Fetal surgery

Minimally Invasive Fetal Surgery and the Next Frontier

Most patients with congenital anomalies do not require prenatal intervention. Furthermore, many congenital anomalies requiring surgical intervention are treated adequately after birth. However, there is a subset of patients with congenital anomalies who will die before birth, shortly after birth, or experience severe postnatal complications without fetal surgery. Fetal surgery is unique in that an operation is performed on the fetus as well as the pregnant woman who does not receive any direct benefit from the surgery but rather lends herself to risks, such as hemorrhage, abruption, and preterm labor. The maternal risks involved with fetal surgery have limited the extent to which fetal interventions may be performed but have, in turn, led to technical innovations that have significantly advanced the field. This review will examine congenital abnormalities that can be treated with minimally invasive fetal surgery and introduce the next frontier of prenatal management of fetal surgical pathology.

A new ethical framework to determine acceptable risks in fetal therapy trials

OBJECTIVE

Fetal therapy trials pose complex ethical challenges because risks and benefits to both fetuses and pregnant persons must be considered. Existing regulatory guidance is limited and many proposed ethical frameworks have unnecessarily restrictive criteria that would block the development and implementation of important new fetal therapies. We aimed to develop a new ethical framework for assessing the risks and benefits of fetal therapy trials.

METHODS

We reviewed existing regulatory and ethical guidance on fetal therapy trials. We used conceptual analysis to design a new ethical framework, which is grounded in general ethical principles for clinical research.

RESULTS

We propose a new framework for assessing the risks and benefits of fetal therapy trials. We suggest that the potential benefits of a fetal therapy trial - for the fetus, the pregnant person, and society - should outweigh the risks for the fetus and the pregnant person. Furthermore, the risk-benefit profile for just the fetus and the risk-benefit profile for just the pregnant person should be appropriate.

CONCLUSIONS

We hope that this new framework will permit important studies while protecting pregnant persons and fetuses from disproportionate harms.

A New Ethical Framework for Assessing the Unique Challenges of Fetal Therapy Trials

New fetal therapies offer important prospects for improving health. However, having to consider both the fetus and the pregnant woman makes the risk-benefit analysis of fetal therapy trials challenging. Regulatory guidance is limited, and proposed ethical frameworks are overly restrictive or permissive. We propose a new ethical framework for fetal therapy research. First, we argue that considering only biomedical benefits fails to capture all relevant interests. Thus, we endorse expanding the considered benefits to include evidence-based psychosocial effects of fetal therapies. Second, we reject the commonly proposed categorical risk and/or benefit thresholds for assessing fetal therapy research (e.g., only for life-threatening conditions). Instead, we propose that the individual risks for the pregnant woman and the fetus should be justified by the benefits for them and the study's social value. Studies that meet this overall proportionality criterion but have mildly unfavorable risk-benefit ratios for pregnant women and/or fetuses may be acceptable.

The concept of prenatal gene therapy

This introductory chapter provides a short review of the ideas and practical approaches that have led to the present and perceived future development of prenatal gene therapy. It summarizes the advantages and the potential adverse effects of this novel preventive and therapeutic approach to the management of prenatal diseases. It also provides guidance to the range of conditions to which prenatal gene therapy may be applied and to the technical approaches, vectors, and societal/ethical considerations for this newly emerging field of Fetal Medicine.

MRI of the fetal central nervous system and body

MRI is being increasingly used to assess for fetal abnormalities. Although significant progress in the field of fetal MRI has occurred during the past 20 years, continued technical advances will likely contribute to significant growth of the field. Moreover, with continued hardware and software improvements, additional MRI sequences will likely become available. Prenatal MRI complements ultrasound because of larger field-of-view, superior soft tissue contrast, easier and more precise volumetric measurement, and greater accuracy in the demonstration of intracranial and spinal abnormalities. While ultrasound remains the primary modality for fetal imaging, these advantages of MRI make it a valuable adjunct to fetal surgery. Because fetal MRI involves many disciplines, the future of fetal MR will best be achieved through collaborative efforts.

Port insertion and removal techniques to minimize premature rupture of the membranes in endoscopic fetal surgery

BACKGROUND

Premature rupture of membranes (PROM) remains a significant complication of fetal surgery. Rates of 40% to 100% have been reported after both open and endoscopic fetal surgery. We describe a technique of endoscopic port insertion and removal that minimizes trauma to the membranes.

METHODS

Twenty-seven consecutive patients undergoing endoscopic laser ablation for twin-to-twin transfusion syndrome were reviewed. In each case, a minilaparotomy was performed, and the amniotic cavity was entered under direct vision of the uterus using a Seldinger technique. The entry site was carefully dilated to accommodate a 4.0-mm-diameter cannula. A gelatin sponge plug was placed at port removal. Postoperative management and outcome were evaluated.

RESULTS

Median gestational age at operation was 21.3 weeks. Median operating time was 60 minutes. One patient delivered intraoperatively because of fetal distress. Seventeen (65.4%) patients required postoperative tocolysis (median duration, 12 hours). Median postoperative gestation was 6.5 weeks (range, 1-20 weeks). Only 1 (4.2%) of 24 patients with successful gelatin sponge placement developed PROM.

CONCLUSIONS

Meticulous technique and atraumatic insertion and removal of ports help minimize the risk of postoperative amniotic leak after endoscopic fetal surgery. Our PROM rate of 4.2% contrasts sharply with previously reported rates after similar operations.

Programmed healing of membranous bone in the fetal lamb

In fetal tissues, both soft and hard tissue healing (in long bones) have been found to be scarless. However, healing of membranous bone in the fetal craniofacial skeleton has not been well documented. Pregnant ewes (gestational age range, 80-95 days) underwent a hysterotomy, and fetal lambs had a full-thickness excision of the entire mandibular symphysis region (10 mm). Nonoperated controls were used for comparison (n = 8). After 10 days and 2 weeks, fetuses showed incomplete regeneration of the anterior mandible by examination, computed tomographic scan, and histology. By 4 weeks postoperatively, the mandibular defect had completely closed, but regenerated bony volume was less than control specimens. At 6 weeks postoperatively, the specimen demonstrated complete bony healing without scar or inflammation. Computed tomographic scan measurements for mandibular shape (length over width) was similar in experimental and control specimens. The data indicate that fetal lamb membranous bone defects heal in a scarless fashion and suggest preprogrammed migration of osteogenic tissue.

Local anesthetics inhibit uterine activity in vitro. Possible application on preterm labor prevention and treatment

OBJECTIVE

Analysis of the effects of local anesthetics upon the gravid uterus.

METHODS

Isolated strips of pregnant-rat myometrium were placed within tissue baths. Muscular activity was then recorded by a force transducer, at cumulative concentrations of either procaine, lidocaine, or ropivacaine.

RESULTS

The effects of myometrial activity were non-monotonic. At lower concentrations, an increase in contraction frequency was noted, concomitant with a depression in amplitude. As the concentrations increased, both amplitude and frequency were depressed until, eventually, activity was abolished.

CONCLUSIONS

Local anesthetics administered in situ consistently inhibit or completely arrest overall myometrial activity. These agents may prove clinically useful in preterm labor management, if administered locally to the myometrium via suitable slow release drug delivery systems, warranting further trials in vivo.

Hematology of equine fetuses with comparisons to their dams

The Hematologic values of 19 equine fetuses between 202 and 238 days gestation were compared with those of their dams. The red blood cell (RBC) count, hemoglobin concentration, hematocrit, and mean corpuscular hemoglobin concentration were significantly lower in fetal blood, while the mean corpuscular volume, mean corpuscular hemoglobin, and red cell distribution width were significantly higher. Mares had a significantly higher nucleated blood cell count than fetuses, and all nucleated cells were leukocytes (WBC). Most WBC in mare blood were segmented neutrophils and lymphocytes. In contrast, over one-half of the nucleated cells in fetal blood were nucleated RBC, and the majority of WBC in fetal blood were lymphocytes. Mares also had significantly higher plasma protein and fibrinogen concentrations than their fetuses. Mild macrocytosis and mild polychromasia were observed in most fetal blood samples, but not in blood samples from mares. All fetal blood contained reticulocytes, and most samples contained Heinz bodies and Howell-Jolly bodies. The results of this study will contribute to the development of hematologic reference values that may be useful in equine fetal research and, possibly, in the diagnosis of equine fetal disease.

Fetal operations in the head and neck area: current state

BACKGROUND

Fetal surgery is defined as prenatal surgical intervention. Such intervention is currently considered in selected cases of fetal malformations that endanger the child's life prenatally or postnatally, such as death or severe impairment.

METHODS

Current indications are reviewed, with special emphasis on success rates and complications, including concomitant ethical problems. Data sources are based on personal experience and medical information systems (especially MEDLINE).

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

In the head and neck areas, especially the upper respiratory tract, such procedures can be indicated in selected cases. They include exposure and temporary obstruction of the fetal trachea to reduce the viscera and to prevent pulmonary hypoplasia in congenital diaphragmatic hernia, prenatal tracheotomy in laryngeal atresia, and intranatal establishment of an airway in airway-obstructing embryonic tumors. The latter surgery can be performed after delivery of the fetal head and neck and before umbilical cord severance. This method ensures oxygenation of the fetus by the maternofetal circulation until completion of the surgical intervention (so called EXIT procedure = Ex-Utero Intrapartum Treatment). The relatively high surgical risk of fetal surgery, in particular postoperative preterm labor, may be reduced by the use of minimally invasive endoscopic techniques. By reducing operative risks even further, prenatal surgical interventions may even be used in nonlethal conditions. Consequently, more diseases of the head and neck area could thus be included in the spectrum of indications, such as prenatal correction of the cleft lip palate. Because fetal wound healing incurs no scarring up to a certain stage in pregnancy, such fetal surgical correction could be a perspective.

Role of magnetic resonance imaging in fetal surgery

Prenatal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has several advantages over obstetric ultrasound, including a larger field of view, superior soft-tissue contrast, more precise volumetric measurements, and greater accuracy in the demonstration of intracranial abnormalities. Prenatal MRI has been shown to positively and incrementally influence management in a substantial proportion of patients being considered for fetal intervention. Despite these findings, precise indications for prenatal MRI in the setting of fetal surgery are not yet established, because both prenatal MRI and fetal surgery are relatively new techniques that remain in evolution. Conditions in which prenatal MRI appears to contribute to fetal surgical planning and postoperative evaluation are described in this review. These conditions include congenital diaphragmatic hernia, cystic adenomatoid malformation, sacrococcygeal teratoma, complicated twin pregnancies, upper airway obstruction, and myelomeningocele.

Perinatal management of fetal malformations amenable to surgical correction

Advances in prenatal imaging modalities such as ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging have permitted the more frequent and accurate diagnosis of congenital malformations. Fetal surgical intervention has been reserved for those malformations that lead to fetal demise or are life-threatening in the neonatal period. We review the current indications for intervention in fetuses diagnosed with congenital lung lesions, congenital diaphragmatic hernia, sacrococcygeal teratoma, and obstructing airway lesions. A discussion of the recent interest in the fetal repair of severe myelomeningocele is also included.

Prolonged local myometrial blockade prevents preterm labor after fetal surgery in a leporine model

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Postoperative premature labor remains the foremost limiting factor to the development of fetal surgery. Most attempts at controlling this complication have involved the use of drugs delivered systemically to the mother. This study assessed the effects of prolonged local anesthetic blockade of the myometrium on preterm delivery after open fetal surgery.

METHODS

Eighteen New Zealand rabbits at 23 days' gestation (term, 31 to 33 days) were divided in three groups. In group I (n = 6), the most proximal fetuses of both uterine horns were submitted to open amputation of a forelimb; in a few animals, one of the uterine horns was empty, hence, only one fetus was manipulated. In groups II (n = 5) and III (n = 7), an identical surgical procedure was performed. In group II, immediately before hysterotomy, the myometrium was injected with 0.5 mL of 0.5% bupivacaine along the incision line. In group III, only saline was injected. In group II, before uterine closure, the incised area of the myometrium was injected with 1.5 mL of a novel suspension of biodegradable polylactic-co-glycolic acid microspheres loaded with 75% w/w bupivacaine and 0.05% w/w dexamethasone. This suspension previously has been shown to provide peripheral nerve blockade for approximately 5 days. In group III, microspheres without any drug were injected.

RESULTS

Abortion rates were significantly different among the groups: 83.3% (five of six) for the does in group I, zero in group II, and 71.4% (five of seven) in group III (P < .05). The absence of abortions observed in group II occurred despite the fact that the fetal mortality rate was significantly higher in this group (87.5%, seven of eight fetuses) than in groups I (0) and III (33.3%, 4 of 12 fetuses, P < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

Prolonged local blockade of the myometrium with bupivacaine inhibits preterm labor after fetal surgery in rabbits. The high fetal mortality rate observed in this study may be caused by "transplacental" transfer of the local anesthetic to the fetus. Notably, the abortifacient effect of a dead fetus was completely suppressed by the local blockade. Studies using microspheres with local anesthetics that do not cross the placenta, in animal models with longer gestational periods, are warranted.

Forty years of obstetric ultrasound 1957-1997: from A-scope to three dimensions

In this article, we record the history of obstetric ultrasound as it developed worldwide in the second half of the twentieth century. The technological advances during this period saw the evolution of equipment from the original adapted metal flaw detectors producing a simple A-scan to the modern, purpose built, real-time colour flow machines with three-dimensional capability (Fig. 1). Clinically, ultrasound began as a research tool, but the poor quality of the images led to the ridicule of many of the early investigators. However, because of their perseverance, ultrasound developed into an imaging modality providing immense diagnostic capabilities and facilitating with precision many invasive procedures, diagnostic and therapeutic, both of which have made significant contributions to patient care. In this history, we recall the people, the personalities, and the problems they encountered during the development of ultrasound and how these problems were resolved, so that ultrasound now is available for use in the care of pregnant women throughout the developed world.

Foetal bypass: concepts and controversies

One of the most controversial and challenging surgical undertakings of the next century promises to be foetal cardiac surgery. Animal studies have been underway for several years to gain an understanding of the physiological mechanisms required to achieve this undertaking. Not since the days of crosscirculation has there been a maternal risk associated with open-heart surgery. The diagnosis of congenital heart defects with foetal ultrasound can now be made as early as 12 weeks gestation. Simple cardiac abnormalities, such as valvular stenosis or atresia, alter intracardiac flow patterns and affect normal cardiac chamber development. Without early intervention, these complex lesions often require major surgical reconstruction, beginning in the neonatal period. Foetal cardiac bypass techniques have evolved from the use of roller pumps and bubble oxygenators primed with maternal blood to the use of an axial flow pump incorporated in a right atrial to pulmonary artery or aortic shunt. Because the blood entering the right atrium is oxygenated by the placenta, an oxygenator in the bypass circuit is probably not needed. The low prime axial flow pump system avoids the dilution of the foetus with the maternal adult haemoglobin and improves the outcome. A major focus of research has concentrated on maintenance of placental blood flow with the use of vasodilators and cyclooxygenase inhibitors. Investigation with primates will be necessary to confirm the placental physiology before human operations can be performed. As the foetal bypass challenges are overcome, there is the potential for a reduction in the number of complex cardiac lesions requiring early surgical intervention in the twenty-first century.