Further motor unit studies in Duchenne muscular dystrophy

Fine-wire recordings of flexor hallucis brevis motor units up to maximal voluntary contraction reveal a flexible, nonrigid mechanism for force control

Our current knowledge on the neurophysiological properties of intrinsic foot muscles is limited, especially at high forces. This study therefore aimed to investigate the discharge characteristics of single motor units in an intrinsic foot muscle, namely flexor hallucis brevis, during voluntary contractions up to 100% of maximal voluntary contraction. We measured the recruitment threshold and discharge rate of flexor hallucis brevis motor units using indwelling fine-wire electrodes. Ten participants followed a target ramp up to maximal voluntary contraction by applying a metatarso-phalangeal flexion torque. We observed motor unit recruitment thresholds across a wide range of isometric forces (ranging from 10 to 98% of maximal voluntary contraction) as well as across a wide range of discharge rates (ranging from 4.8 to 23.3 Hz for initial discharge rate and 9.5 to 34.2 Hz for peak discharge rate). We further observed patterns of high variability in recruitment threshold and discharge rate as well as crossover in discharge rate between motor units within the same participant. These findings suggest that the force output of a muscle is generated through a mechanism with substantial variability rather than relying on a rigid organization, which is in contrast to the proposed onion-skin theory. The demands placed on the plantar intrinsic foot muscles during high- and low-force tasks may explain these observed neurophysiological properties.NEW & NOTEWORTHY We recorded for the first time single motor unit action potential trains in the flexor hallucis brevis, a short toe muscle, over the full range of maximum voluntary contraction. Its motor units are recruited up to very high (98%) recruitment thresholds with a substantial range of discharge rates. We further show high variability with crossover of discharge rates as a function of recruitment threshold both between participants and between motor units within participants.

A review of electrophysiological studies of lower motor neuron involvement in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a neurodegenerative disease involving both the upper and lower motor neuron diseases. In this review, we studied and compared different articles regarding the electrodiagnostic criteria for diagnosis of lower motor neuron pathology in ALS. We reviewed the most recent articles and metaanalysis regarding various lower motor neuron electrodiagnostic methods for ALS and their sensitivities. We concluded that Awaji Shima criteria is by far the most sensitive criteria for diagnosis of ALS.

Motor unit number estimation

Since its introduction 30 years ago, MUNE techniques have increasingly been refined and applied to a wide variety of neuromuscular disorders. Differences of opinion remain among MUNE investigators as to which method is best; however, statistical and MPS MUNE are currently the most widely used. Numerous methodologic issues remain, including the development of detailed universal standards for each technique and the implementation of modifications for the enhancement of reproducibility. These issues are the subjects of ongoing investigation. Despite technical variability, the MUNE values obtained using different methods show good agreement in studies of normal subjects and in patients with a variety of neurogenic processes. MUNE has been applied most successfully to patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and to animal models of motor neuron disease, providing significant insight into the pathophysiology of these disorders. These techniques are increasingly being incorporated into clinical therapeutic trials. MUNE offers promise in the study of neuromuscular disease, enabling the collection of novel data in the living patient unobtainable by any other method.

Motor unit number estimation in human neurological diseases and animal models

Motor unit number estimation (MUNE) was introduced in 1971 as a way of providing an objective and meaningful estimate of axon loss in diseases affecting the motor system. Over the last 30 years, different methods of MUNE have been proposed, with each having specific strengths and limitations. The goal of this paper is to review the available methods, and to present data generated using MUNE in a variety of disease entities. The incremental, multiple point stimulation, spike-triggered averaging, F-wave, and statistical methods of MUNE are reviewed, along with data obtained using these methods in patients with neuropathy, motor neuron disorders, and muscle disease. All methods reviewed have theoretical concerns associated with them. However, with the exception of the spike-triggered averaging method, all give results in normal subjects that are quite similar. MUNE has been of great value in assessing progression of motor neuron disease, and has also shown promise in the assessment of generalized neuropathy. Despite the lack of a perfect method for performing MUNE, it has great clinical value in the assessment of progressive motor axon loss. Further refinements in the method will likely increase its utility in the future.

Motor unit number estimation: sample size considerations

A computer model of the motor unit number estimation procedure was developed to evaluate the sampling error associated with estimates of the number of motor units in muscles. Two different distributions were used to model the motor unit amplitude distribution and were chosen in such a manner that they qualitatively matched the distributions observed under both normal and neurogenic conditions. As expected, the results indicated that estimation error decreases as a function of sample size. However, the relationship between these two variables was nonlinear in the sense that successive increases in sample size lead to progressively smaller decreases in estimation error. The results also indicated that the shape of the motor unit amplitude distribution plays an important role. Specifically, estimates obtained using the distribution modeling normal muscle were generally higher than the actual number of motor units in the muscle, which was not the case for the distribution modeling neurogenic muscle. In addition, the neurogenic distribution was associated with much smaller estimation error, suggesting that motor unit number estimation is well suited to the analysis of neurogenic disease processes.

Diseases and disorders of muscle

Muscle may suffer from a number of diseases or disorders, some being fatal to humans and animals. Their management or treatment depends on correct diagnosis. Although no single method may be used to identify all diseases, recognition depends on the following diagnostic procedures: (1) history and clinical examination, (2) blood biochemistry, (3) electromyography, (4) muscle biopsy, (5) nuclear magnetic resonance, (6) measurement of muscle cross-sectional area, (7) tests of muscle function, (8) provocation tests, and (9) studies on protein turnover. One or all of these procedures may prove helpful in diagnosis, but even then identification of the disorder may not be possible. Nevertheless, each of these procedures can provide useful information. Among the most common diseases in muscle are the muscular dystrophies, in which the newly identified muscle protein dystrophin is either absent or present at less than normal amounts in both Duchenne and Becker's muscular dystrophy. Although the identification of dystrophin represents a major breakthrough, treatment has not progressed to the experimental stage. Other major diseases of muscle include the inflammatory myopathies and neuropathies. Atrophy and hypertrophy of muscle and the relationship of aging, exercise, and fatigue all add to our understanding of the behavior of normal and abnormal muscle. Some other interesting related diseases and disorders of muscle include myasthenia gravis, muscular dysgenesis, and myclonus. Disorders of energy metabolism include those caused by abnormal glycolysis (Von Gierke's, Pompe's, Cori-Forbes, Andersen's, McArdle's, Hers', and Tauri's diseases) and by the acquired diseases of glycolysis (disorders of mitochondrial oxidation). Still other diseases associated with abnormal energy metabolism include lipid-related disorders (carnitine and carnitine palmitoyl-transferase deficiencies) and myotonic syndromes (myotonia congenita, paramyotonia congenita, hypokalemic and hyperkalemic periodic paralysis, and malignant hyperexia). Diseases of the connective tissues discussed include those of nutritional origin (scurvy, lathyrism, starvation, and protein deficiency), the genetic diseases (dermatosparaxis, Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, osteogenesis imperfecta, Marfan syndrome, homocystinuria, alcaptonuria, epidermolysis bullosa, rheumatoid arthritis in humans, polyarthritis in swine, Aleutian disease of mink, and the several types of systemic lupus erythematosus) and the acquired diseases of connective tissues (abnormal calcification, systemic sclerosis, interstitial lung disease, hepatic fibrosis, and carcinomas of the connective tissues). Several of the diseases of connective tissues may prove to be useful models for determining the relationship of collagen to meat tenderness and its other physical properties. Several other promising models for studying the nutrition-related disorders and the quality-related characteristics of meat are also reviewed.

Invited review: motor unit estimation: methods, results, and present status

The renewed interest in motor unit estimation (counting) has coincided with the introduction of computer-based methodology and with the application of the technique to proximal as well as distal muscles. The advantages and disadvantages of the different methods are considered, together with the assumptions inherent in this type of examination. In normal subjects, the extensor digitorum brevis (EDB) muscle has approximately 200 motor units while each of the intrinsic muscles of the hand has about 100 units; larger muscles in the limbs contain greater numbers of units. Beyond the age of 60 years, there is a decline in the number of functioning motor units in both proximal and distal muscles. In denervating disorders, motor unit estimation is useful for diagnosis and assessment; abnormal values may often be observed in muscles judged clinically to be unaffected. Serial studies have enabled the rate of motor unit loss to be determined in ALS and in spinal muscular atrophy. Depletion of motor units has also been found following upper motoneuron lesions caused by injury to the spinal cord or by cerebral hemorrhage; trans-synaptic dysfunction has been presumed responsible. Rather surprisingly, reduced numbers of motor units have been observed in a variety of myopathic disorders; of these, the most consistent abnormalities have been reported in myotonic muscular dystrophy.

A review of techniques employed to estimate the number of motor units in a muscle

Being the smallest functional units under neural control, motor units play an integral role in muscle physiology. However, at the present time, there does not exist any widely accepted technique for quantifying or estimating the number of motor units in a muscle. Specifically, the existing techniques are the increment-counting technique, a technique based on spike-triggered averaging, and a macro-EMG based technique which vary in invasiveness from noninvasive to highly invasive, respectively. We discuss each of these techniques, along with their associated shortcomings, in detail.

Incidence, severity, and time-course of motoneurone dysfunction in myotonic dystrophy: their significance for an understanding of anticipation

The numbers of functioning motor units and the amplitudes of the maximum evoked muscle responses have been measured in 198 muscles of 102 patients with myotonic dystrophy. Losses of units could be demonstrated in most of the extensor digitorum brevis and thenar muscles but less commonly in the hypothenar groups. A more proximal limb muscle, the soleus, was also shown to be involved frequently. Investigation of two premature infants withmyotonic dystrophy also revealed reductions of functiong units; in one infant clinical improvement was associated with increased muscle innervation. Repeated examinations of 10 adult patients disclosed an abnormal decline in neuromuscular function below the age of 60 years. The reduction in functioning units amounted to approximately 3% of the mean control value per annum. Analysis of 19 families showed that the severity of neuromuscular involvement was nearly always greater in members of later generations. If the predicted deterioration was also taken into account, the results strongly suggested that anticipation was a true genetic phenomenon rather than an artefact of selection. The combined results are considered to strengthen the concept of motoneurone dysfunction as the major pathogenetic factor in this form of dystrophy.

The neural hypothesis of muscular dystrophy. A review of recent experimental evidence with particular reference to the Duchenne form

Recent observations are considered to provide further evidence for an abnormality involving motoneurones in DMD. The dystrophic process appears to take place in two stages of which the first occurs during early embryonic life. This stage is thought to involve faulty inductive actions of the neural tube upon mesoderm and upon itself. The neural consequences vary among individuals and are manifested as mental retardation; EEG abnormalities and losses of functioning motor units. While the first two abnormalities are non-progressive, a further loss of motor units, associated with striking reductions in the numbers of excitable muscle fibers, takes place in trunk and large limb muscles at 9--12 years. The latter process, the cause of which is uncertain, constitutes the second stage of DMD.