The effect of thiopentone on somatosensory evoked responses and EEGs in comatose patients

Neuronal excitability and sensory responsiveness in the thalamo-cortical network in a novel rat model of isoelectric brain state

KEY POINTS

The neuronal and network properties that persist during an isoelectric coma remain largely unknown.  We developed a new in vivo rat model to assess cell excitability and sensory responsiveness in the thalamo-cortical pathway during an isoflurane-induced isoelectric brain state.  The isoelectric electrocorticogram reflected a complete interruption of spontaneous synaptic and firing activities in cortical and thalamic neurons.  Cell excitability and sensory responses in the thalamo-cortical network persisted at a reduced level in the isoelectric condition and returned to control values after resumption of background brain activity.  These findings could lead to a reassessment of the functional status of the drug-induced isoelectric state: a latent state in which individual neurons and networks retain to some extent the ability of being activated by external inputs.

ABSTRACT

The neuronal and network properties that persist in an isoelectric brain completely deprived of spontaneous electrical activity remain largely unexplored. Here, we developed a new in vivo rat model to examine cell excitability and sensory responsiveness in somatosensory thalamo-cortical networks during the interruption of endogenous brain activity induced by high doses of isoflurane. Electrocorticograms (ECoGs) from the barrel cortex were captured simultaneously with either intracellular recordings of subjacent cortical pyramidal neurons or extracellular records of the related thalamo-cortical neurons. Isoelectric ECoG periods reflected the disappearance of spontaneous synaptic and firing activities in cortical and thalamic neurons. This was associated with a sustained membrane hyperpolarization and a reduced intrinsic excitability in deep-layer cortical neurons, without significant changes in their membrane input resistance. Concomitantly, we found that whisker-evoked potentials in the ECoG and synaptic responses in cortical neurons were attenuated in amplitude and increased in latency. Impaired responsiveness in the barrel cortex paralleled with a lowering of the sensory-induced firing in thalamic cells. The return of endogenous brain electrical activities, after reinstatement of a control isoflurane concentration, led to the recovery of cortical neurons excitability and sensory responsiveness. These findings demonstrate the persistence of a certain level of cell excitability and sensory integration in the isoelectric state and the full recovery of cortico-thalamic functions after restoration of internal cerebral activities.

Cortical neurons and networks are dormant but fully responsive during isoelectric brain state

A continuous isoelectric electroencephalogram reflects an interruption of endogenously-generated activity in cortical networks and systematically results in a complete dissolution of conscious processes. This electro-cerebral inactivity occurs during various brain disorders, including hypothermia, drug intoxication, long-lasting anoxia and brain trauma. It can also be induced in a therapeutic context, following the administration of high doses of barbiturate-derived compounds, to interrupt a hyper-refractory status epilepticus. Although altered sensory responses can be occasionally observed on an isoelectric electroencephalogram, the electrical membrane properties and synaptic responses of individual neurons during this cerebral state remain largely unknown. The aim of the present study was to characterize the intracellular correlates of a barbiturate-induced isoelectric electroencephalogram and to analyse the sensory-evoked synaptic responses that can emerge from a brain deprived of spontaneous electrical activity. We first examined the sensory responsiveness from patients suffering from intractable status epilepticus and treated by administration of thiopental. Multimodal sensory responses could be evoked on the flat electroencephalogram, including visually-evoked potentials that were significantly amplified and delayed, with a high trial-to-trial reproducibility compared to awake healthy subjects. Using an analogous pharmacological procedure to induce prolonged electro-cerebral inactivity in the rat, we could describe its cortical and subcortical intracellular counterparts. Neocortical, hippocampal and thalamo-cortical neurons were all silent during the isoelectric state and displayed a flat membrane potential significantly hyperpolarized compared with spontaneously active control states. Nonetheless, all recorded neurons could fire action potentials in response to intracellularly injected depolarizing current pulses and their specific intrinsic electrophysiological features were preserved. Manipulations of the membrane potential and intracellular injection of chloride in neocortical neurons failed to reveal an augmented synaptic inhibition during the isoelectric condition. Consistent with the sensory responses recorded from comatose patients, large and highly reproducible somatosensory-evoked potentials could be generated on the inactive electrocorticogram in rats. Intracellular recordings revealed that the underlying neocortical pyramidal cells responded to sensory stimuli by complex synaptic potentials able to trigger action potentials. As in patients, sensory responses in the isoelectric state were delayed compared to control responses and exhibited an elevated reliability during repeated stimuli. Our findings demonstrate that during prolonged isoelectric brain state neurons and synaptic networks are dormant rather than excessively inhibited, conserving their intrinsic properties and their ability to integrate and propagate environmental stimuli.

Induction of an Isoelectric Brain State to Investigate the Impact of Endogenous Synaptic Activity on Neuronal Excitability In Vivo

The way neurons process information depends both on their intrinsic membrane properties and on the dynamics of the afferent synaptic network. In particular, endogenously-generated network activity, which strongly varies as a function of the state of vigilance, significantly modulates neuronal computation. To investigate how different spontaneous cerebral dynamics impact single neurons' integrative properties, we developed a new experimental strategy in the rat consisting in suppressing in vivo all cerebral activity by means of a systemic injection of a high dose of sodium pentobarbital. Cortical activities, continuously monitored by combined electrocorticogram (ECoG) and intracellular recordings are progressively slowed down, leading to a steady isoelectric profile. This extreme brain state, putting the rat into a deep comatose, was carefully monitored by measuring the physiological constants of the animal throughout the experiments. Intracellular recordings allowed us to characterize and compare the integrative properties of the same neuron embedded into physiologically relevant cortical dynamics, such as those encountered in the sleep-wake cycle, and when the brain was fully silent.

Neuroanesthesia

Neuroanesthesia is a subspecialty area of anesthesia that deals with the complex relationships of anesthetic medications, neurosurgical procedures, and the critical care issues that surround the management of these patients. In this chapter we will focus on a brief overview of the key features associated with the management of patients undergoing neurosurgical procedures, including a review of hemodynamic/neurologic effects of anesthetic agents, neurophysiologic monitoring, and unique medical complications associated with these procedures. For successful patient outcomes, multidisciplinary approaches and effective team communications are essential in these high-intensity environments. This chapter should serve as an introduction to the multitude of issues that face the anesthesiologist and surgeon when dealing with this patient population.

Hypoxemic resuscitation in newborn piglets: recovery of somatosensory evoked potentials, hypoxanthine, and acid-base balance

We tested the hypothesis that hypoxic newborn piglets can be successfully resuscitated with lower O2 concentrations than 21%. Severely hypoxic, 2-4-d-old, anesthetized piglets were randomly divided into five resuscitation groups: 21% O2 (n = 10), 18% O2 (n = 9), 15% O2 (n = 9), 12% O2 (n = 8), all normoventilated, and a hypoventilated 21% O2 group (PaCO2; 7.0-8.0 kPa, n = 9). Base excess (BE) reached -20 +/- 1 mmol/L at the end of hypoxia. After 3 h of resuscitation, BE had risen to -4 +/- 1 mmol/L in the 21% O2, 18% O2, and hypoventilated groups, but was -10 +/- 2 mmol/L in the 15% O2 group (p < 0.05 versus 21% O2 group) and -22 +/- 2 mmol/L in the 12% O2 group (p < 0.05 versus 21% O2 group). Four animals died during resuscitation, all allocated to the 12% O2 group (p < 0.05 versus 21% O2 group). Somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) recovered in 39 of 45 piglets, and remained present during resuscitation in all except the 12% O2 group. SEP recovered initially even in six of eight animals in the 12% O2 group, but disappeared again in all later during resuscitation. The SEP amplitude recovered to levels not significantly different from the 21% O2 group in all groups except the 12% O2 group. Plasma hypoxanthine concentrations and extracellular hypoxanthine concentrations in the striatum decreased during resuscitation to levels not significantly different from the 21% O2 group in all but the 12% O2 group (p < 0.05 versus 21% O2 group). In conclusion, severely hypoxic newborn piglets were resuscitated as efficiently with both hypoventilation and 18% O2 as with 21% O2.

The rationale and utility of neurophysiological investigations in clinical monitoring for brain and spinal cord ischaemia during surgery and intensive care

This review concerns the role of neurophysiological monitoring in prevention of damage to the brain or spinal cord from inadequate supply of oxygenated blood during surgery and intensive care. The spontaneous and evoked electrical activity from neurones depends on oxidative metabolism of glucose, the substrate being delivered via the arterial blood supply and not stored locally. In critical situations electrical activity declines as oxygen delivery fails. Since this happens before neuronal death occurs it can provide early warning of risk. Methods for signal processing of EEG for this purpose must include time domain assessment and recognition of burst suppression pattern, as well as frequency domain information, and provide multivariate pattern recognition. Models for monitoring systems require analysis of data sets based on clinical studies where accurate outcome data is available so that valid comparisons between different approaches can be made. Neurophysiological features must be considered in the context of other relevant clinical parameters in the design of effective warning systems for prevention of brain damage due to inadequate oxygen supply.

Predictive value of brain-stem auditory evoked potentials in children with post-traumatic coma produced by diffuse brain injury

In the present study, brain-stem auditory evoked potentials (BAEPs) in 31 children in post-traumatic coma with diffuse brain injury were examined. The BAEPs were recorded in the first 72 h after hospital admission and the findings of 29 patients related to the level of neurological recovery at 6 months after head injury. On the basis of the results, children were divided into three groups: the first consisted of children with bilateral and normal BAEPs (n = 19); the second of those with asymmetrical BAEPs (n = 6); and the third of those in whom BAEPs has disappeared or in whom only responses of the seventh cranial nerve and cochlear nucleus were recorded (n = 4). All the patients in the first group presented a good clinical outcome, with excellent recovery in 80%. In the second group three children (42.8%) had a good recovery, two (28.6%) were moderately disabled and one (14.3%) died of extraneurological causes. All the patients in the third group died. Abnormal BAEPs showed a significant correlation with absence of pupillary and/or corneal reflex, but not with the Glasgow Coma Score and anisocoria. Good statistical correlation was observed between normal BAEPs and visualization of basal cisterns on computed tomographic scan. The incidence of increased intracranial pressure was higher in patients with abnormal BAEPs, but the differences were not significant (P = 0.06). Our study confirms the predictive value of BAEPs in children's post-traumatic coma due to diffuse brain injury.

Somatosensory evoked potentials for prediction of outcome in acute severe brain injury

The purpose of this study was to evaluate prospectively short-latency somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) as a predictor of outcome in acute, severe brain injury, and to compare this with the predictive power of the motor component of the Glasgow Coma Scale score and computed tomographic scan. Outcome was measured with the Glasgow Outcome Scale at a minimum of 6 months after injury. We studied 109 patients (aged 0.1 to 16.8 years) with SEPs within 4 days of the onset of coma. Four patients had absent SEPs and a favorable outcome by the Glasgow Outcome Scale (full recovery or moderate disability); two of these patients had meningitis with bilateral subdural effusions, one had a midbrain hemorrhage, and one had a decompressive craniectomy for uncontrolled intracranial hypertension. Normal SEPs had a positive predictive value for favorable outcome of 93% (95% confidence interval (CI), 77% to 99%), and absent SEPs had a positive predictive value for unfavorable outcome by the Glasgow Outcome Scale (severe disability, survival in a persistent vegetative state, or death) of 92% (95% CI, 80% to 98%). If the above identifiable clinical situations in which a physical barrier existed to impede cutaneous reception of the electrical impulse were excluded, the positive predictive value of absent SEPs for poor outcome reached 100% (95% CI, 92% to 100%). An absent motor response to painful stimulus also had 100% positive predictive value (95% CI, 84% to 100%) for unfavorable outcome; however, 23% of patients could not be evaluated because of the effects of muscle relaxants or sedatives. In patients with traumatic brain injury, results of computed tomography did not reliably predict outcome. Of the 59 patients with unfavorable outcome, 76% could be identified with SEPs compared with 36% with examination of motor function. We suggest that SEPs be performed in children with acute severe brain injury because they add an important tool to the physician's prognostic armamentarium. We conclude that in the absence of the above mentioned identifiable clinical situations, absent SEPs predict 100% unfavorable outcome, and this finding may warrant consideration of withdrawal of treatment in children with brain injuries.

Electroencephalography

Notwithstanding recent advances in neuroimaging, EEG remains a major technique for investigation of the brain. Its main applications are in assessment of cerebral function rather than for detecting structural abnormalities. The principal clinical applications are in epilepsy, states of altered consciousness including postanoxic and traumatic coma, the parasomnias, dementias, toxic confusional states, cerebral infections, and various other encephalopathies. Abnormalities in EEG reflect general pathophysiological processes, raised intracranial pressure, cerebral anoxia, or oedema, epileptogenesis etc, and show little specificity for a particular disease. Consequently, they need to be interpreted in a particular clinical context; the use of routine EEG examination for screening purposes is rarely of value. Conversely, the investigation becomes most cost effective when applied to specific problems--for instance, monitoring serial changes in postanoxic coma or during open heart surgery, differential diagnosis (by telemetric ictal recordings) of epileptic and non-epileptic attacks, and providing early prediction of outcome after stroke. High technological standards and an individualised problem solving approach are prerequisites of a cost effective, reliable clinical EEG service. These are most likely to be achieved by a considered, selective referral policy, the use where necessary of prolonged complex procedures such as telemetry, and the avoidance of routine examinations of dubious clinical relevance.

Automated evoked potential monitoring

We have developed a computer system for use in the operating room and intensive care unit for the automated acquisition and classification of flash evoked potentials. The project goals were to: (1) acquire evoked potentials without user intervention; (2) recognize, label, and trend important parameters; and (3) alarm if parameters deviate too far from normal. The system consists of a Nicolet Pathfinder, programmed for periodic flash visual evoked potential acquisition and a personal computer for analysis. Analysis software utilizes the C+ +language. The system has been tested on sixteen cases, determinations of specific waveforms were validated ex post facto by two experts. Three parameters in each of three channels were correctly recognized in more than 87% of all waveforms acquired. No signals at all were obtained in only 0.8% of all samples.

[Effect of anesthetics on sensory evoked potentials]

The authors have reviewed the main effects of anaesthetic agents on sensory evoked potentials (EPs) in the auditory, somatosensory and visual modalities. Knowledge of EP changes induced by anesthetic drugs is important to avoid false alarms when monitoring neural structures at risk during surgery. Intraoperative EP monitoring is all the more efficient as the following points are taken into account: 1) whatever the sensory modality considered, EPs are more attenuated by volatile halogenated agents than by intravenous drugs; 2) the cortical components of EPs are more sensitive to anesthetic drugs than the brainstem components; 3) in each modality, the first component of the "primary cortical complex" is less attenuated by anaesthetic agents than the following cortical waves; 4) continuous administration of anaesthetic agents rather than acute administration (bolus) is preferred during EP monitoring. EPs also represent an objective means to assess the depth of surgical anaesthesia, since they may provide a reliable index of cortical depression. Amplitude changes of middle-latency auditory responses (Pa/Nb) seem to be a good marker for estimating depth of anaesthesia with the aid of EPs.

Management of intracranial hypertension

Intracranial hypertension is the final common denominator of morbidity and mortality for diverse neurologic problems, and its proper treatment requires the heuristic application of the available therapeutic alternatives when the clinical situation and patient's prognosis warrants treatment. The initial therapeutic focus for ICP reduction should be control of factors that may aggravate intracranial hypertension such as inappropriate head and body position, elevated body temperature, pain, noxious stimuli, elevated airway pressure, elevated blood pressure, seizures, and hypotonic intravenous fluids. The appropriate conventional therapies (e.g., hyperventilation, osmotic agents, sedatives, barbiturates, and cerebrospinal fluid removal) should be selected based on the details of each individual case. Surgical removal of intracranial mass lesions may be indicated in some circumstances, particularly for intractable intracranial hypertension and progressive, severe brain tissue shifts.

The effects of low pass filtering on central somatosensory conduction time

Central Somatosensory conduction time (CSCT) in the rat was measured by simultaneously recording the cortical somatosensory evoked potential (SEP) and cervical SEP and then subtracting the peak latency of the cervical response from that of the primary cortical response. The low frequency (high pass) filter of the recording system was kept fixed at 3.2 Hz but the high frequency cut-off was progressively raised from 32 to 16 kHz to examine the effects of low pass filtering on the two waveforms from which CSCT is derived. With a bandpass of 3.2-32 Hz, no activity could be reliably identified in either the cortical or cervical traces. With subsequent rises in the high frequency filter, the amplitude of both potentials increased with a concomitant decrease in their latencies. Stable values were obtained with a bandpass of 3.2-3.2 kHz and there was little additional change in waveform configuration. In contrast to the waveforms, low pass filtering had only minimal effects on CSCT and near constant values (in the range 3.6-4.1 ms) were obtained regardless of the setting of the low pass filter. I concluded that low pass filtering has a largely uniform effect on somatosensory activity generated in both primary cortical and cervico-medullary locations.

Somatosensory evoked potentials and outcome in perinatal asphyxia

Somatosensory evoked potentials (SEP) can be measured in the term newborn infant and given an index of function in the areas of the brain most likely to be damaged in perinatal asphyxia. We studied the median nerve SEP in 30 asphyxiated term infants over the course of their encephalopathy and until discharge from the neonatal unit. Three types of response were noted: normal waveform, abnormal waveform, or absence of cortical response. Follow up of the survivors was undertaken at a mean age of 12 months by means of a Griffiths' assessment and neurological examination. Nine infants died of their asphyxial illness and one of spinal muscular atrophy. Of the 20 survivors, three have cerebral palsy, four have minor abnormalities, and 13 are neurodevelopmentally normal. There was a close correlation between outcome and SEP. All 13 infants with normal outcome had normal SEP by 4 days of age, whereas those with abnormal or absent responses beyond 4 days had abnormalities at follow up.

EEG and evoked potentials in comatose patients with severe brain damage

EEGs and evoked potentials were recorded in 76 deeply comatose and unresponsive patients with traumatic or non-traumatic cerebral damage. Spontaneous EEG activity was absent in 37 of the patients on the initial examination. The cortical somatosensory evoked potentials were invariably absent in these patients as were the visual evoked potentials. Brain-stem evoked potentials were abnormal, either lacking all waves or with only wave I or II present. Cerebral angiography performed in 33 of the patients within minutes to a few hours after the neurophysiological examination verified an established brain death, showing full intracerebral circulatory arrest in all. Spontaneous EEG activity was initially present in 32 patients on the first examination, 20 of whom had bilaterally abolished cortical somatosensory potentials. Ten of the patients died a few hours after the initial examination, another 10 were followed for 2-3 days and subsequently developed electrocortical silence (ECS). Twelve of the patients with spontaneous EEG activity had preserved cortical somatosensory potentials, either uni- or bilaterally. The only two who survived were found in this group. In the patients followed with multiple recordings over a few days, the first parameter to indicate a grave prognosis was always disappearance of the cortical somatosensory potentials bilaterally, which generally occurred hours, and sometimes a day or two, before cessation of the spontaneous EEG activity. EEG records from 7 patients did not meet the technical criteria of ECS; all, however, had abolished cortical somatosensory potentials bilaterally, and none in this group survived.

Short-latency somatosensory evoked potentials in brain-dead patients

Ten adult brain-dead patients were evaluated for the presence of clearly defined median nerve short-latency somatosensory evoked potentials (SSEPs). All met clinical criteria recommended by the President's Commission report (1981), had positive apnea tests, and had electrocerebral silent EEGs. P13-P14 and N20 were absent in all scalp-scalp channels, although 3 patients showed P13-P14 in scalp-non-cephalic channels. Of 6 patients showing N13, 3 lacked P13-P14. Our data suggest a characteristic destruction of N20 and rostral P13-P14 generators, with variable rostral-caudal loss of lower generators. SSEPs can provide valuable information about brain-stem activity in the evaluation of suspected brain-dead patients.

Unexpected myogenic contaminants observed in the somatosensory evoked potentials recorded in one brain-dead patient

Visual, brain-stem auditory and somatosensory evoked potentials (EPs) have been recorded in a 53-year-old woman who fulfilled all criteria of brain death. We observed the persistence of 48 msec latency somatosensory activities. Their muscular, and not neural, origin was, however, suggested by their disappearance after curarization. The practical consequences of this observation are two-fold. On the one hand, more precautions must be taken before reaching the conclusion that central neural activities can be obtained in coma dépassé patients. On the other, it suggests a possible test to enhance the sensitivity of EPs in diagnosing brain death.

Somatosensory evoked potentials in comatose patients: correlation with outcome and neuropathological findings

Subcortical and early cortical somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) were recorded in 63 comatose patients and classified into five salient SEP grades, which were defined as follows: grade 1, normal SEP; grade 2, SEPs with a clearly recognizable scalp component N20, normal central conduction time but clearly distorted wave N20-P25; grade 3, SEPs with a still recognizable N20 but delayed central conduction time and severely altered wave N20-P25; grade 4, SEPs with absence of N20 but with a more or less recognizable P15; grade 5, SEPs with absence of both N20 and P15. When these five patterns were compared with outcome, it was found that bilaterally normal SEPs or only unilaterally distorted SEPs were generally followed by good outcomes. Bilaterally altered SEPs (grade 2 or 3) were indicative of reduced chances of full recovery. The great majority of patients showing either grade 4 or 5 SEPs died within a few days after the recording session. In 31 patients, it was found post mortem that grade-2 SEPs reflected cortical brain damage, whereas grade-3 SEPs correlated well with subcortical lesions. In post-traumatic patients, this SEP pattern corresponded to diffuse subcortical shearing lesions. Patients with grade 4 or 5 SEPs were found to have severe brain oedema giving rise to transtentorial herniation, which was combined with secondary midbrain haemorrhage and tonsillar herniation in all patients with bilateral grade-5 SEPs.

The use of evoked potentials in the management of patients with severe cerebral trauma

Evoked potentials (SEP and BAEP) were measured daily in 18 patients who had suffered severe craniocerebral trauma, but could not be examined neurologically due to a barbiturate coma or neuromuscular blockade. The BAEP had only limited value as an indicator of the prognosis for these patients. The N20 component of the SEP appeared to be more valuable in this respect. Serial registration of the EPs was also of prognostic significance and proved to play an important role in the decision to stop or continue the barbiturate coma. In some patients serial measurement of the EPs also gave an indication of the presence of late posttraumatic intracranial mass lesions. EPs are useful for the monitoring of cerebral functions in patients who have suffered a contusion of the brain and can no longer be assessed clinically.

Prognostic and neurophysiological implications of concurrent burst suppression and alpha patterns in the EEG of post-anoxic coma

Concurrent burst suppression and alpha pattern coma developed in the EEG of a 2-year-old child who suffered a cardiac arrest secondary to hypoxemia from Haemophilus influenza epiglottis. The neurophysiological implications of this association are discussed and the literature pertaining to the role of barbiturates in the production of post-anoxic coma with an alpha pattern and experimental post-resuscitative alpha frequencies is reviewed.