Clinical features of cystic fibrosis patients with rare genotypes

Rescue of Rare CFTR Trafficking Mutants Highlights a Structural Location-Dependent Pattern for Correction

Cystic Fibrosis (CF) is a genetic disease caused by mutations in the gene encoding the Cystic Fibrosis Transmembrane Conductance Regulator (CFTR) channel. Currently, more than 2100 variants have been identified in the gene, with a large number being very rare. The approval of modulators that act on mutant CFTR protein, correcting its molecular defect and thus alleviating the burden of the disease, revolutionized the field of CF. However, these drugs do not apply to all patients with CF, especially those with rare mutations-for which there is a lack of knowledge on the molecular mechanisms of the disease and the response to modulators. In this work, we evaluated the impact of several rare putative class II mutations on the expression, processing, and response of CFTR to modulators. Novel cell models consisting of bronchial epithelial cell lines expressing CFTR with 14 rare variants were created. The variants studied are localized at Transmembrane Domain 1 (TMD1) or very close to the signature motif of Nucleotide Binding Domain 1 (NBD1). Our data show that all mutations analyzed significantly decrease CFTR processing and while TMD1 mutations respond to modulators, those localized in NBD1 do not. Molecular modeling calculations confirm that the mutations in NBD1 induce greater destabilization of CFTR structure than those in TMD1. Furthermore, the structural proximity of TMD1 mutants to the reported binding site of CFTR modulators such as VX-809 and VX-661, make them more efficient in stabilizing the CFTR mutants analyzed. Overall, our data suggest a pattern for mutation location and impact in response to modulators that correlates with the global effect of the mutations on CFTR structure.

Phenotypic expression of genotype-phenotype correlation in cystic fibrosis patients carrying the 852del22 mutation

Currently, more than 1,000 mutations have been identified in the cystic fibrosis transmembrane regulator (CFTR) gene. While some mutations are common worldwide, the majority are restricted in certain ethnic groups. We have found that in Southern Italy, the 852del22 mutation is well represented with a frequency of 3.5%. We have screened, by reverse dot blot, denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE), and gene sequencing, the entire coding regions of CFTR gene in 371 consecutive cystic fibrosis (CF) patients from Southern Italy and have identified 17 patients carrying rare genotypes, among which 13 [6 M; median age 21.7 years (range: 4.5-47.7 years)] carry the 852del22 mutation. To assess the phenotypic expression of CF in patients with the 852del22 mutations we have compared these patients with a group of age and gender matched patients homozygous for the DeltaF508 mutation [n = 34; 19 M; median age 19.9 years (range: 3.8-34.6 years)]. Overall, we found no difference in terms of complications, patient survival (17.6% vs. 30.7%; P = NS), estimated time needed to develop a severe lung disease (22.1 vs. 24.5 years; P = NS), nutritional status, and rate of infection or colonization by most common pathogens between patients in the two groups. Finally, we have found that a late diagnosis was associated with a poor outcome (severe lung disease) regardless of genotype. Our data show that 852del22 mutation results in a phenotypic expression of disease as severe as that determined by the more typical DeltaF508 and, as in the latter case, there is no strict genotype/phenotype correlation.

Genotype-phenotype correlation and frequency of the 3199del6 cystic fibrosis mutation among I148T carriers: results from a collaborative study

PURPOSE

We expect that the mutation panel currently recommended for preconception/prenatal CF carrier screening will be modified as new information is learned regarding the phenotype associated with specific mutations and allele frequencies in various populations. One such example is the I148T mutation, originally described as a severe CF mutation. After implementation of CF population-based carrier screening, we learned that I148T exists as a complex allele with 3199del6 in patients with clinical CF, whereas asymptomatic compound heterozygotes for I148T and a second severe CF mutation were negative for 3199del6.

METHODS

We performed reflex testing for 3199del6 on 663 unrelated specimens, including I148T heterozygotes, compound heterozygotes, and a homozygous individual.

RESULTS

Less than 1% of I148T carriers were also positive for 3199del6. Excluding subjects tested because of a suspected or known CF diagnosis or positive family history, 0.6% of I148T-positive individuals were also positive for 3199del6. We identified 1 I148T homozygote and 6 unrelated compound heterozygous individuals with I148T and a second CF variant (2 of whom also carried 3199del6). In addition, one fetus with echogenic bowel and one infertile male were heterozygous for I148T (3199del6 negative).

CONCLUSIONS

Reflex testing for 3199del6 should be considered whenever I148T is identified. Reflex testing is of particular importance for any symptomatic patient or whenever one member of a couple carries a deleterious CF mutation and the other member is an I148T heterozygote. Further population data are required to determine if I148T, in the absence of 3199del6, is associated with mild or atypical CF or male infertility.

The I148T CFTR allele occurs on multiple haplotypes: a complex allele is associated with cystic fibrosis

PURPOSE

To determine whether intragenic changes modulate the cystic fibrosis (CF) phenotype in individuals who are positive for the I148T allele.

METHODS

The genes from individuals who carried at least one copy of the I148T allele were analyzed for additional changes that may be acting as genetic modifiers.

RESULTS

Seven of eight individuals with a known or suspected diagnosis of CF who carried I148T in combination with a severe CF mutation also carried 3199del6. Eight apparently healthy adult individuals who were compound heterozygous for I148T and a severe CF mutation or homozygous for I148T did not carry the deletion ( = 0.0014). The I148T allele occurs on at least three haplotypes: an IVS-8 9T background, a 7T background, or a 9T + 3199del6 background. The 3199del6 allele was not identified in 386 non-CF chromosomes.

CONCLUSIONS

It is concluded that I148T occurs on at least three haplotypes and the complex allele I148T + 9T + 3199del6 is associated with a classic CF phenotype.

Genotype-phenotype correlation in cystic fibrosis: the role of modifier genes

More than 1,000 mutations have been identified in the cystic fibrosis (CF) transmembrane regulator (CFTR) disease gene. The impact of these mutations on the protein and the wide spectrum of CF phenotypes prompted a series of Genotype-Phenotype correlation studies. The CFTR genotype is invariably correlated with pancreatic status-in about 85% of cases with pancreatic insufficiency and in about 15% of cases with pancreatic sufficiency. The correlations between the CFTR genotype and pulmonary, liver, and gastrointestinal expression are debatable. The heterogeneous phenotype in CF patients bearing the same genotype or homozygotes for nonsense mutations implicated environmental and/or genetic factors in the disease. However, the discordant phenotype observed in CF siblings argued against a major role of environmental factors and suggested that genes other than CFTR modulate the CF phenotype. A locus that modulates gastrointestinal expression was identified in mice and subsequently in humans. By analyzing nine CF patients discordant for meconium ileus we were able to show that this locus had a dominant effect. Moreover, in a collaborative study we found a higher rate of polymorphisms in beta-defensin genes 1 and 2 in CF patients and in controls. In another multicenter study mutations in alpha-1 antitrypsin (A1AT) and mannose binding lectin genes were found to be independent risk factors for liver disease in CF patients. The body of evidence available suggests that the variegated CF phenotype results from complex interactions between numerous gene products.

Cystic fibrosis mutations R1162X and 2183AA®G in two southern Brasilian states

We screened 79 southern Brazilian patients with cystic fibrosis for the rare cystic fibrosis mutations R1162X and 2183AA<FONT FACE="Symbol">®</FONT>G. Forty-nine patients were born in the State of Paraná (PR) and 30 in the State of Santa Catarina (SC). Two 2183AA<FONT FACE="Symbol">®</FONT>G alleles were found among the SC patients and one among the PR patients. Six R1162X alleles were found among the SC patients and one among the PR patients. Fourteen percent of the alleles found among patients of Italian origin were R1162X, and 7% were 2183AA<FONT FACE="Symbol">®</FONT>G mutations. These mutations, together with <FONT FACE="Symbol">D</FONT>F508, were also studied in a sample of 270 normal non-related subjects of Italian origin who have been born in PR. In this sample we found two <FONT FACE="Symbol">D</FONT>F508 alleles and one 2183AA<FONT FACE="Symbol">®</FONT>G allele. <FONT FACE="Symbol">D</FONT>F508, R1162X and 2183AA<FONT FACE="Symbol">®</FONT>G frequencies were not statistically different from those observed in Italy. Our results demonstrate that it is important to include these mutations in southern Brazilian surveys of cystic fibrosis patients, especially when they are of Italian descent.

Severe liver impairment in a cystic fibrosis-affected child homozygous for the G542X mutation

The clinical and laboratory findings of a cystic fibrosis (CF) patient homozygous for the G542X mutation are described. This is the first case, among the 7 G542X homozygous CF subjects described so far who shows severe liver involvement, associated pancreatic insufficiency, and moderate pulmonary expression of the disease, as demonstrated by laboratory and imaging data. This case adds to the conclusion that genotype/phenotype correlation in cystic fibrosis is more complex than formerly suspected.

Mouse models of human genetic disease: which mouse is more like a man?

There has always been great interest in animal models of human genetic disease, and mice provide the largest number of examples. A mutation in the homologous gene in mice does not always lead to the same phenotype as is found in man, however. Recent studies made it apparent that one mutation can have markedly different phenotypes when placed on different genetic backgrounds. This variation is due to different alleles at modifying loci in various inbred strains. Thus, if one wishes to obtain the optimal mouse model for a human disease, one needs to choose the correct genetic background as well as the correct mutation.

Molecular epidemiology of cystic fibrosis mutations and haplotypes in southern Italy evaluated with an improved semiautomated robotic procedure

We screened for 22 cystic fibrosis (CF) mutations in DNA from a first cohort of 69 CF patients from southern Italy using a semiautomated allele specific oligonucleotide (ASO) dot blot procedure based on two multiplex PCR amplifications. Seven mutations (delta F508, N1303K, G542X, 1717-1 G-->A, W1282X, 1148T, and R553X) identified 77.6% of CF chromosomes. Detection reached 79.8% with the 2183 AA-->G mutation analysed with the restriction generating PCR method. Thus, we included the 2183 AA-->G mutation in the ASO protocol and set up the conditions to amplify the gene regions that include the eight mutations in a single multiplex PCR reaction. With this method we tested the DNA of the first cohort of 69 CF patients, a second cohort of 63 CF patients, and 300 carrier relatives; we also performed 12 prenatal diagnoses. The results from the 132 CF patients showed differences in the distribution of CF mutations between the south and north of Italy. The XV2c, KM19, and intron 8 VNDR haplotypes suggested the presence, in CF chromosomes bearing undetected mutations, of a limited number of unknown mutations typical of southern Italy. Finally, for six of the eight mutations, we compared the ASO procedure with the methods based on restriction enzymes; the results obtained with the two procedures were identical for all the 57 chromosomes compared.