Skeletal muscle energetics are compromised only during high-intensity contractions in the Goto-Kakizaki rat model of type 2 diabetes

On the role of skeletal muscle acidosis and inorganic phosphates as determinants of central and peripheral fatigue: A 31 P-MRS study

Intramuscular hydrogen ion (H⁺ ) and inorganic phosphate (Pi) concentrations were dissociated during exercise to challenge their relationships with peripheral and central fatigue in vivo. Ten recreationally active, healthy men (27 ± 5 years; 180 ± 4 cm; 76 ± 10 kg) performed two consecutive intermittent isometric single-leg knee-extensor trials (60 maximal voluntary contractions; 3 s contraction, 2 s relaxation) interspersed with 5 min of rest. Phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy (³¹ P-MRS) was used to continuously quantify intramuscular [H⁺ ] and [Pi] during both trials. Using electrical femoral nerve stimulation, quadriceps twitch force (Q_tw ) and voluntary activation (VA) were quantified at rest and throughout both trials. Decreases in Q_tw and VA from baseline were used to determine peripheral and central fatigue, respectively. Q_tw was strongly related to both [H⁺ ] (β coefficient: -0.9, P < 0.0001) and [Pi] (-1.1, P < 0.0001) across trials. There was an effect of trial on the relationship between Q_tw and [H⁺ ] (-0.5, P < 0.0001), but not Q_tw and [Pi] (0.0, P = 0.976). This suggests that, unlike the unaltered association with [Pi], a given level of peripheral fatigue was associated with a different [H⁺ ] in Trial 1 vs. Trial 2. VA was related to [H⁺ ] (-0.3, P < 0.0001), but not [Pi] (-0.2, P = 0.243), across trials and there was no effect of trial (-0.1, P = 0.483). Taken together, these results support intramuscular Pi as a primary cause of peripheral fatigue, and muscle acidosis, probably acting on group III/IV muscle afferents in the interstitial space, as a contributor to central fatigue during exercise. KEY POINTS: We investigated the relationship between intramuscular metabolites and neuromuscular function in humans performing two maximal, intermittent, knee-extension trials interspersed with 5 min of rest. Concomitant measurements of intramuscular hydrogen (H⁺ ) and inorganic phosphate (Pi) concentrations, as well as quadriceps twitch-force (Q_tw ) and voluntary activation (VA), were made throughout each trial using phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy (³¹ P-MRS) and electrical femoral nerve stimulations. Although [Pi] fully recovered prior to the onset of the second trial, [H⁺ ] did not. Q_tw was strongly related to both [H⁺ ] and [Pi] across both trials. However, the relationship between Q_tw and [H⁺ ] shifted leftward from the first to the second trial, whereas the relationship between Q_tw and [Pi] remained unaltered. VA was related to [H⁺ ], but not [Pi], across both trials. These in vivo findings support the hypotheses of intramuscular Pi as a primary cause of peripheral fatigue, and muscle acidosis, probably acting on group III/IV muscle afferents, as a contributor to central fatigue.

Measuring Mitochondrial Function: From Organelle to Organism

Mitochondrial energy production is crucial for normal daily activities and maintenance of life. Herein, the logic and execution of two main classes of measurements are outlined to delineate mitochondrial function: ATP production and oxygen consumption. Aerobic ATP production is quantified by phosphorus magnetic resonance spectroscopy (³¹PMRS) in vivo in both human subjects and animal models using the same protocols and maintaining the same primary assumptions. Mitochondrial oxygen consumption is quantified by oxygen polarography and applied in isolated mitochondria, cultured cells, and permeabilized fibers derived from human or animal tissue biopsies. Traditionally, mitochondrial functional measures focus on maximal oxidative capacity-a flux rate that is rarely, if ever, observed outside of experimental conditions. Perhaps more physiologically relevant, both measurement classes herein focus on one principal design paradigm; submaximal mitochondrial fluxes generated by graded levels of ADP to map the function for ADP sensitivity. We propose this function defines the bioenergetic role that mitochondria fill within the myoplasm to sense and match ATP demands. Any deficit in this vital role for ATP homeostasis leads to symptoms often seen in cardiovascular and cardiopulmonary diseases, diabetes, and metabolic syndrome.

Are Alterations in Skeletal Muscle Mitochondria a Cause or Consequence of Insulin Resistance?

As a major site of glucose uptake following a meal, skeletal muscle has an important role in whole-body glucose metabolism. Evidence in humans and animal models of insulin resistance and type 2 diabetes suggests that alterations in mitochondrial characteristics accompany the development of skeletal muscle insulin resistance. However, it is unclear whether changes in mitochondrial content, respiratory function, or substrate oxidation are central to the development of insulin resistance or occur in response to insulin resistance. Thus, this review will aim to evaluate the apparent conflicting information placing mitochondria as a key organelle in the development of insulin resistance in skeletal muscle.

Mitochondrial Utilization of Competing Fuels Is Altered in Insulin Resistant Skeletal Muscle of Non-obese Rats (Goto-Kakizaki)

Aim

Insulin-resistant skeletal muscle is characterized by metabolic inflexibility with associated alterations in substrate selection, mediated by peroxisome-proliferator activated receptor δ (PPARδ). Although it is established that PPARδ contributes to the alteration of energy metabolism, it is not clear whether it plays a role in mitochondrial fuel competition. While nutrient overload may impair metabolic flexibility by fuel congestion within mitochondria, in absence of obesity defects at a mitochondrial level have not yet been excluded. We sought to determine whether reduced PPARδ content in insulin-resistant rat skeletal muscle of a non-obese rat model of T2DM (Goto-Kakizaki, GK) ameliorate the inhibitory effect of fatty acid (i.e., palmitoylcarnitine) on mitochondrial carbohydrate oxidization (i.e., pyruvate) in muscle fibers.

Methods

Bioenergetic function was characterized in oxidative soleus (S) and glycolytic white gastrocnemius (WG) muscles with measurement of respiration rates in permeabilized fibers in the presence of complex I, II, IV, and fatty acid substrates. Mitochondrial content was measured by citrate synthase (CS) and succinate dehydrogenase activity (SDH). Western blot was used to determine protein expression of PPARδ, PDK isoform 2 and 4.

Results

CS and SDH activity, key markers of mitochondrial content, were reduced by ∼10-30% in diabetic vs. control, and the effect was evident in both oxidative and glycolytic muscles. PPARδ (p < 0.01), PDK2 (p < 0.01), and PDK4 (p = 0.06) protein content was reduced in GK animals compared to Wistar rats (N = 6 per group). Ex vivo respiration rates in permeabilized muscle fibers determined in the presence of complex I, II, IV, and fatty acid substrates, suggested unaltered mitochondrial bioenergetic function in T2DM muscle. Respiration in the presence of pyruvate was higher compared to palmitoylcarnitine in both animal groups and fiber types. Moreover, respiration rates in the presence of both palmitoylcarnitine and pyruvate were reduced by 25 ± 6% (S), 37 ± 6% (WG) and 63 ± 6% (S), 57 ± 8% (WG) compared to pyruvate for both controls and GK, respectively. The inhibitory effect of palmitoylcarnitine on respiration was significantly greater in GK than controls (p < 10^-3).

Conclusion

With competing fuels, the presence of fatty acids diminishes mitochondria ability to utilize carbohydrate derived substrates in insulin-resistant muscle despite reduced PPARδ content.

Quantification of Mitochondrial Oxidative Phosphorylation in Metabolic Disease: Application to Type 2 Diabetes

Type 2 diabetes (T2D) is a growing health concern with nearly 400 million affected worldwide as of 2014. T2D presents with hyperglycemia and insulin resistance resulting in increased risk for blindness, renal failure, nerve damage, and premature death. Skeletal muscle is a major site for insulin resistance and is responsible for up to 80% of glucose uptake during euglycemic hyperglycemic clamps. Glucose uptake in skeletal muscle is driven by mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation and for this reason mitochondrial dysfunction has been implicated in T2D. In this review we integrate mitochondrial function with physiologic function to present a broader understanding of mitochondrial functional status in T2D utilizing studies from both human and rodent models. Quantification of mitochondrial function is explained both in vitro and in vivo highlighting the use of proper controls and the complications imposed by obesity and sedentary lifestyle. This review suggests that skeletal muscle mitochondria are not necessarily dysfunctional but limited oxygen supply to working muscle creates this misperception. Finally, we propose changes in experimental design to address this question unequivocally. If mitochondrial function is not impaired it suggests that therapeutic interventions and drug development must move away from the organelle and toward the cardiovascular system.