Comparison of the utility of multiple breath inert gas washout parameters in cystic fibrosis

Correlation of computed tomography findings and lung function in children and adolescents with cystic fibrosis

BACKGROUND

The timely and appropriate monitoring of pulmonary status is of utmost importance for patients with cystic fibrosis (CF). Computed tomography (CT) has been used in clinical and research settings for tracking lung involvement in CF patients. However, as CT delivers a considerable amount of radiation, its sequential use in CF patients remains a concern. The application of CT, therefore, should take into account its potential risks. This review aims to understand whether and to what extent the CT findings correlate with the findings from other monitoring tools in CF lung disease.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed was searched for articles about the correlation of chest CT findings with spirometric indices and with lung clearance index in children and adolescents with CF. The most relevant articles were reviewed and are presented herein.

RESULTS

Most studies have shown that forced expiratory volume in the first second (FEV₁) and other spirometric indices correlate moderately with CT structural lung damage. However, at the individual level, there were patients with FEV₁ within the normal range and abnormal CT and vice versa. Furthermore, longitudinal studies have indicated that the deterioration of structural lung damage does not occur in parallel with the progression of lung function. Lung clearance index is a better predictor of CT findings.

CONCLUSIONS

In general, the existing studies do not support the use of lung function tests as surrogates of chest CT.

Clinical and lung function outcomes in a cohort of children with severe asthma

BACKGROUND

Uncontrolled severe asthma in children is burdensome and challenging to manage. This study aims to describe outcomes in children with uncontrolled severe asthma managed in a nurse-led severe asthma clinic (SAC).

METHODS

This retrospective analysis uses data collected from children referred by a paediatric respiratory specialist to a nurse-led SAC for uncontrolled severe asthma between 2014 and 2019. The pre-clinical assessments included a home visit to assess modifiable factors that could be addressed to improve control. A comprehensive lung function analysis was conducted at each visit. Interventions were personalised and included biologic agents. Statistical analysis was performed using nonparametric, two-tailed Mann-Whitney U-test, the parametric Student's t-test, or analysis of variance (ANOVA) as appropriate.

RESULTS

Twenty-three children with a median age of 12 years were seen once, and 16 were followed up. Compared to a non-asthmatic (NA) and asthmatic (A) age-matched cohort, children with severe asthma (SA) had a lower FEV1, and FVC% predicted before and after bronchodilator inhalation, and a higher mean Lung Clearance Index [LCI] (10.5 [SA] versus 7.3 [NA] versus 7.6 [A], p = 0.003). Almost 80% of children with SA had an abnormal LCI, and 48% had a reduced FEV1% at the first SAC visit. Asthma control and FEV1% predicted significantly improved at a follow-up visit, while LCI remained abnormal in the majority of children (83%).

CONCLUSION

Over time, many children with severe asthma showed improved clinical outcomes and lung function while lung ventilation inhomogeneities persisted. Future appropriately controlled studies are required to determine if a nurse-led multidisciplinary SAC is associated with better outcomes.

Applications of lung clearance index in monitoring children with cystic fibrosis

A sensitive, reproducible and feasible measure of lung function for monitoring the respiratory health is a prerequisite for the optimization of management of the patients with cystic fibrosis (CF). Spirometry has been considered the method of choice, although it is applicable only in children older than 6 years of age, as good cooperation is necessary for its proper performance. However, over the last 15 years, scientific interest in gas dilution techniques and particularly in multiple breath wash out (MBW) method has been revived. The most commonly reported index of MBW is lung clearance index (LCI). The aim of this review is to present the most recent developments in the application of LCI as a monitoring index of respiratory status of CF patients. LCI is a sensitive and reproducible marker of ventilation inhomogeneity. It is more sensitive than spirometry and, unlike spirometry; it can be performed across the whole pediatric age range. Since it is dependent on body size, until at least the age of 6 years, the relative and not the absolute changes are more appropriate for providing clinically meaningful conclusion on ventilation inhomogeneity. Until now, MBW has been mainly used as a research tool. Based on the currently available data LCI cannot safely predict high-resolution computed tomography findings in children with CF, especially in infants. It can be used as an end-point measure for the assessment of beneficial effect of interventions. However, its utility as an outcome measure for the efficacy of therapeutic interventions seems to be dependent on the pathophysiologic mechanisms that underlie each intervention. It seems that more studies, especially longitudinal ones, are required in order to fully clarify the clinical usefulness of LCI, not only in the research setting, but also in every day practice of CF clinic.

Variability of monthly nitrogen multiple-breath washout during one year in children with cystic fibrosis

BACKGROUND

Knowledge of between-session variability of nitrogen multiple-breath washout (N₂MBW) indices is crucial when designing longitudinal interventional studies and in disease monitoring using N₂MBW as end-point. Such information is currently sparse.

METHODS

Monthly triplets of N₂MBW were prospectively obtained from 14 children with CF during one year. Linear mixed models were used to analyze variability. Our aim was to assess between-session variability of N₂MBW indices from repeated measurements and compare LCI derived from different software packages currently in use (TestPoint® vs. Spiroware®).

RESULTS

Baseline LCI (median; range) was 9.37 (6.82; 12.08). Between-session differences in LCI measurements were up to 25%. Intra Class Correlation-Coefficient was 0.82. There was no systematic difference between LCI measurements derived from the two software packages (p=0.18); however, variability was significantly higher using Spiroware®.

CONCLUSIONS

We report between-session variability of LCI using N₂MBW in school-age children and adolescents with CF. LCI changes exceeding 25% may be considered clinically relevant. TestPoint® and Spiroware® can be used interchangeably in longitudinal studies.

Characterizing Lung Disease in Cystic Fibrosis with Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Airway Physiology

Translational investigations in cystic fibrosis (CF) have a need for improved quantitative and longitudinal measures of disease status. To establish a non-invasive quantitative MRI technique to monitor lung health in patients with CF and correlate MR metrics with airway physiology as measured by multiple breath washout (MBW). Data were collected in 12 CF patients and 12 healthy controls. Regional (central and peripheral lung) measures of fractional lung water density (FLD: air to 100% fluid) were acquired both at FRC and TLC on a 1.5T MRI. The median FLD (mFLD) and the FRC-to-TLC mFLD ratio were calculated for each region at both lung volumes. Spirometry and MBW data were also acquired for each subject. Ventilation inhomogeneities were quantified by the lung clearance index (LCI) and by indices S_cond* and S_acin* that assess inhomogeneities in the conducting (central) and acinar (peripheral) lung regions, respectively. MBW indices and mFLD at TLC (both regions) were significantly elevated in CF (p<0.01) compared to controls. The mFLD at TLC (central: R = 0.82) and the FRC-to-TLC mFLD ratio (peripheral: R = -0.77) were strongly correlated with S_cond* and LCI. CF patients had high lung water content at TLC when compared to controls. This is likely due to the presence of retained airway secretions and airway wall edema (more water) and to limited expansions of air trapping areas (less air) in CF subjects. FRC-to-TLC ratios of mFLD strongly correlated with central ventilation inhomogeneities. These combined measures may provide a useful marker of both retained mucus and air trapping in CF lungs.

Transfer factor, lung volumes, resistance and ventilation distribution in healthy adults

Monitoring of chronic lung disease requires reference values of lung function indices, including putative markers of small airway function, spanning a wide age range.We measured spirometry, transfer factor of the lung for carbon monoxide (TLCO), static lung volume, resistance and ventilation distribution in a healthy population, studying at least 20 subjects per sex and per decade between the ages of 20 and 80 years.With respect to the Global Lung Function Initiative reference data, our subjects had average z-scores for forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV1), forced vital capacity (FVC) and FEV1/FVC of -0.12, 0.04 and -0.32, respectively. Reference equations were obtained which could account for a potential dependence of index variability on age and height. This was done for (but not limited to) indices that are pertinent to asthma and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease studies: forced expired volume in 6 s, forced expiratory flow, TLCO, specific airway conductance, residual volume (RV)/total lung capacity (TLC), and ventilation heterogeneity in acinar and conductive lung zones.Deterioration in acinar ventilation heterogeneity and lung clearance index with age were more marked beyond 60 years, and conductive ventilation heterogeneity showed the greatest increase in variability with age. The most clinically relevant deviation from published reference values concerned RV/TLC values, which were considerably smaller than American Thoracic Society/European Respiratory Society-endorsed reference values.

Progressive ventilation inhomogeneity in infants with cystic fibrosis after pulmonary infection

Measures of ventilation distribution are promising for monitoring early lung disease in cystic fibrosis (CF). This study describes the cross-sectional and longitudinal impacts of pulmonary inflammation and infection on ventilation homogeneity in infants with CF.Infants diagnosed with CF underwent multiple breath washout (MBW) testing and bronchoalveolar lavage at three time points during the first 2 years of life.Measures were obtained for 108 infants on 156 occasions. Infants with a significant pulmonary infection at the time of MBW showed increases in lung clearance index (LCI) of 0.400 units (95% CI 0.150-0.648; p=0.002). The impact was long lasting, with previous pulmonary infection leading to increased ventilation inhomogeneity over time compared to those who remained free of infection (p<0.05). Infection with Haemophilus influenzae was particularly detrimental to the longitudinal lung function in young children with CF where LCI was increased by 1.069 units for each year of life (95% CI 0.484-1.612; p<0.001).Pulmonary infection during the first year of life is detrimental to later lung function. Therefore, strategies aimed at prevention, surveillance and eradication of pulmonary pathogens are paramount to preserve lung function in infants with CF.

Comparison of lung clearance index measured during helium washin and washout in children with cystic fibrosis

AIM

Lung clearance index (LCI) is a sensitive marker of early lung disease in cystic fibrosis (CF). This preliminary study compares results obtained from the washin and the washout phase of the multiple breath washout in CF children and healthy controls using an early commercially available device.

METHODS

LCI was measured using a device measuring flow and mainstream molar mass with helium as the inert gas. Sixty-five healthy controls and 65 CF children (age range 4.6-17.9 years) were included.

RESULTS

LCI measured on the washout (LCIWO ) and on the washin (LCIWI ) were correlated in CF children (R = 0.440, P < 0.001, n = 185). LCIWO was higher than LCIWI with a mean difference of 1.08 (95% limits of agreement -2.11 to 4.27, n = 185) in CF children and 0.26 (95% LA -3.2 to 3.72, n = 185) in controls. Within-test repeatability criteria were met in 107/130 WO and 93/130 WI (P = 0.034), In 81 children, LCIWI and LCIWO were obtained. LCIWI was higher in CF patients than in controls (7.72 vs. 6.55, P < 0.001), as was LCIWO (8.49 vs. 7.13, P < 0.001). In 34 CF patients with normal FEV1 , LCIWI only was abnormal in five, LCIWO only in five and both were abnormal in three. One of seven CF patients with abnormal FEV1 had normal LCIWI and LCIWO .

CONCLUSION

In CF patients, discordances between abnormal LCIWI and LCIWO were observed. LCIWI and LCIWO were only weakly correlated. This likely resulted from technical factors as the use of mainstream molar mass signal, a temperature model validated for infants only and absence of CO2 correction.

Relationships between the lung clearance index and conductive and acinar ventilation heterogeneity

The lung clearance index (LCI) derived from a multiple breath washout test has regained considerable popularity in recent years, alternatively being promoted as an early detection tool or a marker of small airways function. In this study, we systematically investigated the link between LCI and indexes of acinar and conductive airways ventilation heterogeneity (Sacin, Scond) to assess potential contributions from both lung zones. Relationships were examined in 55 normal subjects after provocation, where only Scond is known to be markedly increased, and in 55 asthma patients after bronchodilation, in whom both Scond and Sacin ranged between normal and abnormal. LCI was correlated to Scond in both groups (R = 0.37-0.43; P < 0.01 for both); in the asthma group, LCI was also tightly correlated to Sacin (R = 0.70; P < 0.001). Potential mechanisms operational at various levels of the bronchial tree were identified by considering washout curvilinearity in addition to LCI to distinguish specific ventilation and dead space effects (also illustrated by simple 2-compartment model simulations). Although the asthma data clearly demonstrate that LCI can reflect very peripheral ventilation heterogeneities, the normal provocation data also convincingly show that LCI increases may be the exclusive result of far more proximal ventilation heterogeneities. Because LCI potentially includes heterogeneities at all length scales, it is suggested that ventilation imaging in combination with LCI measurement at the mouth could identify the scale of relevant ventilation heterogeneities. In the meantime, interpretations of LCI results in the clinic based on washout curves collected at the mouth should be handled with caution.

Lung clearance index: clinical and research applications in children

Multiple breath washout (MBW) has been demonstrated to be sensitive for assessing ventilation inhomogeneity (VI). VI is supposed to reflect changes in peripheral airways which are not apparent using spirometry. The lung clearance index (LCI) is the most robust parameter to quantify VI, and is largely independent of age; therefore, it potentially qualifies as a surrogate outcome parameter for clinical and research purposes, particularly during childhood. This review summarizes the current evidence regarding the clinical value of measuring LCI in children. Feasibility, reproducibility and diagnostic accuracy have been demonstrated; available data confirm that LCI is superior to spirometry in detecting small air way disease. However, there is little information regarding the value in the individual patient, and sparse longitudinal data looking at its prognostic value. Currently, only in patients with Cystic Fibrosis, it appears likely that knowledge of LCI will be useful for routine clinical management.