Unusual (CGG)n expansion and recombination in a family with fragile X and DiGeorge syndrome

Expansions and contractions of the FMR1 CGG repeat in 5,508 transmissions of normal, intermediate, and premutation alleles

Instability of the FMR1 repeat, commonly observed in transmissions of premutation alleles (55-200 repeats), is influenced by the size of the repeat, its internal structure and the sex of the transmitting parent. We assessed these three factors in unstable transmissions of 14/3,335 normal (~5 to 44 repeats), 54/293 intermediate (45-54 repeats), and 1561/1,880 premutation alleles. While most unstable transmissions led to expansions, contractions to smaller repeats were observed in all size classes. For normal alleles, instability was more frequent in paternal transmissions and in alleles with long 3' uninterrupted repeat lengths. For premutation alleles, contractions also occurred more often in paternal than maternal transmissions and the frequency of paternal contractions increased linearly with repeat size. All paternal premutation allele contractions were transmitted as premutation alleles, but maternal premutation allele contractions were transmitted as premutation, intermediate, or normal alleles. The eight losses of AGG interruptions in the FMR1 repeat occurred exclusively in contractions of maternal premutation alleles. We propose a refined model of FMR1 repeat progression from normal to premutation size and suggest that most normal alleles without AGG interruptions are derived from contractions of maternal premutation alleles.

Fragile X full mutation expansions are inhibited by one or more AGG interruptions in premutation carriers

PURPOSE

Fragile X CGG repeat alleles often contain one or more AGG interruptions that influence allele stability and risk of a full mutation transmission from parent to child. We have examined transmissions of maternal and paternal alleles with 45-90 repeats to quantify the effect of AGG interruptions on fragile X repeat instability.

METHODS

A novel FMR1 polymerase chain reaction assay was used to determine CGG repeat length and AGG interruptions for 1,040 alleles from 705 families.

RESULTS

We grouped transmissions into nine categories of five repeats by parental size and found that in every size category, alleles with no AGGs had the greatest risk for instability. For maternal alleles <75 repeats, 89% (24/27) that expanded to a full mutation had no AGGs. Two contractions in maternal transmission were accompanied by loss of AGGs, suggesting a mechanism for generating alleles that lack AGG interruptions. Maternal age was examined as a factor in full mutation expansions using prenatal samples to minimize ascertainment bias, and a possible effect was observed though it was not statistically significant (P = 0.06).

CONCLUSION

These results strengthen the association of AGG repeats with CGG repeat stability and provide more accurate risk estimates of full mutation expansions for women with 45-90 repeat alleles.

JAG1 mutation in a patient with deletion 22q11.2 syndrome and tetralogy of Fallot

Deletion 22q11.2 (del22q11.2) syndrome, also known as DiGeorge/Velo-cardio-facial syndrome (DG/VCFS), and Alagille syndrome are genetic disorders characteristically associated with congenital heart defects (CHDs). We report on a patient with tetralogy of Fallot (TOF) and clinical features of DG/VCFS, hemizygous for del22q11.2 and heterozygous for the 2810G > A (p.Arg937Gln) mutation in the JAG1 gene associated with Alagille syndrome. The clinical features of del22q11.2 syndrome are present in the patient, including facial anomalies, typical TOF, speech delay with hypernasal voice, and learning difficulties. TOF and mild hepatic involvement, consisting of slightly elevated aminotransferase conjugated bilirubin levels, were the only features of Alagille syndrome in our patient. The anatomic type of TOF displayed no distinctive recognizable pattern for either DG/VCFS or Alagille syndrome. It is likely that hemizygosity of the TBX1 gene was causally related to TOF in this patient, although a synergistic pathogenic role of the JAG1 gene mutation in causing the heart defect cannot be excluded. JAG1 mutations have been previously detected in patients with nonsyndromic TOF and recent molecular evidence supports the cumulative effect of multiple genetic defects in the etiology of human malformations. We hypothesize that a similar mechanism could be present in this patient with del22q11.2 syndrome associated with a JAG1 missense mutation acting as possible modifier factor for TOF.

Expansion to full mutation of a FMR1 intermediate allele over two generations

Fragile X syndrome is due to an expanded CGG repeat in the 5' UTR of the FMR1 gene. According to repeat size, we distinguish four allele categories: normal (<40 CGG), intermediate (46-60 CGG), premutated (55-200 CGG) and full mutated (>200 CGG). However, the boundaries among these categories are unclear, making it difficult to classify unstable alleles and to estimate the risk of expansion. We report a family with a proband, carrying a methylated full mutation with an amplification of 1.2 kb. PCR analysis demonstrated two alleles of 29 and 61 CGGs in the mother. Sequencing of the 61 CGG allele showed no AGG interruptions. Both mother's sisters had two alleles of 31 and 44 CGGs, and the daughter of one of these had two alleles of 22 and 44 repeats, demonstrating stable transmission of the 44 CGG allele. The maternal grandfather was deceased, but haplotype reconstruction using markers DXS548 and FRAXAC1 demonstrated that he was carrier of the premutated allele. Furthermore, molecular analysis confirmed the same paternity with a probability of 99.79% for all the three sisters. According to these findings, it is likely that the maternal grandfather carried the 44 CGG allele, showing unstable transmission, given that it expanded first to 61 CGGs in one daughter, and then to full mutation in her child. Although we cannot exclude paternal mosaicism, it is likely that a rare event of progression from an intermediate to a premutated and on to a full mutated allele occurred in this family over two generations.

Haplotypic determinants of instability in the FRAX region: Concatenated mutation or founder effect?

The fragile X triplet repeat expansion at Xq27.3 has been shown to be associated with mutation or instability 600 kb distal at the FMR2 repeat locus. Concatenated mutation, whereby a mutation at one locus somehow interacts with mutation, recombination, deletion, or transposition at another locus, is a possible explanation. In this study we examine evidence from a sample of over 7,000 independent haplotypes from the FRAX region. We adopt the use of cladistic groups to more thoroughly define the properties of these haplotypes, and in doing so isolate one group of haplotypes which may be predisposed to the phenomenon of concatenated mutation. Distinguishing concatenated mutation from founder effects is difficult within a single population. We present our evidence for and against concatenated mutation, and in the process describe a previously undefined mutation at FRAXE.

The fragile X syndrome

The fragile X syndrome is characterised by mental retardation, behavioural features, and physical features, such as a long face with large protruding ears and macro-orchidism. In 1991, after identification of the fragile X mental retardation (FMR1) gene, the cytogenetic marker (a fragile site at Xq27.3) became replaced by molecular diagnosis. The fragile X syndrome was one of the first examples of a "novel" class of disorders caused by a trinucleotide repeat expansion. In the normal population, the CGG repeat varies from six to 54 units. Affected subjects have expanded CGG repeats (>200) in the first exon of the FMR1 gene (the full mutation). Phenotypically normal carriers of the fragile X syndrome have a repeat in the 43 to 200 range (the premutation). The cloning of the FMR1 gene led to the characterisation of its protein product FMRP, encouraged further clinical studies, and opened up the possibility of more accurate family studies and fragile X screening programmes.

Cloned human FMR1 trinucleotide repeats exhibit a length- and orientation-dependent instability suggestive of in vivo lagging strand secondary structure

The normal human FMR1 gene contains a genetically stable (CGG) n trinucleotide repeat which usually carries interspersed AGG triplets. An increase in repeat number and the loss of interspersions results in array instability, predominantly expansion, leading to FMR1 gene silencing. Instability is directly related to the length of the uninterrupted (CGG) n repeat and is widely assumed to be related to an increased propensity to form G-rich secondary structures which lead to expansion through replication slippage. In order to investigate this we have cloned human FMR1 arrays with internal structures representing the normal, intermediate and unstable states. In one replicative orientation, arrays show a length-dependent instability, deletions occurring in a polar manner. With longer arrays these extend into the FMR1 5'-flanking DNA, terminating at either of two short CGG triplet arrays. The orientation-dependent instability suggests that secondary structure forms in the G-rich lagging strand template, resolution of which results in intra-array deletion. These data provide direct in vivo evidence for a G-rich lagging strand secondary structure which is believed to be involved in the process of triplet expansion in humans.

The role of size, sequence and haplotype in the stability of FRAXA and FRAXE alleles during transmission

Factors involved in the stability of trinucleotide repeats during transmission were studied in 139 families in which a full mutation, premutation or intermediate allele at either FRAXA or FRAXE was segregating. The transmission of alleles at FRAXA, FRAXE and four microsatellite loci were recorded for all individuals. Instability within the minimal and common ranges (0-40 repeats for FRAXA, 0-30 repeats for FRAXE) was extremely rare; only one example was observed, an increased in size at FRAXA from 29 to 39 repeats. Four FRAXA and three FRAXE alleles in the intermediate range (41-60) repeats for FRAXA, 31-60 for FRAXE) were unstably transmitted. Instability was more frequent for FRAXA intermediate alleles that had a tract of pure CGG greater than 37 although instability only occurred in two of 13 such transmissions: the changes observed were limited to only one or two repeats. Premutation FRAXA alleles over 100 repeats expanded to a full mutation during female transmission in 100% of cases, in agreement with other published series. There was no clear correlation between haplotype and probability of expansion of FRAXA premutations. Instability at FRAXA or FRAXE was more often observed in conjunction with a second instability at an independent locus suggesting genomic instability as a possible mechanism by which at least some FRAXA and FRAXE mutations arise.

Familial transmission of the FMR1 CGG repeat

To better define the nature of FMR1 CGG-repeat expansions, changes in allele sizes for 191 families with fragile X and for 33 families with gray-zone repeats (40-60) were analyzed. Expansion of the fragile X chromosome to the full mutation was seen in 13.4% of offspring from premutation mothers with 56-59 repeats, 20.6% of those with 60-69 repeats, 57.8% of those with 70-79 repeats, 72.9% of those with 80-89 repeats, and 97.3% of those with 90-199 repeats. For premutation fathers, the majority (62%) of their daughters had a larger repeat number, while a few had either a smaller (22%) or the same (16%) repeat number, compared with their fathers' sizes. However, daughters with a smaller repeat number were observed only if their fathers had > or = 80 repeats. Fifteen (39.5%) of 38 such daughters carried a smaller repeat than did their fathers. We observed that a similar repeat number was inherited more often than expected by chance, among the members of a sibship segregating fragile X. This familial clustering, observed in the offspring of both males and females with a premutation, implies there may be an additional factor, independent of parental repeat size, that influences CGG-repeat instability. Instability in gray-zone allele transmissions was observed in 25% of alleles with 50-60 CGGs but in <8% of those with 40-49 CGGs. Examination of gray-zone allele organization revealed that long tracts of pure CGGs (>34) are not always unstably transmitted. These results raise new questions regarding the familial factors that may determine transmission expansions.

Fragile X founder chromosomes in Italy: a few initial events and possible explanation for their heterogeneity

A total of 137 fragile X and 235 control chromosomes from various regions of Italy were haplotyped by analyzing two neighbouring marker microsatellites, FRAXAC1 and DXS548. The number of CGG repeats at the 5' end of the FMR1 gene was also assessed in 141 control chromosomes and correlated with their haplotypes. Significant linkage disequilibrium between some "major" haplotypes and fragile X was observed, while other "minor" haplotypes may have originated by subsequent mutation at the marker microsatellite loci and/or recombination between them. Recent evidence suggests that the initial mechanism leading to CGG instability might consist of rare (10 (-6/-7)) CGG repeat slippage events and/or loss of a stabilizing AGG via A-to-C transversion. Also, the apparently high variety of fragile X chromosomes may be partly due to the relatively high mutation rate (10 (-4/-5)) of the microsatellite markers used in haplotyping. Our fragile X sample also showed a higher than expected heterozygosity when compared to the control sample and we suggest that this might be explained by the chance occurrence of the few founding events on different chromosomes, irrespective of their actual frequency in the population. Alternatively, a local mechanism could enhance the microsatellite mutation rate only on fragile X chromosomes, or fragile X mutations might occur more frequently on certain background haplotypes.

Evolution of the cryptic FMR1 CGG repeat

We have sequenced the 5' untranslated region of the orthologous FMR1 gene from 44 species of mammals. The CGG repeat is present in each species, suggesting conservation of the repeat over 150 million years of mammalian radiation. Most mammals possess small contiguous repeats (mean number of repeats = 8.0 +/- 0.8), but in primates, the repeats are larger (mean = 20.0 +/- 2.3) and more highly interrupted. Parsimony analysis predicts that enlargement of the FMR1 CGG repeat beyond 20 triplets has occurred in three different primate lineages. In man and gorilla, AGG interruptions occur with higher-order periodicity, suggesting that historical enlargement has involved incremental and vectorial addition of larger arrays demarcated by an interruption. Our data suggest that replication slippage and unequal crossing over have been operative during the evolution of this repeat.

FMR1 triplet arrays: paying the price for perfection

Our understanding of FMRI trinucleotide instability has increased dramatically with knowledge of its detailed structures. While most arrays seem to be protected by interspersions, for a few the price of perfection is instability. Although there remain many unanswered questions, diagnosis in the “grey zone” can be greatly improved by studying array content. For the future, as we strive to delineate normal from premutation, we should increasingly be able to estimate rates of instability for future generations and predict the risk of conversion to the full mutation.