Traumatic compression fractures in thoracic-lumbar junction: vertebroplasty vs conservative management in a prospective controlled trial

Surgical Versus Non-Surgical Treatment for Thoracolumbar Burst Fractures Without Neurological Deficit: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

STUDY DESIGN

A systematic review and meta-analysis.

OBJECTIVE

To update the systematic review comparing the outcomes between surgical and non-surgical treatment for thoracolumbar burst fractures without neurological deficit.

METHODS

We registered a protocol in PROSPERO (ID: CRD42021291769) and searched Medline, Embase, Web of Science, and Google Scholar databases. Surgical and non-surgical treatments were compared in patients with thoracolumbar burst fractures without neurological deficits. Predefined outcomes at ≥6 months included pain (defined as a visual analog scale [VAS] of 0-100), functional outcomes (Oswestry Disability Index [ODI] of 0-50 and Roland-Morris Disability Questionnaire [RMDQ] of 0-24), and kyphotic angulation.

RESULTS

Nineteen studies involving 1056 patients were included in the analyses. For outcomes at ≥6 months, little to no difference was found in pain VAS score (mean difference, .95 [95% confidence interval {CI}, -6.02 to 7.92]; 827 participants; 15 studies; I2 = 92%), ODI (mean difference, -1.40 [95% CI, -5.11 to 2.31]; 446 participants; 7 studies; I2 = 79%), and RMDQ (mean difference, -.73 [95% CI, -5.13 to 3.66]; 216 participants; 5 studies; I2 = 77%). The kyphotic angulation in the surgery group was 6.35° lower than that in the non-surgery group (mean difference, -6.56° [95% CI, -10.26° to -2.87°]; 527 participants; ten studies; I2 = 86%). The trial sequential analysis indicated all outcomes reached adequate statistical power. The certainty of the evidence for all 4 outcomes was very low. For the analysis of minimally invasive procedures compared to traditional open surgeries, a statistically significant subgroup difference was found for VAS and ODI (P < .01 and P < .04, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Surgical and non-surgical treatments showed little or no difference in outcomes at ≥6 months. This review provides a conclusion with adequate statistical power by including non-randomized studies. However, non-randomized studies also lowered the certainty of the evidence to a very low level.

Prediction of subsequent vertebral compression fractures after thoracolumbar kyphoplasty: a multicenter retrospective analysis

OBJECTIVE

Second fractures at the cemented vertebrae (SFCV) are often seen after percutaneous kyphoplasty, especially at the thoracolumbar junction. Our study aimed to develop and validate a preoperative clinical prediction model for predicting SFCV.

METHODS

A cohort of 224 patients with single-level thoracolumbar osteoporotic vertebral fractures (T11-L2) from 3 medical centers was analyzed between January 2017 and June 2020 to derive a preoperative clinical prediction model for SFCV. Backward-stepwise selection was used to select preoperative predictors. We assigned a score to each selected variable and developed the SFCV scoring system. Internal validation and calibration were conducted for the SFCV score.

RESULTS

Among the 224 patients included, 58 had postoperative SFCV (25.9%). The following preoperative measures on multivariable analysis were summarized in the 5-point SFCV score: bone mineral density (≤-3.05), serum 25-hydroxy vitamin D3 (≤17.55 ng/mL), standardized signal intensity of fractured vertebra on T1-weighted images (≤59.52%), C7-S1 sagittal vertical axis (≥3.25 cm), and intravertebral cleft. Internal validation showed a corrected area under the curve of 0.794. A cutoff of ≤1 point was chosen to classify a low risk of SFCV, for which only 6 of 100 patients (6%) had SFCV. A cutoff of ≥4 points was chosen to classify a high risk of SFCV, for which 28 of 41 (68.3%) had SFCV.

CONCLUSION

The SFCV score was found to be a simple preoperative method for identification of patients at low and high risk of postoperative SFCV. This model could be applied to individual patients and aid in the decision-making before percutaneous kyphoplasty.

Failure of Conservatively Managed Traumatic Vertebral Compression Fractures: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Most vertebral compression fractures (VCFs) are successfully managed conservatively, however, some patients fail conservative management and require further surgical treatment. Here, we identify significant variables that contribute to progressive vertebral collapse in non-operative treatment of traumatic VCFs.

METHODS

A systematic review using PRISMA guidelines identified original research articles of conservatively managed VCF secondary to trauma from inception to September 2021. Articles with patients treated with initial non-operative therapy, AO-Type A0/A1/A2 fractures, risk factor analysis, >10 patients, and vertebral fracture secondary to trauma were included. Articles including pediatric patients, burst fractures or AO-Type A3/A4 fractures, vertebral fractures secondary to neoplasm or infectious disease, and operative versus non-operative treatment comparative studies were excluded. Failure of non-operative treatment was defined as salvage surgery/vertebral augmentation, progressive kyphosis, chronic pain, or functional disability.

RESULTS

3,877 articles were identified, and six articles were included. 582 patients had conservatively managed thoracolumbar VCFs. 102 patients had reported treatment failure (17.5%). Of the 102 treatment failures, 37 (36.3%) were due to subsequent VCF, 33 (32.4%) to back pain or functional disability at follow-up, and 32 (31.4%) were to increased compression rate or kyphotic deformity at follow-up. Two of the six studies (33.3%) demonstrated prior VCF as a significant variable. Age, lumbar bone mineral density, segmental Cobb angle, and vertebral height loss were each described as a significant factor in one of the six studies (16.7%).

CONCLUSION

Identifying patients who are at risk for treatment failure may help select individuals that would benefit from close clinical follow-up or early surgical/procedural intervention.