Distal radius: in vivo assessment with quantitative MR imaging, peripheral quantitative CT, and dual X-ray absorptiometry

The feasibility study of XACT imaging for characterizing osteoporosis

BACKGROUND

Osteoporosis is a progressive bone disease that is characterized by a decrease in bone mass and the deterioration in bone microarchitecture, which might be related to age and space travel. An unmet need exists for the development of novel imaging technologies to characterize osteoporosis.

PURPOSE

The purpose of our study is to investigate the feasibility of X-ray-induced acoustic computed tomography (XACT) imaging for osteoporosis detection.

METHODS

An in-house simulation workflow was developed to assess the ability of XACT for osteoporosis detection. To evaluate this simulation workflow, a three-dimensional digital bone phantom for XACT imaging was created by a series of two-dimensional micro-computed tomography (micro-CT) slices of normal and osteoporotic bones in mice. In XACT imaging, the initial acoustic pressure rise caused by the X-ray induce acoustic (XA) effect is proportional to bone density. First, region growing was deployed for image segmentation of different materials inside the bone. Then k-wave simulations were deployed to model XA wave propagation, attenuation, and detection. Finally, the time-varying pressure signals detected at each transducer location were used to reconstruct the XACT image with a time-reversal reconstruction algorithm.

RESULTS

Through the simulated XACT images, cortical porosity has been calculated, and XA signal spectra slopes have been analyzed for the detection of osteoporosis. The results have demonstrated that osteoporotic bones have lower bone mineral density and higher spectra slopes. These findings from XACT images were in good agreement with porosity calculation from micro-CT images.

CONCLUSION

This work explores the feasibility of using XACT imaging as a new imaging tool for Osteoporosis detection. Considering that acoustic signals are generated by X-ray absorption, XACT imaging can be combined with traditional X-ray imaging that holds potential for clinical management of osteoporosis and other bone diseases.

Survey of MRI Usefulness for the Clinical Assessment of Bone Microstructure

Bone microarchitecture has been shown to provide useful information regarding the evaluation of skeleton quality with an added value to areal bone mineral density, which can be used for the diagnosis of several bone diseases. Bone mineral density estimated from dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) has shown to be a limited tool to identify patients' risk stratification and therapy delivery. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has been proposed as another technique to assess bone quality and fracture risk by evaluating the bone structure and microarchitecture. To date, MRI is the only completely non-invasive and non-ionizing imaging modality that can assess both cortical and trabecular bone in vivo. In this review article, we reported a survey regarding the clinically relevant information MRI could provide for the assessment of the inner trabecular morphology of different bone segments. The last section will be devoted to the upcoming MRI applications (MR spectroscopy and chemical shift encoding MRI, solid state MRI and quantitative susceptibility mapping), which could provide additional biomarkers for the assessment of bone microarchitecture.

Validation of quantitative magnetic resonance imaging-based apparent bone volume fraction in peri-articular tibial bone of cadaveric knees

BACKGROUND

In the knee, high-resolution magnetic resonance (MR) imaging has demonstrated that increased apparent bone volume fraction (trabecular bone volume per total volume; BV/TV) in the peri-articular proximal medial tibia is associated with joint space narrowing and the presence of bone marrow lesions. However, despite evidence of construct validity, MR-based apparent BV/TV has not yet been cross-validated in the proximal medial tibia by comparison with a gold standard (e.g., micro-computed tomography [microCT]). In this cadaveric validation study we explored the association between MR-based apparent BV/TV and microCT-based BV/TV in the proximal peri-articular medial tibia.

METHODS

Fresh cadaveric whole knee specimens were obtained from individuals 51 to 80 years of age with no knee pathology other than osteoarthritis. Ten knees were collected from five cadavers within 10 hours of death and underwent a 3-Tesla MR exam including a coronal-oblique 3-dimensional fast imaging with steady state precession (3D FISP) sequence within 36 hours of death. The specimens were placed in a 4% paraformaldehyde in phosphate buffer within 58 hours of death. After preservation, a subchondral region from the tibial plateau was collected and underwent microCT imaging with a voxel size of 9 μm x 9 μm x 9 μm. A single reader analyzed the microCT images in a similar volume of interest as selected in the MR measures. A different reader analyzed the MR-based trabecular morphometry using a custom analysis tool. To analyze the MR-based trabecular morphometry, a rectangular region of interest (ROI) was positioned on the 20 central images in the proximal medial tibial subchondral bone. The primary outcome measures were MR-based and microCT-based trabecular BV/TV in the proximal medial tibia.

RESULTS

The MR-based apparent BV/TV was strongly correlated with microCT-based BV/TV (r=0.83, confidence interval=0.42 to 0.96), despite the MR-based apparent BV/TV being systematically lower than measured using microCT.

CONCLUSIONS

MR-based apparent BV/TV in the proximal peri-articular medial tibia has good construct validity and may represent an alternative for CT-based BV/TV.

A fully automated trabecular bone structural analysis tool based on T2* -weighted magnetic resonance imaging

One major source affecting the precision of bone structure analysis in quantitative magnetic resonance imaging (qMRI) is inter- and intraoperator variability, inherent in delineating and tracing regions of interest along longitudinal studies. In this paper an automated analysis tool, featuring bone marrow segmentation, region of interest generation, and characterization of cancellous bone of articular joints is presented. In evaluation studies conducted at the knee joint the novel analysis tool significantly decreased the standard error of measurement and improved the sensitivity in detecting minor structural changes. It further eliminated the need of time-consuming user interaction, and thereby increasing reproducibility.

Evaluation by quantitative magnetic resonance imaging of trabecular bone quality in mandible and cervical vertebrae

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to make a comparison between mandibular and cervical vertebral bone quality (BQ) using quantitative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

METHODS

The cervical MRI images included in this study belonged to 36 patients (23 women, 13 men; mean age 54 years) who had various clinical symptoms (e.g., headache, vertigo, imbalance). The mandible and cervical vertebrae BQ measurements were performed by the same investigator on these sections. Mandibular and cervical vertebral T2(*) axial cross sections were performed following receipt of consent from each patient. T2(*) relaxation time values were determined in the trabecular area.

RESULTS

The relationship between cervical vertebral and mandibular BQ was revealed by regression and correlation analysis. The correlation coefficient was r=0.04, r(2)=0.002, and P=0.818, which is not statistically significant. The relation between age and mandible BQ was very weak (r=0.001, r(2)=0.000001, and P=0.995), and the relation between age and cervical vertebrae BQ was correlated (r=-0.585, r(2)=0.342, and P<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

There is a low correlation between the BQ measurements of cervical vertebrae and the mandible. Precise mandibular BQ measurement does not provide information that correlates with BQ in the other sites of the skeleton. Although an age-dependent decrease occurs in vertebral BQ, no significant alteration occurs in mandibular BQ.

Whole bone geometry and bone quality in distal forearm fracture

Fracture of the distal radius is a sentinel for future increased risk of other "osteoporotic" fractures, in which the peak age for incidence of distal radius fracture is 5 to 10 years before that for spine and hip fractures. Mean bone mineral density (BMD) of the distal radius was lower in patients with osteoporosis compared with age- and sex-matched normal subjects. However, it has been shown that to predict the strength of the distal radius at the site where fractures occur requires more than measurement of bone mineral content (BMC) or BMD. Only moderate correlations have been found between forearm sites, which may be a result of differences in bone composition between sites. Different forearm sites may be used interchangeably for diagnostic purposes, but the prognostic value is not known. Using the distal radius as a screening tool for identifying individuals at risk of "osteoporotic" fracture shows that forearm site selection and accuracy of measurement can be important confounders in group studies.Improving resolution of computed tomography (CT) scanners has enabled quantitation of cortical bone density and cortical thickness. These measurements have enabled the mechanism of bone loss in the distal radius to be elucidated and show that, after menopause, bone loss is primarily through thinning of the cortex. CT imaging allows the precise localization of bone changes in individuals and should be of value in the assessment of the severity of osteoporosis. It also shows that this technology has the potential to determine the efficacy of therapeutic interventions. A concerted effort has been made to elucidate the interrelationships between the amount of bone and the geometry and that clinical imaging of BMC and/or cross-sectional area in the radius would provide improved prediction of an individual's risk of fracture.The technological tools are available, in the clinic, to accurately measure the 3-dimensional (3D) geometry of the distal radius and the amount of bone. In addition, the cortical and cancellous bone compartments can be analyzed separately. This capability, along with the easy accessibility of the distal radius to clinical imaging modalities, provides an excellent framework for longitudinal prospective studies to determine morphologic risk factors for osteoporotic fractures of the distal radius.

T2, Carr-Purcell T2 and T1rho of fat and water as surrogate markers of trabecular bone structure

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques have been developed for non-invasive assessment of the structural properties of trabecular bone. These measurements, however, suffer from relatively long acquisition times and low resolution compared to the trabecular size. Spectroscopic measurement of relaxation times could be applied for more detailed and faster assessment of relaxation properties of bone marrow and also provide surrogate information on trabecular structure. In the present study, bovine trabecular bone was investigated with spectroscopic NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance) methods to determine the relationship between structural parameters as measured with micro-CT and T(2), Carr-Purcell T(2) and T(1rho) relaxation times of fat and water. To compare bone with a sample matrix with magnetic susceptibility interfaces, phantoms consisting of glass beads with different diameters in oil or water were used. The behavior of T(2) measured with different sequences and T(1rho) at different magnitudes of spin-lock fields were characterized, and relaxation times were correlated with structural parameters. T(2) and T(1rho) showed significant associations with structural bone parameters. Strongest linear correlations (r = 0.81, p < 0.01) were established between R(1rho) (1/T(1rho)) of fat component and structural model index. For glass beads, the behavior of T(2) and T(1rho) was similar to that of the water compartment of bone marrow. The present results suggest feasibility of spectroscopic NMR measurements to assess trabecular structure. However, further studies are required to determine the sensitivity of this approach to fat content of bone marrow and to lower the field strengths used in clinical devices.

Evaluation by quantitative magnetic resonance imaging of trabecular bone quality in the dentate and edentulous mandible

OBJECTIVE

To quantify the differences in mandibular trabecular bone quality between edentulous and dentate patients using quantitative magnetic resonance imaging (QMRI).

METHODS

The patients in this study had been referred to our clinic for QMRI examination for various reasons. A total of 40 male patients (18 dentate, 22 edentulous), 45-55 years of age, were examined. Mandibular T2* axial cross-sections were performed following receipt of consent from each patient. T2* relaxation time values (RTVs) were determined in the trabecular area.

RESULTS

The mean mandibular T2* RTVs of dentate and edentulous patients were 181 and 182, respectively. There were no significant differences between the two groups (P=0.929) (Student's t-test).

CONCLUSIONS

Mandibular trabecular bone quality may not be influenced by edentulousness according to QMRI.

Quantitative MRI of parallel changes of articular cartilage and underlying trabecular bone in degeneration

OBJECTIVE

To determine the interrelations between degenerative changes in articular cartilage and underlying trabecular bone during development of osteoarthritis and to test the ability of quantitative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to detect those changes.

METHODS

Human cadaver patellae were investigated with quantitative MRI methods, T(2) and dGEMRIC, at 1.5T. Same measurements for isolated cartilage samples were performed at 9.4T. Bone samples, taken at sites matched with cartilage analyses, were measured with MRI and peripheral quantitative computed tomography (pQCT). Mechanical and quantitative microscopic methods were also utilized for both cartilage and bone samples.

RESULTS

Significant differences were found between the samples with different stages of degeneration in mechanical properties, T(2) at 1.5T and proteoglycan (PG) content of articular cartilage. dGEMRIC at 9.4T discerned samples with advanced degeneration from the others. Bone variables measured with pQCT discerned samples with no or minimal and advanced degeneration, and mechanical properties of trabecular bone discerned samples with no or minimal degeneration from the others. Significant linear correlations were found between the bone and cartilage parameters. Characteristically, associations between variables were stronger within the samples with no or minimal degeneration compared to all samples.

CONCLUSIONS

Quantitative MRI variables, especially T(2) relaxation time of articular cartilage, may be feasible surrogate markers for early and advanced osteoarthritic changes in joint tissues, including decreased elastic moduli, PG and collagen contents of cartilage and mineral density and volume fraction of trabecular bone. Further work is required to resolve the relaxation mechanisms at clinically applicable field strengths.

Prediction of mechanical properties of trabecular bone using quantitative MRI

Techniques for quantitative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) have been developed for non-invasive estimation of the mineral density and structure of trabecular bone. The R*(2) relaxation rate (i.e. 1/T*(2)) is sensitive to bone mineral density (BMD) via susceptibility differences between trabeculae and bone marrow, and by binarizing MRI images, structural variables, such as apparent bone volume fraction, can be assessed. In the present study, trabecular bone samples of human patellae were investigated in vitro at 1.5 T to determine the ability of MRI-derived variables (R*(2) and bone volume fraction) to predict the mechanical properties (Young's modulus, yield stress and ultimate strength). Further, the MRI variables were correlated with reference measurements of volumetric BMD and bone area fraction as determined with a clinical pQCT system. The MRI variables correlated significantly (p < 0.01) with the mechanical variables (r = 0.32-0.46), BMD (r = 0.56) and bone structure (r = 0.51). A combination of R*(2) and MRI-derived bone volume fraction further improved the prediction of yield stress and ultimate strength. Although pQCT showed a trend towards better prediction of the mechanical properties, current results demonstrate the feasibility of combined MR imaging of marrow susceptibility and bone volume fraction in predicting the mechanical strength of trabecular bone and bone mineral density.

Trabecular bone volume fraction measurements of a large number of subjects using a compact MRI

Trabecular bone volume fraction (TBVF) and speed of sound (SOS) were measured for the right calcanei of 416 female volunteers. The TBVF was measured with a compact MRI developed in our laboratory. The SOS was measured with a commercial quantitative ultrasound system. It was observed that the correlation coefficient between TBVF and SOS and that between TBVF and age varied depending on the location of region of interest (ROI) in the calcaneus. As a result, an optimum circular ROI with a diameter of 20 mm was determined so that the correlation coefficients were maximized. In the optimum ROI, transverse relaxation time (T2) of the bone marrow protons of the calcaneus was found to be concentrated in a narrow range over the subjects. This result suggested that a 50% scan time reduction in the TBVF measurements could be made by skipping the T2 correction procedure.

Development of a compact MRI system for trabecular bone volume fraction measurements

A compact MRI system for measuring trabecular bone volume fraction (TBVF) of the calcaneus was developed with the use of a 0.21 T permanent magnet and portable MRI console. The entire system weighed < 600 kg and was installed in a 2 m x 2 m space. Two cross-sectional spin-echo images of a heel acquired with external reference phantoms (total measurement time = 5 min) were used to quantify the TBVF of the calcaneus. The linearity and reproducibility of the measurements were evaluated by means of proton density-adjusted phantoms. Comparative measurements with quantitative ultrasound (QUS) in groups of healthy female volunteers showed a relatively high positive correlation (R(2) = 0.4539, 0.2693) between TBVF and the speed of sound (SOS). These results demonstrate the potential of this new system for measuring bone density. Magn Reson Med 52:440-444, 2004.

Estimation of femoral head bone density using magnetic resonance imaging: comparison between men with and without hip osteoarthritis

Bone changes are thought to be one important etiological element in the pathogenesis of hip osteoarthritis (OA). The magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-derived T2* relaxation time has been shown to provide information about bone mineral status of the femoral neck. The aim of this study was to test the hypothesis that the MRI-derived T2* relaxation time of the proximal femur in hip OA differs from that seen in healthy subjects. Based on the American College of Rheumatology criteria regarding classification of the OA of the hip, 27 men (aged 47-64 yr) with unilateral or bilateral hip OA and 30 age-matched randomly selected healthy men were studied. Bone mineral density (BMD), bone mineral content (BMC), and bone width of the femoral neck were measured with dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA). Subsequently, T2* measurements were performed with a 1.5-T scanner (Siemens Magnetom 63SP; Erlangen, Germany). A single 10-mm-thick coronal slice was generated on the femur, with a repetition time of 60 ms and nine echo times (4-20 ms) to derive T2* values. T2* measurements were performed from the different region of interests (ROIs) from the femoral neck and head. T2* relaxation times showed significant negative correlations with BMC, BMD (r = -0.401 to -0.794; p < 0.05-0.001). T2* relaxation time values revealed no significant differences between the groups in the femoral neck and in the head of the femur, whereas it was 12% lower (p < 0.01) in OA subjects than in controls in acetabulum. There were no significant differences in the T2* relaxation time values between the radiographic OA subgroups. Our findings suggest that hip OA is not associated with an increase of BMD in the femoral neck or in the head of the femur.

Imaging modalities in the assessment of osteoporosis

Imaging can be helpful in the diagnosis and treatment of osteoporosis. Several imaging modalities have become available to assess bone mass in the peripheral, axial, or entire skeleton. The basic principles, indications, and limitations of each imaging method are presented.

A 2-year prospective study on the effects of depot medroxyprogesterone acetate on bone mass-response to estrogen and calcium therapy in individual users

The primary aim of this prospective 2-year follow-up study was to investigate the effect of depot medroxyprogesterone acetate (DMPA) on the maintenance of bone mass in women aged 30-45 years. The effects of estrogen or calcium substitution during the second year of follow-up was investigated in seven DMPA users with a high annual bone loss during the first year. The bone mass of 35 users of DMPA and 10 women without hormonal contraception was investigated using peripheral quantitative computed tomography. The baseline cortical and trabecular bone mass (TBM) and the annual change was not different in DMPA users and controls. Over 24 months we measured an increase in TBM of 0.6% and a decrease in cortical bone mass of 0.1% in exposed women. Some but not all of the DMPA users with a bone loss during the first year could be successfully treated with estradiol or calcium. In conclusion, we did not observe an accelerated bone loss in DMPA users aged 30-45 years.

Local differences in the trabecular bone structure of the proximal femur depicted with high-spatial-resolution MR imaging and multisection CT

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

The authors performed this study to investigate structural variations in the trabecular bone of the proximal femur at high-resolution magnetic resonance (MR) imaging and high-resolution multisection computed tomography (CT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Bone mineral density (BMD) was measured in 36 proximal human femur specimens by using dual x-ray absorptiometry. High-resolution MR imaging was performed at 1.5 T with an in-plane spatial resolution of 0.195 x 0.195 mm and a section thickness of 0.3 and 0.9 mm. Multisection CT was performed with an ultra-high-resolution protocol; images were obtained with an in-plane spatial resolution of 0.25 mm and a section thickness of 1 mm. In a subset of these specimens, micro CT was performed with an isotropic spatial resolution of 30 microm. Identical regions of interest (ROIs) were used to analyze images obtained with MR imaging, multisection CT, and micro CT. Trabecular bone structural parameters were obtained, and the parameters from the individual imaging modalities and BMD were correlated.

RESULTS

Significant differences concerning the trabecular microarchitecture between the individual ROIs were demonstrated with multisection CT and MR imaging. A number of the correlations between structural parameters derived with multisection CT, MR imaging, micro CT, and BMD measurements were significant. For MR imaging, threshold technique and section thickness had an effect on structural parameters.

CONCLUSION

Structural parameters obtained in the proximal femur with multisection CT and high-resolution MR imaging show regional differences. These techniques may be useful for depicting the trabecular architecture in the diagnosis of osteoporosis.

Surface area overestimation within three-dimensional digital images and its consequence for skeletal dosimetry

The most recent methods for trabecular bone dosimetry are based on Monte Carlo transport simulations within three-dimensional (3D) images of real human bone samples. Nuclear magnetic resonance and micro-computed tomography have been commonly used as imaging tools for studying trabecular microstructure. In order to evaluate the accuracy of these techniques for radiation dosimetry, a previous study was conducted that showed an overestimate in the absorbed fraction of energy for low-energy electrons emitted within the marrow space and irradiating the bone trabeculae. This problem was found to be related to an overestimate of the surface area of the true bone-marrow interface within the 3D digital images, and was identified as the surface-area effect. The goal of the present study is to better understand how this surface-area effect occurs in the case of single spheres representing individual marrow cavities within trabecular bone. First, a theoretical study was conducted which showed that voxelization of the spherical marrow cavity results in a 50% overestimation of the spherical surface area. Moreover, this overestimation cannot be reduced through a reduction in the voxel size (e.g., improved image resolution). Second, a series of single-sphere marrow cavity models was created with electron sources simulated within the sphere (marrow source) and outside the sphere (bone trabeculae source). The series of single-sphere models was then voxelized to represent 3D digital images of varying resolution. Transport calculations were made for both marrow and bone electron sources within these simulated images. The study showed that for low-energy electrons (<100 keV), the 50% overestimate of the bone-marrow interface surface area can lead to a 50% overestimate of the cross-absorbed fraction. It is concluded that while improved resolution will not reduce the surface area effects found within 3D image-based transport models, a tenfold improvement in current image resolution would compensate the associated errors in cross-region absorbed fractions for low-energy electron sources. Alternatively, other methods of defining the bone-marrow interface, such as with a polygonal isosurface, would provide improvements in dosimetry without the need for drastic reductions in image voxel size.

Skeletal dosimetry via NMR microscopy: investigations of sample reproducibility and signal source

Nuclear magnetic resonance microscopy has been used for several years as a means of quantifying the 3D microarchitecture of the cancellous regions of the skeleton. These studies were originally undertaken for the purpose of developing non-invasive techniques for the early detection of osteoporosis and other bone structural changes. Recently, nuclear magnetic resonance microscopy has also been used to acquire this same 3D data for the purpose of both (1) generating chord length data across bone trabeculae and marrow cavities and (2) generating 3D images for direct coupling to Monte Carlo radiation transport codes. In both cases, one is interested in the reproducibility of the dosimetric data obtained from nuclear magnetic resonance microscopy. In the first of two studies, a trabecular bone sample from the femoral head of a 51-y-old male cadaver was subjected to repeated image acquisition, image processing, image coupling, and radiation transport simulations. The resulting absorbed fractions at high electron energies (4 MeV) were shown to vary less than 4% among four different imaging sessions of the same sample. In a separate study, two femoral head samples were imaged under differing conditions of the NMR signal source. In the first case, the samples were imaged with intact marrow. These samples were then subjected to marrow digestion and immersed in Gd-doped water, which then filled the marrow cavities. Energy-dependent absorbed fraction profiles for both the marrow-intact and marrow-free samples showed essentially equivalent results. These studies thus provide encouragement that skeletal dosimetry models of improved patient specificity can be achieved via NMR microscopy in vivo.

Comparison of DXA and MRI methods for interpreting femoral neck bone mineral density

The aim of the study was to improve the practical implementation of the dual X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) by converting the areal bone mineral density BMD (BMD(areal)) to volumetric BMD using magnetic resonance (MR) imaging (MRI) because a failure to control for the femoral neck size can lead to erroneous interpretation of BMD values. We also evaluated the feasibility of MR T2* relaxation time in assessing bone mineral status of the femoral neck. Twenty-eight randomly selected 47- to 64-yr-old healthy men were studied. The men had neither unilateral nor bilateral hip osteoarthritis according to radiographs. Bone width, mineral content (BMC), BMD(areal), and apparent volumetric BMD (BMD(vol)) of the right femoral neck were measured with DXA. The BMD(vol) was calculated by approximating the femoral neck to be cylindrical with a circular cross-section (Vol(dxa)). Volumetric measurements from MR (Vol(mri)) images of the femoral neck were also used to create a BMD measure that was corrected for the femoral neck volume (BMD(mri)). T2* measurements were performed with a 1.5-T scanner (Siemens Magnetom 63SP, Erlangen, Germany). A single 10-mm-thick coronal slice was generated on the femur with a repetition time of 60 ms, and nine echo times (4-20 ms) were used to derive T2* values. Vol(mri) correlated positively (r = 0.828, p < 0.001) with Vol(dxa). However, the Vol(mri) of the femoral neck was 18% lower than the Vol(dxa). Similarly, the BMD(mri) was related to the BMD(vol) (r = 0.737, p < 0.001). Because of the difference in the volumetric measures, the BMD(mri) of the femoral neck was 21% higher than the BMD(vol) (p < 0.001). T2* relaxation time showed a significant negative correlation with BMC, BMD(areal), BMD(vol), and BMD(mri) (r = -0.423 to -0.757, p < 0.05-0.001). In conclusion, these results are evidence that DXA-derived volume approximations by the cylinder with circular cross-section geometry may lead to lower DXA-derived BMD(vol) values, as compared to true MRI-derived volumetric bone mineral density. Thus, the BMD(vol) may not be an accurate method to calculate the true volumetric BMD in the femoral neck. Our results also suggest that the MRI-derived T2* method may be used to approximate the BMD in the proximal femur.

Future methods in the assessment of bone mass and structure

There have been major advances in the diagnosis of osteoporosis over the last few decades not only in the definitions that are now used but also in the technology that is available. The future will see further development of the techniques currently in common clinical use, such us dual energy X-ray absorptiometry and quantitative ultrasound. In addition new techniques for assessing bone structure, including MRI and fractal analysis of X-rays, may add significantly to our understanding of the pathophysiology of osteoporosis and to the prediction of fracture risk.

Proton magnetic relaxation in bone marrow related to age and bone mineral density: low-resolution in vitro studies

Detailed analysis of proton spin-spin and spin-lattice relaxation behaviors of the bone marrow in the presence of trabecular bone network was performed at low-resolution (B(0) = 0.496T) on rat vertebrae specimens deprived of spinal cord. Two groups of samples, from young and old healthy animals, were investigated before cellular necrosis had started. BMD measurements were carried out to quantify the expected age-related modifications of the trabecular bone network. 1H-MR measurements were also performed on the same samples, deprived of marrow and saturated with water, in order to control the validity of a possible interpretation of the marrow 1H-MR characteristics, in terms of marrow components, and to investigate the possible employment of these samples to study the trabecular bone network properties. We pointed out that: 1) a bimodal distribution of T(2i) and T(1i) values (distinguishing "fast" and "slow" relaxations) describes satisfactorily all the 1H-MR experimental decays; 2) age-related modifications of the trabecular bone network are marked by correlate variations of the BMD value and of the proton spin-spin relaxation rates in water saturated samples; 3) age-related modifications of marrow are underlined by variations of the average value of the "fast" T(2i) and of the "slow" T(1i) relaxation time distributions, which could be attributed to the marrow components different from the fat granules of the adipose cells. Our results suggest that studies in vitro on bone tissue, by 1H-MR techniques at low-resolution, may contribute to a better bone function characterization and, therefore, to a better clinical utilization of MRI techniques.

Does the trabecular bone structure depicted by high-resolution MRI of the calcaneus reflect the true bone structure?

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to compare trabecular bone structure parameters assessed with high-resolution magnetic resonance imaging (HR-MRI) with those determined in specimen sections.

METHODS

High-resolution MR images were obtained for 30 calcaneus specimens with a three-dimensional, T1-weighted spin-echo sequence (spatial in-plane resolution 0.195 mm, slice thicknesses of 0.3 and 0.9 mm). Thirty-eight sections were obtained from the specimens, and contact radiography was performed. In the corresponding sections, structural parameters analogous to bone histomorphometry were determined.

RESULTS

Significant correlations between MRI-derived structural parameters and those derived from macro pathological sections were found: r values of up to 0.75 were obtained (P < 0.01). The highest correlations were found for apparent bone volume/total volume and trabecular thickness. Image thresholding techniques showed a significant impact on these correlations (P < 0.01). The thinner MR sections were less susceptible to the different thresholding algorithms.

CONCLUSIONS

Trabecular bone structure depicted by HR-MR images is significantly correlated with that shown in macro sections (P < 0.01); however, a number of limitations have to be considered, including the substantial impact of thresholding techniques and slice thickness.

A prospective study on the effects of depot medroxyprogesterone acetate on trabecular and cortical bone after attainment of peak bone mass

OBJECTIVE

To study the annual change of bone mass in women aged 30-45 years being treated with depot medroxyprogesterone acetate (DMPA) in order to evaluate whether the bone mass depends on the duration of DMPA use or the oestradiol level.

DESIGN

Prospective longitudinal study over an interval of 12 months.

SETTING

A family planning centre of a university hospital.

PATIENTS

Thirty-six current users of DMPA.

INTERVENTIONS

Injection of 150 mg DMPA every 12 weeks.

MEASUREMENTS

Bone mass was measured at the distal radius by peripheral quantitative computed tomography (reproducibility 0.3%).

RESULTS

Mean annual changes (SD) in trabecular and cortical bone mass were 0.06 (1.6%) [P = 0.8] and -0.26% (0.6) [P < 0.04]. The decrease in cortical bone mass was not significant because the changes were within the precision error of the method used for the measurements. Duration of DMPA use and oestradiol levels were not associated to the bone parameters.

CONCLUSION

We did not find a negative impact of DMPA on the bone mass of premenopausal women aged 30-45 years.

Magnetic resonance osteodensitometry in human heel bones: correlation with quantitative computed tomography using different measuring parameters

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

Density of trabecular bone structures in human heel bones was assessed by 3D magnetic resonance (MR) gradient echo imaging (GEI) with multiple echoes. Different spatial resolutions were applied to investigate the influence of the pixel size on signal characteristics in GEI and to find suitable measuring parameters for a maximum correlation between GEI and bone mineral density obtained by quantitative computed tomography (QCT).

METHODS

Thirty-five patients aged 31 to 65 years with suspected osteoporosis underwent MR and QCT examinations of the heel bones. The MR protocol included 3D GEI with three echo times (TE1 = 9.3, TE2 = 27.9, and TE3 = 46.5 ms) and isotropic pixel sizes of (0.6 mm)3, (1.2 mm)3, and (2.4 mm)3. Several subregions in the heel bones were analyzed. For determination of signal reduction with increasing TE, signal intensity ratios were calculated pixelwise from images with TE2/TE1 and TE3/TE1.

RESULTS

All examinations showed that the T2*-related signal decrease was more pronounced for lower spatial resolution. In the dorsal part of the heel bones, the correlation between signal ratios in GEI and QCT-based bone mineral density values was between r = -0.86 for a spatial resolution of (0.6 mm)3 and r = -0.73 for (2.4 mm)3. Areas with low trabecular density in the ventral part of the heel bones showed clearly lower correlation coefficients (-0.65 < r < -0.67).

CONCLUSIONS

Spatial resolution in 3D GEI clearly influences the T2*-related signal characteristics. Despite measuring different physical properties of spongy bone by GEI and QCT, a relatively high correlation between GEI with small pixel sizes and QCT was obtained in the dorsal part of the heel bones, but not in the ventral part with partly thickened trabeculae and irregular distribution. However, standardized measuring protocols with preferably small pixel sizes (as low as [0.6 mm]3) should be applied, and correlation curves must be determined, dependent on the actual bone marrow site, before clinical routine MR osteodensitometry becomes possible.

Peripheral quantitative CT of the forearm: scanner cross-calibration using patient data

Bone density measurements by peripheral quantitative CT (pQCT) of the distal radius in 87 women (age 38.4 +/- 12.3 years) were obtained on a both a Stratec XCT 900 and an updated version XCT 1400. Axial area, and total and trabecular bone mineral density (BMD) results from both scanners were compared for all patients using linear regression analysis. To achieve scanner calibration we used the intercept and slope of the patients' correlations. The correlations of the patients' values were good for area (r = 0.83) as well as total BMD (r = 0.90) and excellent for trabecular BMD (r = 0.97). The cross-calibration approach in our study provided compatibility of pQCT for trabecular and total ROIs, the clinically mostly utilized volumes of measurement.

Quantitative ultrasound of the calcaneus: an in vivo comparison with dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry and magnetic resonance imaging

The current study was performed in a clinical setting and aimed to evaluate the relationship between quantitative ultrasound (QUS) of the calcaneus with bone mineral density (BMD) assessed with dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA) and with variables derived from magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Thirty-two postmenopausal women (mean age 61 years) were studied at the level of the nondominant calcaneus. QUS was performed using a DTU-one device including parametric imaging and yielded speed of sound (SOS) and broadband ultrasound attenuation (BUA) data. DXA was performed at a matched region of interest (ROI) in the calcaneus, using a Hologic QDR 4500 device. MRI, also performed at a matched ROI, yielded, using a Siemens Magnetom Vision device, the inverse of the transverse relaxation time (1/T(2)(*)) and the phase standard deviation (PSD). The strongest relationship between QUS and the other variables involved BUA and BMD (r &equals: 0.677, p < 0.001); 1/T(2)(*) showed a trend to correlation with SOS (r = 0.359, p = 0. 044) and with BMD (r = 0.364, p = 0.040), while the relationship between 1/T(2)(*) and BUA, PSD and BUA, PSD and SOS, PSD and BMD remained far from significance. Regression analysis of QUS, DXA, and MRI variables against age showed a trend to significant decline only for 1/T(2)(*) (r = -0.409, p = 0.020). In conclusion, this study shows that BUA of the calcaneus has the best correlation with BMD, and that, at least in a clinical setting, the ability of QUS to give information about bone structure is limited.

Comparison of three different plating techniques for the dorsum of the distal radius: a biomechanical study

Three different plating techniques were used on experimentally produced dorsally displaced distal radius fractures in cadavers and were tested in 4-point bending: a AO 3.5-mm T plate (group 1), two 2. 0-mm titanium plates 60 degrees to each other (group 2), and the AO pi plate (group 3). A metaphyseal defect was simulated by a dorsally open wedge osteotomy. The tests show that the 2-mm double-plating technique has superior stiffness and statistically equivalent bending and bone gap to failure compared with the AO 3.5-mm T plate or the pi plate when applied to the unstable distal radius fracture model. (J Hand Surg 2000; 25A:29-33.

CT and MR assessment of osteoporosis

Over the past decades there has been remarkable progress in the development and application of non-invasive radiological methods for assessing the skeletal bone mass and status. It is possible to evaluate the peripheral or axial entire skeleton as well as the trabecular bone or cortical bone envelopes with a high degree of accuracy and precision, and with a reasonable capacity for determining bone strength and predicting fracture risk. Cross sectional imaging methods such as CT and MR yield significant advantages for these applications since they are the only techniques which allow for accurate three dimensional localization of tissue and for true isolation of the trabecular and the cortical bone compartment. Both methods can be applied to practically every anatomic location in the human body.

Effects of trabecular bone on marrow relaxation in the tibia

The effects of bone on marrow relaxation in the trabecular volume of the most proximal 3 cm in the left tibia were studied with a RF-spoiled gradient echo MRI protocol on a 1.0 T MR unit. The MR measurements were performed on six healthy volunteers, and repeated within one month in order to assess the precision of the method. In the same subjects, the area bone mineral density (BMD, g/cm2) was measured at the left proximal femur using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry. The calcaneus of the same side was examined with quantitative ultrasound. The marrow T2* relaxation deviated from a mono-exponential decay, and resembled the decay of subcutaneous fat. The shape of the relaxation curve reflected the presence of several spectral components in bone marrow, and was further influenced by the amount and structure of the surrounding trabecular bone. The bone marrow decays showed substantially reduced inter-subject variability after normalisation of the marrow data fit parameters to corresponding values for s.c. fat. This suggests the use of an internal adipose tissue reference in order to correct for diet-related variations of marrow T2* estimates. The mean relative precision of the MR measurements was between 5% and 10% depending on the data fit model. Moderate-to-strong correlations between DXA BMD indices in the proximal femur and MR parameters were found (r(max)=-0.96; p < 0.01), while ultrasound-derived measures of bone strength measured on the calcaneus demonstrated significantly weaker correlations to the MR parameters (r(max)=-0.78; p > 0.05). The method employed in this study showed reasonable precision and a moderate to good correlation compared to other bone parameters derived at the same extremity, and is a promising tool for the use on patients.

Trabecular bone mineral and calculated structure of human bone specimens scanned by peripheral quantitative computed tomography: relation to biomechanical properties

The relationship of cortical bone mineral density (BMD), and geometry to bone strength has been well documented. In this study, we used peripheral quantitative computerized tomography (pQCT) to acquire trabecular BMD and high-resolution images of trabeculae from specimens to determine their relationship with biomechanical properties. Fifty-eight human cubic trabecular bone specimens, including 26 from the vertebral bodies, were scanned in water and air. Trabecular structure was quantitated using software developed with Advanced Visual Systems interfaced on a Sun/Sparc Workstation. BMD was also obtained using a whole-body computerized tomography scanner (QCT). Nondestructive testing of the specimens was performed to assess their elastic modulus. QCT and pQCT measurements of BMD of specimens in water were strongly correlated (r2 = 0.95, p < 0.0001), with a slope (0.96) statistically not significantly different from 1. Strong correlations were found between pQCT measurements of specimens in water and in air, for BMD (r2 = 0.96, p < 0.0001), and for apparent trabecular structural parameters (r2 = 0.89-0.93, p < 0.0001). Correlations were moderate between BMD and apparent trabecular structural parameters (r2 = 0.37-0.64, p < 0.0001). Precision as coefficient of variation (CV) and standardized coefficient of variation (SCV) for these measurements was < 5%. For the vertebral specimens, the correlation was higher between elastic modulus and BMD (r2 = 0.76,p < 0.0001) than between elastic modulus and apparent trabecular structural parameters (r2 = 0.58-0.72, p < 0.0001), while the addition of apparent trabecular nodes and branches to BMD in a multivariate regression model significantly increased the correlation with the elastic modulus (r2 = 0.86, p < 0.01). Thus, pQCT can comparably and reproducibly measure trabecular bone mineral in water or air, and trabecular structure can be quantitated from pQCT images. The combination of volumetric BMD with trabecular structural parameters rather than either alone improves the prediction of biomechanical properties. Such a noninvasive approach may be useful for the preclinical study of osteoporosis.

Trabecular bone characterization with low-field MRI

Multiple-echo (ME) T2 measurements were performed in vitro at 0.1 T on a series of human trabecular bone samples filled with water and compared to site-matched bone density measurements. Multiple-echo T2 is strongly correlated to bone density and allows distinction between samples of equivalent bone density. Multiple-echo T2 is also dependent on the trabecular orientation with respect to the direction of the main field.

Bone density determination

Bone mineral density determination is an integral part of the diagnosis, therapeutic planning, and monitoring of a patient with osteoporosis. Although the utility of measuring bone density seems intuitive, decisions must be made regarding whom to test, when to test, which technique to use, and which body site to evaluate. Once a determination has been made, consideration has to be given to what to do with the results. Each patient must be individually considered, incorporating genetic, nutritional, lifestyle, pharmacologic, and endocrine risk factors. Other diseases that may be associated with a reduced bone mass must be excluded.

Comparisons of noninvasive bone mineral measurements in assessing age-related loss, fracture discrimination, and diagnostic classification

The purpose of this study was to examine the commonly available methods of noninvasively assessing bone mineral status across three defined female populations to examine their interrelationships, compare their respective abilities to reflect age- and menopause-related bone loss, discriminate osteoporotic fractures, and classify patients diagnostically. A total of 47 healthy premenopausal (age 33 +/- 7 years), 41 healthy postmenopausal (age 64 +/- 9 years), and 36 osteoporotic postmenopausal (age 70 +/- 6 years) women were examined with the following techniques: (1) quantitative computed tomography of the L1-L4 lumbar spine for trabecular (QCT TRAB BMD) and integral (QCT INTG BMD) bone mineral density (BMD); (2) dual X-ray absorptiometry of the L1-L4 posterior-anterior (DXA PA BMD) and L2-L4 lateral (DXA LAT BMD) lumbar spine, of the femoral neck (DXA NECK BMD) and trochanter (DXA TROC BMD), and of the ultradistal radius (DXA UD BMD) for integral BMD; (3) peripheral QCT of the distal radius for trabecular BMD (pQCT TRAB BMD) and cortical bone mineral content (BMC) (pQCT CORT BMC); (4) two radiographic absorptiometric techniques of the metacarpal (RA METC BMD) and phalanges (RA PHAL BMD) for integral BMD; and (5) two quantitative ultrasound devices (QUS) of the calcaneus for speed of sound (SOS CALC) and broadband ultrasound attenuation (BUA CALC). In general, correlations ranged from (r = 0.10-0.93) among different sites and techniques. We found that pQCT TRAB BMD correlated poorly (r < or = 0.46) with all other measurements except DXA UD BMD (r = 0.62,p < or = 0.0001) and RA PHAL BMD (r = 0.52, p < or = 0.0001). The strongest correlation across techniques was between QCT INT BMD and DXA LAT BMD (r = 0.87, p < or = 0.0001), and the weakest correlation within a technique was between pQCT TRAB BMD and pQCT CORT BMC (r = 0.25,p < or = 0.05). Techniques showing the highest correlations with age in the healthy groups also showed the greatest differences among groups. They also showed the best discrimination (as measured by the odds ratios) for the distinction between healthy postmenopausal and osteoporotic postmenopausal groups based on age-adjusted logistic regression analysis. For each anatomic site, the techniques providing the best results were: (1) spine, QCT TRAB BMD (annual loss, -1.2% [healthy premenopausal and healthy postmenopausal]); Student's t-value [not the T score], 5.4 [healthy postmenopausal vs. osteoporotic postmenopausal]; odds ratio, 43 [age-adjusted logistic regression for healthy postmenopausal vs. osteoporotic postmenopausal]); (2) hip, DXA TROC BMD (-0.46; 3.5; 2.2); (3) radius, DXA UD BMD (-0.44; 3.3; 1.9) and pQCT, CORT BMC (-0.72; 2.9; 1.7); (4) hand, RA PHAL (-0.51; 3.6; 2.0); and (5) calcaneus, SOS (-0.09; 3.4; 2.1) and BUA (-0.52; 2.6; 1.7). Despite these performance trends, the differences among sites and techniques were statistically insignificant (p > 0.05) using age-adjusted receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis. Nevertheless, kappa score analysis (using -2.0 T score as the cut-off value for osteopenia and -2.5 T score for osteoporosis) showed that in general the diagnostic agreement among these measurements in classifying women as osteopenic or osteoporotic was poor, with kappa scores averaging about 0.4 (exceptions were QCT TRAB/INTG BMD, DXA LAT BMD, and RA PHAL BMD, with kappa scores ranging from 0.63 to 0.89). Often different patients were estimated at risk by using different measurement sites or techniques.

Magnetic susceptibility measurement of insoluble solids by NMR: magnetic susceptibility of bone

Measurements of the volume magnetic susceptibility of solids using the classical Gouy balance approach are hampered by variations in apparent density of the packed powder. In this paper a quantitative NMR measurement of the volume magnetic susceptibility of powdered solids is described and the volume susceptibility of bone is reported. The technique is based on the measurement of changes in incremental linewidth (1/pi T2') induced in a marker fluid whose susceptibility can be predictably modified by changing the composition, such as by addition of a soluble diamagnetic compound. The spectroscopic linewidth of the marker fluid is determined by the susceptibility difference between the fluid and the suspended solid. Changes in the linewidth are accompanied by bulk magnetic susceptibility induced frequency shifts in the fluid resonance. Correlating the two dependencies allows measurement of the absolute volume susceptibility of the solid. The susceptibility of bovine rib bone was found to be -0.9 +/- 0.02 x -10(-6) (CGS) confirming previous estimates which suggested bone to be more diamagnetic than the marrow constituents. Knowledge of the susceptibility of bone is relevant in view of the growing interest in MRI osteodensitometric techniques.

Field strength and angle dependence of trabecular bone marrow transverse relaxation in the calcaneus

The contribution from reversible dephasing, R2', to the effective transverse relaxation rate, R2*, in trabecular bone marrow, is governed by the magnetic field inhomogeneity induced by the difference in diamagnetic susceptibility between bone and bone marrow and should, therefore, scale linearly with field strength. Measurement of R2' in the calcaneus at 1.5 and 4 T by means of the GESFIDE (gradient-echo sampling of free induction decay and echo) pulse sequence showed R2' to increase by a factor of 2.73 at the higher field, which is close to the ratio of the field strengths (2.67). At both field strengths, R2' dominates R2*, contributing more than 90% to the total relaxation rate at 4 T. The data further indicate large regional variations within the calcaneus and a notable dependence of R2' on the angle of the foot relative to the direction of the static field. The findings have implications on the choice of the calcaneal site for assessment of trabecular density.