Does analysis of bronchoalveolar lavage fluid provide a tool to monitor disease progression or to predict survival in patients with HIV-1 infection?

Research bronchoscopies do not adversely affect HIV-infected individuals' future health-care decisions

STUDY OBJECTIVES

Asymptomatic HIV-infected individuals are increasingly recruited for studies involving invasive procedures such as bronchoscopy. We sought to determine the response to and outcome of a request for a research bronchoscopy in HIV-positive individuals with no respiratory disease, and whether this would adversely affect future decisions to have a medically indicated bronchoscopy.

DESIGN AND SETTING

Prospective, semistructured, questionnaire-based study in a London teaching hospital HIV outpatient clinic.

PARTICIPANTS

One hundred and seven consecutive HIV-infected eligible individuals. Thirty-one healthy volunteers served as a control group for the subjective response to bronchoscopy.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Subjects' attitudes and responses to requests for bronchoscopy and subsequent behavior when they required medically indicated bronchoscopy.

RESULTS

Seventy-five patients (70%) agreed to the procedure in principle, predominantly for altruistic reasons. Thirty-nine subjects underwent bronchoscopy. Five percent found it worse than expected; and 79% agreed to another research bronchoscopy (performed in 11 subjects approximately 2 years later). All patients said they would undergo bronchoscopy again for diagnostic purposes (required in seven during the study). When compared to a healthy volunteer population within the same study, postbronchoscopy symptoms were similar in frequency although somewhat different in nature. Subjects felt that a clear explanation of what was involved enhanced their participation in this research.

CONCLUSIONS

Invasive research procedures such as bronchoscopy can be performed and are repeatable in a healthy HIV-infected population. Performance of procedures for research purposes does not appear to adversely affect future health-care decisions.

Functionally relevant changes occur in HIV-infected individuals' alveolar macrophages prior to the onset of respiratory disease

OBJECTIVE

We have compared the phenotypic and functional changes found in alveolar macrophages recovered from the lungs of 39 HIV-positive individuals with no respiratory disease with those from 33 HIV-positive individuals with pneumonitis and 31 healthy controls.

METHODS

Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) cell cytospin preparations were stained using monoclonal antibody immunoperoxidase and double immunofluorescence techniques. Cytokine levels within supernatant BAL were determined using enzyme immunoassay.

RESULTS

There were marked differences in alveolar macrophage phenotype between the three groups. In particular, the relative proportion of cells staining RFD1+RFD7- (inducer cells) was reduced in the HIV-positive individuals without respiratory disease. This was correlated with measures of declining systemic immunity. Patients with pneumonitis had the highest levels of measured cytokines [interleukin-1 beta, tumour necrosis factor-alpha and transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta 2], followed by the HIV-positive individuals without respiratory disease. In this latter population a negative correlation was found between active (non acid dissociated) TGF-beta 2 and blood CD4 cell count.

CONCLUSIONS

The differences between the three groups suggest that alterations of potential relevance to the pulmonary immune response are occurring in alveolar macrophages prior to the onset of respiratory disease. This study confirms the importance of investigating asymptomatic HIV-positive individuals.

Immunologic effects of HIV in the lung

This article covers a selected group of topics dealing with the contribution of lung immunocompetent cells in the host defense mechanisms against HIV. These include recent findings suggesting that bidirectional signals between alveolar macrophages and pulmonary cytotoxic T lymphocytes define regulatory networks, which contribute to the accumulation of HIV-specific effector cells in the lung microenvironment. The authors also emphasize the cell pattern of HIV infection in the lung, highlighting the role of the retrovirus in weakening pulmonary host defenses and its spreading into the lower respiratory tract.

[Quality and selection of samples of bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) in diffuse pneumopathies]

Bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) samples used to study immune or inflammatory response in interstitial lung disease must be representative of the lower respiratory tract. Thus, the selection of suitable samples must be part of routine practice. To assess the incidence of unsuitable BAL samples used for cytology and to determine the relation between parameters related to underlying disease and the quality of samples. One hundred sixty-one patients were enrolled. Seventy-two were HIV positive and had diffuse pulmonary infiltrates, 34 had idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF), 10 had sarcoidosis, 10 had hypersensitivity pneumonitis, 19 had interstitial lung disease and collagen diseases and 2 had pulmonary eosinophilia. Fourteen individuals formed the control group. The quality study was carried out by staining the BAL samples following a modified Wright-Giemsa technique and evaluating the samples by the selection criteria described by Chamberlain and colleagues (1987). We identified unsuitable samples from 53% of the HIV positive patients, from 35% of the IPF patients and from 21% of the interstitial lung disease patients with associated connective tissue disease. In the other groups, all samples were suitable for analysis. Intolerance of BAL with decreasing percentage of fluid recovered was significantly associated with sample quality, particularly in the IPF group. The cytology results that invalidated the samples differed by group. In all groups, unsuitable specimens had low cell counts. The finding or not of evidence of associated infection in HIV-infected patients, on the other hand, did not appear to determine sample quality in and of itself, although it did in samples related to other entities. We can predict that a high rate of unsuitable BAL samples will come mainly from patients with diffuse lung disease associated to HIV infection, IPF and interstitial lung disease with associated connective tissue disease. Tolerance to the technique influences quality of the specimen obtained and, therefore, should be taken into account in interpreting the findings of cytology. The criteria applied by the various teams using BAL should be unified, and it should be determined whether the exclusion of inappropriate samples affects the final composition of study groups.

[A comparison of lymphocyte populations of the blood and bronchoalveolar lavage in AIDS patients]

Changes in cell immunity made manifest by decreases in blood levels of CD4 T cells is the main indicator of progressing HIV infection. The decrease in these lymphocytes, as well as in the CD4/CD8 index and increases in suppressant or cytotoxic CD8 cells can be detected in bronchoalveolar (BAL) lung samples. It is not clear whether the high incidence of respiratory system diseases in HIV patients stems from local or systemic immune changes. The aim of this study was to compare changes in the systemic cell immunity studied in samples of peripheral blood with changes detected in BAL samples from HIV patients with acute respiratory disease. We studied 42 patients in the advanced stages of AIDS (C3 by Centers for Disease Control classification) who were hospitalized for acute respiratory disease and who underwent diagnostic fiberoptic bronchoscopy and BAL. Cell counts and lymphocyte populations were analyzed by flow cytometry in samples of peripheral blood and BAL. The percentage of CD4 lymphocytes and the CD4/CD8 index were lower in BAL, particularly in patients with blood CD4 levels below 12% of the total T cell population, or at a level of 20 CD4 cells/microliters. Changes in cell immunity in patients with advanced HIV infection (C3 classification) and acute respiratory disease are more manifest locally in the lung than peripherally in blood. Lung depletion of CD4 T cells in the lung can be predicted based on blood levels.

Lung lymphocytes: origin, biological functions, and laboratory techniques for their study in immune-mediated pulmonary disorders

Different types of immunocompetent cells, including T lymphocytes and alveolar macrophages, account for pulmonary host defense. Taking advantage of the availability of the monoclonal antibody technique, cell culture facilities, pure recombinant cytokines, and molecular probes for their genes, in the last few years it has been possible to keenly study the different steps that lead to the compartmentalization of immune response in human lung. Furthermore, the immunological analysis of cells retrieved from bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) allowed recognition of the importance of immune mechanisms in the evolution of immune-mediated pulmonary disorders. The purpose of this review is to summarize recent advances on the immunologic characterization of lung lymphocytes in health and disease. Following a brief description of the pathways through which the pulmonary lymphoid system contributes to removing potentially harmful inhaled antigenic materials, available laboratory techniques to evaluate the lymphoid component of the pulmonary immune system and their byproducts are discussed. These techniques cover methods for preparing lymphocytes from the BAL fluid and for characterizing lung lymphocytes both in cell suspensions and pulmonary tissue biopsies. Other sections of this review describe the techniques for measuring the immunologic effector functions of lung lymphocytes. We also provide the reader with a flavor of the molecular biology methods used to characterize lymphocytes in the pulmonary microenvironment. The final sections of the review article highlight the pathogenetic role envisaged for lymphoid cells in pulmonary disease states and emphasize the importance of the BAL analysis in the clinical management of the most relevant immune-mediated lung disease.

Changes to alveolar macrophage phenotype in HIV infected individuals with normal CD4 counts and no respiratory disease

BACKGROUND

It has previously been shown that HIV infected individuals with pneumonitis have identifiable abnormalities in alveolar macrophages obtained by bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL). In particular, alterations in the expression of alveolar macrophage surface antigens associated with macrophage function have been reported. To determine whether these changes reflect HIV infection or the respiratory episode itself, a population of HIV infected patients with no respiratory disease was studied.

METHODS

Twenty two HIV antibody positive individuals with a peripheral blood CD4 count of > 400/microliters and 10 healthy volunteer controls underwent bronchoscopy and BAL. Cytospin preparations from the recovered cells were stained using immunoperoxidase and double immunofluorescence techniques with monoclonal antibodies RFD1, RFD7, EBM11/CD68 (mature macrophages), UCHM1/CD14 (monocyte marker), and HLA-DR (RFDR1). Differential cell counts were also performed.

RESULTS

There was an increase in overall alveolar macrophage HLA-DR expression in the HIV population. This was not reflected in a change in the percentage of cells staining CD14 (monocytes) or CD68 (mature macrophages) positive. The relative proportions of cells staining RFD1 + RFD7- (inducer cells), RFD1 - RFD7+ (effector cells), and RFD1 + RFD7+ (suppressive cells) were unchanged between HIV and control groups.

CONCLUSIONS

In a population of HIV infected individuals with normal CD4 counts and no respiratory disease there was an increase in overall alveolar macrophage HLA-DR expression which occurred independently of any alteration in the relative proportions of alveolar macrophage subpopulations.