Value of electron microscopy in diagnosis of renal disease

Role of Ultrastructural Study in the Diagnosis of Medical Renal Diseases: A Tertiary Medical Center Experience and Review of the Literature

The 20th century unfolded many mysteries regarding renal pathology with the advent of ancillary techniques such as immunofluorescence (IF) and electron microscopy (EM) studies. EM plays a major role in confirming the routine and IF findings or may uncover new and unsuspected features. The aim of the study is to elucidate the role of ultrastructural findings in patients with medical kidney diseases on whom kidney biopsy was performed at the American University of Beirut Medical Center, between November 2018 and June 2019. A total of 188 renal biopsies were examined during the study period. EM confirmed the light microscopy diagnosis in 54% of the cases while completely changed the diagnosis in 23% of the cases. In 23% of the sample, EM provided additional features and a secondary diagnosis. Our study emphasizes the important diagnostic role of EM and its significance, particularly in minimal change disease, basement membrane abnormalities, and glomerulopathies.

Imaging the Kidney with an Unconventional Scanning Electron Microscopy Technique: Analysis of the Subpodocyte Space in Diabetic Mice

Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) remains the gold standard for renal histopathological diagnoses, given its higher resolving power, compared with light microscopy. However, it imposes several limitations on pathologists, including longer sample preparation time and a small observation area. To overcome these, we introduced a scanning electron microscopy (SEM) technique for imaging resin-embedded semi-thin sections of renal tissue. We developed a rapid tissue preparation protocol for experimental models and human biopsies which, alongside SEM digital imaging acquisition of secondary electrons (SE–SEM), enables fast electron microscopy examination, with a resolution similar to that achieved by TEM. We used this unconventional SEM imaging approach to investigate the subpodocyte space (SPS) in BTBR ob/ob mice with type 2 diabetes. Analysis of semi-thin sections with secondary electrons revealed that the SPS had expanded in volume and covered large areas of the glomerular basement membrane, forming wide spaces between the podocyte body and the underlying filtering membrane. Our results show that SE–SEM is a valuable tool for imaging the kidney at the ultrastructural level, filling the magnification gap between light microscopy and TEM, and reveal that in diabetic mice, the SPS is larger than in normal controls, which is associated with podocyte damage and impaired kidney function.

Molecular Studies on the Nephroprotective Potential of Celastrus paniculatus against Lead-Acetate-Induced Nephrotoxicity in Experimental Rats: Role of the PI3K/AKT Signaling Pathway

Chemicals can induce nephrotoxicity, with damage to different segments of the nephron and deterioration of renal function. Nephrotoxicity due to exposure to a toxin such as carbon tetrachloride, sodium oxalate, or heavy metals is the most common cause of kidney injury. The current study aimed to evaluate the protective effects of Celastrus paniculatus seed extract against lead-acetate-induced nephrotoxicity by evaluating the histopathology, immunohistochemistry, ultrastructure, and phosphoinositide 3-kinase (PI3K)/protein kinase B (AKT) signaling pathway. Twenty-four rats were divided into four groups (n = 6 per group): group 1 contained normal animals and served as the control; group 2 received lead acetate (30 mg/kg body weight (b.w.)/day, oral); group 3 received lead acetate and the standard drug N-acetylcysteine (NAC, 200 mg/kg b.w./day, oral); and group 4 received lead acetate and the ethanolic extract of C. paniculatus seed (EECP; 800 mg/kg b.w./day, oral). Treatment was given for 28 consecutive days. The data were analyzed using one-way analysis of variance with SIGMA PLOT 13 using SYSTAT software followed by Newman–Keul’s test for comparison between the groups. EECP ameliorated the adverse changes caused by lead acetate. PI3K and AKT messenger RNA (mRNA) levels were diminished in lead-acetate-treated rats. Treatment with EECP inhibited the occurrence of shrunken cells, the atrophy of glomeruli, and degenerative changes in renal tubules caused by lead acetate. Interestingly, the PI3K and AKT mRNA levels were significantly increased in EECP-treated animals. Our results clearly evidence for the first time that C. paniculatus seed extract inhibits lead-acetate-induced detrimental changes in kidneys by regulating PI3K/AKT signaling pathways.

[The relevance of electron microscopy in kidney biopsies to 21st century pathology]

INTRODUCTION

Electron microscopy (EM) has been used in the study of renal biopsies for more than 5 decades; however, it is expensive and the possibility of restricting it to selected cases has been considered. This study aims to reevaluate the necessity for EM in the diagnosis of renal biopsies today.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

All renal biopsies taken between 2016 and 2019 with adequate light microscopy (LM), immunofluorescence (IF) and EM studies were included. The initial diagnosis (without EM) and the final diagnosis (with EM) was recorded. EM was considered necessary in cases in which the initial and final diagnoses did not concur, when diagnosis could not be made with LM and IF only or if the EM study revealed further clinically relevant findings.

RESULTS

A total of 621 biopsies were included, 498 (80.2%) of native kidneys and 123 (19.8%) of transplanted kidneys. In 115 cases (18.5%) EM had been deemed necessary for diagnosis; it was required more frequently in hereditary diseases (96.8%) and isolated hematuria (88.9%) but less often in nephrotic syndrome (6.7%) and renal transplant biopsy (5.7%) (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

EM was required in less than a fifth of renal biopsies, being more necessary in isolated hematuria and hereditary diseases and less so in nephrotic syndrome and in renal graft biopsies. These findings may prove useful as a guide to case selection protocols in which EM could be considered as a non-mandatory technique.

Electron microscopy in renal pathology: overall applications and guidelines for tissue, collection, preparation, and stains

Electron microscopy is a mainstay in the analysis of renal biopsies, where it is typically employed in a correlative fashion along with light and immunofluorescence microscopy. Despite the development of a growing armamentarium of molecular and biochemical analytic methods as well as new immunostains with a widening panel of immunoreactants, electron microscopy remains crucial to the diagnosis of a number of disorders involving the renal glomerulus, vasculature, and tubulointerstitial compartment. The number of renal biopsies continues to grow and the indications for these biopsies continue expanding together with our understanding of disease processes. Proper collection of biopsies and careful analysis of data emanating from diagnostic modalities, clinical information, imaging, gross and microscopic tissue analysis, including a wide range of ancillary studies, represent the essential paradigm for generating detailed diagnoses with clinical significance. This communication offers a guide to the pre-analytic and analytic process for renal biopsy examination, discusses diagnostic keys and pitfalls for an important category of renal diseases (immune complex disorders), and provides an introduction to a useful adjunct diagnostic method (ultrastructural immunolabeling). Renal pathologists should render expert diagnoses that guide patient management, provide prognostic information and lead to targeted new therapeutic interventions that are currently available.

Contribution of Electron Microscopy to the Clinicopathologic Diagnosis in Childhood Glomerular Renal Diseases

Background: Electron microscopy (EM) provides another diagnostic assessment of glomerular lesions in addition to light and fluorescent microscopy. Objectives: We evaluated the contribution of diagnostic EM in childhood glomerular diseases. Patients and methods: Forty-eight renal biopsies which were assessed by EM between 2000 and 2014 were evaluated. Results: There were 21 (44%) females and 27 (56%) males, ages ranged between 6 and 204 months. EM findings were compatible with light and immunofluorescence microscopy in 65%, made additional contributions to diagnosis in 31% (especially in focal segmental glomerulosclerosis, Alport disease, membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis, dense deposit disease, thin basement membrane disease, and nephronophthisis), and was non-contributory in 4%. Conclusion: Electron microscopic evaluation supports other histopathological diagnoses in most cases, contributes additional diagnostic information in pediatric glomerular disease, especially in FSGS, thin glomerular basement membrane nephropathy, Alport disease, MPGN, and dense deposit disease, and its utilization should clinically justify the increase in cost and testing time.

Lack of electron microscopy hinders correct renal biopsy diagnosis: A study from India

Electron microscopy (EM) is performed routinely on all native kidney biopsies in the western world. However, in India, it is not regularly performed due to non-availability and financial constraints. The aim of this prospective study was to evaluate the usefulness of routinely performing EM on native kidney biopsies. In order to eliminate selection bias, all consecutive native kidney biopsies were included in this study, provided they had adequate tissue for light, immunofluorescence (IF), and EM. The biopsies were reported on the basis of light and IF microscopy. EM was performed on each case by another pathologist who also independently reviewed the light microscopic slides and IF images. The findings were then reviewed to assess how the ultrastructural features contributed to the primary diagnosis and assigned to one of the following categories: 1. Crucial for diagnosis, 2. Important contribution, or 3. Not required. Of the 115 cases evaluated, EM was crucial in 12% of the cases. In 20% of the cases, it provided important confirmatory information and in the remaining 68% cases, EM was not considered required. This study supports the use of EM as a routine diagnostic tool in the evaluation of native kidney biopsies. There is an urgent need for availability and accessibility of EM in our country.

Electron microscopy in end stage renal disease: a case of Fabry's disease

Fabry's disease is an X-linked error of metabolism with deficiency of the enzyme &#x03B1;-glycosidase A, and glycosphingolipid accumulation in multiple tissues. Patients may be asymptomatic and present with advanced disease. We report a case of a 38 year old white male who presented with end stage renal disease of unknown etiology. He received a living-related donor kidney transplant (mother), but lost the graft after 10 years to multiple episodes of rejection. Review of the native renal biopsy with added ultrastructural studies established the diagnosis of Fabry's disease. Evaluation of renal biopsies showing advanced chronic injury should include electron microscopic studies, which may reveal characteristic diagnostic features, as seen in this case of Fabry's disease. Identification of hereditary disorders involving the kidney is important for appropriate treatment and prevention of disease recurrence. Potential living related donors should be screened for genetic involvement.

Value of Electron Microscopy in Kidney Biopsy Diagnosis

Kidney biopsy reports given during 2003 were collected from the authors' pathology database. A total of 111 biopsies were performed. Five tumor samples were not studied with electron microscopy (EM). Of the remaining 106 biopsies, 85 were studied with EM. EM was not performed in 10/24 transplant biopsies, or in 11/82 cases of suspected primary kidney disease. The role of EM was evaluated by grouping the samples in 3 categories: (1) EM was essential for diagnosis, (2) EM contributed to the interpretation and cleared uncertainties, and (3) EM had no influence on the diagnostic process. In transplant biopsies EM influenced the final diagnosis in 86% of cases (category 2). In biopsies performed for primary kidney disease EM was essential for diagnosis in 18.3% clearly contributed in 53.5%, and had no influence on the final diagnosis in 28.2% of cases. The study suggests that the importance of EM has not decreased during the last few years. Because only about 25% of the EM reports did not have any influence on the diagnostic process, it is recommended that kidney biopsy protocols should include EM in all biopsy cases, or at least tissue should be reserved for EM studies of all cases. Because of the influence of EM on the diagnostic process the need for EM in pathology training should be emphasized.

Application of transmission electron microscopy to the clinical study of viral and bacterial infections: present and future

Transmission electron microscopy has had a profound impact on our knowledge and understanding of viruses and bacteria. The 1000-fold improvement in resolution provided by electron microscopy (EM) has allowed visualization of viruses, the existence of which had previously only been suspected as the causative agents of transmissible infectious disease. Viruses are grouped into families based on their morphology. Viruses from different families look different and these morphological variances are the basis for identification of viruses by EM.

Electron microscopy initially came to prominence in diagnostic microbiology in the late 1960s when it was used in the rapid diagnosis of smallpox, by differentiating, on a morphological basis, poxviruses from the less problematic herpesviruses in skin lesions. Subsequently, the technique was employed in the diagnosis of other viral infections, such as hepatitis B and parvovirus B19. Electron microscopy has led to the discovery of many new viruses, most notably the various viruses associated with gastroenteritis, for which it remained the principal diagnostic method until fairly recent times. Development of molecular techniques, which offer greater sensitivity and often the capacity to easily process large numbers of samples, has replaced EM in many areas of diagnostic virology. Hence the role of EM in clinical virology is evolving with less emphasis on diagnosis and more on research, although this is likely only to be undertaken in specialist centres. However, EM still offers tremendous advantages to the microbiologist, both in the speed of diagnosis and the potential for detecting, by a single test, any viral pathogen or even multiple pathogens present within a sample.

There is continuing use of EM for the investigation of new and emerging agents, such as SARS and human monkeypox virus. Furthermore, EM forms a vital part of the national emergency response programme of many countries and will provide a frontline diagnostic service in the event of a bioterrorism incident, particularly in the scenario of a deliberate release of smallpox virus.

In the field of bacteriology, EM is of little use diagnostically, although some bacterial pathogens can be identified in biopsy material processed for EM examination. Electron microscopy has been used, however, to elucidate the structure and function of many bacterial features, such as flagellae, fimbriae and spores and in the study of bacteriophages. The combined use of EM and gold-labelled antibodies provides a powerful tool for the ultrastructural localisation of bacterial and viral antigens.

The role of electron microscopy for the diagnosis of glomerulopathies

CONTEXT

Electron microscopy has been used for the morphological diagnosis of glomerular diseases for more than three decades and its value has been widely emphasized. However, recent reports have analyzed the routine use of electron microscopy critically. Its use in other areas of diagnosis such as tumor diseases has declined considerably; in addition, in view of the unavoidable financial pressure for the reduction of costs due to investigations and diagnostic routines, the selection of cases for electron microscopy has been quite rigorous.

OBJECTIVE

To identify the glomerular diseases that depend on electron microscopy for a final diagnosis, by means of reviewing renal biopsies performed over a 12-year period.

DESIGN

Prospective

SETTING

Hospital Ana Costa, Hospital Guilherme Alvaro and Serviço de Anatomia Patológica de Santos, Santos, São Paulo, Brazil.

PARTICIPANTS

200 consecutive renal biopsies obtained from private hospitals and the teaching hospital from 1979 to 1991 were studied.

MAIN MEASUREMENTS

All cases were analyzed via light microscopy, immunofluorescence and electron microscopy. The diagnosis was first made via light microscopy plus immunofluorescence and then via electron microscopy.

RESULTS

Electron microscopy was diagnostic or essential for diagnosis in 10.0% of the cases, corresponding to 3.4% of primary glomerulopathies and 100% of hereditary glomerulopathies. Electron microscopy was contributory (useful) to the diagnosis in 5.5% of the cases, confirming the preliminary diagnosis formulated on the basis of clinical and laboratory data and light microscopy plus immunofluorescence findings. We obtained a 7.5% rate of discordant immunofluorescence, which was considered as such when negative immunofluorescence findings were not confirmed by electron microscopy. The final diagnosis with the use of light microscopy plus immunofluorescence alone was 77.0%.

CONCLUSIONS

It was possible to diagnose with certainty a great percentage of glomerulopathies (82.5-90% of the cases) based on the light microscopy and immunofluorescence findings alone. Electron microscopy was essential for the diagnosis of hereditary nephropathies.

Aspergillus antigen testing in bone marrow transplant recipients

AIMS

To assess the clinical usefulness of a commercial aspergillus antigen enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) in the diagnosis of invasive aspergillosis (IA) in bone marrow transplant recipients, and to compare it with a commercial latex agglutination (LA) test.

METHODS

In total, 2026 serum samples from 104 bone marrow transplant recipients were tested. These comprised 67 sera from seven patients who had died with confirmed IA, 268 sera from nine patients who had died with suspected IA, and 1691 sera from 88 patients with no clinical, radiological, or microbiological signs of IA.

RESULTS

The ELISA was more sensitive than the LA test. All patients who were ELISA positive were also LA positive, and a positive LA result never preceded a positive ELISA. Twelve of 16 patients with confirmed or suspected IA were ELISA positive on two or more occasions, compared with 10 of 15 who were LA positive. ELISA was positive before LA in five patients (range, 2-14 days), and became positive on the same day in the remainder. Aspergillus antigen was detected by ELISA a median of 15 days before death (range, 4-233). Clinical and/or radiological evidence of IA was noted in all patients, and a positive ELISA was never the sole criterion for introduction of antifungal treatment. Two samples (one from each of two patients without IA) gave false positive results.

CONCLUSIONS

The aspergillus ELISA is a specific indicator of invasive aspergillosis if the criterion of two positive samples is required to confirm the diagnosis. However, the test is insufficiently sensitive to diagnose aspergillosis before other symptoms or signs are apparent, and hence is unlikely to lead to earlier initiation of antifungal treatment. It is therefore unsuitable for screening of asymptomatic patients at risk of invasive aspergillosis, but does have a useful role in confirming the diagnosis in symptomatic patients.

The diagnostic value of electron microscopy in human immunodeficiency virus-positive patients with gastrointestinal disease

BACKGROUND

Our aim was to determine the diagnostic value of electron microscopy in evaluating the etiology of gastrointestinal disease in patients infected with the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV).

METHODS

A retrospective review of electron microscopic and light microscopic results of all HIV-positive patients with gastrointestinal and liver diseases was made during a 3-year period from June 1995 to June 1998.

RESULTS

A total of 145 HIV-positive patients had their electron microscopy specimens reviewed. Of these, 136 were investigated for diarrhea, and the other 9 for increased liver enzymes. Twenty-seven of the 145 (18.6%) HIV-positive patients had a pathogen identified by electron microscopy, compared with only 13 of 145 (9%) identified by light microscopy (P < 0.005). The sensitivity of light microscopy for detecting opportunistic pathogens was 68%. Twenty-one of the 27 (77.8%) patients diagnosed by electron microscopy had microsporidiosis, and the most commonly diagnosed species was Enterocytozoon bieneusi. Light microscopy failed to identify 12 cases of microsporidiosis and 2 cases of leishmaniasis.

CONCLUSIONS

Electron microscopy contributes substantially to the identification of pathogens in HIV-positive patients. Light microscopy failed to identify one of every two pathogens diagnosed by electron microscopy.