Airway responsiveness depends on the diffusion rate of methacholine across the airway wall

In mice of both sexes, repeated contractions of smooth muscle in vivo greatly enhance the response of peripheral airways to methacholine

BALB/c mice from both sexes underwent one of two nebulized methacholine challenges that were preceded by a period of 20 min either with or without tone induced by repeated contractions of the airway smooth muscle. Impedance was monitored throughout and the constant phase model was used to dissociate the impact of tone on conducting airways (R_N - Newtonian resistance) versus the lung periphery (G and H - tissue resistance and elastance). The effect of tone on smooth muscle contractility was also tested on excised tracheas. While tone markedly potentiated the methacholine-induced gains in H and G in both sexes, the gain in R_N was only potentiated in males. The contractility of female and male tracheas was also potentiated by tone. Inversely, the methacholine-induced gain in hysteresivity (G/H) was mitigated by tone in both sexes. Therefore, the tone-induced muscle hypercontractility impacts predominantly the lung periphery in vivo, but also promotes further airway narrowing in males while protecting against narrowing heterogeneity in both sexes.

Respiratory mechanics evaluation of mice submitted to intravenous methacholine: Bolus vs. continuous infusion

IMPACT STATEMENT

Respiratory mechanics studies are associated with fundamental research and translational studies; the present work thus investigates this particular matter. Our current research describes differences and similarities between two different ways of administrating a very prevalent bronchoconstrictor (methacholine) in an aging process scenario. The core issue of our work is related with troubles we find with the bolus protocol and the application of the mathematical model used to assess the respiratory mechanics. Our findings reveal the continuous infusion as an alternative to these problems and we hope to provide the proper foundations to a more reliable assessment in the respiratory field.

Shortening of airway smooth muscle is modulated by prolonging the time without simulated deep inspirations in ovine tracheal strips

The shortening of airway smooth muscle (ASM) is greatly affected by time. This is because stimuli affecting ASM shortening, such as bronchoactive molecules or the strain inflicted by breathing maneuvers, not only alter quick biochemical processes regulating contraction but also slower processes that allow ASM to adapt to an ever-changing length. Little attention has been given to the effect of time on ASM shortening. The present study investigates the effect of changing the time interval between simulated deep inspirations (DIs) on ASM shortening and its responsiveness to simulated DIs. Excised tracheal strips from sheep were mounted in organ baths and either activated with methacholine or relaxed with isoproterenol. They were then subjected to simulated DIs by imposing swings in distending stress, emulating a transmural pressure from 5 to 30 cmH₂O. The simulated DIs were intercalated by 2, 5, 10, or 30 min. In between simulated DIs, the distending stress was either fixed or oscillating to simulate tidal breathing. The results show that although shortening was increased by prolonging the interval between simulated DIs, the bronchodilator effect of simulated DIs (i.e., the elongation of the strip post- vs. pre-DI) was not affected, and the rate of re-shortening post-simulated DIs was decreased. As the frequency with which DIs are taken increases upon bronchoconstriction, our results may be relevant to typical alterations observed in asthma, such as an increased rate of re-narrowing post-DI.NEW & NOTEWORTHY The frequency with which patients with asthma take deep inspirations (DIs) increases during bronchoconstriction. This in vitro study investigated the effect of changing the time interval between simulated DIs on airway smooth muscle shortening. The results demonstrated that decreasing the interval between simulated DIs not only decreases shortening, which may be protective against excessive airway narrowing, but also increases the rate of re-shortening post-simulated DIs, which may contribute to the increased rate of re-narrowing post-DI observed in asthma.

Independent and combined effects of airway remodelling and allergy on airway responsiveness

Airway remodelling and allergic inflammation are key features of airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR) in asthma; however, their interrelationships are unclear. The present study investigated the separate and combined effects of increased airway smooth muscle (ASM) layer thickness and allergy on AHR. We integrated a protocol of ovalbumin (OVA)-induced allergy into a non-inflammatory mouse model of ASM remodelling induced by conditional and airway-specific expression of transforming growth factor-α (TGF-α) in early growth response-1 (Egr-1)-deficient transgenic mice, which produced thickening of the ASM layer following ingestion of doxycycline. Mice were sensitised to OVA and assigned to one of four treatment groups: Allergy - normal chow diet and OVA challenge; Remodelling - doxycycline in chow and saline challenge; Allergy and Remodelling - doxycycline in chow and OVA challenge; and Control - normal chow diet and saline challenge. Airway responsiveness to methacholine (MCh) and histology were assessed. Compared with the Control group, airway responsiveness to MCh was increased in the Allergy group, independent of changes in wall structure, whereas airway responsiveness in the Remodelling group was increased independent of exposure to aeroallergen. The combined effects of allergy and remodelling on airway responsiveness were greater than either of them alone. There was a positive relationship between the thickness of the ASM layer with airway responsiveness, which was shifted upward in the presence of allergy. These findings support allergy and airway remodelling as independent causes of variable and excessive airway narrowing.

The role of iNKT cells on the phenotypes of allergic airways in a mouse model

iNKT cells and mast cells have both been implicated in the syndrome of allergic asthma through their activation-induced release of Th2 type cytokines and secretion of histamine and other mediators, respectively, which can promote airways hyperresponsiveness (AHR) to agents such as methacholine. However, a mechanistic link between iNKT cells and mast cell recruitment or activation has never been explored. Our objective was to determine whether iNKT cells are necessary for the recruitment of mast cells and if iNKT cells can influence the acute allergen induced bronchoconstriction (AIB) caused by mast cell mediator release. To do so, we pharmacologically eliminated iNKT cells using a specific antibody (NKT-14) and examined its impact on airway inflammation and physiological phenotype. In mice treated with NKT-14, the elimination of iNKT cells was sufficient to prevent AHR and pulmonary eosinophilic inflammation elicited by administration of the iNKT cell agonist αGalCer. In mice treated with NKT-14 and then sensitized and challenged with house dust mite extract (HDM), eliminating the iNKT cells significantly reduced both AHR and AIB but did not affect pulmonary inflammation, the mast cell population, nor the release of the mast cell mediators mast cell protease-1 and prostaglandin D2. We conclude that while iNKT cells contribute to the phenotype of allergic airways disease through the manifestation of AIB and AHR, their presence is not required for mast cell recruitment and activation, or to generate the characteristic inflammatory response subsequent to allergen challenge.

[Mechanisms of non-specific airway hyperresponsiveness: Methacholine-induced alterations in airway architecture]

Multiple mechanisms drive non-specific airway hyperresponsiveness in asthma. At the organ level, methacholine inhalation induces a complex bronchomotor response involving both bronchoconstriction and, to some extent, paradoxical bronchodilatation. This response is heterogeneous both serially, along a single bronchial axis, and in parallel, among lung regions. The bronchomotor response to methacholine induces contraction of distal airways as well as focal airway closure in select lung territories, leading to anatomically defined ventilation defects and decreased vital capacity. In addition, loss of the bronchoprotector and bronchodilator effects of deep inspirations is a key contributor to airway hyperresponsiveness in asthma.

The contractile lability of smooth muscle in asthmatic airway hyperresponsiveness

The contractile capacity of airway smooth muscle is not fixed but modulated by an impressive number of extracellular inflammatory mediators. Targeting the transient component of airway hyperresponsiveness ascribed to this contractile lability of ASM is a quest of great promises in order to alleviate asthma symptoms during inflammatory flares. However, owing to the plethora of mediators putatively involved and the molecular heterogeneity of asthma, it is more likely that many mediators conspire to increase the contractile capacity of ASM, each of which contributing to a various extent and in a time-varying fashion in individuals suffering from asthma. The task of identifying a common mend for a tissue rendered hypercontractile by imponderable assortments of inflammatory mediators is puzzling.

Delivered dose estimate to standardize airway hyperresponsiveness assessment in mice

Airway hyperresponsiveness often constitutes a primary outcome in respiratory studies in mice. The procedure commonly employs aerosolized challenges, and results are typically reported in terms of bronchoconstrictor concentrations loaded into the nebulizer. Yet, because protocols frequently differ across studies, especially in terms of aerosol generation and delivery, direct study comparisons are difficult. We hypothesized that protocol variations could lead to differences in aerosol delivery efficiency and, consequently, in the dose delivered to the subject, as well as in the response. Thirteen nebulization patterns containing common protocol variations (nebulization time, duty cycle, particle size spectrum, air humidity, and/or ventilation profile) and using increasing concentrations of methacholine and broadband forced oscillations (flexiVent, SCIREQ, Montreal, Qc, Canada) were created, characterized, and studied in anesthetized naïve A/J mice. A delivered dose estimate calculated from nebulizer-, ventilator-, and subject-specific characteristics was introduced and used to account for protocol variations. Results showed that nebulization protocol variations significantly affected the fraction of aerosol reaching the subject site and the delivered dose, as well as methacholine reactivity and sensitivity in mice. From the protocol variants studied, addition of a slow deep ventilation profile during nebulization was identified as a key factor for optimization of the technique. The study also highlighted sensitivity differences within the lung, as well as the possibility that airway responses could be selectively enhanced by adequate control of nebulizer and ventilator settings. Reporting results in terms of delivered doses represents an important standardizing element for assessment of airway hyperresponsiveness in mice.

The gain of smooth muscle's contractile capacity induced by tone on in vivo airway responsiveness in mice

Airway hyperresponsiveness to a spasmogenic challenge such as methacholine, and an increased baseline tone measured by the reversibility of airway obstruction with a bronchodilator, are two common features of asthma. However, whether the increased tone influences the degree of airway responsiveness to a spasmogen is unclear. Herein, we hypothesized that increased tone augments airway responsiveness in vivo by increasing the contractile capacity of airway smooth muscle (ASM). Anesthetized, tracheotomized, paralyzed, and mechanically ventilated mice were either exposed (experimental group) or not (control group) to tone for 20 min, which was elicited by nebulizing serial small doses of methacholine. Respiratory system resistance was monitored during this period and the peak response to a large cumulative dose of methacholine was then measured at the end of 20 min to assess and compare the level of airway responsiveness between groups. To confirm direct ASM involvement, the contractile capacity of excised murine tracheas was measured with and without preexposure to tone elicited by either methacholine or a thromboxane A2 mimetic (U46619). Distinct spasmogens were tested because the spasmogens liable for increased tone in asthma are likely to differ. The results indicate that preexposure to tone increases airway responsiveness in vivo by 126 ± 37% and increases the contractile capacity of excised tracheas ex vivo by 23 ± 4% for methacholine and 160 ± 63% for U46619. We conclude that an increased tone, regardless of whether it is elicited by a muscarinic agonist or a thromboxane A2 mimetic, may contribute to airway hyperresponsiveness by increasing the contractile capacity of ASM.

Potential role of the airway wall in the asthma of obesity

The pathogenesis of late-onset TH2-low asthma in obesity is thought to be related to weight-related decreases in lung volume, but why only a subset of individuals with obesity develop this condition is unknown. We tested the hypothesis that natural variations in both airway wall stiffness and airway wall thickness could lead to a subpopulation of hyperresponsive individuals exhibiting the symptoms of asthma in the setting of obesity. Increases in airway resistance (Raw) after airway smooth muscle stimulation were simulated using a computational model of an elastic airway embedded in elastic parenchyma. Using a range of randomly chosen values for both airway wall stiffness and thickness, we determined the resulting probability distributions of Raw responsiveness for a variety of different levels of transpulmonary pressure (Ptp). As Ptp decreased from 5 to 1 cmH2O, the resulting distributions of Raw moved toward progressively higher levels of responsiveness. With appropriate choices for the mean and standard deviation of the parameter that controls either airway wall stiffness or thickness, the model predicts a relationship between airway hyperresponsiveness and body mass index that is similar to that which has been reported in populations with obesity. We conclude that natural variations in airway wall mechanics and geometry between different individuals can potentially explain why an increasing percentage of the population exhibits the symptoms of asthma as the obesity of the population increases.

Issues determining direct airways hyperresponsiveness in mice

Airways hyperresponsiveness (AHR) is frequently a primary outcome in mouse models of asthma. There are, however, a number of variables that may affect the outcome of such measurements and the interpretation of the results. This article highlights issues that should be kept in mind when designing experiments using AHR as an outcome by reviewing techniques commonly used to assess AHR (unrestrained plethysmography and respiratory input impedance using forced oscillations), discussing the relationship between structure and function and, then exploring how the localization of AHR evolves over time, how the airway epithelium may affect the kinetics of methacholine induced AHR and finally how lung volume and positive end expiratory pressure (PEEP) can be used as tools assessing respiratory mechanics.

Airway Smooth Muscle Dynamics and Hyperresponsiveness: In and outside the Clinic

The primary functional abnormality in asthma is airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR)-excessive airway narrowing to bronchoconstrictor stimuli. Our understanding of the underlying mechanism(s) producing AHR is incomplete. While structure-function relationships have been evoked to explain AHR (e.g., increased airway smooth muscle (ASM) mass in asthma) more recently there has been a focus on how the dynamic mechanical environment of the lung impacts airway responsiveness in health and disease. The effects of breathing movements such as deep inspiration reveal innate protective mechanisms in healthy individuals that are likely mediated by dynamic ASM stretch but which may be impaired in asthmatic patients and thereby facilitate AHR. This perspective considers the evidence for and against a role of dynamic ASM stretch in limiting the capacity of airways to narrow excessively. We propose that lung function measured after bronchial provocation in the laboratory and changes in lung function perceived by the patient in everyday life may be quite different in their dependence on dynamic ASM stretch.

Asthmatic airway hyperresponsiveness: the ants in the tree

Airways from asthmatics have a propensity to narrow excessively in response to spasmogens (i.e., contractile agonists), a feature called airway hyperresponsiveness (AHR). AHR is an important contributor to asthma symptoms because the degree of responsiveness dictates the amount of airway narrowing that occurs in response to inflammation-derived spasmogens produced endogenously following exposure to environmental triggers, such as allergens, viruses, or pollutants. The smooth muscle encircling the airways is responsible for responsiveness because it constricts the airway lumen when commanded to contract by spasmogens. However, whether AHR seen in asthmatics is due to stronger muscle is equivocal. In this opinion article, I propose that environmental triggers and other inflammatory molecules released during asthma attacks contribute to AHR by increasing muscle force.

Airway contractility and remodeling: links to asthma symptoms

Respiratory symptoms are largely caused by obstruction of the airways. In asthma, airway narrowing mediated by airway smooth muscle (ASM) contraction contributes significantly to obstruction. The spasmogens produced following exposure to environmental triggers, such as viruses or allergens, are initially responsible for ASM activation. However, the extent of narrowing of the airway lumen due to ASM shortening can be influenced by many factors and it remains a real challenge to decipher the exact role of ASM in causing asthmatic symptoms. Innovative tools, such as the forced oscillation technique, continue to develop and have been proven useful to assess some features of ASM function in vivo. Despite these technologic advances, it is still not clear whether excessive narrowing in asthma is driven by ASM abnormalities, by other alterations in non-muscle factors or simply because of the overexpression of spasmogens. This is because a multitude of forces are acting on the airway wall, and because not only are these forces constantly changing but they are also intricately interconnected. To counteract these limitations, investigators have utilized in vitro and ex vivo systems to assess and compare asthmatic and non-asthmatic ASM contractility. This review describes: 1- some muscle and non-muscle factors that are altered in asthma that may lead to airway narrowing and asthma symptoms; 2- some technologies such as the forced oscillation technique that have the potential to unveil the role of ASM in airway narrowing in vivo; and 3- some data from ex vivo and in vitro methods that probe the possibility that airway hyperresponsiveness is due to the altered environment surrounding the ASM or, alternatively, to a hypercontractile ASM phenotype that can be either innate or acquired.