Comparison of nucleolar organiser regions and DNA flow cytometry in the evaluation of pleural effusion

Are we ready to develop a tiered scheme for the effusion cytology? A comprehensive review and analysis of the literature

BACKGROUND

Cytology is widely utilized in the initial evaluation of fluid accumulation in the body cavities. The aim of this study was to determine the accuracy of cytology in distinguishing between benign and malignant (MAL) effusions.

METHODS

A comprehensive and systematic review of the literature was conducted to evaluate the accuracy of serous effusion cytology (SEC) against tissue biopsy/resection histology, imaging, or clinical follow-up as the reference test. Risk of publication bias and level of heterogeneity in the included studies was assessed. Meta-regression was performed to assess the effect of various variables on the accuracy of SEC.

RESULTS

Eighty studies met the inclusion criteria for meta-analysis comprising of 34 941 samples; of which 52 (0.2%), 22 202 (72.7%), 194 (0.6%), 711 (2.3%), and 6507 (21.3%) could be reclassified as nondiagnostic (ND), negative for malignancy (NFM), atypical (atypia of uncertain significance-AUS), suspicious for malignancy (SFM), and malignant (MAL), respectively. On follow-up, the mean risk of malignancy for ND, NFM, AUS, SFM, MAL was 17.4%, 20.7%, 65.9%, 81.8%, and 98.9%, respectively. A total of 73 studies were included in estimating the diagnostic accuracy of SEC. The bivariate mixed-effect model estimated the SEC sensitivity, specificity, diagnostic odds ratio, positive likelihood ratio, and negative likelihood ratio as 73.1%, 99.9%, 7850.6%, 2112.2%, and 0.27%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Serous effusion cytology shows high specificity and moderate sensitivity in the evaluation of serous effusions. A tiered classification scheme can improve the consistency of terminology for reporting SEC results, thus improving communication between the pathologists and clinical team, and quality of patient care.

Silver-stained nucleolar organizer regions in normal and dysplastic cervical lesions: correlation with DNA ploidy and S-phase fraction by flow cytometry

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the prognostic significance of DNA ploidy and silver-stained nucleolar organizer regions (AgNOR), their relation to the cytological grades of cervical dysplasia and correlation of cells in the S-phase of the cell cycle and DNA ploidy with AgNOR count.

METHODS

Multiparametric DNA flow-cytometric analysis and AgNOR count were performed on cervical smear samples, cytologically diagnosed as normal (n = 196), atypical squamous cells of unknown significance (ASCUS, n = 98) and various grades of cervical dysplasia (n = 127).

RESULTS

Among the cytological grade, aneuploid cases from low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (mild) and high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesion (moderate and severe) groups were showing high AgNOR counts (ranges 4.33-5.86 and 5.91-7.42, respectively). Aneuploid cases from the ASCUS group also presented high AgNOR (range 3.72-4.93). The high percentage of cells in the S-phase (>12%) correlated with these 2 parameters in the ASCUS and dysplasia groups. After grouping the cases into those with high (>4.0) and low (<4.0) AgNOR counts, significant correlations in the group with high AgNOR count with DNA ploidy, S-phase and cytological grade were recorded (p < 0.001). Results obtained from follow-up study revealed that cases with aneuploidy, high AgNOR count and S-phase fraction presented with a progressive trend of disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Thus, the study shows that high AgNOR count, S-phase fraction and aneuploid DNA have prognostic significance in the early detection of cervical cancer.

Heparanase expression: a potential ancillary diagnostic tool for distinguishing between malignant cells and reactive mesothelium in body cavity effusions

OBJECTIVE

Heparanase, an endoglycosidase that cleaves heparan sulphate, is frequently expressed in carcinomas and was suggested to play a role in cell invasion and metastasis. We investigated whether heparanase expression may serve as a reliable marker to discriminate benign mesothelial cells from malignant cells shed into body cavities.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Cytological smears of effusions from 51 hospitalized patients were immunostained for heparanase. Strong immunoreactivity was noted in 35 of 40 (88%) carcinoma samples and in all three malignant mesothelioma cases. Only rare (<3%) reactive mesothelial cells were noted showing a faint negligible staining. Specificity was 100%, sensitivity 88%, and positive and negative predictive values were 100% and 89% respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that heparanase may be of value as a complementary component in a diagnostic panel of markers, contributing to its reliability and accuracy.

Diagnostic value of a second generation CA 15-3 antibody to detect adenocarcinoma in body cavity effusions

BACKGROUND

Detecting malignant cells in body cavity effusions can be diagnostically challenging. Several monoclonal antibodies have been studied to improve the diagnostic yield of effusion cytology but without widespread acceptance. The CA 15-3 antibody has demonstrated high sensitivity but limited specificity for breast carcinoma in surgical pathology. A second generation CA 15-3 antibody has been developed that has not been studied in serous effusions to the authors' knowledge. The authors examined this second generation CA 15-3 antibody for its diagnostic utility in detecting adenocarcinomas in this cytologic setting.

METHODS

Cell block material from 114 cases of unequivocally benign or malignant body cavity effusions were studied. Slides were stained for CA 15-3 by using the avidin-biotin complex method. The percentage of cells exhibiting strong staining was estimated both for breast carcinoma and for all adenocarcinomas as a group. These results were compared with CA 15-3 staining exhibited by benign mesothelium.

RESULTS

CA 15-3 was expressed in at least 10% of tumor cells in 97% of breast carcinoma cases and in 90% of adenocarcinomas overall. The highest sensitivity was observed in carcinomas of the breast, ovary, and lung. Of 40 cases of benign mesothelium, only 4 (10%) were positive (P < 0.001). The sensitivity of CA 15-3 was 97% for breast carcinoma and 91% for adenocarcinomas overall. Specificity was 95% for breast carcinoma and 91% for adenocarcinomas.

CONCLUSIONS

CA 15-3 is an immunostain with high specificity and sensitivity for adenocarcinomas in cell block material from effusions. The antibody holds particular promise for detecting breast carcinoma. Cancer (Cancer Cytopathol)

Image analysis and flow cytometric DNA studies of benign and malignant body cavity fluids: reappraisal of the role of current methods in the differential diagnosis of reactive versus malignant conditions

Cytologic examination of body fluids is commonly performed in the clinical laboratory. Determination of the presence of malignancy may sometimes be difficult. In this study, we prospectively studied 60 body fluids with a panel of antibodies, including MOC-31, epithelial membrane antigen, carcinoembryonic antigen, B72.3, keratin, desmin, and CA-125. DNA and S-phase studies were performed both by flow cytometry and image analysis. Thirty-seven fluids were classified as benign and 23 were classified as malignant. The sensitivity of the antibodies for identification of carcinoma in descending order of percentage detection rate were MOC-31 (95%), epithelial membrane antigen (93%), B72.3 (84%), and carcinoembryonic antigen (80%). Desmin stained mesothelial cells in all cases. CA-125 gave similar results but was less specific. Flow cytometry detected 14 of 20 malignant fluids and image analysis 17 of 23 by identifying an aneuploid population. Benign reactive mesothelial cells were not aneuploid. Tetraploidy due to reactive mesothelial cells was found in 9 of 37 body fluids. Their S-phase fraction was low (average, 3.2%). Tetraploidy in malignant cells was distinguished from the reactive mesothelial cells by high S-phase (average, 25.95). S-phase had some use as a discriminating factor, because no benign reactive cases had more than 17%. However, 7 of 23 malignant cases had a value below 17%. DNA analysis by image was more sensitive and specific than flow. Either may be used when immunocytochemistry is nondiagnostic or cannot be performed.

FHIT protein is expressed in benign mesothelium and has no clinical value in detecting carcinoma in body cavity effusions

The fragile histidine triad (FHIT) protein is a suspected tumor-suppressor gene frequently expressed in adenocarcinomas of the lung and other organs. Its expression in benign mesothelium has not been reported. This study examined the expression of FHIT in mesothelium from benign body cavity effusions. FHIT expression was also examined in a diversity of malignant effusions to evaluate any value of the FHIT protein to discriminate carcinomas from benign mesothelium. Fifty-eight cases of benign and malignant effusions were immunostained using cell block material and two different antigen retrieval methods with the ABC method. Benign and malignant cases were scored for percentage of cells with strong immunoreactivity. Benign mesothelium exhibited strong immunoreactivity for the FHIT protein in 32 of 32 (100%) cases, with 26 of 32 (81%) cases having expression in at least 50% of cells. Seventeen of 21 (81%) cases of adenocarcinomas also exhibited the FHIT protein in at least 50% of tumor cells. FHIT expression was also noted in small numbers of other malignancies. The FHIT protein is expressed consistently in benign mesothelium as well as many types of adenocarcinomas. Immunostaining for this protein has no value in discriminating adenocarcinomas from reactive mesothelium.

Relation between natural killer cells and neoplastic cells in serous fluids

Natural killer (NK) cells are capable of lysing certain tumor cells in vitro. We investigated whether the percentage of NK cells (NK%) in serous effusions has any relation with the presence of malignant cells. Fresh effusions were routinely processed, and a portion of them was submitted for lymphocyte immunophenotyping, using a flow cytometer. Fifty-one fluids (15 peritoneal, 36 pleural), from 47 patients were analyzed. Thirty-two cases were negative and 19 were positive for neoplastic cells: there were 13 adenocarcinomas, 2 malignant mesotheliomas (MM), 3 malignant lymphomas (ML), and 1 rhabdomyosarcoma (R). Negative cases showed an average NK% of 5.09% (1-16%). Effusions positive for adenocarcinoma had an average NK% of 22.08% (12-33%) (P < 0.001). MM, ML, and R had a low NK%, with an average of 3.01% (0-5%). Investigation of the NK% could be useful in cytologically doubtful cases and in the differential diagnosis between MM and adenocarcinoma.

Clinical value of DNA image cytometry in effusions with atypia

Malignant cells in serosal effusions provide essential information about the extent of malignant disease. The main aim of this study was to examine the additional diagnostic value of DNA image cytometry for cases with uncertainty in the cytological diagnosis. In addition, the feasibility of automated nuclei detection was investigated. Out of 457 cases, 33 samples in 32 patients were diagnosed with "atypia" (probably benign) and 21 as "suspicious for malignancy." DNA image cytometry was performed on these 54 cases and on an additional group of 14 cytologically malignant cases. The results show that automatic classification is useful for separation of control cells, i.e., lymphocytes and neutrophilic granulocytes from other mononuclear cells. In 21 cases an insufficient number of control cells were measured. Seventy-two percent of the cytologic malignant cases were aneuploid. In contrast, in none of the cases with "atypia" and in only 2 of the cases "suspicious for malignancy" was aneuploidy present (2 of the remaining 32, 6%). From the cases with follow-up, a malignancy in the pleural fluid was present in 2 out of 17 cases with "atypia" and in 5 out of 10 with a "suspicious for malignancy" cytologic diagnosis, respectively. In conclusion, the additional diagnostic value of DNA image cytometry in cases with a cytological diagnosis of "atypia" or "suspicious for malignancy" is limited. Diagn. Cytopathol. 1999;21:112-116.

Usefulness of argyrophilic nucleolar organizer regions score to differentiate suspicious malignancy in pulmonary cytology

OBJECTIVE

Pulmonary cytologic specimens reported as "suspicious for malignancy" pose problems in clinical management. Silver staining for argyrophilic nucleolar organizer regions (AgNOR) has proved useful in making a cytopathologically differential diagnosis between benign and malignant cells. This study aimed to evaluate the usefulness of AgNOR score in the diagnosis of pulmonary cytologic specimens deemed inconclusive by conventional staining methods.

METHODS

Pulmonary cytologic specimens initially reported as suspicious for malignancy with Papanicolaou or May-Grünwald-Giemsa (MGG) staining obtained from 35 proved cases were destained then restained using the AgNOR technique. Another 35 cases with clear cytologic diagnosis were also examined for comparison. The median number of dots, defined as the AgNOR score, was used to differentiate malignant from benign specimens.

RESULTS

Malignant cases had significantly higher AgNOR scores than benign ones (p<0.001). There were no significant differences among smears previously stained with Papanicolaou or MGG method, among specimens obtained via bronchoscopic brushing, fine-needle aspiration of lung or pleural effusion, or among subgroups of malignant diseases. Based on the results of our previous study, the cutoff value of the AgNOR score to differentiate benignancy from malignancy was set at 6. At this setting, the sensitivity and specificity of AgNOR score were 88% and 80%, respectively, in aiding a differential diagnosis of pulmonary cytologic specimens initially classified as suspicious for malignancy. For those cases with a clear cytologic diagnosis, the sensitivity and specificity of AgNOR score were 92% and 100%, respectively. For all cases, the sensitivity of AgNOR score was 90% and the specificity was also 90%.

CONCLUSIONS

The AgNOR score is of value in aiding a differential diagnosis between benign and malignant lesions in pulmonary specimens with equivocal cytologic features.

DNA ploidy, S-phase, and Ki-67 antigen expression in the evaluation of cell content of pleural effusions

Cells from pleural effusions (28 malignant and 14 nonmalignant with reactive mesothelial cells) were examined in parallel by means of conventional cytology and multiparametric flow cytometry. The latter included the evaluation of DNA ploidy, the calculation of DNA index (DI), the determination of S phase fraction (SPF), and cell proliferation associated with Ki-67 antigen expression. Propidium iodide was used for the DNA staining, and fluorescein-conjugated monoclonal mouse antibodies were applied to the human Ki-67 antigen staining. The specimens were analyzed by the Becton Dickinson (BD) FACScan apparatus. 10(4) events were collected, and thereafter the obtained data were analyzed by the software Lysis II and CellFit (BD) for DNA and Ki-67 data analysis, respectively. Out of the 28 cases examined, 18 (64%) of the malignant effusions were aneuploid. All of the benign effusions were typically diploid. The average SPF of benign, malignant diploid, and malignant aneuploid cases was 6, 6, and 30 respectively. The comparison between SPF and DI in malignant cases showed a significant correlation (p < 0.001). The average of Ki-67-positive cells that were benign, malignant diploid, and malignant aneuploid were 11, 19, and 35, respectively. There was a significant correlation between Ki-67 expression, SPF (p < 0.05), and the percent of the aneuploid cell population (p = 0.01). The sensitivity of conventional cytology, the determination of DNA ploidy and of Ki-67 expression, was 80, 64, and 92%, respectively; specificity was 100% for cytology and DNA ploidy and 46% for Ki-67 expression. These data show that Ki-67 antigen expression is a potentially useful adjunct to cytometric DNA content analysis, determination of SPF, and conventional cytology in the diagnosis of malignant pleural effusions.