Single-Molecule Investigations of Morphology and Mass Transport Dynamics in Nanostructured Materials

Single-Molecule Fluorescence Investigations of Solute Transport Dynamics in Nanostructured Membrane Separation Materials

Many materials used for membrane separations are composed of nanoscale structures such as pores and domains. Such nanostructures often control the solute permeability and selectivity of the separation membranes. Thus, for future development of highly efficient separation membranes, it is important to understand the structural and chemical properties of these nanostructures and also their influences on solute transport dynamics. For the last two decades, single-molecule fluorescence techniques have been used to measure the detailed dynamics of solute molecules diffusing in various nanostructured materials, giving valuable insights into molecular transport mechanisms influenced by nanoscale material heterogeneity. This Perspective discusses recent single-molecule fluorescence studies on solute diffusion in materials relevant to membrane separations, including dense polymer films and nanoporous materials. These studies have revealed the formation and properties of nanostructures and unique transport dynamics of solute molecules manipulated by their confinement and partitioning to the nanostructures, which play key roles in membrane separations. This Perspective will also point out scientific challenges toward a thorough understanding of molecular-level mechanisms in membrane separations.

Direct Visualization of Nanoconfinement Effect on Nanoreactor via Electrochemiluminescence Microscopy

Nanoconfinement in mesoporous nanoarchitectures could dramatically change molecular transport and reaction kinetics during electrochemical process. A molecular-level understanding of nanoconfinement and mass transport is critical for the applications, but a proper route to study it is lacking. Herein, we develop a single nanoreactor electrochemiluminescence (SNECL) microscopy based on Ru(bpy)₃ ²⁺ -loaded mesoporous silica nanoparticle to directly visualize in situ nanoconfinement-enhanced electrochemical reactions at the single molecule level. Meanwhile, mass transport capability of single nanoreactor, reflected as long decay time and recovery ability, is monitored and simulated with a high spatial resolution. The nanoconfinement effects in our system also enable imaging single proteins on cellular membrane. Our SNECL approach may pave the way to decipher the nanoconfinement effects during electrochemical process, and build bridges between mesoporous nanoarchitectures and potential electrochemical applications.

Solvent-Induced Swelling Behaviors of Microphase-Separated Polystyrene-block-Poly(ethylene oxide) Thin Films Investigated Using In Situ Spectroscopic Ellipsometry and Single-Molecule Fluorescence Microscopy

Block copolymers have attracted considerable interest in the fields of nanoscience and nanotechnology because these polymers afford well-defined nanostructures via self-assembly. An in-depth understanding of solvent effects on the physicochemical properties of these microdomains is crucial for their preparation and utilization. Herein, we employed in situ spectroscopic ellipsometry and single-molecule fluorescence techniques to gain detailed insights into microdomain properties in polystyrene-block-poly(ethylene oxide) (PS-b-PEO) films exposed to ethanol- and water-saturated N₂. We observed a quick increase and a subsequent gradual decrease in the ellipsometric thickness of PS-b-PEO films upon exposure to ethanol-saturated N₂. This observation was unexpected because ethanol-saturated N₂ induced negligible thickness change for PS and PEO homopolymer films. The similarity in maximum thickness gain observed under ethanol- and water-saturated N₂ implied the swelling of PEO microdomains. Ethanol vapor permeation through the PEO microdomains was supported by the redshift of the ensemble and single-molecule fluorescence emission of Nile red in PS-b-PEO films. Single-molecule tracking data showed the initial enhancement and subsequent reduction of the diffusion of hydrophilic sulforhodamine B molecules in PS-b-PEO films upon exposure to ethanol-saturated N₂, consistent with the spectroscopic ellipsometry results. The higher ethanol susceptibility of the PEO microdomains was attributable to their amorphous nature, as shown by FTIR data.

Investigation of Molecular Diffusion at Block Copolymer Thin Films Using Maximum Entropy Method-Based Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy and Single Molecule Tracking

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) has been widely used to investigate molecular diffusion behavior in various samples. The use of the maximum entropy method (MEM) for FCS data analysis provides a unique means to determine multiple distinct diffusion coefficients without a priori assumption of their number. Comparison of the MEM-based FCS method (MEM-FCS) with another method will reveal its utility and advantage as an analytical tool to investigate diffusion dynamics. Herein, we measured diffusion of fluorescent probes doped into nanostructured thin films using MEM-FCS, and validated the results with single molecule tracking (SMT) data. The efficacy of the MEM code employed was first demonstrated by analyzing simulated FCS data for systems incorporating one and two diffusion modes with broadly distributed diffusion coefficients. The MEM analysis accurately afforded the number of distinct diffusion modes and their mean diffusion coefficients. These results contrasted with those obtained by fitting the simulated data to conventional two-component and anomalous diffusion models, which yielded inaccurate estimates of the diffusion coefficients. Subsequently, the MEM analysis was applied to FCS data acquired from hydrophilic dye molecules incorporated into microphase-separated polystyrene-block-poly(ethylene oxide) (PS-b-PEO) thin films characterized under a water-saturated N₂ atmosphere. The MEM analysis revealed distinct fast and slow diffusion components attributable to molecules diffusing on the film surface and inside the film, respectively. SMT studies of the same materials yielded trajectories for mobile molecules that appear to follow the curved PEO microdomains. Diffusion coefficients obtained from the SMT data were consistent with those obtained for the slow diffusion component detected by MEM-FCS. These results highlight the utility of MEM-FCS and SMT for gaining complementary information on molecular diffusion processes in heterogeneous material systems.

The competing influence of surface roughness, hydrophobicity, and electrostatics on protein dynamics on a self-assembled monolayer

Surface morphology, in addition to hydrophobic and electrostatic effects, can alter how proteins interact with solid surfaces. Understanding the heterogeneous dynamics of protein adsorption on surfaces with varying roughness is experimentally challenging. In this work, we use single-molecule fluorescence microscopy to study the adsorption of α-lactalbumin protein on the glass substrate covered with a self-assembled monolayer (SAM) with varying surface concentrations. Two distinct interaction mechanisms are observed: localized adsorption/desorption and continuous-time random walk (CTRW). We investigate the origin of these two populations by simultaneous single-molecule imaging of substrates with both bare glass and SAM-covered regions. SAM-covered areas of substrates are found to promote CTRW, whereas glass surfaces promote localized motion. Contact angle measurements and atomic force microscopy imaging show that increasing SAM concentration results in both increasing hydrophobicity and surface roughness. These properties lead to two opposing effects: increasing hydrophobicity promotes longer protein flights, but increasing surface roughness suppresses protein dynamics resulting in shorter residence times. Our studies suggest that controlling hydrophobicity and roughness, in addition to electrostatics, as independent parameters could provide a means to tune desirable or undesirable protein interactions with surfaces.

Single molecule fluorescence imaging of nanoconfinement in porous materials

This review covers recent progress in using single molecule fluorescence microscopy imaging to understand the nanoconfinement in porous materials. The single molecule approach unveils the static and dynamic heterogeneities from seemingly equal molecules by removing the ensemble averaging effect. Physicochemical processes including mass transport, surface adsorption/desorption, and chemical conversions within the confined space inside porous materials have been studied at nanometer spatial resolution, at the single nanopore level, with millisecond temporal resolution, and under real chemical reaction conditions. Understanding these physicochemical processes provides the ability to quantitatively measure the inhomogeneities of nanoconfinement effects from the confining properties, including morphologies, spatial arrangement, and trapping domains. Prospects and limitations of current single molecule imaging studies on nanoconfinement are also discussed.

Fluorescence Microscopic Investigations of Molecular Dynamics in Self-Assembled Nanostructures

Many analytical methods employ self-assembled nanostructured materials as chemical recognition media. Molecular permeation through these materials exhibits unique selectivity owing to nanoconfinement-induced enhancement of permeant-nanostructure interactions. This Personal Account introduces our efforts to investigate the detailed dynamics of single or a small number of molecules in nanostructured materials. We developed new experimental and analysis approaches built upon laser-based fluorescence microscopy to measure the detailed translational and orientational dynamics of molecules diffusing in horizontally-oriented, cylindrical nanostructures, including surfactant micelles, silica mesopores, block copolymer microdomains, and bolaamphiphile-based organic nanotubes. Our studies clarified nanoscale details on the structural/chemical heterogeneity of the nanostructures, and their impacts on molecular mass transport dynamics.

Transforming Separation Science with Single-Molecule Methods

Empirical optimization of the multiscale parameters underlying chromatographic and membrane separations leads to enormous resource waste and production costs. A bottom-up approach to understand the physical phenomena underlying challenges in separations is possible with single-molecule observations of solute-stationary phase interactions. We outline single-molecule fluorescence techniques that can identify key interactions under ambient conditions. Next, we describe how studying increasingly complex samples heightens the relevance of single-molecule results to industrial applications. Finally, we illustrate how separation methods that have not been studied at the single-molecule scale can be advanced, using chiral chromatography as an example case. We hope new research directions based on a molecular approach to separations will emerge based on the ideas, technologies, and open scientific questions presented in this Perspective.

Single Molecule Investigation of Nanoconfinement Hydrophobicity in Heterogeneous Catalysis

Nanoconfinement imposes physical constraints and chemical effects on reactivity in nanoporous catalyst systems. In the present study, we lay the groundwork for quantitative single-molecule measurements of the effects of chemical environment on heterogeneous catalysis in nanoconfinement. Choosing hydrophobicity as an exemplary chemical environmental factor, we compared a range of essential parameters for an oxidation reaction on platinum nanoparticles (NPs) confined in hydrophilic and hydrophobic nanopores. Single-molecule experimental measurements at the single particle level showed higher catalytic activity, stronger adsorption strength, and higher activation energy in hydrophobic nanopores than those in hydrophilic nanopores. Interestingly, different dissociation kinetic behaviors of the product molecules in the two types of nanopores were deduced from the single-molecule imaging data.

Three-Dimensional Single Particle Tracking and Its Applications in Confined Environments

Single particle tracking (SPT) has proven to be a powerful technique in studying molecular dynamics in complicated systems. We review its recent development, including three-dimensional (3D) SPT and its applications in probing nanostructures and molecule-surface interactions that are important to analytical chemical processes. Several frequently used 3D SPT techniques are introduced. Especially of interest are those based on point spread function engineering, which are simple in instrumentation and can be easily adapted and used in analytical labs. Corresponding data analysis methods are briefly discussed. We present several important case studies, with a focus on probing mass transport and molecule-surface interactions in confined environments. The presented studies demonstrate the great potential of 3D SPT for understanding fundamental phenomena in confined space, which will enable us to predict basic principles involved in chemical recognition, separation, and analysis, and to optimize mass transport and responses by structural design and optimization.

Single-Molecule Imaging of Protein Interactions and Dynamics

Live-cell single-molecule fluorescence imaging has become a powerful analytical tool to investigate cellular processes that are not accessible to conventional biochemical approaches. This has greatly enriched our understanding of the behaviors of single biomolecules in their native environments and their roles in cellular events. Here, we review recent advances in fluorescence-based single-molecule bioimaging of proteins in living cells. We begin with practical considerations of the design of single-molecule fluorescence imaging experiments such as the choice of imaging modalities, fluorescent probes, and labeling methods. We then describe analytical observables from single-molecule data and the associated molecular parameters along with examples of live-cell single-molecule studies. Lastly, we discuss computational algorithms developed for single-molecule data analysis.

Tracking and Analyzing the Brownian Motion of Nano-objects Inside Hollow Core Fibers

Tracking and analyzing the individual diffusion of nanoscale objects such as proteins and viruses is an important methodology in life science. Here, we show a sensor that combines the efficiency of light line illumination with the advantages of fluidic confinement. Tracking of freely diffusing nano-objects inside water-filled hollow core fibers with core diameters of tens of micrometers using elastically scattered light from the core mode allows retrieving information about the Brownian motion and the size of each particle of the investigated ensemble individually using standard tracking algorithms and the mean squared displacement analysis. Specifically, we successfully measure the diameter of every gold nanosphere in an ensemble that consists of several hundreds of 40 nm particles, with an individual precision below 17% (±8 nm). In addition, we confirm the relevance of our approach with respect to bioanalytics by analyzing 70 nm λ-phages. Overall these features, together with the strongly reduced demand for memory space, principally allows us to record thousands of frames and to achieve high frame rates for high precision tracking of nanoscale objects.

Deciphering nanoconfinement effects on molecular orientation and reaction intermediate by single molecule imaging

Nanoconfinement could dramatically change molecular transport and reaction kinetics in heterogeneous catalysis. Here we specifically design a core-shell nanocatalyst with aligned linear nanopores for single-molecule studies of the nanoconfinement effects. The quantitative single-molecule measurements reveal unusual lower adsorption strength and higher catalytic activity on the confined metal reaction centres within the nanoporous structure. More surprisingly, the nanoconfinement effects on enhanced catalytic activity are larger for catalysts with longer and narrower nanopores. Experimental evidences, including molecular orientation, activation energy, and intermediate reactive species, have been gathered to provide a molecular level explanation on how the nanoconfinement effects enhance the catalyst activity, which is essential for the rational design of highly-efficient catalysts.

Diffusion Behavior of Differently Charged Molecules in Self-Assembled Organic Nanotubes Studied Using Imaging Fluorescence Correlation Spectroscopy

The diffusion behavior of fluorescent molecules within bolaamphiphile-based organic nanotubes (ONTs) was systematically investigated using imaging fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (imaging FCS). Anionic sulforhodamine B, zwitterionic/cationic rhodamine B, or cationic rhodamine 123 was loaded into ONTs having cylindrical hollow structures (ca. 10 nm in inner diameter) with amine and glucose groups on the inner and outer surfaces, respectively. Wide-field fluorescence video microscopy was used to acquire imaging FCS data for dye-doped ONTs in aqueous solutions of different ionic strengths (1-500 mM) at different pH (3.4-8.4). The diffusion behavior of these dyes was discussed on the basis of their apparent diffusion coefficients ( D) that were determined by autocorrelating the time transient of fluorescence intensity at each pixel on an ONT. Molecular diffusion in the ONTs was significantly slowed by the molecule-nanotube interactions, as shown by the very small D (10^-1 to 10^-2 μm²/s). The pH dependence of D revealed that dye diffusion was basically controlled by electrostatic interactions associated with the protonation of the amine groups on the ONT inner surface. The pH-dependent change in D was observed over a wide pH range, possibly because of electrostatically induced variations in the p K_a of the densely packed ammonium ions on the ONT inner surface. On the other hand, the influence of ionic strength on D was relatively unclear, suggesting the involvement of non-Coulombic interactions with the ONTs in molecular diffusion. Importantly, individual ONTs of different lengths (1-5 μm) afforded similar diffusion coefficients for each type of dye at each solution condition, implying that the properties of the ONTs were uniform in terms of solute loading and release. These results highlight the characteristics of the molecular diffusion behavior within the ONTs and will help in the design of ONTs better suited for use as drug vehicles and contaminant adsorbents.

Structural and rheological changes of lamellar liquid crystals as a result of compositional changes and added silica nanoparticles

Lamellar liquid crystals comprising oil, water and surfactant(s) were formulated and analysed in order to examine how these materials responded to the inclusion of inorganic nanoparticles, in terms of their structural and rheological characteristics. Lamellar phases were formed from mixtures of water, para-xylene and Triton X-100, and analysis was performed via small-angle neutron scattering (SANS), polarising light microscopy (PLM), and amplitude and viscosity sweeps. The partial replacement of Triton X-100 with oleic acid appeared to cause an increase in bilayer thickness, attributed to less efficient packing of the different molecules. Addition of oleic acid also appeared to cause both a loss in lamellar repeat ordering, attributed to heterogeneity of the bilayers, and a rise in long range order, potentially caused by the stiffer bilayers. Adding silica nanoparticles of different size and surface chemistry caused a stiffening of the samples at the expense of a longer-range lamellar repeat order. This strengthening is attributed to aggregation at the domain boundaries, and it was found that hydrophobic particles tended to form stronger aggregates while for larger particles (20 nm as opposed to 10 nm) aggregation was apparently reversible. These results give a more comprehensive understanding of how to reliably control the structural and rheological properties of lamellar liquid crystals, and emphasise the importance of the size and surface chemistry of any inclusions, for applications in cosmetics, drug delivery, and microfluidics.

Photochemistry and Photophysics in Silica-Based Materials: Ultrafast and Single Molecule Spectroscopy Observation

Silica-based materials (SBMs) are widely used in catalysis, photonics, and drug delivery. Their pores and cavities act as hosts of diverse guests ranging from classical dyes to drugs and quantum dots, allowing changes in the photochemical behavior of the confined guests. The heterogeneity of the guest populations as well as the confinement provided by these hosts affect the behavior of the formed hybrid materials. As a consequence, the observed reaction dynamics becomes significantly different and complex. Studying their photobehavior requires advanced laser-based spectroscopy and microscopy techniques as well as computational methods. Thanks to the development of ultrafast (spectroscopy and imaging) tools, we are witnessing an increasing interest of the scientific community to explore the intimate photobehavior of these composites. Here, we review the recent theoretical and ultrafast experimental studies of their photodynamics and discuss the results in comparison to those in homogeneous media. The discussion of the confined dynamics includes solvation and intra- and intermolecular proton-, electron-, and energy transfer events of the guest within the SBMs. Several examples of applications in photocatalysis, (photo)sensors, photonics, photovoltaics, and drug delivery demonstrate the vast potential of the SBMs in modern science and technology.

Single Particle Tracking: From Theory to Biophysical Applications

After three decades of developments, single particle tracking (SPT) has become a powerful tool to interrogate dynamics in a range of materials including live cells and novel catalytic supports because of its ability to reveal dynamics in the structure-function relationships underlying the heterogeneous nature of such systems. In this review, we summarize the algorithms behind, and practical applications of, SPT. We first cover the theoretical background including particle identification, localization, and trajectory reconstruction. General instrumentation and recent developments to achieve two- and three-dimensional subdiffraction localization and SPT are discussed. We then highlight some applications of SPT to study various biological and synthetic materials systems. Finally, we provide our perspective regarding several directions for future advancements in the theory and application of SPT.

Diffusion of single dye molecules in hydrated TiO2 mesoporous films

Fluorescence correlation spectroscopy (FCS) shows how the pore dimensions of thin and hydrated TiO₂ mesoporous calcined films modulate the diffusion of molecules across the pore network.

Probing Heterogeneity and Bonding at Silica Surfaces through Single-Molecule Investigation of Base-Mediated Linkage Failure

The nature of silica surfaces is relevant to many chemical systems, including heterogeneous catalysis and chromatographies utilizing functionalized-silica stationary phases. Surface linkages must be robust to achieve wide and reliable applicability. However, silyl ether-silica support linkages are known to be susceptible to detachment when exposed to basic conditions. We use single-molecule spectroscopy to examine the rate of surface linkage failure upon exposure to base at a variety of deposition conditions. Kinetic analysis elucidates the role of thermal annealing and addition of blocking layers in increasing stability. Critically, it was found that successful surface modification strategies alter the rate at which base molecules approach the silica surface as opposed to reducing surface linkage reactivity. Our results also demonstrate that the innate structural diversity of the silica surface is likely the cause of observed heterogeneity in surface-linkage disruption kinetics.

Single-Molecule Investigation of Initiation Dynamics of an Organometallic Catalyst

The action of molecular catalysts comprises multiple microscopic kinetic steps whose nature is of central importance in determining catalyst activity and selectivity. Single-molecule microscopy enables the direct examination of these steps, including elucidation of molecule-to-molecule variability. Such molecular diversity is particularly important for the behavior of molecular catalysts supported at surfaces. We present the first combined investigation of the initiation dynamics of an operational palladium cross-coupling catalyst at the bulk and single-molecule levels, including under turnover conditions. Base-initiated kinetics reveal highly heterogeneous behavior indicative of diverse catalyst population. Unexpectedly, this distribution becomes more heterogeneous at increasing base concentration. We model this behavior with a two-step saturation mechanism and identify specific microscopic steps where chemical variability must exist in order to yield observed behavior. Critically, we reveal how structural diversity at a surface translates into heterogeneity in catalyst behavior, while demonstrating how single-molecule experiments can contribute to understanding of molecular catalysts.

Imaging fluorescence correlation spectroscopy studies of dye diffusion in self-assembled organic nanotubes

Imaging fluorescence correlation spectroscopy is used to elucidate the rate and mechanism for diffusion of charged molecules within charged, self-assembled organic nanotubes.

Transport properties of hierarchical micro–mesoporous materials

This work provides an overview of different experimental techniques of diffusion measurements in porous materials and discusses transport properties of several classes of hierarchically organized micro-mesoporous materials.

Fluorescence Recovery after Photobleaching and Single-Molecule Tracking Measurements of Anisotropic Diffusion within Identical Regions of a Cylinder-Forming Diblock Copolymer Film

This work demonstrates ensemble and single-molecule diffusion measurements within identical regions of a cylinder-forming polystyrene-poly(ethylene oxide) diblock copolymer (PS-b-PEO) film using fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) and single-molecule tracking (SMT). A PS-b-PEO film (∼4 μm thick) with aligned cylindrical PEO microdomains containing 10 μM sulforhodamine B (SRB) was prepared by directional solvent-vapor penetration (SVP) of 1,4-dioxane. The ensemble diffusion behavior of SRB in the microdomains was assessed in FRAP studies of circular photobleached regions (∼7 μm in diameter). The SRB concentration was subsequently reduced by additional photobleaching, and the diffusion of individual SRB molecules was explored using SMT in the identical area (∼16 × 16 μm(2)). The FRAP data showed anisotropic fluorescence recovery, yielding the average microdomain orientation. The extent of fluorescence recovery observed (∼90%) demonstrated long-range microdomain connectivity, while the recovery time dependence provided an ensemble measurement of the SRB diffusion coefficient within the cylindrical microdomains. The SMT data exhibited one-dimensional diffusion of individual SRB molecules along the SVP direction across the entire film thickness, as consistent with the FRAP results. Importantly, the average of the single-molecule diffusion coefficients was close to the value obtained from FRAP in the identical area. In some cases, SMT offered smaller diffusion coefficients than FRAP, possibly due to contributions from SRB molecules confined within short PEO microdomains. The implementation of FRAP and SMT measurements in identical areas provides complementary information on molecular diffusion with minimal influence of sample heterogeneity, permitting direct comparison of ensemble and single-molecule diffusion behavior.