Probing the Nature of the Transition-Metal-Boron Bonds and Novel Aromaticity in Small Metal-Doped Boron Clusters Using Photoelectron Spectroscopy

Borozenes: Benzene-Like Planar Aromatic Boron Clusters

ConspectusWith three valence electrons and four valence orbitals, boron (2s22p1) is an electron-deficient element, resulting in interesting chemical bonding and structures in both borane molecules and bulk boron materials. The electron deficiency leads to electron sharing and delocalization in borane compounds and bulk boron allotropes, characterized by polyhedral cages, in particular, the ubiquitous B12 icosahedral cage. During the past two decades, the structures and bonding of size-selected boron clusters have been elucidated via combined photoelectron spectroscopy and theoretical investigations. Unlike bulk boron materials, finite boron clusters have been found to possess 2D structures consisting of B3 triangles, dotted with tetragonal, pentagonal, or hexagonal holes. The discovery of the planar B36 cluster with a central hexagonal hole provided the first experimental evidence for the viability of 2D boron nanostructures (borophene), which have been synthesized on inert substrates. The B7-, B8-, and B9- clusters were among the first few boron clusters to be investigated by joint photoelectron spectroscopy and theoretical calculations, and they were all found to possess 2D structures with a central B atom inside a Bn ring. Recently, the B73- (C6v), B82- (D7h), and B9- (D8h) series of closed-shell species were shown to possess similar π bonding akin to that in the C5H5-, C6H6, and C7H7+ series, respectively, and the name "borozene" was coined to highlight their analogy to the classical aromatic hydrocarbon molecules.Among the borozenes, the D7h B82- species is unique for its high stability originating from both its double aromaticity and the fact that the B7 ring has the perfect size to host a central B atom. The B82- borozene has been realized experimentally in a variety of MB8 and M2B8 complexes. In particular, the B82- borozene has been observed to stabilize the rare valence-I oxidation state of lanthanides in LnB8- complexes, as well as a Cu2+ species in Cu2B8-. The B6 ring in B73- is too small to host a B atom, resulting in a slight out-of-plane distortion. Interestingly, the bowl-shaped B7 borozene is perfect for coordination to a metal atom, leading to the observation of a series of highly stable MB7 borozene complexes. On the other hand, the B8 ring is slightly too large to host the central B atom, such that a low-lying and low-symmetry isomer also exists for B9-. Even though most 2D boron clusters are aromatic, the B73-, B82-, and B9- borozenes are special because of their high symmetries and their analogy to the series of C5H5-, C6H6, and C7H7+ prototypical aromatic compounds. This Account discusses recent experimental and theoretical advances on the investigations of various borozene complexes. It is expected that many new borozene compounds can be designed and may be eventually synthesized.

Theoretical prediction of low-energy photoelectron spectra of AlnNi- clusters (n = 1-13)

CONTEXT

Mixed-metal clusters have long been studied because of their peculiar properties and how they change with cluster size, composition, and charge state and their potential roles in catalysis. The characterization of these clusters is therefore a very important issue. One of the main experimental tools for characterizing their electronic structure is photoelectron spectroscopy. Theoretical computation completes the task by fully determining the structural properties and matching the theoretical predictions to the measured spectra. We present density functional theory computations of the structural, magnetic, and electronic properties of negatively charged mixed AlnNi- clusters with up to 13 Al atoms. The lowest energy structures of the anionic clusters with up to 7 atoms are also found to be low-energy isomers of the neutral counterparts found in the literature. The 13-atom cluster is found to be a quartet and a perfect icosahedron. The predicted photoelectron spectra are also presented and can be used to interpret future experimental data. We also presented indicators that can be used to determine the potential of these systems for single-atom catalysis. These indicators point to smaller clusters to be more reactive as the gap between the Fermi energy and the center of the d-band increases with cluster size and that Ni occupies an internal site for n = 11-13. We speculate that reactivity can be enhanced if one adds an additional Ni atom.

METHODS

The DFT calculations were performed using the Becke exchange and Perdew-Wang/91 correlation functionals (BPW91), a DFT-optimized all-electron basis set for the aluminum atom, and the Stuttgart small core pseudopotential for the Ni atom. All of the computations used the Gaussian 03 software.

Metal-Centered Boron-Wheel Cluster of Y©B112- with Rare D11h Symmetry

Molecules with high point-group symmetry are interesting prototype species in the textbook. As transition metal-centered boron clusters tend to have highly symmetric structures to fulfill multicenter bonding and high stability, new boron clusters with rare point-group symmetry may be viable. Through in-depth scrutiny over the structures of experimentally already observed transition metal-centered boron-wheel complexes, geometric and electronic design principles are summarized, based on which we studied M©B11k- (M = Y, La; Zr, Hf; k = 1, 2) clusters and found that a Y©B112- boron-wheel complex has an unprecedented D11h point-group symmetry. The remarkable stability of the planar Y©B112- complex is illustrated via extensive global-minimum structural search as well as comprehensive chemical bonding analyses. Similar to other boron-wheel complexes, the Y©B112- complex is shown to possess σ and π double aromaticity, indeed following the electronic design principle previously summarized. This new compound is expected to be experimentally identified, which will extend the currently known largest possible planar molecular symmetry and enrich the metal-centered boron-wheel class.

Size effects and electronic properties of zinc-doped boron clusters Zn B n (n = 1-15)

CONTEXT

To gain a deeper understanding of zinc-doped boron clusters, theoretical calculations were performed to investigate the size effects and electronic properties of zinc-doped boron clusters. The study of the electronic properties, spectral characteristics, and geometric structures of Zn B n (n = 1-15) is of great significance in the fields of semiconductor materials science, material detection, and improving catalytic efficiency. The results indicate that Zn B n (n = 1-15) clusters predominantly exhibit planar or quasi-planar structures, with the Zn atom positioned in the outer regions of the B n framework. The second stable structure of Zn B 3 is a three-dimensional configuration, indicating that the structures of zinc-doped boron clusters begin to convert from the planar or quasi-planar structures to the 3D configurations. The second low-energy structure of Zn B 15 is a novel configuration. Relative stability analyses show that the Zn B 12 has better chemical stability than other clusters with a HOMO-LUMO gap of 2.79 eV. Electric charge analysis shows that part electrons on zinc atoms are transferred to boron atoms, and electrons prefer to cluster near the B n framework. According to the electron localization function, it gets harder to localize electrons as the equivalent face value drops, and it's challenging to see covalent bond formation between zinc and boron atoms. The spectrograms of Zn B n (n = 1-15) exhibit distinct properties and notable spectral features, which can be used as a theoretical basis for the identification and confirmation of boron clusters doped with single-atom transition metals.

METHODS

The calculations were performed using the ABCluster global search technique combined with density functional theory (DFT) methods. The selected low-energy structures were subjected to geometric optimization and frequency calculations at the PBE0/6-311 + G(d) level to ensure structural stability and eliminate any imaginary frequencies. To acquire more precise relative energies, we performed single-point energies calculations for the low-lying isomers of Zn B n (n = 1-15) at the CCSD(T)/6-311 + G(d)//PBE0/6-311 + G(d) level of theory. All calculations were performed using Gaussian 09 software. To facilitate analysis, we utilized software tools such as Multiwfn, and VMD.

Investigation of Pb-B Bonding in PbB2(BO)n- (n = 0-2): Transformation from Aromatic PbB2- to Pb[B2(BO)2]-/0 Complexes with BB Triple Bonds

Boron has been found to be able to form multiple bonds with lead. To probe Pb-B bonding, here we report an investigation of three Pb-doped boron clusters, PbB2-, PbB3O-, and PbB4O2-, which are produced by a laser ablation cluster source and characterized by photoelectron spectroscopy and ab initio calculations. The most stable structures of PbB2-, PbB3O-, and PbB4O2- are found to follow the formula, [PbB2(BO)n]- (n = 0-2), with zero, one, and two boronyl ligands coordinated to a triangular and aromatic PbB2 core, respectively. The PbB2- cluster contains a BB double bond and two Pb-B single bonds. The coordination of BO is observed to weaken Pb-B bonding but strengthen the BB bond in [PbB2(BO)n]- (n = 1, 2). The anionic [PbB2(BO)2]- and its corresponding neutral closed-shell [PbB2(BO)2] contain a BB triple bond. A low-lying Y-shaped isomer is also observed for PbB4O2-, consisting of a central sp2 hybridized B atom bonded to two boronyl ligands and a PbB unit.

Two-Dimensional Transition Metal Boron Cluster Compounds (MBnenes) with Strain-Independent Room-Temperature Magnetism

Two-dimensional (2D) metal borides (MBenes) with unique electronic structures and physicochemical properties hold great promise for various applications. Given the abundance of boron clusters, we proposed employing them as structural motifs to design 2D transition metal boron cluster compounds (MBnenes), an extension of MBenes. Herein, we have designed three stable MBnenes (M4(B12)2, M = Mn, Fe, Co) based on B12 clusters and investigated their electronic and magnetic properties using first-principles calculations. Mn4(B12)2 and Co4(B12)2 are semiconductors, while Fe4(B12)2 exhibits metallic behavior. The unique structure in MBnenes allows the coexistence of direct exchange interactions between adjacent metal atoms and indirect exchange interactions mediated by the clusters, endowing them with a Néel temperature (TN) up to 772 K. Moreover, both Mn4(B12)2 and Fe4(B12)2 showcase strain-independent room-temperature magnetism, making them potential candidates for spintronics applications. The MBnenes family provides a fresh avenue for the design of 2D materials featuring unique structures and excellent physicochemical properties.

Generalized Octet Rule with Fractional Occupancies for Boron

The octet rule is a fundamental theory in the chemical bonding of main-group elements, which achieve stable configurations by gaining, losing, or sharing electrons. However, the conventional octet rule, as depicted through Lewis structures, is inadequate for describing the electron delocalization in boron allotropes and boron-rich compounds due to the electron deficiency of boron. To address this, we introduce the concept of fractional electron occupancies, which more accurately reflect the electron delocalization in boron systems. Based on this, we propose a generalized octet rule that provides a more comprehensive understanding of the complex bonding configurations in boron allotropes and boron-rich compounds. Importantly, our predictions for α-B12 are validated by both first-principles calculations and existing experimental data. Beyond boron, this generalized octet rule is also applicable to systems with multiple resonance structures.

Observation of an electron-precise metal boryne complex: [BiBH]. Chem Commun (Camb) 2023;59:12431-12434. [PMID: 37768059 DOI: 10.1039/d3cc04235a] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0]

Metal-boron triple bonds are rare due to the electron deficiency of boron. This study uncovers a simple electron-precise metal boryne complex, [BiBH]-, which is produced within an ion trap through chemical reactions of the open-shell BiB- anion with H2. Photoelectron imaging is used to investigate the electronic structure and chemical bonding of the BiBH- complex. The B atom in the linear closed-shell BiBH- is found to undergo sp hybridization, forming a B-H single bond and a BiB triple bond. Photoelectron imaging reveals three detachment transitions from the BiBH- (1Σ+) anion to the neutral BiBH, including the ground state (2Π3/2) and two excited states (2Σ+ and 2Π1/2). Strong vibronic coupling is observed between the 2Π3/2 and 2Σ+ states, evidenced by the appearance of bending vibrations and their unique photoelectron angular distributions. The BiBH- complex not only stands as the simplest metal boryne complex, but also serves as an ideal molecular system to investigate both spin-orbit and vibronic couplings.

Geometric and electronic structures of medium-sized boron clusters doped with plutonium

Doping metal heteroatoms is an effective strategy to regulate the geometric and electronic structure of boron based nanoclusters. However, the exploration of the ground state structures of metal-boron-based nanoclusters is still a challenge duo to the complexity of the bonding interactions between heterogeneous atoms and boron cluster and the number of isomers on the potential energy surface increases exponentially with cluster size. Here, we use the CALYPSO cluster structural search method in combination with density functional theory calculations to study the geometries and electronic properties of anionic boron clusters doped with plutonium (PuBn-,n= 10-20). Our results show that the medium-sized PuB14-cluster exhibits excellent stability with highest occupied molecular orbital-lowest unoccupied molecular orbital energy gap of 2.30 eV. The remarkable stability of the anionic PuB14-cluster is due to the robust interactions between the Pu metal and the B14skeleton, along with the strong covalent interactions between the B atoms. These findings enrich the geometric structure database of metal doped clusters and provide valuable insights for the future synthesis of boron based nanomaterials.