Cardiovascular response to acute hypoxemia induced by prolonged breath holding in air

Physiological responses during static apnoea efforts in elite and novice breath-hold divers before and after two weeks of dry apnoea training

This study examined the effect of breath-hold (BH) training on apnoeic performance in novice BH divers (NBH:n = 10) and compared them with data from elite BH divers (EBH:n = 11). Both groups performed 5-maximal BHs (PRE). The NBH group repeated this protocol after two weeks of BH training (POST). The NBH group during BH efforts significantly increased red blood cell concentration (4.56 ± 0.16Mio/μl) by 5.06%, hemoglobin oxygen saturation steady state duration (110.32 ± 29.84 s) by 15.48%, and breath-hold time (BHT:144.19 ± 47.35 s) by 33.77%, primarily due to a 59.70% increase in struggle phase (71.85 ± 30.89 s), in POST. EBH group exhibited longer BHT (283.95 ± 36.93 s) and struggle-phase (150.10 ± 34.69 s) than NBH (POST). Elite divers recorded a higher peak MAP (153.18 ± 12.28 mmHg) compared to novices (PRE:123.70 ± 15.65 mmHg, POST:128.30 ± 19.16 mmHg), suggesting that a higher peak MAP is associated with a better BHT. The concurrent abrupt increase of diaphragmatic activity and MAP, seen only in the EBH group, suggests a potential interaction. Additionally, apnoea training increases red blood cells concentration in repeated apnoea efforts and increases BH stamina.

Influence of sympathetic activation on myocardial contractility measured with ballistocardiography and seismocardiography during sustained end-expiratory apnea

Ballistocardiography (BCG) and seismocardiography (SCG) assess vibrations produced by cardiac contraction and blood flow, respectively, through micro-accelerometers and micro-gyroscopes. BCG and SCG kinetic energies (KE) and their temporal integrals (iK) during a single heartbeat are computed in linear and rotational dimensions. Our aim was to test the hypothesis that iK from BCG and SCG are related to sympathetic activation during maximal voluntary end-expiratory apnea. Multiunit muscle sympathetic nerve traffic [burst frequency (BF), total muscular sympathetic nerve activity (tMSNA)] was measured by microneurography during normal breathing and apnea (n = 28, healthy men). iK of BCG and SCG were simultaneously recorded in the linear and rotational dimension, along with oxygen saturation ([Formula: see text]) and systolic blood pressure (SBP). The mean duration of apneas was 25.4 ± 9.4 s. SBP, BF, and tMSNA increased during the apnea compared with baseline (P = 0.01, P = 0.002,and P = 0.001, respectively), whereas [Formula: see text] decreased (P = 0.02). At the end of the apnea compared with normal breathing, changes in iK computed from BCG were related to changes of tMSNA and BF only in the linear dimension (r = 0.85, P < 0.0001; and r = 0.72, P = 0.002, respectively), whereas changes in linear iK of SCG were related only to changes of tMSNA (r = 0.62, P = 0.01). We conclude that maximal end expiratory apnea increases cardiac kinetic energy computed from BCG and SCG, along with sympathetic activity. The novelty of the present investigation is that linear iK of BCG is directly and more strongly related to the rise in sympathetic activity than the SCG, mainly at the end of a sustained apnea, likely because the BCG is more affected by the sympathetic and hemodynamic effects of breathing cessation. BCG and SCG may prove useful to assess sympathetic nerve changes in patients with sleep disturbances.NEW & NOTEWORTHY Ballistocardiography (BCG) and seismocardiography (SCG) assess vibrations produced by cardiac contraction and blood flow, respectively, through micro-accelerometers and micro-gyroscopes. Kinetic energies (KE) and their temporal integrals (iK) during a single heartbeat are computed from the BCG and SCG waveforms in a linear and a rotational dimension. When compared with normal breathing, during an end-expiratory voluntary apnea, iK increased and was positively related to sympathetic nerve traffic rise assessed by microneurography. Further studies are needed to determine whether BCG and SCG can probe sympathetic nerve changes in patients with sleep disturbances.

Cardiovascular magnetic resonance assessment of acute cardiovascular effects of voluntary apnoea in elite divers

BACKGROUND

Prolonged breath holding results in hypoxemia and hypercapnia. Compensatory mechanisms help maintain adequate oxygen supply to hypoxia sensitive organs, but burden the cardiovascular system. The aim was to investigate human compensatory mechanisms and their effects on the cardiovascular system with regard to cardiac function and morphology, blood flow redistribution, serum biomarkers of the adrenergic system and myocardial injury markers following prolonged apnoea.

METHODS

Seventeen elite apnoea divers performed maximal breath-hold during cardiovascular magnetic resonance imaging (CMR). Two breath-hold sessions were performed to assess (1) cardiac function, myocardial tissue properties and (2) blood flow. In between CMR sessions, a head MRI was performed for the assessment of signs of silent brain ischemia. Urine and blood samples were analysed prior to and up to 4 h after the first breath-hold.

RESULTS

Mean breath-hold time was 297 ± 52 s. Left ventricular (LV) end-systolic, end-diastolic, and stroke volume increased significantly (p < 0.05). Peripheral oxygen saturation, LV ejection fraction, LV fractional shortening, and heart rate decreased significantly (p < 0.05). Blood distribution was diverted to cerebral regions with no significant changes in the descending aorta. Catecholamine levels, high-sensitivity cardiac troponin, and NT-pro-BNP levels increased significantly, but did not reach pathological levels.

CONCLUSION

Compensatory effects of prolonged apnoea substantially burden the cardiovascular system. CMR tissue characterisation did not reveal acute myocardial injury, indicating that the resulting cardiovascular stress does not exceed compensatory physiological limits in healthy subjects. However, these compensatory mechanisms could overly tax those limits in subjects with pre-existing cardiac disease. For divers interested in competetive apnoea diving, a comprehensive medical exam with a special focus on the cardiovascular system may be warranted.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

This prospective single-centre study was approved by the institutional ethics committee review board. It was retrospectively registered under ClinicalTrials.gov (Trial registration: NCT02280226 . Registered 29 October 2014).

Breath-Hold Diving

Breath-hold diving is practiced by recreational divers, seafood divers, military divers, and competitive athletes. It involves highly integrated physiology and extreme responses. This article reviews human breath-hold diving physiology beginning with an historical overview followed by a summary of foundational research and a survey of some contemporary issues. Immersion and cardiovascular adjustments promote a blood shift into the heart and chest vasculature. Autonomic responses include diving bradycardia, peripheral vasoconstriction, and splenic contraction, which help conserve oxygen. Competitive divers use a technique of lung hyperinflation that raises initial volume and airway pressure to facilitate longer apnea times and greater depths. Gas compression at depth leads to sequential alveolar collapse. Airway pressure decreases with depth and becomes negative relative to ambient due to limited chest compliance at low lung volumes, raising the risk of pulmonary injury called "squeeze," characterized by postdive coughing, wheezing, and hemoptysis. Hypoxia and hypercapnia influence the terminal breakpoint beyond which voluntary apnea cannot be sustained. Ascent blackout due to hypoxia is a danger during long breath-holds, and has become common amongst high-level competitors who can suppress their urge to breathe. Decompression sickness due to nitrogen accumulation causing bubble formation can occur after multiple repetitive dives, or after single deep dives during depth record attempts. Humans experience responses similar to those seen in diving mammals, but to a lesser degree. The deepest sled-assisted breath-hold dive was to 214 m. Factors that might determine ultimate human depth capabilities are discussed. © 2018 American Physiological Society. Compr Physiol 8:585-630, 2018.

β1-Blockade increases maximal apnea duration in elite breath-hold divers

We hypothesized that the cardioselective β₁-adrenoreceptor antagonist esmolol would improve maximal apnea duration in elite breath-hold divers. In elite national-level divers (n = 9), maximal apneas were performed in a randomized and counterbalanced order while receiving either iv esmolol (150 μg·kg^-1·min^-1) or volume-matched saline (placebo). During apnea, heart rate (ECG), beat-by-beat blood pressure, stroke volume (SV), cardiac output (CO), and total peripheral resistance (TPR) were measured (finger photoplethysmography). Myocardial oxygen consumption (MV̇o₂) was estimated from rate pressure product. Cerebral blood flow through the internal carotid (ICA) and vertebral arteries (VA) was assessed using Duplex ultrasound. Apnea duration improved in the esmolol trial when compared with placebo (356 ± 57 vs. 323 ± 61 s, P < 0.01) despite similar end-apnea peripheral oxyhemoglobin saturation (71.8 ± 10.3 vs. 74.9 ± 9.5%, P = 0.10). The HR response to apnea was reduced by esmolol at 10-30% of apnea duration, whereas MAP was unaffected. Esmolol reduced SV (main effect, P < 0.05) and CO (main effect; P < 0.05) and increased TPR (main effect, P < 0.05) throughout apnea. Esmolol also reduced MV̇o₂ throughout apnea (main effect, P < 0.05). Cerebral blood flow through the ICA and VA was unchanged by esmolol at baseline and the last 30 s of apnea; however, global cerebral blood flow was reduced in the esmolol trial at end-apnea (P < 0.05). Our findings demonstrate that, in elite breath-hold divers, apnea breakpoint is improved by β₁-blockade, likely owing to an improved total body oxygen sparring through increased centralization of blood volume (↑TPR) and reduced MV̇o₂NEW & NOTEWORTHY The governing bodies for international apnea competition, the Association Internationale pour le Développment de l'Apnée and La Confédération Mondaile des Activités Subaquatiques, have banned the use of β-blockers based on anecdotal reports that they improve apnea duration. Using a randomized placebo-controlled trial, we are the first to empirically confirm that β-blockade improves apnea duration. This improvement in apnea duration coincided with a reduced myocardial oxygen consumption.

An integrated mathematical model of the human cardiopulmonary system: model validation under hypercapnia and hypoxia

A novel integrated physiological model of the interactions between the cardiovascular and respiratory systems has been in development for the past few years. The model has hundreds of parameters and variables representing the physical and physiological properties of the human cardiopulmonary system. It can simulate many dynamic states and scenarios. The description of the model and the results in normal resting conditions were presented in a companion paper (Albanese A, Cheng L, Ursino M, Chbat NW. Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol 310: 2016; doi:10.1152/ajpheart.00230.2014), where model predictions were compared against average population data from literature. However, it is also essential to test the model in abnormal or pathological conditions to prove its consistency. Hence, in this paper, we concentrate on testing the cardiopulmonary model under hypercapnic and hypoxic conditions, by comparing model's outputs to population-averaged cardiorespiratory data reported in the literature. The utility of this comprehensive model is demonstrated by testing the internal consistency of the simulated responses of a significant number of cardiovascular variables (heart rate, arterial pressure, and cardiac output) and respiratory variables (tidal volume, respiratory rate, minute ventilation, alveolar O2 and CO2 partial pressures) over a wide range of perturbations and conditions; namely, hypercapnia at 3–7% CO2 levels and hypoxia at 7–9% O2 levels with controlled CO2 (isocapnic hypoxia) and without controlled CO2 (hypocapnic hypoxia). Finally, a sensitivity analysis is performed to analyze the role of the main cardiorespiratory control mechanisms triggered by hypercapnia and hypoxia.

Cardiorespiratory adaptation to breath-holding in air: Analysis via a cardiopulmonary simulation model

Apnea via breath-holding (BH) in air induces cardiorespiratory adaptation that involves the activation of several reflex mechanisms and their complex interactions. Hence, the effects of BH in air on cardiorespiratory function can become hardly predictable and difficult to be interpreted. Particularly, the effect on heart rate is not yet completely understood because of the contradicting results of different physiological studies. In this paper we apply our previously developed cardiopulmonary model (CP Model) to a scenario of BH with a twofold intent: (1) further validating the CP Model via comparison against experimental data; (2) gaining insights into the physiological reasoning for such contradicting experimental results. Model predictions agreed with published experimental animal and human data and indicated that heart rate increases during BH in air. Changes in the balance between sympathetic and vagal effects on heart rate within the model proved to be effective in inverting directions of the heart rate changes during BH. Hence, the model suggests that intra-subject differences in such sympatho-vagal balance may be one of the reasons for the contradicting experimental results.

Assessing and ensuring patient safety during breath-holding for radiotherapy

Objective:

While there is recent interest in using repeated deep inspiratory breath-holds, or prolonged single breath-holds, to improve radiotherapy delivery, breath-holding has risks. There are no published guidelines for monitoring patient safety, and there is little clinical awareness of the pronounced blood pressure rise and the potential for gradual asphyxia that occur during breath-holding. We describe the blood pressure rise during deep inspiratory breath-holding with air and test whether it can be abolished simply by pre-oxygenation and hypocapnia.

Methods:

We measured blood pressure, oxygen saturation (SpO₂) and heart rate in 12 healthy, untrained subjects performing breath-holds.

Results:

Even for deep inspiratory breath-holds with air, the blood pressure rose progressively (e.g. mean systolic pressure rose from 133 ± 5 to 175 ± 8 mmHg at breakpoint, p < 0.005, and in two subjects, it reached 200 mmHg). Pre-oxygenation and hypocapnia prolonged breath-hold duration and prevented the development of asphyxia but failed to abolish the pressure rise. The pressure rise was not a function of breath-hold duration and was not signalled by any fall in heart rate (remaining at resting levels of 72 ± 2 beats per minute).

Conclusion:

Colleagues should be aware of the progressive blood pressure rise during deep inspiratory breath-holding that so far is not easily prevented. In breast cancer patients scheduled for breath-holds, we recommend routine screening for heart, cardiovascular, renal and cerebrovascular disease, routine monitoring of patient blood pressure and SpO₂ during breath-holding and requesting patients to stop if systolic pressure rises consistently >180 mmHg and or SpO₂ falls <94%.

Advances in knowledge:

There is recent interest in using deep inspiratory breath-holds, or prolonged single breath-holding techniques, to improve radiotherapy delivery. But there appears to be no clinical awareness of the risks to patients from breath-holding. We demonstrate the progressive blood pressure rise during deep inspiratory breath-holds with air, which we show cannot be prevented by the simple expedient of pre-oxygenation and hypocapnia. We propose patient screening and safety guidelines for monitoring both blood pressure and SpO₂ during breath-holds and discuss their clinical implications.

Brain responses to emotional stimuli during breath holding and hypoxia: an approach based on the independent component analysis

Voluntary breath holding represents a physiological model of hypoxia. It consists of two phases of oxygen saturation dynamics: an initial slow decrease (normoxic phase) followed by a rapid drop (hypoxic phase) during which transitory neurological symptoms as well as slight impairment of integrated cerebral functions, such as emotional processing, can occur. This study investigated how breath holding affects emotional processing. To this aim we characterized the modulation of event-related potentials (ERPs) evoked by emotional-laden pictures as a function of breath holding time course. We recorded ERPs during free breathing and breath holding performed in air by elite apnea divers. We modeled brain responses during free breathing with four independent components distributed over different brain areas derived by an approach based on the independent component analysis (ICASSO). We described ERP changes during breath holding by estimating amplitude scaling and time shifting of the same components (component adaptation analysis). Component 1 included the main EEG features of emotional processing, had a posterior localization and did not change during breath holding; component 2, localized over temporo-frontal regions, was present only in unpleasant stimuli responses and decreased during breath holding, with no differences between breath holding phases; component 3, localized on the fronto-central midline regions, showed phase-independent breath holding decreases; component 4, quite widespread but with frontal prevalence, decreased in parallel with the hypoxic trend. The spatial localization of these components was compatible with a set of processing modules that affects the automatic and intentional controls of attention. The reduction of unpleasant-related ERP components suggests that the evaluation of aversive and/or possibly dangerous situations might be altered during breath holding.

Mind-body relationships in elite apnea divers during breath holding: a study of autonomic responses to acute hypoxemia

The mental control of ventilation with all associated phenomena, from relaxation to modulation of emotions, from cardiovascular to metabolic adaptations, constitutes a psychophysiological condition characterizing voluntary breath-holding (BH). BH induces several autonomic responses, involving both autonomic cardiovascular and cutaneous pathways, whose characterization is the main aim of this study. Electrocardiogram and skin conductance (SC) recordings were collected from 14 elite divers during three conditions: free breathing (FB), normoxic phase of BH (NPBH) and hypoxic phase of BH (HPBH). Thus, we compared a set of features describing signal dynamics between the three experimental conditions: from heart rate variability (HRV) features (in time and frequency-domains and by using nonlinear methods) to rate and shape of spontaneous SC responses (SCRs). The main result of the study rises by applying a Factor Analysis to the subset of features significantly changed in the two BH phases. Indeed, the Factor Analysis allowed to uncover the structure of latent factors which modeled the autonomic response: a factor describing the autonomic balance (AB), one the information increase rate (IIR), and a latter the central nervous system driver (CNSD). The BH did not disrupt the FB factorial structure, and only few features moved among factors. Factor Analysis indicates that during BH (1) only the SC described the emotional output, (2) the sympathetic tone on heart did not change, (3) the dynamics of interbeats intervals showed an increase of long-range correlation that anticipates the HPBH, followed by a drop to a random behavior. In conclusion, data show that the autonomic control on heart rate and SC are differentially modulated during BH, which could be related to a more pronounced effect on emotional control induced by the mental training to BH.

Cardiac magnetic resonance imaging during pulmonary hyperinflation in apnea divers

PURPOSE

Apnea divers hyperinflate the lung by taking a deep breath followed by glossopharyngeal insufflation. The maneuver can lead to symptomatic arterial hypotension. We tested the hypotheses that glossopharyngeal insufflation interferes with cardiac function further reducing cardiac output (CO) using cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to fully sample both cardiac chambers.

METHODS

Eleven dive athletes (10 men, 1 woman; age = 26 ± 5 yr, body mass index = 23.5 ± 1.7 kg·m(-2)) underwent cardiac MRI during breath holding at functional residual capacity (baseline), at total lung capacity (apnea), and with submaximal glossopharyngeal insufflation. Lung volumes were estimated from anatomic images. Short-axis cine MR images were acquired to study biventricular function. Dynamic changes were followed by long-axis cine MRI.

RESULTS

Left and right ventricular end-diastolic volumes (LVEDV, RVEDV) decreased during apnea with and without glossopharyngeal insufflation (baseline: LVEDV = 198 ± 19 mL, RVEDV = 225 ± 30 mL; apnea: LVEDV = 125 ± 38 mL, RVEDV = 148 ± 37 mL, P < 0.001; glossopharyngeal insufflation: LVEDV = 108 ± 26 mL, RVEDV = 136 ± 29 mL, P < 0.001 vs baseline). CO decreased during apnea (left = -29 ± 4 %, right = -29 ± 4 %) decreasing further with glossopharyngeal insufflation (left = -38% ± 4%, right = -39% ± 4%, P < 0.05). HR increased 16 ± 4 bpm with apnea and 17 ± 5 bpm with glossopharyngeal insufflation (P < 0.01). Ejection fraction moderately decreased (apnea: left = -5% ± 2%, right = -7% ± 2%, glossopharyngeal insufflation: left = -6% ± 2%, right = -10% ± 2%, P < 0.01). With continued apnea with and without glossopharyngeal insufflation, LVEDV and CO increased over time by a similar but small amount (P < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

The major finding of our study was that submaximal glossopharyngeal insufflation decreased CO further albeit by a small amount compared to maximal inspiratory apnea. The response was not associated with severe biventricular dysfunction.

Behavioral responses to hypoxia and hyperoxia in Drosophila larvae: molecular and neuronal sensors

The ability to detect changes in oxygen concentration in the environment is critical to the survival of all animals. This requires cells to express a molecular oxygen sensor that can detect shifts in oxygen levels and transmit a signal that leads to the appropriate cellular response. Recent biochemical, genetic and behavioral studies have shown that the atypical soluble guanylyl cyclases function as oxygen detectors in Drosophila larvae triggering a behavioral escape response when exposed to hypoxia. These studies also identified the sensory neurons that innervate the terminal sensory cones as likely chemosensors that mediate this response. Here I summarize the data that led to these conclusions and also highlight evidence that suggests additional, as yet unidentified, proteins are also required for detecting increases and decreases in oxygen concentrations.

Walking with Gianluca Di Bella during the development of clinical cardiac imaging

Cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for the diagnosis and management of many cardiac diseases has been established in clinical practice. It provides anatomic and functional information and is the most precise technique for quantification of ventricular volume, function and mass. Among cardiac MRI sequences used in clinical practice, delayed contrast enhancement is an accurate and reliable method used in the diagnosis of ischemic and nonischemic cardiomyopathies. In addition, new technology applied in echocardiographic imaging has permitted quantification of myocardial deformations with 2-dimensional strain imaging (longitudinal, circumferential and radial strain). Cardiac MRI and echocardiography therefore both play a crucial role in the diagnosis and management of cardiovascular disease. Dr. Di Bella and colleagues have defined the roles of cardiac MRI and echocardiography in many clinical and experimental settings.