by the pathogen and are not MHC restricted can result in marked polyclonal activation of CD4 and CD8 T cells. Future studies must differentiate the targets of pathologic immunity and distinguish self-antigens from infectious nonself-antigens. Transgenic animal models of AIH are needed to assess the pathogenicity of the antigenic targets.

The cytoskeleton of digestive epithelia in health and disease

The mammalian cell cytoskeleton consists of a diverse group of fibrillar elements that play a pivotal role in mediating a number of digestive and nondigestive cell functions, including secretion, absorption, motility, mechanical integrity, and mitosis. The cytoskeleton of higher-eukaryotic cells consists of three highly abundant major protein families: microfilaments (MF), microtubules (MT), and intermediate filaments (IF), as well as a growing number of associated proteins. Within digestive epithelia, the prototype members of these three protein families are actins, tubulins, and keratins, respectively. This review highlights the important structural, regulatory, functional, and unique features of the three major cytoskeletal protein groups in digestive epithelia. The emerging exciting biological aspects of these protein groups are their involvement in cell signaling via direct or indirect interaction with a growing list of associated proteins (MF, MT, IF), the identification of several disease-causing mutations (IF, MF), the functional role that they play in protection from environmental stresses (IF), and their functional integration via several linker proteins that bridge two or potentially all three of these groups together. The use of agents that target specific cytoskeletal elements as therapeutic modalities for digestive diseases offers potential unique areas of intervention that remain to be fully explored.

Auto-antibodies in hepatitis C

Hepatitis C virus (HCV) has been implicated in the development of a variety of autoimmune phenomena, some of which are well documented and include a panel of auto-antibodies shared with autoimmune hepatitis (AIH). Anti-nuclear (ANA) and smooth muscle (SMA) antibodies (markers of AIH type 1 [AIH-1]), have been demonstrated in 9-38% and 5-91% of cases respectively, whereas anti-liver/kidney microsomal type 1 (anti-LKM-1) and anti-liver cytosol type 1 antibodies (anti-LC1) (markers of AIH type 2 [AIH-2]), are definitely rarer, especially in adults. The presence of these auto-reactivities in chronic hepatitis C generates clinical overlaps and dilemmas in the correct classification and treatment of such patients. The immunopathological characterization of the auto-antibodies, anti-nuclear and smooth muscle antibodies in particular, combined with internationally defined criteria for the diagnosis of AIH is helpful in this clinical process. Thyroid auto-antibodies and cryoprecitable rheumatoid factors are also commonly detected in hepatitis C, while the occurrence of other auto-antibodies still awaits confirmation.

Autoimmunity in hepatitis C and D virus infection

A large number of viruses are capable of inducing acute or chronic hepatitis. The syndrome of chronic hepatitis encompasses not only viral but also autoimmune liver diseases. The hepatitis C virus, and recently also the hepatitis D virus have been found to be associated with an array of autoimmune syndromes, diseases and markers of autoimmunity. The relationship of hepatotropic virus infection and the immune system leading to virus-associated autoimmunity, and its distinction from genuine autoimmune disease represents a fascinating field of research. Clinically, the differentiation between autoimmune liver diseases, virus infection and virus-associated autoimmunity is difficult and epidemiological evaluations have not come up with universally applicable and valid classification criteria. However, both autoimmune liver diseases and viral hepatitis can readily be diagnosed and distinguished through precise and molecularly determined immunological testing systems. The overlap of both, virus-associated autoimmunity, is still at the centre of research activities aimed at establishing diagnostic and risk-assessment criteria. Studies of molecular autoantigens and autoepitopes have begun to define the differences of the B-cell response in autoimmune disease and virus-associated autoimmunity. This provides data that may contribute to the safe application of therapeutic strategies as different as immunosuppression and interferon-alpha (IFN-alpha). The present review focuses on the clinical, epidemiological and molecular aspects of these disease entities.

Heterogeneity of liver-kidney microsomal autoantibodies in chronic hepatitis C and D virus infection

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Anti-liver-kidney microsomal (LKM) autoantibodies occur in a proportion of patients with chronic hepatitis C and D infections. Because of different immunofluorescence patterns, antibodies in hepatitis C and D were termed LKM-1 and LKM-3, respectively. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the different specificities of LKM-1 and LKM-3 antibodies.

METHODS

Forty-nine samples of LKM-1 sera and 16 samples of LKM-3 sera were studied for reactivity against rat and human liver microsomal proteins by immunofluorescence, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay, and Western blot.

RESULTS

Thirty-four percent of the LKM-1 sera reacted with 50-kilodalton cytochrome P4502D6 in Western blot. In addition, a proportion of the sera recognized either a 59- or 70-kilodalton antigen, and 45% of the sera did not react in Western blot. Recently, the major LKM-3 antigen was identified as an autoepitope expressed on uridine diphosphate-glucuronosyltransferases (UGT). Seven LKM-3-positive sera reacted with recombinant rabbit family one UGT. None of the anti-LKM-1-positive hepatitis C sera reacted with UGT. Antibody reactivity against liver microsomal proteins in enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay ended when antigens were pretreated with sodium dodecyl sulfate, confirming that antibodies recognize conformational epitopes.

CONCLUSIONS

LKM-1 antibodies in hepatitis C are more heterogeneous and react with different antigens compared with LKM-3 antibodies in hepatitis D.

Autoantibodies in hepatitis delta

Hepatitis delta virus infection is associated with a wide range of different autoantibodies. The humoral immune response in chronic hepatitis D is directed against the cytoskeleton, the nucleus, the nuclear lamina and the endoplasmic reticulum. Smooth muscle antibodies (SMA), basal cell layer antibodies (BCLA), stellate epithelial cell antibodies (SECA), thymic reticular cell antibodies (TRA), perithymocytic cell antibodies (PTA), and anti-calmodulin antibodies are reactive with constituents of the cytoskeleton. Antinuclear antibodies (ANA) and anti-lamin C antibodies recognize antigens of the nucleus and the nuclear lamina, respectively. Autoantibodies directed against antigens of the endodoplasmic reticulum (LKM) are also common in chronic hepatitis D. Recently, the major molecular target of LKM-3 autoantibodies was described as an epitope on UDP-glucuronosyltransferases of family 1. In view of the important role of UGTs in drug metabolism, LKM-3 autoantibodies represent a new model to study virus induced autoimmunity in man. Future studies should focus on the role of the host immune response and the clinical relevance of these autoantibodies in chronic hepatitis D.

Anti-GOR in hepatitis D: specific association with hepatitis C virus superinfection

A group of 113 patients with chronic hepatitis D was investigated for the presence of anti-GOR and liver kidney microsomal antibodies. Eight patients were anti-GOR positive and also positive for hepatitis C virus-infection. In sera from 16 patients liver-kidney microsomal antibodies were detectable by immunofluorescence. They were classified as LKM-3 due to their fluorescence pattern. Two of the LKM-3-positive sera were also anti-hepatitis C virus and anti-human immunodeficiency virus positive. None of these patients were positive for anti-GOR. Fourteen sera from LKM-3-positive patients reacted in Western blot with a microsomal protein at 55 kDa that differs from the 50-kDa LKM-1 (cytochrome P450IID6) antigen. Our studies demonstrate that hepatitis D virus itself does not induce an autoimmune reaction against the GOR antigen and that autoimmunity to the LKM-3 antigen induced by hepatitis D virus infection does not correlated with anti-GOR. These studies support the specificity of the anti-GOR response for hepatitis C virus infection.

Recognition of uridine diphosphate glucuronosyl transferases by LKM-3 antibodies in chronic hepatitis D

Patients with chronic hepatitis D often have liver-kidney microsomal antibodies type 3 (LKM-3). These antibodies react with several microsomal antigens that have a molecular weight of 55 KDa and an isoelectric point of about 8. We studied the molecular nature of the antigen and, by immunoscreening a human liver cDNA expression library with KM-3 sera, found that uridine diphosphate glucuronosyl transferases (UGT) appeared as candidate antigens. We confirmed the identity of UGT as an antigen by reacting the sera with recombinant rabbit liver UGT proteins. Some sera reacted with rabbit UGT-2 proteins, but UGT-1 proteins were more sensitive and specific in detecting LKM-3 autoantibodies in patient sera. Anti-UGT-1 antibodies were detected in all LKM-3 positive sera from patients with hepatitis D and 1 out of 11 patients with autoimmune hepatitis type 2. Sera from patients who had hepatitis B only did not react with UGT proteins. The UGT proteins are part of the phase II enzymes of drug metabolism and are the first such enzymes to be identified as human autoantigens.

Anti-rat liver microsomal and cytosolic antibodies in hepatitis C virus infection

In order to assess the frequency of autoimmunity markers in hepatitis C virus infection, 229 RIBA 2 HCV positive individuals were tested by ELISA and Immunoblot assay using as antigen rat liver microsomal and cytosolic proteins. Twenty-one out of 229 individuals (9%) showed anti-rat liver microsome antibodies by ELISA, but the titre was low (1:100 to 1:1,600). In Immunoblot, only 5 of these 21 ELISA positive sera recognized also rat liver microsomal proteins (MW between 30 to 64 kDa). Antibodies against rat liver cytosolic proteins were found by ELISA in 14 out of 229 individuals (6%). Three of them showed a reactivity in Immunoblot to 42 kDa or 55 kDA proteins. In conclusion, HCV infection could induce an autoimmune response against rat liver microsomal and cytosolic proteins in a small number of subjects; the titre of antibodies being lower and the pattern of reactivity different in respect to patients with autoimmune hepatitis.

Anti-LKM-1 antibodies determined by use of recombinant P450 2D6 in ELISA and western blot and their association with anti-HCV and HCV-RNA

Several subtypes of anti-liver-kidney microsome antibodies (LKM) are known. LKM-1 antibodies associated with autoimmune chronic active hepatitis recognize P450 2D6, a cytochrome P450 mono-oxygenase. The frequent association of anti-LKM-1 antibodies and hepatitis C virus (HCV) infections and the probable existence of an infectious and autoimmune form of anti-LKM-1-associated hepatitis, requiring different therapeutical strategies, necessitates the exact determination of anti-LKM-1 specificities. Therefore, we compared various antibody tests (immunofluorescence, ELISA with recombinant P450 2D6, and Western blot with recombinant and natural antigens and agargel double diffusion) with sera of 27 anti-LKM-1-positive chronic active hepatitis (CAH) patients, with 61 sera harbouring anti-mitochondrial antibodies, 100 sera each from HCV-RNA-positive and HCV-RNA-negative patients, and 50 sera of healthy persons. Western blot techniques using recombinant MS2-polymerase P450 2D6 fusion protein were found to be the most sensitive and specific method for anti-LKM-1 antibody determination in routine laboratory. The recently recognized association of anti-LKM-1 antibody and HCV infection was confirmed by the results of this study. In anti-HCV and HCV-RNA-positive patients with anti-LKM-1 antibodies there was a preponderance of males with higher mean age and lower antibody titres. The results support the hypothesis of the existence of an autoimmune as well as an infectious (HCV triggered) subgroup of anti-LKM-1-positive hepatitis.

Serum non-organ specific autoantibodies in human immunodeficiency virus 1 infection

Serum samples from 66 seropositive subjects (56 with a history of intravenous drug abuse), including asymptomatic carriers and patients with persistent generalised lymphadenopathy (PGL), AIDS related complex (ARC), and AIDS, were tested by indirect immunofluorescence on rat tissue sections and HEp-2 cells for the presence of antibodies to nuclei, smooth muscle, intermediate filaments (anti-IMF) and microfilaments (anti-MF). Counterimmunoelectrophoresis was also used to detect antibodies to extractable nuclear antigens. Smooth muscle antibodies with the V pattern or antinuclear antibodies, mainly of the speckled type, or anti-IMF, occurred in 35 cases, being widely distributed in all groups. Such an autoantibody response resembles the "viral" autoimmunity described in various infectious diseases and in particular that of non-A, non-B post-transfusion hepatitis. Autoantibodies may be of some prognostic relevance, as the prevalence of smooth muscle antibodies V increased as the disease progressed (asymptomatic carriers 20%, those with PGL 29%, those with ARC 47%, and those with AIDS 63%. In the PGL group autoantibody positivity correlated with the presence of skin anergy. The fact that autoantibodies were more frequently detected in patients with circulating immune complexes suggests that these can contain autoantibodies and the corresponding autoantigens.

Serological profile of tissue autoantibodies during acute and chronic delta hepatitis

In order to assess the serological profile in relation to other serological and histological markers of hepatitis delta virus (HDV) infection we have investigated the presence of autoantibodies during acute and chronic delta infection in 353 serum samples from different patients with acute and chronic hepatitis and autoimmune diseases. Basal cell layer antibodies (BCLA) were found in 58% acute hepatitis B, in 73% chronic hepatitis D and in 4% primary biliary cirrhosis. Stellate thymic epithelial cell antibodies (SECA) were detected in 40% acute D hepatitis and in 49% chronic D hepatitis. No tissue autoantibodies were detected in 50 acute B hepatitis, 35 autoimmune chronic liver diseases, 24 connective tissue diseases or 25 controls. In addition, two previously unreported specificities of anti-thymic antibodies reacting with reticular (TRA) and perithymocytic cells (PTA) were identified in 33% and 9% acute D hepatitis, respectively, and in 13% and 6% chronic D hepatitis cases. Among patients with acute HBV-HDV coinfection these antibodies were detected transiently (less than 4 weeks) and at low titer, whereas in those with chronic infection autoantibodies levels tend to be high and persistent throughout the follow-up. Among patients with chronic HDV infection no correlation was found between the presence of tissue autoantibodies and hepatic delta antigen expression and serum HDV-RNA which suggest that autoimmune phenomena observed during chronic delta infection are not related to the level of viral replication.

Serum antibodies to thymus epithelial cells in non-A, non-B and cryptogenic chronic liver disease

Antibodies against thymus epithelial cells (anti-TEC) and the basal cell layer (BCLA) of squamous epithelia have been described in association with HDV-related chronic liver disease (CLD). Data are lacking on their presence during nAnB virus infection. Sera from 51 patients with nAnB post-transfusion hepatitis, including acute and chronic cases diagnosed during a prospective study on candidates for cardiac surgery, and 167 with various forms of CLD were tested for the presence of anti-TEC and BCLA using indirect immunofluorescence on human thymus and rat forestomach sections. Both antibodies mainly occurred in nAnB, HDV and cryptogenic CLD (anti-TEC: 51%, 47% and 42%; BCLA: 29%, 38% and 31%, respectively). The prevalence of anti-TEC in nAnB CLD turned out to be higher than that recorded in alcoholic, HBV-related, autoimmune, liver and kidney microsomal antibody positive CLD and primary biliary cirrhosis (p ranging from less than 0.03 to less than 0.0004). Two monoclonal antibodies (Mabs) to cytokeratins gave a pattern superimposable on that of spontaneous anti-TEC (both Mabs) and BCLA (only one). Antibodies against epithelial constituents, presumably targeting cytokeratin-associated antigens, occur not only in HDV CLD, as previously reported, but also in nAnB CLD, where they might represent a diagnostic aid, due to the unavailability of reliable serological markers of nAnB infection. The close similarity of anti-TEC and BCLA status between nAnB and cryptogenic CLD suggests a nAnB etiology of at least a proportion of chronic liver patients at present scored as cryptogenic.

Hepatitis delta virus (HDV) infection and disease

The conformational and biologic properties of the hepatitis delta virus (HDV), a defective RNA hepatotropic pathogen dependent on obligatory helper functions provided by the hepatitis B virus (HBV), are different from the properties of conventional RNA animal viruses but resemble in many aspects the characteristics of the satellite RNAs and satellite viruses of higher plants. The HBsAg coat provided to HDV by HBV makes the defective virus transmissible via the vectors and modes of transmission of the ubiquitous helper; alike HBV, HDV is prevalent in tropical and subtropical areas and in the Mediterranean basin. In contrast to HBV, HDV is highly pathogenic and its infection aggravates the underlying HBV infection upon which it thrives. The defective pathogen has been recognized worldwide as a major cause of fulminant hepatitis and of severe chronic hepatitides leading to cirrhosis and liver failure. There is yet no established therapy for this ominous disease.

An autoantibody profile in primary sclerosing cholangitis

A high frequency of a variety of autoantibodies has been found in sera from patients with primary sclerosing cholangitis (PSC). The prevalence of all types of autoantibodies in PSC was significantly higher than that in healthy controls and patients with isolated inflammatory bowel disease. The titres of the antibodies were rather elevated, particularly in females, and most of them were IgM. The most frequent type of antinuclear antibody was the 'homogenous' type, which is a marker of many autoimmune diseases. The overall prevalence of the antibody was 35%, whereas in female patients it reached 67%. No correlation was found between autoantibody positivity and any clinical parameter. The present findings support the hypothesis that immunological factors may be relevant in PSC.