Mechanism of Radical Initiation in the Radical SAM Enzyme Superfamily

Proteomic strategies to interrogate the Fe-S proteome

Iron‑sulfur (Fe-S) clusters, inorganic cofactors composed of iron and sulfide, participate in numerous essential redox, non-redox, structural, and regulatory biological processes within the cell. Though structurally and functionally diverse, the list of all proteins in an organism capable of binding one or more Fe-S clusters is referred to as its Fe-S proteome. Importantly, the Fe-S proteome is highly dynamic, with continuous cluster synthesis and delivery by complex Fe-S cluster biogenesis pathways. This cluster delivery is balanced out by processes that can result in loss of Fe-S cluster binding, such as redox state changes, iron availability, and oxygen sensitivity. Despite continued expansion of the Fe-S protein catalogue, it remains a challenge to reliably identify novel Fe-S proteins. As such, high-throughput techniques that can report on native Fe-S cluster binding are required to both identify new Fe-S proteins, as well as characterize the in vivo dynamics of Fe-S cluster binding. Due to the recent rapid growth in mass spectrometry, proteomics, and chemical biology, there has been a host of techniques developed that are applicable to the study of native Fe-S proteins. This review will detail both the current understanding of the Fe-S proteome and Fe-S cluster biology as well as describing state-of-the-art proteomic strategies for the study of Fe-S clusters within the context of a native proteome.

Structural features and substrate engagement in peptide-modifying radical SAM enzymes

In recent years, the biological significance of ribosomally synthesized, post-translationally modified peptides (RiPPs) and the intriguing chemistry catalyzed by their tailoring enzymes has garnered significant attention. A subgroup of bacterial radical S-adenosylmethionine (rSAM) enzymes can activate C-H bonds in peptides, which leads to the production of a diverse range of RiPPs. The remarkable ability of these enzymes to facilitate various chemical processes, to generate and harbor high-energy radical species, and to accommodate large substrates with a high degree of flexibility is truly intriguing. The wide substrate scope and diversity of the chemistry performed by rSAM enzymes raise one question: how does the protein environment facilitate these distinct chemical conversions while sharing a similar structural fold? In this review, we discuss recent advances in the field of RiPP-rSAM enzymes, with a particular emphasis on domain architectures and substrate engagements identified by biophysical and structural characterizations. We provide readers with a comparative analysis of six examples of RiPP-rSAM enzymes with experimentally characterized structures. Linking the structural elements and the nature of rSAM-catalyzed RiPP production will provide insight into the functional engineering of enzyme activity to harness their catalytic power in broader applications.

Darobactin Substrate Engineering and Computation Show Radical Stability Governs Ether versus C-C Bond Formation

The Gram-negative selective antibiotic darobactin A has attracted interest owing to its intriguing fused bicyclic structure and unique targeting of the outer membrane protein BamA. Darobactin, a ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptide (RiPP), is produced by a radical S-adenosyl methionine (rSAM)-dependent enzyme (DarE) and contains one ether and one C-C cross-link. Herein, we analyze the substrate tolerance of DarE and describe an underlying catalytic principle of the enzyme. These efforts produced 51 enzymatically modified darobactin variants, revealing that DarE can install the ether and C-C cross-links independently and in different locations on the substrate. Notable variants with fused bicyclic structures were characterized, including darobactin W3Y, with a non-Trp residue at the twice-modified central position, and darobactin K5F, which displays a fused diether ring pattern. While lacking antibiotic activity, quantum mechanical modeling of darobactins W3Y and K5F aided in the elucidation of the requisite features for high-affinity BamA engagement. We also provide experimental evidence for β-oxo modification, which adds support for a proposed DarE mechanism. Based on these results, ether and C-C cross-link formation was investigated computationally, and it was determined that more stable and longer-lived aromatic Cβ radicals correlated with ether formation. Further, molecular docking and transition state structures based on high-level quantum mechanical calculations support the different indole connectivity observed for ether (Trp-C7) and C-C (Trp-C6) cross-links. Finally, mutational analysis and protein structural predictions identified substrate residues that govern engagement to DarE. Our work informs on darobactin scaffold engineering and further unveils the underlying principles of rSAM catalysis.

Functional Integrity of Radical SAM Enzyme Dph1•Dph2 Requires Non-Canonical Cofactor Motifs with Tandem Cysteines

The Dph1•Dph2 heterodimer from yeast is a radical SAM (RS) enzyme that generates the 3-amino-3-carboxy-propyl (ACP) precursor for diphthamide, a clinically relevant modification on eukaryotic elongation factor 2 (eEF2). ACP formation requires SAM cleavage and atypical Cys-bound Fe-S clusters in each Dph1 and Dph2 subunit. Intriguingly, the first Cys residue in each motif is found next to another ill-defined cysteine that we show is conserved across eukaryotes. As judged from structural modeling, the orientation of these tandem cysteine motifs (TCMs) suggests a candidate Fe-S cluster ligand role. Hence, we generated, by site-directed DPH1 and DPH2 mutagenesis, Dph1•Dph2 variants with cysteines from each TCM replaced individually or in combination by serines. Assays diagnostic for diphthamide formation in vivo reveal that while single substitutions in the TCM of Dph2 cause mild defects, double mutations almost entirely inactivate the RS enzyme. Based on enhanced Dph1 and Dph2 subunit instability in response to cycloheximide chases, the variants with Cys substitutions in their cofactor motifs are particularly prone to protein degradation. In sum, we identify a fourth functionally cooperative Cys residue within the Fe-S motif of Dph2 and show that the Cys-based cofactor binding motifs in Dph1 and Dph2 are critical for the structural integrity of the dimeric RS enzyme in vivo.

Radical SAM Enzyme PylB Generates a Lysyl Radical Intermediate in the Biosynthesis of Pyrrolysine by Using SAM as a Cofactor

Pyrrolysine, the 22nd amino acid encoded by the natural genetic code, is essential for methanogenic archaea to catabolize methylamines into methane. The structure of pyrrolysine consists of a methylated pyrroline carboxylate that is linked to the ε-amino group of the l-lysine via an amide bond. The biosynthesis of pyrrolysine requires three enzymes: PylB, PylC, and PylD. PylB is a radical S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) enzyme and catalyzes the first biosynthetic step, the isomerization of l-lysine into methylornithine. PylC catalyzes an ATP-dependent ligation of methylornithine and a second l-lysine to form l-lysine-Nε-methylornithine. The last biosynthetic step is catalyzed by PylD via oxidation of the PylC product to form pyrrolysine. While enzymatic reactions of PylC and PylD have been well characterized by X-ray crystallography and in vitro studies, mechanistic understanding of PylB is still relatively limited. Here, we report the first in vitro activity of PylB to form methylornithine via the isomerization of l-lysine. We also identify a lysyl C4 radical intermediate that is trapped, with its electronic structure and geometric structure well characterized by EPR and ENDOR spectroscopy. In addition, we demonstrate that SAM functions as a catalytic cofactor in PylB catalysis rather than canonically as a cosubstrate. This work provides detailed mechanistic evidence for elucidating the carbon backbone rearrangement reaction catalyzed by PylB during the biosynthesis of pyrrolysine.

Direct Detection of the α-Carbon Radical Intermediate Formed by OspD: Mechanistic Insights into Radical S-Adenosyl-l-methionine Peptide Epimerization

OspD is a radical S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) peptide epimerase that converts an isoleucine (Ile) and valine (Val) of the OspA substrate to d-amino acids during biosynthesis of the ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptide (RiPP) natural product landornamide A. OspD is proposed to carry out this reaction via α-carbon (Cα) H-atom abstraction to form a peptidyl Cα radical that is stereospecifically quenched by hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) from a conserved cysteine (Cys). Here we use site-directed mutagenesis, freeze-quench trapping, isotopic labeling, and electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy to provide new insights into the OspD catalytic mechanism including the direct observation of the substrate peptide Cα radical intermediate. The putative quenching Cys334 was changed to serine to generate an OspD C334S variant impaired in HAT quenching. The reaction of reduced OspD C334S with SAM and OspA freeze-quenched at 15 s exhibits a doublet EPR signal characteristic of a Cα radical coupled to a single β-H. Using isotopologues of OspA deuterated at either Ile or Val, or both Ile and Val, reveals that the initial Cα radical intermediate forms exclusively on the Ile of OspA. Time-dependent freeze quench coupled with EPR spectroscopy provided evidence for loss of the Ile Cα radical concomitant with gain of a Val Cα radical, directly demonstrating the N-to-C directionality of epimerization by OspD. These results provide direct evidence for the aforementioned OspD-catalyzed peptide epimerization mechanism via a central Cα radical intermediate during RiPP maturation of OspA, a mechanism that may extend to other proteusin peptide epimerases.

ENDOR Spectroscopy Reveals the "Free" 5'-Deoxyadenosyl Radical in a Radical SAM Enzyme Active Site Actually is Chaperoned by Close Interaction with the Methionine-Bound [4Fe-4S]2+ Cluster

1/2H and 13C hyperfine coupling constants to 5'-deoxyadenosyl (5'-dAdo•) radical trapped within the active site of the radical S-adenosyl-l-methionine (SAM) enzyme, pyruvate formate lyase-activating enzyme (PFL-AE), both in the absence of substrate and the presence of a reactive peptide-model of the PFL substrate, are completely characteristic of a classical organic free radical whose unpaired electron is localized in the 2pπ orbital of the sp2 C5'-carbon (J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2019, 141, 12139-12146). However, prior electron-nuclear double resonance (ENDOR) measurements had indicated that this 5'-dAdo• free radical is never truly "free": tight van der Waals contact with its target partners and active-site residues guide it in carrying out the exquisitely precise, regioselective reactions that are hallmarks of RS enzymes. Here, our understanding of how the active site chaperones 5'-dAdo• is extended through the finding that this apparently unexceptional organic free radical has an anomalous g-tensor and exhibits significant 57Fe, 13C, 15N, and 2H hyperfine couplings to the adjacent, isotopically labeled, methionine-bound [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster cogenerated with 5'-dAdo• during homolytic cleavage of cluster-bound SAM. The origin of the 57Fe couplings through nonbonded radical-cluster contact is illuminated by a formal exchange-coupling model and broken symmetry-density functional theory computations. Incorporation of ENDOR-derived distances from C5'(dAdo•) to labeled-methionine as structural constraints yields a model for active-site positioning of 5'-dAdo• with a short, nonbonded C5'-Fe distance (∼3 Å). This distance involves substantial motion of 5'-dAdo• toward the unique Fe of the [4Fe-4S]2+ cluster upon S-C(5') bond-cleavage, plausibly an initial step toward formation of the Fe-C5' bond of the organometallic complex, Ω, the central intermediate in catalysis by radical-SAM enzymes.

Benzylic Radical Stabilization Permits Ether Formation During Darobactin Biosynthesis

The Gram-negative selective antibiotic darobactin A has attracted interest owing to its intriguing fused bicyclic structure and unique mode of action. Biosynthetic studies have revealed that darobactin is a ribosomally synthesized and post-translationally modified peptide (RiPP). During maturation, the darobactin precursor peptide (DarA) is modified by a radical S-adenosyl methionine (rSAM)-dependent enzyme (DarE) to contain ether and C-C crosslinks. In this work, we describe the enzymatic tolerance of DarE using a panel of DarA variants, revealing that DarE can install the ether and C-C crosslinks independently and in different locations on DarA. These efforts produced 57 darobactin variants, 50 of which were enzymatically modified. Several new variants with fused bicyclic structures were characterized, including darobactin W3Y, which replaces tryptophan with tyrosine at the twice-modified central position, and darobactin K5F, which displays a fused diether ring pattern. Three additional darobactin variants contained fused diether macrocycles, leading us to investigate the origin of ether versus C-C crosslink formation. Computational analyses found that more stable and long-lived Cβ radicals found on aromatic amino acids correlated with ether formation. Further, molecular docking and calculated transition state structures provide support for the different indole connectivity observed for ether (Trp-C7) and C-C (Trp-C6) crosslink formation. We also provide experimental evidence for a β-oxotryptophan modification, a proposed intermediate during ether crosslink formation. Finally, mutational analysis of the DarA leader region and protein structural predictions identified which residues were dispensable for processing and others that govern substrate engagement by DarE. Our work informs on darobactin scaffold engineering and sheds additional light on the underlying principles of rSAM catalysis.

Pyruvate formate-lyase activating enzyme: The catalytically active 5'-deoxyadenosyl radical caught in the act of H-atom abstraction

Enzymes of the radical S-adenosyl-l-methionine (radical SAM, RS) superfamily, the largest in nature, catalyze remarkably diverse reactions initiated by H-atom abstraction. Glycyl radical enzyme activating enzymes (GRE-AEs) are a growing class of RS enzymes that generate the catalytically essential glycyl radical of GREs, which in turn catalyze essential reactions in anaerobic metabolism. Here, we probe the reaction of the GRE-AE pyruvate formate-lyase activating enzyme (PFL-AE) with the peptide substrate RVSG734YAV, which mimics the site of glycyl radical formation on the native substrate, pyruvate formate-lyase. Time-resolved freeze-quench electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy shows that at short mixing times reduced PFL-AE + SAM reacts with RVSG734YAV to form the central organometallic intermediate, Ω, in which the adenosyl 5'C is covalently bound to the unique iron of the [4Fe-4S] cluster. Freeze-trapping the reaction at longer times reveals the formation of the peptide G734• glycyl radical product. Of central importance, freeze-quenching at intermediate times reveals that the conversion of Ω to peptide glycyl radical is not concerted. Instead, homolysis of the Ω Fe-C5' bond generates the nominally "free" 5'-dAdo• radical, which is captured here by freeze-trapping. During cryoannealing at 77 K, the 5'-dAdo• directly abstracts an H-atom from the peptide to generate the G734• peptide radical trapped in the PFL-AE active site. These observations reveal the 5'-dAdo• radical to be a well-defined intermediate, caught in the act of substrate H-atom abstraction, providing new insights into the mechanistic steps of radical initiation by RS enzymes.

DPH1 Gene Mutations Identify a Candidate SAM Pocket in Radical Enzyme Dph1•Dph2 for Diphthamide Synthesis on EF2

In eukaryotes, the Dph1•Dph2 dimer is a non-canonical radical SAM enzyme. Using iron-sulfur (FeS) clusters, it cleaves the cosubstrate S-adenosyl-methionine (SAM) to form a 3-amino-3-carboxy-propyl (ACP) radical for the synthesis of diphthamide. The latter decorates a histidine residue on elongation factor 2 (EF2) conserved from archaea to yeast and humans and is important for accurate mRNA translation and protein synthesis. Guided by evidence from archaeal orthologues, we searched for a putative SAM-binding pocket in Dph1•Dph2 from Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We predict an SAM-binding pocket near the FeS cluster domain that is conserved across eukaryotes in Dph1 but not Dph2. Site-directed DPH1 mutagenesis and functional characterization through assay diagnostics for the loss of diphthamide reveal that the SAM pocket is essential for synthesis of the décor on EF2 in vivo. Further evidence from structural modeling suggests particularly critical residues close to the methionine moiety of SAM. Presumably, they facilitate a geometry specific for SAM cleavage and ACP radical formation that distinguishes Dph1•Dph2 from classical radical SAM enzymes, which generate canonical 5'-deoxyadenosyl (dAdo) radicals.