Comparing routine versus selective use of intraoperative cerebral angiography in aneurysm surgery: a prospective study

Intraoperative angiography during neurosurgical procedures on patients in prone, three-quarters prone, and park-bench positions: tertiary single-center experience with systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

There is limited evidence about the role and effectiveness of intraoperative angiography (IOA) during neurosurgical procedures with patients in prone, three-quarters prone, and park-bench positions.

OBJECTIVE

To carry out a systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature to evaluate the safety and efficacy of IOA during neurosurgical procedures.

METHODS

We reviewed (between January 1960 and July 2022) all studies in which IOAs were performed during neurosurgical procedures with patients in either prone, three-quarters prone, or park-bench positions. Additionally, a cohort of patients from our institutional experience was included. Efficacy outcomes were the rate of successful angiography and the rate of surgical adjustment/revision after IOA. Safety outcomes were the rate of angiography-related complications and mortality. Data were analyzed using a random-effects meta-analysis of proportions, and statistical heterogeneity was assessed.

RESULTS

A total of 26 studies with 142 patients plus 32 subjects from our institution were included in the analysis. The rate of successful intraoperative angiography was 98% (95% CI 94% to 99%; I²=0%). The rate of surgical adjustment/revision was 18% (95% CI 12% to 28%; I²=0%). The rate of complications related to the angiography was 1% (95% CI 0% to 5%; I²=0%). There were no deaths associated with IOA.

CONCLUSION

We found that IOA performed with patients in prone, three-quarters prone, and park-bench positions is feasible and safe with a non-negligible rate of intraoperative post-angiographical surgical adjustment/revision. Our findings suggest that the performance of IOA to complement vascular neurosurgical procedures might have a valuable role in favoring patient outcomes.

Transradial Versus Transfemoral Intraoperative Cerebral Angiography for Open Cerebrovascular Surgery: Effectiveness, Safety, and Learning Curve

BACKGROUND

Intraoperative cerebral angiography (IOA) is a valuable adjunct in open and hybrid cerebrovascular surgery. Commonly, transfemoral access (TFA) is used. Lately, transradial access (TRA) has gained popularity for neurointervention. However, the TRA has not yet been compared with the TFA for IOA.

OBJECTIVE

To compare the effectiveness and safety of the TRA and TFA for IOA. In addition, the learning curve for implementing the TRA for IOA was evaluated.

METHODS

Between July 2020 and 2022, 92/1787 diagnostic cerebral angiographies met inclusion criteria for IOA. Sheath run time to primary target vessel run time (STT), amount of contrast dye (CD), fluoroscopy time (FT), and dose-area products (DAPs) were compared between TRA and TFA, different aortic arch types, and both study years.

RESULTS

One case required transitioning from TRA to TFA (1/26, 3.8%) because of a minute proximal radial vasculature. The STT, CD, FT, and DAP were similar for the TRA (n = 25) and the TFA groups (n = 67) (p = ns). One groin hematoma (1.5%) was observed in the TFA group. No other complications or any change in modified Rankin Scale were observed. Aortic arch type II/III was associated with longer STT ( P = .032) but not CD, FT, or DAP. There was a nonsignificant decline of STTs among the TRA cases ( P = .104) but stable STTs among TFA cases ( P = .775).

CONCLUSION

The TRA and TFA represent equally effective and safe routes for IOA. In addition, expertise with the TRA can rapidly be gained and facilitates tailoring the access for IOA to patient's individual anatomy and surgeon's needs.

Intraoperative Angiogram Using C-Arm Fluoroscopy and Direct Common Carotid Artery Puncture During Surgical Treatment of Paraclinoid Aneurysms

BACKGROUND

Intraoperative angiography (IOA) has been shown to be a useful adjunct in surgical treatment of cerebral aneurysms. However, its use can be limited by hybrid operating room availability. On the other hand, the use of C-arm fluoroscopy can add challenges to IOA during navigation of the aortic arch and selection of the great vessels. We aimed to describe a simple method of IOA that can be applied during surgery of paraclinoid aneurysms and can be performed in a normal operating room without the need to navigate the aortic arch.

METHODS

In patients undergoing surgery for paraclinoid aneurysms with need for cervical carotid artery exposure, IOA was performed using a single plane C-arm fluoroscopy unit after direct puncture of the carotid artery.

RESULTS

Five patients were included: 2 with subarachnoid hemorrhage, 2 with unruptured aneurysm and history of subarachnoid hemorrhage, and 1 with unruptured aneurysm. There were 2 internal carotid blister aneurysms, 2 ophthalmic artery aneurysms, and 1 superior hypophyseal artery aneurysm. IOA was performed using direct carotid puncture through the neck incision required for proximal control. In all cases, intraoperative images were of sufficient quality to determine the completeness of aneurysm occlusion as well as parent and branching vessel patency. There were no postoperative infarctions and no complications related to IOA.

CONCLUSIONS

IOA using direct carotid puncture can be performed in a standard operating room with the use of a C-arm, eliminating the need to catheterize the great vessels of the aortic arch.

Early postoperative MRI and detection of residual adenoma after transsphenoidal pituitary surgery

OBJECTIVE

Current practice guidelines recommend delayed (≥ 3 months after operation) postoperative MRI after transsphenoidal surgery for pituitary adenomas, although this practice defers obtaining important information, such as the presence of a residual adenoma, that might influence patient management during the perioperative period. In this study, the authors compared detection of residual adenomas by means of early postoperative (EPO) MRI (< 48 hours postsurgery) with both surgeon intraoperative assessment and late postoperative (LPO) MRI at 3 months.

METHODS

Adult patients who underwent microscopic transsphenoidal surgery for pituitary adenomas with MRI preoperatively, < 48 hours after the operation, 3 months postoperatively, and yearly for 4 years were included. The presence or absence of residual tumor was assessed intraoperatively by a single surgeon and postoperatively by 2 neuroradiologists blinded to the intraoperative assessment and other postoperative imaging studies. The presence of residual tumor was confirmed by reresection, tumor growth on imaging, or hormonal evidence. Interreader reliability was calculated at each imaging time point. Specificity, sensitivity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value for EPO and LPO imaging and intraoperative assessment were determined.

RESULTS

In total, 102 consecutive patients who underwent microscopic transsphenoidal resection of a pituitary adenoma were included. Eighteen patients (18%) had confirmed residual tumors (12 confirmed by tumor growth, 5 by surgery, and 1 by biochemical evidence of persistent disease). Interreader reliability for detecting residual tumor on EPO MRI was almost perfect (κ = 0.88) and significantly higher than that for LPO MRI (κ = 0.69, p = 0.03). EPO MRI was highly specific for residual tumor (98%), a finding similar to that for intraoperative assessment (99%, p = 0.60) and significantly higher than that for LPO MRI (81%, p < 0.001). Notably, EPO MRI was significantly more sensitive for residual tumor (100%) than both intraoperative assessment (78%, p = 0.04) and LPO MRI (78%, p = 0.04). EPO MRI had a 100% negative predictive value and was used to find 4 residual tumors that were not identified intraoperatively. Residual tumors found on EPO MRI allowed for reresection during the same hospitalization for 3 patients.

CONCLUSIONS

EPO MRI after transsphenoidal pituitary surgery can be reliably interpreted and has greater sensitivity for detecting residual tumor than intraoperative assessment and LPO MRI. This result challenges current guidelines stating that delayed postoperative imaging is preferable to early imaging. Pituitary surgeons should consider performing EPO MRI either in addition to or instead of delayed imaging.

Comparison of Intra- and Postoperative 3-Dimensional Digital Subtraction Angiography in Evaluation of the Surgical Result After Intracranial Aneurysm Treatment

BACKGROUND

Postoperative three-dimensional digital subtraction angiography (3D-DSA) is the gold standard in evaluating intracranial aneurysm (IA) remnants after clipping. Should intraoperative 3D-DSA image quality be equally good as postoperative 3D-DSA, it could supplant the latter as standard of care for follow-up of clipped IA.

OBJECTIVE

To directly compare the quality of assessment of clipped IA by intraoperative and postoperative 3D-DSA.

METHODS

From a prospective cohort of 221 consecutive patients who underwent craniotomy for IA treatment in a hybrid operating room, we retrospectively studied 26 patients who had both intraoperative and postoperative 3D-DSA imaging of their clipped aneurysm. Comparison of intraoperative and postoperative 3D-DSA images (blinded for review) included parameters that affected image quality and differences between the 2 periods.

RESULTS

In the 26 patients with 32 clipped IAs, the mean interval was 11 ± 7 mo between intraoperative and postoperative imaging 3D-DSA examinations. Reconstruction with multiple clips was used in 14 (44%) cases. Of 15 remnants, 9 (60%) were small (<2 mm). In comparing intraoperative and postoperative 3D-DSA, no discordance or discrepancy in assessment of the surgical result was noted for any clipped IA, and overall imaging quality was excellent for both modalities. Factors affecting minor differences in image quality were not identified.

CONCLUSION

Compared with postoperative 3D-DSA, intraoperative 3D-DSA images achieved equally high quality and effective, immediate interpretation of the surgical clipping result. With comparable imaging quality and no discordant findings, intraoperative 3D-DSA could replace postoperative 3D-DSA to become the standard of care in IA surgery.

Intraoperative 3-Dimensional Rotational Angiography in Cerebrovascular Surgery: A Case Series

OBJECTIVE

Intraoperative imaging is critical in cerebrovascular surgery to assess the technical success of the operation. This case series aimed to evaluate the safety and efficacy of 3-dimensional rotational angiogram (3D-RA) in addition to 2-dimensional intraoperative angiography (2D-IOA) during cerebrovascular surgery in the hybrid operating room.

METHODS

All consecutive patients who underwent open cerebrovascular surgery and intraoperative 2D-IOA with 3D-RA in a hybrid operating room at 2 academic centers between August 2018 and December 2019 were identified from a prospectively maintained institutional database. Medical charts and operative videos including intraoperative angiography were reviewed, and clinical and angiographic outcomes assessed.

RESULTS

A total of 40 cerebrovascular surgeries in 39 patients (mean age, 53 ± 13 years; 51% female) were carried out with the addition of 3D-RA to 2D-IOA in the hybrid operating room. After 3D-RA in addition to 2D-IOA, 1 (2.5%) surgical alteration occurred in an aneurysm clipping. Other procedures were not altered with the addition of 3D-RA to 2D-IOA. There were no complications from the addition of 3D-RA to 2D-IOA.

CONCLUSIONS

Using a combination of 3D-RA and 2D-IOA in the hybrid operating room may enhance the likelihood of achieving an optimal result when employing microsurgical cerebrovascular surgery and avoid unanticipated incomplete outcomes, complications, and returns to the operating room. Whereas the addition of 3D-RA elucidated residual aneurysm not otherwise visualized on the 2D-IOA, in other cerebrovascular procedures studied, there was no additional value of the 3D-RA over the 2D-IOA.

Transradial intraoperative cerebral angiography: a multicenter case series and technical report

BACKGROUND

Use of the radial artery as an access site for neurointerventional procedures is gaining popularity after several studies in interventional cardiology have demonstrated superior patient safety, decreased length of stay, and patient preference compared with femoral artery access. The transradial approach has yet to be characterized for intraoperative cerebral angiography.

OBJECTIVE

To report a multicenter experience on the use of radial artery access in intraoperative cerebral angiography, including case series and discussion of technical nuances.

METHODS

27 patients underwent attempted transradial cerebral angiography betweenMay 2017 and May 2019. Data were collected regarding technique, patient positioning, vessels selected, technical success rate, and access site complications.

RESULTS

24 of the 27 patients (88.8%) underwent successful transradial intraoperative cerebral angiography. 18 patients (66.7%) were positioned supine, 6 patients (22.2%) were positioned prone, 1 patient (3.7%) was positioned lateral, and 2 patients (7.4%) were positioned three-quarters prone. A total of 31 vessels were selected including 13 right carotid arteries (8 common, 1 external, 4 internal), 11 left carotid arteries (9 common and 2 internal), and 6 vertebral arteries (5 right and 1 left). Two patients (7.4%) required conversion to femoral access in order to complete the intraoperative angiogram (1 due to arterial vasospasm and 1 due to inadvertent venous catheterization). One procedure (3.7%) was aborted because of inability to obtain the appropriate fluoroscopic views due to patient positioning. No patient experienced stroke, arterial dissection, or access site complication.

CONCLUSIONS

Transradial intraoperative cerebral angiography is safe and feasible with potential for improved operating room workflow ergonomics, faster patient mobility in the postoperative period, and reduced costs.

Comparison of 3D intraoperative digital subtraction angiography and intraoperative indocyanine green video angiography during intracranial aneurysm surgery

OBJECTIVE

During the last decade, improvements in real-time, high-resolution imaging of surgically exposed cerebral vasculature have been realized with the successful introduction of intraoperative indocyanine green video angiography (ICGVA) and technical advances in intraoperative digital subtraction angiography (DSA). With the availability of 3D intraoperative DSA (3D-iDSA) in hybrid operating rooms, the present study offers a contemporary comparison for rates of accuracy and discordance.

METHODS

In this retrospective study of prospectively collected data, 140 consecutive patients underwent microsurgical treatment of intracranial aneurysms (IAs) in a hybrid operating room. Variables analyzed included patient demographics, aneurysm-specific characteristics, intraoperative ICGVA and 3D-iDSA findings, and the need for intraoperative clip readjustment. The authors defined the discordance rate of the two modalities as a false-negative finding that necessitated clip repositioning after 3D-iDSA.

RESULTS

In 120 patients, ICGVA and 3D-iDSA were used to evaluate 134 IA obliterations. Of 215 clips used, 29 (14%) were repositioned intraoperatively, improving the surgical result in all 29 patients (24%). Repositioning was prompted by visual inspection and microvascular Doppler ultrasonography in 8 (28%), ICGVA in 13 (45%), and 3D-iDSA in 7 (24%) patients. Clip repositioning was needed in 7 patients (6%) based on 3D-iDSA, yielding an ICGVA accuracy rate of 94%. Five (71%) of the ICGVA-3D-iDSA discordances that prompted clip repositioning occurred at the anterior communicating artery complex.

CONCLUSIONS

A combination of vascular monitoring techniques most often achieved correct intraoperative interpretation of complete IA occlusion and parent artery integrity. Compared with 3D-iDSA imaging, ICGVA demonstrated high accuracy. Despite the relatively low discordance rate, iDSA was confirmed to be the gold standard. Improved imaging quality, including 3D-iDSA, supports its routine use in IA surgery, obviating the need for postoperative DSA.

Evaluation of Surgical Resection Goal and Its Relationship to Extent of Resection and Patient Outcomes in a Multicenter Prospective Study of Patients With Surgically Treated, Nonfunctioning Pituitary Adenomas: A Case Series

BACKGROUND

The influence of the surgeon's preoperative goal regarding the extent of tumor resection on patient outcomes has not been carefully studied among patients with nonfunctioning pituitary adenomas.

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the relationship between surgical tumor removal goal and patient outcomes in a prospective multicenter study.

METHODS

Centrally adjudicated extent of tumor resection (gross total resection [GTR] and subtotal resection [STR]) data were analyzed using standard univariate and multivariable analyses.

RESULTS

GTR was accomplished in 148 of 171 (86.5%) patients with planned GTR and 32 of 50 (64.0%) patients with planned STR (P = .001). Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value of GTR goal were 82.2, 43.9, 86.5, and 36.0%, respectively. Knosp grade 0-2, first surgery, and being an experienced surgeon were associated with surgeons choosing GTR as the goal (P &lt; .01). There was no association between surgical goal and presence of pituitary deficiency at 6 mo (P = .31). Tumor Knosp grade (P = .004) and size (P = .001) were stronger predictors of GTR than was surgical goal (P = .014). The most common site of residual tumor was the cavernous sinus (29 of 41 patients; 70.1%).

CONCLUSION

This is the first pituitary surgery study to examine surgical goal regarding extent of tumor resection and associated patient outcomes. Surgical goal is a poor predictor of actual tumor resection. A more aggressive surgical goal does not correlate with pituitary gland dysfunction. A better understanding of the ability of surgeons to meet their expectations and of the factors associated with surgical result should improve prognostication and preoperative counseling.

Microsurgical Clipping of a Giant Middle Cerebral Artery Aneurysm with Successful Postoperative Endovascular Mechanical Thrombectomy for Emergent Treatment of Large Vessel Occlusion

BACKGROUND

Giant intracranial aneurysms (>25 mm) are uncommon. These lesions typically manifest clinically due to mass effect, acute hemorrhage, or thromboembolic events. To minimize the risk of poor clinical outcome, detailed operative planning and a consideration of all neurosurgical and endovascular techniques are essential before proceeding with microsurgical clipping of ruptured giant aneurysms.

CASE DESCRIPTION

We describe a case involving a 15-year-old male with a ruptured giant middle cerebral artery aneurysm treated with microsurgical clipping. After clip application, poor distal flow was demonstrated intraoperatively, and emergent angiography demonstrated an M1 occlusion with thrombus. A salvage procedure using endovascular mechanical thrombectomy reestablished distal flow resulting in a good neurologic outcome.

CONCLUSIONS

To our knowledge, this is the first case report to describe microsurgical clipping of an aneurysm followed by successful postoperative endovascular mechanical thrombectomy.

A Critical Analysis of the Utility of Intraoperative Angiography

OBJECTIVE

Intraoperative digital subtraction angiography (ioDSA) is touted as the gold standard imaging evaluation for aneurysm clip constructs. Candid evaluations of its limitations are sparse.

METHODS

A prospectively collected hospital billing database was queried to identify craniotomies for aneurysm clipping from January 2010 to December 2013. We evaluated the rate of occult residual and parent vessel stenosis determined on follow-up angiography for patients undergoing ioDSA and those not undergoing ioDSA. Comparisons were performed via Fisher exact test, with P < 0.05 considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

From our database search, we found 187 patients who underwent ioDSA after aneurysm clipping and an additional 91 patients who did not. Results from ioDSA influenced operative management in 17% of cases. Sixty-four patients with 70 treated aneurysms undergoing ioDSA had postoperative angiography; 7 occult residuals were discovered, yielding a 10% false-negative rate, with 10% of aneurysms showing residual. Occult residuals at the middle cerebral artery bifurcation represented most discovered residuals (6/7). Thirty-two patients with 37 treated aneurysms did not undergo ioDSA and had angiographic follow-up; 24% of patients were found to have residual aneurysms (P = 0.08 compared with patients undergoing ioDSA). Residuals at the anterior communicating artery (ACoA) represented 56% of all residuals, whereas the ACoA represented only 18% of aneurysms clipped. The rate of residuals was significantly higher than that for patients with clipped ACoA aneurysms undergoing ioDSA (P = 0.008).

CONCLUSIONS

ioDSA influenced management in nearly one fifth of cases. It can be particularly beneficial in detecting residuals for ACoA aneurysms; its benefit was less apparent for middle cerebral artery aneurysms.