Genome analysis of South American Elymus (Triticeae) and Leymus (Triticeae) species based on variation in repeated nucleotide sequences

The launch of satellite: DNA repeats as a cytogenetic tool in discovering the chromosomal universe of wild Triticeae

Fluorescence in situ hybridization is a powerful tool that enables plant researchers to perform systematic, evolutionary, and population studies of wheat wild relatives as well as to characterize alien introgression into the wheat genome. This retrospective review reflects on progress made in the development of methods for creating new chromosomal markers since the launch of this cytogenetic satellite instrument to the present day. DNA probes based on satellite repeats have been widely used for chromosome analysis, especially for "classical" wheat probes (pSc119.2 and Afa family) and "universal" repeats (45S rDNA, 5S rDNA, and microsatellites). The rapid development of new-generation sequencing and bioinformatical tools, and the application of oligo- and multioligonucleotides has resulted in an explosion in the discovery of new genome- and chromosome-specific chromosome markers. Owing to modern technologies, new chromosomal markers are appearing at an unprecedented velocity. The present review describes the specifics of localization when employing commonly used vs. newly developed probes for chromosomes in J, E, V, St, Y, and P genomes and their diploid and polyploid carriers Agropyron, Dasypyrum, Thinopyrum, Pseudoroegneria, Elymus, Roegneria, and Kengyilia. Particular attention is paid to the specificity of probes, which determines their applicability for the detection of alien introgression to enhance the genetic diversity of wheat through wide hybridization. The information from the reviewed articles is summarized into the TRepeT database, which may be useful for studying the cytogenetics of Triticeae. The review describes the trends in the development of technology used in establishing chromosomal markers that can be used for prediction and foresight in the field of molecular biology and in methods of cytogenetic analysis.

Chromosomal characterization in native populations of Elymus scabrifolius from Argentina through classical and molecular cytogenetics (FISH–GISH)

The karyotype of Elymus scabrifolius (Döll) J.H. Hunz. (2n = 4x = 28) was investigated by DAPI staining and in situ hybridization. All the accessions studied presented a symmetric and uniform karyotype constituted by 9m+2m–sm+3sm. DAPI stain showed 1–7 conspicuous bands in all the chromosomes and polymorphisms between accessions. FISH experiments carried out with 45S rDNA as probe (pTa71) showed strong hybridization signals on the metacentric SAT-chromosome pair 8; the submetacentric SAT-chromosome pair 13 presented weaker hybridization. FISH using pSc119.2 clone as probe identified five chromosome pairs. Then, the combination of chromosome morphology, DAPI-staining, and FISH enabled the accurate identification of each chromosome pair in E. scabrifolius. Genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) experiments using Hordeum DNA as probe on mitotic metaphases confirmed unequivocally the presence of the H genome in E. scabrifolius, allowing us to observe six uniformly labeled chromosome pairs and two chromosome pairs with only one arm labeled. The remaining six chromosome pairs were weakly labeled. The rehybridization of FISH slides with Hordeum DNA as probe allow us to assign the genomic provenance of most of the chromosomes in the studied accessions. Moreover, intergenomic rearrangement was detected between genome H and the still unknown progenitor genome.

Origin of the H genome in StH-genomic Elymus species based on the single-copy nuclear gene DMC1

Previous studies have suggested that the H haplome in Elymus could originate from different diploid Hordeum species, however, which diploid species best represent the parental species remains unanswered. The focus of this study seeks to pinpoint the origin of the H genome in Elymus. Allopolyploid Elymus species that contain the StH genome were analyzed together with diploid Hordeum species and a broad sample of diploid genera in the tribe Triticeae using DMC1 sequences. Both parsimony and maximum likelihood analyses well separated the American Hordeum species, except Hordeum brachyantherum subsp. californicum, from the H genome of polyploid Elymus species. The Elymus H-genomic sequences were formed into different groups. Our data suggested that the American Horedeum species, except H. brachyantherum subsp. californicum, are not the H-genomic donor to the Elymus species. Hordeum brevisubulatum subsp. violaceum was the progenitor species to Elymus virescens, Elymus confusus, Elymus lanceolatus, Elymus wawawaiensis, and Elymus caninus. Furthermore, North American H. brachyantherum subsp. californicum was a progenitor of the H genome to Elymus hystrix and Elymus cordilleranus. The H genomes in Elymus canadensis, Elymus sibiricus, and Elymus multisetus were highly differentiated from the H genome in Hordeum and other Elymus species. The H genome in both North American and Eurasian Elymus species was contributed by different Hordeum species.

Molecular evolution and phylogeny of the RPB2 gene in the genus Hordeum

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

It is known that the miniature inverted-repeat terminal element (MITE) preferentially inserts into low-copy-number sequences or genic regions. Characterization of the second largest subunit of low-copy nuclear RNA polymerase II (RPB2) has indicated that MITE and indels have shaped the homoeologous RPB2 loci in the St and H genome of Eymus species in Triticeae. The aims of this study was to determine if there is MITE in the RPB2 gene in Hordeum genomes, and to compare the gene evolution of RPB2 with other diploid Triticeae species. The sequences were used to reconstruct the phylogeny of the genus Hordeum.

METHODS

RPB2 regions from all diploid species of Hordeum, one tetraploid species (H. brevisubulatum) and ten accessions of diploid Triticeae species were amplified and sequenced. Parsimony analysis of the DNA dataset was performed in order to reveal the phylogeny of Hordeum species.

KEY RESULTS

MITE was detected in the Xu genome. A 27-36 bp indel sequence was found in the I and Xu genome, but deleted in the Xa and some H genome species. Interestingly, the indel length in H genomes corresponds well to their geographical distribution. Phylogenetic analysis of the RPB2 sequences positioned the H and Xa genome in one monophyletic group. The I and Xu genomes are distinctly separated from the H and Xa ones. The RPB2 data also separated all New World H genome species except H. patagonicum ssp. patagonicum from the Old World H genome species.

CONCLUSIONS

MITE and large indels have shaped the RPB2 loci between the Xu and H, I and Xa genomes. The phylogenetic analysis of the RPB2 sequences confirmed the monophyly of Hordeum. The maximum-parsimony analysis demonstrated the four genomes to be subdivided into two groups.

Interspecific polymorphism at non-coding regions of chloroplast, mitochondrial DNA and rRNA IGS region in Elymus species

Several published universal primers for amplification of non-coding regions of chloroplast, mitochondrial and ribosomal (rRNA) IGS region were tested whether they can amplify respective regions in Elymus species. PCR-RFLP analysis of the chloroplast, mitochondral DNA, and rRNA IGS region of the genus Elymus was used to determine if the method could be employed to detect inter-specific variation in this genus. Published universal primers for amplification of trnK [tRNA-Lys (UUU) exon 1]-trnK [tRNA-Lys (UUU) exon2], and mitochondrial nad1 exon B-nadl exon C intron successfully amplified the respective regions in Elymus species. However, the primers for amplification of chloroplast trnD-trnT intron and rRNA IGS failed to amplify the respective region in Elymus species. New primer pairs were designed and successfully amplified the cpDNA trnD-trnT intron and rRNA IGS region in Elymus species. The amplification products were digested with seven restriction enzymes. The results showed that the investigated regions of chloroplast and mitochondrial genomes are variable in most of the tested taxa and contain multiple variable regions. These regions should serve as useful molecular markers in phylogenetic studies of closely related species, at least at the interspecific level in Elymus. It is likely that further studies, including larger sample sizes, more regions of these genomes and/or more powerful methods for the detection of cpDNA and mt DNA variation will reveal additional variation for this genus. Highly inter- and intra-specific polymorphisms for rRNA IGS region were detected, suggesting the IGS will be a useful molecular marker for population studies of Elymus species.

Genetic and genomic relationships in Leymus Hochst

Genetic and genomic relationships among three taxonomically related species of Leymus, northern European L. arenarius (octoploid, 2n = 56), northern American/Pacific L. mollis (tetraploid, 2n = 28) and central Eurasian L. racemosus (tetraploid, 2n = 28), were examined using molecular and cytogenetic methods. The amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP) analysis clearly differentiated Icelandic populations of L. arenarius from Alaskan populations of L. mollis. The former group is more genetically homogeneous than the latter. Leymus arenarius in Iceland has a common gene pool and a relatively recent origin. The Alaskan L. mollis, on the other hand, is probably a glacial survival that has accumulated high level of genetic variation and has differentiated into subspecies. Analysis of the 18S-26S ribosomal genes, by restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), revealed a very close relationship between the octoploid northern European L. arenarius and the tetraploid Eurasian L. racemosus, such that the former could have originated from the latter, probably via interspecific hybridization. Leymus-specific DNA sequences were isolated and used for analyzing genetic relatedness among five Leymus species and four Psathyrostachys species. The RFLP analysis of retrotransposon sequence pLm44 and ribosomal clone pTa71 clearly revealed a close relationship between these two genera, i.e. higher variation was found within genera than between them. The results support the previous notion that Leymus is autopolyploid having all genomes being designated Ns as in Psathyrostachys, but a major taxonomic revision of this group would require analysis of more species.

Karyotypes of Elymus scabrifolius (Poaceae: Triticeae) from South America studied by banding techniques and in situ hybridization

Karyotypes of 4 accessions of Elymus scabrifolius (2n = 4x = 28) were investigated by Giemsa C- and N-banding, GAA-banding (one accession), AgNO3-staining and in situ hybridization with the rDNA probe pTa71. Two additional accessions were studied in less detail. The chromosomes were large (9-14 microns). The complements included 11 pairs of metacentrics, one with conspicuous satellites on the short arms, and 3 pairs of submetacentrics. Two of 4 accessions from Eastern Argentina and Uruguay had minute or small satellites on a submetacentric pair. No such satellites were observed in the other two accessions. In two accessions from the Cordoba province, a non-homologous submetacentric pair had very long satellites. AgNO3-staining established the presence of 4 nucleoli, two larger and two small ones, in 5 accessions. The C-banding patterns comprised from one to 12 conspicuous bands per chromosome at no preferential positions. The amount of constitutive heterochromatin (19-21%) was the highest hitherto established in the Triticeae. Similarities in banding patterns and chromosome morphology identified homologous and discriminated between non-homologous chromosomes within and, except for two chromosomes, between plants. Heteromorphic chromosome pairs were identified in satellite-carrying chromosomes only. N-banding produced conspicuous bands overall at the same positions as C-banding. GAA-banding patterns were similar to N-banding patterns. The rDNA probe hybridized to chromosome segments at nucleolar constrictions only. The production of C- and N-banding patterns in both genomes of E. scabrifolius suggests the presence of two H genomes and the absence of the pivotal St genome of Elymus. On account of the uncertain identity of one genome, and the overall similar gross morphology of E. scabrifolius and other tetraploid South American species referred to Elymus, E. scabrifolius is retained in Elymus.

Genome discrimination by in situ hybridization in Icelandic species of Elymus and Elytrigia (Poaceae: Triticeae)

The genome constitution of Icelandic Elymus caninus, E. alaskanus, and Elytrigia repens was examined by fluorescence in situ hybridization using genomic DNA and selected cloned sequences as probes. Genomic in situ hybridization (GISH) of Hordeum brachyantherum ssp. californicum (diploid, H genome) probe confirmed the presence of an H genome in the two tetraploid Elymus species and identified its presence in the hexaploid Elytrigia repens. The H chromosomes were painted uniformly except for some chromosomes of Elytrigia repens which showed extended unlabelled pericentromeric and subterminal regions. A mixture of genomic DNA from H. marinum ssp. marinum (diploid,Xa genome) and H. murinum ssp. leporinum (tetraploid,Xu genome) did not hybridize to chromosomes of the Elymus species or Elytrigia repens, confirming that these genomes were different from the H genome. The St genomic probe from Pseudoroegneria spicata (diploid) did not discriminate between the genomes of the Elymus species, whereas it produced dispersed and spotty hybridization signals most likely on the two St genomes of Elytrigia repens. Chromosomes of the two genera Elymus and Elytrigia showed different patterns of hybridization with clones pTa71 and pAes41, while clones pTa1 and pSc119.2 hybridized only to Elytrigia chromosomes. Based on FISH with these genomic and cloned probes, the two Elymus species are genomically similar, but they are evidently different from Elytrigia repens. Therefore the genomes of Icelandic Elymus caninus and E. alaskanus remain as StH, whereas the genomes of Elytrigia repens are proposed as XXH.Key words: Elymus, Elytrigia, H genome, St genome, in situ hybridization.

Genomic and genetic relationships among species of Leymus (Poaceae: Triticeae) inferred from 18S-26S ribosomal genes

The 18S-26S ribosomal genes in three closely related species of Leymus (Poaceae: Triticeae) were examined using fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) and restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP). Both approaches revealed a close relationship between L. arenarius (8x = 56, northern European) and L. racemosus (4x = 28, central Eurasian), whereas L. mollis (4x = 28, northern American/Pacific) was distinct. Each species had three homologous pairs of major rDNA loci: a1, a2, and a3 for L. arenarius; m1, m2, and m3 for L. mollis; and r1, r2, and r3 for L. racemosus. Leymus arenarius had in addition three minor loci, a4, a5, and a6. The major loci of L. arenarius and L. racemosus were identical, indicating that the former species could have originated from the latter, via interspecific hybridization and/or polyploidy. The rDNA-RFLPs further indicated relationships of these species to other species of Leymus (L. karellini, 8x = 56 and L. angustus, 12x = 84) and Psathyrostachys (P. fragilis, P. huashanica, P. juncea, and P. lanuginosa, which are all diploids). A phenogram constructed from 20 BamHI, EcoRI, and DraI rDNA fragments revealed closer relationship between the two genera, Leymus and Psathyrostachys, than that among species within a genus.

Genome-specific repetitive DNA and RAPD markers for genome identification in Elymus and Hordelymus

We have developed RFLP and RAPD markers specific for the genomes involved in the evolution of Elymus species, i.e., the St, Y, H, P, and W genomes. Two P genome specific repetitive DNA sequences, pAgc1 (350 bp) and pAgc30 (458 bp), and three W genome specific sequences, pAuv3 (221 bp), pAuv7 (200 bp), and pAuv13 (207 bp), were isolated from the genomes of Agropyron cristatum and Australopyrum velutinum, respectively. Attempts to find Y genome specific sequences were not successful. Primary-structure analysis demonstrated that pAgc1 (P genome) and pAgc30 (P genome) share 81% similarity over a 227-bp stretch. The three W genome specific sequences were also highly homologous. Sequence comparison analysis revealed no homology to sequences in the EMBL- GenBank databases. Three to four genome-specific RAPD markers were found for each of the five genomes. Genome-specific bands were cloned and demonstrated to be mainly low-copy sequences present in various Triticeae species. The RFLP and RAPD markers obtained, together with the previously described H and St genome specific clones pHch2 and pPlTaq2.5 and the Ns genome specific RAPD markers were used to investigate the genomic composition of a few Elymus species and Hordelymus europaeus, whose genome formulas were unknown. Our results demonstrate that only three of eight Elymus species examined (the tetraploid species Elymus grandis and the hexaploid speciesElymus caesifolius and Elymus borianus) really belong to Elymus.