Abrogation of alpha-adrenergic vasoactivity in chronically inflamed rat knee joints

A History of Psycho-Neuro-Endocrine Immune Interactions in Rheumatic Diseases

BACKGROUND

All active scientists stand on the shoulders of giants and many other more anonymous scientists, and this is not different in our field of psycho-neuro-endocrine immunology in rheumatic diseases. Too often, the modern world of publishing forgets about the collective enterprise of scientists. Some journals advise the authors to present only literature from the last decade, and it has become a natural attitude of many scientists to present only the latest publications. In order to work against this general unempirical behavior, neuroimmunomodulation devotes the 30th anniversary issue to the history of medical science in psycho-neuro-endocrine immunology.

SUMMARY

Keywords were derived from the psycho-neuro-endocrine immunology research field very well known to the authors (R.H.S. has collected a list of keywords since 1994). We screened PubMed, the Cochran Library of Medicine, Embase, Scopus database, and the ORCID database to find relevant historical literature. The Snowballing procedure helped find related work. According to the historical appearance of discoveries in the field, the order of presentation follows the subsequent scheme: (1) the sensory nervous system, (2) the sympathetic nervous system, (3) the vagus nerve, (4) steroid hormones (glucocorticoids, androgens, progesterone, estrogens, and the vitamin D hormone), (5) afferent pathways involved in fatigue, anxiety, insomnia, and depression (includes pathophysiology), and (6) evolutionary medicine and energy regulation - an umbrella theory.

KEY MESSAGES

A brief history on psycho-neuro-endocrine immunology cannot address all relevant aspects of the field. The authors are aware of this shortcoming. The reader must see this review as a viewpoint through the biased eyes of the authors. Nevertheless, the text gives an overview of the history in psycho-neuro-endocrine immunology of rheumatic diseases.

The contribution of autonomic mechanisms to pain in temporomandibular disorders: A narrative review

BACKGROUND

Temporomandibular disorders (TMD) are diagnosed based on symptom presentation and, like other functional pain disorders, often lack definitive pathology. There is a strong association between elevated stress levels and the severity of TMD-related pain, which suggests that alterations in autonomic tone may contribute to this pain condition.

OBJECTIVES

This narrative review examines the association between altered autonomic function and pain in TMD.

METHODS

Relevant articles were identified by searching PubMed and through the reference list of those studies.

RESULTS

TMD sufferers report an increased incidence of orthostatic hypotension. As in other chronic musculoskeletal pain conditions, TMD is associated with increased sympathetic tone, diminished baroreceptor reflex sensitivity and decreased parasympathetic tone. It remains to be determined whether ongoing pain drives these autonomic changes and/or is exacerbated by them. To examine whether increased sympathetic tone contributes to TMD-related pain through β₂ adrenergic receptor activation, clinical trials with the beta blocker propranolol have been undertaken. Although evidence from small studies suggested propranolol reduced TMD-related pain, a larger clinical trial did not find a significant effect of propranolol treatment. This is consistent with human experimental pain studies that were unable to demonstrate an effect of β₂ adrenergic receptor activation or inhibition on masticatory muscle pain. In preclinical models of temporomandibular joint arthritis, β₂ adrenergic receptor activation appears to contribute to inflammation and nociception, whereas in masticatory muscle, α₁ adrenergic receptor activation has been found to induce mechanical sensitization. Some agents used to treat TMD, such as botulinum neurotoxin A, antidepressants and α₂ adrenergic receptor agonists, may interact with the autonomic nervous system as part of their analgesic mechanism.

CONCLUSION

Even if dysautonomia turns out to be a consequence rather than a causative factor of painful TMD, the study of its role has opened up a greater understanding of the pathogenesis of this condition.

Mechanisms and Mediators That Drive Arthritis Pain

There are over 100 different types of arthritis and each can differ greatly in their aetiology and pathophysiology; however, one characteristic that is common to all arthritic conditions is joint pain. Musculoskeletal pain is the leading cause of disability in the world, and the number one reason arthritis patients visit their primary care physician. Despite the prevalence and burden of arthritis pain, current analgesics lack sufficient efficacy and are plagued by multiple adverse side effects. In this review, we outline the current landscape of research concerning joint pain, drawing from both preclinical and clinical studies. Specifically, this review is a discussion of the different neurophysiological processes that occur during joint disease and how inflammatory and neuropathic aspects contribute to the development of arthritis pain.

Alteration in α- and β- adrenoceptor profile of rabbit-knee-joint blood vessels due to chronic inflammation

Experiments were performed to investigate the nature of alpha- and beta-adrenoceptors in blood vessels supplying the posterior capsule of the chronically inflamed rabbit knee joint, and results were compared to the finding from previous experiments on the normal and acutely inflamed joint to assess any alteration which may occur in the adrenoceptor profile due to the chronic inflammation process. Electrical stimulation of the posterior articular nerve resulted in vasoconstriction that was completely blocked by phentolamine. This constrictor response was almost equally inhibited by prazosin and yohimbine. The dose-response curves to close intraarterial injection of alpha-adrenoceptor agonists showed a rank-order potency of adrenaline = clonidine = phenylephrine. The adrenaline dose-response curve was shifted to the right by administration of alpha-antagonists with a rank-order potency of phentolamine = prazosin = yohimbine. At this stage of experiments, there was an equal response of alpha(1)- and alpha(2)- adrenoceptors in blood vessels of the chronically inflamed rabbit knee joint. In another group of animals, the neurally mediated vasodilatation, which appeared after administration of phentolamine, was completely blocked by propranolol and was reduced significantly by ICI118551, but the effect of atenolol was not significant. The dose-response curve to close intraarterial injection of beta-adrenoceptor agonists showed a rank-order potency of: isoprenaline > salbutamol > dobutamine. The isoprenaline dose-response curve was shifted to the right by administration of beta-antagonists with rank-order potency of propranolol > ICI118551 > atenolol. These experiments showed a greater beta(2)-adrenoceptor response than beta(1)-adrenoceptor response in chronically inflamed rabbit-knee-joint blood vessels. Overall, compared to previous experiments on normal joint in which alpha(2)- and beta(1)-adrenoceptor responses predominated, and in acutely inflamed joint in which an equal alpha(1)/alpha(2) and beta(1)/beta(2) response was shown, in chronically inflamed joint the sympathetic constriction response was returned toward normal. No more alpha-adrenoceptor shift had happened, and the shift of beta(1) to beta(2) response continued.

Sympathetic neurotransmitters in joint inflammation

This article demonstrates the dual pro- and anti-inflammatory role of the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) in inflammatory joint disease (IJD) by way of distinct adrenoceptors. The dual role of the SNS depends on involved compartments, timing of distinct effector mechanisms during the inflammatory process, availability of respective adrenoceptors on target cells, and an intricate shift from beta-to-alpha adrenergic signaling in the progressing course of the inflammatory disease (beta-to-alpha adrenergic shift). Additional critical points for the dual role of the SNS in inflammation are the underlying change of immune effector mechanisms during the process of disease progression and the behavior of sympathetic nerve fibers in inflamed tissue (nerve fiber loss). This is accompanied by a relative lack of anti-inflammatory glucocorticoids in relation to inflammation. In quintessence, in early stages of IJD, the SNS plays a predominantly proinflammatory role, whereas in late stages of the disease the SNS most probably exerts anti-inflammatory effects. Because patients who have rheumatoid arthritis most often present in the chronic phase of the disease, support of anti-inflammatory sympathetic pathways can be a promising therapeutic option.

Pathophysiology of vascular dysfunction in a rat model of chronic joint inflammation

The impact of chronic joint inflammation on articular vascular function in rats was investigated to address whether joint swelling and the associated vascular dysfunction are dependent upon a common prostanoid mechanism. Urinary nitrate/nitrite (NO(x)) and PGE(2) excretion, knee joint diameter and body weight were measured following induction of adjuvant-induced arthritis (AIA). Ten days postinduction of AIA, joint vascular reactivity was assessed by measuring the perfusion response using a laser Doppler imager (LDI) to topical application of acetylcholine (ACh) and sodium nitroprusside (SNP). Four groups were compared: a non-inflamed control group and three AIA groups treated i.p. with vehicle, indomethacin or SC-236 (at equimolar doses). The selective cyclooxygenase-2 (COX-2) inhibitor (SC-236) was used to differentiate between COX-1 and -2-derived prostaglandins. Urinary NO(x) and PGE(2) levels increased substantially during the early phase of AIA but decreased thereafter. Toxicity to indomethacin but not SC-236 was observed, as indicated by a marked decrease in body weight. Joint swelling was similarly attenuated by indomethacin and SC-236 (P= 0.0001 cf. vehicle-treated AIA; n= 5-6 per group), indicating that this is due to COX-2 and not COX-1 inhibition. The AIA-induced changes in urinary NO(x) and PGE(2) were corrected by both COX inhibitors. While vascular reactivity to ACh and SNP was significantly attenuated by AIA (P < 0.002; n= 5-10 per group), the perfusion responses to these vasodilating agents were similar in all three AIA groups, demonstrating that the vascular dysfunction was not corrected by inhibition of either COX-1 or COX-2 enzymes. Furthermore, the attenuation of both ACh and SNP-induced responses in AIA suggest that vascular dysfunction was not exclusively endothelial in nature. In conclusion, the joint swelling and vascular dysfunction associated with AIA appear to be mediated, at least in part, by independent mechanisms. While COX-1/COX-2 inhibition reduced joint swelling, vascular dysfunction in AIA is independent of constitutive or inducible prostanoid mechanisms, and appears not to be solely endothelial-derived, but to involve other components such as the vascular smooth muscle.

Loss of vasomotor responsiveness to the mu-opioid receptor ligand endomorphin-1 in adjuvant monoarthritic rat knee joints

Endomorphin-1 is a short-chain neuropeptide with a high affinity fo the mu-opioid receptor and has recently been localized in acutely inflamed knee joints where it was found to reduce inflammation. The present study examined the propensity of endomorphin-1 to modulate synovial blood flow in normal and adjuvant-inflamed at knee joints. Under deep urethane anesthesia, endomorphin-1 was topically applied to exposed normal and 1 wk adjuvant monoarthritic knee joints (0.1 ml bolus; 10(-12)-10(-9) mol). Relative changes in articular blood flow were measured by laser Doppler perfusion imaging and vascular resistances in response to the opioid were calculated. In normal knees, endomorphin-1 caused a dose-dependent increase in synovial vascular resistance and this effect was significantly inhibited by the specific mu-opioid receptor antagonist d-Phe-Cys-Tyr-d-Trp-O n-Thr-Pen-Th amide (CTOP) (P < 0.0001, 2-factor ANOVA, n = 5-7). One week after adjuvant inflammation, the hypoaemic effect of endomorphin-1 was completely abolished (P < 0.0001, 2-factor ANOVA, n = 5-7). Immunohistochemical analysis of normal and adjuvant-inflamed joints showed a ninefold increase in endomorphin-1 levels in the monoarthritic knee compared with normal control. Western blotting and immunohistochemistry revealed a moderate number of mu-opioid receptors in normal knees; however, mu-opioid receptors were almost undetectable in arthritic joints. These findings demonstrate that peripheral administration of endomorphin-1 reduces knee joint blood flow and this effect is not sustainable during advanced inflammation. The loss of this hypoaemic response appears to be due to down regulation of mu-opioid receptors as a consequence of endomorphin-1 accumulation within the arthritic joint.

Effects of adrenoceptor antagonists on the cutaneous blood flow increase response to sympathetic nerve stimulation in rats with persistent inflammation

There is some evidence that the sympathetic nervous system plays a role in the development and/or maintenance of painful states, and that sympathetic nervous function is altered in these conditions. Our previous experiments showed that electrical stimulation of the lumbar sympathetic trunk (sympathetic stimulation: SS), which normally induces a decrease in blood flow (BF) of plantar skin, induced its BF increase in about 50% of adjuvant-inflamed rats. To investigate the mechanism of this BF-increase response, we examined whether noradrenaline (NA) plays any role in this changed response to SS, and which receptor subtype is involved. We measured paw cutaneous BF response with a laser Doppler flowmeter in rats chronically inflamed with complete Freund's adjuvant. SS induced the BF-increase response in 50-67% of measured sites. Close-arterially injected NA induced the BF-increase response at dosages between 10-100 ng/kg only at the sites with the BF-increase response to SS. The BF-increase and -decrease responses to NA was significantly reduced after the close-arterial injection of either alpha1- or alpha2-adrenoceptor antagonists (p lt; 0.05, respectively). In contrast, although the BF-decrease responses to SS were significantly reduced by administration of alpha1- and alpha2-adrenoceptor antagonist, BF-increase response was reduced only by alpha1-adrenoceptor antagonist, and that only at a higher dose. In addition, the beta-adrenoceptor antagonist had no effects on both responses. These results suggest that the BF-increase response to SS involves, additionally to NA, a non-adrenergic mechanism.

Physiological significance of alpha(2)-adrenergic receptor subtype diversity: one receptor is not enough

Alpha(2)-adrenergic receptors mediate part of the diverse biological effects of the endogenous catecholamines epinephrine and norepinephrine. Three distinct subtypes of alpha(2)-adrenergic receptors, alpha(2A), alpha(2B), alpha(2C), have been identified from multiple species. Because of the lack of sufficiently subtype-selective ligands, the specific biological functions of these receptor subtypes were largely unknown until recently. Gene-targeted mice carrying deletions in the genes encoding for individual alpha(2)-receptor subtypes have added important new insight into the physiological significance of adrenergic receptor diversity. Two different strategies have emerged to regulate adrenergic signal transduction. Some biological functions are controlled by two counteracting alpha(2)-receptor subtypes, e.g., alpha(2A)-receptors decrease sympathetic outflow and blood pressure, whereas the alpha(2B)-subtype increases blood pressure. Other biological functions are regulated by synergistic alpha(2)-receptor subtypes. The inhibitory presynaptic feedback loop that tightly regulates neurotransmitter release from adrenergic nerves also requires two receptor subtypes, alpha(2A) and alpha(2C). Similarly, nociception is controlled at several levels by one of the three alpha(2)-receptor subtypes. Further investigation of the specific function of alpha(2)-subtypes will greatly enhance our understanding of the relevance of closely related receptor proteins and point out novel therapeutic strategies for subtype-selective drug development.