Weight, BMI and stability are risk factors associated with lateral ankle sprains and chronic ankle instability: a meta-analysis

Treatment and prevention of chronic ankle instability: An umbrella review of meta-analyses

BACKGROUND

Chronic ankle instability (CAI) is a common and highly disabling condition. Although several studies have evaluated and analyzed prevention and treatment strategies for CAI, an unbiased and systematic synthesis of evidence is required to provide the most powerful and comprehensive evidence-based measures for the its prevention and treatment of CAI. This study aimed to synthesize evidence from the existing literature addressing the treatment and prevention of CAI.

METHODS

The PubMed, Embase, Cochrane, and Web of Science databases were systematically searched for relevant studies from inception to December 12, 2023. Data on effect sizes and corresponding 95 % confidence intervals for selected intervention measures were extracted. Systematic reviews were assessed for quality of included studies using a measurement tool (i.e., "AMSTAR 2").

RESULTS

In total, 37 studies were included, among which 21 (57 %) were of high or moderate quality. Strong evidence suggested that lower weight (P < 0.001), lower body mass index (P = 0.002), and non-stability defects (P = 0.04) significantly reduced the risk of developing CAI. Strong evidence supported exercise and moderate evidence supported manual therapy, acupuncture, and surgery for improving CAI. Additionally, external support plays an active role in the treatment process of CAI.

CONCLUSION

This is the first study synthesizing evidence supporting interventions for the treatment and prevention of CAI. Low body weight and body mass index were effective preventive measures against CAI. Exercise, manual therapy, acupuncture, and surgery can improve ankle function in patients with CAI. Plantar sensory treatment and neuromuscular training may be good therapeutic options for patients with CAI.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level I.

Effect of Progressive Balance Control Strategies on Chronic Ankle Instability in Middle-Aged Obese Women

INTRODUCTION

Chronic ankle instability (CAI) is a disease characterized by persistent feelings of instability in the ankle joint and a propensity for recurrent ankle sprains. It is often caused by ligamentous laxity or neuromuscular deficits. Middle-aged obese females represent a demographic subset at increased risk for CAI due to factors such as reduced proprioception and increased loading on the ankle joint. The gaps in the current evidence suggest that more research is needed on middle-aged obese females, who are particularly vulnerable to CAI due to physiological changes associated with poor balance.

OBJECTIVES

This study aims to determine the effect of progressive balance control strategies on CAI in middle-aged obese women.

METHOD

In this experimental study, 72 patients with CAI in middle-aged women were selected randomly using a simple random sampling method. Females aged 35-45 with a body mass index (BMI) greater than 27 kg/m2 and a history of ankle sprains greater than one and having residual symptoms. The experimental group (Group B) received progressive balance control strategies, and the conventional group (Group A) received conventional balance exercises. Foot and ankle ability measure (FAAM) scale, push-and-release test (PART), single-leg stance test (SLST), evaluations, and star excursion balance test (SEBT) were used for pre- and posttreatment.

RESULTS

The experimental group post-intervention for static balance, dynamic balance, and postural control tests showed extremely significant improvement with a p-value of <0.0001. Between groups A and B, the dynamic balance was considered very significant, with a p-value of 0.0001. In the single-leg stance test, Group B's result was significantly greater than that of Group A's (63.4 + 16.1 and 63.4 + 16.1). PART results indicate that Group B is more significant than Group A (0.76 and 0.51, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

The study concluded that progressive balance control strategy training is effective in middle-aged obese women with CAI.

Balance, strength and physical activity after ankle sprain: Comparison between children with chronic ankle instability and copers

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to compare muscle strength, balance, and physical activity between children with chronic ankle instability and copers.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

SETTING

Pediatric Physical Therapy laboratory.

PARTICIPANTS

Children aged between 7 and 12 years old from regular schools who had a history of unilateral ankle sprain.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Lower extremity strength, Static and dynamic standing balance, and Level of physical activity.

RESULTS

Fifteen children with chronic ankle instability and 15 copers were recruited. Demographic data showed no differences between group except for sex and the Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool-Youth (CAITY) score. Children with CAI had a significantly lower score during the standing long jump test (p < 0.05), poorer performance of single leg stance test (p < 0.001) and Y-Balance test in the anterior, posteromedial, and posterolateral directions (p < 0.05) when compared to copers. Total METs per week was significantly higher in the copers (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Children with chronic ankle instability exhibited weaker lower limb strength, poorer static and dynamic standing balance, and participate in less physical activity compared to those in a coper group which may have future negative health consequences. Knowledge about the differences between the two groups may provide guidance for physical educators and physical therapists. (200 words).

Patient-Reported Outcomes Following Open Broström-Gould Procedure: Minimum 5-Year Follow-Up

Background

Ankle sprains are a common musculoskeletal injury among the general population and often involve the lateral ligament complex. Although the majority of ankle sprains are treated successfully with nonsurgical conservative measures, an estimated 5% to 20% of ankle injuries ultimately develop chronic lateral ankle instability (CAI). Multiple surgical treatment modalities for the lateral ankle complex exist, such as anatomical and nonanatomical reconstruction. The current gold standard for primary surgical repair is the Broström-Gould procedure. This is the first article to provide PROMIS scores following BG and the largest study with 5-year outcomes for an open BG.

Methods

This was a descriptive study of a retrospective cohort of patients undergoing a BG with a minimum follow-up of 5 years. Patient-reported outcome instruments collected postoperatively were PROMIS Pain, Physical Function, Depression, and FAAM. Further preoperative clinic characteristics were analyzed to correlate with the final outcome. The electronic medical record was queried for Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) code 27698 (Broström-Gould) from January 2010 to June 2017. Surveys were conducted in the clinic and through phone interviews. Patient charts were reviewed to obtain basic patient demographic information including sex, age, race, and body mass index (BMI). The following preoperative variables were recorded: history of prior CAI procedures, history of major trauma, duration of symptoms, number of diagnosed ankle sprains, other collagen pathologies, generalized ligament laxity, participation in sports/activity level, peroneal subluxation, clinically diagnosed peroneus longus or brevis tendinopathy, deltoid ligament injury, anterior ankle impingement, and posterior ankle impingement. The PROMIS and Foot and Ankle Ability Measure (FAAM) scores were obtained with a combination of clinic and phone interviews. Data were aggregated in Microsoft Excel and entered in R (version 4.2.0) for statistical analysis.

Results

Our results show that the minimum 5-year patient-reported PROMIS scores for patients following a Broström-Gould procedure are as follows: PROMIS physical function, 50.5; PROMIS pain interference, 48.2; and PROMIS depression, 38.2. This indicates, at a minimum, that patients 5 years removed from the procedure are within 1 SD of the general population in regard to PROMIS physical function and pain. Our patient-reported FAAM, activities of daily living, and FAAM sports scores were 59.6 and 13.0 respectively. Preoperative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings were recorded. Arthroscopic examination was performed before lateral ligaments reconstruction for patients with intra-articular pathologies confirmed on MRI.

Conclusion

The findings from our study offer evidence supporting the effectiveness of the Broström-Gould procedure to be associated with normal physical function, even 5 years after surgery. Furthermore, our research identified specific factors such as tobacco use, diabetes, and sports participation that independently correlated with reported outcome measures. These insights enable physicians to better manage patient expectations and tailor treatment strategies accordingly. Our study establishes a foundation for future prospective research endeavors that aim to leverage the PROMIS system for comprehensive outcome assessments.

Level of Evidence

Level III, retrospective cohort study.

The morphology of osseous structure in subtalar joint with chronic ankle instability

BACKGROUND

Osseous structures have been demonstrated as risk factors for chronic ankle instability (CAI). Previously, the researchers only focused on the osseous structures of ankle, but ignored the osseous structures of subtalar joint(STJ). Accordingly, the aim of our study was to investigate the morphological characteristics of STJ osseous structures in CAI.

METHODS

52 patients with CAI and 52 sex- and age- matched control subjects were enrolled from The Affiliated Traditional Chinese Medicine Hospital of Southwest Medical University. The lateral radiographs of ankle in weight-bearing were used to compare the diversity of the two groups. Specifically, The Length of calcaneus, Calcaneal facet height and Absolute foot height, Böhler's angle, Gissane's angle, Calcaneal inclination angle, Talocalcaneal angle, Tibiotalar angle, Tibiocalcaneal angle, Talar-horizontal angle, talar declination angle, facet inclination angle were gauged in the two groups.

RESULTS

The Böhler's angle, Calcaneal inclination, Talocalcaneal angle, Tibiotalar angle, Talar-horizontal angle, Talar declination angle, Facet inclination angle and Absolute foot height of CAI group were significantly higher than normal control group (P < 0.05). There were no significant differences in Gissane's angle, Tibiocalcaneal angle, Length of calcaneus and Calcaneal facet height between patients with CAI and normal controls (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The osseous structures of STJ in CAI patients are different from normal people in morphology. Therefore, we should pay more attention to the changes of STJ anatomical parameters in the diagnosis and prevention of CAI.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Ⅲ.

Five-year clinical follow-up of arthroscopically treated chronic ankle instability

INTRODUCTION

Arthroscopic treatment of lateral ankle instability is a recent innovation. In 2014, a prospective study was initiated by the French Society of Arthroscopy demonstrating the feasibility, morbidity and short-term results of arthroscopic treatment of ankle instability.

HYPOTHESIS

The functional results of arthroscopic treatment of chronic ankle instability found after one year were maintained in the medium term.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The prospective follow-up of the patients included in the initial cohort was continued. The Karlsson and AOFAS scores, as well as patient satisfaction, were assessed. The causes of failure underwent univariate and multivariate analyzes. The results of 172 patients were included (40.2% ligament repairs; 59.7% ligament reconstructions). The average follow-up was 5years. The average satisfaction was 8.6/10, the average Karlsson score was 85 points and the average AOFAS score was 87.5 points. The reoperation rate was 6.4% of patients. The failures were related to an absence of sports practice, a high BMI and female gender. A high BMI and the intense sports practice were associated to ligament repair failure. The absence of sports practice and the intraoperative presence of the anterior talofibular ligament were associated to ligament reconstruction failure.

DISCUSSION

Arthroscopic treatment of ankle instability confers high satisfaction in the medium term, as well as long-lasting results with a low reoperation rate. A more detailed evaluation of the failure criteria could help guide the choice of treatment between ligament reconstruction or repair.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

II.

Variability of the lower limb symmetry index associated with the gait parameters in the overweight adult population with flatfoot: a case-control study

Background: Adult acquired flatfoot is characterized by a medial arch collapse during monopodal support in the stance phase, developing eversion of the calcaneus and abduction of the forefoot linked to the hindfoot. The purpose of our research was to analyze the dynamic symmetry index in the lower limbs comparing patients with flatfoot and normal foot. Methods: A case-control study was carried out with a sample of 62 participants divided into two groups consisting of 31 participants were overweight with bilateral flatfoot and 31 participants with healthy feet. A portable plantar pressure platform with piezoresistive sensors was used to measure the load symmetry index in the lower limbs in the foot areas and gait phases. Results: Gait pattern analysis showed statistically significant differences in the symmetry index for lateral load (p = 0.004), the initial contact phase (p = 0.025) and the forefoot phase (p < 0.001). Conclusion: The adults were overweight with bilateral flatfoot evidenced alterations in the symmetry index in the lateral load and in the initial contact and flatfoot contact phases, showing greater instability in overweight adult flatfoot compared to the people with normal feet.

Septic History Limits the Outcome of Tibiotalocalcaneal Arthrodesis

Joint destruction necessitates tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis (TTCA) in cases of clinical deficits that cannot be controlled conservatively, possibly leading to sepsis. We aimed to compare the underlying etiology of posttraumatic joint destruction and the outcomes after TTCA in patients with a septic or aseptic history. Between 2010 and 2022, 216 patients with TTCA were retrospectively enrolled (septic TTCA (S-TTCA) = 129; aseptic TTCA (A-TTCA) = 87). Patient demographics, etiology, Olerud and Molander Ankle Scores (OMASs), Foot Function Index (FFI-D) scores, and Short Form-12 Questionnaire (SF-12) scores were recorded. The mean follow-up period was 6.5 years. Tibial plafond and ankle fractures were the most common causes of sepsis. The mean OMAS was 43.0; the mean FFI-D was 76.7; and the mean SF-12 physical component summary score was 35.5. All the scores differed significantly between the groups (p < 0.001). With an average of 11 operations until the arthrodesis was achieved, the S-TTCA patients underwent about three times as many operations as the A-TTCA patients (p < 0.001), and 41% of S-TTCA patients remained permanently unable to work (p < 0.001). The significantly worse results of S-TTCA compared to A-TTCA show the long and stressful ordeal that patients with a septic history suffer. Further attention must be paid to infection prophylaxis and, if necessary, early infection revision.

Re-injury after arthroscopic anatomical reconstruction of the lateral ankle ligaments treated by a new arthroscopic anatomical reconstruction: A case report

INTRODUCTION AND IMPORTANCE

Lateral ankle ligament reconstruction failures are increasingly frequent. To our knowledge no reports of using a new arthroscopic anatomical reconstruction with a gracilis autograft to treat an ankle re-injury have been described.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 19-year-old man presented with a right ankle injury resulting in isolated lateral ankle instability. The clinical examination showed significant laxity. The MRI confirmed a grade 3 tear of the lateral ligament complex. Arthroscopic anatomical reconstruction with a gracilis autograft was performed and the patient was able to return to all of his activities. Eighteen months after the primary reconstruction, he had another high-energy injury. Despite rehabilitation, he experienced isolated lateral instability. Arthrography confirmed graft failure. The patient underwent a new anatomical reconstruction with the controlateral gracilis autograft, with no difficulties. At 6 months, he had returned to all of his activities, with no limitations or discomfort.

CLINICAL DISCUSSION

Articular hypermobility, hindfoot varus and/or excess weight should be looked for or treated to explain the graft failure. Other therapeutic options are possible for revision surgery such as non-anatomical tenodesis, allografts or artificial ligaments.

CONCLUSION

Arthroscopic anatomical reconstruction of the lateral ligaments of the ankle with a new arthroscopic anatomical reconstruction procedure seems to be feasible. Other studies are needed to define the therapeutic strategy for ligament reconstruction graft failures.

Approach to Ankle Instability in Patients With a Negative Ankle MRI: A Case Series

Objectives Injuries to the ankle ligaments are some of the most common musculoskeletal sports injuries. Ankle magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is the standard diagnostic procedure in today's practice, but its reliability and validity remain controversial. The aim of this study was to explore the approach for patients with negative ankle MRI who continue to have symptoms of ankle instability despite conservative therapy. Methods A total of eight patients who were 14 years or older with negative ankle MRI who continue to have symptoms of ankle instability despite conservative therapy were admitted to our institution from January 1, 2015 to December 31, 2021. Results Eight patients with a mean age of 36, and a mean body mass index (BMI) of 37.7. All patients presented with ankle pain, locking, and giving way in variable severity. All the patients had a radiograph followed by an ankle MRI, which showed normal alignment of ankle joints without abnormality. Initially, all patients were treated conservatively but did not show any improvement. After that, they underwent an operation of lateral ankle ligament reconstruction by modified Brostrom technique, followed by casting and physiotherapy. The symptoms of ankle instability resolved in all patients. The ankle pain resolved completely in six patients, improved in one patient, and did not improve in one patient.  Conclusion Based on our results, we advocate reconstruction surgery by modified Brostrom technique for ligament repair in patients with clinical evidence of chronic ankle instability who have failed a trial of conservative management, even in the context of a normal ankle MRI.

Anatomic reconstruction of the lateral ligaments using allograft tendon and suspensory fixation for chronic lateral ankle instability with poor remnant quality: results and complications

PURPOSE

Treatment of chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI) with poor remnant quality is challenging. The aim of the present study was to evaluate clinical results and complications of anatomic reconstruction of the lateral ligaments using allograft tendon and suspensory fixation in the treatment of such patients.

METHODS

One hundred and eight patients with CLAI, who were treated surgically using anatomic reconstruction with allograft tendon and suspensory fixation between April 2016 and January 2018 at our hospital, were retrospectively analysed. None of the patients had sufficient ligament remnants for the modified Broström procedure during the intraoperative evaluation. Eighteen patients were excluded. Seventeen patients were lost to follow-up and 73 patients completed the study. The mean duration of instability symptoms was 39.1 months (range, 6-480 months). The mean follow-up time was 57.5 months (range, 48-69 months). Clinical results were evaluated using the Karlsson scoring scale, American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society-Ankle and Hindfoot (AOFAS-AH) score, visual analogue scale (VAS), patients' subjective satisfaction, and incidence of complications. Mechanical stability was evaluated using the varus talar tilt angle (TTA) and anterior talar displacement (ATD).

RESULTS

The AOFAS-AH scores significantly improved from 67.7 ± 8.5 points to 89.8 ± 9.5 (p < 0.001). The Karlsson scoring scales evolved from 58.8 ± 16.5 to 88.4 ± 11.2 (p < 0.001). VAS scores significantly decreased from 2.9 ± 1.3 to 1.1 ± 1.0 (p < 0.001). On stress radiographs, TTA decreased from 15.1 ± 2.5 degrees to 5.8 ± 2.1 degrees (p < 0.001), whereas ATD reduced from 13.4 ± 2.9 mm to 5.7 ± 1.5 mm (p < 0.001). Patients' subjective satisfaction indicated 46 excellent, 20 good, 5 fair, and 2 bad results. Postoperatively, 15 cases (20.5%) did not achieve complete relief of discomfort or swelling, 9 cases (12.3%) experienced joint stiffness or decreased range of motion, and 6 cases (8.2%) had soft tissue irritation. Residual instability and reoperation are rare. Allograft rejection or wound infection was not observed.

CONCLUSION

For the CLAI patients with poor remnant quality, anatomic reconstruction of the lateral ligaments using allograft tendon and suspensory fixation is an effective procedure, while the top three complications in incidence were residual discomfort, joint stiffness, and soft tissue irritation.

LEVELS OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, retrospective case series.

Differences in health-related quality of life among patients after ankle injury

Ankle sprains are the most common injuries sustained in the physically active, often associated with pain and functional limitations long after initial recovery. In recent years, the impact of ankle sprains on general health and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) has been noted in athletes, but is not well-documented in the general population. We examined differences in HRQoL and general health between individuals with ankle sprain history and healthy controls. Those with ankle sprain reported significantly higher body mass index and general body pain, and lower SF-8 physical component scores than healthy controls. Additionally, there is some indication that physical activity is lower in those with ankle sprain history. This is an important step in illustrating the adverse sequelae of ankle sprains on population health and HRQoL.

Association of Ankle Sprain Frequency With Body Mass and Self-Reported Function: A Pooled Multisite Analysis

CONTEXT

Ankle sprains result in pain and disability. While factors such as body mass and prior injury contribute to subsequent injury, the association of the number of ankle sprains on body anthropometrics and self-reported function are unclear in this population. Therefore, the purpose of this investigation was to assess differences in anthropometric measurements and self-reported function between the number of ankle sprains utilizing a large, pooled data set.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional.

METHODS

Data were pooled from 14 studies (total N = 412) collected by the Chronic Ankle Instability Outcomes Network. Participants were categorized by the number of self-reported sprains. Anthropometric data and self-reported function were compared between those who reported a single versus >1 ankle sprain as well as among groups of those who had 1, 2, 3, 4, and ≥5 ankle sprains, respectively.

RESULTS

Those who had >1 ankle sprain had higher mass (P = .001, d = 0.33) and body mass index (P = .002, d = 0.32) and lower Foot and Ankle Ability Measure-Activities of Daily Living (P < .001, r = .22), Foot and Ankle Ability Measure-Sport (P < .001, r = .33), and Cumberland Ankle Instability Tool (P < .001, r = .34) scores compared to the single ankle sprain group. Those who had a single ankle sprain weighed less than those who reported ≥5 sprains (P = .008, d = 0.42) and had a lower body mass index than those who reported 2 sprains (P = .031, d = 0.45).

CONCLUSIONS

Some individuals with a history of multiple ankle sprains had higher body mass and self-reported disability compared to those with a single sprain, factors that are likely interrelated. Due to the potential for long-term health concerns associated with ankle sprains, clinicians should incorporate patient education and interventions that promote physical activity, healthy dietary intake, and optimize function as part of comprehensive patient-centered care.

Quantitative analysis with load–displacement ratio measured via digital arthrometer in the diagnostic evaluation of chronic ankle instability: a cross-sectional study

Background

Arthrometry has been introduced to evaluate the laxity of ankle joint in recent years. However, its role in the diagnosis of chronic ankle instability is still debatable. Therefore, we assessed the diagnostic accuracy of a digital arthrometer in terms of sensitivity and specificity.

Methods

According to the inclusion and exclusion criteria proposed by the International Ankle Consortium, we recruited 160 uninjured ankles (control group) and 153 ankles with chronic ankle instability (CAI group). Ankle laxity was quantitively measured by a validated digital arthrometer. Data of loading force and joint displacement were recorded in a continuous manner. Differences between the control and CAI groups were compared using 2-tailed independent t test. A receiver operating characteristic curve analysis was used to calculate area under a curve, sensitivity and specificity.

Results

Load–displacement curves of the two groups were depicted. Differences of joint displacement between the control and CAI groups were compared at 30, 45, 60, 75, 90, 105 and 120 N, which were all of statistical significance (all p < 0.001) with the largest effect size at 90 N. Statistical significance was found in the differences between the two groups in load–displacement ratio at 10–120 N, 10–40 N, 40–80 N and 80–120 N (all p < 0.001), with the largest effect size at 10–40 N. Load–displacement ratio at the interval of 10–40 N had the highest area under a curve (0.9226), with sensitivity and specificity of 0.804 and 0.863, respectively, when the cutoff point was 0.1582 mm/N.

Conclusion

The digital arthrometer measurement could quantitively analyze the ankle laxity with high diagnostic accuracy. The load–displacement ratio would be a reliable and promising approach for chronic ankle instability diagnosis.

Level of evidence level II.

Ligament Augmentation Reconstruction System (LARS) for Ankle Lateral Ligament Reconstruction in Higher-Risk Patients: A 5-Year Prospective Cohort Study

Background:

The modified Broström-Gould (MBG) procedure is the gold standard for patients with chronic ankle instability (CAI), but it is relatively contraindicated for patients with higher body weight or generalized ligamentous laxity (GLL). The use of the ligament augmentation reconstruction system (LARS) is an alternative.

Hypothesis:

It was hypothesized that clinical outcomes would be similar in patients with increased body weight (>90 kg) or GLL, relative to controls.

Study Design:

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 2.

Methods:

A total of 66 patients satisfying the inclusion criteria were invited to participate and were divided into 3 groups: controls (no risk factors for inferior clinical outcome), patients with body weight >90 kg, and patients with GLL (Beighton score, ≥5 of 9). All patients underwent imbrication of the lateral collateral ligament complex augmented with the LARS. Primary outcomes of interest were Tegner activity scale (TAS) and Foot and Ankle Outcome Score (FAOS) subscale scores. Secondary outcomes were recurrence of ankle instability, the need for further surgery, and/or complications. Patients were reviewed at 2 and 5 years postoperatively, and outcomes between groups were compared using repeated-measures analysis of variance.

Results:

Complete data were available for 63 patients (21 patients in each group). TAS improved in all groups from preoperatively to 2 years and 5 years postoperatively (P < .001 for all). Relative to the controls, the TAS scores were lower in the >90-kg group at 2 years and 5 years (P < .001 for both periods), while the GLL group had similar scores to controls at both postoperative periods. Both the >90-kg and the GLL groups showed no significant difference in improvement on any FAOS subscale scores relative to the controls, at both 2 and 5 years postoperatively. There were no recurrences, repeat surgeries, or major complications.

Conclusion:

Relative to controls, patients with body weight >90 kg or GLL had similar FAOSs, and TAS scores were lower in the >90-kg group, at 2 and 5 years, after the use of the LARS to augment lateral collateral ligament imbrication for CAI. Use of the LARS in this manner is a viable option in patients for whom the MBG procedure is relatively contraindicated.